Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Shampa Dutt (Paul)
WPA 26551 of 2025
Axis Bank Limited
Vs
Central Government Industrial Tribunal, Kolkata & Ors.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Sukrit Mukherjee,
Mr. Shuvojeet Gupta,
Mr. Rajat Subhra Das.
For the Respondent no. 3
:
Mr. Susanto Pal,
Mr. Mrinal Kanti Sardar.
For the Respondent no. 4
:
Mr. Amritam Mandal.
Judgment reserved on
:
08.07.2026
Judgment delivered on
:
28.07.2026
Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.:
1.
The writ application has been preferred challenging an ex parte award
dated 06.06.2024, passed by the learned Presiding Officer, Central
Government Tribunal, Kolkata.
2.
Vide the impugned order the learned Tribunal directed as follows:“Therefore, the contractor employers are bound to pay
conveyance
allowance,
gun
allowance
and
special
allowance which were earlier paid to those security
personnel deployed by them in the establishment of
principal employer Axis Bank Ltd. from the date they have
stopped payment unilaterally or at the direction of the
principal employer till those security personnel worked for
them in the establishment of the Principal Employer.
In case those contractors fail to pay such due to those
security guards deployed by them in the establishment of
Axis Bank Ltd., then in view of provisions of section 21(4) of
Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970 the
principal employer who is the ultimate user of the service of
those security guards are bound to pay the arrears due to
those security guards employed by it through different
contractors
after
verification
of
their
service
in
its
establishment and also after verifying their wage slips of
September, 2008 onwards till it took their services and
recover the same from its contractors from the pending bills,
if any, provided it had already paid those allowances to the
contractors. In case if it had not paid towards such
allowances to its contractors then it is bound to make
payment of arrear of conveyance allowance, gun allowance
and special allowance to all the security personnel engaged
by it through the above mentioned contractors for the period
of contract it had with them or till the period those security
personnel rendered service to its establishment.
Accordingly, Reference no. 39 of 2015 is allowed with
the finding that unilateral decision of the contractor
employers as well as principal employer Axis Bank Ltd.
without complying with the mandatory provisions of section
9-A of I.D. Act, in effecting changes in the service conditions
of contractor employees by stopping payment of conveyance
allowance, gun allowance and special allowance is held to
be illegal and they are bound to pay the dues of those
workmen from the date, the payment was stopped till their
service in the establishment of the Axis Bank Ltd.
Both the principal employer and contractor employers
are directed to make payment of the above due within three
months from the date hereof failing which the union shall be
at liberty to recover the same according to law.”
3.
The petitioner‟s case in the present writ application is that the petitioner
was established in 1993 and is one of the India‟s largest private sector
banks.
4.
In and around 2008, the petitioner has executed several service
agreements with the respondent nos. 4 and 7 respectively (hereinafter
referred to as the “said agreements”) for providing armed guards and
security services for certain bank branches and ATMs in Kolkata.
5.
In connection with the payment of wages to the workmen, the roles and
responsibilities of the petitioner and the contractors are clearly defined
between the parties. Whilst the petitioner is responsible for the clearing
monthly invoices raised by the contractors which is inclusive of the wages
payable to the workmen and it is the contractors who are responsible to
make the payments of wages to the individual workman.
6.
The workmen employed under the agreements by the contractors had
claimed that since November 4, 2008, the contractors have denied
allegedly the payment of (i) conveyance allowance, (ii) gun allowance and
(iii) special allowance to the workmen without any prior notice or
intimation of doing so, effectively stopping the payment of wages to the
workmen from the month of October 2008. It is stated that the petitioner
has cleared all the invoices raised by the contractors for the said period till
now.
7.
The workmen allegedly attempted to resolve the matter by way of
negotiations, failing which the workmen, represented by the respondent
no. 3 approached the respondent no. 2, by way of a letter dated February
14, 2012, but the petitioner was not a party to the conciliation proceedings
as the petitioner never received any summons or notice in connection with
the conciliation proceedings or any claims made by the workmen and thus
the petitioner was at the time, unaware of any concerns raised by the
workmen in connection with their wages. Nonetheless, the aforementioned
conciliation proceedings failed, and a failure report dated 12.05.2015 was
prepared and filed by the Conciliation Officer.
8.
Aggrieved by such failure, respondent no. 3 on behalf of the workmen
approached the Learned Tribunal and filed a statement of claim being
reference No. 39 of 2015, approximately 5 years after the failure report was
filed by the Conciliation Officer.
