Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MACMA NO. 519 OF 2022
VS,J.
APHC010656532022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
TUESDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 519/2022
Between:
1. B.KULLAYAMMA, W/O LATE B.PRABHAKAR, AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,
2. B.HEMANTH KUMAR,, S/O LATE B.PRABHAKAR, AGED ABOUT 14
YEARS,
3. B.AKHIL,, S/O LATE B.PRABHAKAR, AGED ABOUT 7 YEARS, (ALL ARE
R/O KOTANKA, GARLADINNE MANDAL, ANANTAPUR DIST.)
4. B.VENKATALAKSHMI DIED, B.VENKATALAKSHMI DIED
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1. PAGIDI NAGARAJU, S/O VENKATESULU, AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS,
R/O CHINNAMPALLI, ANANTAPUR(R) MANDAL AND DIST. OWNERCUM-DRIVER OF AUTO RICKSHAW NO.AP-02-TF-0801,
2. IFFCOTOKIO GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD, REP. BY ITS
MANAGER, 5-605, 1ST FLOOR, RAJU ROAD, ANANTAPUR. INSURER
VIDE POLICY NO. 1-INMC2YL, P400 AND 2720 6429, VALID FROM 2909-2017 TO 28-09-2018
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. M KARIBASAIAH
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GUDI SRINIVASU
The Court made the following:
MACMA NO. 519 OF 2022
VS,J.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 519/2022
JUDGMENT:
1.
This Motor Accident Claims Miscellaneous Appeal (for short
MACMA) has been preferred by the claimants for enhancement of compensation
amount being aggrieved by the Order/ Award and Decree passed by the
Chairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (for short MACT) –cum- I Additional
District Judge, Ananthapur District at Ananthapur in M.V.O.P.No.599 of 2017
dated 25.07.2022, wherein the Tribunal has awarded an amount of Rs.9,82,000/as against the claim of Rs.16,00,000/-.
For the sake of convenience and to avoid confusion, the parties herein
after referred to as they were arrayed before the Tribunal i.e., Appellants herein
as petitioners and respondents herein as respondents.
2.
The Petitioners being wife and minor children of Late B.Prabhakar
(hereinafter referred to as the “deceased”) filed claim petition in M.V.O.P.No.599
of 2017 under sections 140 and 166 of the M.V Act claiming compensation of
Rs.16,00,000/- along with interest and costs for the death of B.Prabhakar in a
motor vehicle accident..
3.
Brief averments of the claim petition in MVOP No.599 of 2017 are
that: on 25.10.2017 at 9.30 P.M the deceased was traveling in an Auto Rickshaw
bearing No. AP-02-TF-0801 [hereinafter refered to as the 'offending vehicle‟)
MACMA NO. 519 OF 2022
VS,J.
while proceeding from Kotanka towards Anantapuramu, the 1st Respondent [R.1]
being the owner-cum-driver, drove it at high speed, lost control over the vehicle,
as a result, the vehicle turned turtle, the deceased sustained grievous injuries on
his head, he was taken to Saveera Hospital, Anantapuramu, from there he was
shifted to Govt., General Hospital, Kurnool for better treatment, where he
succumbed to injuries at about 5.30 A.M, on 29.10.2017. Anantapuramu Rural
Police have registered the accident as a case in Crime No.227 of 2017 against
R.1, for the offences punishable under section 304-A of Indian Penal Code [in
short 'I.P.C'].
The deceased was a Mason, earning 500/- per day [₹15,000/- per month].
Due to the sudden demise of the 'deceased', his wife- 1st Petitioner, childrenPetitioners No.2, 3 and mother-4th Petitioner, being dependents of the deceased,
lost financial support. Hence, prayed to award compensation.
4.
Respondent No.1 having been remained ex-parte.
5.
