Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010603762017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
FRIDAY,THE TENTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1322 OF 2017
Between:
1. B Tulasi, Krishna District & 1 Other, W/o Nagaraju, Hindu, aged 40
yrs House wife, R/o D No: 2-108, S T Colony, West lbrahimpatnam,
Ibrahimpatnam Village and Mandal, Krishna Dist, .AP
2. Banavathu Nagaraju, S/o Lat Krishna Naik, Hindu, aged 43 yrs ,
Employee,
R/s
22-108,
S
T
Colony,
West
Ibrahimpatnam,
Ibrahimpatnam Village and Mandal ,Krishna Dist, AP (Claimants)
...Petitioners
AND
1. SIRI TECON HYDERABAD & 1 OTHER, Rep by Mr Kommaraju
Jaya, M/s Sentini Cermica Pvt Ltd., Plot No 1229 Road NO 60 ,Jubli
Hills, Hyderabad-500034
2. The United India Insurance Co Ltd, Rep by its Divisional Manager,
Divisional Office, Divisional Office-II, Post Box NO 774, Besides High
School Road, Patamata, Krishna Dist, Vijayawada 520010 AP
...Respondents
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Court to set
aside the Judgment and Decree passed in MVOP 626 of 2013, dt
25.1.2017 on the file of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal Court
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1322 of 2017
Cum XIV Additional District Judge, Vijayawada by allowing appeal
and decreeing M V O P 626 of 2013 as prayed for compensation of
Rs.14,00,000/-with costs and pass
Counsel for the Petitioners: B VAMSI KRISHNA
Counsel for the Respondents: L V S PRASAD BABU PUVVADA
Counsel for the Respondents:
The Court made the following order:
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1322 of 2017
JUDGMENT:
Heard,
Sri B.Vamsi Krishna, learned Counsel for the Claimantsappellants and Sri L.V.S.Prasad Babu, learned Counsel for the second
respondent-United Insurance Company Limited.
2.
The parties are arrayed as arrayed in the present appeal.
3.
Dissatisfied with the Award and Decree, dated 25.01.2017,
passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-XIV Additional
District Judge, Vijayawada in M.V.O.P.No.626 of 2013, filed under
Section 166 (1) (c) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 r/w Rule 455 of the
Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989, wherein the Tribunal dismissed the claim,
the present appeal is filed by the appellants.
4.
The facts germane in the present appeal are capsuled as under:
Petitioners are the father and mother of the deceased, namely
Banavath Madhu Naik @ Madhu Babu, who sustained fatal injuries in
a road accident that occurred on 19.09.2013. The deceased was
travelling along with his cousin, Mr.Bhukya Ramesh, towards
Ibrahimpatnam on 19.09.2013 and at about 9.00 P.M., when they
reached Paritala Bypass Cross Road on NH-65 main road, the
offending lorry bearing No.AP 28 TB 5072, coming from Vijayawada
towards Kanchikacherla, in the wrong route in a rash and negligent
manner, collided with them. As a result, both the deceased and his
cousin sustained multiple grievous injuries. The deceased succumbed
to his injuries on 07.10.2013, while his cousin also died on
19.09.2013
while
undergoing
treatment.
In
pursuance
of
the
complaint, on 21.09.2013, the Station House Officer, Kanchikacherla
Police Station registered Cr.No.227 of 2013 under Section 237 of IPC.
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1322 of 2017
5.
Learned
counsel
for
the
appellants,
Mr.Vamsi
Krishna,
contended that, as per the pleadings before the Tribunal, the deceased
was running a business under the name and style 8Hanuman Tyre Retrading Cool Process9 at Chillakallu Village prior to the accident and
was earning a sum of Rs.50,000/- per month. At the time of the
accident, he was 21 years old and was contributing his entire income
towards the family expenses. It is further contended that the
Claimants incurred an amount of Rs.3,00,000/- towards medical
treatment and Rs.50,000/- towards miscellaneous expenses. The
deceased being the only son of the appellants, they claimed a total
compensation of Rs.14,00,000/-.
6.
Respondent No.1 is the owner of the lorry and respondent No.2
is the Insurer of the crime vehicle bearing No.AP 28 TB 5072.
