Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/45
GAHC010058362017
2026:GAU-AS:9326
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7914/2017
DILIP KARMAKAR and 25 ORS.
ASSTT TEACHER, DHRUBAJYOTI L.P. SCHOOL, CHARIDEO SONARI
SUBDIVISION, BLOCK- SONARI SEPON, DIST- SIVSAGAR, ASSAM.
2: RANJIT HAZARIKA
ASSTT TEACHER
870 NO BHAZONI L.P. SCHOOL
NAZIRA-SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK KHELUA
DIST.- SIVSAGAR
ASSAM.
3: MRS. RENU BEGUM
ASSTT TEACHER
MAIBELA MOSZUR L.P. SCHOOL
NAZIRA-SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK- NAZIRA
DIST.- SIVSAGAR
ASSAM.
4: MRS. PUSPA BHUYAN DUTTA
ASSTT TEACHER
870 NO BHAZANI L.P. SCHOOL
NAZIRA-SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK-KHELUA
DIST.- SIVSAGAR
ASSAM.
5: MRS. LABANYA BORGOHAIN
ASSTT TEACHER
SHYAMOL JYOTI L.P. SCHOOL
CHARIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK- KHELUA
Page No.# 2/45
DIST. SIVSAGAR
ASSAM.
6: MD. PRINCH SAIKIA
ASSTT. TEACHER
52 NO MATHURAPUR GANGOLE L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK-KHELUA
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
7: RATUL BORGOHAIN
ASSTT TEACHER
RUPJYOTI L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO-SONARI SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK SONARI SEPON
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
8: SMTI. HEUWALI BORUAH
ASSTT TEACHER. 945 NO. RANGAPATHAR L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO-SONARI SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK SONARI SEPON
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
9: MRS. MINU BEGUM
ASSTT TEACHER. 91 NO. NAMTICHARIALI L.P. SCHOOL
NAZIRA-SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK-NAZIRA
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
10: MRS. PADMA BORGOHAIN DOIMARI
ASSTT TEACHER
468 NO. TIOKHABI L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO-SONARI SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK SAPEKHATI
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
11: RAJ KUMAR SAH
ASSTT TEACHER. SONARI HINDI L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
Page No.# 3/45
ASSAM.
12: MRS. KAMALA SUKLA BAIDY
ASSTT TEACHER. SONARI ADERSH L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
13: MRS. PREMODA NAYOK
ASSTT TEACHER. TOWKOK BAGICHA L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO-SONARI SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK- SONARI SEPON
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
14: MRS. SIMA BEGUM
ASSTT TEACHER. TOWKOK BAGICHA L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO-SONARI SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK-SONARI SEPON
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
15: SMTI. RAHANA AHMED
ASSTT TEACHER. TOWKOK BAGICHA L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO-SONARI SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK-SONARI SEPON
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
16: MRS. MAMONI MECH
ASSTT TEACHER. SANTIPUR L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
UNDER 1 NO. SONARI SADAR L.P.C.
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
17: MRS. MONJU MALI
ASSTT TEACHER. JYOTIPRASAD L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO-SONARI SUB-DIVISION
UNDER 2 NO. SONARI SADAR L.P.C.
DIST.- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
18: PORESH TASSA
Page No.# 4/45
ASSTT TEACHER. JOYA L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION UNDER 1 NO. SONARI SADAR L.P.
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
19: TILESWAR DARIG
ASSTT TEACHER
SUNAPUR MAMAL L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK-SONARI SEPON
DIST.- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
20: MD. ABDUL ROFIK
ASSTT TEACHER. MATHURAPUR AMGURI L.P.SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK-KHELUA
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
21: MRS. BONTI GOHAIN
ASSTT TEACHER. 309 NO. BHOJOL L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO-SONARI SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
22: MRS. PRITI REKHA MOHAN
ASSTT TEACHER. JOYA L.P. SCHOOL SONARI
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
23: MRS. PARUL GOGOI
ASSTT TEACHER. BANFERA BAGICHA L.P. SCHOOL
CARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK-SONARI SEPON
DIST.- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
24: PHULAMANI DIGHINGIA
ASSTT TEACHER. CHINIHABI L.P. SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
Page No.# 5/45
BLOCK- SONARI SEPON
DIST.- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
25: MRS. PURABI PHUKAN
ASSTT TEACHER. BORAHI GARDEN L.P. SCHOOL. CHARAIDEO SONARI
SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK- SONARI SEPON
DIST.- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
26: MRS. BOBY BURAGOHAIN
ASSTT TEACHER NAPHUK BAGISHA L.P. SCHOOL. CHARAIDEO SONARI
SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK- SONARI SEPON
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM and 6 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY ITS COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT.
OF ASSAM, EDUCATION ELEMENTARY DEPARTMENT, DISPUR,
GUWAHATI-781006.
2:THE SECRETARY
FINANCE EC III DEPTT.
GOVT. OF ASSAM
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-781006
ASSAM.
3:THE DIRECTOR
ELEMENTARY EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI-19.
4:THE DIST. ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
SIVASAGAR
P.O.
P.S. AND DIST.- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
Page No.# 6/45
PIN-785640.
5:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISION
P.O. SIVASAGAR
DIST.- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
6:THE DY. INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
CHARAIDEO-SONARI SUB-DIVISION
P.O. SONARI
DIST.- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN-785690.
7:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
SIVASAGAR DISTRICT
SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN-785640
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR.S F CHISTIE, MD.M U AHMED
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, EDUCATION, SC, FINANCE,GA, ASSAM
Linked Case : WP(C)/4626/2017
KRISHNA NEWAR and 16 ORS.