9.
It is the further case of the petitioner that at the time of the conciliation
proceeding and the Case No. 39 of 2015, the petitioner was uninformed,
unaware and did not receive the summons/notices and papers of: (i) Claim
filed by the workmen before the Conciliation Officer in 2012, (ii) Minutes of
the conciliation proceedings conducted between the workmen and the
contractors, (iii) Failure Report prepared and filed by the Conciliation
Officer dated 12.05.2015.
10. It is the further case of the petitioner that the petitioner was never
awarded the opportunity to be present and attend the conciliation
proceedings or the proceedings of Case No. 39 of 2015 and the petitioner
was unable to present any written statement or arguments.
11. The petitioner then received a letter from respondent no. 2 dated
23.04.2025 (hereinafter referred to as the "ALC Letter") seeking execution
of the impugned Award on 16.05.2025. 16.05.2025.
12. Hence, the writ application challenging the impugned award on the ground
that the learned Tribunal failed to consider the unexplained delay on the
part of the respondent no. 3/Union and also failing to explain the
maintainability of the dispute on the ground of delay.
13. It is the specific case of the petitioner that the petitioner is merely the
principal employer who had entered into contractual arrangement with the
concerned contractor for the provision of manpower and security services
at designated bank branches and ATMs. The role of the petitioner, as
Principal Employer, was confined to making payments in accordance with
the invoices raised by the contractors, in consideration of the services
rendered under the respective service agreements.
14. The petitioner had no role to play, nor any obligation, be it contractual or
statutory, in relation to the manner in which the consideration amount
received by the contractors was distributed or apportioned among the
individual contract workmen engaged by them.
15. The obligation of the petitioner, as well as its legal responsibility under
applicable law, is restricted to timely clearing of the invoices duly raised by
the contractors. Beyond this, the obligation to ensure the payment of
wages to the contract workmen lies solely and squarely upon the
contractors, as per the statutory scheme governing contract labour, and in
particular under Section 21 of the Contract Labour (Regulation and
Abolition) Act, 1970 (hereinafter referred to as the "CLRA Act").
16. It is settled law, as reiterated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in multiple
pronouncements, that the liability of the Principal Employer under Section
21(4) of the CLRA Act is triggered only in the event of default by the
contractor in payment of the wages of the contract workmen and only
upon satisfaction of the procedural requirements prescribed therein. Even
then, such liability is limited in scope and does not extend to supervising
or ensuring the exact manner in which the wages or allowances are
calculated or disbursed by the contractor to its workmen.
17. There exists no provision either under the CLRA Act or the rules framed
thereunder which casts an obligation upon the Principal Employer to
ascertain or verify the internal wage breakups or component-wise
structure of the remuneration paid by the contractor. In the absence of
any
statutory
mandate
or
contractual
stipulation
imposing
such
responsibility, the petitioner cannot be held liable for any alleged shortfall
or deficiency in the payment of specific allowances (such as conveyance,
gun allowance, or special allowance) by the contractor to its workmen.
18. As such, the petitioner submits that they have no liability financial or
otherwise for non-payment of certain components which do not form part
of the wages of the workmen by the contractors to its employees. Such
liability is entirely on the contractors and not the principal employer.
19. It is further submitted that that any liability of the petitioner, as principal
employer, to make payment of the claimed allowances, if at all, can only
arise in a secondary or residual capacity, and strictly in accordance with
the limited framework prescribed under Section 21(4) of the Contract
Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1970.
20. It is contended that the learned Tribunal has committed an error in
fastening liability upon the petitioner for the payment of certain
allowances, namely conveyance allowance, gun allowance, and special
allowance, which admittedly do not fall within the statutory definition of
"wages" as contemplated under the Payment of Wages Act, 1936.
Consequently, such allowances fall outside the scope of the petitioner's
limited and conditional liability under Section 21(4) of the CLRA Act.
21. Hence, the writ application praying for setting aside of the said impugned
award.
22. The learned Tribunal while deciding the reference considered the following
issues:“Whether the action of M/s. S & IB Service Pvt. Ltd., M/s.
PVS Ltd., M/s. Orion Security Solutions and M/s. G4S
Ltd., contractors of Axis Bank Ltd. is justified in
denying (i) Conveyance Allowance, (ii) Gun Allowance
and (iii) Special Allowance to the contractual workmen
is legal and/or justified? If not, what relief the workmen
are entitled.”
