Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/34
GAHC010207952026
2026:GAU-AS:15137
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/5204/2026
AYESHA BEGUM
W/O ASHUK UDIN TAPADAR, R/O - VILLAGE CHOURORGOOL, P.O
ANGLARBAZAAR, DISTRICT SRIBHUMI, ASSAM, PIN - 788701.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM,
PANCHAYAT AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT, DISPUR,
GUWAHATI, PIN - 781006.
2:THE COMMISSIONER
PANCHAYAT AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
ASSAM
JURIPAR
PANJABARI
GUWAHATI
PIN - 781022.
3:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
SRIBHUMI
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OFFICE ROAD
MAIN ROAD
SRIBHUMI
ASSAM
PIN788710.
4:THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
OFFICE OF THE ZILLA PARISHAD
SRIBHUMI
BESIDE DC OFFICE
KARIMGANJ
Page No.# 2/34
P.O. KARIMGANJ
ASSAM
PIN 788710
5:THE BLOCK DEVELOPMENT OFFICER
BADARPUR CHAITANYANAGAR DEVELOPMENT BLOCK
P.O MAHAKAL
DISTRICT SRIBHUMI
ASSAM
PIN 788706
6:SURJANA BEGUM TAPADAR
W/O - MUJIBUR RAHMAN LASKAR
R/O VILLAGE - HARINADIK
P.O ANGLAR BAZAR
P.S BADARPUR
DISTRICT - SRIBHUMI
ASSAM
PIN - 788806
Linked Case : WP(C)/5253/2025
AYESHA BEGUM
W/O ASHUK UDIN TAPADAR
R/O CHOURORGOOL
P.O- ANGLARBAZAAR
DISTRICT- SRIBHUMI
ASSAM
PRESENTLY
THE PRESIDENT OF UMARPUR GAON PANCHAYAT
SRIBHUMI.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
PANCHAYAT AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6.
2:THE COMMISSIONER
PANCHAYAT AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
JURIPAR
PANJABARI
Page No.# 3/34
GUWAHATI-22
3:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
SRIBHUMI
ASSAM
4:THE BLOCK DEVELOPMENT OFFICER
BADARPUR CHAITAYNANAGAR DEVELOPMENT BLOCK
P.O MAHAKAL
PIN- 788701
SRIBHUMI
ASSAM
5:THE AUTHORIZED OFFICER
IN RESPECT OF THE ELECTION OF THE PRESIDENT OF UMARPUR GAON
PANCHAYAT IN ITS FIRST MEETING HELD ON 03.07.2025
6:SURJANA BEGUM TAPADAR
WIFE OF MUJIBUR RAHMAN LASKAR
RESIDENT VILLAGE - HARINADIK
P.O ANGLAR BAZAR
P.S BADARPUR
DISTRICT- SRIBHUMI
ASSAM
PIN-788806.
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
Advocate for the petitioner (s) : Mr. K. N. Choudhury,
Sr. Advocate
Mr. S. K. Talukdar, Advocate
Advocate for the respondent (s): Mrs. M. Hazarika,
Sr. Advocate
Mr. J. I. Borbhuiya, Advocate
Mr. S. Dutta,
SC, P&RD Deptt.
Date on which judgment is reserved
: NA
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 06.10.2026
Page No.# 4/34
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment?
: Yes
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. K. N. Choudhury, the learned Senior Counsel
assisted by Mr. S. K. Talukdar, the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the Petitioner in both the writ petitions. Mr. S. Dutta,
the learned Standing Counsel appears, on behalf of the
Panchayat
and
Rural
Development
Department
of
the
Government of Assam and Mrs. M. Hazarika, the learned Senior
Counsel assisted by Mr. J. I. Borbhuiya, the learned counsel
appears, on behalf of the Respondent No.6 in both the writ
petitions.
2.
Both the writ petitions being interconnected are taken up for
disposal by this common judgment and order.
BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE
3.
Shorn of unnecessary details, ten ward members were
elected to the Umarpur Gaon Panchayat pursuant to the
Panchayat Elections, 2025. The first meeting of the Umarpur
Gaon Panchayat was held on 03.07.2025. The Petitioner and the
private Respondent who is common in both the writ petitions
Page No.# 5/34
contested for the post of the President. From the materials on
record, it transpires that there was no dispute as to who voted
for whom in so far as nine ballot papers were concerned. But in
one ballot paper, the vote mark was placed almost in the middle
of both the candidates. This aspect is apparent from a perusal of
Page No.31 of WP(C) No.5253/2025.
4.
The Respondent No.6 admittedly secured five votes. The
Respondent No.6 on 03.07.2025 also did not dispute the ballot
paper where the vote mark was put almost in the middle
between the Petitioner and the Respondent No.6 and the said
vote was counted as a vote for the Petitioner. Resultantly, both
the Petitioner and Respondent No.6 had five equal votes. At this
stage, it is pertinent to take note of Rule 46(8) of the Assam
Panchayat (Constitution) Rules, 1995 (for short, ‘the Rules of
1995’) and the same is reproduced herein under:“46 (8) After completion of counting and recording of votes received
by each candidate, the Officer authorised under sub-rule (1), shall
declare the candidate who has secured the highest number of votes
to be duly elected as the President and Vice-President of the Gaon
Panchayat. In case of equality of votes between two or more
candidates, declaration of election shall be given by the said Officer
in the manner prescribed under Rule 45 of these rules.”