ASSISTANT TEACHER
MOHANGAON RAJAPUKHURI L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SONARI SEPON
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
2: MISS SAHIDA BANU
ASSISTANT TEACHER
DHRUBAJYOTI L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SONARI SEPON
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
3: SMTI SARIFA BEGUM
Page No.# 7/45
ASSISTANT TEACHER
DHRUBAJYOTI L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SONARI SEPON
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
4: SRI UTTAM GUPTA
ASSISTANT TEACHER
576 NO MOHANGAON L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SONARI SEPON
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
5: MRS. SANTANA GOGOI
ASSISTANT TEACHER
944 NO. LIGIRIBARI L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR KHELUA SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
6: SMTI RUMA DEVI
ASSISTANT TEACHER 753 NO. KOLIAMATI L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR KHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
7: SMTI BHANU GOGOI
ASSISTANT TEACHER
PATHARMURI L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR KHELUA SIAVASGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
8: SMTI DIBYA RAJKUMARI
ASSISTANT TEACHER
339 NO. CHARIMUTHIYA L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR KHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
9: SRI HIRANYA SONOWAL
ASSISTANT TEACHER
751 NO. HOLLOW PHUKON L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR KHELUA
Page No.# 8/45
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
10: SRI JAYANANDA SARMA
ASSISTANT TEACHER
246 NNO. DHAMDHULI L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK-SIVASAGAR KHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
11: SRI SRIBATSHYA SAIKIA
ASSISTANT TEACHER
PATHARMURI L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR KHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
12: MRIDUL CHETIA
ASSISTANT TEACHER
CHULADHARA L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR KHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
13: SMTI DIPTI BORGOHAIN
ASSISTANT TEACHER
689 NO. GORIA PATHAR L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR KHELUA SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
14: SMTI. MANASHI RAJKUMARI
ASSISTANT TEACHER
1000 NO. KHANIKAR PUKHURI L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR KHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
15: SMTI. MONJU PHUKON
ASSISTANT TEACHER
MATHURAPUR
Page No.# 9/45
AMGURI L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR KHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB- DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
16: SRI HARANATH GOGOI
ASSISTANT TEACHER
689 NO. GORIA PATHAR L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
17: MD. TAFIJUR RAHMAN
ASSISTANT TEACHER
DIGHALI SHYAM L.P. SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR KHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM and 13 ORS.
REP. BY ITS COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
EDUCATION DEPTT.
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-781006
2:THE SECRETARY
FINANCE EC III DEPTT.
GOVT. OF ASSAM
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-781006
3:THE DIRECTOR
ELEMENTARY EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI-1
4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
SIVASAGAR DISTRICT
ASSAM
5:THE DISTRICT ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
SIVASAGAR
PO SIVASAGAR
DIST. SIVASAGAR
Page No.# 10/45
ASSAM
6:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
CHARAIDEO
SONARI
PO-SONARI
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
7:THE DEUPTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
SIVASAGAR
PO-SIVASAGAR
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
8:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
SAPEKHATI PO-SIVASAGAR
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
9:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
SIVASAGAR KHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB DIVISION
PO-SIVASAGAR
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
10:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCAITON OFFICER
SONARI BLOCK SEPON CHARIDEO
SONARI SUB DIVISION
PO SONARI
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
11:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
SAPEKHATI
CHARAIDEO
SONARI SUB-DIVISION
PO-SONARI
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
12:THE TREASURY OFFICER
CHARAIDEO
SONARI
PO-SONARI
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
Page No.# 11/45
13:THE TREASURY OFFICER
CHARAIDEO
SONARI
PO SONARI
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
14:THE TREASURY OFFICER
CHARAIDEO
SONARI
PO-SONARI
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
-----------Advocate for : MR.S F CHISTIE
Advocate for : SC
FINANCE appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM and 13 ORS.
Linked Case : WP(C)/4781/2017
PANKHI GOSWAMI and 21 ORS.
ASSISTANT TEACHER
146 NO. POTIA GAON LP SCHOOL
BLOCK SIBSAGARKHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB- DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
2: RINA KONWAR
ASSISTANT TEACHER
676 NO. SUMONI GAON LP SCHOOL BLOCK SIBSAGAR KHELUA SIBSAGAR
SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
3: PARISHMA KAKOTI
ASSISTANT TEACHER
1007 NO. KHUMTAI GAON LP SCHOOL BLOCK SEPON CHARAIDEO SONARI
SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
4: MOMIBALA PHUKAN
ASSISTANT TEACHER
998 NO. KALAKATA MAJGAON L P SCHOOL BLOCK
SAPEKHATI CHARAIDEOSONARI SUB-DIVISION
Page No.# 12/45
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM
5: GUNADA DOLEY
ASSISTANT TEACHER 493 NO. BETENA MODEL LP SCHOOL BLOCK DEMOW
SIVASAGAR SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
6: RINKUMONI GOGOI
ASSISTANT TEACHER
540 NO. DISHANG GOHAIN L P SCHOOL BLOCK DEMOW
SIVASAGAR SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
7: BHARATI BURAGOHAIN
ASSISTANT TEACHER
PASCHIM NAOJAN LP SCHOOL
BLOCK DEMOW
SIVASAGAR SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
8: GIRI KANTA MILI
ASSISTANT TEACHER
987 NO. DEMOW MUKH JANAJATI LP SCHOOL BLOCK DEMOW
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
9: DULUMONI DEORI
ASSISTANT TEACHER
KALIAPANI MAZDUR LP SCHOOL
BLOCK DEMOW
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
10: KUSHAL BURAGOHAIN
ASSISTANT TEACHER
220 NO. KAMALDOI SUKANPUKHURI LP SCHOOL
BLOCK DEMOW SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
11: PAPORI HAZARIKA
ASSISTANT TEACHER 552 NO. MANGALA MOUT LP SCHOOL
Page No.# 13/45
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
12: SWAPNA SAIKIA
ASSISTANT TEACHER
541 NO. BORSAYAK LP SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
13: ALAKA HATIMURIA
ASSISTANT TEACHER
283 NO. KALIAPANI L P SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIBSAGAR
ASSAM
14: BABITA BORGOHAIN
ASSISTANT TEACHER
KALIAPANI MAZDUR LP SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
15: KANMAI HANDIQUEGOGOI
ASSISTANT TEACHER
138 NO. SASHIMAI GOGOI LP SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
16: MADHUSMRITY GOGOIBARUAH
ASSISTANT TEACHER
138 NO. SASHIMAI GOGOI LP SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB- DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
17: BHON KALITA
ASSISTANT TEACHER
RAJAPOOL LP SCHOOL
Page No.# 14/45
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
18: URBASHI BHAGAWATI
ASSISTANT TEACHER
ATHKHEL BAGISHA LP SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGAR KHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
19: BASANTA NEOG
ASSISTANT TEACHER
JOGENDRA NATH BURAGOHAIN LP SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
20: PURABI BORUAH
ASSISTANT TEACHER
DIPLING BAGISHA LP SCHOOL
BLOCK SEPONSONARI
CHARAIDEOSONARI SUB -DIVISION
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM
21: AMINA BEGUM
ASSISTANT TEACHER
300 NO. ACHAL PATHAR LP SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
22: BINUMAI CHETIA
ASSISTANT TEACHER
277 NO. BARPATHAR LP SCHOOL
BLOCK SEPONSONARI
CHARAIDEOSONARI SUB-DIVISION
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM and 15 ORS.
