Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 255 of 2020
Date of Decision: 15.11.2022
Smti Badarisha Nongkhar
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. B. Nongbet, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, AAG with
Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The erstwhile writ petitioner who expired during the
pendency of the writ petition and now substituted by his wife, had
approached this Court assailing the order dated 07.08.2020, whereby it
was given therein, that in the preparation of the pension papers along with
Service Book and other materials, it was informed that there was an overPage 1 of 10
drawal of pay amounting to Rs. 1,18,965/- (Rupees One Lakh Eighteen
Thousand Nine Hundred Sixty-Five only), which was recovered from his
gratuity amount.
2.
The original petitioner was an employee in the office of the
Assistant Registrar of Societies, Nongstoin, and retired as Upper Division
Assistant (UDA) in 2019 after his promotion from the post of Lower
Division Assistant (LDA). It appears his pension was withheld and after
almost 4 months of his retirement, the respondents initiated the process of
recovery of overdrawn pay which was recovered from his gratuity. It is
the case of the original petitioner that he was qualified to receive
upgradation under the Assured Career Progression Scheme (ACPS) and
later under the Modified Assured Career Progressive Scheme (MACPS),
which he claimed he was eligible for the said financial upgradation from
the year 2017. The further case of the original writ petitioner, is that he
never received any intimation about the said recovery of overdrawn
payment and that further he was not heard. Being aggrieved thereby he
had come before this Court.
3.
Mr. B. Nongbet, learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that the recovery of overdrawn pay is arbitrary and impermissible in law
and has placed reliance on the case of State of Punjab & Ors. vs. Rafiq
Masih (white washer) & Ors. reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334, and has
submitted that out of the 5 postulations as given in Para-18 of the said
judgment, 4 are applicable to the case of the petitioner. Learned counsel
has also referred to the other cases which have been referred to in Rafiq
Masih (supra) to stress his points, that recovery after several years of the
implementation of a certain pay scale would not be just and proper, as in
the present case the excess payment since the year 2010 was discovered
only after the retirement in June, 2019, which was also 9 years after the
implementation of the financial upgradation. It is further submitted that
the original petitioner retired from a post belonging to Group-C service in
June 2019 and that the respondents, realised their mistakes allegedly, only
in the year of his retirement. It is further submitted that this is also not a
case where this error that occurred can be attributed to the original
petitioner in any manner.
4.
Learned counsel submits that as the employee had retired,
recovery should have been made as per the Meghalaya Financial Rules
and not under the Meghalaya Service Rules, and if any recovery was to
be done at all, the process should have been initiated prior to his
retirement. It is contended that the issue of wrongful/excess payment
made to Government servants, has to be dealt with in accordance with
Rafiq Masih (supra) and that the Government of India had also issued a
Memorandum in 2016 to this effect. The learned counsel has also placed
reliance in the decision in the case of Thomas Daniel vs. State of Kerala
& Ors. reported in (2022) SCC Online SC 536, wherein he submits that
recovery of excess pay made against an employee due to a wrong principle
of calculating pay/allowance and if not occasioned by fraud or
misrepresentation, after retirement is not allowed. He closes his
arguments by submitting that the petitioner should not suffer because of
the mistake/error committed by the respondents, and the recovery of the
excess pay should be set aside and the amount refunded, apart from the
re-calibration of the pension due, taking into account the financial
upgradations.
5.
Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, learned AAG assisted by Mr. A.H.
Kharwanlang, learned GA in reply, submits that the recovery was legal
and was as per the statutory provisions of law, in terms of Rule 73 of the
Meghalaya Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1983. He submits that no
challenge has been made to the said Rules, which allows the respondents
to recover over-drawal of pay from the pensionary benefits of the
petitioner and his heirs. The said provision of law, he submits, is
applicable across the board, to all the State Government employees
including the original petitioner and is not limited to a certain class of
employees. The learned AAG submits that the original writ petitioner,
upon receiving the benefit of the second financial upgradation under the
Assured Career Progression Scheme, by order dated 25.05.2014, was put
to notice, that any excess amount drawn resulting from the fixation, shall
be recovered from the monthly salary. The original petitioner, he submits
on acceptance of this notice, has therefore given an undertaking to abide
by the said condition. In this context, a reference has been made to the
case of High Court of Punjab & Haryana & Ors. vs. Jagdev Singh
reported in (2016) 14 SCC 267, wherein he submits, it has been held that
when in the first instance, an employee has been put on notice and
furnished an undertaking, he is bound by the said undertaking. He
therefore contends that the original writ petitioner having accepted the
said notice, has also accepted the recovery proceedings by the
respondents, and as the amount has already been recovered, there cannot
be any question of any hardship being caused to the petitioner at this stage.
The learned AAG has also placed reliance in the case of Chandi Prasad
Uniyal & Ors. vs. State of Uttarakhand & Ors. reported in (2012) 8 SCC
417 and submits that any amount paid or received without the authority of
law, can always be recovered and the same cannot be retained as a matter
of right, since the same, would amount to unjust enrichment. With regard
to the judgment relied upon by the petitioner, he submits that the judgment
of Rafiq Masih (supra) is based on the principles of equity enshrined in
Article 142 of the Constitution of India, which is supplementary in nature
and is not binding. He lastly submits that original petitioner having
accepted the notice of recovery, and as recovery was undertaken in
accordance with Rule 73 of the Meghalaya Civil Services (Pension)
Rules, 1983, no case has been made out and the writ petition is liable to
be dismissed.
