Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for orders : 27.07.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 26.10.2026
Date of uploading
: 26.10.2026
APHC010626942016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3606]
MONDAY, THE 26th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR
CHINTALAPUDI
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 2734/2016
Between:
1. BADA NARAYANA REDDY & 5 OTHERS, S/O. BADA PAKIR REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS, HINDU, CULTIVATION, R/O.
CHANDRAYUNIPALLI VILLAGE, H/O. REDDIPALLI, NALLAMADA
MANDAL,
ANANTAPUR
DISTRICT
DIED
BY
LRS.,
PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS 2 TO 6.
2. BADA PARVATHAMMA,, W/O. LATE. B. NARAYANA REDDY, AGED
ABOUT 61 YEARS, R/O. CHANDRAYUNIPALLI VILLAGE, H/O.
REDDIPALLI, NALLAMADA MANDAL, ANANTAPUR DISTRICT.
3. B. RAMANA REDDY,, S/O. LATE. B. NARAYANA REDDY, AGED
ABOUT 40 YEARS R/O. CHANDRAYUNIPALLI VILLAGE, H/O.
REDDIPALLI, NALLAMADA MANDAL, ANANTAP
ANANTAPUR
UR DISTRICT.
4. B. CHANDRA MOHAN REDDY,, S/O. LATE. B. NARAYANA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS, R/ O. CHANDRAYUNIPALLI VILLAGE, H/O.
REDDIPALLI, NALLAMADA MANDAL, ANANTAPUR DISTRICT.
5. S. SUGUNAMMA,, W/O. RAMACHANDRA REDDY, AGED ABOUT 46
YEARS, R/O. SANEVARIPALLI
ANEVARIPALLI VILLAGE, H/O. VANKARAKUNTA,
NALLAMADA MANDAL, ANANTAPUR DISTRICT.
6. MEKA PADMAVATHAMMA,, W/O. MADHAVA REDDY, AGED ABOUT
42 YEARS,
R/O. BADAVANDLAPALLI VILLAGE, NALLAMADA
MANDAL, ANANTAPUR DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
1. THOLETI RAJASEKHAR REDDY,
S/O. THOLETI NARASIMHA
REDDY, AGED 53 YEARS, HINDU, OCC: CULTIVATION, R/O.
CHANDRAYUNIPALLI VILLAGE, H/O REDDIPALLI, NALLAMADA
MANDAL, ANANTAPUR DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, praying that in the
circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may be
pleased to against the Order dated 18-03-2016 in I.A. No. 753/2015 in O.S.
No. 508/2005 on the file of the Court of the Principal Junior Civil Judge, Kadiri,
Anantapur District
IA NO: 1 OF 2016(CRPMP 3468 OF 2016
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
stay all further proceedings in OS No. 508/2005 on the file of the Court of the
Principal Junior Civil Judge, Kadiri, Anantapur District and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. MANJUNATH ALLUR
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. O MANOHER REDDY
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR
CHINTALAPUDI
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO.2734 OF 2016
ORDER:
This revision petition is directed against the order dated 18.03.2016
passed by the learned Principal Civil Judge (Junior Division), Kadiri, in
I.A.No.753 of 2015 in O.S.No.508 of 2005, allowing the application to receive
documents.
2. The revision petitioners are the respondents in I.A.No.753 of 2015 and
plaintiffs in O.S.No.508 of 2005. The respondent herein is the petitioner in the
interlocutory application and defendant in the suit. For convenience, the
parties are referred to as they are arrayed in the suit, namely, the petitioners
as plaintiffs and the respondent as defendant.
Brief facts of the case:
3. The suit was filed seeking the relief of declaration and permanent
injunction. The first plaintiff, Sri Bada Narayana Reddy, died, and plaintiff
Nos.2 to 6 were brought on record as his legal representatives. The plaintiffs
examined Sri B. Ramana Reddy, the third plaintiff, as P.W.1. His examinationin-chief was partly recorded, and the matter was posted for his further
examination. At that stage, the defendant filed I.A.No.753 of 2015 under Order
VIII Rule 3(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter, “the CPC”),
seeking permission to produce certified copies of the depositions of Sri B.
