Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
YOGESH TIWARI
YOGESH Digitally
2026.05.02
TIWARI Date:
14:38:47 +0530
2026:CGHC:20292
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 7714 of 2024
1 - Ranjit Banarjee S/o Ravindra Nath Banarjee, Aged About 61 Years
R/o C-60, Agyey Nagar, Bilaspur, District-Bilaspur (C.G.)
2 - J. Laxmi Shekhar S/o Late J.V. Rao, Aged About 60 Years R/o C/o
Shri D. Laxman Rao, Near Govt. Primary School, Nipaniya, TahsilNipaniya, District- Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.)
3 - Virendra Kumar Yadav S/o Late Shri Jagdish Prasad Yadav, Aged
About 58 Years R/o Kilaward Near Library, Juna Bilaspur, DistrictBilaspur (C.G.)
4 - Shatruhan Prasad Yadav S/o Late Sadashivram Yadav, Aged About
62 Years R/o Jarhabhata, Om Nagar, Near Jatiya Talab, Bilaspur,
District-Bilaspur (C.G.)
5 - Babu Lal Tiwari S/o Ramsujaan Tiwari, Aged About 59 Years R/o C10, Agyey Nagar, Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
6 - Vinit Kumar Devada S/o Late Gyanendra Kumar Devada, Aged
About 60 Years R/o Brahaspati Bazar, Chatapara, Prince Mobile Shop,
Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
7 - Anil Kumar Dubey S/o Chinta Ram Dubey, Aged About 59 Years R/o
Village-Gobripat, P.O. Gobripat, District- Bilaspur (C.G.) 445113.
8 - Jageshwar Prasad Kashyap S/o Late Patiram Kashyap, Aged About
59 Years R/o C/o Dr. G. Bose, 9/80, Green Park Colony, Jarhabhata,
Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
9 - Harcharan Das Vaishnav S/o Prayag Das Vaishnav, Aged About 60
Years R/o Village-Khaprakhol, P.S.-Hardikala, Tahsil- Bodri, DistrictBilaspur (C..G.)
10 - Goverdhan Prasad Kaushik S/o Late Shri Ramkushal Kaushik,
Aged About 60 Years R/o Village-Ghutaku, Tahsil-Sakti, P.S.- Koni,
District-Bilaspur (C.G.)
11 - Smt. Sandhya Chaturvedi W/o Shri K.N. Chaturvedi, Aged About
58 Years O/o Principal, Janpad Primary School, Village-Jalso, Tahsil Tilda, District-Bilaspur (C.G.)
12 - Smt. Shachi Dewangan W/o Shri T.R. Dewangan, Aged About 60
Years R/o Ware House Road, Near Atal Shrivastava's Home, Bilaspur,
District-Bilaspur (C.G.)
13 - Ku. Sunita Deshkar D/o Kamal Lal Deshkar, Aged About 59 Years
R/o Near Mahadev Hotel, Besides Vinod Ata Chakki, Tilak Nagar,
Chatapara, District-Bilaspur (C.G.)
14 - Smt. Tripti Tiwari W/o Shri J.S. Tiwari, Aged About 60 Years R/o
Mahamaya Vihar, Ware House Road, Bilaspur, District-Bilaspur (C.G.)
15 - Smt. Jyoti Konher W/o Arvind Konher, Aged About 62 Years R/o
Shanti Nagar, Behind Shri Mandir, Bilaspur, Distict-Bilaspur (C.G.)
--- Petitioners
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Its Secretary, School Education
Department, Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur, DistrictRaipur (C.G.)
2 - Secretary, Department Of General Administration, Mahanadi
Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Director Of Public Instructions, Indrawati Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nawa
Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.)
4 - District Education Officer, Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
--- Respondents
WPS No. 8475 of 2024
Avinash Kumar Das S/o Late Shri Shivram Das Aged About 63 Years
Retired Lecturer (L.B.) R/o Village Ruwatala Post Dhangaon Block
Dongergarh District- Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh
---Petitioner
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary Education Department
Mantralaya Mahanadi Bhawan Naya Raipur District - Raipur (C.G.)
2 - Secretary Department Of Panchayat Mantralaya Mahanadi Bhawan
Naya Raipur District- Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Secretary Department Of Finance Mantralaya Mahanadi Bhawan
Naya Raipur District- Raipur (C.G.)
4 - Director Directorate Public Education Indrawati Bhawan Block - Iii,
First Floor Naya Raipur District- Raipur (C.G.)
5 - Director Directorate Of Public Instructions Indrawati Bhawan Naya
Raipur District - Raipur (C.G.)
--- Respondents
WPS No. 674 of 2025
1 - Shubha Pandey W/o Rakesh Pandey, Aged About 62 Years R/o 1st
Floor, Sunny Niwas, Rajendra Nagar, Bilaspur, District Bilaspur (C.G.)
2 - Krishna Kumar Tiwari, S/o Bharat Prashad Tiwari, Aged About 60
Years R/o Ward No.15 Gayatri Nagar Ramhepur Lormi, District Mungeli
(C.G.)
3 - Lav Kumar Pandey, S/o Makhan Lal Pandey, Aged About 61 Years
R/o- Purana Sarkanda District Bilaspur (C.G.)
4 - Deepchand Gahwai S/o Late Mohanlal Gahwai, Aged About 61
Years R/o- Village And Post Ratanpur District Bilaspur (C.G.)
5 - Basant Dubey S/o Late Makhanlal Dubey, Aged About 61 Years R/oNera Saraswati Sishu Mandir Rajkishore Nagar, Bilaspur, District
Bilaspur (C.G.)
6 - Bhagat Singh Luniya, S/o Janki Prashad Luniya, Aged About 61
Years R/o- Nawrangpur Post Ramhepur Lormi District Mungeli (C.G.)
