Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3448 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE N/VENTY SECOND DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CIVIL REVISI0N PETITION NO: 1885 OF 2022
Petition under Article 227 of Constitution of lndia aggrieved by the order dated
0410312022 passed in l.A.No. 792 of 2015 in O.S.No. 128 of 2007 on the file of the
Court of the XXVII Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, at Secunderabad.
Between:
B.Rama Rao, S/o. Late B.Shankaraiah, Aged 48 years, Occ: Business, R/o.1210-41612, 211, 212, Sithafalmandi, Secunderabad.
..Petitioner/Respondent No. 4lD-4
AND
1. B.Nageswara Rao and 5Others, S/o: Late B.Shankaraiah, Aged 40 years,
Occ: Business, Rlo.12-1O4161911, ground, 1st floor, Sitafalmandi,
. Secunderabad.
... RespondenUPetitioner/Plaintiff
2. Smt.B.Sarojini Devi(died), per L.Rs (R2)
3. Smt. P.Anitha, Wo P.Satyanarayana, Aged 44years, Occu: Household , Rlo 121 O -4 16, U pstairs, Sitafalmand i, Secund rabad. (R2-D2)
4. B. Srinivas Rao, S/o Late Shankaiah, Aged 42years, Occu: Business, R/o SRT
388, MCH No.1-1-3791237, Mahalakshmi Enclave, Jawaharnagar,
Chikkadpally, Hyderabad.(D3)
5. B.Ganesh Rao, S/o. Late B.shankaraiah, Aged 47 years, Occu: Business,
R/o. 1 2-10 -41 6 19 I 1, Sitafalmand i, Secunderabad. ( D5)
6. Smt.P.Gayatri, Wo. Late P.Ram Mohan Rao, C/o.P.Purnachandra Rao, Aged
34 years, Rlo.3-44, Padmavathi Colony, Shadnagar, Mahabubnagar Dist., (D6)
(Respondent Nos.3 to 5 herein and Defendants 7 to 29 are not necessary parties
to this Revision)
... Res po n de n ts/Res po n de n ts/Defe n da nts
l.A. No. 1 oF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed irr support of the petition, the,High Court may be pleased to suspend
the impugned ,rrder dated 0410312022 passed in 1.A.No.792 of 2015 in O.S.No.128 of
2007 by XXVII Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court at Secunderabad during the
pendency of the present revision in the interest of justice.
l.A. No. 2 oF 2:023
Between:
1. B.Nage:;wara Rao and 5 Others, S/o Late B.Shankaraiah, Aged 40 years,
Occ: ISusiness, Rlo.12-10-4161911, ground, 1st floor, Sitafalmandi,
Secund erabad.
...Petitioner/Respondent No.1
AND
1. B.Ramar Rao, S/o. Late B.Shankaraiah, Aged 48 years, Occ: Business,
Rl o.12- 1 0-41612, 21 1, 212, Sithafalmand i, Secunderabad.
... RespondenUPetitioner
2. Smt.B.,Sarojini Devi(died), per L.Rs
3. Smt. P.Aeitha, W/o P.Satyanarayana, Aged 44years, Occu: Household,Rlo 1210416, Lrpstairs, Sitafalmandi, Secundrabad
4. B. Srinivas Rao, S/o Late Shankaiah, Aged 42years, Occu: Business, R/o SRT
388, MCH No.1-1-379t237, Mahalakshmi'Enclave, Jawaharnagar, Chikkadpally,
Hyderabad.
5. B.Ganesh Rao, S/o. Late B.Shankaraiah, Aged 47 years, Occu: Business,
R/o. 1 2-1(t-41619l1, Sitafalmandi, Secunderabad.
6. Smt.P.Geryatri, Wo. Late P.Ram [\4ohan Rao, C/o.P.Purnachandra Rao, Aged
34 years, ?1o.3-44, Padmavathi Colony, Shadnagar, Mahabubnagar Dist.,
.. Res pondents/Responde nts
(RR 2 to 6 not necessary in this lA)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the Fligh Court may be pleased to vacate the
interim orders Ct.26tOBt2O22in C.R.P.No. 1885 of 2022.
