Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC010211812018
2026:GAU-AS:13622
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6573/2018
ASSAM SANGRAMAI CHAH SRAMIK SANGHA
REPRESENTED BY SRI TILAK TOSSA, AGE- 54 YEARS, CENTRAL
EXECUTIVE MEMBER OF UNION, DISTRICT- BISWANATH, ASSAM, PIN-
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ANR.
LABOUR AND EMPLOYMENT DEPARTMENT, REPRESENTED BY THE
COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF LABOUR, DISPUR,
GHY-05.
2:THE MANAGEMENT OF MONABARI TEA ESTATE
REPRESENTED BY GENERAL MANAGER
P.O.- BISWANATH CHARIALI
DISTRICT- SONITPUR
ASSAM
PIN- 784176
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. S DAS, MRS. R T DAS,MR. N BORUAH,MS. D
BARUAH,MR. H GOGOI
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM, MR S N SARMA SENIOR ADVOCATE (R2),MR. K
KALITA (R2),MR. S CHOWDHURY (R2)
BEFORE
Hon’ble MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
Advocate for the petitioners:
Shri S. Das
Advocates for the respondents : Shri M. Chetia, GA-Assam
Shri K. Kalita, R.2- Management
Page No.# 2/10
Date on which judgment is reserved : 18.08.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment: 15.09.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment? : NA
Whether the full judgment has been pronounced? : Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The instant writ petition has been instituted under Articles 226 and 227 of
the Constitution of India, putting to challenge an Award dated 15.11.2010
passed by the learned Labour Court, Guwahati in Reference Case No. 11/2018.
By the aforesaid Award, the dismissal of the workman who is represented by the
petitioner - Sangha has been upheld. The primary ground of challenge is that
the Award is an ex-parte one.
2.
As per facts projected, an incident had occurred on 24.09.2005 with
regard to payment of bonus, which had also resulted in police firing. In
connection with the said incident, action was initiated against 11 nos. of
workers, including the present workman represented by the Sangha. However,
the suspension orders of 8 nos. of workers were withdrawn and proceeding was
initiated against 3 nos. of workmen. The proceeding culminated in an order
dated 05.12.2006 of dismissal from service. It is however contended that out of
the 3 nos. of workmen, 2 had submitted resignation and only one workman,
namely, Tilok Tosa, remained who has made the present challenge through the
Sangha by initiation of a Reference. The issue of Reference is as follows:
“Whether domestic enquiry held against the workmen was fair or not?”
Page No.# 3/10
3.
The contesting parties had submitted written statements. However, it is
the case of the petitioner that the Advocate of the workman had expired and
this fact was not communicated to the Union. It is also projected that the
learned Labour Court did not issue notice after expiry of the Advocate of the
Union. It is also contended that though the allegation was of manhandling a
manager of the garden, there was no police case lodged. It is also contended
that there was violation of the principles of natural justice and the workman was
not given a proper opportunity. It is on these broad grounds that the impugned
Award has been put to challenge.
4.
I have heard Shri S. Das, learned counsel for the petitioner - Sangha. I
have also heard Shri M. Chetia, learned Government Advocate, Assam and Shri
K. Kalita, learned counsel for the respondent no. 2 – Management.
5.
Shri Das, learned counsel for the petitioner – Sangha has submitted that
though the allegation in the disciplinary proceeding was of manhandling a
manager, there was no police case registered, which makes the entire allegation
unbelievable. He has submitted that the petitioner Union had filed written
statement and an additional written statement in which all the points were
taken up. He has submitted that in the disciplinary proceeding, the workman
was not given any defence assistant. He has submitted that the concerned
workman has already surpassed the age of superannuation and therefore, the
present claim would be confined only to the entitlements.
6.
By drawing the attention of this Court to the averments made in paragraph
26 of the writ petition, the learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that
the delay in approaching this Court has been explained. He has submitted that
the Award has been passed without taking into consideration the relevant
factors and the same being ex-parte, the same is required to be interfered with.
Page No.# 4/10
7.
In support of his submission, the learned counsel for the petitioner has
relied upon a decision in the case of M/s South Assam Roadways Limited
Vs. the State of Assam and Ors. reported in 2024 Supreme (Gau) 1549
wherein this Court, after taking into consideration Rule 18 of the Industrial
Disputes (Central) Rules, 1957 in respect of an ex-parte Award had remanded
back the matter.
8.
Per contra, Shri Kalita, learned counsel for the respondent no. 2 has, at the
outset, submitted that the present case has not been instituted in a fair and
correct manner. He has submitted that there is an inordinate delay of 8 years in
approaching this Court and this delay has not been explained at all. He has
submitted that this Court, in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India is a Court of Equity, wherein a party approaching this Court
has to come with clean hands. However, in the instant case, the approach of the
petitioner after an inordinate delay of 8 years, without any acceptable reasons,
itself would be a factor to dismiss the writ petition.