7 - Harendra Kumar Kaushik S/o Late Chedilal, Aged About 61 Years
R/o- Village Chatavana Post Harri Mines Tehsil Sakri District Bilaspur
(C.G.)
8 - Shiv Kumar Sahu S/o Shri Anjori Ram Sahu, Aged About 61 Years
R/o- Village Nawrangpur, Uraihapara Post Ramhepur Lormi District
Mungeli (C.G.)
9 - Ghanshyam Das Manikpuri, S/o Shri Balwan Das Manikpuri, Aged
About 61 Years R/o- Village Pali Bhuru Chakarbhata Police Station
Harri Tehsil Sakri District Bilaspur (C.G.)
10 - Surendra Kumar Sahu S/o Shri Jankram Sahu, Aged About 60
Years R/o- Post Salka Navagaon, Kargi Road Kota, District Bilaspur
(C.G.)
11 - Ranjeet Singh S/o Shri Jagannath Singh, Aged About 59 Years
R/o- Village Newari Post Malhar District Bilaspur (C.G.) Amardeep
Keshrwani Sahu S/o Shri Anjori Ram Sahu, Aged About 61 Years, R/oVillage Nawrangpur, Uraihapara Post Ramhepur Lormi District Mungeli
(C.G.)
12 - Amardeep Kesharwani Sahu S/o Shri Radhelal Kesharwani, Aged
About 61 Years R/o- Village Faujdar Kanpa Post Office Dindori Lormi
District Mungeli (C.G.)
13 - Radhelal Nirnejak S/o Shri Paharuram, Aged About 60 Years R/oVillage Parsadaved Post Office Tikari Teshil Bhasturi District Bilaspur
(C.G.)
14 - Pitambar Prashad Sahu S/o Late Chaituram Sahu, Aged About 59
Years R/o- Village Joki Post Sakri Teshil Sakri District Bilaspur (C.G.)
15 - Omprakash Jaiswal S/o Ramnarayan Jaiswal Aged About 59 Years
R/o- Post Office Dinduari Lormi District Mungeli (C.G.)
16 - Ramnarayan Kaushik S/o Ramkhilawan Kaushik, Aged About 59
Years R/o- Village Pali Bhuru Police Station Harri Tehsil Sakri District
Bilaspur (C.G.)
---Petitioners
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Its Secretary, School Education
Department Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Naya Raipur (C.G.)
2 - Secretary Department Of General Administration, Mahanadi
Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Director Of Public Instructions, Indrawati Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nawa
Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
4 - District Education Officer, Bilaspur, District Bilaspur (C.G.)
5 - District Education Officer, Mungeli, District Mungeli (C.G.)
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
(In WPS No.7714/2024)
: Mr. Rahul Sharma, Advocate on behalf of
Mr. A.V. Shridhar, Advocate
For Petitioner
(In WPS No.8475/2024)
: Mr. Anmol Sharma, Advocate
For Petitioner
(In WPS No.674/2025)
: Ms. Sweksha Sharma, Advocate
For Respondents/State
: Mr. Sabyasachi Choubey, Government
Advocate
Hon’ble Shri Amitendra Kishore Prasad, Judge
Order on Board
30.04.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Rahul Sharma, learned counsel holding brief of Mr.
A,V. Shridhar, learned counsel for the petitioners in WPS
No.7714/2024, Mr. Anmol Sharma, learned counsel for the
petitioner in WPS No.8475/2024 as well as Ms. Sweksha
Sharma, learned counsel for the petitioners in WPS No.674/2025.
Also heard Mr. Sabyasachi Choubey, learned Government
Advocate, appearing for the State/respondents.
2.
Since a common question is involved in all these petitions, they
have been clubbed together, heard analogously, and are being
decided by this Court by a common order.
3.
By filing the present batch of petitions, the petitioners herein call
in question the legality, validity and propriety of the order dated
30.06.2018 issued by the Respondent No.1/Secretary, School
Education Department, whereby the petitioners, who were
working as Teachers under the Panchayat and Municipal
Corporations and had completed 8 years of service as on
01.07.2018, were absorbed in the Department of School
Education with a stipulation that they would be governed by the
New Contributory Pension Scheme, thereby rendering the
provisions of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Pension) Rules,
1976 (for short, ‘Rules of 1976’) inapplicable to them (Annexure
P/1).
4.
The petitioners have further assailed the subsequent order dated
24.06.2024, whereby it has been provided that the services of
such absorbed employees shall be reckoned only from the date
of absorption and that they shall not be entitled to the benefit of
the Rules of 1976 (Annexure P/2).
5.
The grievance of the petitioners, as raised in WPS No.7714/2024,
WPS No.8475/2024 and WPS No.674/2025, is also directed
against, inter alia, Paragraphs 4 and 6 of the policy/order dated
30.06.2018 to the aforesaid extent. It is contended that the
impugned stipulations are arbitrary and illegal inasmuch as the
past services rendered by the petitioners from their initial date of
appointment, in some cases dating back to the year 1998, have
been ignored for the purpose of pension and other retiral benefits.
6.
Accordingly, the petitioners seek a direction to the respondent
authorities to count their entire length of service from the initial
date of appointment and to extend to them full pensionary and
consequential benefits in accordance with the applicable pension
rules, by setting aside the impugned conditions contained in the
aforesaid orders.
7.
In WPS No.7714/2024, the petitioners have prayed for following
relief(s) :“10.1 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to call the entire records pertaining to
the case of petitioners.
10.2 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to strike down clause 4 and clause 6
of the impugned policy dated 30.06.2018
(Annexure
P/1),
being
arbitrary,
illegal,
discriminatory and unconstitutional.
10.3 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to quash the impugned order dated
24.06.2024 (Annexure P/2).