Counsel for the Petitioner : Sri. B Mohan
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: Sri. L Harish
The Court made the following: ORDER
i
Ii
t
I
I
.. _ -..;_ :r i..
IN THE HIGH COURT r.OR THE STATE OF. TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CTVIL REVISION PE[ITION.NO.1885 OF 2022
Dated: 22nd JANUARY, 20.26
I.ISflTISIEI\II
1. B.Rama Rao, S/o.Late B.Shankaraiah,
... PetitionerRespondent No.4-Defendant No.4
AND
1. B.Nageswara Rao, S/o.Late B.Shankaraiah,
Aged 40 years, Occ: Business,
R/o.12-10-41619/ 1, ground 1"t floor,
Sitafalmandi, Secunderabad.
...RespondentPetitioner-Plaintiff
2..Smt.B.Sarojini Devi (died) per LRs.
3. Smt. P.Anitha, W/o.P.Sat5ranarayana,
Aged 44 years, Occ: Household,
R / o. 12- 10 -4 16, Upstairs,
Sitafalmandi, Secunderabad and Others.
...RespondentRespondents-Defendant6
t.rrilrrf;]
1.
This Memorandum of Civil Revision Petition is filed under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India assailing the order passed
by the learnEfXxvll Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court at
.-:::r--':-::
":
-'
BRMR,J
cRP_188s_2022
C}
Secunderabad in IA.No.792 of 2015 in OS.No.l28 of 2OO7, dated
04.03.20122.
2.
Petitioner is the respondent No.4-defendant No.4, respondent
No.1 is tLLe petitioner-plaintiff, respond.ent No.2 is respondent No.1-
defendant No.1 in IA.No .792 of 2OLS in OS.No.128 of 2OO7.
3.
It is mentioned in the cause title of the CRP that respondent
.'I
Nos.3 to 5-respondent Nos.2, 3, 5 and 6-defendant Nos.2, 3, 5 and
6 are not necessary parties.
4.t. Rer;pondent No.l-petitioner stated in the affidavit (i.e. in
IA.No.791) of 2015) that during the lift time of his mother
(respondt:nt No.2-defendant No.l) and before her demise, after
filing thr: suit, defendant No.4 (petitioner herein) got executed
vaiious gift deeds involving most of the properties in his favour and
to give a belief that he is making a fair PIay, got executed few gift
deeds in favour of defendant Nos.2, 3, 5 and 6 (respondent Nos.3 to
6 herein'r disproportionately when his mother was mentally and
physicalty unstable to misappropriate much of the assets of the
family and to deprive the rights of the plaintiff (i.e.,' respondent
No.1-petitioner). Defendant Nos.2 to 6 (respondent Nos.3, 4,
petitione::, respondent Nos.S and 6 herein) got executed the
following deeds:
I
L
tl..
)
3/20
BRMR,J
cRP_1885_2022
fillaaao7 218/,n0{}7
ultp,l2wt21e31200.7
"
zs/tolzao7
, dnwttter of WNo;4
j---..-,.**.-:..*-
-
2,6,2120,A7
4.2. Without the knowledge of respondent No.l-petitioner al1 the
manipulation is the brainchild of defendant No.4 (petitioner herein)
to knock away the properties and he came to know about the gift
deeds recently and sought to declare them as not binding on him
consequently to declare them as null and void. If the application is
not allowed seeking cancellation of the gift settlernent deed.s,
respondent No.rl{etitioner-plaintiff will be put to irreparable loss
I
BRMR,J
cRP_1885_2022
C
and damage and prayed to declare the gift deeds executed in favour
of defeniant Nos.2 to 6 as null and void. and consequently to
declare .-he same as not binding on respondent No.1-petitioner-
plaintiff.
5.
Petitioner-respondent No.4 has filed counter and contended
that respondent No. 1-petitioner-plaintiff is having knowledge about
the gift settlement deeds on 08.02.2008 when defendant No.l
(respondent No.2 herein) has filed her written statement, all the gift
deeds wore already furnished to the counsel for respondent No.i-
petitioner-plaintiff before the trial Court and after lapse of 7 Yz
years respondent No.1-petitioner-plaintiff cannot seek declaration
to declare the gift settlement deeds as not binding on him and to
declare them as null and void which is hopelessly barred by
liriritatio:r. By virtue of registered gift settlement deeds executed by
defendant No.1 in favour of the petitioner-respondent No.4, he is
collectin;3 the rents from the tenants as a lawful owner and
respondt:nt No.1-petitioner-plaintiff is not entitled for any share.
