Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No.178
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
OWP No. 943/2007
IA No. 1368/2007
IA No. 234/2008
Reserved on:
05.03.2026
Pronounced on:11.03.2026
Uploaded on: 11.03.2026
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced: Full
Assadullah Jan (Abraham)
S/O Sh. Saif-ud-Din Jan
R/O Magarmal Bagh, Srinagar,
At present, House No.69,Christian Colony,
Vir Marg, Jammu.
…..Petitioners/Appellants
Through: Mr. Anuj Dewan Raina, Adv.
Vs.
1.State of Jammu & Kashmir
Th. Secretary to Government,
Revenue Department,
J&K Govt. Civil Secretariat,
Srinagar.
2 Financial Commissioner,
J&K Government,
Jammu/Srinagar.
3.Relief Commissioner (Migrants),
Relief Organization, Jammu.
4. Deputy Commissioner Vigilance,
Relief Organization, Jammu.
5. Zonal Officer,
Zone Talab Tillo (NC-A)
Office of Relief Commissioner(M)
Relief Organization, Jammu
.…. Respondents
Through: Ms. Nazia Fazal, Adv. vice
Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
Ms. Saleeqa Sheikh, Adv. vice
Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
1.
The petitioner has filed the present writ petition under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India read with Section 103 of the Constitution of Jammu
OWP No. 943/2007
and Kashmir, seeking quashment of Communication No. Dev/R/C/1732
dated 09.05.2007 issued by respondent No. 3, as well as Communication No.
Rev./MR/39/2007 dated 09.03.2007 issued by respondent No. 1, and all other
consequential and incidental actions taken by the respondents, whereby
conscious attempts are being made to rescind/revoke the migrant status of the
petitioner. The petitioner also seeks a direction restraining the respondents
from taking any action detrimental to the migrant status of the petitioner as
granted vide Order No. 369 of 1999 dated 07.08.1999 issued by respondent
No. 3. The petitioner further seeks a direction commanding the respondents to
extend all benefits that are admissible in favour of a registered migrant to the
petitioner.
2.
The case of the petitioner as set up by him is that in the year 1984, he
married a Christian lady, namely, Ruby Madhu Brown, and thereafter he
converted to Christianity. Since then, he has been known as A. U. Abraham.
In support of his contention, the petitioner relies upon a certificate issued by
the Centre Pastor, The Pentecostal Mission, New Delhi. Upon conversion to
Christianity, the petitioner was residing at his residence at Magarmal Bagh,
Srinagar, along with his family members, including his father. In the year
1991, the father of the petitioner allegedly started receiving threats from
certain organizations, threatening elimination of the petitioner if he continued
to profess Christianity. It is stated that due to continuous threats, the
petitioner, who was working as Estates Supervisor at Mallinson Girls School,
Sheikh Bagh, Srinagar, was compelled to leave his job. His minor son,
Madhur Jacob Abraham, who was studying at Burn Hall Higher Secondary
School, Srinagar, was also forced to discontinue his studies at the said
institution. To substantiate his residence at Magarmal Bagh, Srinagar, the
OWP No. 943/2007
petitioner has relied upon a copy of FIR No. 942 of 1987 registered at Police
Station Shergari, Srinagar on 19.11.1987, wherein, besides the names of other
family members, the name of the petitioner is also reflected as an accused
being resident of Magarmal Bagh.
3.
It is further stated that due to continuous threats, the petitioner was
forced to leave his employment and migrate from the Valley along with his
minor child. However, he continued to visit the Valley intermittently to look
after his aged father until his death in the year 1997. During his lifetime, the
father of the petitioner executed a registered Gift Deed in favour of the
petitioner in respect of the residential house situated at Magarmal Bagh,
Srinagar, which was duly registered before the Sub-Registrar, Srinagar.
However, after the death of his father on 02.01.1997, the petitioner, finding
himself alone in the prevailing circumstances, could not visit the Valley and
consequently could not maintain his property.
4.
It is further stated that as the petitioner had no source of income after
migrating to Jammu, as such, he approached the concerned authorities
seeking registration of his family as migrants. After verification of the facts
relating to his migration from various quarters, the authorities issued Order
No. 369 of 1999 dated 07.08.1999, whereby the petitioner and his family
were declared as migrants.
5.
Per contra, the respondents have filed objections stating that the relief
benefits in favour of the petitioner and his family continued until the year
2007. It is submitted that the Administrative Department, vide letter No.
REV/MR/39/2007 dated 09.03.2007, directed the Relief Commissioner
(Migrants) to report whether the registration of the petitioner had been
cancelled and, if not, the reasons thereof. It was further directed that the
OWP No. 943/2007
registration of the beneficiary be cancelled forthwith and responsibility be
fixed for delay and extension of undue benefits. Accordingly, the said
direction was conveyed to respondent No. 5 vide letter No. DCV/R/C/1732
dated 09.05.2007 issued by the then Deputy Commissioner (Vigilance).
