Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 13TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE M G UMA
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 1292 OF 2009 (DEC/INJ)
C/W
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 1293 OF 2009 (DEC/INJ)
BETWEEN:
B.O. THIMMESH,
S/O ONKARAPPA
AGED MAJOR
R/AT MAVINAKATTE VILLAGE
KASABA HOBLI, HOSADURGA
TALUK, CHITRADURGA - 577 560.
&COMMON APPELLANT
(BY SRI. A.V. GANGADHARAPPA, ADVOCATE)
Digitally signed
by PRASHANTH
NV
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
AND:
1.
SMT. SHAKUNTHALAMMA
W/O RUDRASWAMY
MAJOR, R/AT MAVINAKATTE
VILLAGE, KASABA HOBLI,
HOSADURGA TALUK,
CHITRADURGA - 577 560.
2.
SOMASHEKHARAPPA
S/O UJJINAPPA, MAJOR,
R/AT BEESANAHALLY VILLAGE,
-2NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
KASABA HOBLI, HOSADURGA
TALUK, CHITRADURGA-577560
&COMMON RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. G.S. PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R1
R2 - SD/-)
RSA NO.1292 OF 2009 IS FILED U/S. 100 OF CPC, AGAINST
THE
JUDGEMENT
&
DECREE
DATED:
23.06.2009
PASSED
IN
R.A.NO.51/2003 ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE, (SR. DN.),
HOLALKERE, DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND CONFIRMING THE
JUDGMENT
AND
DECREE
DATED:27.09.03
PASSED
IN
OS.NO.156/2003 ON THE FILE OF THE ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE,
(JR. DN.), HOSADURGA.
RSA NO.1293 OF 2009 IS FILED U/S. 100 OF CPC, AGAINST
THE
JUDGMENT
&
DECREE
DATED:
23.06.2009
PASSED
IN
R.A.NO.45/2006 ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE, (SR. DN.),
HOLALKERE, DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND CONFIRMING THE
JUDGMENT
AND
DECREE
DATED:21.07.2006
PASSED
IN
OS.NO.134/2004 ON THE FILE OF THE ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE,
(JR. DN.), HOSADURGA.
THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR FURTHER HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE M G UMA
-3NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
COMMON ORAL JUDGMENT
The plaintiff in OS.No.156/2003 on the file of the learned
Additional Civil Judge (Jr.Dn.) Hosadurga (hereinafter referred
to as 'the Trial Court') has preferred RSA No.1292/2009
impugning the judgment and decree dated 23.06.2009 passed
in RA No.51/2003 on the file of the learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division), Holalkere (hereinafter referred to as 'the First
Appellate Court'), dismissing the appeal and confirming the
judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court which partly
decreed his suit, and granted permanent injunction until he is
dispossessed in accordance with law, while rejecting his prayer
for declaration that the decree dated 06.01.2003 obtained by
defendant No.1 in OS.No.186/2002 on the file of Additional Civil
Judge (Jr.Dn.), Hosadurga, is not binding on the plaintiff.
2.
the
Defendant No.2 in OS.No.134/2004 on the file of
learned
Additional
Civil
Judge
(Jr.Dn.),
Hosadurga
(hereinafter referred to as 'the Trial Court') has preferred RSA
No.1293/2009 impugning the judgment and decree dated
21.07.2006 decreeing the suit of the plaintiff therein, declaring
that she is the owner of the schedule property and directing the
-4NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
appellant/defendant No.2 to handover the vacant possession of
the suit schedule property after demolishing the house situated
therein, within six months from the date of decree and the
judgment dated 23.06.2009 passed in RA No.45/2006 on the
file of the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Holalkere
(hereinafter
referred
to
as
'the
First
Appellate
Court'),
dismissing the appeal and confirming the judgment and decree
passed by the Trial Court.
3.
For the sake of convenience, the parties shall be
referred to as per their rank and status before the Trial Court in
OS.No.156/2003.
4.
The facts of the case in brief are that, the plaintiff in
OS.No.156/2003 being the appellant in RSA No.1292/2009 filed
the suit seeking declaration that the judgment and decree
dated 06.01.2003 passed in OS.No.186/2002 on the file of the
learned
Additional
Civil
Judge,
(Jr.Dn.),
Hosadurga,
was
obtained in collusion by the defendants. Hence, the same is not
binding
on
him
and
for
grant
of
permanent
injunction
-5NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
restraining defendant No.1 from executing the said decree in
OS.No.186/2002 against the plaintiff.