REP. BY ITS COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM
Page No.# 15/45
EDUCATION DEPTT.
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006
2:THE SECRETARY
FINANCEEC-III DEPTT.
GOVT OF ASSAM
DISPUR
GHY- 781006
ASSAM
3:THE DIRECTOR
ELEMENTARY EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI- 1
4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
SIVASAGAR DIST
ASSAM
5:THE DISTRICT ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
SIVASAGAR
P.O- SIVASAGAR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
6:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
CHARAIDEO SONARI
P.O- SONARI
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
7:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
SIVASAGAR
P.O- SIVASAGAR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
8:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
NAZIRA
P.O- NAZIRA
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
9:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
SIVASAGARKHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
Page No.# 16/45
P.O- SIVASAGAR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
10:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
SONARI BLOCKSEPON
CHARAIDEO
SONARI SUB-DIVISION
P.O- SONARI
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
11:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
SAPEKHATI CHARAIDEO
SONARI SUB-DIVISION
P.O- SONARI
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
12:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
DEMOW
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
P.O- SIVASAGAR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
13:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
NAZIRA
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB-DIVISION
P.O- NAZIRA
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
14:THE TREASURY OFFICER
SONARI
P.O- SONARI
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
15:THE TREASURY OFFICER
SIVASAGAR
P.O- SIVASAGAR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
16:THE TREASURY OFFICER
NAZIRA
P.O- NAZIRA
Page No.# 17/45
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
-----------Advocate for : MR.S F CHISTIE
Advocate for : SC
FINANCE appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM and 15 ORS.
Linked Case : WP(C)/4618/2017
RUPALI KONWER and 21 ORS.
ASSISTANT TEACHER
573 NO. NAPHUK DOLOI L P SCHOOL
BLOCK SONARISEPON
CHARAIDEOSONARI SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
2: BIMALA GOGOI
ASSTT. TEACHER
1007 NO. KHUMTAI GAON L P SCHOOL BLOCK
SEPONSONARICHARAIDEOSONARI SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
3: DIPALI KONWER
ASSTT. TEACHER
1007 NO. KHUMTAI GAON L P SCHOOL BLOCK
SEPONSONARICHARAIDEOSONARI SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
4: RUNU MILI
ASSTT. TEACHER
1007 NO. KHUMTAI GAON L P SCHOOL BLOCK
SEPONSONARICHARAIDEOSONARI SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
5: NARJIARA BEGUM
ASSTT. TEACHER
SAFRAI BAGAN L P SCHOOL BLOCK SONARISEPON CHARAIDEOSONARI
SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
6: SAJNA BEGUM
ASSTT. TEACHER
Page No.# 18/45
MATHURAPUR BAGICHA L P SCHOOL BLOCK KHELUASIBSAGAR
SIBSAGAR SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
7: TILOK GOGOI
ASSTT. TEACHER
BALIBOR L P SCHOOLBLOCK DEMOW
SIBSAGAR
SIBSAGAR SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIBSAGAR
ASSAM
8: MUAZIM AHMED
ASSTT. TEACHER
913 NO KUSHIAMARI L P SCHOOL BLOCK DEMOW SIBSAGAR
SIBSAGAR SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
9: JONAKI KHETRAPHAL
ASSTT. TEACHER JURIA MAZDUR L P SCHOOL
BLOCK DEMOW. SIBSAGAR
SIBSAGAR SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
10: RUNUMI BORA
ASSTT. TEACHER
424 NO. KAWAIMARI L P SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
11: HAMIDA BEGUM
ASSTT. TEACHER
354 NO. KALGAON L P SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
12: SORIFUL HUSSAIN
ASSTT. TEACHER
CHARAIDEO BAGAN L P SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISION
Page No.# 19/45
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
13: DIPALI ARANDHARA
ASSTT. TEACHER
92 NO. GORAKHIYA PUKHURI L P SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
14: JAYANTI DOIMARI
ASSTT. TEACHER
93 NO. NAGAJAN L P SCHOOL
BLOCK SAPEKHATI
CHARAIDEOSONARI SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
15: PADMA DEVI
ASSTT. TEACHER
850 NO. MAZI BASTI L P SCHOOL
BLOCK SAPEKHATI
CHARAIDEOSONARI SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
16: KHIRADA SONOWAL
ASSTT. TEACHER
577 NO. KONWER GAON L P SCHOOL
BLOCK SAPEKHATI
CHARAIDEOSONARI SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
17: ARPANA GOGOI
ASSTT. TEACHER
476 NO. ROHAN BORTANI L P SCHOOL
BLOCK SAPEKHATI
CHARAIDEOSONARI SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
18: RITA RAJKUMARI
ASSTT. TEACHER
TOM TOM TALA L P SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
Page No.# 20/45
ASSAM
19: YAKUB ALI
ASSTT. TEACHER
BANHGARH ADARSHA L P SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGARKHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
20: SMRITI REKHA GOGOI
ASSTT. TEACHER
386 NO. SILIKHAGURI L P SCHOOL
BLOCK SIVASAGARKHELUA SIVASAGAR SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
21: MONJU GOGOI
ASSTT. TEACHER
NAMATI SUNPURA L P SCHOOL
BLOCK NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
22: RIDIP GOGOI
688 NO. HATI PUKHURI L P SCHOOL
BLOCK SAPEKHATI
CHARAIDEO
SONARI
SUB DIVISION
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM and 15 ORS.
REP. BY ITS COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM
EDUCATION ELEMENTARY DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006
ASSAM
2:THE SECRETARY
FINANCEEC III DEPTT.