6.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties.
7.
The only point in issue herein as can be seen, is the grievance
of the original writ petitioner to the recovery from his pension, the amount
said to have been overdrawn, apart from the claim for third financial
upgradation. It is to be noted initially that as per the affidavit of the State
respondents, the original writ petitioner’s pension had been sanctioned, as
also the gratuity payment order; and that the commutation of pension is
under process, as also the arrears of MACPS which is also currently being
processed by the respondent No. 4, with instructions for immediate
payment. As can be seen from the materials on record, while calculating
the pay of the petitioner as per an Office Memorandum dated 22.02.2010,
the pay was fixed at Rs. 16,440/- (Rupees Sixteen Thousand Four
Hundred Forty only) whereas it should have been fixed at Rs. 16,051/(Rupees Sixteen Thousand Fifty-One only). It is also noted that the same
came to light, only when the Service Book of the original writ petitioner
was examined which is evidenced by the letter dated 31.10.2019
(Annexure-XII to the writ petition).
8.
It is further noted that the recovery of the overdrawn pay was
in terms of Rule 73 of the Meghalaya Civil Services (Pension) Rules,
1983, the relevant portion of which, is reproduced hereinbelow for easy
reference: “73. (1) It shall be the duty of every retiring government
servant to clear all government dues before the date of his
retirement.
(2) where a retiring government servant does not clear the
government dues and such dues are ascertainable(a) An equivalent cash deposit may be taken from him; or
(b) Out of the gratuity payable to him, his nominee or legal
heir, and amount equal to that recoverable on account of
ascertainable government dues shall be deducted.
Explanation- The expression “ascertainable government
dues” includes of house building or convenience advance,
arrears of rent and other charges pertaining to occupation
of government accommodation, over-payment of pay and
allowances and arrears of income-tax deductible at source
under the Income Tax Act.”
A perusal of the said Rule clearly indicates that the
Government servant is duty bound to clear all the Government dues before
the date of retirement and also provides further at Rules 73 (2) (b), that if
the dues are not cleared, the same shall be recoverable from his gratuity
amount.
9.
Another aspect in the instant case as has been contended by
the respondents, is the fact that while accepting the order dated 26.05.2014
(Annexure-IX to the writ petition), whereby the benefit of the 2nd
Financial Upgradation under the Assured Career Progressive Scheme was
granted to original writ petitioner, it was clearly stated therein that any
excess amount drawn from the new fixation, would be recovered from his
monthly salary.
10.
Though, it has been strongly contended by the counsel for the
petitioner that the case of the original writ petitioner will come within the
proposition as given in the case of Rafiq Masih (supra) and Thomas
Daniel (supra), and indeed hardship has been caused due to the recovery,
coupled with the fact that the excess payment was not due to misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the employee, there are two factors
that stand in the way of this Court granting the relief as prayed for. Firstly,
the re-fixed scale of pay, which was allowed to the original writ petitioner
had clearly provided that any excess amount drawn resulting from the
fixation, such amount was to be recovered from the monthly salary. This
condition was known to the original writ petitioner and is an undertaking
in all respects. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the judgment of High Court
of Punjab & Haryana & Ors. vs. Jagdev Singh (supra), has also held that
recovery would be permissible, when the payment was made in the first
instance, the employee had been put to notice that excess payment if found
would be required to be refunded. Para 10 and 11 thereof which is relevant
is reproduced hereinbelow: “10. In the State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih this Court held
that while it is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship where payments have mistakenly been made by an
employer, in the following situations, a recovery by the
employer would be impermissible in law;
(i)
Recovery from employees belonging to Class
III and IV service (or Group C and D service).
(ii)
Recovery from retired employees, or
employees who are due to retire within one
year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess
payment has been made for a period in excess
of five years, before the order of recovery is
issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties
of a higher post, and has been paid
accordingly, even though he should have
rightfully been required to work against an
inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at
the conclusion, that recovery if made from the
employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far
outweigh the equitable balance of the
employer’s right to recover.
11.
The principle enunciated in Proposition (ii) above
cannot apply to a situation such as in the present case. In
the present case, the officer to whom the payment was made
in the first instance was clearly placed on notice that any
payment found to have been made in excess would be
required to be refunded. The officer furnished an
undertaking while opting for the revised pay scale. He is
bound by the undertaking.”
11.
The second factor is the provision of Rule 73 of the Meghalaya
Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1983 which as observed earlier, Rule 73
(2) (b) allows for such recovery from the gratuity amount paid to the
retired employee. This being the stated position of law laid down and by
operation of the Rules, though it may seem harsh to deny the writ
petitioner the relief as claimed, the same for the reasons aforementioned,
cannot be granted by this Court.
12.
With regard to the claim for 3rd Financial Upgradation, it is
noted that the same has already been addressed by the respondents, who
have taken cognizance of the fact that the original writ petitioner is
entitled for the same and an appropriate order, which is annexed at
Annexure-I of the affidavit, dated 28.09.2020, has been passed. Further,
it is also noted that the pension and gratuity has already been sanctioned
and that the calculation of the arrears of the MACPS is being processed.
In this view of the matter, no further orders are called for, except that
whatever terminal benefits due such as family pension be released to the
petitioner most expeditiously, if not already done so.
13.
In the facts and circumstances of the case, this writ petition
stands closed and is accordingly disposed of.
14.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
15.11.2022
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review