Consequently, the relief benefits in favour of the petitioner and his family
were stopped in the year 2007.
6.
The respondents have further contended that there is no valid proof or
threat perception from any concerned security agency and, therefore, the
allegations regarding threats to the petitioner from any organization are
denied. It is also stated that there is no cogent proof that the petitioner was
working as Estates Supervisor at Mallinson Girls School, Sheikh Bagh,
Srinagar. However, the respondents have admitted that the petitioner had
represented before the authorities for registration of his family as migrants
and that, vide Order No. 369 of 1999 dated 07.08.1999, the petitioner’s
family was registered as migrants.
7.
It is further stated that the Administrative Department, vide Order
No. REV/MR/39/2007 dated 09.03.2007, directed respondent No. 3 to report
whether the registration of the petitioner had been cancelled. The respondents
have also stated that OWP No. 450/2005 titled Assadullah Jan vs. Financial
Commissioner & Ors. was disposed of on 06.05.2017, but the petitioner did
not produce the said order or intimate the outcome of the said petition.
8.
It is further contended that, as per the communication dated
09.05.2007, the petitioner was found registered as a migrant illegally and,
after thorough investigation by the concerned agencies, respondent No. 1
directed respondent No. 3 to stop the undue relief benefits being extended to
the petitioner, as a migrant by the Relief Organization.
OWP No. 943/2007
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that since the petitioner
had left behind both movable and immovable properties in his residential
house at Magarmal Bagh, Srinagar, the same were allegedly being misused
by his brother, who had also unlawfully occupied the residential house of the
petitioner. The petitioner, therefore, submitted a written representation before
the Relief Commissioner (Migrants), Jammu, requesting protection of his
property situated at Magarmal Bagh, Srinagar. Pursuant thereto, the Relief
Commissioner (Migrants), Jammu, vide communication dated 31.10.2002,
requested the District Magistrate/Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar to take
appropriate action for eviction of the unlawful occupant of the petitioner’s
property in terms of the provisions of the J&K Migrants Immovable Property
(Preservation, Protection and Restraint on Distress Sales) Act, 1997.
10.
Consequently, respondent No. 2, after calling for a report regarding
the illegal occupation of the property by the petitioner’s brother, issued
Communication
No.
1101-02/RD/DM/MIG/2002
dated
19.12.2002,
requesting the Tehsildar, Srinagar to evict the illegal occupant under law and
to take the property into custody under the provisions of the 1997 Act. In
furtherance thereof, respondent No. 4, vide Communication No. 976-77/RP
dated 21.12.2002, directed the concerned Naib Tehsildar to execute the order
of the District Magistrate, Srinagar and furnish a compliance report.
11.
It is further contended that the brother of the petitioner, who
admittedly was in occupation of the property, preferred an appeal before the
Financial Commissioner against the order dated 19.12.2002 passed by the
District Magistrate, Srinagar. The Financial Commissioner, vide interim order
dated 24.12.2002, stayed the operation of the said order till disposal of the
matter. Upon receipt of notice, the petitioner filed objections seeking vacation
OWP No. 943/2007
of the ex-parte interim order dated 24.12.2002. Ultimately, the Financial
Commissioner, vide order dated 07.05.2003, allowed the appeal and
remanded the matter to the District Magistrate, Srinagar, with directions to
decide the matter afresh after providing the parties an opportunity of being
heard and to pass appropriate orders in accordance with law. The District
Magistrate, Srinagar, vide judgment dated 19.07.2003, rejected the case of the
petitioner on the ground that the petitioner had shifted from the Valley prior
to 01.11.1989, and therefore his case was not covered under the provisions of
the Migrant Act.
12.
Aggrieved by the said order, the petitioner preferred an appeal before
the Financial Commissioner, which was registered as File No. 151/FC-AP.
However, the Financial Commissioner, vide judgment dated 12.07.2005,
dismissed the appeal filed by the petitioner. Being aggrieved, the petitioner
approached this Hon’ble Court by filing OWP No. 450/2005, titled
Assadullah Jan vs. Financial Commissioner & Ors. This Court, upon
consideration of the matter, passed an interim order dated 07.11.2005,
whereby the impugned judgment was stayed and it was further directed that
the order of the Relief Commissioner dated 07.08.1999 shall remain
operative. It is stated that despite the pendency of the aforesaid writ petition
and the clear directions issued by this Court, the respondents have been acting
in contravention of the said judicial order and have been harassing the
petitioner.