Respondent No.1-petitioner-plaintiff is not entitled to seek
amendment for cancellation of gift settlement deed after lapse of
time anc, the application is barred. by limitation, ylrayed to dismiss
the samt:
.--.?
"
..:; f.ir:",;i::::.'l
.:ri{-&n:.*,i;
sl20
/'
BRMR,J
cRP_1885_2022
6.1. The learned trial Court allowed IA.No.792 of 2Ol5 on
12.07.20L7.
6.2. Petitioner has filed CRP against the order dated L2.O7.2017
uide CRP No.4O19 of 2Ol7 which was allowed by the High Court on
23.02.2018 and remanded the matter for fresh consideration.
6.3. After remand the learned trial Court has allowed IA.No.792
of 2Ol5 uide order dated O4.O3.2O22 which is impugned in the
CRP.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner-respondent No.4-
defendant No.4 submits that the learned trial Court ignored the
Iind.ings of the High Court in CRP No.4O 19 of 2Ol7 dated
23.02.2018 and erred in allowing the petition in part permitting the
reppondent No.1-petitioner to amend the plaint for inclusion of the
relief to declare the gift deeds executed in favour of defendant
Nos.3 to 5 (respondent No.4, petitioner and respondent No.5
herein) as null and void subject to payment of cost of Rs.650/- and
on payment of required Court Fee. The learned trial Court failed to
see that IA.No.792 of 2015 is barred by law as the gift deeds were
executed long back commencing from 2OOT till the end of October,
2008. Respqndent No. l-petitioner-plaintiff sought for amendment
after lapse 6S. qgven years which is contrary to Article 59 of the
6l2o
BRMR,J
cRP_r885_2022
:i-\
Limitation Act. The learned trial Court failed to comply the orders
of the H gh Court in CRP No.4019 of 2Ol7 dated 23.02.2018 and
did not zrnswer with regard to the limitation. The plea of limitation
raised by the petitioner-respondent No.4-defendant No.4 is not
tenable and acceptable which finding is whoily in contradiction
with the observations of the High Court in CRP No.4O19 of 2OL7.
The trial Court fell in error in holding that the proposed
amendment sought by the respondent No.1-petitioner-plaintiff is
pre-trial amendment, when admittedly issues were framed,
responde:nt No.1-petitioner-plaintiff has already filed his chief
affidavit as PW. 1. Counsel to substantiate his contentions has
relied on the decisions in the cases of (1) Radhika Devi
Vs. Bajrangi Singh and othersl, (2) Revajeetu Builders and
Developers Vs. Narayanaswamy and Sons and others2, (3) Upender
Prasad f)hube Vs. Shyamalamma Dhube and otherss, (4) Ashwani
Sood Vs. Chanderkanta and another+ and prayed to allow the CRP
by setting aside the impugned order.
8.
learned counsel for respondent No.1-petitioner-plaintiff
submits that the learned trial Court has properly appreciated. the
facts of the case and rightly allowed the application filed by
'j
' lrssoy 7 scc 486
lzoos; 10 scc 84
202t scc onLine TS 3660
o
202q scc cnline HP 136
,t
I
-j_i:r'ri
.. :
:;..ii+i;.ig$i
.;lr;j^itrilEEl
.".x*ffi
,r:iiffi
7l2O
BRMR,J
cRP_1885_2022
respondent No.1-petitioner. Amendment is carried out and neat
copy is filed, the amended plaint was returned by the trial Court as
the amendment carried out was not in accordance with the orders
passed in IA.No.792 of 2015, dated O4.O3.2O22. Counsel to
substantiate his contention has relied on the decision in the case
of Sree Sree Iswar Radha Behari Jew and Sree Sree Iswar Salgram
Jew Represented by Basudeb Das Vs. Smalati P.Sonis.
9.
Learned counsel on record have filed their written arguments
in support of their contentions.