Ramana Reddy, Sri T. Narayana Reddy, Sri K. Kristappa and Sri J. Sankar
Rao. The defendant stated that, during the lifetime of Sri Bada Narayana
Reddy, he had lodged a criminal complaint against the defendant herein and
others, involving alleged offences punishable under Sections 468, 420 and
419 read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter, “the
IPC”). The case was registered as C.C.No.336 of 2015 upon transfer from
original Court. The criminal case was at the stage of arguments. In that case,
the third plaintiff was examined as P.W.1, while Sri T. Narayana Reddy, Sri K.
Kristappa and Sri J. Sankar Rao were examined as P.Ws. 2 to 4 on behalf of
the prosecution. The defendant sought to produce their depositions for use in
the present suit, in which Sri B. Ramana Reddy, the third plaintiff, was being
examined as P.W.1. Accordingly, the sole defendant filed the application to
receive the certified copies of the depositions of the four witnesses.
4. The plaintiffs opposed it contending that the depositions recorded in the
criminal case appeared to have been sought to be used under Section 33 of
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, but were not relevant to the civil suit. They
further contended that criminal and civil proceedings follow different
procedures and that findings in the criminal case would not bind the civil
Court. On these grounds, they sought dismissal of the application.
5. After hearing both sides, the learned Judge allowed the application,
observing in paragraph 8 as follows:
“8. … On considering the contentions of both sides, this Court
feels that merely receiving the documents would not vitiate the
case of the respondents/plaintiffs. The petitioner/defendant has
to prove the admissibility and relevance of the documents
before they are marked. Moreover, there are no tenable
objections in the counter. Accordingly, the petition is allowed.
9. In the result, the petition is allowed.”
6. Aggrieved by the order permitting the defendant to produce the depositions
of the third plaintiff and three other witnesses recorded in the criminal
proceedings, the plaintiffs have filed this revision petition.
7. Heard Sri G. Mahesh, learned counsel representing Sri Manjunath Allur,
learned counsel for the plaintiffs, and Sri K. Devi Prasanna Kumar, learned
counsel representing Sri O. Manohar Reddy, learned Counsel for the
defendant.
Arguments:
8. Sri G. Mahesh, learned counsel appearing for the plaintiffs contended that
the trial Court ought not to have allowed the application to receive certified
copies of depositions recorded in a criminal trial. Such depositions do not, by
themselves, constitute substantive evidence in the civil suit. Referring to Order
VIII Rule 3(1) CPC, counsel submitted that the defendant was required to
explain why the documents had not been filed at the appropriate stage along
with the written statement. No sufficient reason had been stated in the affidavit
for seeking permission to produce them at a later stage. Counsel further
submitted that the certified copies amounted to secondary evidence and that
the defendant had not filed an appropriate application under the relevant
provisions of law. Therefore, the interlocutory application ought to have been
dismissed.
9. In reply, learned counsel for the defendant submitted that the application
was confined to receiving the documents on record and did not seek to treat
them as conclusive evidence. The parties would have an opportunity to
address their admissibility and evidentiary value. Counsel further contended
that Section 33 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, did not apply to the present
case.
Discussion:
10. The principal issue in this revision is whether depositions recorded in the
criminal proceedings can be received in the present civil suit. The record
shows that, during the pendency of the suit, the first plaintiff, Sri Bada
Narayana Reddy, lodged a criminal complaint against the defendant. In that
criminal case, the third plaintiff was examined as P.W.1, and three other
witnesses were also examined.
11. The defendant, who is an accused in C.C.No.336 of 2015, sought to
produce the certified copies of the depositions of B. Ramana Reddy, the third
plaintiff, and the other three witnesses, deposition to place before P.W.1 i.e.
