Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
"
##
$%& $ ' # ()
*$
(
+
Digitally signed
by SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!
"
#
$"
%
&
"
-2-
'($
"
#
)'
")")
#
* $+ ") ,
' $
' $
+
-") "
) ))) -
' $
'
') ))) -
)) ))) -
#
.
.
/
#
#
"
012 344536 12 71859:57 3;31<2: :05 =>7;?5<: *@ 9*<A19:1*<
3<7 *8758 *@ 25<:5<95 73:57 )'
* $+ ") , BC :05
")") 432257 1<
5221*<2 #>7;5 3:
363B>83;1
-3-
@*8 B85A1:C D:05
*>8:E
F0585BC :05
*>8:
9*<A19:57 :05 399>257 3445663<: @*8 :05 *@@5<952 4><1203B65
><758
59:1*<2 ' $ ' $
"
"
)
3B817;57
*@
3<7
@39:2
*@
59:1*< + *@
:05
") , B5:F55< )".))-)".') 4 ? 3:
*6*<C
363B>83;1 A19:1?-
9:
5F
:03:
*<
3;03A5<783
B51<; 3 ?1<*8 ;186 3;57 3B*>:
) C5382 93?5 :* :05 20*4 *@ 399>257 :* B>C 90*9*63:52 @*8
-
: :03: :1?5 :05 399>257 936657 058 1<2175 :05 20*4 *<
:05 485:5G: *@ ;1A1<; 90*9*63:52 BC *B258A1<; :03: <*B*7C F585
<538 :05 20*4
05853@:58 :05 399>257 25G>366C 3B>257 058 BC
485221<; B8532: 3<7 B>::*9H2 @*891B6C
1<2175 :05 20*4
@566 7*F<
3:58
05 A19:1? BC 29853?1<;
:05 ?*:058 *@ A19:1? 1 5
" B8*>;0: 058 :* :05 0*>25 3<7 *< 5<I>18C
1<@*8?57 :05 39: *@ 399>257
B5@*85
:05
>B25I>5<:6C
2 2>90 205 6*7;57 :05 9*?4631<:
8524*<75<:- *6195
85;12:5857 BC
+ 1<
:05
:05 A19:1?
81?5
*+
G "
F0190
") , 32 458
8524*<75<:- *6195
F32
G +
9*<7>9:57
:05
1<A52:1;3:1*< 3<7 6317 9038;5 2055: 3;31<2: :05 399>257 @*8 :05
@*8 :05 *@@5<952 4><1203B65 ><758
3<7
59:1*<2 + 3<7
) *@
59:1*<2 ' $ ' $
*@
9: B5@*85 :05 8136
*>8:
-4-
'
* 48*A5 :05 9038;52 65A5657 3;31<2: :05 399>257
B5@*85 :05
F1:<52252 32
+
*>8:
:05 48*259>:1*< 1< :*:36 5G3?1<57 ,
:* , 3<7 ?38H57 + 7*9>?5<:2 32
G2
:*
05 399>257 <51:058 5G3?1<57 3<C F1:<522 *< 012 B5036@
<*8 ?38H57 3<C 7*9>?5<:2
:05
$
< 322522?5<: *@ *836 3<7 7*9>?5<:38C 5A175<95
*>8:
4><1203B65 ><758
9:
3<7
9*<A19:57
:05
399>257
:05
59:1*<2 ' $ ' $
*@
3<7
25<:5<957
:*
><758;*
01?
1?4812*<?5<: @*8 3 4581*7 *@
@*8
*@@5<952
59:1*< + *@
81;*8*>2
C5382 3<7 :* 43C 3 @1<5 *@
) ))) - 1< 75@3>6: *@ 43C?5<: *@ @1<5 :* ><758;* 21?465
1?4812*<?5<: @*8 3 4581*7 *@
?*<:02 @*8 :05 *@@5<95
4><1203B65 ><758
8 F
9:
59:1*< ' $ *@
59:1*< + *@
5 362* 25<:5<957 :* ><758;* 81;*8*>2 1?4812*<?5<: @*8 3
4581*7 *@ ' C5382 3<7 :* 43C 3 @1<5 *@ ') ))) - 1< 75@3>6: *@
43C?5<: *@ @1<5 :* ><758;* 21?465 1?4812*<?5<: @*8 3 4581*7
*@
C538 @*8 :05 *@@5<95 4><1203B65 ><758
>8:058
9*<9>885<:6C
1< :012 344536
71859:57
:03:
:05
59:1*< ' $
25<:5<952
20366
*@
8><
05 2317 =>7;?5<: 12 903665<;57 BC :05 399>257
-5-
5387 6538<57 9*><256 @*8 :05 3445663<:
9*><256 @*8 8524*<75<:
8524*<75<:
- :3:5 3<7 6538<57 9*><256 @*8
*"
438:
9*><256
*
6538<57
@*8
:05
@8*?