10.4 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to direct the Respondent Authorities to
grant continuity in service from the initial date
of appointment and in pursuance thereto
consider the petitioners eligible for pension
under Chhattisgarh Civil Services Pension
Rules, 1976.
10.5 Any other relief which the Hon'ble Court
deems fit in the circumstances of the case may
be given.”
8.
In WPS No.8475/2024, the petitioner has prayed for following
relief(s) :“10.1. The Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to call for the entire record pertaining
to the case of the petitioner.
10.2. That this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to set-aside/Strike Down Clause 4
and
of
the
impugned
policy
dated
30.06.2018 issued by Respondent authorities
(ANNEXURE P-1).
10.3. That this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
please to quash the impugned order dated
24.06.2024 (ANNEXURE P-2).
10.4. That this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
please to direct the respondent authorities to
grant continuity in service of the petitioner
from the date of the initial appointment i.e.
from the year 1998 for all service benefits.
10.5. The Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to direct the respondent authorities to
consider the petitioner eligible for the pension
under the Chhattisgarh Civil Services Pension
Rules, 1976.
10.6. Any other relief, which this Hon'ble Court
may deems fit and proper may also be
awarded to the petitioner including the cost of
the petition.”
9.
In WPS No.674/2025, the petitoners have prayed for following
relief(s) :-
“10.2 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to quash the impugned order dated
24.06.2024 (Annexure P/2).
10.3 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to direct the Respondent Authorities
to grant continuity in service from the initial
date of appointment and in pursuance thereto
consider the petitioners eligible for pension
under Chhattisgarh Civil Services Pension
Rules, 1976.
10.4 Any other relief which the Hon'ble Court
deems fit in the circumstances of the case
may be given.”
10.
The brief facts of the present batch of cases, in a nutshell, are
that the petitioners were initially appointed as Shikshakarmi under
the Janpad Panchayats in compliance with orders passed by this
Court and continued to discharge their duties as such. Their
services were subsequently regularized in accordance with the
applicable rules. Thereafter, the State of Chhattisgarh, by way of
policy decision dated 30.06.2018, resolved to absorb those
Shikshakarmis working under various Panchayats and Municipal
Corporations who had completed 8 years of service as on
01.07.2018 into the School Education Department in the newly
created cadre of Teachers (Local Body).
11.
Pursuant thereto, the petitioners came to be absorbed; however,
the said policy contained stipulations, inter alia, that the services
of the absorbed employees would be counted only from the date
of absorption i.e. 01.07.2018 and that they would be governed by
the New Contributory Pension Scheme, thereby excluding the
applicability of the Rules of 1976. Being aggrieved, the
petitioners, through their unions, submitted representations
seeking coverage under the Old Pension Scheme, and similarly
situated employees had earlier approached this Court by way of
filing WP(S) No.4828/2020, which was disposed of on 17.12.2020
directing consideration of their representations; however, the
same came to be rejected vide order dated 05.10.2021.
12.
The grievance of the petitioners in the present matters (WPS
No.7714/2024, WPS No.8475/2024 and WPS No.674/2025) is
that despite long years of service, in some cases from as early as
1998, the respondent authorities are counting their qualifying
service only from the date of absorption and are denying them
the benefit of the Old Pension Scheme. One of the petitioners
has also retired on 31.07.2023 (with extension of service), yet the
aforesaid benefits have not been extended. Hence, the
petitioners have challenged, inter alia, Clauses 4 and 6 of the
order dated 30.06.2018 as well as the subsequent order dated
24.06.2024, seeking a direction to the respondents to count their
entire service from the initial date of appointment and to grant
them full pensionary and consequential benefits under the
applicable pension rules.
13.
Learned counsel appearing for the respective petitioners, namely
Mr. Rahul Sharma, learned counsel holding brief of Mr. A.V.
Shridhar, learned counsel in WPS No.7714/2024, Mr. Anmol
Sharma, learned counsel in WPS No.8475/2024, and Ms.
Sweksha Sharma, learned counsel in WPS No.674/2025, would
jointly submit that the impugned action of the respondent-State in
restricting the reckoning of service of the petitioners only from the
date of their absorption i.e. 01.07.2018, and in subjecting them to
the New Contributory Pension Scheme, is ex facie arbitrary,
discriminatory and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India. It is contended that the petitioners were
initially appointed as Shikshakarmis pursuant to orders passed by
the High Court and had continuously discharged their duties
under the control and supervision of the State authorities, their
services having been duly regularized in accordance with the
applicable rules. Thus, the entire length of service rendered by
them cannot be artificially truncated by treating the date of
absorption as the starting point for all consequential benefits,
particularly pension, which is in the nature of deferred wages. It is
further submitted that the policy decision dated 30.06.2018, more
particularly Clauses 4 and 6 thereof, in so far as they provide that
the past services of the petitioners shall not be counted and that
they shall be governed by the New Contributory Pension
Scheme, is wholly unjustified and suffers from the vice of hostile
discrimination.
14.
Learned counsel would argue that similarly situated employees,
who have rendered long years of service under the State, cannot
be denied the benefit of the Old Pension Scheme merely on
account of a change in nomenclature or cadre upon absorption.
The impugned stipulations, it is urged, fail to take into account the
continuity of service, the nature of duties performed, and the fact
that the petitioners were discharging functions identical to those
of regular teachers even prior to their absorption, thereby
rendering the classification unreasonable and lacking any rational
nexus with the object sought to be achieved.
15.
Learned counsel would further contend that despite repeated
representations made by the petitioners and their unions, the
respondent authorities have failed to undertake a fair and
meaningful consideration of their grievances. Attention is invited
to the earlier round of litigation wherein similarly situated
employees had approached this Court in WP(S) No.4828/2020,
which was disposed of with a direction to the authorities to
consider their representations; however, the same came to be
rejected in a mechanical manner vide order dated 05.10.2021
without addressing the core issue of continuity of service and
entitlement to pensionary benefits. It is submitted that such an
approach defeats the legitimate expectation of the petitioners and
reflects non-application of mind on the part of the authorities.