5.
It is the contention of the plaintiff that he being the
owner of the schedule property is in possession and enjoyment
of the same, as he purchased it from defendant No.2 under the
registered sale deed dated 12.08.2002. The schedule attached
to
the
plaint
describes
the
land
bearing
Sy.No.46/p2
measuring 2 guntas out of 13 guntas with the boundaries
mentioned therein (hereinafter referred to as the schedule
property). Since from the date of purchase, he is in peaceful
possession and enjoyment of the property, khata was mutated
in his name and the revenue documents stand in his favour.
6.
It is contended that defendant No.1 is the stranger
to the suit schedule property. However, defendant Nos.1 and 2
in collusion with one another created document styled as
agreement for sale dated 06.09.2001 and based on such
concocted
document,
defendant
No.1
filed
the
suit
OS.No.186/2002 before the Trial Court against defendant No.2
seeking specific performance of contract. The said suit was not
contested by defendant No.2 and defendant No.1 managed to
-6NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
get a decree in her favour on 06.01.2003. Since by that time,
the plaintiff had already purchased schedule property under the
registered sale deed dated 12.08.2002. Defendant No.1 was
not entitled for any relief.
7.
Since the plaintiff was not made as party in
OS.No.186/2002, seeking any relief to avoid the registered sale
deed, the plaintiff is not bound by the decree passed in
OS.No.186/2002. It is contended that defendant Nos.1 and 2
are trying to interfere with the peaceful possession and
enjoyment of the schedule property by the plaintiff and
therefore,
sought
for
permanent
injunction
along
with
declaration that the decree in OS.No.186/2002 is not binding
on him.
8.
The plaintiff also contended that defendant No.1
had filed the suit OS.No.85/2003 before the Trial Court against
the plaintiff seeking permanent injunction. But the Trial Court
has not granted her temporary injunction and finally, suit came
to be dismissed. Therefore, plaintiff prayed for decreeing the
suit as prayed for.
-7NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
9.
Defendant No.1 appeared before the Trial Court and
filed her written statement denying the contentions taken by
the plaintiff. It is contended that defendant No.2 being the
owner of the schedule property had executed an agreement for
sale dated 06.09.2001 for a valid consideration of Rs.5,000/and
had
accepted
the
advance
amount
of
Rs.3,500/-.
Defendant No.1 had agreed to repay the balance consideration
amount at the time of execution of the sale deed. However,
defendant No.2 was not ready and willing to perform his part of
the contract by executing the sale deed and therefore, legal
notice was issued calling upon defendant No.2 to execute the
sale deed. Inspite of service of notice, defendant No.2 had not
executed the sale deed and therefore, defendant No.1 had filed
the suit OS.No.186/2002 for specific performance of contract.
The said suit came to be decreed on 06.01.2003 and on the
basis of said decree, execution No.29/2003 was filed and
registered sale deed got executed in favour of defendant No.1
through process of the Court. It is contended that the plaintiff
and defendant No.2 are colluding with one another and
therefore, prayed for dismissal of the suit.
-8NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
10.
Defendant No.2 remained exparte and has not
contested the matter.
11.
On the basis of these pleadings, the following issues
were came to be framed in OS.No.156/2003.
1. Whether the plaintiff proves that he is the
owner of the suit property by virtue of registered
sale
deed
dated
12.08.2002
executed
by
2nd
defendant?
2. Whether the plaintiff proves that he was in
possession of the suit property as on the date of
suit?
3.
Whether
the
plaintiff
proves
that
the
judgment and decree in OS.No.186/2002 is not
binding on the plaintiff and is liable to be cancelled?
4.
Whether
defendants
are
the
plaintiff
interfering
proves
with
his
that
the
peaceful
possession and enjoyment of the suit property?
5. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for decree as
prayed for?
6. What order or decree?
12.
