Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 24-09-2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE N. SATHISH KUMAR
AND
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.RAJASEKAR
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
CNR:{HCMA012701772025}
and
CRL A No. 233 of 2026,CRL MP No. 7519 of 2026,CRL MP No. 11184 of
2026,CRL A No. 1798 of 2025
Crl.A No.1753 of 2025:
1. Askar Ali
2. Mansoor @ Mansoor Ali
Appellants
Vs
The State Rep by,
The Inspector of Police,
Variety Hall Road Police Station,
Coimbatore.
(Cr.No.436/2015).
Respondent(s)
CRL A No. 233 of 2026
CNR:{HCMA012992892025}
Asarudeen
Appellant(s)
Vs
The state represented by
1/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
The Inspector of Police,
Variety Hall Road Police Station,
Coimbatore District.
Cr.No.436 of 2015.
Respondent(s)
CRL A No. 1798 of 2025
CNR:{HCMA012807882025}
Sadik @ Sadik Ali @ Seeba Sadik
Appellant(s)
Vs
The State by,
The Inspector of Police,
Variety Hall Road Police Station,
Coimbatore.
Cr.No.436/2015.
Respondent(s)
PRAYER
These criminal appeals have been preferred under section 415 of Bharathya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 seeking to set aside the judgment dated
27.10.2025 passed by the Learned V Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Coimbatore in SC NO.195/2016 and thus render justice.
For Appellant(s):
Mr.R.Shunmugasundaram,
Senior Counsel, assisted by
Ms.Sona Sathishkumar
for M.Arun and
Mr. S.Premkumar
in Crl.A.No.1753 of 2025
Mr.S.Ramachandran and
Mr.R.Sivakumar
in Crl.A.No.1798 of 2025
2/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
Mr.C.D.Sugumar
in Crl.A.No.233 of 2026
For Respondent(s):
Mr.C.R.Malarvannan,
Additional Public Prosecutor
in all Criminal Appeals
COMMON JUDGMENT
(Judgment of the Court was made by N.Sathish Kumar J.)
Aggrieved over the judgment of conviction and sentence, dated
27.10.2025 in S.C.No.195 of 2016 on the file of the V Additional District and
Sessions Court, Coimbatore, A1 has filed Crl.A.No.1798 of 2025, A3 and A4
have filed Crl.A.Nos.1753 of 2025 and A-6 has filed Crl.A.No.233 of 2026.
The accused were convicted and sentenced by the trial Court as follows :
Accused
Conviction
Sentence
A1, A3, A4, A5, A6
Section 147 IPC
To undergo six months simple imprisonment
A1
Section 148
To undergo one year simple imprisonment
A1
Section 302
To undergo life imprisonment and to pay a fine of
Rs.10,000/- in default to undergo one year simple
imprisonment
A1, A3, A4, A5
Section 302 r/w 149 IPC (A1)
Section 302 r/w 149 IPC
(2 counts for A3, A4, A5, A6)
To undergo life imprisonment and to pay a fine of
Rs.10,000/- in default to undergo one year simple
imprisonment for A1 and
for A3, A4, A5, A6 -each count
A3, A4, A5, A6
Section 341 IPC
To undergo one month simple imprisonment
The accused to run the sentences concurrently
2.The case of the prosecution is as follows :
2.1.The deceased-1 Mohideen Basha is the brother-in-law of P.W.1.
Deceased-2 Habib Mohamed is the brother of P.W.10. Deceased-1 is running a
3/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
beef stall. P.W.4 was working in the said beef stall. On 31.10.2015, when P.W.4
was in the shop, A-1 came to the shop owned by deceased-1 and took 4 kgs. of
beef liver and bones from the shop. The same when questioned by P.W.4, A-1
informed him that it is none of his business and so saying, he went out of the
shop. Later, deceased-1 was informed that A-1 had taken beef from the shop.