16.
It is also submitted that some of the petitioners had earlier
approached this Court by filing WPS No.777/2021 and other
analogous matters, which came to be disposed of by a Coordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 17.02.2026.
Learned
counsel
would
place
heavy
reliance
upon
the
observations made therein, particularly paragraphs 43 to 49, to
contend that this Court has already recognized the significance of
the issue relating to reckonable service for pension and the need
for a conscious and reasoned policy decision by the State. It is
emphasized that the Co-ordinate Bench has categorically
observed that pension is a welfare measure and a form of
deferred compensation, and that the long years of service
rendered by the employees prior to absorption cannot be ignored.
The Court, while refraining from issuing a positive mandamus,
directed the State to undertake a comprehensive reconsideration
of the issue by taking into account relevant factors such as
continuity of service, nature of duties, and constitutional
mandates of equality and fairness within a stipulated time frame.
17.
Learned counsel would further submit that against the aforesaid
order dated 17.02.2026, the State Government preferred an intracourt appeal being WA No.325/2026 before the Hon’ble Division
Bench of this Court; however, the said appeal came to be
dismissed, thereby affirming the view taken by the learned Single
Judge. It is thus contended that the issue has attained a certain
degree of finality insofar as the obligation of the State to take a
reasoned and constitutionally compliant decision is concerned. In
such circumstances, the continued inaction on the part of the
respondent authorities, coupled with the enforcement of the
impugned clauses and subsequent order dated 24.06.2024, is
wholly unsustainable in law.
18.
On the strength of the aforesaid submissions, learned counsel for
the petitioners would pray that this Court may be pleased to set
aside the impugned Clauses 4 and 6 of the order dated
30.06.2018 as well as the order dated 24.06.2024 to the extent
they deny the benefit of counting past service and the
applicability of the Old Pension Scheme, and further issue
appropriate directions to the respondent authorities to reckon the
services of the petitioners from their initial date of appointment
and to extend all consequential pensionary and retiral benefits in
accordance with the applicable rules.
19.
Per contra, Mr. Sabyasachi Choubey, learned Government
Advocate appearing for the State/respondents, would submit that
the present batch of petitions is devoid of merit and deserves to
be dismissed. It is contended that the petitioners have been
granted the benefit of absorption in the Department of School
Education pursuant to a conscious policy decision taken by the
State Government vide order dated 30.06.2018, and such policy
decision, being within the exclusive domain of the executive, is
not amenable to judicial interference unless shown to be
manifestly arbitrary or unconstitutional. According to him, the
petitioners, having accepted the terms and conditions of
absorption without demur, are now estopped from challenging the
same at a belated stage.
20.
Learned Government Advocate would further submit that the
status
of
Shikshakarmis
prior
to
their
absorption
was
fundamentally distinct from that of regular government servants.
Their appointment, service conditions, source of salary and
administrative
control
were
governed
by
the
respective
Panchayats and Urban Local Bodies, and not by the State in its
capacity as an employer in the School Education Department. It
is, therefore, contended that the past service rendered by the
petitioners as Shikshakarmis cannot be equated with regular
government service so as to claim parity in matters of pension.
The decision to reckon service only from the date of absorption
i.e. 01.07.2018 is thus a reasonable classification based on
intelligible differentia.
21.
It is also submitted that the introduction and applicability of the
New Contributory Pension Scheme to the absorbed employees is
in consonance with the prevailing policy framework of the State,
which has, as a matter of financial prudence and administrative
uniformity, discontinued the Old Pension Scheme for employees
entering government service after a specified cut-off date. The
petitioners, having been brought into the regular cadre only upon
their absorption in the year 2018, have rightly been placed under
the new pension regime. Any direction to extend the benefit of the
Old
Pension
Scheme
would
have
wide-ranging
financial
implications and would disturb the settled policy of the State.
22.
Lastly, it is submitted that the impugned order dated 24.06.2024
merely clarifies the existing position with regard to reckoning of
service and applicability of pension rules, and does not introduce
any new condition warranting interference by this Court.
However, learned Government Advocate fairly submits that
though the State had preferred an intra-court appeal against the
order dated 17.02.2026 passed by the learned Single Judge in
WPS No.777/2021 and analogous matters, the said writ appeal
being WA No.325/2026 has been dismissed by the Hon’ble
Division Bench, thereby affirming the directions issued by the
learned Single Judge. The action of the respondents being in
accordance with the policy decision and applicable rules, no case
for judicial review is made out. Accordingly, learned Government
Advocate prays for dismissal of the writ petitions.
23.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties at considerable
length and with their able assistance carefully gone through the
pleadings, documents placed on record as well as the impugned
orders/policy decisions. I have also duly considered the rival
submissions advanced at the Bar, the earlier rounds of litigation
between the parties, and the legal position governing the field,
including the scope of judicial review in matters involving policy
decisions of the State.
24.
While deciding the earlier round of litigation culminating in the
order dated 17.02.2026 passed in WPS No.777/2021 and
analogous matters, the learned Single Judge, after hearing
learned counsel for the parties at length and taking into
consideration a catena of judicial precedents rendered by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court as well as various High Courts, including
the decisions in Ram Gopal Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh
(arising out of SLP (C) No.6708/2023), Dr. Hira Lal v. State of
Bihar (Civil Appeal Nos.1677-1678 of 2020), Vijay Singh v.