Sri B. Ramana Reddy in the civil suit.
12.
By the time the application was filed, the first plaintiff had died. The
parties disputed whether the depositions recorded in the criminal proceedings
could be used in the civil suit. Although the parties raised these issues before
the trial Court, the impugned order does not discuss them.
13.
Section 33 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, reads as follows:
“33. Relevancy of certain evidence for proving, in
subsequent proceeding, the truth of facts therein stated:
Evidence given by a witness in a judicial proceeding, or before
any person authorized by law to take it, is relevant for the
purpose of proving, in a subsequent judicial proceeding, or in a
later stage of the same judicial proceeding, the truth of the facts
which it states, when the witness is dead, or cannot be found, or
is incapable of giving evidence, or is kept out of the way by the
adverse party, or if his presence cannot be obtained without an
amount of delay or expense which, under the circumstances of
the case, the Court considers unreasonable :
Provided that:
(i) the proceeding was between the same parties or their
representatives in interest;
(ii) the adverse party in the first proceeding had the right and
opportunity to cross-examine; and
(iii) the questions in issue were substantially the same in the
first proceeding and the subsequent proceeding.
Explanation: A criminal trial or inquiry shall be deemed to be
a proceeding between the prosecutor and the accused within
the meaning of this section.”
14. Section 33 falls under Chapter II of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, which
deals with the relevancy of facts. Section 3 defines “evidence” to include oral
evidence and documentary evidence.
(1) All statements that the Court permits or requires witnesses to make
before it in relation to matters of fact under inquiry are called oral
evidence.
(2) All documents, including electronic records, produced for the
inspection of the Court are called documentary evidence.
15.
Sec.3 also defines “fact”-to include anything, any state of things or any
relation of things capable of being perceived by the senses, as well as any
mental condition of which a person is conscious.
16. The illustrations to Section 3 i.e. Sec. 3 illustrations (c) - relevant here say
-“That a man said certain words, is a fact”. This means, fact includes that a
person said certain words. Though he may not be a complainant, but he is a
party witness to the prosecution making a statement for prosecution. That
statement in criminal proceedings is now raised as a relevant fact (Sec. 3
illustration c). Where a party seeks to rely on a statement made in an earlier
judicial proceeding, the Court has to consider the purpose for which the
statement is relied upon and on the applicable rules of relevancy and
admissibility.
17. Section 33 permits evidence given in an earlier judicial proceeding to be
used in a subsequent proceeding to prove the truth of the facts stated therein
only when the conditions prescribed by that section are satisfied. Those
conditions include that the proceedings were between the same parties or
their representatives in interest, that the adverse party had the right and
opportunity to cross-examine the witness, and that the questions in issue were
substantially the same. The Explanation treats a criminal trial or inquiry as a
proceeding between the prosecutor and the accused.
18. The illustrations, ‘fact’ (Sec.3-(c)) means and includes a man had said
certain words. This fact has to be placed for evidence. If the averments are
that, a man has said certain words or statements, it is to be examined to cull
out the truth as to his statements, evidenced by oral or documentary evidence.
Chapter II deals with the relevancy of facts. To this case, relevancy of fact is
the fact that a man has given a statement or said some words in judicial
proceeding or before any person authorised by law, becomes a fact that, is so
relevant to prove that statement.
19.
The statement of such a person, if want to be brought as relevant, the
issue to be considered is, the person who made that statement is alive or not.
Then comes, in which judicial proceedings the statement was made, either
civil or criminal. If it is criminal proceedings, the relevancy would come upon
the conditions laid under Sec. 33 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (herein after
referred as ‘Evidence Act’.
20.
The conditions required for consideration under Sec.33 of Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 are that, the proceedings shall be between the same
parties. Adverse party had an opportunity to cross-examine the said party
i.e.the party who gave statements in criminal proceedings, had been cross
examined. The questions in issue have to be substantially the same in first
and subsequent proceedings.
