Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC.APP.No.103 of 2024
connected with
MAC.APP.No.121 of 2024
MAC.APP.No.103 of 2024
The Divisional Manager,
The Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company Limited,
3rd Floor, Aitorma Agartala Centrum Mall,
Sakuntala Road, Agartala, District-West Tripura,
(Insurer of vehicle No.TR-07-D-7714 Pulsar Motorcycle)
---- Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Baharul Islam Khan,
son of Late Farid Uddain Khan
of Durgapur, Sonamura,
P.O. & P.S. Sonamura, Pin-799131,
District-Sepahijala Tripura
2. Mir Hossain,
son of Late Siraj Miah
of Tarapukur, Dhanpur, Sonamura,
P.O.& P.S. Sonamura, Pin-799131,
District-Sepahijala Tripura
(Owner of vehicle No.TR-07-D-7714 Pulsar Motorcycle)
----Respondent(s)
_____________________________________________________
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Shubhajit Chakraborty, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Saugata Datta, Adv.
______________________________________________________
in connection with
MAC.APP.No.121 of 2024
Baharul Islam Khan,
son of Late Farid Uddain Khan
of Durgapur, Sonamura,
P.O. & P.S. Sonamura, Pin-799131,
District-Sepahijala Tripura
---- Appellant Claimant Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. Mir Hossain,
son of Late Siraj Miah
of Tarapukur, Dhanpur, Sonamura,
P.O.& P.S. Sonamura, Pin-799131,
District-Sepahijala Tripura
(Owner of vehicle No.TR-07-D-7714 Pulsar Motorcycle)
2. The Divisional Manager,
The Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company Limited,
3rd Floor, Aitorma Agartala Centrum Mall,
Sakuntala Road, Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799001
(Insurer of vehicle No.TR-07-D-7714 Pulsar Motorcycle)
----Opposite Party Respondent(s)
_____________________________________________________
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Saugata Datta, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Shubhajit Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
22.04.2025
(2)
Date of Judgment
& Order
:
29.04.2025
Whether fit for reporting :
YES
_________________________________________________________
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Both the appeals are taken up together for hearing
and decision as because both the appeals have arisen out of
common judgment and award dated 29.06.2024 delivered by
Learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sepahijala
District, Sonamura in connection with Case No.T.S.(MAC)14 of
2021. MAC.APP.No.103 of 2024 is preferred by the Bajaj Allianz
General
Insurance
aside/modification
Company
of
the
award
Limited
and
on
for
the
other
setting
hand
MAC.APP.No.121 of 2024 is preferred by the claimant petitioner
for enhancement of the award.
[2]
Heard Learned counsel, Mr. Shubhajit Chakraborty
appearing on behalf of the appellant-Insurance Company in
connection with MAC.APP.No.103 of 2024 and said counsel also
appeared on behalf of the respondent-Insurance Company in
MAC.APP.No.121 of 2024. Further heard Learned counsel, Mr.
Saugata Datta appearing on behalf of the respondent claimant
petitioner in MAC.APP.No.103 of 2024 and also as appellant
claimant petitioner in MAC.APP.No.121 of 2024.
[3]
Taking
part in
the
hearing, Learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the appellant-Insurance Company first of
all submitted that on behalf of the Insurance Company before
the Tribunal one witness Abhishek Chatterjee was examined as
OPW-2. In course of his examination, he stated that on the day
of
alleged
incident
the
rider
of
the
insured
bike
TR07D7714(Pulsar) i.e. OP No.1 Mir Hossain had no effective
(3)
driving license at the time of accident and as such, in absence of
effective and valid driving license of the driver of the vehicle no
liability can be imposed upon the Insurance Company for making
payment of compensation to the claimant petitioner in a case of
this nature. But surprisingly, Learned Tribunal below at the time
of delivery of judgment/award fastened the liability of payment
of compensation upon the appellant-Insurance Company when it
was on record that the driver of the offending vehicle had no
effective driving license on the day of alleged accident.
[4]
Learned
counsel
for
the
appellant-Insurance
Company further drawn the attention of the Court referring para
No.18 Point No.(c) wherein the Learned Tribunal below came to
the observation that from Ext.B the Insurance Certificate of the
offending bike he found that the offending bike had valid
Insurance Certificate from 25.01.2020 to 24.01.2021 which
covers the date of accident i.e. on 01.05.2020. But from Ext.D
i.e. the Driving license, the Learned Tribunal below came to the
observation that the offending vehicle had valid driving license
from 06.07.2020 to 23.01.2037 “covering the date of accident on
01.05.2020.” Referring the said observation Learned counsel for
the Insurance Company drawn the attention of the Court that in
absence of valid documentary evidence on record how the
Learned Tribunal came to the observation that on the day of
accident the driver had valid driving license covering the date of
accident on 01.05.2020.