GOVT OF ASSAM
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006
ASSAM
Page No.# 21/45
3:THE DIRECTOR
ELEMENTARY EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI- 19
ASSAM
4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
SIVASAGAR DISTRICT
ASSAM
PIN- 785640
5:THE DISTRICT ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
SIVASAGAR
P.O- SIVASAGAR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN- 785640
6:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
CHARAIDEO
SONARI
P.O- SONARI
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
7:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
SIBASAGAR
P.O- SIBASAGAR
DIST- SIBASAGAR
ASSAM
8:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
NAZIRA
P.O- NAZIRA
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
9:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
KHELUA
SIVASAGAR SUB DIVISION
P.O- SIVASAGAR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
10:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
CHARAIDEOSEPON
Page No.# 22/45
CHARAIDEO SONARI SUB DIVISION
P.O- SONARI
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
11:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
NAZIRA
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISIONP.O- NAZIRA
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
12:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
DEMOW
SIVASAGAR SUB DIVISION
P.O- DEMOW
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
13:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
SAPEKHATI
CHARAIDEO
SONARI SUB DIVISION
P.O- SAPEKHATI
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
14:THE TREASURY OFFICER
CHARAIDEO
SONARI
P.O- SONARI
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
15:THE TREASURY OFFICER
NAZIRA
P.O- NAZIRA
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
16:THE TREASURY OFFICER
SIVASAGAR
P.O- SIVASAGAR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
-----------Advocate for : MD.M U AHMED
Advocate for : MS.K PHUKANr-4 appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM and 15
ORS.
Page No.# 23/45
Linked Case : WP(C)/7004/2017
ATUL BORUAH and 26 ORS.
ASSTT. TEACHER 492 NO LUKHURAKHAN L.P. SCHOOL UNDER DEPUTY
INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL CHRAIDEO SONARI BLOCK SONARI SEPON DIST.
CHARAIDEO
ASSAM
2: MRS PUNYA BHORALI
NAMONI SUNDARPUR L.P SCHOOL
UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI (SEPON)
DIST-CHARAIDEO
ASSAM
3: MRS. MONJUMONI BHORALI
633 NO. KHUKAMORA L.P SCHOOL UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF
SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI (SEPON)
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM.
4: MRS. RITA PHUKAN
778 NO. KAKOOWANI L.P SCHOOL UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI (SEPON) DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM.
5: MRS PURNIMA GOGOI
277 NO. BORPATHER L.P SCHOOL UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI (SEPON)
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM.
6: MRS MOMI BEGUM
840 NO. DIGHOLIA THANPATHAR L.P SCHOOL UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR
OF SCHOOL
Page No.# 24/45
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK-SONARI (SEPON)
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM
7: MD. NOZIRUDDIN AHMED
840 NO. DIGHOLIA THANPATHAR L.P SCHOOL
UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI (SEPON)
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM.
8: XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
AS PER THER ORDER DATED-20.12.2023
PETITIONER NO. 8 HAS BEEN STRUCK OFF.
9: MRS. PRONITA BORGOHAIN
KHOOMTAIE HEUJEPUR L.P SCHOOL UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF
SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI (SEPON)
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM.
10: MR. LOLIT CHANGMAI
492 NO. LUKHURAKHAN L. UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI (SEPON)
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM.
11: MR. BUDHESWAR GORH
633 NO. KHUKAMORA L.P SCHOOL
UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI (SEPON) DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM.
12: XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
AS PER ORDER DATED-20.12.2023
PETITIONER NO. 12 HAS BEEN STRUCK OFF.
Page No.# 25/45
13: XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
AS PER ORDER DATED- 20.12.2023 PETITIONER NO. 13 HAS BEEN STRUCK
OFF.
14: XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
AS PER ORDER DATED- 20.12.2023 PETITIONER NO. 14 HAS BEEN STRUCK
OFF.
15: MD. ROMISH ALI
TARANIPATHER L.P SCHOOL
UNDER DEPUTY INSPETOR OF SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI (SEPON)
DIST-CHARAIDEO
ASSAM.
16: XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
AS PER THE ORDER DATED-20.12.2023 PETITIONER NO. 16 HAS BEEN
STRUCK OFF.
17: MR. KHATRADHAR GOGOI
153 NO. JOJOLIHABI L.P SCHOOL UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI ( SEPON) DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM.
18: MRS. MORJINA TANTI (KUMAR)
KHOOMTAI BAGICHA L.P SCHOOL
UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI( SEPON)
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM.
19: MR. RAJEN PHUKAN
262 NO. BURAGOHAINBARI L.P SCHOOL
UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI (SEPON)
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM.
20:
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Page No.# 26/45
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXX
AS PER ORDER DATED-20.12.2023 PETITIONER NO. 22 HAS BEEN STRUCK
OFF.
21: MRS .LILA BURAGOHAIN
HALOGURI NOVAJYOTI L.P SCHOOL
UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI (SEPON)
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM
22: XXXXXXXXXX
AS PER THE ORDER DATED-20.12.2023
PETITIONER NO. 22 HAS BEEN STRUCK OFF.
23: XXXXXXXXX
AS PER THE ORDER DATED-20.12.2023
PETITIONER NO. 23 HAS BEEN STRUCK OFF.
24: XXXXXXXXX
AS PER ORDER DATED-20.12.2023 PETITIONER NO. 24 HAS BEEN STRUCK
OFF.
25: MR. ANANTA BORGOHAIN
NALANIBAM L.P SCHOOL UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
CHARAIDEO SONARI
BLOCK- SONARI (SEPON)
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM.
26: SMTI PUHITA BORAH
31 NO. KUMARKATA L.P SCHOOL
UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
SIVSAGAR
BLOCK- DEMOW
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
27: MRS. SUFIA BEGUM
807 NO. DA GAON L.P SCHOOL
UNDER DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
SIVASAGAR
BLOCK- NAZIRA
DIST- SIVASAGAR
Page No.# 27/45
ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM and 6 ORS.
REP. BY ITS COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
EDUCATION ELEMENTARY DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006.
-----------Advocate for : MD.M U AHMED
Advocate for : GA
ASSAM appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM and 6 ORS.
Linked Case : WP(C)/7685/2017
XXXXXXXXX and 6 ORS.