>8;1<;
3445663<:
25A5836
9*<:5<:1*<
481?3816C
9*<:5<757
6538<57
:03:
:05
=>7;?5<: ><758 :012 344536 2>@@582 @8*? 458A5821:C 3<7
1665;361:C 21<95 :05 8136
81;0: 4582459:1A5
*>8: @31657 34485913:5 :05 5A175<95 1< 3
99*871<; :* 01?
:05 399>257 F32 <*:
8><<1<; 3 48*A121*<36 2:*85 F0585 90*9*63:52 9*>67 B5 B*>;0:
: 032 9*?5 *< 859*87 :03: :05 399>257 F32 8><<1<; 3 G58*G
20*4 3<7 <* I>52:1*< *@
90*9*63:52
(
A121:1<; 3 20*4 *@ 399>257 :* B>C
2 2>90 :05 ;5<5212 *@ :05 9325 1:256@ 12 7*>B:@>6
362*
9*<:5<757
:03:
:0585
?3:58136
71298543<9152 1< :05 5A175<95 *@
-A19:1?
4385<:2 1< 852459: *@ :05 1<9175<:
99*871<; :* :05 6538<57
9*><256
2 " 3<7 $-058
-A19:1? 032 2:3:57 :03: 205 037 ;*<5 :* 20*4 *@
399>257 3<7 F05< :05 399>257 ?*652:57 205 @566 7*F< 1< :05
20*4
>: 32 458
" :05 A19:1? F5<: :* :05 20*4 *@ 399>257
3<7 717 <*: 85:>8< @*8 3 4581*7 *@
F5<: <538 :05 20*4 3: :03: :1?5
)-
?1<>:52 32 2>90 205
F32 29853?1<; 1<2175
-6-
:05 20*4 3<7 @566 7*F<
>8:058
3:58
205 B8*>;0: 058 :* 0*?5
$ 032 93:5;*819366C 37?1::57 :03: :0585 385
852175<:136 0*>25 38*><7 :05 20*4 3<7 1< @8*<: *@ :05 20*4
:0585 12 3 8*37 3<7 ?3<C A5019652 385 46C1<; *< :05 8*37
99*871<; :* :05 653<57 9*><256 :05 9*?4631<3<: 6*7;57 :05
@3625 9*?4631<: @*8 :05 8532*< :03: :05 399>257 75<157 :* 65<7
:05 ;8*958152 *< 98571: B3212 :* :05 9*?4631<3<:
0525 32459:2
*@ :05 ?3::58 F585 <*: 48*4586C 34485913:57 BC :05
*>8:
99*871<;6C 05 483C2 :* 366*F :05 344536 BC 25::1<; 32175 :05
1?4>;<57 =>7;?5<: 432257 BC :05 8136
+
6538<57
*>8:
9*<:5<757 :03: :05
*>8: 3@:58 ?5:19>6*>26C 5G3?1<1<; :05 5A175<95 *< 859*87
81;0:6C 9*<A19:57 :05 399>257 1< 3 F566 8532*<57 =>7;?5<:
F0190 7*52 <*: 9366 @*8 3<C 1<:58@585<95 3: :05 03<72 *@ :012
*>8:
9*<:5<757
:03:
:05
5A175<95
*@
-A19:1?
93:5;*819366C 52:3B612057 :03: :05 399>257 03832257 058 25G>366C
BC ?*652:1<; 058
>8:058
9*88*B*83:52 :05 :52:1?*<C *@
@3:058 *@ A19:1?
:05 5A175<95 *@
965386C
2 " 3<7 $ 1 5
?*:058 3<7
0585 12 <* 8532*< @*8
F0* 3;57 3B*>:
) C5382 *67 90167 :* ?3H5 @3625 3665;3:1*< 3;31<2: :05 399>257
-7-
*85*A58
:05 F1:<522 @*8 24*: ?303J38- G $ 2>44*8:57
:05 9325 *@ 48*259>:1*< 032 754*257 :03: :05 399>257 F32
8><<1<; 3 H183<1 20*4
><7124>:576C
>8:058
:05 3;5 *@ :05 A19:1? 12
) C5382 3: :05 :1?5 *@ 1<9175<: 32 458 :05
18:0 958:1@193:5 3:
G
< 2>90 9189>?2:3<95 :05
3:5 *@
5221*<2
*>8: 81;0:6C 34485913:57 :05 5A175<95 3<7 9*<A19:57 :05
399>257 @*8 :05 9038;52 65A5657 3;31<2: 01?