5.
From a perusal of the above quoted Sub-Rule (8) of Rule 46
Page No.# 6/34
of the Rules of 1995, it would transpire that a candidate who has
secured the highest number of votes against the respective office
shall be duly elected as the President or the Vice-President of the
Gaon Panchayat concerned. In the case of equality of votes
between two or more candidates, the declaration of the election
shall be given by the said Officer in the manner prescribed under
Rule 45 of the Rules of 1995. Taking into account the relevance
of Rule 45 of the Rules of 1995, the said Rule is also reproduced
herein under:“45. Equality of Votes. - (1) If after the counting of votes it appears
that two candidates of whom only one is to be declared elected,
having received equal number of votes, the Deputy Commissioner or
the Sub-Divisional Officer as the case may be, or any Officer
authorised by him in this behalf, shall decide which of the two shall
be declared elected by tossing up a coin in presence of such
candidates. Each candidate shall be, assigned one side of the coin
by him or by the Officer just before the toss. The candidate whose
side appears visible at the top of the coin after it has fallen flat on
any plain ground or table, shall be declared elected.
(2) If after counting the votes it appears that more than two
candidates have received equal number of votes, the Deputy
Commissioner or the Sub-Divisional Officer as the case may be, or
any Officer authorised by him, shall cause a draw lot in presence of
the candidates or their Agents in the following manner
Page No.# 7/34
(i) the names of the candidates having equal number of votes
shall be written in separate pieces of paper of the same size
and those pieces of paper shall be rolled into separate balls
and placed together in a bag. Separate pieces of blank paper
of the same size corresponding to the number of pieces placed
in the bag, shall be rolled in separate balls and placed
together in the same bag, and the bag shall be well shaken.
The Deputy Commissioner or the Sub-Divisional Officer as the
case may be, or the Officer authorized by him, shall then
brings out one paper ball from the bag and open the same. If
it is blank, it shall be thrown away and the process shall be
continued till the name of a candidate appears in paper ball.
The candidate whose name so appears first, shall be declared
elected.”
6.
From a perusal of the above quoted Rule 45 (1) of the Rules
of 1995, it would be seen that if after counting of votes, it
appears that two candidates of whom only one is to be declared
elected, have received equal number of votes, the District
Commissioner or the Sub-divisional Officer, as the may be, or any
Officer authorized by him shall decide which of the two shall be
declared elected by tossing up a coin in presence of such
candidates. While carrying out the said tossing of the coin, each
candidate shall be assigned one side of the coin just before the
toss and the candidate whose side appears visible at the top of
Page No.# 8/34
the coin after it has fallen flat on any plain ground or table shall
be declared elected.
Sub-Rule (2) of Rule 45 of the Rules of 1995 has no
relevance in the present proceedings, as such, is not specifically
dealt with.
7.
Taking into account that both the Petitioner and the
Respondent No.6 had agreed to go for the tossing of the coin as
envisaged under Rule 45(1) of the Rules of 1995 which aspect
would be apparent from a perusal of Annexure-3 to the writ
petition being WP(C) No.5253/2025, the toss was held whereby
the Petitioner chose the heads whereas the Respondent No.6
chose the tails.
8.
The toss resulted in the Petitioner being elected as the
President of Umarpur Gaon Panchayat as per the procedure
stipulated in Rule 45(1) of the Rules of 1995.
9.
The
records
representation
was
further
reveal
submitted
by
that
on
04.07.2025,
the
Respondent
a
No.6
countersigned by four other ward members wherein the ballot
paper which had the vote mark almost in the middle of both the
candidates was put to challenge, and consequently, the toss of
coin which was conducted in terms with Rule 45(1) of the Rules
of 1995 was also put to challenge.
Page No.# 9/34
10.
The said challenge which was made by way of a
representation without specifically referring to Section 11 of the
Assam Panchayat Act 1994 (for short, ‘the Act of 1994’). At this
stage, it may not be out of place to mention that neither the Act
of 1994 nor the Rules of 1995 stipulate any format for filing an
election petition or for that matter a limitation for filing an
Appeal. Section 11 of the Act of 1994 is reproduced herein
under:“11.
Any dispute relating to the validity of the election of the
President and the Vice-President of the Gaon Panchayat under this
Act shall be decided by the Deputy Commissioner.”
11. It is relevant at this stage to observe that Section 11 of the
Act of 1994 is not an appellate provision, rather, it is a provision
wherein a dispute pertaining to the validity of any election of the
President and Vice-President of the Gaon Panchayat is to be
decided in the first instance. This aspect would be relevant as
would appear in the later part of the present judgment.
12.
The District Commissioner, Sribhumi however did not take
any steps pursuant to the representation dated 04.07.2025. The
Respondent No.6 being aggrieved approached this Court by filing
a writ petition which was registered and numbered as WP(C)
No.3922/2025. In the said proceedings, the Petitioner herein was
arrayed as the Respondent No.8.