The plaintiff examined PWs.1 to 4 and got marked
Exs.P1 to 5 in support of his contention. Defendant No.1
-9NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
examined herself as DW1 and got marked Exs.D1 to 7 in
support of her defence. The Trial Court after taking into
consideration all these materials on record, answered Issue
Nos.1 and 3 in the Negative, Issue Nos.2 and 4 in the
Affirmative,
Issue
No.5
partly
in
the
affirmative
and
accordingly, decreed the suit of the plaintiff in part. The prayer
for declaration that the judgment in OS.No.186/2002 is not
binding on the plaintiff was rejected. However, permanent
injunction is granted in favour of the plaintiff till defendant No.1
gets possession of the property in accordance with law.
13.
Being aggrieved by the same, plaintiff has preferred
RA No.51/2003 on the file of the learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division),
Holalkere.
The
First
Appellate
Court
on
re-
appreciation of the materials on record dismissed the appeal,
confirming the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court.
Being aggrieved by the same, the plaintiff has preferred RSA
No.1292/2009.
14.
Defendant No.1 in OS.No.156/2003 has filed the
suit OS.No.134/2004 against the appellant - B.O.Thimmesh as
defendant No.2, and the original owner as defendant No.1,
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
seeking declaration that she is the owner of the suit schedule
property and to direct the defendants to deliver possession of
the suit schedule property in her favour.
15.
It is contended by the plaintiff therein, who is
defendant No.1 in the connected suit, that defendant No.1
being the owner of the schedule property had executed the
agreement
to
sale.
Later,
she
obtained
decree
in
OS.No.186/2002 for specific performance of the contract. In
Ex.No.29/2003, she got registered the sale deed executed in
her favour in respect of the schedule property.
16.
It
is
contended
that
defendants
therein
are
colluding with one another and managed to concoct the sale
deed dated 12.08.2002. It is contended that the plaintiff is in
possession and enjoyment of the property since from the date
of agreement to sale. The plaintiff contended that she had filed
OS.No.85/2003
against
defendant
Nos.1
and
seeking
permanent injunction. Since her application for grant of
temporary injunction was dismissed due to technical reasons,
she withdrew the suit. In the meantime, defendant No.2
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
constructed a
building in the schedule property without
obtaining license.
17.
suit
It is contended that defendant No.2 had filed the
OS.No.156/2003
for
declaration
and
for
permanent
injunction, the said suit is already dismissed. Therefore, it is
contended that the plaintiff is the bonafide purchaser for
valuable consideration and thus, she is entitled for declaration
of her title over the schedule property and for possession of the
same.
18.
The schedule attached to the plaint describes the
land bearing Sy.No.46/P2 old No.46/2 measuring 2 guntas with
boundaries mentioned therein.
19.
Defendant
No.2,
who
is
the
plaintiff
in
OS.No.156/2003 filed the written statement taking similar
contention as stated in the plaint in OS.No.156/2003
and
prayed for dismissal of the suit.
20.
Defendant No.1 filed the written statement denying
the contentions taken by the plaintiff and contended that he
was the lawful owner in possession of the schedule property. It
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
is also contended that before the plaintiff filing the suit
OS.No.186/2002
against
defendant
No.2
seeking
specific
performance of contract, defendant No.1 had executed the
registered sale deed in favour of defendant No.2 in respect of
the schedule property and he was put in vacant possession of
the property. Under such circumstances, it is contended that
the plaintiff is not entitled for any relief.
21.
On the basis of these pleadings, following issues
came to be framed in OS.No.134/2004.
1. Whether the plaintiff proves that she is the
owner of the suit property?
2.
Whether
the
plaintiff
is
entitled
for
possession of suit property from the defendants?
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for decree as
prayed for?
4. What order or decree?
22.
Plaintiff examined herself as PW1 and got marked
Exs.P1 to 4, defendants examined DWs.1 and 2. On the basis of
these materials, the Trial Court answered Issue Nos.1 to 3 in
the Affirmative and accordingly, decreed the suit of the plaintiff
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
declaring that she is the owner of the schedule property.
Defendant
No.2
was
directed
to
handover
the
vacant
possession of the schedule property in favour of the plaintiff
after demolishing the house situated therein within six months
from the date of decree.
23.
Being aggrieved by the judgment and decree,
defendant No.2 has preferred RA No.45/2006 on the file of the
Civil Judge (Sr.Dn.), Holalkere. The First Appellate Court on reappreciation of the materials on record dismissed the appeal by
confirming the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court.
Being aggrieved by the same, defendant No.2 is before this
Court in RSA No.1293/2009.
24.