State of Uttar Pradesh (2013) 11 SCC 673, Partha Das v. State
of Tripura, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1844, A.B. Krishna v. State
of Karnataka, (1998) 3 SCC 495, and other authorities governing
the field, came to the considered conclusion that the controversy
with regard to counting of past service for pension had not yet
crystallised into a definitive policy decision of the State. The
learned Single Judge also took note of persuasive precedents
from other High Courts, including Nagar Palika Parishad v.
Kundan Sarla (Writ Appeal No. 3258 of 2024), Dinesh Kumar
Sharma v. State of Madhya Pradesh (Madhya Pradesh High
Court in Writ Appeal No. 11734 of 2021), Pushpa Tiwari v.
State of Madhya Pradesh (Writ Petition No. 8083 of 2019) and
Ram Jatan Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh (W.P. No. 4919
of 2003), wherein continuity of service for pensionary purposes
was recognized even after absorption. Upon a comprehensive
survey of the legal position, the learned Single Judge held that
the issue involves a delicate interplay between statutory service
rules, executive policy and constitutional guarantees, particularly
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
25.
The learned Single Judge, in paragraphs 28 to 49 of the said
judgment, lucidly observed in following terms :-
“28. Having bestowed thoughtful consideration
upon the submissions advanced by the
learned counsel appearing for the parties and
upon a careful examination of the pleadings
and record, this Court is of the view that the
controversy raised in the present batch of writ
petitions primarily emanates from the absence
of
a
clear,
final
and
uniform
policy
determination by the respondent-State on the
determinative date of appointment for the
purpose of pensionary entitlement in cases
such as that of the petitioners. The petitioners
represent a class of employees whose service
journey commenced prior to the introduction of
the New Pension Scheme and thereafter
passed through stages of regularisation and
absorption, thereby creating a hybrid service
structure which has not been conclusively
addressed
under
the
existing
executive
framework.
29. With regard to principle of “approbate and
reprobate”, contention made by Mr. Bhaduri, it
is pertinent to note that no such plea was
specifically averred in the return; the same has
been introduced only during the course of oral
arguments. In my considered opinion, where
the petitioners seek to enforce an inherent
statutory right, the doctrine of 'Approbate and
Reprobate' finds no application. Since the
dispute pertains to pensionary benefits which
are a proprietary right attached to the post, the
technical plea of estoppel cannot override the
law, therefore I am not impressed with the
contention made by Mr. Bhaduri.
30. It is well settled by a catena of judgments
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court that matters
relating to formulation of policy, particularly in
the realm of service conditions, pension, cutoff dates and recognition of past service, fall
squarely within the domain of the executive.
Courts exercising jurisdiction under Article 226
of the Constitution do not sit as policy-makers
but undertake judicial review only after a policy
has been framed and crystallised.
31. In BALCO Employees’ Union v. Union of
India and others, (2002) 2 SCC 333, the
Supreme Court has categorically held that
courts cannot interfere with policy decisions
merely because another view may appear
more equitable or desirable, unless such
policy is shown to be arbitrary, irrational or
violative
of
constitutional
provisions,
by
observing as follows :““87. ………………
"232. While protecting the rights of the
people from being violated in any manner
utmost care has to be taken that the court
does not transgress its jurisdiction. There is,
in our constitutional framework a fairly clear
demarcation of powers. The court has come
down heavily whenever the executive has
sought
to
jurisdiction.
impinge
upon
the
court's
233. At the same time, in exercise of its
enormous power the court should not be
called upon to or undertake governmental
duties or functions. The courts cannot run the
Government nor can the administration
indulge in abuse or non-use of power and get
away with it. The essence of judicial review is
a constitutional fundamental. The role of the
higher judiciary under the Constitution casts
on it a great obligation as the sentinel to
defend the values of the Constitution and the
rights of Indians. The courts must, therefore,
act
within
their
judicially
permissible
limitations to uphold the rule of law and
harness their power in public interest. It is
precisely for this reason that it has been
consistently held by this Court that in matters
of policy the court will not interfere. When
there is a valid law requiring the Government
to act in a particular manner the court ought
not to, without striking down the law, give any
direction which is not in accordance with law.
In other words, the court itself is not above
the law.
234. In respect of public projects and policies
which are initiated by the Government the
courts should not become an approval
authority. Normally such decisions are taken
by the Government after due care and
consideration. In a democracy welfare of the
people at large, and not merely of a small
section of the society, has to be the concern
of a responsible Government. If a considered
policy decision has been taken, which is not
in conflict with any law or is not mala fide, it
will not be in public interest to require the
court to go into and investigate those areas
which are the function of the executive. For
any project which is approved after due
deliberation the court should refrain from
being asked to review the decision just
because a petitioner in filing a PIL alleges
that such a decision should not have been
taken because an opposite view against the
undertaking of the project, which view may
have been considered by the Government, is
possible. When two or more options or views
are possible and after considering them the
Government takes a policy decision it is then
not the function of the court to go into the
matter afresh and, in a way, sit in appeal
over such a policy decision.”
32. Similarly, in Census Commissioner and
others v. R. Krishnamurthy, (2015) 2 SCC
796, the Supreme Court reiterated that Courts
are not equipped to adjudicate upon the merits
of policy choices and that judicial review is
confined
to
examining
the
legality
and
constitutionality of a decision, and not its
wisdom. In the absence of a definitive policy
decision on the core question involved herein,
any attempt by this Court to adjudicate the
issue on merits would result in judicial
overreach into executive territory and held as
follows :“28. …………..
“229. It is now well settled that the courts, in
the exercise of their jurisdiction, will not
transgress into the field of policy decision.
Whether to have an infrastructural project or
not and what is the type of project to be
undertaken and how it has to be executed,
are part of policy-making process and the
courts are ill-equipped to adjudicate on a
policy decision so undertaken. The court, no
doubt, has a duty to see that in the
undertaking of a decision, no law is violated
and people’s fundamental rights are not
transgressed upon except to the extent
permissible under the Constitution.”