10. Heard learned counsel on record, perused the material
11. Now the point for consideration is: Whether the order passed
by the learned trial Court suffers from any perversity or illegality?
If so, does it require interference of this Court?
12.1. Respondent No.1-petitioner-plaintiff has filed suit under
Section 26, Order VII Rule 1 and 2 of Civil Procedure Code, 1908
(for short 'CPCJ for partition and separate possession of the
plaint A'to'G'properties and for allotment of llZu share and to
pass a final decree in terms of preliminary decree. During
pendency of the suit, respondent No.2-defendant No.1 died thereby
s
zo19 AIR (cat) 131
t
I
t
i.
,i
,l
I
8l2o
BRMR,J
cRP_1885_2022
respondent No.1-plaintiff has amended the plaint stating that he is
entitled f.cr I /6h share in the suit schedule
([' to 'G' properties.
L2.2. Tae further case of the plaintiff is that all the suit schedule
properties are joint family properties and lhey are liable for
partition. Suit came to be filed on 27.O9.2OO7 and got registered
on 06.1O.2OO7.
i3.
Respondent No.2-defendant No.1 has filed her written
statement and contended that 'A' schedule property is self acquired
property having purchased the same through a registered sale deed
dated 12.03.1960. Thereafter obtained Municipal permission from
M.C.H. emd constructed a building in the year L977 and she has
gifted d:'fferent portions of A' schedule property in favour of
defendant Nos.3, 4 & 5 i.e., respondent No.4, revision petitioner
and respondent No.S herein and her granddaughters by virtue of
registered gift settlement deed. Therefore, the plaintiff (respondent
No.1 herein) has no share in A' schedule property- In so far as B'
schedult: property is concerned respondent No.2-defendant No.1
stated that she has no objection to partition the propert5r and
'C' sche<lule properties is acquired by late B.Shankaraiah and he
executecl a will on ll.O2.2:OO4 in favour of defendant No.6
P.Gayatri (respondent No.6 herein) and she is alone entitled for the
same
S;uifB&eduie D'property is concerned B.Shankaraiah and
t
,
tI
I
(\
a':'
BRMR,J
cRP_1885_2022
defendant No.1 have purchased the same through three registered
sale deeds. B.Shankaraiah has bequeathed the same to defendant
No.3 under a will deed dated LL.O2.2OO4 and defendant No.3 is in
possession of one portion and the remaining portion was
purchased by her through her stridhana property and she gifted
the same in favour of defendant Nos.3 and 5 by virtue of gift deeds
as such respondent No.1-plaintiff is not entitled for any share. E'
schedule property is purchased by Shankaraiah and he gifted the
same to his wife uide gift deed document No.226 of 1954 and she
became the absolute owner thereof and thereafter she gifted the
same to defendant No.4 by virtue of registered gift deed. 'F'
schedule property is acquired by B.Shankaraiah and he
bequeathed the same to defendant No.2 by virtue of will deed
executed by him. 'G' schedule property is acquired by defendant
No.l by virtue of registered sale deed, dated 31.12.2003 with her
stridhana property and the plaintiff has no share.
14. Defendant Nos.2 to 5 (respondent Nos.3, 4, petitioner and
respondent No.S herein) in the suit have filed their written
statement which is adopted by defendant No.6 (respondent No.6
herein). Their written statement is similar to the written statement
of respondent No.2-defendant No.1. Defendant No.7-Vinod Kumar
Malani is added as a party in the suit as per orders in IA.No.141O
)
)
BRMR,J
10120
cRP_1885_2022
of 2OO8 ,lated Ol.l2.2OO9. Defendant Nos.8 to 29 are aiso added
in the r;uit as per the orders in IA.No.25O4 of 2OtO dated
l3.Og.2Ol2. Defendant Nos.7 to 29 are the tenants of the plaint
schedule property.
15. Th: prayer made in IA.No.792 of 2015 is as under:
"lt is prayed this Honble Court may be pleased to permit
the petitioner/plaintiff to carry out amendments in
pleadings/plaint for declaration to declare that the gift
dee,ds got executed in favour of defendant Nos.2 to 6 as null
antl void and consequently to declare that same are not
binding on the petitioner/plaintiff in the interest of justice".