Page No.# 10/34
13. It is of importance to take note that the learned Coordinate
Bench of this Court vide the order dated 21.07.2025 took into
consideration Section 11 of the Act of 1994 and observed that
the jurisdictional District Commissioner is the authority to decide
a dispute relating to the validity of the election of the President
and the Vice-President of the Gaon Panchayat. The counsel who
represented the Respondent No.6 herein in the said proceedings
prayed before the learned Coordinate Bench of this Court that a
direction may be issued to the District Commissioner, Sribhumi to
consider the representation submitted by the Respondent No.6
herein. The learned counsel who appeared on behalf of the
Petitioner herein (the Respondent No.8 in the said proceedings)
also did not dispute the said prayer made by the learned counsel
for the Respondent No.6 herein (the Petitioner in the said
proceedings). On the basis of consensus reached, a consent
order was passed by the learned Coordinate Bench directing the
jurisdictional District Commissioner to pass a speaking order on
the representation submitted by the Respondent No.6 herein (the
Petitioner in the said proceedings) and communicate the same to
the concerned parties, i.e. the Petitioner and the Respondent
No.6 herein. The parties were granted the liberty to file
additional pleadings, if so desired. The learned Coordinate Bench
also directed that the said exercise be completed within a period
Page No.# 11/34
of 45 days from the receipt of the certified copy of the said order
dated 21.07.2025. Taking into account the relevance of the said
directions to the present dispute, Paragraph Nos.8 to 15 of the
said order dated 21.07.2025 are reproduced herein under:“8.
The Assam Panchayat Act, 1994, in Section 11 thereof has
mandated that in the event of any dispute relating to the validity of
the election of the President and the Vice President of the Gaon
Panchayat, the same shall be decided by the District Commissioner.
Provisions of Section 11 of the Assam Panchayat Act of 1994, being
relevant is extracted hereinbelow :
“11. Any dispute relating to the validity of the election of the
President and the Vice-President of the Gaon Panchayat under
this Act shall be decided by the Deputy Commissioner.”
9. A perusal of the provisions of Section 11, would go to reveal that
any dispute relating to the validity of election of the President and
Vice-President of the Gaon Panchayat, under this Act, shall be
decided by the Jurisdictional District Commissioner. The petitioner,
herein, has already approached the District Commissioner, Sribhumi
District, by way of filing a representation dated 04.07.2025, raising a
grievance with regard to the manner in which the Respondent No.8
was so elected as President of the Goan Panchayat. However, it is
submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the said
representation has not be given its due consideration.
10. Accordingly, Mr. J. I. Borbhuiya, learned counsel, has prayed that
a direction be issued to the District Commissioner, Sribhumi District to
Page No.# 12/34
consider
the
representation
submitted
by
the
petitioner
on
04.07.2025.
11. Mr. S. K. Talukdar, learned counsel, has also not disputed the said
prayer made by the petitioner.
12. In view of the above consensus reached by the learned counsel
for the parties, this Court is of the considered view that the dispute
raised by the petitioner pertaining to the election of the Respondent
No.8, is to be considered at the first instance by the jurisdictional
District Commissioner. Accordingly, the petitioner is directed to
furnish a certified copy of this order along with further pleadings he
desires to bring on record before the jurisdictional District
Commissioner, within a period of 10(ten) days from today. The
jurisdictional District Commissioner, on receipt of the certified copy
of this order along with additional pleadings that may be brought on
record by the petitioner, shall fix a date for hearing and shall issue
notices thereon to the petitioner, Respondent No.8 and any other
stakeholder involved in the matter. Upon hearing the parties to the
proceedings and also appreciating the evidences brought on record
by the parties, the jurisdictional District Commissioner, Sribhumi,
shall proceed to pass a speaking orders determining the grievance
raised by the petitioner in her representations dated 04.07.2025 and
communicate the same to all concerned.
13. The Respondent No.8 and other stakeholders are granted liberty
to bring on record their respective pleadings on or before the date
of hearing scheduled in the matter by the jurisdictional District
Commissioner, Sribhumi.
Page No.# 13/34
14. The exercise now required to be carried out in the matter for
compliance
of
the
directions
passed
hereinabove
by
the
jurisdictional District Commissioner, Sribhumi, shall be so initiated
and concluded within a period of 45(forty five) days from the date of
receipt of a certified copy of this order.
15. With the above observation and directions, writ petition stands
disposed of.”
14.
The records further reveal that both the parties filed their
additional pleadings before the District Commissioner, Sribhumi.
In the objection so filed by the Petitioner on 22.08.2025,
questions were raised as regards the finality attained in respect
to the declaration of result made by an officer under Rule 46(8)
of the Rules of 1995 and that the Respondent No.6 herein was
not entitled to any relief under Section 11 of the Act of 1994. A
further perusal of the said objection dated 22.08.2025 filed by
the Petitioner before the District Commissioner, Sribhumi though
did not challenge the maintainability of the proceedings under
Section 11 of the Act of 1994, but rather contested the
entertainability of the said proceedings in view of the finality
attached to the results by virtue of Rule 46(8) read with Rule
46(9) of the Rules of 1995.