23. The following findings of the learned Tribunal being relevant are
reproduced herein:“In the present case the dispute is between the employees of
the contractors with the contractor employers engaged by the
Axis Bank Ltd. for supply of man power. The establishment
involved in the present case is the Axis Bank Ltd, and
principal employer is also the Axis Bank Ltd. That in view of
the section 2(a) (i) of the 1.D. Act, 1947 the appropriate
Government in relation to any dispute concerning bank is the
Central Govt. and not the State Govt. Further, in view of
proviso of section 2 (a) (ii) of the Act of 1947, in case of a
dispute between a contractor and the contract labour
employed
through
the
contactor
in
any
industrial
establishment where such dispute first arose, the appropriate
Government shall be the Central Government which has
control over such industrial establishment. Therefore, in view
of section 2 (a) (i) and (ii) the appropriate Government who
can make reference of an industrial dispute concerning a
bank to a Tribunal or Labour Court is the Central Government
and not State Government as alleged by both the contesting
contractor employers. Therefore, this Tribunal holds that it
has ample jurisdiction to entertain the present reference.
Whether the contractor employers are justified in
denying conveyance allowance, gun allowance and special
allowance to the security personnel deployed by them in the
establishment of Axis Bank Ltd. and whether the employer
unilaterally stopped payment of those allowances mentioned
above?”
24. The tribunal then observed as follows:“Thus, from such admission made by M.W.1 it proves
the employees of contractor M/s. S & IB Services Pvt. Ltd.
deployed in the establishment of Axis Bank Ltd. were paid
conveyance
allowance,
gun
allowance
and
special
allowance till September, 2008 and thereafter it has
stopped payment of such allowances.
Nothing has come on record to show that payment of
such allowances was stopped by M/s. S & IB Services Pvt.
Ltd. on the basis of settlement it had with the workmen
concerned or the union of its workmen or after serving 21
days' notice to the concerned workmen or to the concerned
union as required u/s 9-A of the I.D. Act as stoppage of
allowances also amounts to change in condition of service or
at the direction of the Principal Employer.
Thus, from such report of ALC (C), Kolkata it appears
the conveyance allowance and special allowance were paid
earlier at the rate of Rs.175/- was stopped from the month
of October, 2006 and not from October, 2008 as contended
by the union in its claim statement. It further shows that
union has demanded payment of conveyance allowance,
special allowance and gun allowance to the contractual
workmen.
Further, it discloses the contractor employers
namely M/s. S & IB Services Pvt. Ltd., M/s. PVS Ltd.
and M/s. G4S Ltd. all contractors of Axis Bank Ltd. have
agreed to make difference payment, if there is any, for the
period from October, 2009 to December, 2009 and agreed to
pay
special
allowance
and
gun
allowance
provided
principal employer reimburse the same.”
In the present case the dispute is in between the
security guards and their employers who have deployed
them to work at different branches and ATMs of Axis Bank
situated in West Bengal and as such they are entitled to get
minimum rate of wages as fixed by the State Government.
Moreover, section 2 (i) of Payment of Wages Act, 1936
provides
that
appropriate
Government
in
relation
to
Railway, Air Transport Services, Mines and Oil Fields is the
Central Government and in relation to all other cases the
State Government. Therefore, the contractors' employees of
Axis Bank are entitled to Minimum Rate of Wages fixed by
the State Government of West Bengal from time to time.
It is the case of the union that conveyance allowance,
gun allowance and special allowance were integral part of
their wages under Payment of Wages Act and which cannot
be withdrawn by the employer unilaterally.”
25. The learned Tribunal considering the definition of the term „wages‟ as
defined in Section 2(vi) of the Payment of Wages Act, 1936 held as follows:“Therefore, on plain reading of the definition of wages as
provided in the Act of 1936, it appears the wages does not
include travelling allowances or the value of any travelling
concession.
Therefore,
this
Tribunal
is
of
view
that
conveyance allowance does not form an integral part of
wages. That apart nothing has come to prove that gun
allowance und special allowance too form part of basic
wages.
Be that as it may, it is admitted fact that contractor
employer S & IB had withdrawn conveyance allowance, gun
allowance and special allowance from the month of October
2008 onwards
without prior notice
to
the
workmen
concerned or to their union. That in view of provisions of
section 9-A of the Industrial Disputes Act, no emplover who
proposed to effect any change in the condition of service
applicable to any workman in respect of any matter
specified in fourth schedule has to give 21 days' notice to the
workmen or to the union.