Respondent No.1 remained ex parte and the respondent No.2 filed
counter, denying the averments of the petition, contending that the
respondent No.2 is not aware of the registration of the case in
Cr.No.227 of 2013, under Section 304-A IPC. The other contention,
which could be seen from the counter, is that the rider of the motor
cycle was not possessing any driving licence and, therefore, the
Insurance company is not liable to pay any compensation.
7.
Basing on the pleadings, so placed before the Tribunal, the
following issues were framed:
1. Whether the deceased, Banavath Madhu Naik @ Madhu
Babu died in a Motor Vehicle accident which took place
on 19.09.2013 at about 9.00 p.m., on the NH 65 main
road near Paritala Byepass road in Kanchikacherla
Village due to the rash and negligent driving of the Tipper
lorry bearing No.AP 28 TB 5072 by its driver ?
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1322 of 2017
2. Whether the petitioners 1 and 2 are entitled to the
compensation as prayed for, if so, from whom ?
3. To what relief ?
8.
During the course of trial, the Claimants got examined P.Ws.1 to
3 and marked Exs.A1 to A14. On behalf of the respondents, R.W.1 was
examined and Exs.B1 and B2 and Ex.X1 were marked on behalf of the
second respondent.
9.
While answering Issue No.1, the Tribunal has taken note of the
evidence adduced on behalf of the petitioners. P.W.1 reiterated the
averments made in the Claim Petition and got examined one Banavath
Vijaya Babu Naik as P.W.2. The evidence of P.W.2 fortifies that,
immediately after the accident, he rushed to the place of accident and
shifted both the injured persons to the hospital and, thereafter, lodged
a complaint on 21.09.2013. Banavath Madhu Naik succumbed to his
injuries on 07.10.2013, while undergoing treatment and the other
injured person, who was accompanying the Claimants9 son, also died
on 19.09.2013, while undergoing treatment. Ex.A1, which is the copy
of F.I.R., reveals that complaint was lodged alleging that the accident
occurred due to the rash and negligent driving, which was fortified by
the Inquest Report, that was conducted on the dead body and Ex.A4,
postmortem examination report, confirms that the death was caused
due to multiple injuries.
10.
Claimants got examined P.W.3, an Orthopedic Consultant
working at Help Hospitals, Vijayawada, who deposed that, on
20.09.2013, when Madhu Babu was admitted in the hospital, he was
found to have sustained a Grade-I compound comminuted fracture of
left femur. On 29.09.2013, an external fixator was applied as part of
the treatment. The medical bills issued by the hospital, marked as
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1322 of 2017
Ex.A10, amount to Rs.2,99,731.81ps. Ex.X1 is the copy of the Case
Sheet of the patient and Ex.A11 is the bunch of X-ray films. Ex.X1,
Ex.A10, and Ex.A11, coupled together, substantiate the evidence of
P.W.3 regarding the treatment provided to the injured, Banavath
Madhu Naik @ Madhu Babu, who subsequently succumbed to his
injuries. The Tribunal has taken note of the evidence of P.W.2, who
stated that the deceased died on 07.10.2013 while undergoing
treatment.
11.
Learned counsel for the Appellants vehemently contended that
the Tribunal was completely misdirected in placing undue reliance on
the evidence of P.W.3. It is argued that the Inquest report and the
Postmortem report clearly establish that the deceased succumbed to
death on the same day, however, the Tribunal erroneously observed
that the patient had left the hospital and, on that basis, questioned
the genuineness of the evidence of P.W.3.
12.
While coming to the evidence of R.W.1, through which nothing
could be elicited, the Tribunal has categorically observed that it can be
safely concluded that the deceased, Madhu Naik, died due to multiple
injuries sustained in the accident. Further, while appreciating the
evidence of R.W.1, who is the owner of the lorry, the Tribunal noted
that the petitioner had neither impleaded the lorry driver as a party
nor examined him as a witness. Ex.A6 is the copy of the Registration
Certificate of the lorry bearing No.AP 28 TB 5072 in the name of
respondent No.2 and Ex.A7 is the copy of the Insurance policy of the
crime vehicle bearing No.AP 28 TB 5072 and Ex.A8 is the copy of the
driving licence of the deceased, Banavath Madhu Naik. Ex.A9 is the
copy of the driving licence of Bhukya Ramesh Naik @ Ramesh Naik.
