Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3303 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, IHE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 7310 OF 2019
Between
B. Gayathri, W/O B. Sampath Kumar, Aged about 48Years. OCC House Wife,
R/O H.NO 12-13-123, Street No 3, Tarnaka, Secunderabad.
Pet it ioner/Acc u s ed
AND
1.
B. Jagan lMohan Rao S/o B. Mallesh Aged about 35 Years. OCC Second Grade
Teacher, R/O Flat No 406, Sai Tirumala Residency Street No 9, Taranaka
Secunderabad.
...RespondenUdefacto-Com plai na nt
2. The State of Telangana, Represented by its Public Prosecutor, High Court at
Hyderabad
Res po n dent/C om pla inant
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C praying that in the circumstances stated in
the lVlemorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be pleased to
quash all further proceedings against the Petitioner in CC No 1567 ot 2018 on the file of
lV Additional Chief Mekopolitan Magistrate At Hyderabad the circumstances mentioned
above to meet the ends of justice.
l.A. No. 1 of 2019
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C praying that in the c i )umstances stated in
the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Cc_ t may be pleased to
stay of al [urther proceedings against the Petitioner in CC No 15i; of 201g on the file of
lV Additional chief Metropolitan r\,4agistrate At Hyderabad, pendirrr rlisps5al of the main
case.
l.A. No. 2 ot 2019
Petrtion under seclron 482 of cr.P.c praying that in the c r umstances stated in
the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Co r t may be pleased to
extend the stay granted on 14-11-2019 in CdP No 7310 of 201( n C C 1567/2018 on
the file of on the flle of the lv Additional chief Metropolitan [v1i.r istrate at Hyderabad
pending drsposal of the main petition.
l.A. No. 1 ot 2020
Petition under sectron 482 of cr.P.c praying that in the crr umstances stated in
the Memorandum of Grounds of criminal Petition, the High colr:may be pleased to
extend the stay granted on 27 -12-2019 in lA No 2 of 2019 in CRI- . , No 7310 of 2019 in
cc 156712018 on the file of tV Additional chief Metropolitan l\rlz r strate at Hyderabad
pending disposal of the main petition.
This Petition conring on for hearing, upon perusing the Merr )randum of Grounds
of criminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of Sri Ra t esh Ra j Bhatnagar,
Advocate for the Petitioner, Srr M A Mujeeb, Advocate for Resp r rdent No.1 and sri
M-vivekananda Reddy, Additional Public Prosecutor on behalf of rl .. Respondent No.2
The Court made the following: OROER
.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE J. SREENIVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PETITION No.7 310 of 2019
Date:22.Ot.2026
Be twe e n:
Il. (l:r va t it r-r
Pctitionel
And
'l lre
Sttrr<, ol Teiane:rna,
Rcprcsen tr.rl br. its public prosecutor :rnd :rnother
Rcsponrlcnts
:ORDER
This Criminal pctiLion is liled under Sectron 4g2
ol'C'r.P.('. by lhc peliti()ner-accused seekinB ro quash
l-hc procccdings against her in C.C.No.
1567 o{ 2O1B on
the file of learned IV Additional Chief Metropolitan
Magistrate at Hyderabad, for the offences under
Sections 504 and 506 of Indian penal Code,
1860 (for
short'lPC')
2.
Tlrc brief facts of thc case are that on 26.06.2O1g,
the de facto complainant filed complaint stating
that
on 14.04'2O 18. between 7:OO pM and 7:30 pM, thc
petr tloner (':ime 1o
his apartme r-it and ask,t i to mect
hirn to disr:ttss st)nte apartment t'clated jssrr' ;. :ts he is
thr: secre lirrv ol' the apartment. and the '':rtt:hnl:ttl
rn{irrmi:cl lrct- Lhirl t['rc hc was ttol avail:rlrlc i I thtrt titltr:
ar-r
d that hc u'oulrl be available onlv in lhe tt:r lltirlg. C)tl
thr: next dav on 15.04 20 18, at irbout 12:0C roor-r, shtr
again camc to thr: apartt'Ile nt aud mel hirri 'Vh<:n thcr
hc erskcd h<:r about the issue ar-rd u'hv she r:rnted to
discuss it rritl-r him, she started usinl zrbusivc
languagc and threatenecl that shc u'oul<1 scnd otrc
Rajkumar and his familv to.1ai1. Shc furthcl s rrtr:d- that
she r,t oulcl do ar-rything to achievc this. ' ti hrrn thc
Se<:retarv questioned her behaviour. she r : I lie cl that
since he was th<: Secretary of the aparttl ,trt wherc
Rajkumar and his family
\trere
residing. she rvits
informing him. Rased on the said t omplaint,
F.l.R.No.171 of 2018 u'as registered by 1.h': Osmania
University Policer Station, Hl,clerabad Distri
against
thc pctitioner. The lnvcstigating C) lli :r--r altcr
conducting invcstigation liled a cherrge she('1 )cf()re thc
-)
IV Adcll Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, at Hyderabad
'l'he lr:arned Magrstr:rtr: took cognizance frrr tl-rc:
albrcs:ricl offcni:es and numbercd thc case as
C C No. 1567 of 2018
3.