15.
The District Commissioner thereupon passed the impugned
order dated 27.08.2025 whereby he rejected the ballot paper
Page No.# 14/34
which contained the vote mark almost in the middle between the
names of the Petitioner and the Respondent No.6, and
thereupon, came to an opinion that as the Respondent No.6 had
secured five votes and the Petitioner had secured four votes and
one ballot paper was rejected and accordingly declared the
Respondent No.6 to be the President of the Umarpur Gaon
Panchayat. This order dated 27.08.2025 is the subject matter of
challenge in WP(C) No.5253/2025.
16.
The learned Coordinate Bench of this Court vide an order
dated 05.09.2025 while issuing notice and also taking into
consideration the submission made by the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the Respondent No.6 that pursuant to the
passing of the impugned order dated 27.08.2025, the charge was
handed over to the Respondent No.6, directed the parties to
maintain status quo. The status quo direction is of relevance in
as much as the same became the basis of the proceedings in
WP(C) No.5204/2026. It is also of importance to note that the
order dated 27.08.2025 was not stayed.
17.
Pleadings were exchanged. The interim order dated
05.09.2025 was extended by this Court from time to time on
various dates. This aspect would be apparent from a perusal of
the orders dated 10.06.2026, 17.07.2026 and 19.08.2026. Be
that as it may, when the WP(C) No.5253/2025 was taken up on
Page No.# 15/34
26.08.2026, this Court did not extend the interim order. It is
noted that vide order dated 19.08.2026 it was clearly mentioned
that the interim order passed on 05.09.2025 shall continue till
26.08.2026. The records further reveal that the matter was again
heard on 03.09.2026 and as the hearing remained inconclusive,
this Court directed the matter to be listed today for final disposal.
18. While narrating the facts, another aspect is also required to
be taken note of. Though the order dated 05.09.2025 directed
the maintenance of status quo between the parties, the
Petitioner herein was not allowed to function as the President. It
is under such circumstances that the Petitioner filed the writ
petition before this Court which was registered and numbered as
WP(C) No.2359/2026. In the said writ petition amongst the
various reliefs sought for, one such relief was the issuance of a
writ in the nature of mandamus thereby directing and
commanding the Respondent Authorities, more particularly, the
District Commissioner, Sribhumi; the Chief Executive Officer,
Sribhumi Zilla Parishad as well as the Block Development Officer,
Badarpur Chaitayanagar Development Block to activate the
Petitioner's
digital
signature
and
provide
all
necessary
administrative login credentials and access to the government
portals (e-Gram Swaraj, etc.) to enable the Petitioner to
discharge her statutory duties as President of Umarpur Gaon
Page No.# 16/34
Panchayat.
When
the
said
writ
petition
being
WP(C)
No.2359/2026 was moved, the learned Coordinate Bench of this
Court vide an order dated 19.06.2026 issued notice and further
observed that the Panchayat and Rural Development Department
shall traverse the observations made in the order dated
08.05.2026 and shall deal with the issue who is presently holding
the charge of the President of the Gaon Panchayat.
19.
The said writ petition was withdrawn on 03.09.2026 with a
further observation that the interim order, if any, stood vacated.
In other words, in view of the withdrawal of the writ petition
being WP(C) No.2359/2026, the various reliefs which were
sought including the relief that the Petitioner should be permitted
to discharge the functions of the President of Umarpur Gaon
Panchayat, stood closed on withdrawal.
20.
In the backdrop of the above, it is now relevant to take
note of that pursuant to the withdrawal of WP(C) No.2359/2026,
the Chief Executive Officer, Sribhumi Zilla Parishad observed that
the District Commissioner's order dated 27.08.2025 declaring the
Respondent No. 6, as the President must be implemented in
letter and spirit. This communication was issued on 17.09.2026
which is the subject matter of challenge in WP(C) No.5204/2026.
21.
The learned Coordinate Bench of this Court vide an order
Page No.# 17/34
dated 22.09.2026 while issuing notice observed that the
directions
made
in
the
order
dated
17.09.2026
for
implementation of the order dated 27.08.2025 shall not be given
effect till the returnable date.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
PARTIES
22.
Mr. K. N. Choudhury, the learned Senior Counsel appearing
on behalf of the Petitioner submitted that taking into account
Rule 46(9) of the Rules of 1995 whereby a declaration of result
made under Rule 46(8) of the Rules of 1995 is final, proceedings
under Section 11 of the Act of 1994 could not have been
maintained or even decided by the District Commissioner, and
therefore, the impugned order dated 27.08.2025 is without
jurisdiction, and accordingly, liable to be interfered with. The
learned Senior Counsel further submitted that in the meeting
which was held on 03.07.2025, the parties to the present
proceedings, more particularly the Petitioner as well as the
Respondent No.6 had duly agreed to that both secured equal
votes, and therefore, participated in the procedure as envisaged
in terms with Rule 46(8) read with Rule 45(1) of the Rules of
1995, and therefore, the Respondent No.6 cannot challenge the
ballot paper or even the toss of coin which had taken place in
terms with the procedure mandated under Rule 45(1) of the
Page No.# 18/34
Rules of 1995.
