Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 06
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 106 of 2020
Date of Order :21.10.2021
ATC Telecom Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. Vs. State of Meghalaya & 5 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjit More, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S.Jindal, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. A.Kumar, AG with
Mr. K.Khan, Sr. GA
Mr. A.Kharwanlang, GA.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Yes/No
Law journals etc:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
in press:
__________________________________________________________
Per R.More, (CJ)
1.
Heard Mr. S.Jindal, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr.
A.Kumar, learned AG along with Mr. K.Khan, learned Sr. GA for the
respondents.
2.
By this petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
the petitioner is challenging the constitutional validity of Section 3(1)(c) of
the Meghalaya Electricity Duty (Assam Act XXX of 1964 as adapted by
Meghalaya) as amended vide amendment Act dated 15th October, 2019
(hereinafter for the sake of brevity referred to as “the Act”).
3.
Before the 2019 amendment, Section 3(1)(c) of the Assam
Electricity Duty Act, 1964 (Assam Act XXX of 1964) reads as follows:
“3.
4.
(1)
There shall be levied and paid to the State
Government a duty, to be called the “electricity
duty”, at the rate of five paise per unit of energy.
(c)
generated by a person or a company or a firm or
any organisation for own use or consumption”.
The provision of Sub-section (c) of Section 3(1) was challenged
before the Gauhati High Court by filing WP(C) No. 710/2010. Admittedly,
the Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court held and declared that the
State is not legally competent to levy duty from the cellular phone
companies on self-produced and self-consumed electricity. The Division
Bench further held that taxable event is generate and that cannot be read as
consumption and hence Entry 53 of the State List of the Seventh Schedule
does not support the State action. Consequently, Section 3(1)(c) of the
Assam Electricity Duty Act, 1964 is declared ultra vires. Sub Section 3 (1)
(c), thereafter was subsequently substituted by the State of Assam. Similar
action was taken by the State of Meghalaya and Sub Section 3(1) (c) of the
Meghalaya Electricity Duty (Assam Act XXX of 1964 as adapted by
Meghalaya) was amended. Thereby, Sub-Section (c) was substituted as
follows:
“(c) Consumed by any person or any organization
generating energy”.
5.
Mr. S.Jindal, learned counsel for the petitioner invited our attention
to the definition of “consumer” in Section 2 (b) of the said Act and
submitted that the petitioner does not fall within this definition and
therefore, is not a consumer. He submitted that if the petitioner is not a
consumer of electricity, in that event, the electricity duty cannot be levied
against it under Section 3 (1) of the said Act. He also submitted that the
petitioner is generating the electricity as well as consuming the electricity
generated by it. In short, his argument is that self-consumption cannot be
taxed or levied under Section 3 (1) of the said Act.
6.
Per contra, Mr. A.Kumar, learned AG and Mr. K.Khan, learned Sr.
GA appearing for the respondents submitted that the 2019 amendment of
the said Act is in consonance with Entry 53 of the State List. Learned AG
further submitted that the 2019 amendment to the said Act has made it
abundantly clear that taxable event in respect of captive consumption of
electricity is when the electricity is “consumed” by the person generating
it. Consequently, the duty is not imposed under Section 3 (1) (c) of the said
Act on the mere act of “generation” of electricity. He further submitted that
levy of electricity duty under the amended Sub Section 3(1) on
consumption of electricity is perfectly admissible. In this regard, they
relied upon decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Jiyageerao Cotton
Mills Ltd. vrs. State of Madhya Pradesh AIR 1963 SC 414 and State of
Andhra Pradesh vrs. National Thermal Power Corporation Limited
(NTPC) AIR 2002 SC 1895.
7.
Having considered the rival submission of the respective counsels,
we are of the opinion that the issue raised in this petition is squarely covered
by the two Apex Court judgments in Jiyageerao Cotton Mills Ltd. (Supra)
and National Thermal Power Corporation Limited (Supra). The Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Jiyageerao Cotton Mills Ltd. (Supra) in para 5 and 6
held as follows:
“5…’Producer’ as defined in Section 2 (d-1) of the Act
means “ a person who generates electrical energy at a
voltage exceeding hundred volts for his own
consumption or for supplying to others”. If we read the
two definitions together, omitting the non-essentials,
‘consumer’ would include “any person who consumes
electrical energy supplied by a person who generates
electrical energy for his own consumption”. Under
Section 3 a person who generates electrical energy over
hundred volts for his own consumption is liable to pay
duty on the units of electrical energy consumed by
himself. A producer consuming the electrical energy
generated by him is also a consumer, that is to say, he
is a person who consumes electrical energy supplied by
himself. The Table prescribes rates of duty payable with
respect to electrical energy supplied for consumption
and, therefore, the levy on the appellant falls squarely
within the table under Section 3 of the Act and Mr.
Viswanatha Sastri’s argument is devoid of substance.
6.