[5]
Company
So, finally Learned counsel for the Insurance
urged
for
setting
aside
of
the
judgment/award
delivered by the Learned Tribunal and to fasten the liability of
payment of compensation upon the owner/driver of the offending
vehicle.
(4)
[6]
On the other hand, Learned counsel for the
respondent claimant petitioner firstly submitted before the Court
that there was no irregularity or infirmity in the judgment/award
delivered by the Learned Tribunal and as such, there is no scope
to interfere with the judgment/award. Learned counsel further
drawn the attention of the Court that in para No.15 of the
judgment/award it was clearly stated that PW-1 i.e. the claimant
in his deposition clearly stated that after the accident he was
brought to Sonamura Hospital but due to his serious injuries he
was shifted to AGMC and GBP hospital and admitted on
01.05.2020 and as due to Covid situation the treatment of the
said hospital was not satisfactory and day by day his condition
was deteriorating so the family members of the claimant shifted
him in Bhaumic Polyclinic and Nursing Home, Agartala on
21.05.2020 from AGMC and GBP Hospital wherein he was
admitted from 21.05.2020 to 27.05.2020. But the Learned
Tribunal below at the time of determination of compensation did
not fix any award towards attendant charges for the period w.e.f.
01.05.2020 to 20.05.2020 when he was admitted in AGMC and
GBP Hospital supported by the attendant and for which according
to Learned counsel a considerable sum may be considered for
the aforesaid period when the victim was admitted in AGMC and
GBP Hospital with severe injuries on his person.
[7]
On the other hand, to counter his submission,
Learned counsel for the Insurance Company submitted that since
the alleged victim is a government servant and as such, he is not
entitled to get any benefit in this regard and submitted that the
observation of Learned Tribunal below was proper in this respect
and the claimant petitioner is not entitled to get any sum for the
aforesaid period of his treatment, since he was a government
(5)
servant and he was getting salary without any job during the
Covid period and finally urged for dismissal of the appeal filed by
the claimant petitioner.
Considered.
[8]
In the case at hand, the claimant filed one claim
petition under Section 166 of M.V. Act before the Learned
Tribunal alleging inter alia that on 01.05.2020 at about 10 a.m.
the claimant Baharul Islam Khan was proceeding taking extreme
proper side of Melaghar to Sonamura road by riding his bike and
when he reached near Sonamura BOC, at that time over
Melaghar to Sonamura road one vehicle bearing No.TR07-D—
7714 (Pulsar) dashed the injured with his bike by rash and
negligent driving with excessive speed and as a result of which
the accident took place and for that the claimant petitioner
Baharul Islam Khan sustained severe injuries on his person.
Accordingly, a case was registered under Section 279/338 of IPC
and also under Section 184/187 of M.V. Act and finally on
conclusion of investigation the IO laid charge-sheet against the
rider/owner of the offending bike bearing No. TR07-D—7714
(pulsar) namely Mir Hossen.
[9]
After filing of the claim petition, the case was
contested by OP i.e. the owner of the offending pulsar bike by
filing written statement denying the assertions of the claimant
petitioner and submitted that on the alleged day the vehicle was
duly insured with the Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company
Limited
covering
the
date
of
compensation
and
if
any
compensation is awarded that should be borne by the Insurance
Company.
[10]
The noticee Insurance Company also contested the
claim petition by filing written statement denying the plea of the
(6)
claimant petitioner and also took the plea that the petition is not
maintainable and the same is liable to be dismissed on the
ground that on the day of alleged accident the driver/rider of the
offending pulsar bike had no valid driving license rather the
claimant petitioner who was the rider of the Scooty bearing
No.TR01-E-8615 was solely responsible for the alleged accident.
Upon the pleadings of the parties Learned Tribunal below framed
the following issues :
“(i) Is the suit maintainable in its present form and
nature?
(ii) Whether the claimant petitioner sustained
injuries out a vehicular accident occurred on
01.05.2020 at about 10.00 am near Sonamura BOC,
on Sonamura-Melaghar road involving the vehicle
bearing registration No.TR07D7714(Pulsar)?
(iii) Whether such accident occurred due to rash and
negligent driving
by the
driver of
vehicle
No.TR07D7714(Pulsar)?