I-learcl Sri L Ravi Chander, learned Senior
Counscl repre scr-rting Sri Ratnesh Raju Bhatnagar,
lcarnccl counscl lbr rhc pctitioner, Sri M.A.Mujeeb,
lc:rmcd counsel lor
respondcnt No.1
and
Sri M.Vivekananda Redd1,, learned Assistant Public
[)rosecutor lor respondent No.2 -State.
f.
i,earned Senior Counsel lor the petitioner
submitted that the petitioner has not committed any
oflencc and shc has becn falseiy implicated in the
presenI crime. He further submitted Lhat even
according to the allegations made in the complaint, the
allegcd incident has occurred on 15.04.2018, whereas,
respondent No.2 liled complaint on 27.06.2018 u,ith a
lapsc o[ morg than 2 months without assigning any
r-casolts
-
4.I
IIc furtlrcr submitted that lhc pctitiorlr. onl.r saicl
that one R:tjl<Lrrnar- is a lakc cloctor tnr: rcrlucstecl
r-cspondent r-ro. I to re l)love hin-r from tlrr .lpartrncnt.
He lurlher sultrnitted that thc said Rir lrlmar \\ras
already in .judir:ia1 custod-\- on the clittr ,tf allcged
incidcr-rt. Even ar:cording to tl-re allcgationsr r racle cithcr
in the compl:ririt or ir-r tlte linal rcport. llrr, rrgt.cclicnts
lor the oflenccs Lrndcr Scctions 50,,1 ancl .r( r, , of lt)C cicr
not attract. FIcnce, Lhc conLinuatior-r of
-:rcecdings
against the petitioner is a clear abuse o[ 1lr . process of
1aw.
4.2 In support lris contention he has relir r upor-r the
following judgmcnts:
i) B.V.Ram Kumar v State of Telalgana and
Ors.1
ii) Manik Taneja v. State of Karnatakz 2
'u o:s ( r) zr t.o (crt. ) :t6 (\(.1
20 I 5( I )n cR6,i9(sc )
iii) A.M.Mohan V. The State represented by
SHO and Ors.3
iv) Pradeep Kumar Kesarwani v. The state of
Uttarpradesh and Anra
5.
Per cortlre, learr-red counsel lor respondent No. 1
vehemcnt[_r, r:ontendccl that
there are specific
allegettions levelted against the petitioner to attract tltc
ingredicnLs of the offcnccs under Sections 504 and 5O6
of Il)C. He lurther subrnitted that the petitioner
appeared before the triai Court on 29.O2.2024 and she
u.as exerrninecl undcr Section 25 1 oi Cr.p.C., where she
pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. pursuant to
the sarnc, thc matLcr was posted lbr triai. He lurther
submittcd that due to behavior of the petitioner,s
daughtcr, the proccedings before the trial Court were
stalled <tn 02.06.2025. Hcnce, the petitioner is not
cntitlcd to seek thc relief o[ quashing the proceedings.
'1014(t6i)\t( lIj
r2025
Livct-.r\ ( sc)380
.-
5.1 He fi-rrtl-rer submittecl 1l-rat thc jucler I rrlts u'hich
\1'C1-e
r:1iccl uyrort bt'tl-rt'lcartlt'rl Scniol- ('o llsc:l iol tht:
petitioner. al'c not allllLicablc to thC Iar:ts rtrlcl
circumstanccs ol the cascr
Learnecl Assistar-rt Public Prosccutr I rcitcrated
Lhe submission s madc by thc lcarnc<l our-rsel for
respondent No.2
1.