However, in view of the provision of section 9-A of the I.D.
Act both the employers are bound to give prior notice in
respect of any change in condition of service which includes
allowances also, when the contractor employer has failed to
produce any settlement it had with the workmen or their
union for withdrawal of such allowances. The employers
cannot wriggle out of the provisions of section 9-A of the I.D.
Act, 1947.
“Therefore, the contractor employers are bound to pay
conveyance
allowance,
gun
allowance
and
special
allowance which were earlier paid to those security
personnel deployed by them in the establishment of
principal employer Axis Bank Ltd. from the date they have
stopped payment unilaterally or at the direction of the
principal employer till those security personnel worked for
them in the establishment of the Principal Employer.
In case those contractors fail to pay such due to those
security guards deployed by them in the establishment of
Axis Bank Ltd., then in view of provisions of section 21(4) of
Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970 the
principal employer who is the ultimate user of the service of
those security guards are bound to pay the arrears due to
those security guards employed by it through different
contractors
after
verification
of
their
service
in
its
establishment and also after verifying their wage slips of
September, 2008 onwards till it took their services and
recover the same from its contractors from the pending bills,
if any, provided it had already paid those allowances to the
contractors. In case if it had not paid towards such
allowances to its contractors then it is bound to make
payment of arrear of conveyance allowance, gun allowance
and special allowance to all the security personnel engaged
by it through the above mentioned contractors for the period
of contract it had with them or till the period those security
personnel rendered service to its establishment.
Accordingly, Reference no. 39 of 2015 is allowed with the
finding that unilateral decision of the contractor employers
as well as principal employer Axis Bank Ltd. without
complying with the mandatory provisions of section 9-A of
I.D. Act, in effecting changes in the service conditions of
contractor employees by stopping payment of conveyance
allowance, gun allowance and special allowance is held to
be illegal and they are bound to pay the dues of those
workmen from the date, the payment was stopped till their
service in the establishment of the Axis Bank Ltd.
Both the principal employer and contractor employers are
directed to make payment of the above due within three
months from the date hereof failing which the union shall be
at liberty to recover the same according to law.”
26. Written notes have been filed by the parties wherein the petitioner has
argued that the impugned order, not being in accordance with law, is
liable to be set aside.
27. The petitioner has relied upon the following judgments in support of their
contention, regarding delay:(i)
Ramkrishan Ramnath Bidi Manufacturing vs. Presiding
Officer reported in 1962 SCC OnLine Bom 52;
(ii)
Shalimar Works Ltd. vs. Workmen reported in AIR 1959 SC
1217;
(iii) Vazir Sultan Tobacco Co. Ltd. vs. State of A.P. reported in
(1964) 1 LLJ 622 (AP);
(iv)
Nedungadi Bank Ltd. vs. K.P. Madhavankutty (2000) 2 SCC
455;
(v)
Sapan Kumar Pandit vs. U.P. SEB, (2001) 6 SCC 222;
(vi)
Prabhakar vs. Joint Director, Sericulture Deptt. & Anr., (2015)
15 SCC 1;
28. The delay in this case, as alleged, is not long or unreasonable and
considering the nature of issues involved herein, the claim being a
continuing one, the plea of delay cannot be applied herein, to deny the
legitimate claim if any of the workmen.
29. The Opposite party in the present case on filing their written notes has
supported the impugned award and has relied upon the judgment of this
Court passed in WPO 387 of 2025 on 19.06.2025 in HDFC Bank Ltd.
vs. The Union of India & Ors., wherein this Court has held as follows:“5.
The petitioner/company’s contention against the
said award is as follows:-
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
v)
vi)
The concept of "industrial dispute" does not
recognize a dispute between a principal employer
and a contractor's employee, and in the instant
proceeding, it is the admitted case of all the parties
that the concerned workmen are contract labours.
Restructurisation of wages in an employeremployee contract cannot attract an industrial
dispute between a principal employer and the
contract labours, if at all.
That decision of the service providers to stop
Special Allowance and Gun Allowance and
restructurised payment by making additional
release of salary through revision cannot be the
subject matter of an industrial dispute between the
bank and the trade union representing the
contractors' employees.
There can be no scope of violation of Section 9A of
the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 at the behest of
the petitioner bank against the employees of the
service providers since admittedly there has been
no
establishment
of
employer
employee
relationship between the bank and the employees
of the contractors.