AS PER ORDER DATED 20.12.2023 PETITIONER NO. 1 HAS BEEN STRUCK
OFF.
3: SMTI. APARAJITA BORUAH
ASSISTANT TEACHER
192 NO. BORTOLA MOKTAB L.P. SCHOOL
UNDER DY. INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
NAZIRA SUB- DIVISION
BLOCK- NAZIRA
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
4: SRI JAYANTA NEOG
ASSISTANT TEACHER
BORTOLA L.P. SCHOOL
UNDER DY. INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
NAZIRA SUB- DIVISION
BLOCK- NAZIRA
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
5: SMTI. PRASSANNA KUMARI PHUKON
ASSISTANT TEACHER
KALIAPANI L.P. SCHOOL
UNDER DY. INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK- DEMOW
SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
Page No.# 28/45
6: SRI MUNIN DUTTA
ASSISTANT TEACHER
NA-HAT BONUA L.P. SCHOOL
UNDER DY.INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
SIVASAGAR
SUB-DIVSION
BLOCK - DEMOW
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
7: SMTI. BICHITRA GOGOI
ASSISTANT TEACHER
139 NO. BORDUBA L.P. SCHOOL
UNDER DY. INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
CHARAIDEO- SONARI SUB-DIVISION
BLOCK- SEPON
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM and 7 ORS.
REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
EDUCATION ELEMENTARY DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAAHTI - 781006.
2:THE SECRETARY
FINANE EC-III DEPARTMENT
GOVT. OF ASSAM
DISPUR
GUWAHATI - 781006
ASSAM
3:THE DIRECTOR
ELEMENTARY EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI - 19
4:THE DISTRICT ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
SIVASAGAR
P.O.
P.S. and DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN - 785640.
Page No.# 29/45
5:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
SIVASAGAR
SIVASAGAR SUB-DIVISION
P.O. SIVASAGAR
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN - 785640.
6:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
CHARAIDEO- SONARI SUB-DIVISION
P.O. SONARI DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
7:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
NAZIRA SUB-DIVISION
P.O. NAZIRA DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
8:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
SIVASAGAR DISTRICT
SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN - 785640
-----------Advocate for : MR.S F CHISTIE
Advocate for : SC
FINANCE appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM and 7 ORS.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
23/06/2026
Heard Mr. M U Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioners and Mr. B
Kaushik, learned Standing counsel, Department of School Education, appearing
for the respondents.
Page No.# 30/45
2.
The petitioners by way of instituting the present writ petition have prayed
for a direction upon the respondent authorities to release to them the arrears of
their salaries pending, w.e.f. March, 2012, as well as for a direction to release to
them their current salaries.
3.
As projected in the above noted writ petitions, the petitioners, herein,
were appointed as Stipendiary Teachers by the District Elementary Education
Officer, Sivasagar and the Deputy Inspector of Schools, Nazira and Charaideo
Sub-Divisions, during the years 1994, 1995, 1996 and 1999. The appointments
of the petitioners as Stipendiary Teachers is projected to be so done after a due
selection was carried out in the matter.
The petitioners categorically contend that their initial appointments are not
irregular and/or illegal and were recruited after they were selected in a
selection, held in pursuance to an advertisement issued for the purpose. The
petitioners project that they were deputed to undergo the Basic Training Course
and on completion of the said course, the petitioners were authorized their
respective scales of pay.
The petitioners contend that they were in receipt of their regular salaries
till August, 2006. However, post August 2006, the payment of their regular
salaries were stopped and the names of the petitioners came to be included in a
list of excess teachers. The salaries of the petitioners were being, thereafter,
released on annual retention basis. The petitioners project that in the year
2009, their names were so incorporated against supernumerary posts created
for the purpose of releasing to the petitioners their due monthly salaries.
As projected in the writ petitions, around 1528 nos. of supernumerary
Page No.# 31/45
posts were created in the year 2009 and the petitioners contend that such posts
were created for them only. The petitioners in the above noted writ petitions
were in the above manner, being released their salaries till February, 2012. The
petitioners have also projected that they being appointed after a due process of
selection and being in continuous service, having completed their respective
Basic Training Courses, the petitioners are at par with regular employees and
accordingly, their salaries in arrears, w.e.f. March, 2012, was to be released to
them.
The petitioners in support of their case, had referred to the directions
passed by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court, vide order dated 08.08.2016 in
WP(C) No. 3045/2012, judgment & order dated 10.02.2017 in WP(C) No.
1449/2014 and judgment & order dated 19.05.2017 in WP(C) No. 2712/2017,
which are projected to have been instituted by persons similarly situated like the
petitioners, herein. The salaries of the petitioners having remained in arrears in
spite of repeated approaches made by the petitioners, the petitioners have
instituted the above noted writ petitions, praying for the reliefs, as noticed
hereinabove.
4.
Mr. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioners, at the outset, has
submitted that the case of the petitioners, herein, is squarely covered by the
decision of the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court passed vide order dated
08.08.2016 in WP(C) No. 3045/2012, judgment & order dated 10.02.2017 in
WP(C) No. 1449/2014 and judgment & order dated 19.05.2017 in WP(C) No.
2712/2017 and accordingly, the petitioners in the above noted writ petitions are
also entitled for a direction to be authorized their respective salaries in arrears
since March, 2012.
Page No.# 32/45
4.1
Mr. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that the
petitioners in the present writ petitions were all recruited in pursuance to a
process of selection and were appointed against regular sanctioned vacant
posts. He, however, submits that the respondents in the Education Department,
with a view to provide protection to the illegally/irregularly appointed teachers,
had denoted the petitioners to be excess appointees and accordingly,
incorporated their names in a list of 1528 of irregular/illegal teachers and had
created supernumerary posts for payment of salaries to them.
4.2
Mr. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the
petitioners, herein, being recruited in pursuance to a regular selection process
initially as Stipendiary Teachers and thereafter, on completion of their Basic
Training Course being appointed as Assistant Teachers, the authorization of the
scale of pay of the petitioners on completion of their respective Basic Training
Course, would go to indicate that the petitioners in the above noted writ
petitions were all recruited by following the due process mandated in this
connection.