Therefore, deceased-1, Sikkandar (P.W.3) and P.W.4 went to the shop of A-1
and questioned him as to why he took away beef from his shop. A-1 shouted at
deceased-1 stating how dare you come and question me and so saying, he
proclaimed that he would come to his place and would eliminate him, for which
deceased-1 said, if you have guts, you come to my area and so saying,
deceased-1 left the place. The above incident was explained by deceased-1 to
P.W.1 when P.W.1 was in his mother-in-laws residence at 07.00 p.m. At that
time, P.W.2, one Sheriff, deceased-2, one Abbas Mandri were there in the house.
While Deceased-1 was informing them about the said incident which happened
that morning, A-3 called deceased-1 over mobile phone around 07.30 p.m and
asked him to come near Aroma Bakery situated in Oppanakara Street to solve
the issues between them. Therefore, P.W.1, P.W.2, Sheriff, Abbas Mandri and
deceased-1 had discussion for about 1 hour and 15 minutes and went to the
place of occurrence around 09.30 p.m. At that time, when deceased-1
questioned A-1 as to why he called him, A-1 informed him that he had come to
his place to finish him off. At that time, A-3 and A-5 caught hold of deceased-1
4/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
and A-1 stabbed him with knife on his stomach. When deceased-2 came there,
A-1 also shouted that he should also be caught. So, A-4 and A-6 caught hold of
deceased-2 and A-2 stabbed him on the right side stomach. The above knives
are M.Os.1 and 2. The above occurrence was witnessed by P.Ws.1,2,3 and 7 and
14.
2.2.P.W.2 is also relative to deceased-1. P.W.2 took the deceased-1 in an
auto to the CMC hospital and P.W.10, the brother of deceased-2, who came to
the spot at that time took deceased-2 in a two wheeler to the K.G.Hospital. After
the deceased were sent to the hospital, P.W.1 came to his house to inform the
incident and thereafter,
he went to the government hospital and he was
informed that Mohideen Basha died. Thereafter, he came to the police station
and gave Ex.P.1 complaint. P.W.18, Sub Inspector of Police who received the
complaint from P.W.1 at 01.30 a.m., registered the case in Crime No.436 of
2015 under sections 302 and 307 IPC under Ex.P.29, First Information Report
and forwarded a copy to the Inspector of Police for investigation.
2.3.P.W.22, Inspector of Police, took up the investigation and went to the
place of occurrence. He prepared observation mahazar and rough sketch in the
presence of P.W.5 Ganeshkumar and one Asif. Ex.P.2 is the observation mahazar
and Ex.P.34 is the rough sketch. Thereafter, he went to the K.G.Hospital and
was informed that deceased-2 died and hence his dead body was sent to the
Government Hospital, Coimbatore and therefore, he proceeded to the
5/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
Coimbatore Government medical college hospital. He altered the crime into
section 302 IPC (2 counts). Thereafter, he conducted inquest on the dead body
of deceased-1 and prepared inquest report Ex.P.35 and later sent the dead body
with a requisition to conduct postmortem. Thereafter, he conducted inquest
over the dead body of deceased-2 and prepared inquest report Ex.P.37 and
thereafter, sent his dead body for postmortem with requisition Ex.P.38.
2.4.In the meanwhile, P.W.15 medical officer attached to the Coimbatore
Medical college hospital when he was on duty on 31.10.2015 at about 10.20
p.m., deceased-1 was brought by his relative for treatment and on examination,
he found 10x4 cm stab injury on his right side chest and 3 x 2 cm laceration
injury on his left leg second toe and he found him dead. He has issued Ex.P.17
accident register and has sent an intimation to the police which was marked as
Ex.P.18.
2.5.P.W.19, medical officer attached to KG Hospital while he was on
duty, has examined deceased-2 who was brought to the hospital for treatment.
According to him, he was brought by one Sugaib Mohamed and that deceased-2
died during treatment due to heart attack, severe hypovolemic shock. According
to P.W.20, medical officer attached to KG hospital, Coimbatore while he was in
the hospital, deceased-2 was brought by his friends at about 10.00 p.m and he
6/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
was informed that the deceased-2 suffered injury around 09.30 p.m. He has
issued Ex.P.30 accident register and has given intimation to the police.
