Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 92 of 2018
Date of Decision: 26.03.2021
Shri. Aynal Haque
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. A.H. Hazarika, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. H. Kharmih, GA. (For R 1-3)
Mr. K. Paul, Adv. (For R 4-6).
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The writ petitioner by this application is seeking a mandamus to
include his name in the list of sanctioned post of teachers of Beparipara
S.S.A. L.P School, to allow him to take charge of the post Head Teacher of
the said school and to order for removal of the private respondent No. 6,
from the post of sanctioned teacher who he alleges, is continuing in service
on the strength of fake certificates. The case as put up is that the Managing
Committee of the School by Resolution dated 03.11.2016, had resolved to
promote the petitioner to the post of head teacher in place of one Shri. Saidul
Miah (Respondent No. 5), which was also duly approved by the Competent
Authority, but however, he was not permitted to take charge of the said post.
The other grievance of the petitioner is that, though he was more eligible to
be considered for appointment to a sanctioned post having attained the
essential qualifications at an earlier point of time, he was not accommodated
against the same and instead respondents No. 5 and 6 were appointed against
the sanctioned posts. Further grievance is that, respondent No. 6 by
submission of fake certificates continues to hold on to his post of Teacher,
which is a sanctioned post and that as there has been no response to his
representations and complaints in this regard, has compelled the petitioner
to approach this Court by way of this instant writ petition.
2.
Mr. A.H. Hazarika, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the petitioner and the respondents No. 5 and 6, were appointed together on
29.01.2002, on the recommendation of the Managing Committee as Lower
Primary School Teachers in Beparipara L.P School, on a lump sum salary of
Rs.3000/- (Three Thousand Rupees only) per month. It is further submitted
that after his appointment in the year 2005, the writ petitioner attained further
qualification of (10+2) HSSLC pass, and is now pursuing D.El.Ed. from the
National Institute of Open Schooling, and as such, is well qualified to hold
the post of L.P. School teacher.
3.
Learned counsel submits that vide a Resolution dated 03.11.2016
of the Managing Committee, the petitioner was promoted and asked to take
charge as Head Teacher of the School from Shri. Saidul Miah, the respondent
No. 5, who by another Resolution in the same meeting itself, was demoted
from the said post of Head Teacher for allegedly mis-appropriating the MidDay Meal Scheme amount, taking bribe as well as being inattentive in
school. Learned counsel submits that the said Resolution was forwarded to
the District Mission Co-ordinator who approved the same, but however, the
petitioner till date has not been permitted or allowed to take over as Head
Teacher.
4.
The learned counsel then submits that apart from the above, the
respondent No. 6, who is occupying a sanctioned post and appointed together
with the petitioner, is incompetent to hold the same as it appears he was
appointed on the basis of fake (10+2) certificates dated 15.05.2012. The
learned counsel submits that the certificates were obtained from an
institution which he alleges is fake, as it has been never set up or recognized
by the Ministry of Human Resource Development as per the R.T.I reply
received by the petitioner. He further submits that, the said respondent No.
6, in spite of a representation for his removal is still continuing as Assistant
Teacher in the school. As such, the learned counsel prays that directions be
issued that the petitioner be considered for appointment to a sanctioned post,
be allowed to hold the post of Head Teacher and that further the respondent
No. 6 be removed from the post of Assistant Teacher of Beparipara S.S.A.
L.P School.
5.
Mr. H. Kharmih, learned State counsel for the respondents No. 1-3
submits that the petitioner was a teacher in Beparipara L.P. School in 2007,
before the school was under S.S.A. and that once the school was brought
under S.S.A. in 2007, a fresh Managing Committee was constituted as per
the norms and respondents No. 5 and 6 were appointed in the two S.S.A.
sanctioned posts. Learned counsel in support of this submission has referred
to orders both dated 27.02.2007 (Annexure – A and C to affidavit) which
reflect that respondents No. 5 and 6 were duly appointed as such. He also
submits that the petitioner never raised any grievance at that stage or when
the data for 2013-2014 and 2016-2017 showing respondents No. 5 and 6 as
sanctioned post teachers and the petitioner as a teacher appointed by the
Managing Committee was published. He further submits that the petitioner
is therefore estopped at this juncture from raising any grievance. With regard
to the Resolution, it is submitted that the same was motivated by other
considerations, inasmuch as, the same was passed on 03.11.2016, just before
the expiry of the term of the Managing Committee on 06.11.2016, and on a
mistaken premise the then District Mission Co-ordinator had approved the
said Resolution without verifying the facts. Moreover, he submits the
respondent No. 5 before the Resolution was passed for his removal as Head
Teacher, was never given an opportunity to defend himself, but even leaving
this aspect aside, the petitioner could not have occupied the post of a Head
Teacher as he was a non-sanctioned teacher.