99*871<;6C 05
483C2 :* 712?122 :05 344536 BC 9*<@18?1<; :05 1?4>;<57
=>7;?5<: 432257 :05 8136
,
*>8:
03A5 ;1A5< ?C 3<G1*>2 9*<217583:1*< B*:0 *< :05
2>B?1221*<2 ?375 BC :05 6538<57 9*><256 @*8 :05 852459:1A5
438:152 3<7 458>257 :05 7*9>?5<:2 ?375 3A3163B65 B5@*85 :012
*>8:
)
2 9*>67 B5 ;3:05857 @8*? 859*872 :* 48*A5 :05
3;5 *@ :05 A19:1? :03: 205 F32 ?1<*8 1 5
3;57 3B*>:
3:
:05
:1?5
*@
1<9175<:
48*259>:1*< 856157 :05
75419:2 :03: 058
A19:1? F32
18:0
3:5 *@
F32 9*??1::57 *< "
3438:
)
5A175<95
58:1@193:5 32 458
18:0 12 )
") ,
@8*?
) C5382
G
:05
F0190
)$ ") ) 3<7 :05 1<9175<:
32 2>90 1: 12 96538 :03: :05
) C5382 3: :05 :1?5 *@ 1<9175<:
3257 *<
G
-8-
290**6 37?1221*< 85;12:58 362* 122>57 32 458
2:>7C1<; 1<
F3?1
@8*? :03:
:05
1A5H3<3<73
90**6 1< $:0
G (
05 F32
:3<7387
438:
*9:*8-
F0* 5G3?1<57 :05 A19:1? 032
*41<57 :03: D32 458 :05
5<:12: :05 3;5 *@ :05 A19:1? F32 +-,
C5382E
:* :03: 5@@59:
205 122>57 ?571936 958:1@193:5 32 458
G
< :05 *:058 03<7
:05 399>257 032 <*: 463957 3<C
7*9>?5<: :* 85B>: :05 5A175<95 *@ :05 3B*A5 F1:<52252 3<7 :*
48*A5 :03: :05 A19:1? F32 ?3=*8 3: :05 :1?5 *@ 1<9175<:
5<95
:05 48*259>:1*< 032 48*A57 :03: :05 A19:1? F32 ?1<*8 3<7 3;57
3B*>: ,- ) C5382 3: :05 :1?5 *@ 1<9175<:
< 9385@>6 458>236 *@ :05 5A175<95 *@ A19:1?205 032 93:5;*819366C 2:3:57 :03: *< :05 73:5 *@ 1<9175<: 205
F32 2>@@581<; @8*? @5A58 :0585@*85 205 9*>67 <*: ;* :* 290**6
3<7 3: 3B*>: " 4 ? 205 F5<: :* :05 20*4 *@ 399>257 :* B>C
90*9*63:52 3: :03: :1?5 :05 399>257 936657 058 1<2175 :05 20*4
3<7 ?*652:57 058
@5561<; :1857
??5713:56C 205 29853?57 3<7 @566 7*F< BC
3:58 058 ?*:058 3<7 @3:058 93?5 :0585 3<7 :**H
058 :* 0*>25 3<7 205 <3883:57 :05 1<9175<: :* 058 4385<:2
99*871<;6C :05 9*?4631<: F32 6*7;57 BC 058 ?*:058
32459:2 *@ :05 ?3::58 385 2:3:57 BC :05 A19:1? B5@*85 :05
-9-
6538<57
3;12:83:5 1< 058
$ 2:3:5?5<: 32 458
G
2:*>:6C 75<157 :05 2>;;52:1*< *@ :05 75@5<95 :03: :05 1<9175<:
<*:
B55<
93>257
9*88*B*83:52 :05 5A175<95 *@
@3:058 852459:1A56C
:52:1?*<C
*@
965386C
2 " 3<7 $-058 ?*:058 3<7
05C 03A5 851:583:57 :05 9*<:5<:2 *@
9*?4631<: 3<7 2:3:57 :05 981?1<36 39: *@ 399>257
:05?
21<95
?1<>:52
G "-
99*871<; :*
717 <*: 85:>8<57 0*>25 @*8 3B*>:
)-
" A121:57 <538 :05 20*4 3<7 @*><7 :03: :05 A19:1?
F32 98C1<; <538 :05 20*4 3<7 *< 5<I>18C 205 85A53657 :05 39:
*@ 399>257
"
>8:058
- *9:*8 F0* 5G3?1<57 :05 A19:1? 362*
2:3:57 :03: :05 A19:1? 032 <3883:57 :05 5<:185 1<9175<: B5@*85
0*>;0 :0585 F585 <* 1<=>8152 *< :05 4582*< *@ :05 A19:1?