(iv) Whether claimant petitioner is entitled to get
compensation as prayed for, if so then to what
extent?
(v) Who is responsible for payment of compensation
as prayed for?”
[11]
To substantiate the issues, both the parties have
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record :
APPENDIX
Claimant Witness :PW.1 –Sri Baharul Islam Khan
Claimant Exhibits:Ext.1(as a whole):-Certified copy of FIR (5 sheets).
Ext.2:-Certified copy of ejahar (two sheets).
Ext.3:-Certified copy of seizure list.
Ext.4:-Certified copy of MVI report.
Ext.5(as a whole):-Certified copy of final report.
Ext.6(sheets):-Certified copy of injury report.
Ext.7:-Discharge certificate dated 27.05.2020 issued
from Bhowmik Poly Clinic and Nursing Home.
Ext.8
series:-Cash
memos,
money
receipts,
bills/invoices(21 sheets).
Ext.9 series:- Test report, prescriptions (6 sheets).
Ext.10:-Salary certificate dated 03.01.2022.
Ext.11 series (SO):- two original bills in reference to
the maintenance cost of damaged vehicle bearing
No.TR01E8615.
Opposite party‟s Witness:OPW.1:-Mir Hossain.
OPW.2:-Abhishek Chatterjee.
Exhibits by Opposite party:Ext.A:-one Xerox copy of registration certificate.
Ext.B:-One Xerox copy of the insurance policy.
Ext.C:-one Xerox copy of the form 24.
Ext.D:-one Xerox copy of the driving licence.
(7)
Ext.E:-Extract copy of driving licence.
Ext.F(series):-Insurance Policy of Bajaj
GIC.
Ext.G:-Certified copy of seizure list.
[12]
Alliance
Finally, on conclusion of enquiry, Learned Tribunal
below allowed the claim petition and fasten the liability of
payment
of
compensation
upon
the
appellant
Insurance
Company. The operative portion of the judgment/order of the
Learned Tribunal below runs as follows :
“20. It is ordered that, a total amount of
Rs.3,17,000/(Rupees
three
lakh
seventeen
thousand) is awarded in favour of the petitioner as
compensation. The OP No.2, the Noticee, Bajaj
Allianz Insurance Company Ltd., the insurer of the
offending
motor
bike
bearing
No.TR07D7714(Pulsar) is hereby directed to pay the
compensation as awarded. The OP No.2, the Noticee
is also directed to pay the interest @ 8% per annum
on total awarded sum from the date of filing of this
petition i.e. on 16.04.2021 till the date of
realization.”
Challenging the judgment and award, both the
appeals have been preferred before this Court by the Insurance
Company as well as by the claimant petitioner.
[13]
I have heard detailed arguments of both the sides
and gone through the records of Learned Tribunal below
including the judgment/award delivered by the Learned Tribunal
below. It is the admitted position that Learned Tribunal below at
the time of delivery of judgment/award fastened the liability of
payment
of
compensation
upon
the
appellant-Insurance
Company. It is also the admitted position that on the day of
alleged accident the owner/driver of the offending pulsar bike
had no driving license, although, the offending vehicle had valid
Insurance Certificate. On perusal of the judgment/award of the
Learned Tribunal below it appears that in para No.9 it was clearly
written that on behalf of the Insurance Company one Senior
Legal executive appeared who was examined as OPW-2 and he
clearly stated that on the day of alleged occurrence the rider of
(8)
the offending pulsar bike had no valid driving license, although
the offending vehicle had valid Insurance Certificate. As such,
the Company was not responsible for making payment of
compensation. In para No.18 of the judgment/award Learned
Tribunal below on perusal of Exbt.D observed that the driver of
the offending bike had valid driving license w.e.f. 06.07.2020 to
31.01.2037 covering the date of accident on 01.05.2020 but it is
surprising as to how the Learned Tribunal below came to such
observation when there was no such evidence on record like that
and furthermore the owner/driver/rider of the said bike also
could not produce any other earlier driving license to draw
attention of the tribunal below that he earlier possessed driving
license but the validity was expired. However, on conclusion of
the proceeding, Learned Tribunal below fastened the liability of
payment of compensation upon the Insurance Company which in
my considered view was not proper.