Ex.12 is the copy of the Charge sheet in Cr.No.227 of 2013 while
Ex.A13 is the copy of the M.V.I. report. Ex.A.12 reveals that on
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1322 of 2017
19.09.2013 at 9.00 P.M., the driver one Pamula Andraiah, S/o
Yesupadam drove the lorry bearing No.AP 28 TB 5072 in a rash and
negligent manner and dashed the motor cycle due to which the rider
and pillion rider of the motor cycle fell down and sustained injuries.
13.
Ex.A13, the Motor Vehicle Inspector9s report, entails that the
offending vehicle involved in the accident was a lorry bearing No.AP 28
TB 5072. The report also refers to the driving licence of the lorry driver
and opines that the accident did not occur due to any mechanical
defect in the vehicle, which can be safely construed to indicate that
the accident was the result of rash and negligent driving on the part of
the driver. However, despite recording a finding that the accident
vehicle was driven in a rash and negligent manner, the Tribunal
ultimately concluded that the accident did not occur due to such rash
and negligent driving. Further, while holding that the Claimants failed
to adduce sufficient evidence in support of their claim, the Tribunal
answered Issue No.1 in favour of the Respondents and against the
Claimants.
14.
Learned counsel for the Appellants/Claimants would draw the
attention of this Court to paragraph No.15 of the Award of the
Tribunal, wherein it is observed at the very outset that, except for the
copy of the charge sheet, marked as Ex.A12, the petitioner did not
produce any direct evidence to establish that the lorry was driven in a
rash and negligent manner at the time of the accident. Learned
counsel strenuously contended that the charge sheet itself is sufficient
to establish that the offending vehicle was driven in a rash and
negligent manner. It was further argued that the Tribunal erred in
holding that the Claimants failed to establish the rash and negligent
driving, as strict proof beyond reasonable doubt.
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1322 of 2017
15.
In
support
of
his
claim,
learned
Counsel
for
the
Appellants/Claimants relied upon the judgment of the Hon9ble
Supreme Court reported in Sanju Bai Prajapati and Others vs. New
India Assurance Company Limited and Others 1 , wherein, at
paragraph No.6, it was held as follows:
<6. As far as the accident, it is seen that there is no dispute since a
Murg report was made on intimation from the hospital which is
produced as Annexure P-1 in which it was recorded that a person
involved in a road accident was admitted to the hospital who died at
12:30 am. The accident is said to have occurred at 6 pm and the murg
report was on the same day. The mere fact that PW-2, the eyewitness
did not approach the police cannot be a reason to find the delay in FIR
to be suspicious. The accident itself having been proved and a Murg
report filed, definitely investigation would be carried out. We see from
the FIR that based on the Murg report an investigation was carried out
in the course of which the eyewitness was detected and Annexure P-2
FIR was registered. We do not find any reason to disbelieve the FIR,
especially since the insurance company did not make any attempt to
examine the investigating officer before the Tribunal.=
16.
In oppugnation to the said arguments advanced by the learned
Counsel for the Claimants, Sri L.V.S.Prasad Babu, learned Counsel
for the second respondent-United Insurance Company Limited, would
vehemently contend that, in the absence of any cogent evidence
adduced by the Claimants, the Tribunal has rightly concluded that
rash and negligent driving was not established and rejected the claim
of the Claimants, which needs no interference.
17.
After hearing both the learned Counsel, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the Tribunal is erroneous in concluding that
the Claimants failed to establish the fact of rash and negligent driving
by the driver of the offending vehicle. In the light of the dictum laid
down by the Hon9ble Supreme Court that the Claimants need not
stress themselves to prove rash and negligent driving when the charge
(2025) 9 SCC 414
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1322 of 2017
sheet and the F.I.R. contend the same and, more so, since the charge
sheet is filed only after investigation.
18.
It is to be noted that the respondents, who contend that no
evidence other than the charge sheet has been adduced by the
claimants, have failed to satisfy this Court as to whether they have
challenged the said charge sheet before any legal forum . In the absence
of such challenge, the charge sheet has to be taken into consideration
and, in view of the ratio laid down by the Hon9ble Supreme Court ibid,
this Court is of the opinion that there is an element of rash and
negligent driving and the Appellants/Claimants have satisfactorily
placed evidence to substantiate their claim regarding the rash and
negligent driving and the Issue No.1 is answered in favour of the
Claimants and against the respondents in the present appeal. The
decision of the Tribunal is overturned.