4.3
Having made the said submissions, Mr. Ahmed, learned counsel for the
petitioners, has referred to orders passed in respect of some of the petitioners
in the above noted writ petitions engaging them as Teachers/Tutors with
prospective effect, i.e., w.e.f. 01.11.2020 and also bringing them within the
purview of the New Pension Scheme.
4.4
Mr. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the said
accommodation made in respect of such petitioners, involved in the above noted
writ petitions would be of no consequence, inasmuch as, the same has the
effect of wiping out the services rendered by each of such petitioners, w.e.f. the
Page No.# 33/45
date of their respective initial appointments. He submits that the petitioners
having been appointed as Assistant Teachers in continuance of their initial
appointment as Stipendiary Teachers, after completing the Basic Training
Course, the petitioners are required to be deemed to be in regular service, with
effect from their respective dates of appointment as Stipendiary Teachers.
4.5
Mr. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that the
subsequent accommodation of the petitioners as Teachers/Tutors was so made
taking advantage of the position the petitioners had found themselves to be on
account of non-receipt of salaries since March, 2012. Mr. Ahmed, submits that
the said accommodation would also not be maintainable considering the
bargaining power the petitioners had with the mighty state.
4.6
In this connection, Mr. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioners has
referred to the following decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases of
(i) Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Limited and Another Vs.
Brojonath Ganguly and Another, reported in 1986 3 SCC 156 and (ii) Union of
India and Others Vs. Bharat Enterprises, reported in 2023 SCC OnLine SC 369.
4.7
Mr. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioners, has further submitted that
the respondent authorities in their pleadings, have only referred to the
advertisement issued in the year 2012, with regard to the screening
contemplated for determining the illegal and/or irregular teachers. Mr. Ahmed,
has submitted that the petitioners had approached the authorities by way of
submitting representations, requiring their exemption from the said screening
process. However, the respondent authorities, vide a communication dated
20.02.2012, had rejected such prayer of the petitioners and required the
petitioners to submit their applications in pursuance to the advertisement in
Page No.# 34/45
question. He submits that the contention of the petitioners that they were
forced to appear in the screening examination, accordingly, stands affirmed.
4.8
Mr. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioners has further referred to the
Office Memorandum dated 15.11.2011, laying down the guidelines for
functioning of the screening committee constituted for the purpose of screening
the illegally/irregularly appointed teachers working in Lower Primary/Upper
Primary Schools in the State. He submits that a perusal of the said guidelines
would reveal that the same was for determining illegal as well as irregular
teachers. However, the respondents in the advertisement, had stipulated that
eligibility for applying against the said advertisement would be with regard to
persons appointed during the period 1991 to 2001 in different Lower
Primary/Upper Primary schools and working without break till date, but not
getting their salaries since joining of getting the same intermittently.
Accordingly, he submits that the advertisement was so issued invariance with
the requirements laid down in the guidelines dated 15.11.2011.
4.9
Mr. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioners, has further by referring to
an RTI reply dated 17.11.2008 submitted that the respondents had contended
that no genuine teachers has been identified in Sivasagar Sub-Division.
Secondly working teachers number is more than the budget allotment posts.
Accordingly, he submits that without there being a determination of genuine and
non-genuine teachers, the steps taken by the respondents in the matter is
clearly impermissible.
4.10 In the above premises, Mr. Ahmed, submits that although, the petitioners
have not assailed the subsequent accommodation orders passed in their
respective cases in the present writ petitions, this Court would be pleased to
Page No.# 35/45
mould the reliefs sought for in the writ petitions and direct the respondents to
effect such accommodation with retrospective effect, w.e.f. the date each of the
petitioners in the above noted writ petitions had cleared their respective Basic
Training Courses and to release to the petitioners their salaries in arrears.
4.11
Mr. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioners further submits that as
some of the petitioners had already retired and/or died-in-harness, the
respondent authorities be also directed to reckon the period of services
rendered by such petitioners with effect from their initial engagement as
Stipendiary Teachers for the purpose of computing their pension and pensionary
benefits, which is now required to be so computed by applying the provisions of
the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969.
5.
Per contra, Mr. B Kaushik, learned Standing counsel, Department of School
Education, has submitted that in pursuance to the directions passed by this
Court with regard to the manner in which the services of illegal and/or irregular
teachers are to be so considered, the Government had placed the matter before
the Cabinet in its meeting held on 26.02.2011. Thereafter, in terms of the
decisions arrived at in the matter, the Education Department had proposed to
constitute a Screening Committee to examine the validity of the appointments of
teachers, who are claiming regularization and salaries. Accordingly, an Office
Memorandum dated 15.11.2011, was issued and a Screening Committee was
constituted to examine the cases of irregularly/illegally appointed teachers, so
as to arrive at a decision for their regularization and entitlement of salaries or
otherwise. To facilitate the teachers, who are not in receipt of salaries for
considerable periods of time and who have been projected to be either
irregularly and/or illegally appointed, to have their cases considered by the said
Page No.# 36/45
Screening
Committee
constituted
vide
the
Office
Memorandum
dated
15.11.2011, the Director of Elementary Education, Assam had published
advertisements in newspapers, inviting applications from such category of
teachers appointed during the years 1991-2001. Such advertisements were
issued in the news dailies in its issues dated 01.02.2012 and 04.02.2012.
5.1
Mr. Kaushik, learned Standing counsel, Department of School Education,
submits that in pursuance to the said advertisements, along with other similarly
situated persons, the petitioners, had also submitted their respective
applications, along with the requisite particulars for having their cases placed
before the Screening Committee.
5.2
Mr. Kaushik, learned Standing counsel, Department of School Education
submits that the above noted writ petitions were only instituted in the year
2017. However, in the writ petitions, the petitioners have not challenged the
process initiated vide the
said advertisements dated
01.02.2012 and
04.02.2012, although, they were found to have subjected themselves to the
said process.
5.3
Mr. Kaushik, learned Standing counsel, Department of School Education
has further submitted that the petitioners in the above noted writ petitions have
also not projected as to why the process as initiated vide advertisement dated
01.02.2012 and 04.02.2012, cannot be made applicable in their respective
cases.