[14]
Furthermore,
on
perusal
of
the
said
judgment/award it also appears that at the time of delivery of
judgment in para No.16 the Learned Tribunal below awarded
cost of attendant charges w.e.f. 21.05.2020 to 27.05.2020 for a
period of seven days for two attendances per day showing cost
of each attendant @ Rs.500 each. Thus, determined the cost of
attendant
charges
amounting
to
Rs.7000/-
which
in
my
considered view was also not proper because it is on record that
on and from the date of accident i.e. w.e.f. 01.05.2020 to
20.05.2020 the victim was admitted in AGMC and GBP Hospital
when there was severe Covid across the world. So, naturally in
absence of any support person it was very difficult on the part of
the claimant-petitioner to survive and as such, for the said
period he is also entitled to get the cost of attendant charges
(9)
which the Learned Tribunal below failed to consider and as such
for the period w.e.f. 01.05.2020 to 20.05.2020 for a period of
twenty days he will be further entitled to get more Rs.20,000/showing two attendant charges @ Rs.500 each per attendant
(Rs.500 x 2 x 20). Thus, towards cost of attendant charges the
claimant petitioner would get Rs.27,000/- in place of Rs.7000/-.
From the award of the Learned Tribunal it appears that Learned
Tribunal below at the time of determination of compensation
awarded
Rs.1,80,000/-
treatment,
towards
hospitalization,
expenditure
medicine
etc.
incurred
also
for
awarded
Rs.1,00,000/- towards pain, sufferings and trauma and for future
medical
expenses
also
awarded
Rs.30,000/-.
Thus,
after
calculation Learned Tribunal below determined the total amount
of compensation amounting to Rs.3,17,000/-. At the time of
hearing, Learned counsel for the appellant claimant petitioner
also submitted that after the accident till today the claimant
petitioner also undergoing treatment and taking medicines. So,
the amount of Rs.30,000/- needs to be enhanced. Learned
counsel for the Insurance Company did not submit anything
before this Court. So, considering all it appears to me that
towards that head the appellant claimant petitioner also would
get Rs.50,000/- in place of Rs.30,000/- as future medical
expenses. So, after calculation the appellant claimant petitioner
is now entitled to get enhanced compensation of Rs.1,80,000 +
27,000 + 1,00,000 + 50,000 =Rs.3,57,000/-.
[15]
Now, here I would like to discuss what would be
the position if the driver does not possess any valid driving
license on the day of alleged accident in any case in spite of
having valid Insurance certificate. In this regard, I would like to
rely upon one citation of our Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
(10)
Singh Ram versus Nirmala and Others reported in (2018) 3
SCC 800 wherein in para Nos.6 to 8 Hon’ble the Apex Court
observed as under :
“6. In National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran
Singh(2004)3 SCC 297, this Court held that the
holder of a driving licence has a period of thirty days
on its expiry, to renew it:
“45. Thus, a person whose licence is ordinarily
renewed in terms of the Motor Vehicles Act and
the Rules framed thereunder, despite the fact
that during the interregnum period, namely,
when the accident took place and the date of
expiry of the licence, he did not have a valid
licence, he could during the prescribed period
apply for renewal thereof and could obtain the
same automatically without undergoing any
further test or without having been declared
unqualified
therefor.
Proviso
appended
to Section 14 in unequivocal terms states that
the licence remains valid for a period of thirty
days from the day of its expiry.
46. Section 15 of the Act does not empower the
authorities to reject an application for renewal
only on the ground that there is a break in
validity or tenure of the driving licence
has lapsed, as in the meantime the provisions
for disqualification of the driver contained
in Sections 19, 20, 21, 22, 23 and 24 will not be
attracted, would indisputably confer a right
upon the person to get his driving licence
renewed. In that view of the matter, he cannot
be said to be delicensed and the same shall
remain valid for a period of thirty days after its
expiry.”
The following conclusion has been recorded in
summation in the judgment:
“(iii) The breach of policy condition e.g.
disqualification of the driver or invalid driving
licence of the driver, as contained in subsection (2)(a)(ii) of Section 149, has to be
proved to have been committed by the insured
for avoiding liability by the insurer. Mere
absence, fake or invalid driving licence or
disqualification of the driver for driving at the
relevant time, are not in themselves defences
available to the insurer against either the
insured or the third parties. To avoid its
liability towards the insured, the insurer has to
prove that the insured was guilty of negligence
and failed to exercise reasonable care in the
matter of fulfilling the condition of the policy
regarding use of vehicles by a duly licensed
driver or one who was not disqualified to drive
at the relevant time.
(iv) Insurance companies, however, with a
view to avoid their liability must not only
establish the available defence(s) raised in the
said proceedings but must also establish
“breach” on the part of the owner of the
vehicle; the burden of proof wherefor would be
on them.