23.
The learned Senior Counsel also submitted drawing
reference to Page 31 of WP(C) No.5253/2025 to the effect that
the vote mark though was almost in the middle of the names of
the Petitioner and the Respondent No.6, but the larger portion of
the vote mark was towards the Petitioner, and as such, in terms
with the directions issued for the Panchayat Elections, 2025, i.e.
the Instructions issued to all Trainers, Counting Supervisors and
Counting Assistants, the said ballot paper was not only valid but
also that the vote should be counted in favour of the Petitioner.
He referred to the valid Sample No.2 and submitted that as the
major portion of the cross mark was in favour of the Petitioner,
the ballot paper in question was valid and could not have been
rejected.
24.
The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that if the
ballot paper is valid, the vote has to be counted in favour of the
Petitioner, and therefore, as the Petitioner and the Respondent
No.6 had duly agreed to the procedure as stipulated under Rule
45(1) of the Rules of 1995, the declaration that the Petitioner is
the President should be upheld thereby setting aside and
quashing the impugned order dated 27.08.2025.
25.
The learned Senior Counsel further referring to the
Page No.# 19/34
judgment of the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in the
case of High Court Bar Association Allahabad vs. the State of Uttar
Pradesh and Others, reported in (2024) 6 SCC 267, submitted that
as there was an interim order passed on 05.09.2025 thereby
directing the parties to maintain status quo, the said interim
order cannot be said to be vacated unless specifically mentioned
that it is vacated. In that regard, he referred to Paragraphs 54,
55 and 56 of the said judgment. The learned Senior Counsel
therefore submitted that the impugned communication dated
17.09.2026 which is assailed in WP(C) No.5204/2026 is therefore
liable to be interfered with.
26.
Mrs. M. Hazarika, the learned Senior Counsel assisted by
Mr. J. I. Borbhuiya, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the Respondent No.6 submitted that the finality which is
attached to the result of the election by virtue of Rule 46(9) of
the Rules of 1995 is in respect to the declaration of results to be
made in terms with Rule 46(8) of the Rules of 1995. The learned
Senior Counsel therefore submitted that the Rule 46(8) envisages
two situations; first, a declaration of result when a candidate
secures the highest number of votes in respect to a particular
post whereby the candidate is declared as the President or the
Vice-President as the case may be. The second situation is
where, when two or more candidates secure equal number of
Page No.# 20/34
votes then in such case the procedure mandated under Rule 45
of the Rules of 1995 has to be followed. The learned Senior
Counsel therefore submitted that the finality so attached by Rule
46(9) of the Rules of 1995 is only in respect to the declaration of
the result which has nothing to do with an election dispute in as
much as an election dispute resolution is provided under Section
11 of the Act of 1994. The learned Senior Counsel referring to
Section 11 of the Act of 1994 submitted that the said provision is
unambiguous, unfettered and unbridled by any of the restrictions
contained in the Rules of 1995, and therefore, to put a restriction
as contended by the learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner
would be interfering with the legislative wisdom in so far as
Section 11 is concerned. The learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that Section 11 of the Act of 1994 provides that the
validity of any election to the President or the Vice-President
shall be decided by the Deputy Commissioner.
27.
Referring to Section 141 of the Act of 1994, Mrs. M.
Hazarika, the learned Senior Counsel submitted that the power
has been conferred upon the State Government to make Rules
for carrying out the purpose and object of the Act. Elaborating
further, the learned Senior Counsel therefore submitted that
Section 11 of the Act of 1994 does not put any restrictions on
questioning the validity of an election to the President or the
Page No.# 21/34
Vice-President, and as such, the Rules so framed for carrying out
the purpose and the object of the Act cannot be interpreted to
curtail the powers conferred under Section 11 of the Act of 1994.
In that regard, the learned Senior Counsel referred to the
judgments of the Supreme Court in the case of Kunj Behari Lal
Butail & Others vs. State of H.P. & Others , reported in (2000) 3 SCC
40 wherein the Supreme Court observed that the delegated
power to legislate by making Rules cannot circumscribe the
statute in as much as the Rules have been made for carrying out
the purpose of the Act. The delegated power as submitted by the
learned Senior Counsel cannot be used to bring within its net a
subject excluded by the Act itself or to bring into existence
substantive right or obligation or disabilities not contemplated by
the provisions of the Act. The learned Senior Counsel also
referred to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of
Jyoti Basu and Others vs. Debi Ghosal and Others , reported in (1982)
1 SCC 691 and referred to Paragraph No.8 and submitted that a
right to elect, fundamental though it is to democracy, is
anomalously enough, neither a fundamental right nor a common
law right. It is pure and simple, a statutory right. Statutory
creations as they are, they are subject to statutory limitation. An
election proceeding is a statutory proceeding where neither the
common law nor the principles of equity apply, but only those
Page No.# 22/34
Rules which the statute makes and applies.
28.
The learned Senior Counsel therefore submitted that the
provisions of Rule 46(8) and Rule 46(9) of the Rules of 1995
under no circumstance can be said to circumscribe the powers of
resolution of the dispute pertaining to the validity of the election
of a President as envisaged under Section 11 of the Act of 1994.