It is difficult to see how the levy of duty upon
consumption of electrical energy can be regarded as
duty of excise falling within Entry 84 of List I. Under
that Entry what is permitted to Parliament is levy of
duty of excise on manufacture or production of goods
(other than those excepted expressly by that entry). The
taxable event with respect to a duty of excise is
“manufacture” or “production”. Here the taxable
event is not production or generation of electrical
energy but its consumption. If a producer generates
electrical energy and stores it up, he would not be
required to pay any duty under the Act. It is only when
he sells it or consumes it that he would be rendered
liable to pay the duty prescribed by the Act. The Central
Provinces and Berar Electricity Act was enacted under
Entry 48-B of List II of the Government of India Act,
1935. The relevant portion of that Entry read thus:
“Taxes on the consumption or sale of
electricity…..”.
Entry 53 of List II of the Constitution is to the
same effect. The argument of Mr. Sastri is that the word
“consumption” should be accorded the meaning which
it had under the various electricity Acts, including the
Indian Electricity Act, 1910. Under that Act and under
the various Provincial and State Acts, Consumption of
Electricity means, according to him, consumption by
persons other than producers and that both in the
Government of India Act and under the Constitution the
word ‘consumption’ must be deemed to have been used
in the same sense. The Acts in question deal only with a
certain aspect of the topic “electricity”, and not with all
of them. Therefore, in those Acts the word
“consumption” may have a limited meaning, as pointed
out by learned Counsel. But the word “consumption”
has a wider meaning. It means also “use-up”, “spend”
etc. The mere fact that a series of laws were concerned
only with a certain kind of use of electricity, that is
consumption of electricity by persons other than the
producer cannot justify the conclusion that the British
Parliament in using the word “consumption’ in Entry
48-B and the Constituent Assembly in Entry 53 of List
II wanted to limit the meaning of “consumption” in the
same way. The language used in the legislative entries
in the Constitution must be interpreted in a broad way
so as to give the widest amplitude of power to the
Legislature to legislate and not in a narrow and
pedantic sense. We cannot, therefore, accept either of
the two grounds urged by Mr. Viswanatha Sastri
challenging the vires of the Act”.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in National Thermal Power
Corporation Limited (Supra), in para 22 and 23 held as follows:
“22. We now come to the question on the
interpretation of Entry 53 in List II of Seventh Schedule.
It provides for taxes on the consumption or sale of
electricity. The word 'sale' as occurring in Entry 52
came up for the consideration of this Court in BurmahShell Oil Storage & Distributing Co. India Ltd. Vs. The
Belgaum Borough Municipality 1963 Supp. (2) SCR
216. It was held that the act of sale is merely the means
for putting the goods in the way of use or consumption.
It is an earlier stage, the ultimate destination of the
goods being “use or consumption”. We feel that the
same meaning should be assigned to the word 'sale' in
Entry 53. This is for a fortiorari reason in the context of
electricity as there can be no sale of electricity
excepting by its consumption, for it can neither be
preserved nor stored. It is this property of electricity
which persuaded this Court in Indian Aluminium Co.
Ltd. v. State of Kerela (1996) 7 SCC 637: AIR 1996 SC
1431, to hold that in the context of electricity, the word
'supply' should be interpreted to include sale or
consumption of electricity. Entry 53 should therefore be
read as 'taxes on the consumption or sale for
consumption of electricity'.
23. With these two things in mind, namely, that
electricity is goods, and that sale of electricity has to be
construed and read as sale for consumption within the
meaning of Entry 53, the conflict, if any, between Entry
53 and Entry 54 ceases to exist and the two can be
harmonized and read together. Because electricity is
goods it is covered in Entry 54 also. It is not disputed
that duty on electricity is tax. Tax on the sale or
purchase of goods including electricity but excluding
newspapers shall fall within Entry 54 and shall be
subject to provisions of Entry 92A of List I. Taxes on the
consumption or sale for consumption of electricity
within the meaning of Entry 53 must be consumption
within the State and not beyond the territory of the
State. Any other sale or electricity shall continue to be
subject to the limits provided by Entry 54. Even
purchase of electricity would be available for taxation
which it would not be if electricity was not includible in
the meaning of term “goods”. A piece of legislation
need not necessarily fall within the scope of one entry
alone; more than one entry may overlap to cover the
subject-matter of a single piece of legislation. A bare
consumption of electric energy even by one who
generates the same may be liable to be taxed by
reference to Entry 53 and if the State Legislature may
choose to impose tax on consumption of electricity by
the one who generates it such, tax would not be deemed
to be a tax necessarily on manufacture or production or
a duty of excise, as held by Constitution Bench in
Jiyajeerao Cotton Mills Ltd., Birlanagar, Gwalior Vs.
State of Madhya Pradesh 1962 Supp. (1) SCR 282. A
mere consumption of goods (other than electricity), not
accompanied by purchase or sale would not be taxable
under Entry 54 because it does not provide for taxes on
the consumption and Entry 53 does not speak of goods
other than electricity. Thus in substance Entries 53 and
54 can be and must be read together and to the extent
of sale of electricity for consumption outside the State,
the electricity being goods, shall also be subject to
provisions of Entry 92A of List I…..”.
8.
Reading of the above observation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
makes it clear that even bare consumption of electricity energy by a person
who generates the same is permissible to be taxed by reference to Entry 53
of the State List. In the light of the above, we find no merit in the petition.
Same is accordingly disposed of.
(H.S.Thangkhiew)
Judge
(R. More)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
21.10.2021
“Samantha PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review