16. Now it is apt to refer Rule 28 of Civil Rules of Practice which
reads as under:
"28. (New) Amendment in Pleadings: An application for
amendment made under Order I, Rule 10, Order VI, Rule
L7, or Order XXII of the Code, shall also contain a prayer for
all consequential amendments. The Presiding Officer shall
rejt:ct the appiication if it is not in accordance with the law
or these rules. Provided that verbal corrections may at any
time be made in pleadings with permission of the Court".
17. On reading of Rule 28 of Civil Rules of practice an
application for amendment shall also contain a prayer for all
consequential amendments. The Presiding Officer shall reject the
application if it is not in accordance with the law or these rules.
i
I
I
,l
ttl20
{':"
BRMR,J
cRP_1885-2022
Admittedly, in tJre prayer portion in IA.No.792 of 2075 it does not
contain the consequential amendment. The learned trial Court has
lost sight of the same and did not answer with regard to Rule 28.
18. Suit Docket Proceedings dated 07 .09.2OL7 , L5.O9.2OLT ,
18.09.2017 (lssue No.4), 18.07.2019, O4.O3.2O22, LO.O3.2O22,
t2.o4.2022, 16.06.2022, 13.O7.2022, 1O.08.2022, 13.O9.2022
which reads as under:
)7.O9.20t7
lhe main contention of the learned counsel for D4 & D5 is that
rlaintiff carried out the amendment of plaint more than the relief
lor amendment sought under this petition. It is not the case of
:hanging the nature o[ the suit. On careful perusal, I am of the
,ziew that the D4 & D5 are having ample opportunity to raise the
rame in their additional written statement. Further in view of
:rature of the suit and the amendment sought, as it is not
:hanging the nature of the suit, I find no force in the contention
:f the counsel for D4 & D5. For addl. WS as last chance. No
:urther time call on ll-O9-2OL7.
15.o9.20t7
qddl. WS of D4 & D5. The rest of defendants have failed to file
rddl. WS despite of sufficient time and conditional order. Hence
:heir addl. WS is treated as nil. For hearing on issues call on
1a.o9.20t7.
t8.o9.20t7
Basing on the pleadings the following issues are framed for trial:
1. Whether the gift deeds executed by the l"t defendant in favour
rf defendant Nos.3 to 6 are valid and on all his successors.
18.07.20t9
Perusal of record show that CRP No.4019/2017 was allowed by
Hon'ble High Court on O3-O2-2O18 setting aside the order dated
l2-O7-2O17 in IA No. 792/?OLS passed by XII AAJ and remanded
lhe matter with a direction to consider the contentions of
petitioners therein and to pass appropriate reasoned order afresh
|n accordance with law, within 2 months from the date of receipt
rf copy of the order. This apart the Hon'ble High Court allowed
CRP NO.40O4/2OL7 on 03-O2-2018 and set aside the order dated
L2-O7-2O17 in IA No.424 /2017 passed by XII AC.I and remanded
the matter to consider the contentions of petitioner therein and
pass appropriate reasoned order afresh within 2 months from the
iate of receipt.of copy of the order. For hearing lANo.792l2Ol5
tnd 424/2017 posted to 25-07-2019 (and from then to O5-O82O19 to 14-O8-2O19).
)4.O3.2022
A 792 / 15 in the result, the petition. is partly allowed.
1O.O3.2022
)osts paid. Amendment carried out. Neat copy of plaint filed. For
\ddl. Written statement if anv call on 23.O3.2Q22. lA 424/2OLs
(\
T
I
E
l
ta
I
12120
BRMR,J
cRP-1885_2022
Pending. Call on 23.03.2022 (further adjourned to 28.03.2022 to
t2.o4.20221.
2.O4.2022
A.mendment carried out and neat copy of the plaint already hled.
But however, as the plaintiff as party in person has carrying out
Lhe amendment and filed the neat copy, the office is directed to
,rerify the carrying out amendment and also neat copy of the
olaint as the same is in accordance with the orders passed in
1.A.792/15. Hence, for verification of the same, call on 22.4.22.
ifurther adjourned to 29-04-2022 to 06-06-2022 to 16-06-20221.