29.
On merits, the learned Senior Counsel submitted that a
perusal of the ballot paper in question would show that the said
vote mark was almost in the middle. Referring to Sample No.6 at
Page 160 to the writ petition being WP(C) No.5253/2025, the
learned Senior Counsel submitted that this is a classic example of
an invalid ballot paper in as much as it cannot be ascertained for
whom the vote was cast. The learned Senior Counsel further
referring to Page 146 to the writ petition being WP(C)
No.5253/2025 submitted that if a cross mark is placed against
the names and the symbols of more than one candidate, it is a
case for rejecting a ballot paper. The learned Senior Counsel
therefore submitted that in the instant case what was done by
the District Commissioner by passing the impugned order is
exercising the powers which the Officer authorized by the Deputy
Commissioner to conduct the election ought to have done in
terms with Rule 46(6) read with Rule 46(7) (b) and (c) of the
Rules of 1995.
Page No.# 23/34
30.
In so far as the contention made by the learned Senior
Counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioner to the effect that
the Respondent No.6 having agreed to the procedure as
mandated under Rules 45, the learned Senior Counsel referred to
the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Jibontara
Ghatowar vs. Sarbananda Sonowal and Others , reported in (2003) 6
SCC 452 and placed reliance upon Paragraph No.14 wherein the
Supreme Court observed that a defect in the ballot paper having
been detected, the issue had to be decided by the satisfaction of
the Returning Officer. Even a concession given by the candidates
or their election agents submitting to a decision arrived at by the
Returning Officer in accordance with the law may come in the
way of the candidate turning around and disputing a doubtful
position of law taken as resolved and conceded or accepted. The
learned Senior Counsel therefore submitted that in an election
dispute, a concession contrary to law or a failure to discharge
statutory obligation cast on an election officer which has resulted
in prejudicing the result of the election cannot ipso facto claim
immunity from challenge.
POINTS FOR DETRMINATION
(i) Whether the District Commissioner, Sribhumi had the
jurisdiction to exercise the powers under Section 11 of the
Act of 1994 in the present facts and circumstances of the
Page No.# 24/34
case?
(ii) Whether the impugned order dated 27.08.2025 calls for
any interference?
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION
FIRST POINT FOR DETERMINATION
31. In the foregoing segment of the present judgment, this Court
has reproduced the provisions of Rule 46(8) of the Rules of 1995
as well as Section 11 of the Act of 1994. Rule 46(9) of the Rules
of 1995 being relevant, is reproduced herein under:“46(9)
Declaration as to the election of the President and Vice-
President of the Gaon Panchayat under sub-rule (8) by the Officer
authorised, shall be final.”
32.
Section 11 of the Act of 1994 was amended by the Assam
Panchayat (Amendment) Act, 2023 whereby the validity of the
election of a President was brought within the fold of Section 11
of the Act of 1994. A perusal of Section 11 of the Act of 1994
would show that it uses the term “any dispute” which in the
opinion of this Court would bring within the fold of Section 11 of
the Act of 1994 all such disputes that have arisen in respect of
an election to the office of the President and the Vice-President
of the Gaon Panchayat whatsoever. Further, the Legislature has
not circumscribed the powers under Section 11 of the Act of
1994 to be controlled by the Rules of 1995.
Page No.# 25/34
33. In the backdrop of the above, if this Court now takes note of
Rule 46(8) and Rule 46(9) of the Rules of 1995, it would show
that Rule 46(8) refers to declaration of a candidate to be elected
as the President and Vice-President of the Gaon Panchayat. It
can be either by way of securing the highest number of votes in
respect to the respective post or a declaration of the election by
following the procedure prescribed under Rule 45 of the Rules of
1995. Rule 46(9) of the Rules of 1995 does not confine the
finality to a declaration of result in terms with Rule 45; it
mandates the declaration of result under Sub-Rule (8) of Rule 46
of the Rules of 1995.
34. It is also very pertinent to mention, that Rule 46 of the Rules
of 1995 specifically deals with the election of the President and
the Vice-President of the Gaon Panchayat. In the said provision,
how the elections are to be conducted, who is to conduct, where
it is to be conducted and how the declaration of results is to be
made, have been prescribed. The finality attached to the
declaration of results in terms with Rule 46(9) of the Rules of
1995, in the opinion of this Court, has to be limited within the
fold of the said Rule 46 of the Rules of 1995 itself. The said
opinion is based upon the settled principles of administrative law
that the Rules framed for carrying out the purpose of the Act
under any circumstances cannot be permitted to override or
Page No.# 26/34
circumscribe the powers conferred upon an Authority under the
parent Act provides so. The judgment of the Supreme Court
referred to in the case of Kunj Behari Lal Butail & Others (supra)
also supports the view that the delegated power to make the
Rules cannot be used to bring within its net a subject excluded
by the Act itself or to bring into existence substantive rights or
obligations or disabilities not contemplated by the Act. It is also
the opinion of this Court that if Rule 46 (9) of the Rules of 1995
is to be read that the declaration of the result in an election in
terms with Rule 46(8) read with Rule 45(1) of the Rules of 1995
cannot be challenged under Section 11 of the Act of 1994, it
would render Section 11 of the Act of 1994 subject to the Rules
of 1995 though Section 11 of the Act of 1994 makes it clear that
any dispute pertaining to the legality and validity of an election
to President and Vice-President is to be decided by the Deputy
Commissioner, such interpretation would curtain the powers
conferred by Section 11 of the Act of 1994.