6.
With regard to the prayer for removal of respondent No. 6, learned
counsel submits that the enquiry which was instituted with regard to the
alleged fake certificate was inconclusive as per enquiry conducted on
19.07.2017, by the Joint District Mission Co-ordinator SSA, South West
Garo Hills, Ampati (Annexure – 13 to the writ petition) and is of no
relevance presently as the respondent No. 6 has also obtained (10+2)
certification from the Meghalaya Board of School Education in 2017
securing 55.80%. He therefore submits that, apart from putting up a stale
claim, the petitioner on merits has no case, whatsoever, as he was never
appointed or considered for appointment against the sanctioned post and has
not made out any grounds to merit any interference by this Court.
7.
Mr. K. Paul, learned counsel for the respondents No. 4, 5 and 6 has
also placed reliance on the affidavit filed by the State and has also supported
the arguments made by the State counsel. Learned counsel also submits that
though the petitioner has objected to the qualification of the respondent No.
6, especially for pursuing a (10+2) certificate in the year 2017, he points out
that the petitioner himself has also sought re-qualification in the year 2017
from the Meghalaya Board of School Education and has secured a II
Division with 56.20% as is evident from page-20 of Annexure-1 to the writ
petition. He therefore states that, the writ petitioner has failed to make out
any case and that the writ petition should be dismissed.
8.
Mr. A.H. Hazarika, learned counsel in reply and in addition to his
earlier submissions, has strongly contended that at the time of initial
appointment, he was the only HSSLC passed (10+2) candidate and that
respondent No. 5 and 6 were only mere matriculates, when the prescribed
minimum qualification for recruitment to the post of Lower Primary School
Teachers in the State was HSSLC or Class XII passed or its equivalent.
Learned counsel submits that it is not understood on what basis the name of
respondent No. 6 was put against a sanctioned post, when he should have
been HSSLC qualified at the time of appointment. He lastly submits that, if
in the year 2007 itself the two teachers were appointed against the sanctioned
posts when they were not qualified, the same cannot be overlooked and they
are liable to be removed from the category of sanctioned post teacher.
9.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties, and I have given my
due consideration to the facts as placed and also to the materials on record.
A pertinent point that is noted, is that the writ petitioner has approached this
Court in the year 2018, that is 11 years after the appointment of the
respondents No. 5 and 6 in Beparipara School in the year 2007 as sanctioned
teachers. From a perusal of the materials on records, it appears that the writ
petitioner started agitating for his perceived right only after the Resolution
dated 03.11.2016 had been passed, wherein it was resolved to promote him
to the post of Head Teacher. This was followed by his quest to get respondent
No. 6 removed for allegedly possessing fake certificates which however, on
enquiry as noted earlier, did not yield any fruit. Even the Resolution on which
the petitioner has strongly relied upon apart from being deprecated by the
State respondents themselves was never implemented and as submitted by
the respondents, the petitioner could not have held the post of Head Teacher
as he was occupying a non-sanctioned post.
10.
The grounds raised as to the respondent No. 6 not possessing the
required qualifications at the time of appointment has also no legs to stand
on, inasmuch as, the respondent No. 6 as on today is qualified to occupy the
post. Challenge if any, should have been made by the petitioner 11 years ago
and not at this late stage, which if entertained will unsettle a settled position.
From the facts and circumstances, it can be clearly seen that the petitioner
became active only after the Resolution dated 03.11.2016, was passed by the
Managing Committee and it seems was satisfied as to his situation in
employment all these years.
11.
In this view of the matter, no sufficient grounds have been made
out to show that the petitioner has any subsisting right or that he has been
deprived of his rights in any manner and as such, the writ application fails
and accordingly stands dismissed.
Judge
Meghalaya
26.03.2021
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review