(v) The court cannot lay down any criteria as to
how the said burden would be discharged,
(11)
inasmuch as the same would depend upon the
facts and circumstances of each case.
(vi) Even where the insurer is able to prove
breach on the part of the insured concerning
the policy condition regarding holding of a valid
licence by the driver or his qualification to
drive during the relevant period, the insurer
would not be allowed to avoid its liability
towards the insured unless the said breach or
breaches on the condition of driving licence
is/are so fundamental as are found to have
contributed to the cause of the accident. The
Tribunals in interpreting the policy conditions
would apply “the rule of main purpose” and the
concept of “fundamental breach” to allow
defences available to the insurer under Section
149(2) of the Act.
(vii) The question, as to whether the owner has
taken reasonable care to find out as to whether
the driving licence produced by the driver (a
fake one or otherwise), does not fulfil the
requirements of law or not will have to be
determined in each case”.
7. In the present case it is necessary to note, as
observed by the Tribunal, that the owner did not
depose in evidence and stayed away from the
witness box. He produced a licence which was found
to be fake. Another licence which he sought to
produce had already expired before the accident and
was not renewed within the prescribed period. It
was renewed well after two years had expired. The
appellant as owner had evidently failed to take
reasonable care (proposition (vii) of Swaran Singh)
since he could not have been unmindful of facts
which were within his knowledge.
8. In the circumstances, the direction by the
Tribunal, confirmed by the High Court, to pay and
recover cannot
be faulted. The
appeal is,
accordingly, dismissed. There shall be no order as to
costs.”
Further, Hon’ble the Apex Court in another case in
Parminder Singh versus New India Assurance Company
Limited and Others reported in (2019) 7 SCC 217 in para
No.7 observed as under :
“7. On the issue of liability to pay the compensation
awarded, we affirm the view taken by the High
Court that the Respondent – Insurance Company is
absolved of the liability to bear the compensation,
as evidence has been produced from the office of
the Regional Transport Office to prove that the
drivers of the two offending trucks were driving on
the basis of invalid driving licenses. It is also
relevant to note that the owners and drivers of the
offending trucks have not appeared at any stage of
the proceedings, including this Court.
7.1. This Court in Shamanna v. Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd. : (2018) 9 SCC 650 held that
if the driver of the offending vehicle does not
possess a valid driving license, the principle of
„pay and recover‟ can be ordered to direct the
insurance company to the pay the victim, and
then recover the amount from the owner of the
offending vehicle.
(12)
7.2. We deem it just and fair to direct the
Respondent – Insurance Company to pay the
enhanced amount of compensation as indicated
in Para. 6 above, to the Appellant within a
period of 12 weeks from the date of this
judgment.
The
Respondent
–
Insurance
Company is directed to make out a Demand
Draft in the name of the Appellant, which can
be used for his care for the rest of his life. The
Respondent – Insurance Company is entitled to
recover the amount from the owners and
drivers of the two offending trucks.”
From the aforesaid citations of law it appears to
me that in such a situation Hon’ble the Apex Court have been
pleased to observe that principle of pay and recovery be followed
and the respondent-Insurance Company would be entitled to
recover the amount from the owner/driver of the offending bike.
Relying upon the principle it appears to me that here in the case
at hand since it is the admitted position that on the alleged day
of accident the driver/owner of the offending pulsar bike had no
valid driving license although the vehicle had valid Insurance
certificate and as such, the appellant-Insurance Company shall
pay the amount of compensation to the claimant petitioner and
shall recover the amount from the owner/rider of the offending
bike.
[16]
In the result, both the appeals are disposed of with
the following observations :
The appellant claimant petitioner shall be entitled to
get compensation amounting to Rs.3,57,000/- with
8% p.a. (8% interest) from the date of filing the
claim petition to till the date of realization. The
appellant Insurance Company shall pay the aforesaid
amount
to
the
appellant
claimant
petitioner
in
MAC.APP.No.121 of 2024 within a period of 6(six)
weeks from today to the Registry of the High Court
deducting the amount if anything being paid and
(13)
shall recover the amount from the owner/rider of the
offending pulsar bike bearing registration No. TR07D-7714.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of this
judgment/award
passed
by
this
Court.
Supply
copy
of
judgment/award free of cost to Learned counsels for the
Insurance Company and the claimant petitioner.
With
this
observation,
both
the
appeals
are
disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
SABYASACHI Digitally
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHA BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2025.05.01
RJEE
00:14:11 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review