5.4
Mr. Kaushik, learned Standing counsel, Department of School Education
submits that after the applications were scrutinized and the persons eligible for
being placed before the Screening Committees shortlisted, the constituted
Page No.# 37/45
Screening Committees had proceeded to examine the applications submitted in
the matter and thereafter, the Screening Committees as constituted had
segregated the teachers appearing before it into four categories. The broad
categories into which the applicants were so incorporated are as follows:“Category 1 - Recommended and working till date 136.
Category 2 - Recommended but discontinued jobs - 250.
Category 3 - Not recommended but working till date - 8470.
Category 4 - Not recommended and discontinued jobs - 2900 .”
5.5
Mr. Kaushik, learned Standing counsel, Department of School Education
submits that on conclusion of the follow up proceedings involved and also on
receipt of the approval, the Committee constituted for the purpose, had further
prepared three lists. List-1 by including therein Teachers, who received salaries
at some point of time and have JBT/D.El.Ed., qualification, List-2 included
Teachers, who received salaries at some point of time, but did not have
JBT/D.El.Ed. qualification and List-3 included Teachers, who neither received
salaries nor qualified the training in JBT/D.El.Ed.
5.6
Basing on the Cabinet approval granted in the matter, the petitioners in
the above noted writ petitions, who were included in List-1 came to be
accommodated as Teachers against posts created for the purpose personal to
them. The petitioners in the above noted writ petitions, who were included in
List-2 came to be so accommodated against posts of Tutors as created personal
to them. The petitioners in the above noted writ petitions, who were not
included in either List-1 or List-2, were not extended with accommodation of
their services as Teachers and/or Tutors.
Page No.# 38/45
5.7
Mr. Kaushik, learned Standing counsel, Department of School Education,
responding to the submissions made by Mr. Ahmed, learned counsel for the
petitioners, with regard to the rejection of the applications submitted by the
petitioners, seeking exemption from the proceedings instituted vide the
advertisement dated 01.02.2012, has submitted that the prayer of the
petitioners for exemption from the screening process having been rejected, they
had not assailed the same before this Court in the present proceedings and/or
in any other proceedings instituted by them. He further submits that the said
aspect of the matter was also not disclosed in the writ petition. He submits that
even the communication dated 20.02.2012, was not challenged, rather the
petitioners have clearly suppressed their participation in the selection process,
as well as the steps taken by them seeking exemption.
5.8
Mr. Kaushik, learned Standing counsel, Department of School Education,
responding to the contentions raised by Mr. Ahmed, by referring to the RTI reply
dated 17.11.2008, has submitted that it is specifically for the said reason that
the respondent authorities had taken a decision to constitute a Screening
Committee. The Screening Committee had, thereafter, examined the service
particulars of each of the applicants and had, thereafter, segregated the
applicants into the list involved. Accordingly, he submits that the exercise carried
out by the Screening Committee is infact a determination of the genuineness of
the appointment in respect of each of the applicants.
5.9
Mr. Kaushik, has further submitted that the petitioners, in the above
noted writ petitions, who in pursuance to the process of screening carried out in
the matter, were accommodated as Teachers and/or as Tutors, had all accepted
their such accommodation with the conditions so stipulated therein, without any
Page No.# 39/45
objection and were thereafter, continuing in their services. He reiterates that the
stipulations as imposed for their such accommodation were also not assailed by
such of the petitioners.
5.10 Accordingly, Mr. Kaushik, learned Standing counsel, Department of School
Education, submits that the petitioners’ participation in the process initiated vide
the advertisements dated 01.02.2012 and 04.02.2012 admittedly reflects that
the initial appointment of the petitioners were either illegal and/or irregular.
Accordingly, he submits that for the period of service rendered by the petitioners
after March, 2012, till the accommodation made in respect of the Teachers, who
were included either in List-1 and/or List-2, indicated hereinabove, would not
mandate a consideration by this Court.
6.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and also perused the
materials available on record.
7.
The prayer of the petitioners as well as the grounds, on which such prayer
is being sought to be supported, has been noticed, hereinabove.
8.
This Court, at the outset, would have to consider as to whether the
petitioners were appointed by following the due procedure as laid down in the
Rules holding the field.
9.
As noticed hereinabove, the petitioners, in the above noted writ petitions,
were appointed during the years 1994, 1995, 1996 and 1999.
10.
It is projected by the petitioners that their appointments were in
pursuance to a due process of selection. While such submissions have been
advanced by the petitioners, it has not been brought on record that they were
Page No.# 40/45
so appointed in pursuance to their selection for the posts involved. The select
lists in question, have also not been placed on record. Further, the merit position
obtained by the petitioners in their respective select lists, have also not been
disclosed. Accordingly, the materials coming on record would go to reveal that
the petitioners, herein, were so appointed in excess of the advertised posts.
Accordingly, the appointments of the petitioners are to be held to be
irregular/illegal.
11.
The prayer of the petitioners in the present writ petitions is for release of
their due salaries in arrears since March, 2012. The above noted writ petitions
were instituted only in the year 2017. Before institution of the present writ
petitions, an important development had taken place, insofar as, the services of
the petitioners are so concerned. The Government in the Education Department,
in pursuance to the directions passed by a Division Bench of this Court in WP(C)
No. 1048/2004, had approached the Cabinet, with regard to regularization of
irregularly/illegally appointed teachers in various Elementary Schools of the
State. The Education Department, thereafter, proposed to constitute a Screening
Committee, to examine the validity of the appointment of the teachers, who
were identified to have been irregularly/illegally appointed. Accordingly, an
Office Memorandum dated 15.11.2011, was issued constituting a Screening
Committee, to examine the cases of such irregularly/illegally appointed
teachers. In terms of the said Office Memorandum dated 15.11.2011, the
Director of Elementary Education, Assam, issued advertisements dated
01.02.2012 and 04.02.2012, inviting applications from teachers, who have not
been
paid
their
respective
salaries
irregularly/illegally appointed teachers.
and
who
were
projected
to
be
Page No.# 41/45
12.
The petitioners, in pursuance to the issuance of the said advertisements,
proceeded to approach the respondent authorities by way of submitting
representations, praying for exempting their cases from the purview of the
Screening
Committee,
as
constituted
vide
Office
Memorandum
dated
15.11.2011.
13.