16.06.2022
Plaintiff present and represented that he engaged new counsel by
name K. Gopala Krishna, advocate in place of the earlier counsel
on record but the earlier counsel has not given NOC and delaying
the matter and in those circumstances, he may be permitted to
engage new counsel for conducting the suit proceedings. He also
filed his affidavit in support thereof. Considering the reasons
stated in the affidavit filed by the plaintiff, and as the present suit
is the oldest suit, he may be permitted to engage new counsel in
place of the earlier counsel on record. K.Gopala Krishria, advocate
lrled vakalat on behalf of plaintiff and the same is considered.
Cffice is directed to verify whether the carrying our of amendment
is in accordance with the orders passed inl.A.792l15 and put up
a note accordingly, call on 29.6.22. (PO is on Half day C.L, hence,
posted to 6.7.22 to L3.7.22]l.
13.o7.2C22
So far the concerned BC has ncit put up a note despite of the
locket order dt. 16.6.22. Hence, he is directed to go through
rrders in 1.A.792/15 and to verify whether the amendment
:arried and the neat copy so filed by the plaintiff as party in
person is in accordance with the orders inl.A.792/15 are not and
io put up a detailed note accordingly, call on 19.7.22. (further
rdjourned to 1O-O8-2O221.
1o.o8.2c22
in view of the above office note, fair copy of plaint is returned. For
iling fair copy of plaint properly, call on2O.O8.2O22.
3.O9.2C22
Received copy of order in CRP. 1885/22 dt.26.a.22 of the Hon'ble
{igh Court, for the State of Telangana wherein interim
suspension is granted till 23.9.22. Hence, in view of the same, call
tn28-9.22-
19. tA.No.792 of 2015 was initially allowed on L2.0T.2olz by rhe
learned trial court by a cryptic order thereby the petitionerrespondent No.4 filed cRP before the High court uide cRp No.4o19
of 2017 'vhich was allowed on 23.02.2018 and was remanded for
fresh corrsideration. The observation of the High court in cRp
No.4019 of 2077, dated 12.07.2017 is with a direction to consider
I
I
,':-)
t3120
BRMR,J
cRP_1885_2022
the contentions of the parties therein and to pass appropriate
reasoned order afresh in accordance with law within two months
from the date of receipt of copy of the order.
20. It is the contention of the petitioner-respondent No.4 in the
counter filed in IA.No.792 of 2O15 that the amendment application
filed by respondent No.1-petitioner is barred by limitation and hit
by Article 59 of the Limitation Act i.e., to cancel or set aside an
instrument or decree for the recession of the contract is 3 years
when it is first become known to the party. The prayer made in
IA.No.792 of 20 15 is to declare the gift deeds executed in favour of
defendant Nos.2 to 6 as null and void and consequently not
binding on him. Hence, Article 59 is not applidable to the facts of
the case. Article 58 of the Limitation Act states that to obtain any
other declaration, the period is 3 years when the right to sue first
accrues.
21. It is the contention of respondent No.l-petitioner counsel
that the suit is filed on 27.09.2002 and registered on O6.10.2007,
summons to the defendant Nos.l to 6 therein were served on
23124-LO-2OO7. Admittedly, defendant No.1 (respondent No.2
herein) has frled her written statement on O8.O2.2O08 and stated
that she executed gift settlement deeds in respect of A' schedule
propelty in favour of defendant Nos.3 to 5 and her grand,\
L4/2O
BRMR,J
cRP_1885_2022
daughtert; and also stated in the written statement with regard to
D' sche<lule property that she has executed registered gift
settlement deeds in favour of defendant Nos.3 and 5 and in respect
of 'G' schedule property she stated that the properties acquired by
her through a registered sale deed, dated 31.L2.2003 and that she
has riglrt to deal with the property standing in her
name. Defendant No.l (respondent No.2 herein) has specifically
contenderi in the written statement that she has gifted 'A'and 'D'
schedule properties by way of registered gift deeds in favour of
defendanl Nos.3 to 5.