19.
Now, coming to Issue No.2, regarding the compensation, in a
connected matter, M.A.C.M.A.No.1388 of 2017, filed by the claimants
of the deceased, motorcyclist, by name Bhukya Ramesh Nayak @
Ramesh Nayak, this Court allowed the appeal on 02.01.2026 by
setting aside the Award of the Tribunal, which had rejected the claim
of the claimants therein for compensation on the ground that the
claimants failed to prove the rash and negligent driving. In the said
appeal, this Court, after reiterating the ratio laid down by the Hon9ble
Supreme Court in the case of Sarla Verma & others v. Delhi
Transport Corporation & another 2 applied the multiplier method
8179 since the deceased was aged 28 years.
20.
Interestingly, learned Counsel for the Appellants states, at this
stage, that a connected Appeal, M.A.C.M.A.No.1388 of 2017, arising
2009 (3) ALD 83 (SC)
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1322 of 2017
out of the same accident, was allowed and the present Appeal also
deserves to be allowed.
21.
As could be seen from the Award passed by the Tribunal, there
is no mention about the income of the deceased. When there is a clear
statement made by the Claimants that the deceased was earning a
sum of Rs.50,000/- per month and in the absence of any categorical
denial by the respondents, the Tribunal has not ventured to deal with
the said fact for the sole reason that Issue No.1 was rejected. Further,
as could be seen from the evidence, there is no contradiction or crossexamination by the Insurance company regarding the income of the
deceased at the time of accident and when there is no rebuttal to the
contention so raised, this Court has to necessarily accept the said
assertion as true and take the statement into consideration.
22.
In the interest of justice, it would be right to take the income of
the deceased on a reasonable basis since no material is placed before
the Tribunal to substantiate that he was earning Rs.50,000/- per
month towards the business i.e., 8Hanuman Tyre Retrading Cool
Process9 at Chillakallu Village. Though there is no rebuttal to the said
claim, this Court is inclined to accept the arguments of the learned
Counsel appearing for the Insurance Company that it is only a mere
bald contention that the deceased is earning Rs.50,000/-, which is not
supported by any evidence and, in such absence, a statement so made
in the Claim Petition cannot be taken as a sacrosanct.
23.
As
stated
supra,
this
Court,
in
a
connected
Appeal,
M.A.C.M.A.No.1388 of 2017, arising out of the same accident, has
taken note and held that Rs.5000/- per month to be calculated as
income of the deceased and it would continue a JUST compensation if
the same is taken uniformly in the present case also. Therefore, the
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1322 of 2017
annual income of the deceased comes to Rs.60,000/- (Rs.5,000 x 12).
After deducting 1/4th of the annual income towards the personal
expenses of the deceased, the annual income of the deceased comes to
Rs.45,000/- (Rs.60,000-Rs.15,000/-). Applying the multiplier 8189 as
per the judgment of the Hon9ble Supreme Court in the case of Sarla
Verma & Others vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Another 3, the
compensation comes to Rs.45,000 x 18 = Rs.8,10,000/-. An amount of
Rs.70,000/- towards loss of consortium, loss of estate and funeral
expenses is fixed. The claimants placed on record the medical bills
amounting to Rs.2,90,731.81ps, which cannot be denied and need to
be awarded to the Claimants. Therefore, the total compensation comes
to Rs.11,70,731.81ps (Rs.8,10,000/-+ 70,000/-+ 2,90,731.81ps).
24.
In fine, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed,
setting
aside
the
Award
and
Decree,
dated
25.01.2017,
in
M.V.O.P.No.626 of 2013, passed by the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal-cum-XIV Additional District Judge, Vijayawada. Respondents
1 and 2 are directed to deposit Rs.11,70,731.81ps before the Tribunal,
within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment. On such deposit, Claimants are entitled to withdraw the
same in equal shares. There shall be no order as to costs.
25.
As a sequitur, Interlocutory Applications pending, if any, shall
stand closed.
___________________________
TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA, J
10th April, 2026
Tsy
2009 (3) ALD 83 (SC)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review