Havir-rg <:orlsidcrecl thc sul;rnissior-rs I lrclt: lll' tl-re
re spective perrties
and upon pcrusal o1' ri: matcriai
available on rccord, it rcveals that thc ir ridc:nt took
place on 15.04.20i8, u'he rcas the cotr plaint u'as
lodged on 27.06.2018, alter a delay of trto r: than trr"o
months, for q'l-rich no proper explanal.ic I has been
given. Further, the corlplaint does t-toL I rcntioll the
specific abusive or thre ater-ring ri'ords r t ;r:d llv the
petitioner and the allegations are vague :.rtt i generztl in
nature. Such gener:rl allegatior-rs, u'ithout ':larils ol the
exact words of conduct, do not lullill tl tr t:sscrltial
requirements of Sections 504 and 506 of the Indian
Penal Cocle
I
In B.V. Ram Kurnar supra, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court held that arr oflencc undcr Section 504 IpC
requlrcs an ir-rtcr.r tionai insult couplerl with thc
intention or knou,leclge thal such insult is iikely to
provokc a brcach of public peacc, and that mere
abuse, rud<rncss or discourtesy, without the requisite
mens rca, clot:s r-rot attract thc sarcl provision. Similarly
in Manik Taneja supra, it u,as hcld that an offence
undcr Sectior-r 506 llrc is rnade ouL only when there is
a clear thrcat ol' injury to person, reputation or
property with intent to cause alarm or to compel the
vlctrm to act or omit an act which he or she is legally
entitled to do. Furthcr, in Pradeep Kurnar Kesarwq.ni
supra, the Flonble Supreme Court laid down the
guiding parameters for exercise of rnherent jurisdiction
under Section 482 Cr.l).C., holding that criminal
proceedings rlray be quashed where the materia-l
-E
li
placed b5,' the accused is of ster-ling qtr L;it1- arrcl
contir-ruation of ploceedings r'r'oulcl atrlount t I 'rbusc ol
proccss o[ Ielv. ln A.M, Mohan .sttTrrc Il'
Hon iritr
Suprcmc Court helcl that tl'rc High Corrrt tr rr c1u:tsl't
proccedings where the allcgatir)l1s, evcn if tzrli rrr t1t fzl(rc
valuc, do nr>1 disclosc the ctln-rmissiotl of :r rl olli'rlt' "
u,hile cautioning Lhat such pou'er tnust bt c-xcrcisc tt
sparingly to securc the ends of justic<r'
light of the above [cga1 prirr'ples' tlrtr
the
In
'
allegations against the pc titioncr are cot t lcd to a
verb:rl exchange during the meeting on I ()4 201'3'
Eve r-r from the perusal of tl-re complzrir-rt :r I I 1 chargt:
-
sheet, it docs not disclose any intentiona I r sult lvit]r
the requisite, metTs rea, \kely to provoke :r r;reach of
public peace, nor do they reveal anv speci I: or clc;'ir
threat inter-rded to cause alarm so as ir littract
Sections 504 or 506 olIPC. In terms of [hr: 1l trametcrs
govcrning tl-re exercise ol inherent juriscli<'l :rll under
Section 482 Cr.P.C., as laid don'n in Prade<p Kumar
---r
Kesarwqni supra and A.M. Mohan supra,
continuation of the proceedings in C.C. No.1567 of
20.1.8 rvould amollnt to an abuse oI process of 1aw
LQ. Insofar as the contention made by learned
counsel for respondent No. 1 that the petitioner
appeared before the trial Court for examinatior-r under
Section 251 of Cr.P.C. :rnd pleaded not guiity and
claime d to bc tricd. ancl hence, petitioner is not
entiticd to seek quashrng of thc procce dings, is
concerned, this Court is not entitled to accept the said
submission on the ground that merely pieading not
guilty before the trial Court is not a ground for seeking
dismissal of the present criminal petition.
ll,.
For the foregoing reasons as well as in view of the
principles laid do'*rn by the Hon'ble Apex Court suprq,
this Court is of the view that the continuation of
proceedings against the petitioner for thc offences
under Sections 5O4 and 506 of IpC are clear abuse of
the process of lau,.
t0
-
lL. In the result, this Crimrnal Pctil-rorr s allo',r'ccl
Accordinglv, the proceedings against the prctilioncr/
irc:cused iir C.C.No.7567 of 2018 on tire ii l, 'rf learnecl
IV Additional Chief Metropolitan N{l.rr istrate ar
Hr.derabad are hereby quashed
Pending miscellaneous petitior-rs. if :rnr'. s1ral1
stand closed
;D/- B REKHA RANI,
ASS I ;TANT REGISTRAR.
//TRUE COPY//
',:>
SECTION OFFICER
To
1. The Vlll Metropolitan tvlagistrate at Nampally, Hyderabad.
2. The Station House Officer, Police Station Osmania Univer; y, Hyderabad.
3. Two CCs to the Public Prosecutor, High Court for the State rf Telangana at
Hyderabad. [OUT]
4. One CC to Sri Ratnesh Raj Bhatnagar, Advocate [OPUC]
5. One CC to Sri t\4 A Mujeeb, Advocate [OPUC]
6. Two CD Copies
ba
4ty
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2210112026
4:::]--::J:;-..i,,','ti.r;.-l/ii.\
o-
ORDER
CRLP.No.7310 of 2019
o-)
a)
2 [[B 2026
I
a--
ALLOWING THE CRLP
0,, 1 yb
q
o'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review