In so f.ar as 'G' schedule property is
concernerl defendant No.l has executed registered gift deed in
favour of defendant No.4 on 13.10.2008 uid.e document No.563O of
2008 afte,r filing the written statement. It can be said that it is a
deemed rrotice to the respondent No.1-petitioner that schedule 'A'
and 'D' properties are gifted by defendant No.l in favour of
defendanl Nos.3 to 5. As stated supra for seeking any other
declaration the period of limitation is three years when the right to
sue first accrues. In this case, this court is of the view that right to
sue first accrues when defendant No.l has filed .her written
statement on O8.02.2OO8. Furthermore, the affidavit in IA.No.792
of 2015 is silent about the date of knowledge of the gift deeds.
It is state:d in the affidavit that respondent No.l-petitioner came to
know abc,ut the particulars recently.
f
I
,t
r\
I
Lsl20
I
22.
BRMR,J
cRP_1885_2022
Admittedly, daughters of defendant Nos.4 and 5 are not
parties to the suit and as per the contention of respondent No.l-
petitioner in IA.No.792 of 2015, defendant No.1 has executed a
registered gift deed on L4.|2.2OOT uidedocument No.2186 of 2007
in favour of daughter of defendant No.5 in.respect of 'A' schedule
propert5r for 256 square feet and two other registered gift deeds
were executed by defendant No.1 in favour of elder and younger
daughter of defendant No.4 uide documet'rt No.2183 of 2O07 in
r, t
'
:
respect of A' schedule propert5l for 328.00 square feet and
I
:
document No.2182 of 2OOT in respect of iA.' schedule property for
l
I
336.00 square feet uid.ed.ated 14.12.2OO7. There is no explanation
I
:
i
i
from respondent No.1-petitioner-plaintiff how he is entitled to seek
j
I
i
i
i
a declaration to declare the documents void and not binding on
him when the daughters of defendant Nos.4 and 5 are not parties
I
I
I
i
to the suit.
i
23. On careful perusal of the affidavit of respondent No.lpetitioner in IA.No.792 of. 2OL5, there is no para with regard to
valuing the registered gift deeds to declare them as null and void
and not binding on the plaintiff. It is a serious flaw in the
application and the respondent No.l-petitioner has not sought nor
valued the declaration of documents to be declared as null and
!
I
T
I
I
,t
16120
BRMR,J
cRP_1885_2022
void. This aspect goes to the root of the matter and the application
made by respondent No.1-petitioner suffers from serious flaws.
24.L. The gift deed was executed and registered as early as
28.07.19'78 which is a notice to everyone. Eve5r after filing of the
written srtatement, for 3 years no steps were taken to file the
application for amendment of the plaint. Thereby the accrued right
in favou:: of the respondents would be defeated by permitting
amendmr:nt of the plaint: See Radhika Devil. The same view is
followed :n Upender Prasad Dhube3.
24.2. Factors to be taken into consideration while dealing with
applications for amendments :
On critically analysing both the English and Indian cases,
sorne be.sic principles emerge which ought to be taken into
consideration while allowing or rejecting the application for
amendm,:nt:
(1) whether the amendment sought is imperative for proper
and effective adjudication of the case;
(21 whether the application for amendment is bonalide or
malafide;
(3) the amendment should not cause such prejudice to the
other side which cannot be compensated adeguately in
te rms of money;
r-..,
BRMR,J
cRP_1EE5_2022
17120
it
(4) refusing amendment would in fact lead to injustice or
lead to multiple litigation;
(5) whether the proposed amendment constitutionally or
fundamentally changes the nature and character of the
case; and or
(6) as a general rule, the court should decline amendments
if a fresh suit on the amended claims would be barred by
limitation on the date of application.
These are some of the important factors which may be kept
in mind while dealing with application filed under Order 6 Rule 17.
These are only illustrative and not exhaustive : See Revajeetu
Builders and Developers2.
24.3. The proposed amendments ought'to have been clearly and
distinctly spelled out with reference to the place where these
amendments were intended to be added in the amended plaint :
See Ashwani Sood+.
25. In Sree Sree lswar Radhe Behari Jews, the High Court of
Calcutta held that "when does the trial of an election petition
commences or what is the meaning to be assigned to the word trial
in the context of an election petition". The High Court held as
under:
'It is implicit that the commencement of trial, for the relevant
purpose, is when the court applies its mind to assess the lis
?-
a$ter the first aflidavit of evidence is filed. To rep-eat, such
\i
t8120
BRMR,J
cRP_1885_2022
atr,plication of the judicial mind is when the first witness
proves his aflidavit of evidence or such witness seeks to prove
a document for it to be tendered in evidence or the crossexamination of such witness begins, whichever is earlier".