Heard Sri. A.V.Gangadharappa, learned counsel
representing the appellant in both the appeals. Sri. G.S.Patil,
learned counsel for respondent No.1 is absent and has not
addressed his argument inspite of giving sufficient opportunity
and therefore his argument is taken as nil.
25.
Perused the materials on record in the light of the
grounds urged by the learned counsel for the appellant and the
reasons assigned by the Trial Court as well as by the First
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
Appellate Court in the impugned judgment and decree in both
the suits.
26.
Learned counsel for the appellant contended that as
per the materials that are placed before the Court it is clear
that defendant No.1 had executed the registered sale deed
dated 12.08.2002 in favour of defendant No.2 as per Ex.P1.
The suit OS.No.186/2002 came to be filed on 07.10.2002,
seeking specific performance of contract. By that time, sale
deed was already executed in favour of the plaintiff. In the said
suit, plaintiff is not made as party. Defendant No.1 remained
exparte and the suit came to be decreed on 06.01.2003 as per
Ex.P3.
27.
Learned
counsel
also
submitted
that
OS.No.85/2003 was filed against plaintiff and defendant No.1,
seeking permanent injunction but no injunction was granted in
her favour and the suit came to be withdrawn as not pressed.
28.
Learned counsel contended that defendant No.1
filed the suit OS.No.134/2004 seeking declaration regarding
registered sale deed Ex.P1 dated 12.08.2002, which was
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
executed much prior to filing of the suit OS.No.186/2002.
Therefore, defendant No.1 was not entitled for any relief.
Naturally, plaintiff is not bound by decree in OS.No.186/2002.
Ignoring all these facts, the Trial Court and the First appellate
Court committed an error in passing the impugned judgment.
Accordingly, prays for allowing both the appeals.
29.
This Court vide order dated 26.03.2013 formulated
the following substantial questions of law for consideration.
a.
Whether in the facts and circumstances
of the case, the Courts below were
justified in holding that the judgment and
decree
passed
in
OS.No.186/2002
is
binding on the plaintiff in view of the fact
that the sale deed dated 12.08.2002 was
executed in favour of the appellant by
the
2nd
respondent
before
filing
OS.No.186/2002?
b.
Whether in the facts and circumstances
of the case, the Courts below were
justified in holding that the appellant is
not the
owner of the
suit schedule
property by virtue of the registered sale
deed dated 12.08.2002?
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
30.
The admitted facts of the case are that the plaintiff
in OS.No.156/2003 had purchased the schedule property from
defendant
No.2
under
the
registered
sale
deed
dated
12.08.2002 marked as Ex.P1 in OS.No.156/2003, which is also
marked as Ex.P3 in OS.No.134/2004. The suit is for declaration
that the decree obtained by defendant No.1 in OS.No.186/2002
on the file of the Trial Court is not binding on the plaintiff and
for permanent injunction from executing the decree. The said
suit was decreed in-part by holding that the plaintiff is in
possession of the schedule property measuring 2 guntas of land
and granted permanent injunction restraining defendant Nos.1
and 2 from interfering with the peaceful possession and
enjoyment of the plaintiff, till he is dispossessed in accordance
with law. However, rejecting the claim for declaration that the
decree in OS.No.186/2002 is not binding on the plaintiff.
31.
In
the
meantime,
defendant
No.1
in
OS.No.156/2003 filed the suit OS.134/2004 against the plaintiff
in OS.No.156/2003 arraigned him as defendant No.2 and the
owner of the property as defendant No.1 seeking declaration of
her title and for delivery of possession of the schedule property,
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
which is 2 guntas of land described in the schedule. The said
suit came to be decreed declaring that the plaintiff therein is
the owner of the property in question and directing defendant
No.2 to deliver possession of the property in favour of the
plaintiff after demolishing the building constructed thereon.
32.
separate
These judgments came to be passed separately and
Regular
Appeals
in
RA
No.51/2003
and
RA
No.45/2006 came to be filed. Both these regular appeals came
to be dismissed by confirming the judgment and decree passed
by the Trial Court. Therefore, the plaintiff in OS.No.156/2003,
who is defendant No.2 in OS.No.134/2004 has preferred these
appeals RSA No.1292/2009 and RSA No.1293/2009 impugning
the said judgments and decree.
33.