13.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that in the process, the
Deputy Commissioner (Vigilance), Office of the Relief Commissioner,
Jammu, vide Communication No. DCV/R/C/1732 dated 09.05.2007, to
respondent No. 5 directed stoppage of relief benefits to the petitioner, in
OWP No. 943/2007
compliance to Administrative Department letter No. Rev/MR/39/2007 dated
09.03.2007, whereby directions had been issued to cancel the registration of
the petitioner as a migrant and to report compliance; that upon learning of the
aforesaid communications dated 09.05.2007 and 09.03.2007, the petitioner
approached the respondents through his counsel by issuing a legal
communication explaining the factual position, particularly the pendency of
OWP No. 450/2005, and requested the respondents to refrain from harassing
the petitioner. Respondent No. 4, in response to the said communication, vide
Communication No. DCV/R/C/1941 dated 28.06.2007, addressed to the
Secretary to the Government, Revenue Department, acknowledged that the
migrant status of the petitioner was protected by virtue of the interim order
dated 07.11.2005 passed by this Court and sought appropriate orders in that
regard. However, despite the same, the respondents continued to take steps
detrimental to the migrant status of the petitioner in contravention of the
judicial order.
14.
Learned counsel for the respondents next argued that the District
Magistrate Srinagar had rejected the case of the petitioner in the ancillary
proceedings on the ground that the petitioner had shifted from Valley prior to
1st November 1989, as such, his case was not covered under the provisions of
the Migrant Act, so as to deal with his house property regarding which he had
dispute with his brother and the order passed by the District Magistrate was
also affirmed by the Financial Commissioner, J&K vide judgment dated
12.07.2005. As such, the petitioner who had no status of being a migrant
could not claim that he should be continued to be registered as such so as to
draw benefits of being a migrant from Kashmir valley.
OWP No. 943/2007
15.
They further argue that the impugned orders have been passed by the
respondent- Relief Organization Authorities perfectly in consonance with law
as the petitioner was alleged to have been drawing benefits from the relief
organization illegally, without being a migrant to be entitled to such benefits.
It was finally prayed that the petition be dismissed and the impugned order be
upheld.
16.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the file and considered
the matter.
17.
The petitioner who claimed to have converted to Christianity from the
faith of Islam, after his marriage to a Christian woman in the year 1984 and
that couple was blessed with the birth of a son, however, after the onset of
militancy in the Kashmir valley, the petitioner being a soft target received
threat from the terrorists for his elimination, in case, he continued to profess
Christianity. As such, on an application moved to the Minister in-charge the
petitioner and his family was registered as migrants vide Order No. 369 of
1999 dated 07.08.1999 having his stay in Christian Colony of Jammu City. It
appears that the impugned orders have been passed by the respondents
without seeking any show-cause from the petitioner, as such, the respondents
have not followed the principle of natural justice of being heard before an
adverse order has been passed against him and that the relief benefits to him
were also stopped by the respondent on 09.05.2007.
18.
The petitioner having been registered as a migrant, could have been
divested of his status as a migrant only after holding an inquiry by associating
the petitioner by seeking his explanation/show-cause, as to why he and his
family should not be de-registered from being migrants. The impugned orders
having been passed against him, whereby his status being migrant was
OWP No. 943/2007
ordered to be withdrawn, without resorting to the aforesaid exercise of
granting an opportunity of being heard to the petitioner, has resulted in
stoppage of the relief benefits. Though the declaration made by the District
Magistrate Srinagar in a property related case that the petitioner was not a
migrant in view of provisions of the Migrant Act so as to claim protection of
his house property may be relevant for the consideration of the respondent
authorities, but an ex parte and unilateral decision on the part of the
respondents, without associating the petitioner to the matter, renders the
impugned orders arbitrary and not sustainable.
19.
Having regard to the foregoing reasons and the observations made
hereinabove, this Court is of the considered opinion that the impugned orders
are liable to be quashed. The petition is, thus, allowed and the impugned
orders are quashed with liberty to the respondents to proceed in accordance
with law, after providing an opportunity of being heard to the petitioner, to
take a final decision with regard to his migrant status. Till such an exercise is
undertaken and concluded, the petitioner’s status as migrant is ordered to be
continued, holding him and his family entitled to receive all the relief benefits
to which he was entitled, before issuance of impugned orders.
20.
The petition is, accordingly, allowed along with pending applications.
(M A Chowdhary)
Judge
JAMMU
11.03.2026
Raj Kumar
Whether order is speaking: Yes/No
Whether order is reportable: Yes/No
Raj Kumar
2026.03.11 17:27
OWPand
No. 943/2007
I attest to the accuracy
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review