9.
On the merits of the case, the learned counsel for the respondent no. 2
has submitted that it is not a case where the disciplinary proceeding was
vitiated by bias or a violation of the principles of natural justice. He has
submitted that the records of the case would clearly show that all reasonable
opportunities were granted to the workman in the disciplinary proceeding which
resulted in the order dated 05.12.2006 of dismissal of service of 3 nos. of
workmen. He has denied the submission that the other 2 workmen had
submitted resignation. He has also submitted that the records would reveal that
the learned Tribunal had fixed the matter on 04.11.2009 as the date for
preliminary hearing. He has also submitted that as there was no representation
on behalf of the workman, fresh notice was issued to the Union on 28.05.2010.
Page No.# 5/10
The learned Tribunal had also satisfied itself regarding service of fresh notice by
return of the A/D card on 03.08.2010 and accordingly on 18.08.2010, an order
was passed to proceed ex-parte. He accordingly submits that all reasonable
opportunities, including fresh notice, was issued to the workman and therefore,
the present allegation made on behalf of the petitioner are incorrect and
without any basis.
10.
On the aspect of violation of the principles of natural justice, the learned
counsel for the Management has submitted that the workman had participated
in the disciplinary proceeding and had even cross examined the Management
witnesses and there is a clear finding in this regard. By drawing the attention of
this Court to the averments made in paragraph 9 of the writ petition, he has
submitted that there is, in fact, an admission that the workman had participated
in the disciplinary proceeding. As regards the allegation of bias that the Senior
Manager had issued the dismissal order who was also the victim of alleged
manhandling, the learned counsel for the Management has submitted that such
contention is ex-facie erroneous. By drawing the attention of this Court to the
order of dismissal dated 05.12.2006, he has submitted that the same was issued
by another officer and only on the aspect of serving the copy, the same was
signed by the Senior Manager, who was involved. He has also denied the
contention made on behalf of the workman that so far as the other 2 workmen
are concerned, there has been a settlement. He has submitted that the
dismissal was still effective and statutory dues have been paid to them. He has
also submitted that the statutory dues, including the PF, is ready to be disbursed
to the present workman who has chosen not to accept the same till now.
11.
In support of his submissions, Shri Kalita, learned counsel for the
respondent no. 2 has relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Page No.# 6/10
Krishnakali Tea Estate Vs. Akhil Bhartiya Chah Mazdoor Sangha and
Anr. reported in (2004) 8 SCC 200. In the said case, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court had held that a situation of unrest created by the workman would be
gross misconduct for which the penalty of dismissal would be commensurate.
Reliance has also been placed in the case of Muriadih Colliery Vs. Bihar
Colliery Kamgar Union reported in (2005) 3 SCC 331 and the subsequent
decision of L.K. Verma Vs. HMT Ltd. reported in (2006) 2 SCC 269 in which
the earlier law has been endorsed that use of abusive language cannot be held
to be disproportionate qua the penalty of dismissal.
12.
The rival submissions advanced in the Bar have been duly considered and
the materials placed before this Court have been carefully examined.
13.
The primary ground of challenge of the Award dated 15.11.2010 is that
the same is an ex-parte one and no proper opportunity was granted to the
petitioner. It is specifically contended that no notice was issued by the learned
Tribunal when the Advocate of the workman had passed away during the
proceeding. A submission has also been made challenging the validity of the
domestic enquiry against the workman by bringing the allegation of bias and
violation of the principles of natural justice.
14.
Let us, at first deal with the 2 ndsubmission. A perusal of the records of the
case as well as the documents placed before this Court would show that the
disciplinary proceeding was held by giving all opportunities to the workman. In
fact, in paragraph 9 of the writ petition, there is an admission that workman had
participated in the disciplinary proceeding. There is also a clear finding in the
Award of the learned Tribunal that the workman had participated and even cross
examined the Management witnesses. Though, a submission has been made
Page No.# 7/10
that no defence assistant was allowed, this Court, on a perusal of the pleadings
in the written statement, additional written statement and even in the writ
petition, has failed to come across any such projected case. On the contrary, the
materials available would show that the workman had participated in the
disciplinary proceeding, which culminated in the order dated 05.12.2006 of
dismissal from service. The contention advanced that the disciplinary proceeding
was bad on the ground of bias is also apparently fallacious. A perusal of the
dismissal order dated 05.12.2006, would show that the same was not issued by
Shri S. Ghosh, the Senior Manager who was involved in the incident of
manhandling, but another Senior Manager. This Court has noticed that though
the signature of one S. Ghosh appears, it is only with respect to furnishing of a
copy of the order of dismissal upon the workman. This Court is unable to accept
the contention that the disciplinary proceeding is vitiated by bias.