2.6.P.W.17, the medical officer attached to the Coimbatore Medical
college hospital has conducted autopsy on the dead body of deceased-1 and
found the following injuries:
‘Transversely oblique stab wound 8x2 cm x cavity deep noted over
right lower chest at the level of 7th and 8th ribs in its mid clavicular
line, the upper medial end is 10 cm below to the right nipple. On
dissection the wound passes inwards, upwards, towards, medially,
cutting the underlying muscle, vessel, nerves, and 7 th and 8th ribs
and enter into the peritoneum and piecing the diaphragm,
pericardium and enter into the right ventricle cavity. Peritoneum
cavity contains about 1000 ml of fluid blood with clots. Both sides
pleural cavities contain about 750 ml of fluid blood.
-Reddish deep abrasion noted over dorsum of left great toe and 2 nd
toe.’
P.W.17 has issued Ex.P.23 postmortem certificate opining that the deceased-1
would appear to have died of shock and hemorrhage due to stab injury in the
chest and its corresponding internal injuries and the death would have occurred
12 to 24 hours prior to autopsy. and after receiving the viscera report, he has
opined that viscera does not contain any poison. Then, he issued Ex.P.25 final
opinion. Further, he has also received the serology report Ex.P.21.
7/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
2.7.Thereafter, he has conducted autopsy on the dead body of deceased-2
and found the following injuries:
‘”Tick” shaped stab injury 4x3 cm x cavity deep noted over
anterior aspect of right upper abdomen. The medial end is 5 cm
below right costochondral margin.
On dissection the wound passes backwards, laterally and cutting
the underlying muscle, vessel, nerves, piercing the greater
Omentum and entire into the retro peritoneal region by cutting the
right renal vessels. Peritoneal cavity contains about 1500 ml of
fluid blood with clots.
-Deep graze abrasion reddish in colour over on area of 4x2 cm
noted over dorsum of right great toe.’
He has issued Ex.P.26 postmortem certificate in respect of deceased-2 opining
that the deceased would appear to have died of shock and hemorrhage due to
stab injury abdomen and corresponding internal injuries and the death would
have occurred 12 to 24 hours prior to autopsy. He has collected biology and
serology report and has issued final opinion Ex.P.28.
2.8.P.W.22, Inspector of Police continued his investigation, recorded the
statement of witnesses. After the postmortem, he has recovered the dresses from
the dead body of both the deceased which was handed over to him and he
recovered the same under Form 91 which were marked as Exs.P.39 and 40 and
sent them to the court. Thereafter, on 02.11.2015 at about 10.30 a.m., A-5 was
8/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
arrested in the presence of one Imran and Ismail, namely P.Ws.7 and 8 and has
recorded his confession statement. Later, on 04.11.2015, when he was in search
of other accused with his police team, including P.W.18 and P.W.21, they have
intercepted a Honda Civic Car bearing registration no.TN 37 AS 2526 and
arrested A-1, A-2, A-3 and A-4 in the presence of P.W.8 and one Ansar Ali and
recorded the confession statement of the arrested accused, the admissible
portion of the confession statement of A-1 was marked as Ex.P.41, The
confession statement of A-2 was also recorded, the admissible part of the same
was marked as Ex.P.42. The admissible portion of confession of A-3 was
marked as Ex.P.43 and the admissible portion of the confession of A-4 was
marked as Ex.P.44. Pursuant to the confession statements, bloodstained knife, a
fullhand shirt and blootstained black pant was recovered from A-1. Further, a
knife and a shirt and pant were recovered from A-2. A Black colour Honda
Civic car bearing registration no.TN 37 AS 2526 and a bloodstained shirt and
pant were recovered from A-3. A bloodstained t-shirt and pant were recovered
under a cover of mahazar from A-4. Further, a Pulsar motor cycle bearing
registration no.TN 66 E 0128 was recovered pursuant to the confession of A-4
under a cover of mahazar. The investigating officer forwarded the material
objects to the court and the accused were sent to judicial remand. Later, he
handed over the investigation to the other Inspector of Police due to his transfer.