It is an admitted fact that plaintiff has purchased
the schedule property from defendant No.2 in OS.No.156/2003,
who is defendant No.1 in OS.No.134/2004 under the sale deed
dated 12.08.2002, which is produced in both the suits. The
materials
on
OS.No.156/2003
record
especially
Ex.P3
marked
in
discloses that the said suit OS.No.186/2002
came to be filed on 07.10.2002. Therefore, it is clear that by
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
the time, the plaintiff in OS.No.134/2004 filed the suit
OS.No.186/2002
before
the
Trial
Court,
the
plaintiff
in
OS.No.156/2003 had already purchased the schedule property
from its previous owner under the registered sale deed dated
12.08.2002.
34.
Admittedly, the plaintiff in OS.No.156/2003 was not
arrayed as party in OS.No.186/2002. The owner, who was the
defendant in OS.No.186/2002 had never contested the suit and
an ex- parte decree came to be passed for specific performance
of the contract in the said suit. Pursuant to the same, the
decree holder filed the execution case and got the sale deed
executed through process of law as the owner had not even
contested the execution case. It is pertinent to note that the
owner had never taken a contention that he had already
executed
the
sale
deed
in
favour
of
the
plaintiff
in
OS.No.156/2003 by the time the suit OS.186/2002 was filed.
Since the purchaser was not a party in the said suit, the decree
came to be passed uncontested and even the decree was
executed without any objection.
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
35.
In view of these admitted facts, now the question
arises as to whether the registered sale deed dated 12.08.2002
produced in both the suits, which came into existence much
earlier to filing of the suit OS.No.186/2002 seeking specific
performance of the contract, could be ignored simply because
an exparte decree in OS.No.186/2002 was passed and the
decree was executed to get the sale deed registered without
any objection from the owner. The answer would be in the
negative. Since the registered sale deed was already in
existence, admittedly, the purchaser being the plaintiff in
OS.No.156/2003 was put
in possession of the
schedule
property, who even constructed a building thereon. Under such
circumstances, it cannot be said that the decree obtained
behind his back in OS.No.186/2002, which was instituted much
after the sale deed in his favour, is binding on the plaintiff.
36.
It
is
pertinent
to
note
that
the
plaintiff
in
OS.No.186/2002, after getting the sale deed in her favour,
instituted the suit OS.No.134/2004 against the original owner
as defendant No.1 and the plaintiff in OS.No.156/2003 as
defendant No.2, seeking declaration of her title and for delivery
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
of possession of the suit schedule property. The declaration of
title
is
solely
on
the
basis
of
the
decree
passed
in
OS.No.186/2002 and the sale deed executed through process
of law in the execution case to execute the decree in the said
suit. Strangely, the plaintiff in OS.No.134/2004 had never
sought for a declaration that the sale deed dated 12.08.2002
which came into existence much prior to she filing the suit
OS.No.186/2002 is not binding on her. Even though, there is
reference
to
the
said
sale
deed
in
the
plaint
in
OS.No.134/2004, it is contented that it was a collusive sale
deed got executed in favour of the plaintiff in OS.No.156/2003,
and no relief was sought to avoid the same.
37.
It is relevant to refer to the following decisions
which will through much light on the position of law on the
subject. Sri. U.Vijaya Kumar and Another Vs. Smt. Malini
V.Rao1
and
Sri.
Suhrid
Singh
Alias
Sardool
Singh
V.Randhir Singh and others2. This Court in Revansiddappa
Vs. Saraswati w/o Devendra Hulgera3 by referring to the
above decisions, reiterated the position of law to hold that the
ILR 2016 KAR 2670
(2010) 12 SCC 112
RSA No.7339/2011 DD 08.11.2023
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
parties to the document or decree can avoid the same by
seeking its cancellation. But if they are not parties to the
document or decree, it is sufficient for them to seek declaration
that the same is not binding on them. Thus, the position of law
is very well settled. Unless the plaintiff in OS.No.134/2004
avoids the registered sale deed dated 12.08.2002 by seeking a
declaration that the same is not binding on her, she could not
have sought for a declaration of her title solely on the basis of
exparte decree and the sale deed by executing the said exparte
decree through process of law.
38.