21. The learned counsel for the plaintiffs relied on the distinction between the
parties to a criminal proceeding and those to a civil suit. In a criminal
proceeding, the parties are the prosecution and the accused; in a civil suit,
they are the plaintiff and the defendant. The applicability of Section 33 must,
however, be assessed by applying the statutory conditions to the facts of the
particular case.
22. In the case on hand, the prosecution was not a party to the criminal
proceeding, and the defendant was an accused. The third plaintiff was
examined as a prosecution witness. But he a party to that proceeding, as to
the relevant facts of statement in the criminal proceeding. If he is a party as to
the fact of statement in that case, that statements of him as to the said facts,
becomes relevancy to the civil suit. This requires for consideration. The third
plaintiff, who stated in the criminal proceedings, is alive. It do not satisfy the
conditions under Section 33 of the Evidence Act, as he is alive. But
statements previously made by the party before authority can be confronted
under Section 145 of the Evidence Act.
23. The documents sought to be received comprise the deposition of the third
plaintiff and the depositions of three other persons. The third plaintiff is a party
to the present suit and is available for examination. His deposition in the
criminal proceedings as can discussed above may be considered as a
previous statement. If the statement is relied upon to contradict him, the
procedure prescribed by Section 145 of the Evidence Act, for crossexamination as to previous statements in writing would follow. Mere receipt of
the deposition does not, by itself, prove the truth of its contents. It can be
tested in examination.
24. Thus, by provision of Section 145 read with Section 33 of the Evidence
Act, to prove the relevant fact of statements can be applied from the
statements made before the criminal Court. The witness in criminal case is 3 rd
plaintiff is the party on behalf of deceased first plaintiff, and in civil case, he is
a party as LR of deceased first plaintiff. Thus, the 3rd plaintiff is per se not
original complainant or a party to the criminal proceedings but becomes a
party as a witness for the original complainant i.e. 1st plaintiff (died) likewise in
the present suit, he is not the original plaintiff but on behalf of original
deceased 1st plaintiff, he came on record as a party being the LR of deceased
1st plaintiff. Thus, in both the cases, he becomes the party of the proceedings.
25. The depositions of T. Narayana Reddy, K. Kristappa and J. Sankar Rao
stand on a different stage. They are not parties to the present suit, and the
record does not show that they are to be examined as witnesses in it. Their
depositions cannot be treated as previous statements made by the third
plaintiff, on the premise that all four witnesses were examined in the same
criminal proceedings. For the above three persons, the issue arise, Section 33
of the Evidence Act, 1872, that they were have to be parties in the criminal
and civil proceedings. They are not parties in civil proceedings. Therefore,
they do not fall under Section 33 read with Section 145 of the Evidence Act,
1872.
26. The defendant relied on Jerrypothu Shamu John Babu v. Peddipoga
Anandarao and another 1 . In that case, the plaintiff had filed a suit for
recovery of money on a promissory note and sought to recall P.W.1 under
Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC to receive the deposition of the second defendant
recorded in an earlier suit, O.S.No.111 of 1988, instituted by the defendants.
The objection was that the deposition could not be received in view of Section
33 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The trial Court rejected the application,
and the matter was carried in revision. This Court held, relying on the decision
of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Moksh Builders and Financiers2,
that an admission made by the opposite party in an earlier proceeding may be
relevant even where Section 33 does not apply. The Court also noted that the
earlier evidence had been recorded in a suit between the same parties. The
relevant passage reads as follows:
“8. After hearing both the learned Counsel for the parties and
considering the material on record, I find merit in the contention
of the learned Counsel for the petitioner, especially in the light
of the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Union of
India v. Moksh Builders and Financiers (supra), that the petition
is liable to be allowed. As per the said decision of the Apex
Court even though the situation is not covered by Section 33 of
the Evidence Act, still the party is entitled for admission of such
evidence where the other side has made admissions. Further, it
is also a fact that the evidence was recorded in the suit
instituted between the same parties. Therefore, it is appropriate
that the admissions made in an earlier suit should be received
as evidence and the same should be marked as an exhibit on
behalf of the present plaintiff. The decisions of the Calcutta High
Court relied upon by the learned Counsel also support his
contention.”