The learned Tribunal failed to appreciate that
principal employer cannot give notice under Section
9A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, and hence
the very foundation of passing the award and
granting relief was erroneous and perverse.
The learned Tribunal also failed to appreciate that
the provisions of Section 21(4) of the Contract
Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970 has no
manner of application in the facts and
circumstances of the case.
6.
Admittedly, the petitioner Bank herein is the principal
employer.
7.
The referee order dated 3rd July, 2025 states the
opinion “that an industrial dispute exists
between the employers in relation to the
management of M/s. S & IB Services Pvt. Ltd.,
and their workmen. …”
8. The “employers” in relation to the management of
M/s. S & IB Services Pvt. Ltd. includes the principal
employer being the petitioner/Bank herein, which has
admittedly employed the said contractors.
9. The management of M/s. S & IB Services Pvt. Ltd. is
the contractor, whereas the petitioner/Bank herein is
the principal employer and the learned Tribunal
rightly held that the workers through their contractor
were in the service of the petitioner/Bank carrying out
all duties related to the smooth functioning of the
Bank.
10. The service conditions of the workers were also
as per the requirement of the petitioner/bank
and not the contractor through whom the
workers were employed and as such any change
in service condition is the change in
requirement of the petitioner/Bank, which
directly effects the workers, who carried out
and/or put in such service.
11. The denial of (i) Gun Allowance, (ii) Special Allowance
and (iii) Conveyance Allowance to the said contractual
workers is directly related to the services which are
being specifically provided by the workers only to the
petitioner Bank and none else.
12. About the application of Section 9A of the Act. Section
9A of the I.D. Act provides as follows:“9A. Notice of change.
-No employer, who proposes to effect any change in
the conditions of service applicable to any workman
in respect of any matter specified in the Fourth
Schedule, shall effect such change,
-(a) without giving to the workmen likely to be
affected by such change a notice in the
prescribed manner of the nature of the change
proposed to be effected; or
(b)
within twenty-one days of giving such notice:
Provided that no notice shall be required for
effecting any such change-
(a)
(b)
where the change is effected in pursuance of
any [settlement or award] [ Substituted by Act
46 of 1982, Section 6, for certain words (w.e.f.
21.8.1984).]; or
where the workmen likely to be affected by the
change are persons to whom the Fundamental
and Supplementary Rules, Civil Services
(Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, Civil
Services (Temporary Service) Rules, Revised
Leave Rules, Civil Service Regulations, Civilians
in Defence Services (Classification, Control and
Appeal) Rules or the Indian Railway
Establishment Code or any other rules or
regulations that may be notified in this behalf
by the appropriate Government in the Official
Gazette, apply.”
13. The copies of “Service Agreement” between the
Bank (principal employer) and the contractors clearly
show that the agreements relate to the services to be
provided to the petitioner/Bank, the principal
employer herein and as such any change in service
conditions done in this case is also as per
requirement of the petitioner/Bank, the principal
employer, who as per agreement has changed the
service conditions of the workers herein and is thus
responsible, as rightly held by the Tribunal.
14. In the present case the “employer” herein is the
“principal employer” as the change in the condition of
service herein is directly related to the “principal
employer” who exclusively availed of such service.
The contractor herein is only the provider and is
bound by the terms and conditions imposed by the
“principal employer”, i.e., petitioner/Bank herein and
the petitioner is thus liable under Section 9A of the
Act, which was rightly held by the Tribunal.
15. Regarding the contention that the relief granted is
beyond the reference, as it does not include the
petitioner/Bank, it is observed that “Employer of the
Management of ...” includes the petitioner/Bank who
has employed the workers through the contractors for
solely doing the duties of Bank.
16. Regarding the part of the reference “if not, what relief
the workmen are entitled to”, the Tribunal rightly
applied Section 21(4) of the contract to provide relief
prayed/entitled for/to and found fit to give to the
workers and there is thus no irregularity in the said
order.
17. The reference relates to the year 2015. Award was
passed in 2024. 10 (ten) long years have passed,
and the workers are still fighting for their lawful dues
under a beneficial legislation. End of justice requires
immediate implementation of the award dated 20th
August, 2024.
18. The writ petition (WPO/387/2025) is thus dismissed.
The award of the Tribunal under challenge be
implemented within six weeks from the date of this
order. All dues be paid with interest @ 10% per
annum till date of payment as directed.