9/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
2.9.P.W.23, Inspector of Police took up the further investigation. He has
recorded the statement of witnesses. He prepared the alteration report and sent
the same to the court. He took police custody of A-6 who had surrendered
before the Judicial Magistrate Court, Tiruppur and recorded his confession
statement in the presence of witnesses. Pursuant to his confession, he recovered
a two wheeler bearing registration no.TN 37 AM 8092 and forwarded the
material object under Form 91, Ex.P.46, to the court. After collecting the
postmortem certificates and after recording the witnesses, he handed over the
case file to his successor investigating officer since he was transferred.
2.10.P.W.24, the Inspector of Police, who has taken over the
investigation, on completion of the investigation, laid the final report against six
accused under sections 147, 148, 302, 302 r/w 149 r/w 109, 302 r/w 149 IPC.
3.On appearance of the accused, the provisions of Section 207 Cr.P.C.
were complied with and the case was committed to the Court of Session in
S.C.No.195 of 2016 and was made over to the V Additional District and
Sessions Court, Coimbatore for trial.
4.The trial Court framed the charges against the accused. When
questioned, the accused pleaded ‘not guilty’. After the amendment of the
charges, when the accused were questioned again regarding the amended
charges, the accused [A-1, A-3 to A-6] denied the charges and sought to
examine the witnesses. The charges and the amended charges are as follows:
10/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
Accused Charge sheet
Amended Charge 1 Amended Charge 2 Amended Charge 3
sent to court on 13.12.2018
17.09.2025
25.10.2025
04.03.2016
A-1
147, 148, 302
147, 148, 302
147, 148, 302,
302 r/w 149
147, 148, 302,
302 r/w 149
A-2
147, 148, 302
A-3
147, 341,
147,
302 r/w 149
302 r/w 149 r/w
302 r/w 149 r/w 109
302 r/w 149,
147,
341,
302 r/w 149
(2 counts)
147,
341,
302 r/w 149
(2 counts)
A-4
147, 341,
147,
147,
302 r/w 149 r/w 302 r/w 149 r/w 341,
109,
302 r/w 149
302 r/w 149
302 r/w 149
(2 counts)
147,
341,
302 r/w 149
(2 counts)
A-5
147,
147,
147,
302 r/w 149,
302 r/w 149,
302 r/w 149
302 r/w 149 r/w 302 r/w 149 r/w (2 counts),
147,
341,
302 r/w 149
(2 counts),
A-6
147,
147,
302 r/w 149, 302 r/w 149,
302 r/w 149 r/w 302 r/w 149 r/w
147,
341,
302 r/w 149
(2 counts)
147,
302 r/w 149
(2 counts),
After the last amendment of the charges, though all the accused pleaded further
examination, by receiving memo from the counsel for appellants / accused, the
judgment in the case was pronounced in the next working day.
5.To prove the case, the prosecution has examined as many as 24
witnesses as P.W.1 to P.W.24 and marked 47 documents, namely Exs.P1 to P.47
and produced M.Os.1 to 20. The court documents, namely Exs.C.1 to C.4 were
marked. On the side of the defence, no witness was examined and no documents
were marked.
6.The trial Court, after appreciating the oral and documentary evidence
11/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
and materials on record, by judgment dated 27.10.2025, found all the accused
A1, A3 to A6 guilty of the offences and thereby, convicted and sentenced them
as stated above. The charges against A-2 got abated as he died
7.Challenging the conviction and sentence, Crl.A.No.1753 of 2025 is
filed by A-3 and A-4, Crl.A.No.1798 of 2025 is filed by A-1 and Crl.A.No.233
of 2026 is filed by A-6. No criminal appeal was preferred by A-5.
8.The learned senior counsel and the counsel appearing for the appellants
would submit that the eyewitnesses account for the entire occurrence is
doubtful. P.Ws.1 to 3, 7 and 14 would not have been the eyewitnesses to the
occurrence. The conduct of P.W.1 clearly shows that he could not be the
eyewitness to the occurrence. P.W.1 is none other than the brother-in-law of
deceased-1. His conduct clearly shows that he never made any attempt to save
the deceased-1 from the attack. His evidence would indicate that he has gone to
the house after the occurrence and thereafter, went to the hospital and then to
the police station to given Ex.P.1 complaint at 01.30 a.m.. The police station is
situate very near to the place of occurrence. The alleged occurrence took place
in the busy Oppanakara street in Coimbatore. According to P.W.1, there are six
persons at the time when P.W.1 went to his mother-in-laws residence. P.W.2,
Sheriff, deceased-2, Abbas Mandri and deceased-1 were there and they have
gone to the place of occurrence. If really there was any altercation, there was no
attempt whatever was made by P.W.1 and others to prevent such attack made by
12/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
the accused people. The evidence of P.W.1 is totally contradictory to the earlier
statement given in the FIR. In the FIR, it is stated that they went to the spot
immediately after receiving the call at around 07.30 p.m. Whereas in the
evidence, he has improved his version as if they had discussion for about 1 hour
and 15 minutes and thereafter went to the place of occurrence at around 09.30
p.m. and at that time, the occurrence took place.