35.
Rule 46(9) of the Rules of 1995 as already observed
hereinabove not only envelops within itself a declaration of result
under Rule 45 of the Rules of 1995, but also a declaration of
result to a candidate who has secured the highest number of
votes in the respective post. Under such circumstances, if the
submission made by the learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner
Page No.# 27/34
is accepted, it would result in Rule 46(8) and Rule 46(9) of the
Rules of 1995 running counter to Section 11 of the Act of 1994,
and therefore, would become ultra vires the Act of 1994.
36.
In that view of the matter, the submission of the learned
Senior Counsel for the Petitioner that the Respondent No.6 could
not have approached the District Commissioner challenging the
ballot paper as well as the election of the Petitioner as the
President cannot be accepted.
37.
This Court therefore decides the First Point for Determination
holding inter alia that the District Commissioner had the authority
and jurisdiction to pass the order dated 27.08.2025 in terms with
Section 11 of the Act of 1994. It is also observed that the
directions passed by the learned Coordinate Bench in the order
dated 21.07.2025 in WP(C) No.3922/2025 on the consensus of
the parties amount to converting the representation submitted by
the Respondent No.6 dated 04.07.2025 into an election petition
challenging the validity of the election of the Petitioner as
President of the Gaon Panchayat in question.
SECOND POINT FOR DETERMINATION
38. The second point for determination is a question on merit as
regards the legality and validity of the impugned order dated
27.08.2025. It may not be out of place to mention that the
Page No.# 28/34
District Commissioner, Sribhumi is a fact-finding authority who
had decided that the ballot paper in question wherein the vote
mark appeared almost in the middle ought to have been
rejected. To interfere with such finding of fact, in exercise of
certiorari jurisdiction, the burden lies upon the Petitioner to show
that such finding of fact suffered from perversity or is contrary to
the settled principles of law. Nothing in that regard could be
shown except the instructions which were issued to the Trainers,
Supervisors and Counting Assistants by the Assam State Election
Commission.
39.
The learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the
Petitioner referred to Sample No.2 which is at Page 155 to the
writ petition being WP(C) No.5253/2025 and submitted that the
said Sample No.2 would apply. In the opinion of this Court,
Sample No.2 at Page 155 to the writ petition being WP(C)
No.5253/2025 would not apply, in as much as at Sample No.2, a
major part of the vote mark was in favour of one Amar Singh
and the remaining portion was in the blank portion not touching
upon the other candidate. On the other hand, a perusal of invalid
Sample No.6 at Page 160 of WP(C) No.5253/2025, which the
learned Senior Counsel for the Respondent No.6 placed reliance
upon, in the opinion of this Court squarely applies to the ballot
paper which is at Page 31 of the WP(C) No.5253/2025.
Page No.# 29/34
40.
This Court now finds it relevant to take note of the question
of waiver as contended by the learned Senior Counsel appearing
on behalf of the Petitioner it is submitted that the Respondent
No.6 by accepting that the Petitioner and the Respondent No.6
having secured an equal number of votes could not have
challenged the procedure mandated under Rule 45 of the Rules
of 1995. In the opinion of this Court, the said submission is
misconceived in as much as a perusal of Rule 46(7)(b) and (c) of
the Rules of 1995 categorically provides that a ballot paper shall
be invalid if the cross mark is placed against more than one
name or the cross mark is so placed thereon as to make it
doubtful for which candidate the vote was intended to be given.
Rule 46(7)(b) and (c) of the Rules of 1995 are reproduced herein
under:“46(7) (b) the cross mark is placed against more than one name;
or
(c) the cross mark is so placed thereon as to make it doubtful for
which candidate the vote was intended to be given.”
41.
It was therefore the obligation and duty of the officer
authorized by the Deputy Commissioner in terms with Rule 46(1)
to have rejected the said ballot paper, in as much as the Officer
was conducting the election under Rule 46 of the Rules of 1995.
The learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the
Respondent No.6 had referred to the judgment of the Supreme
Page No.# 30/34
Court in the case of Jibontara Ghatowar (supra). Paragraph 14 of
the said judgment is of relevance which is reproduced herein
under:“14. A bare reading of the rules shows that the obligation is cast on
the polling officer to stamp with such distinguishing mark as the
Election Commission may direct and to sign in full on the back of the
ballot papers. The candidate has no role to play in the performance
of such duty by the polling officer. Absence of mark and the
signature renders the ballot paper liable to be rejected. However,
still, where the Returning Officer feels satisfied that such defect has
been caused by any mistake or failure on the part of the Presiding
Officer or polling officer, the ballot paper shall not be rejected
merely on the ground of such defect. An analysis of this rule and the
legal implication thereof may not detain us any longer inasmuch as
we find these rules having been dealt with in Arun Kumar Bose v.