15.
As regards the aspect that the learned Tribunal had acted unreasonably
by proceeding with the matter when the advocate of the workman had passed
away. This Court, upon perusal of the records, is of the opinion that such
contention cannot be countenanced. The records, more particularly, pages 6
and 7 would show that a date for preliminary hearing was fixed on 04.11.2009
and subsequently, on 28.05.2010 as none had appeared for the workman, fresh
notices were issued to the Union. The learned Tribunal had come to a
satisfaction that the notice was indeed served as the A/D card had returned
after service and this fact has been recorded in the order dated 03.08.2010. As
there was still no representation, the learned Tribunal had passed an order
dated 18.08.2010 to proceed ex-parte and finally, the impugned Award has
been passed on 15.11.2010. Under those circumstances, this Court is of the
opinion that the learned Tribunal had acted in accordance with law and had
Page No.# 8/10
given full opportunity to the workman, as non-appearance of the Advocate was
taken into consideration and fresh notices were issued.
16.
Reliance upon the case of M/s South Assam Roadways Limited
(supra) would be of no avail to the petitioner inasmuch as, the facts are wholly
distinguishable. In the said case, there was absence of service report for which
it could not be concluded that the notices were indeed served. However, in the
instant case, not only the Reference was initially contested, on absence of the
learned counsel for the petitioner, fresh notice was issued which was also duly
served, even after which, the petitioner did not take steps to engage a new
counsel.
17.
This Court is also intrigued by the aspect that the Award, which was
passed on 15.11.2010 came to be challenged after a long period of 8 years. It is
not the case of the petitioner that they were not aware of the Award and the
only explanation comes in paragraph 26 of the writ petition, which are as
follows:
“26.
That, the workmen approached the Management again after the
Award of Learned Labour Court with a prayer to review his case and allow
him to continue his service. The local Management of the garden assured
him to discuss the matter with the higher Management and allowed him
to stay in the quarter along with his other members of the family. The
workman was waiting with a hope for a positive response of the
Management, but, the local management of the garden delayed the
matter on various pretexts and now pressurizing the workman to vacate
the quarter. Therefore, the workman decided to the challenge the ex-parte
order dated 15-11-0 and approached the Union (Assam Sangrami Chah
Sramik Sangha) to prefer a writ Petition. In this way a considerable delay
Page No.# 9/10
has been caused to prefer this Writ Petition. Considering the
backwardness and poor conditions of the workman and also as there is no
specific limitation period in the Industrial Dispute Act, 1947, the instant
Writ Petition may be admitted and after hearing the parties appropriate
order may be passed for the ends of justice.”
18.
The aforesaid explanation, in the considered opinion of this Court, would
not constitute reasonable explanation, as the delay is an inordinate and long
one of 8 years. This Court exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India is a Court of Equity, wherein the conduct of the party
approaching this Court is of paramount importance. The delay, without any
reasonable explanation, would also be a factor which would play a significant
role in the adjudication process. Though a Writ Court is not strictly bound by the
Limitation Act, 1963, the aspect of laches would definitely come in. A
Constitutional Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of MP
Vs. Bhailal Bhai reported in AIR 1964 SC 1006 has laid down as follows:
“21. … Learned counsel is right in his submission that the provisions of
the Limitation Act do not as such apply to the granting of relief under Art
226. It appears to us however that the maximum period fixed by the
legislature as the time within which the relief by a suit in a Civil Court
must be brought may ordinarily be taken to be a reasonable standard by
which delay in seeking remedy under Article 226 can be measured. The
court may consider the delay unreasonable even if it is less than the
period of limitation prescribed for a civil action for the remedy but where
the delay is more than this period, it will almost always be proper for the
court to hold that it is unreasonable. …”
Page No.# 10/10
19.
The delay of 8 years in approaching this Court would be of significant
importance, inasmuch as, in the meantime, sufficient development had taken
place. As submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner, the workman has
already surpassed the age of supervision and therefore, the aspect of interfering
with the order of dismissal and the consequent Award dated 15.11.2010,
upholding the dismissal may not arise.
20.
The learned counsel for the Management has clearly submitted that the
concerned workman would be entitled to the Provident Fund, which is lying with
them.
21.
This Court is of the opinion that the certiorari jurisdiction exercised by this
Court would only look into the decision-making process and in the instant case,
the decision-making process appears to be just reasonable and fair. This Court is
of the opinion that no case for interference is made out and accordingly, the writ
petition stands dismissed.
22.
As submitted by the learned counsel for the Management, the Provident
Fund which is ready to be released may be received by the workman.
23.
Cost made easy.
24.
Records be sent back.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review