9.It was submitted that the entire eyewitnesses projected by the
prosecution have spoken as if parrot like repetition and their evidence is highly
improbable. Their evidence is to the effect that A-3 and A-5 caught hold of
deceased-1 and A-1 stabbed him. Later, A-4 and A-6 caught hold of deceased-2
and A-2 stabbed him. This shows that their evidence is attached with
artificiality. This shows that all the accused were unnecessarily dragged into the
case. Ex.P.1 is the not the first information. P.W.18, the sub Inspector of Police
has received intimation from the hospital and he went there. It was the evidence
of P.W.2 who admitted deceased-1 in the hospital that the police came to the
hospital and he informed about the incident. Therefore, the complaint Ex.P.1
allegedly given at about 01.30 a.m. is an afterthought which is a result of
deliberation and discussion. Therefore, the entire evidence of eyewitness is
highly doubtful. Further, the prosecution has not even proved the place of
occurrence. No bloodstains whatever were recovered from the place of
occurrence. The investigating officer has not even made any attempt to take
13/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
photographs of the place of occurrence. Further, the CCTV footages were
available near the place of occurrence as it is a busy area, but the CCTV
footages were not collected by the prosecution.
10.It is further submitted by the learned senior counsel and the counsel
for the appellants that the alleged seizure of the vehicles is also attached with
artificiality. The RC book of the vehicle was not seized and the owner of the
vehicle has not been established. The so-called eyewitness P.W.3 was examined
by the police for the first time only on 06.11.2015 and P.W.4 was examined only
on 08.11.2015. P.W.7 was examined for the first time by the police on
02.11.2015 and the statements have reached the court on 04.03.2016. Further,
all the material objects reached the court belatedly. The delay has not been
explained by the prosecution. Therefore, all these facts create serious doubt
about the entire prosecution theory. P.Ws.1 to 3,7 and 14 the eyewitnesses relied
on by the prosecution would not have been present in the place of occurrence
and that the accused were implicated at a later point of time after discussion. It
is the further contention that the so-called eyewitnesses were examined at a later
part of the investigation. If really the eyewitnesses are friends and relatives and
they were present during the occurrence, their normal conduct would be to give
statement to the police at the very earliest point of time. Therefore, these facts
creates serious doubt. Further, the trial court has altered the charges at a later
point of time. That apart, the trial court relied upon the evidence of P.W.2. The
14/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
incriminating evidence of P.W.2 was not put to accused. Therefore, the
prosecution case is doubtful and hence the appellants are certainly entitled the
benefit of doubt and the judgment of conviction and sentence of the trial court
requires interference.
11.The learned Public Prosecutor would submit that P.Ws.1 to 3, 7 and 14
are the eyewitnesses to the occurrence and they have clearly spoken about the
nature of overt acts of each of the accused. The motive aspect has been clearly
spoken by P.W.4. The occurrence took place in a busy area and merely because,
bloodstains were not recovered from the place, it cannot be said that no such
occurrence took place. Dehors the evidence of P.Ws.1 to 3, the evidence of
P.W.7 and P.W.14 clinchingly establishes the guilt of the accused and therefore,
their evidence cannot be discarded merely on the ground that they were
examined by the police belatedly and their statements were sent to the court
later. Hence, it is submitted that the prosecution has proved the guilt of the
accused/appellants and hence these criminal appeals deserve to be dismissed.