:03: 1:256@ 12 <*: 3 ;8*><7 :* 712B5615A5 :05 :52:1?*<C *@
*9:*8 032 965386C 754*257 :03: 1< :05 61;0: 48522>85
485221<; 1<=>8152 ?3C <*: *99>8 *< :05 B*7C
99*871<; :* 058
:05 B37 :*>90 2:1?>63:52 :05 25G>36 *8;3<2
:05C ?3C <*:
93>25 1<=>8C B>: 75@1<1:56C 0>8: :05 25G>36 @5561<;2 *@ 3 ?1<*8
90167
438: @8*? :05 3B*A5 5A175<95
-:05 1<7545<75<:
F1:<522 @*8 24*: ?303J38 2>44*8:57 :05 9325 *@ 48*259>:1*<
- 10 -
3<7 75<157 :05 2>;;52:1*< *@ 75@5<95 :03: 399>257 F32 <*:
8><<1<; :05 H183<1 20*4
'
5<95 *< *A58366 458>236 *@ :05 5A175<95 *< 859*87
1< ?C 9*<2175857 A15F
:05 48*259>:1*< 032 52:3B612057 :05
;>16: *@ 399>257 @*8 :05 9038;52 65A5657 3;31<2: 01? 3<7 :05
*>8: 032 81;0:6C 9*<A19:57 :05 399>257 @*8 :05 *@@5<952 05
12 9038;57
$
*F5A58 :05
@*8 :05 *@@5<95 ><758
9:
*>8: F0165 1?4*21<; 25<:5<95
59:1*< ' $ *@
8 F
59:1*< + *@
1?4*257 :05 ?3G1?>? 25<:5<95
05 6538<57
9*><256 @*8 :05 399>257 2>B?1::57 :03: :05 399>257 12 <*F 3;57
3B*>: 3B*A5 () C5382 3<7 2>@@581<; @8*? *67 3;5 316?5<:2 32
2>90 65<15<: A15F ?3C B5 :3H5< BC :012
*>8: BC 1?4*21<;
?1<1?>? 25<:5<95 :* :05 399>257
4*< 9*<217581<; :05 @39:2 3<7 9189>?2:3<952 *@ :05
9325 3<7 9*<217581<; :05 32459: :03: :05 1<9175<: 93>257 1< :05
C538 ") , :166 :*73C :05 3445663<: 12 *< B316 3<7 <*F 12 3;57
3B*>: () C5382 3<7 362* 9*<217581<; :05 32459: :03: :0585 385
<* *:058 B37 3<:59575<:2 854*8:57 3;31<2: :05 3445663<:
3?
- 11 -
*@ :05 9*<2175857 A15F :03: :05 25<:5<95 1?4*257 BC :05
*>8: 12 613B65 :* B5 ?*71@157
81?1<36
44536 12
=>7;?5<:
)'
")") 432257 1<
*@
9*<A19:1*<
73:57
* $+ ") , *< :05 @165 *@ 6538<57
5221*<2
#>7;5
9*<@18?57
363B>83;1
0585BC
*F5A58 :05 *8758 *@ 25<:5<95
1?4*257 BC :05 8136
399>257
*>8: 12 ?*71@157
25<:5<957
:*
><758;*
81;*8*>2 1?4812*<?5<: @*8 3 4581*7 *@ '
C5382 3<7 :* 43C @1<5 *@
) ))) -
1<
75@3>6: :* ><758;* 21?465 1?4812*<?5<: @*8
3 4581*7 *@ *<5 C538 @*8 *@@5<95 4><1203B65
><758
59:1*< ' $ *@
F
59:1*< + *@
9: ") "
1A
>8:058
:05
399>257
25<:5<957
:*
><758;* 81;*8*>2 1?4812*<?5<: @*8 3 4581*7
*<5 C538 3<7 :* 43C @1<5 *@
2 ') ))) - 1<
75@3>6: :* ><758;* 21?465 1?4812*<?5<: @*8
3 4581*7 *@
?*<:02 @*8 :05 *@@5<95
4><1203B65 ><758
59:1*< ' $
*@
- 12 -
A
1<5 3?*><:
1@ 3<C
754*21:57 BC :05
399>257 12 *875857 :* B5 4317 :* :05 A19:1?
*< 7>5 175<:1@193:1*<
1< 3771:1*< :* :05
9*?45<23:1*< 48*A1757 ><758
*@
A1
BC :05 8136
59:1*< ' (
*>8:
05 399>257 12 5<:1:657 @*8 25: *@@ ><758 $"+
*@
5;12:8C 12 71859:57 :* 25<7 B39H :05
36*<; F1:0
958:1@157 9*4C *@ :012 =>7;?5<: :* :05 9*<958<57
@*8:0F1:0
,)
$
12: * .
. #
*. +
(
*>8:
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review