Mohd. Furkan Ansari, wherein this Court found that the absence of
signature and distinguishing mark on seventy-four ballot papers was
attributable to failure on the part of the Presiding Officer. Having
found so, the Court held:
‘It
was the obligation of the Presiding Officer to put his
signature on the ballot papers before they were issued to the
voters. Every voter has the right to vote and in the democratic
set-up prevailing in the country no person entitled to share the
franchise can be denied the privilege. Nor can the candidate
be made to suffer. Keeping this position in view, we are of the
Page No.# 31/34
definite view that the present case is one of failure on the part
of the Presiding Officer to put his signature on those ballot
papers so as to satisfy the requirement of law. The proviso,
once it is applicable, has also a mandate that the ballot paper
is not to be rejected. We, therefore, hold that the ballot papers
were not liable to be rejected as the proviso applied and the
High Court, in our opinion, came to the correct conclusion in
counting these ballot papers and giving credit thereof to
Respondent 1.’
It is pertinent to note that it is nobody’s case that 824 ballot papers
were spurious. The present one is not a case of booth-capturing or
rigging. In an election dispute, there are not the candidates alone
who are the persons interested. In a democratic set-up, as is ours,
in an election, the fate of the whole constituency is at stake and
every voter and every citizen has, therefore, an interest in that
candidate being returned to assembly who has secured the majority
of the valid votes. An election dispute cannot be decided on
concessions contrary to law. A defect in the ballot papers in the light
of Rule 38(1) read with Rule 56(2)(h) having been detected, the
issue had to be decided by the satisfaction of the Returning Officer.
The concession given by candidates or their election agents
submitting to a decision arrived at by the Returning Officer in
accordance with law may come in the way of that candidate turning
around and disputing a doubtful position of law taken as resolved
and conceded or accepted. In an election dispute, a consensus
contrary to law or a failure to discharge statutory obligation cast on
Page No.# 32/34
an election officer which has resulted in prejudicing the result of the
election, cannot ipso facto claim immunity from challenge. In the
present case the Returning Officer has clearly failed in discharging
his obligation cast by the first proviso below clauses (g) and (h) of
sub-rule (2) of Rule 56. Disagreeing with the High Court, therefore,
we hold that these 824 ballot papers should have been included for
the purpose of counting.”
42.
From a perusal of the above quoted paragraph, it would be
seen that in an election dispute, a concession given before the
Returning Officer which is contrary to law or a failure to
discharge statutory obligation cast on an election officer cannot
ipso facto be claimed as an immunity from challenge. In the
instant case, merely because the Respondent No.6 had agreed to
the ballot paper in question which had the vote mark almost in
the middle between the Petitioner and the Respondent No.6 to
be counted in favour of the Petitioner and thereby agreed to the
toss of coin, does not, in the opinion of this Court operate as a
waiver or an estoppel on the part of the Respondent No.6 to
challenge the same under Section 11 of the Act of 1994 in as
much as there was a failure of a statutory obligation cast upon
the Officer authorized by the Deputy Commissioner to exercise
powers in terms with Rule 46(7)(b) and (c) of the Rules of 1995.
43.
Considering the above, this Court does not find that the
Page No.# 33/34
impugned order dated 27.08.2025 calls for any interference,
more so as nothing was shown which would reveal that the
impugned order dated 27.08.2025 was perverse or contrary to
law.
44. In the backdrop of the above, this Court now finds it relevant
to take note of WP(C) No.5204/2026. This writ petition is the
fallout of the withdrawal of WP(C) No.2359/2026.
45.
At the cost of repetition, this Court finds it pertinent to
observe that in WP(C) No.2359/2026, the Petitioner had sought a
direction that she should be permitted to carry out the statutory
functions of the President which admittedly the Petitioner was
not permitted to do. The withdrawal of the said writ petition had
resulted in the Petitioner giving up the relief sought for to the
effect that the Petitioner should be permitted to exercise the
statutory powers of the President. It is therefore the opinion of
this Court that the impugned order dated 17.09.2026 do not
appear to be contrary.
46.
Be that as it may, this Court having upheld the order dated
27.08.2025 whereby the Respondent No.6 was declared to be
the President of the Umarpur Gaon Panchayat, no further
deliberation is required in respect of WP(C) No.5204/2026.
47. Accordingly, both the writ petitions stand disposed of with the
Page No.# 34/34
following observations and directions:(i) This Court, in exercise of the powers of judicial review
finds no ground to interfere with the order dated
27.08.2025 passed by the District Commissioner, Sribhumi.
(ii) The Writ Petition being WP(C) No.5253/2025 is meritless,
and accordingly, stands dismissed.
(iii) In view of the order dated 27.08.2025 passed by the
District Commissioner, Sribhumi not being interfered with,
nothing remains in WP(C) No.5204/2026. Accordingly, this
Court therefore closes the writ petition being WP(C)
No.5204/2026
by
vacating
the
interim
22.09.2026.
(iv) There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Pradip Kumar Kalita
Comparing Assistant
Date: 2026.10.16 10:45:54 +05'30'
order
dated
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review