2002 (3) ALT 510
(1977) 1 SCC 60
27. The High Court set aside the order rejecting the application and permitted
the earlier deposition to be received, having regard to the admissions relied
upon and the fact that the evidence had been recorded in a suit between the
same parties.
28. The facts of the present case are distinguishable. First, the deposition
sought to be produced in this case was in criminal proceedings. Secondly, Sri
T. Narayana Reddy, Sri K. Kristappa and Sri J. Sankar Rao are not parties to
the present suit. They were examined as witnesses in the criminal case. Sri B.
Ramana Reddy, on the other hand, is a party to the present suit and was
examined as a prosecution witness in the criminal proceedings.
29. The earlier proceeding was a criminal case, whereas the present
proceeding is a civil suit. The nature of the proceedings and the purpose for
which the depositions are sought to be used are therefore to be considered.
30. The three other witnesses are not parties to the present suit. Their
depositions cannot be treated as the previous statements of Sri B. Ramana
Reddy on behalf of deceased 1st plaintiff. The admissibility and evidentiary use
of those depositions has to be assessed independently. For these reasons,
the above ruling is distinguishable.
31. The learned trial Judge allowed the application in respect of all four
depositions without separately considering their nature and the purpose for
which each was sought to be used. The deposition of Sri B. Ramana Reddy
can be considered as his previous statement. The other three depositions
cannot be treated as statements of Sri B. Ramana Reddy and must be dealt
with in accordance with law.
31. In view of the foregoing discussion, I am of the view that, allowing the
application in respect of all four depositions without distinguishing between
them, is not proper. The certified copy of the deposition of B. Ramana Reddy,
examined as P.W.1 in C.C.No.336 of 2015, can be received on record, subject
to objections as to its admissibility, relevance and permissible use.
32. As to the objection of certified copy of the document concerned, it is the
deposition of the party relevant to confront. Thus, per se, certified copy, in the
circumstances, cannot be said secondary evidence. It is production of a
previous statement to the witness. It is not an entire document that sought to
be produced. The relevant statements in the depositions are required to prove
the fact/relevant fact of a statement of a person. The document of deposition
is the statement recorded by the concerned authority that may not be equated
with the entire document. Hence the stand that, certified copy of the
deposition becomes secondary evidence in the present circumstances of the
case is not tenable. The certified copies of the depositions of Sri T. Narayana
Reddy, Sri K. Kristappa and Sri J. Sankar Rao cannot be received under the
same reasoning or treated as previous statements of Sri B. Ramana Reddy.
The revision petition therefore deserves to be allowed in part.
Result:
33. In the result, the revision petition is allowed in part, with the following
directions:
i.
The order dated 18.03.2016 passed in I.A.No.753 of 2015 in
O.S.No.508 of 2005 on the file of the Principal Civil Judge (Junior
Division), Kadiri, is hereby set aside.
ii.
The certified copy of the deposition of B. Ramana Reddy, examined as
P.W.1 in C.C.No.336 of 2015, is hereby received, subject to proof, and
relevancy. Both parties are at liberty to raise their objections at the
appropriate stage, including when the document is tendered for
marking.
iii.
The application to receive the depositions of Sri T. Narayana Reddy,
Sri K. Kristappa and Sri J. Sankar Rao, is hereby rejected.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending interlocutory applications, if any, shall stand closed.
Interim order granted earlier is hereby vacated.
Dt: 26.10.2026
DSV
______________________________________
PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR CHINTALAPUDI, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review