33.
So
far
as
pensionary
matters
are
concerned, it is beyond cavil that pension is
not a bounty but a deferred portion of
compensation for past service, as held in D.S.
Nakara and others v. Union of India, (1983)
1 SCC 305. At the same time, the Supreme
Court has consistently held that the State is
entitled to frame pension schemes, prescribe
eligibility criteria and fix cut-off dates, provided
such classification is founded on an intelligible
differentia and bears a rational nexus with the
object sought to be achieved.
34. In Government of Andhra Pradesh and
others v. N. Subbarayudu and others,
(2008) 14 SCC 702, it was specifically
observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that
fixing of a cut-off date is within the policy
domain of the State and Courts cannot lightly
interfere with such determination unless it is
manifestly
arbitrary
or
discriminatory
by
observing as follows :“5. In a catena of decisions of this Court it
has been held that cut-off date is fixed by
the executive authority keeping in view the
economic conditions, financial constraints
and many other administrative and other
attending circumstances. This Court is also
of the view that fixing cut-off dates is within
the domain of the executive authority and
the court should not normally interfere with
the fixation of cut-off date by the executive
authority unless such order appears to be
on the face of it blatantly discriminatory and
arbitrary. (See State of Punjab v. Amar Nath
Goyal, (2005) 6 SCC 754).”
35. Further, the Supreme Court has further
clarified in Union of India v. P. N. Menon and
others, (1994) 4 SCC 68, that financial
implications and administrative feasibility are
legitimate considerations for the State while
framing pension policies, and that equality
does not mandate extension of benefits to all
merely on the ground of perceived hardship.
Therefore, while recognition of past service for
pensionary purposes may be a desirable
policy choice, whether such past service is to
be wholly counted, partially recognised, or
excluded altogether is a matter to be assessed
by the policy-maker after due consideration of
financial,
implications.
administrative
and
structural
36. Applying the aforesaid settled principles to
the facts of the present batch of writ petitions,
this Court finds that the controversy does not
arise
from
a
mere
dispute
regarding
calculation of individual pensionary benefits,
but emanates from a structural ambiguity in
the State’s executive framework governing
employees
whose
service
trajectory
commenced prior to the introduction of the
New Pension Scheme and thereafter passed
through
stages
of
regularisation
and
absorption into regular government service.
The petitioners constitute a distinct class
whose engagement as Shikshakarmis dates
back to the years 1998–1999, followed by
long,
uninterrupted
service
under
State
control, regularisation in terms of prevailing
statutory norms, and eventual absorption into
the School Education Department under the
policy dated 30.06.2018.
37. In the present batch of writ petitions, this
Court notes that the respondent-State has, as
a matter of conscious policy choice, restored
the Old Pension Scheme by issuing Gazette
Notifications
dated
11.05.2022
and
20.01.2023. However, a careful and purposive
reading of the aforesaid Notifications reveals
that they do not decisively resolve the core
and determinative issue arising in the present
matters, namely, the exact date which ought to
be reckoned as the date of appointment for
the purpose of pensionary entitlement.
38. The Notifications are conspicuously silent
on the treatment of services rendered by the
petitioners prior to their regularisation or
absorption into regular cadres. They neither
expressly recognise such past service nor
categorically exclude it, thereby leaving the
matter open to divergent interpretations at the
departmental level. This normative silence has
resulted in a lack of uniformity, administrative
uncertainty, and the spawning of avoidable
litigation,
compelling
similarly
situated
employees to repeatedly approach the courts
for redress.
39. The restoration of the Old Pension
Scheme by the State Government through
Gazette Notifications dated 11.05.2022 and
20.01.2023
undoubtedly
represents
a
conscious policy shift. However, a careful
reading of the said Notifications reveals that
while the contributory nature of the New
Pension Scheme has been rolled back for a
defined category of employees, the crucial
determinative question as to what constitutes
the “date of appointment” for pensionary
purposes
has
been
left
unanswered,
particularly in cases such as the present,
where employees entered service prior to
01.11.2004,
but
were
regularised
and
absorbed at a later stage. The Notifications do
not expressly clarify whether pension eligibility
is to be reckoned from the date of initial
engagement, date of regularisation, date of
confirmation, or date of absorption into the
regular cadre.
40. This statutory and executive silence
assumes greater significance in the context of
the
admitted
factual
position
that
the
petitioners rendered continuous service as
Shikshakarmis
against
sanctioned
posts,
discharged sovereign educational functions in
government schools, were paid out of public
funds, and thereafter continued in pensionable
establishments under the direct administrative,
disciplinary, and financial control of the State
Government. Despite this continuity of service,
different executive authorities have adopted
varying
and
inconsistent
approaches
in
determining pension eligibility, culminating in
the issuance of the impugned order dated
16.02.2021, which itself reflects an absence of
a settled policy position.
41. The pleadings and submissions placed on
record
further
situated
demonstrate
employees
dissimilarly
have
depending
on
that
similarly
been
treated
departmental
interpretation, resulting in avoidable litigation
and
erosion
administration.
rightly
of
uniformity
The
petitioners,
characterise
their
in
service
therefore,
grievance
as
institutional rather than individual, seeking not
an immediate adjudication on the quantum or
grant of pension, but a clear, reasoned and
uniform executive determination which would
govern all employees placed in an identical
service continuum.
42. This Court is mindful of the consistent
position
of
law
that
policy
formulation,
particularly in service matters relating to
pension, cut-off dates, and recognition of past
service, lies primarily within the domain of the
executive. Judicial review at the stage of
policy vacuum or ambiguity must be exercised
with circumspection, lest the Court transgress
into the realm of policy-making. As noticed
earlier,
the
Supreme
Court
in
BALCO
Employees’ Union (supra) and Census
Commissioner
(supra)
has
repeatedly
cautioned against courts assuming the role of
policy architects in the absence of manifest
arbitrariness or constitutional infirmity.