The said representations submitted by the petitioners, on consideration,
were rejected by the competent authority and the petitioners were required to
submit their applications in pursuance to the advertisements dated 01.02.2012
and 04.02.2012. The prayer made by the petitioners for their exemption was so
rejected vide a communication dated 20.02.2012. The petitioners, accordingly,
submitted their applications in pursuance to the said advertisements dated
01.02.2012 and 04.02.2012.
14.
It is during the pendency of the consideration of the cases of the
petitioners by the constituted Screening Committees that the petitioners had
instituted the present writ petition.
15.
The petitioners, while instituting the present writ petitions, had not
disclosed the fact that they had submitted their respective applications, in
pursuance to the advertisements dated 01.02.2012 and 04.02.2012. The
petitioners, in the above noted writ petitions, have also not made any averment
to the effect that they were not to be held to be covered by the provisions of
the Office Memorandum dated 15.11.2011. Further, there is no challenge
presented
to
the
Office
Memorandum
dated
15.11.2011
or
to
the
advertisements issued in pursuance, thereof. The rejection of the prayer of the
petitioners for exempting them from the screening process is also not under
challenge.
Page No.# 42/45
16.
As the present matters were pending consideration before this Court, the
Screening Committee as constituted, proceeded to consider the cases of all
irregularly/illegally appointed teachers, including the petitioners in the above
noted writ petitions. Thereafter, the matter was again placed before the State
Cabinet. Thereafter, the Screening Committees constituted for the purpose had
further prepared three lists – List-1 by including therein, Teachers, who received
salaries at some point of time and have JBT/D.El.Ed. qualification; List-2
included Teachers, who received salaries at some point of time, but did not have
JBT/D.El.Ed. qualification; and List-3 included Teachers, who neither received
salaries nor qualified the training in JBT/D.El.Ed. Basing on the Cabinet approval
granted in the matter, the petitioners in the above noted writ petitions, who
were included in List-1 came to be accommodated as Teachers against posts
created for the purpose personal to them. The petitioners in the above noted
writ petitions, who were included in List-2 came to be so accommodated against
posts of Tutors as created personal to them. The petitioners in the above noted
writ petitions, who were not included in either List-1 or List-2, were not
extended with the accommodation of their services as Teachers and/or Tutors.
17.
The petitioners in the above noted writ petitions, who were placed in List-
1 & List-2 and thereafter, accommodated as Teachers and/or Tutors is found by
this Court to have joined their respective services in terms of the
accommodations made, by accepting the stipulations as made in their respective
cases in the orders issued towards accommodating their respective services.
18.
As disclosed by the respondents in their affidavit filed in the present writ
petitions,
the
persons,
who upon
screening,
were accommodated
as
Teachers/Tutors, were held to receive their salaries and/or fixed pay, w.e.f.
Page No.# 43/45
01.11.2020, with a further stipulation that they would not be entitled to claim
any benefits for the past services rendered by such persons, prior to
01.11.2020. Further, such of the petitioners were also placed in the New
Pension Scheme, inasmuch as, the accommodation as effected in their cases,
w.e.f. 01.11.2020, had the effect of effecting a fresh appointment in their cases.
It is found that in the present writ petitions, the petitioners have not assailed
the subsequent accommodations made in their respective cases by the
respondent authorities and the petitioners are found to have been continuing to
enjoy the benefits, as flowing from such accommodation extended to them after
they were so screened for the purpose.
19.
This Court finds that the petitioners having subjected themselves to the
screening process, the petitioners have accepted the fact that their initial
appointments were not so effected by following the due process as laid down in
the Rules governing the recruitment to the post of Teachers in Upper
Primary/Lower Primary Schools in the State.
20.
Accordingly, this Court is of the considered view that the petitioners,
having being accommodated in pursuance to a screening process, which was so
initiated
specifically
for
the
purpose
of
considering
the
cases
of
irregularly/illegally appointed Teachers in the State, the same in the considered
view of this Court would not mandate an interference. The petitioners having
accepted the benefits as flowing to them on account of such accommodation,
the same has to be construed to be also enjoyed, upon accepting the conditions
as mentioned in such accommodation orders. Accordingly, this Court is of the
further view that no further benefit than that extended to the petitioners in their
respective orders of accommodation, would be mandated to be extended to the
Page No.# 44/45
petitioners, herein.
21.
Having drawn the said conclusions, this Court would now consider the
decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioners passed by the
Co-ordinate Benches of this Court.
22.
This Court has carefully perused the decisions relied upon by the learned
counsel for the petitioners and finds that the issue as involved in the present
writ petitions of the petitioners, herein, being accommodated on a screening of
their case was not raised, therein. The said writ petitions are found to have
been so instituted proximate to the period when the petitioners, therein, had
been denied their respective salaries.
23.
In the present writ petitions, it is found that the fact that the petitioners,
herein, were irregularly/illegally appointed, have been established after their
cases were so considered by the Screening Committees, involved in the matter.
Accordingly, considering the issue presently raised in the present writ petitions
and the facts and circumstances coming on record in the matter, this Court is of
the considered view that the decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for
the petitioners would not advance the case of the petitioners, herein.
24.
This Court has also considered the decisions of the Co-ordinate Benches
of this Court relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioners. On a
consideration of the said decisions, this Court finds that the said decisions are
clearly distinguishable, considering the further facts and circumstances involved
in the above noted writ petitions. Accordingly, it is held that the said decisions
also would not advance the case of the petitioners in the above noted writ
petitions.
Page No.# 45/45
25.
In view of the above discussions, this Court finds that the petitioners in
the above noted writ petitions, whose services have been accommodated
subsequently, in pursuance of their placement in the List-1 and/or List-2, as
prepared by the Screening Committees, approval of which was received from
the Cabinet as Teachers and/or Tutors, would not mandate any interference and
the petitioners would not be entitled to any further benefit other than what
came to be extended to them on account of their such accommodation. The
petitioners whose services have not been so accommodated, after the process
of screening undertaken by the respondent authorities must be deemed to be
illegally appointed teachers and they would not be entitled to any direction for
release of their salaries.
26.
In view of the above discussions, the above noted writ petitions are held
to be devoid of any merit and accordingly, the same stands dismissed. However,
there would be no order as to cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review