26. Three Judge Bench of the Supreme Court in Kailash Vs.
Nanhku rrnd Others6 observed that "ln a civil suit, the trial begins
when issues are framed and the case is set down for recording of
evidence. A11 the proceedings before that stage are treated as
proceedirrgs preliminary to trial or for making the case ready for
trial".
27. [n view of the Three Judge Bench Judgment of the Supreme
Court stetted Supra, in a civil suit, the trial begins when issues are
framed and the case is set down for recording the evidence. In
view of the above said decision, the decision cited by the
respondent No.1-petitioner counsel is not applicable to the case on
hand.
28. Respondent No.1-petitioner has not prayed for consequential
amend.mr:nt as per Rule 28 ofCivil Rules of Practice in the petition.
So also, the application filed for amendment of pleadings is also
barred by limitation in view of the fact that respondent No.2defendant No.1 has specifically stated in the written statement filed
lzoos; 4 scc 4Bo
f
f
I
o
BRMR,J
cRP_1885_2022
19120
on 08.02.2OO8 that she gifted the properties to defendant Nos.3 to
5 and it is a deemed notice, which squarely falls within the ambit
of the decision cited by the petitioner-respondent No.4 counsel in
Radhika Devi casel. The daughters of defendant Nos.4 and 5 are
not parties to the suit and the respondent-No.l-petitioner is
estopped from seeking relief of declaration to declare the
documents executed in the name of the daughters of defendant
Nos.4 and 5 on 14. 12.2OO7.
29. As stated supra, the application i.e., IA.No.792 of 20i5 lacks
material particulars such as at which para of the plaint, pleadings
have to be amended. So also, there is no paragraph of valuation of
declaration in the appiication.
:
30. Affidavit of PW.1 is already filed and defendant Nos.S to 9
were impleaded in the suit but the documents were not marked.
The learned. trial Court observed that the predecessor has
inadvertently posted the matter for trial though summons were not
served on the impleaded parties i.e., defendant Nos.8 to 29 and
mere filing of affidavit of PW.1 does not amounts to commencement
of trial. The Three Judge Bench of the Supreme Court in Kailash6
\
held that in a civil suit the trial begins when issues are framed and
\
the case is set down for recording the evidence. Admittedly,
affidavit of PW.l-plaintiff is already filed. The learned trial Court
BRMR,J
20l2O
c.RjP_18A5 2022
has lost sight of the contentions raised by the petitionerrespondent No.4 counsel and also faiied to answer with regard to
the limir:ation, with regard to declaration of documents of
daughters of defendant Nos.4 and 5 who are not parties to the suit
and alsc, lost sight that material particulars are missing in
IA.No.791Z of 2015.
31. Thr: decisions cited by the petitioner counsel stated supra are
applicable to the case on hand.
32. [n view of the reasons above, the order passed by the learned
trial Cotrrt suffers from perversity and illegality and requires
interference of this Court in exercise of Revisional Powers under
Article 2'.ZT of the Constitution of India and the same is liable to be
set aside.
33. In the result, cRP is allowed. order passed by the learned
XXVII Aclditional Chief Judge, City Civil Court at Secunderabad in
IA.No.792 of 2015, dated 04.03.2022 is set aside, consequently
petition rstands dismissed.
Inr:erim Orders if any shall stands vacated. Miscellaneous
application/ s stands closed.
SD/- AHMED ABDULLA KHAN
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
To,
,J
SECTION OFFICER
1. The XX\/ll Additional Chief Judge, City Civit Court, at Secunderabad
2. One CC to Sri B Mohan, Advocate tOpUCl
3. One CC to Sri L Harish, Advocate [OPUC]
N, 4. Two CD
a
HIGH COURT
DATED: '.?-210112026
3 0$ rE$ affi
ORDER
CRP.No.1l885 of 2022
ALLOWITIG THE CRP
q x,
I
!
I
I
*
't
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review