2nd Respondent [R.2] filed the written statement, denied the material
averments in the petition regarding the accident, claim of the petitioners as legal
heirs, details of accident, income of the deceased etc., and contended that as on
the date and time of accident, R.1 drove the offending vehicle without holding
valid driving license, thereby violated the terms and conditions of the insurance
policy, as well as the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act and Rules therein. R.1
MACMA NO. 519 OF 2022
VS,J.
was not qualified for holding or obtaining such driving license. As the police who
investigated into the matter- accident have filed charge sheet against R.1 not
only for the offence punishable under section 304-A of I.P.C and also under
section 3 r/w 181 of Motor Vehicles Act, the petition is not maintainable. As R.1
having knowledge that he had no license, drove the vehicle and caused the
accident, thereby violated the terms of policy, R.2 need not pay anything as
compensation to anybody. The amount claimed as compensation is excessive.
The petition is not maintainable either in law or on facts and therefore it is liable
to be dismissed, with costs.
6.
Basing on the above pleadings the following issues were framed by
the tribunal for trial/enquiry:
1) Whether the deceased 'B.Prabhakar' sustained grievous injuries in the
accident that occurred on 25.10.2017 at about 9.30 a.m, near MYR
function hall, Bellary Road, Anantapuramu, either due to rash and/ or
negligent driving of 1st Respondent being the driver of Auto bearing
No.AP-02-TF-0801 and died ?
2) Whether the Petitioners are entitled to claim any compensation? If so, to
what amount and from which of the Respondents?
3) To what relief?
MACMA NO. 519 OF 2022
VS,J.
[Subsequently issue No.1 is altered [or amended), in view of powers of Court
under Order XIV, Rule 5(1) of the Civil Procedure Code [C.P.C], as per docket
order dated 20.07.2022].
7.
During the course of trial, 1st Petitioner - Smt B.Kullayamma got
examined as P.W.1, an independent witness by name Boya Bandi Adeppa @
Bandi Adinarayana got examined as P.W.2, and got marked Ex.A.1 – attested
copy of inquest report, Ex.A.2 – attested copy of postmortem report, Ex.A.3 –
attested copy of M.V.I report, Ex.A.4 – attested copy of charge sheet, Ex.A.5 –
medical bills issued by Severa Hospital, Ananthapuramu.
On behalf of 2nd respondent, its Assistant Manager (Legal) by name
V.Anand Kiran got examined as R.W.1 and got marked Ex.B.1 – copy of
Insurance Policy along with terms and conditions.
8.
Upon hearing the learned counsel for the Petitioners as well as
Respondent No.2 and upon perusing the oral as well as documentary evidence
placed on record by both parties, the Tribunal awarded Rs.9,82,000/- towards
compensation, with proportionate costs and with interest at 6% p.a from the date
of filing the petition till the date of deposit and directing the 1st respondent to pay
the same within three (03) months from the date of order along with costs and
dismissed the claim against 2nd respondent – insurance company.
MACMA NO. 519 OF 2022
VS,J.
9.
Being aggrieved by the said order and decree, the claimants have
preferred the present appeal on the grounds that – the Tribunal failed to consider
that the 1st respondent has insured his vehicle with 2nd respondent and in such
case, both are liable to pay compensation to the claimants and when the
insurance policy was in existence as on the date of accident, the insurance
company cannot be exempted from the liability to pay compensation to the
petitioners as ordered by the tribunal. Hence, prayed to allow the appeal and to
direct the insurance company to pay the compensation amount to the petitioners
and then recover it from the 1st respondent.
10.
Heard the learned Counsel for appellants/petitioners as well as
respondents and perused the material available in record.
11.
Now the point for determination is – Whether the order/award
passed by the Tribunal needs any interference?
12.
POINT: On a perusal of the award, it can be observed that R.W.1 –
the Assistant Manger (Legal) of Respondent No.2 was examined.
Through
R.W.1 the insurance policy was marked as Ex.B.1. However, the only ground
raised by the insurance company is that as the driver (R.1) was not holding valid
driving license as on the date of accident and as he has violated the terms and
conditions of insurance policy and as such the insurance company is not liable to
pay any compensation.