43. In the present cases, this Court finds that
the issue has not yet crystallised into a
challenge against a definitive policy decision
of the State. On the contrary, what emerges is
an absence of a conscious, categorical and
final executive determination on the core issue
of reckonable service for pension in respect of
employees
like
the
petitioners.
In
such
circumstances, any attempt by this Court to
conclusively determine whether the service
rendered prior to absorption must or must not
be counted for pension would amount to preempting executive discretion and venturing
into policy formulation.
44. At the same time, it cannot be lost sight of
that pension is a welfare measure and a form
of deferred compensation, and the long years
of service rendered by the petitioners prior to
absorption cannot be brushed aside as
irrelevant. The fact that several petitioners
would otherwise be required to complete ten
years of service from 01.07.2018, thereby
becoming eligible for pension only after
01.07.2028, despite having already rendered
more than a decade of service under State
control,
raises
proportionality
issues
of
fairness,
and
administrative
reasonableness, which are matters requiring
due consideration at the policy level.
45. In the considered view of this Court, the
ends of justice would be best served not by
issuing
a
mandamus
either
granting
or
denying pensionary benefits, but by requiring
the
respondent-State
to
undertake
a
comprehensive and reasoned reconsideration
of the determinative date of appointment for
pensionary purposes in respect of employees
whose service commenced as Shikshakarmis
and later culminated in absorption into regular
government service. Such reconsideration
must
necessarily
continuity
of
take
service,
into
account
nature
of
the
duties
performed, source of salary, administrative
control, and the constitutional mandate of
equality under Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution.
46. It is, therefore, clarified in unequivocal
terms that this Court does not strike down or
modify the existing policy, nor does it direct
extension of any specific pensionary benefit.
The formulation or amendment of policy
remains within the exclusive prerogative of the
State
Government.
decision
so
unambiguous,
However,
taken
must
uniformly
any
policy
be
clear,
applicable
and
constitutionally compliant, so as to obviate
further litigation and ensure predictability in
service administration.
47. The State Government is accordingly
expected to take a conscious, reasoned and
categorical decision on the issue, including the
question as to whether and to what extent the
service
rendered
by
the
petitioners
as
Shikshakarmis prior to absorption in the
School
Education
consideration
for
Department
pensionary
merits
purposes,
including the requirement of completion of ten
years of qualifying service from 01.07.2018.
Such
decision
shall
be
finalized
and
communicated via a speaking order within a
strict period of 120 days from the date of
receipt of this order. It is expected that
authorities would consider the observations
made herein above.
48. Needless to observe that any such
decision
shall
be
informed
by
relevant
considerations, shall eschew arbitrariness,
and
shall
conform
to
the
constitutional
guarantees of fairness, non-discrimination,
and proportionality.
49. With the aforesaid observations/directions,
all these writ petitions are disposed of. There
shall be no order as to costs.”
26.
It is also noteworthy that the aforesaid order dated 17.02.2026
was carried in appeal by the State Government by filing WA
No.325/2026 before the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court. The
Division Bench, upon due consideration, dismissed the said writ
appeal and affirmed the view taken by the learned Single Judge,
thereby lending finality, at least at the intra-court level, to the
directions requiring the State to take a conscious and reasoned
policy decision on the issue, by observing as under :“20. A careful reading of paragraphs 45 to 47
of the impugned order would reveal that the
learned
Single
Judge
has
consciously
refrained from issuing any positive mandamus
either granting or denying pensionary benefits
to the respondents. The direction issued is
neither in the nature of conferring any
substantive benefit nor does it unsettle any
existing policy. On the contrary, the learned
Single Judge has adopted a restrained and
balanced approach by requiring the State
Government to take a conscious, reasoned,
and policy-based decision on the issue.
21. It is significant to note that the controversy
in the present case arises in a peculiar factual
backdrop, where the respondents initially
served
as
subsequently
Shikshakarmis
absorbed
and
into
were
regular
government service. The question as to
whether,
and
to
what
extent,
the
pre-
absorption service ought to be reckoned for
pensionary purposes involves consideration of
multiple factors, including continuity of service,
nature of duties, administrative control, and
the constitutional mandate of equality under
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
These are matters which squarely fall within
the domain of executive policy.
22.
The
learned
Single
Judge,
in
our
considered view, has rightly refrained from
adjudicating upon such policy matters and has
instead directed the competent authority to
undertake
an
informed
decision-making
process.
The
clarification
contained
in
paragraph 46 of the impugned order explicitly
preserves the prerogative of the State in
matters of policy formulation, thereby ensuring
that there is no judicial overreach.
23. The contention of the appellants/State that
the impugned direction amounts to revival of a
stale or concluded issue is also misplaced.
The direction issued is not for consideration of
an individual or belated representation so as
to attract the ratio of M.K. Sarkar (supra).
Rather, it is a direction to the State to address
a broader, systemic issue affecting a class of
employees,
which
has
continuing
civil
consequences and has led to recurring
litigation. Such a direction, in our opinion,
cannot be equated with the “consideration
jurisprudence” deprecated by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court. In fact, the requirement of
passing a reasoned and speaking order within
a stipulated timeframe advances the cause of
transparency
and
accountability
in
governance, and ensures that the issue is
examined at the appropriate level on relevant
considerations.
irreparable
No
prejudice,
prejudice,
is
much
caused
to
less
the
appellants by such a direction.
24. As regards the submission pertaining to
judicial discipline and binding precedent, we
find that the learned Single Judge has not
taken any view in derogation of the judgment
rendered by the Division Bench of this Court in
Har Narayan Yadav (supra). The learned
Single Judge has neither overruled nor
disregarded the said judgment, but has merely
directed reconsideration of the issue in light of
existing
legal
and
factual
parameters.