19. In case this order is not complied with, as directed, the
dues will have to be paid with enhanced interest @
18% per annum till payment.”
30. The status of the petitioner Bank herein being similar to the petitioner
Bank in HDFC Bank (Supra) and the issue too being exactly similar in
both these cases, the views of this Court in HDFC Bank (Supra) will apply
squarely in the present case.
31. Admittedly, the petitioner Bank herein is the principal employer.
32. The “employers” in relation to the management of the contractors being
the respondents no. 4 to 7 herein includes the principal employer being
the petitioner/Bank herein, which has admittedly employed the said
contractors.
33. The managements of the respondents no. 4 to 7 herein are the
contractors, whereas the petitioner/Bank herein is the principal employer
and the learned Tribunal rightly held that the workers through their
contractors were in the service of the petitioner/Bank carrying out all
duties related to the smooth functioning of the Bank.
34. The service conditions of the workers were also as per the
requirement of the petitioner/bank and not the contractors through
whom the workers were employed and as such any change in service
condition is the change in requirement of the petitioner/Bank, which
directly effects the workers, who carried out and/or put in such
service.
35. The denial of (i) Gun Allowance, (ii) Special Allowance and (iii) Conveyance
Allowance to the said contractual workers is directly related to the services
which are being specifically provided by the workers only to the petitioner
Bank and none else.
36. About the application of Section 9A of the Act. Section 9A of the I.D. Act
provides as follows:“9A. Notice of change.
-No employer, who proposes to effect any change in the conditions of
service applicable to any workman in respect of any matter specified in the
Fourth Schedule, shall effect such change,
-(a) without giving to the workmen likely to be affected by such change a
notice in the prescribed manner of the nature of the change proposed to
be effected; or
(b) within twenty-one days of giving such notice:
Provided that no notice shall be required for effecting any such change-
(a) where the change is effected in pursuance of any [settlement or
award] [ Substituted by Act 46 of 1982, Section 6, for certain
words (w.e.f. 21.8.1984).]; or
(b) where the workmen likely to be affected by the change are
persons to whom the Fundamental and Supplementary Rules,
Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, Civil
Services (Temporary Service) Rules, Revised Leave Rules, Civil
Service Regulations, Civilians in Defence Services (Classification,
Control and Appeal) Rules or the Indian Railway Establishment
Code or any other rules or regulations that may be notified in this
behalf by the appropriate Government in the Official Gazette,
apply.”
37. The copies of “Service Agreement” between the Bank (principal
employer) and the contractors clearly show that the agreements relate to
the services to be provided to the petitioner/Bank, the principal employer
herein and as such any change in service conditions done in this case is
also as per requirement of the petitioner/Bank, the principal employer,
who as per agreement has changed the service conditions of the workers
herein and is thus responsible, as rightly held by the Tribunal.
38. In the present case the “employer” herein is the “principal employer” as
the change in the condition of service herein is directly related to the
“principal employer” who exclusively availed of such service. The
contractors herein are only the provider and are bound by the terms and
conditions imposed by the “principal employer”, i.e., petitioner/Bank
herein and the petitioner is thus liable under Section 9A of the Act, which
was rightly held by the Tribunal.
39. Regarding the contention that the relief granted is beyond the reference,
as it does not include the petitioner/Bank, it is observed that “Employer
of the Management of ...” includes the petitioner/Bank who has
employed the workers through the contractors for solely doing the
duties of Bank.
40. Regarding the part of the reference “if not, what relief the workmen are
entitled to”, the Tribunal rightly applied Section 21(4) of the contract to
provide relief prayed/entitled for/to and found fit to give to the workers
and there is thus no irregularity in the said order.
41. The reference relates to the year 2015. Award was passed in 2024. 10
(ten) long years have passed, and the workers are still fighting for their
lawful dues under a beneficial legislation. Ends of justice requires
immediate implementation of the award dated 20th August, 2024.
42. The writ petition (WPO/387/2025) is thus dismissed. The award of the
Tribunal under challenge be implemented within six weeks from the date
of this order. All dues be paid with interest @ 10% per annum till date of
payment as directed.
43. In case this order is not complied with, as directed, the dues will have to
be paid with enhanced interest @ 18% per annum till payment.
44. Writ application stands disposed of.
45. Applications, if any, connected thereto stand disposed of consequently.
46. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
47. Photostat certified copy of this Judgment, if applied for, be given to the
parties on priority basis upon compliance of all formalities.
(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review