It
is
OS.No.186/2002
pertinent
to
that
the
plaintiff
had
OS.No.85/2003
for
permanent
filed
note
in
injunction. Admittedly, the plaintiff in the said suit was not
successful in getting the temporary injunction and later, even
the suit came to be withdrawn on 28.05.2003. The said order is
produced as per Ex.P5 in OS.No.156/2003. This shows the
conduct
of
the
plaintiff
in
OS.No.186/2002
and
OS.No.134/2004, who made an attempt to get a decree of
permanent
injunction
restraining
the
plaintiff
in
OS.No.156/2003, who was admittedly in possession of the
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
schedule property on the basis of the registered sale deed
dated 12.08.2002, without seeking any relief about the same.
39.
It is thereafter, the suit OS.No.134/2004 came to
be filed seeking declaration of title and for delivery of
possession of the schedule property.
There is absolutely no
explanation by the plaintiff in OS.No.134/2004 as to why she
has filed the suit OS.No.85/2003 seeking permanent injunction
when admittedly she was not in possession of the schedule
property.
40.
At least when the plaintiff in OS.No.134/2004 came
to know about the sale deed dated 12.08.2002 executed in
favour of the plaintiff in OS.No.156/2003 much prior to filing of
the suit OS.No.186/2002, she should have sought for a
declaration that the sale deed is not binding on her. In the
absence of any such relief, the plaintiff in OS.No.134/2004 is
not
entitled
for
any
relief.
Moreover,
the
plaintiff
in
OS.No.156/2003 is entitled for declaration that the exparte
decree passed in OS.No.186/2002 is behind his back, much
after the sale deed executed in his favour and the same is not
binding on him.
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
41.
I have gone through the impugned judgment and
decree passed in OS.No.156/2003. The Trial Court placed its
judgment solely on the decree passed in OS.No.186/2002 and
execution of the sale deed executed through process of law in
the execution that was filed by the decree holder, to dismiss
the suit of the plaintiff, without taking into consideration the
fact that the sale deed dated 12.08.2002 relied on by the
plaintiff was much earlier to filing of the suit OS.No.186/2002.
It has also not considered the effect of the registered sale deed
while granting the relief of specific performance of the contract
in OS.No.186/2002. It has also ignored the fact that the
plaintiff in OS.No.156/2003 was not a party to OS.No.186/2002
and the original owner, who was the defendant in the said suit
never contested the suit. The Trial Court while decreeing the
suit of the plaintiff in OS.No.134/2004 blindly accepted the
judgment passed in OS.No.156/2003, without application of
mind about the facts narrated above.
42.
Strangely, even the First Appellate Court proceeded
to dismiss the suit without taking into consideration any of
these factual and legal aspects of the matter. Therefore, I am
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
of the opinion that The Trial Court and the First Appellate Court
were not justified in holding that the judgment and decree
passed in OS.No.186/2002 is binding on the plaintiff in OS
No.156/2003,
ignoring
the
registered
sale
deed
dated
12.08.2002 executed in favour of the appellant by respondent
No.2. Similarly, the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court
were not justified in holding that the appellant is not the owner
of the suit schedule property, even though the registered sale
deed
dated
12.08.2002
was
executed
in
his
favour.
Accordingly, I answer the substantial questions of law in favour
of the appellant and against the respondent. As a result, I
proceed to pass the following.
ORDER
(i)
Appeals are allowed with costs.
(ii)
The judgment and decree dated 27.09.2003
passed in OS.No.156/2003 on the file of the
learned
Additional
Civil
Judge
(Jr.Dn.),
Hosadurga is set aside.
(iii)
The suit OS.No.156/2003 is decreed with costs.
It is declared that the judgment and decree
passed in OS.No.186/2002 on the file of the
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC:1919
RSA No. 1292 of 2009
C/W RSA No. 1293 of 2009
HC-KAR
learned Civil Judge (Jr.Dn.), Hosadurga, is not
binding on the plaintiff.
(iv)
The defendants are restrained by a decree of
permanent injunction from interfering with the
peaceful
possession
and
enjoyment
of
the
schedule property by the plaintiff.
(v)
The judgment and decree dated 21.07.2006
passed in OS.No.134/2004 on the file of the
learned
Additional
Civil
Judge
(Jr.Dn.),
Hosadurga, is set aside. As a result, the said suit
stands dismissed with costs.
(vi)
Office is directed to draw decree accordingly.
Send back the records along with copy of the judgment
and the decree.
SD/(M G UMA)
JUDGE
BH
CT:VS
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 1
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review