Therefore, the argument founded on alleged
breach of judicial discipline is misconceived.
25. Similarly, the plea based on delay and
laches, as well as the reliance placed upon the
affidavit of the Secretary, Department of
Finance, are matters which can appropriately
be considered by the State Government while
undertaking the exercise directed by the
learned Single Judge. The impugned order
does not foreclose any such contention and
leaves it open to the State to take an
appropriate decision in accordance with law.
26. We also find merit in the submission
advanced on behalf of the respondents that
the impugned order strikes a balance between
judicial restraint and the need to ensure
fairness in State action. The learned Single
Judge has neither encroached upon the policy
domain nor abdicated judicial responsibility,
but has facilitated a lawful and structured
decision-making process.
27. In view of the aforesaid discussion, we are
of the considered opinion that the impugned
order passed by the learned Single Judge
does not suffer from any legal infirmity
warranting
interference
in
exercise
of
appellate jurisdiction.
28. For the foregoing reasons, the writ appeal
being devoid of merit is liable to be and is
hereby dismissed . No order as to costs.”
27.
Having
given
my
thoughtful
consideration
to
the
entire
conspectus of facts and law, the rival submissions advanced at
the Bar, and the material placed on record, this Court finds that
the controversy involved in the present batch of writ petitions is
no longer res integra insofar as the nature of adjudicatory
exercise required to be undertaken by this Court is concerned.
The core issue raised herein, namely, the determinative date for
reckoning qualifying service for pension in respect of employees
who initially served as Shikshakarmis and were subsequently
absorbed into regular government service, stands squarely
covered by the earlier decision of a Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court in WPS No.777/2021 and analogous matters, decided on
17.02.2026.
28.
This Court cannot lose sight of the fact that in the aforesaid
decision,
the
Co-ordinate
Bench,
after
an
exhaustive
consideration of the statutory framework, constitutional principles,
and binding judicial precedents, consciously refrained from
issuing any positive mandamus either granting or denying the
relief sought therein. Instead, the Court adopted a balanced and
constitutionally sound approach by recognizing that the issue
pertains to a policy vacuum and requires a conscious, reasoned
and categorical determination by the State Government. The said
approach has subsequently received the imprimatur of the
Hon’ble Division Bench in WA No.325/2026, wherein the appeal
preferred by the State Government came to be dismissed,
affirming the directions issued by the learned Single Judge and
upholding the principle that such matters fall primarily within the
domain of executive policy-making.
29.
In the considered opinion of this Court, the present batch of writ
petitions arises out of the very same structural ambiguity and
absence of a definitive policy decision which was noticed and
addressed in the earlier round of litigation. The grievance
projected by the petitioners herein is not merely individual in
nature but reflects a broader systemic issue affecting a class of
employees who share a common service trajectory, marked by
initial engagement under local bodies, prolonged service under
State control, and eventual absorption into regular government
service. The absence of a clear, uniform and unambiguous policy
on the aspect of reckonable service for pension has led to
inconsistent administrative practices and recurring litigation,
thereby necessitating a comprehensive resolution at the policy
level.
30.
At the same time, this Court is mindful of the settled legal position
that while pension is a valuable right and a form of deferred
compensation, and while the past service rendered by the
petitioners
cannot
be
treated
as
wholly
irrelevant,
the
determination as to whether such service should be counted, and
if so, to what extent, involves complex considerations relating to
financial implications, administrative feasibility, and structural
coherence of service rules. These are matters which fall squarely
within the realm of executive discretion and are not amenable to
direct adjudication by this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction,
in the absence of a crystallized policy decision.
31.
In view of the binding precedent of the Co-ordinate Bench in
WPS No.777/2021 and analogous matters, as affirmed by the
Hon’ble Division Bench in WA No.325/2026, this Court finds no
justifiable reason to take a divergent view in the present matters.
Judicial discipline and consistency demand that this Court follow
the same course of action, particularly when the controversy
involved, the factual matrix, and the reliefs sought are
substantially identical.
32.
Consequently, without expressing any opinion on the merits of
the rival claims of the parties, and without adjudicating upon the
validity of the impugned Clauses 4 and 6 of the order dated
30.06.2018 or the order dated 24.06.2024, this Court deems it
appropriate to dispose of the present batch of writ petitions in
terms of the directions issued in WPS No.777/2021.
33.
Accordingly, the respondent-State is directed to undertake a
comprehensive, conscious and reasoned reconsideration of the
entire issue relating to the determinative date of appointment and
reckoning of qualifying service for pensionary purposes in respect
of employees like the petitioners, whose service commenced as
Shikshakarmis and culminated in absorption into regular
government service. While undertaking such exercise, the State
shall take into account all relevant considerations, including the
continuity of service, nature of duties performed, source of salary,
administrative and disciplinary control, and the constitutional
mandate of equality, fairness and non-discrimination under
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
34.
The State Government shall also ensure that the decision so
taken is clear, categorical, uniformly applicable to all similarly
situated employees, and is supported by cogent reasons in the
form of a speaking order, so as to obviate further ambiguity and
litigation. It is further directed that such decision shall be taken
and communicated within a period of 120 days from the date of
receipt of a copy of this order.
35.
It is made clear that all contentions of the parties on merits,
including those relating to entitlement, applicability of pension
rules, delay and laches, estoppel, and financial implications, are
left open to be considered by the State Government while
undertaking the aforesaid exercise, and, if necessary, in any
subsequent proceedings that may arise pursuant to the decision
so taken.
36.
With the aforesaid observations and directions, all the writ
petitions, namely WPS No.7714/2024, WPS No.8475/2024 and
WPS No.674/2025, stand disposed of.
37.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Sd/-
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Yogesh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review