MACMA NO. 519 OF 2022
VS,J.
13.
Under similar circumstances, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
“National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh & Ors. 1” has categorically held
that the insurance company may not be liable to satisfy the decree and,
therefore, its liability may be zero but it does mean that it did not have initial
liability at all. Thus, if the insurance company is made liable to pay any amount it
can recover the entire amount paid to the third party on behalf of the assured.
Therefore, the Tribunal has power to direct them to satisfy the decree at the first
instance and then direct recovery of the same from the owner.
14.
In “National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh & Ors.,”
(referred above) the Hon‟ble Supreme Court while dealing with the case of
unauthorized passengers held as follows:
“Sub-section (5) of Section 149 which imposes a liability on the insurer must also
be given its full effect. The insurance company may not be liable to satisfy the
decree and, therefore, its liability may be zero but it does mean that it did not
have initial liability at all. Thus, if the insurance company is made liable to pay
any amount it can recover the entire amount paid to the third party on behalf of
the assured. If this interpretation is not given to the beneficent provisions of the
Act having regard to its purport and object, we fail to see a situation where
beneficent provisions can be given effect to Sub-section (7) of Section 149 of the
Act, to which pointed attention of the Court has been drawn by the learned
counsel for the petitioner, which is in negative language may now be noticed.
The said provision must be read with Sub-section (1) thereof. The right to avoid
liability in terms of Sub-section (2) of Section 149 is restricted as has been
discussed hereinbefore. It is one thing to say that the insurance companies are
(2004) 3 SCC 297
MACMA NO. 519 OF 2022
VS,J.
entitled to raise a defence but it is another thing to say that despite the fact that
its defence has been accepted having regard to the facts and circumstances of
the case, the Tribunal has power to direct them to satisfy the decree at the first
instance and then direct recovery of the same from the owner. These two matters
stand apart and require contextual reading.”
15.
As per the law laid down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the
judgment (referred supra) even if the insurer successfully proves a breach of
policy condition, the insurance company may still be directed to pay
compensation to the claimant and then recover the amount from the insured
(owner of the vehicle). This ensures that the rights of the third-party victim are
protected and it was emphasized that insurance policies are statutorily required
to protect third parties, and even in cases of breach by the insured, the insurer's
liability towards third-party victims does not vanish immediately.
16.
In the absence of the documentary evidence, the Tribunal
considered the monthly income of the deceased as Rs.6,500/-. Accordingly,
annual income would come to Rs.78,000/- (Rs.6,500 X 12). As there are 3
dependents in the present case, 1/3rd has to be deducted towards his personal
expenses. After deducting 1/3rd, the monthly income of the deceased would
come to Rs.52,000/- (Rs.78,000 – Rs.26,000). After applying the appropriate
multiplier i.e. „16‟ for the age group of 31 to 35 years, as per the decision of the
MACMA NO. 519 OF 2022
VS,J.
Hon‟ble Apex Court in “Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation2”, the
loss of dependency would come to (Rs.52,000 X16) Rs.8,32,000/-.
17.
In addition to the above, the Tribunal also awarded a sum of
Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses, Rs.1,20,000/- towards loss of consortium,
Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate. In total, the Tribunal below awarded
Rs.9,82,000/- to the claimants, which needs no interference.
18.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the appeal is partly allowed
directing respondent No.2 – Insurance company to initially pay the compensation
amount of Rs.9,82,000/- along with interest at the rate of 7.5% p.a, from the date
of petition till realization to the claimants, within a period of three (03) months
from the date of receipt of copy of the order and then recover the same from the
insured-owner of the offending vehicle by filing Execution Proceedings before the
Tribunal. No costs.
Accordingly, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
__________________
JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
KS
Dated 10.03.2026.
2009 ACJ 1298
MACMA NO. 519 OF 2022
VS,J.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENTS CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO:519 /2022
DATED 10.03.2026
KS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review