12.In the light of the above submissions, now it has to be seen whether
the prosecution has proved the guilt of the accused beyond all reasonable doubt?
13.Unfortunately, deceased nos.1 and 2 died on 31.10.2015 in a homicidal
violence. The prosecution has projected P.Ws.1 to 3, 7 and 14 as eyewitnesses to
the occurrence. P.Ws.1 and 2 are brother-in-law of deceased-1. P.W.3 claimed to
be the chance witnesses who was said to be in the place of occurrence. P.W.7 is
15/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
also a chance witness and P.W.14 is said to be a auto driver in the auto stand.
The law was set in motion on the basis of Ex.P.1 said to have been registered in
the police station by P.W.18 at 01.30 a.m.
14.When the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 2 is carefully seen, it is the specific
case that P.W.1 came to his mother-in-law’s house at 07.00 p.m. where P.W.2,
deceased-1, one Sheriff, deceased-2 and one Abbas Mandri were present in the
house. Deceased no.1 informed them that in the morning A-1 came to his shop
and took away 4 kgs. of Beef and the same was questioned by deceased-1 in the
evening. At that time, accused shouted at him as to how dare you came and
shouted at them and so, they proclaimed that they will come to his place and
will eliminate him. When they were together in the house, A-3 called
deceased-1 through cell phone to come near Aroma bakery at Oppanakara street
junction to sort out the issue between them. Then, P.W.1 and others had
discussion for about 1 hour 15 minutes and went to the place of occurrence at
09.30 p,m. At that time, all the accused were present there. A-3 and A-5 caught
hold of deceased-1 while A-1 stabbed him. When deceased-2 tried to prevent it,
A-1 shouted that he should also be caught. Accordingly, A-4 and A-6 caught
hold of deceased-2 and A-2 stabbed him. Immediately, P.W.2 took deceased-1 to
the government hospital and P.W.10 brother of deceased-2 , who came there,
took deceased-2 in a two wheeler to the KG hospital. Immediately, P.W.1 came
to the house to inform the family members and thereafter, he went to the
16/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
hospital where he came to know that deceased-1 died. Immediately, he went to
the police station and gave Ex.P.1 complaint.
15.The entire perusal of the evidence of P.W.1 would show that after the
occurrence, deceased-1 was taken to the hospital by P.W.2. P.W.1 returned to his
house and thereafter went to the hospital and later had gone to the police station
at 01.30 a.m. According to P.W.1, the occurrence took place at 09.30 p.m. P.W.2
in his evidence has also supported the version of P.W.1. According to him, they
went to the place of occurrence at 09.30 p.m and A-3 called deceased-1 over
cell phone at 07.30 p.m. Therefore, they went to the place of occurrence at
09.30 p.m. He, deceased nos.1 and 2, P.W.1 and one Abbas Mandri, Sheriff have
gone to the place of occurrence. According to him, A-5 and A-6 caught hold of
deceased-1 and A-1 stabbed him and A-2 shouted to catch hold deceased-2.
Accordingly, A-4 and A-6 caught hold of deceased-2 and A-2 stabbed him.
Thereafter, P.W.2 took deceased-1 to the government hospital and he also came
to know that deceased-2 was taken to the hospital by his brother. The police
came to the hospital at 10.30 p.m and he informed the incident to the police.
Even, in the cross examination, he had asserted that on 31.10.2015, the Sub
Inspector of Police came to the hospital and he narrated the incident to the Sub
Inspector at 10.30 p.m. Therefore, the evidence of P.W.2 clearly shows that with
regard to the occurrence, the information was given to the police in the hospital
itself. Whereas, according tot the prosecution, the FIR came to be registered at
17/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
01.30 a.m by P.W.18 only on the complaint given by P.W.1.
16.A perusal of the evidence of P.W.18 would show that according to him,
he had received the death intimation from the hospital at 00.55 hours and went
to the hospital. Since there was no relatives of deceased in the hospital, he came
back to the police station. At that stage, at around 01.30 a.m., P.W.1 came and
gave Ex.P.1 complaint. When the evidence of P.W.18 and P.W.2 is carefully
looked into, it is seen that the entire genesis of the first information has been
suppressed by the prosecution. P.W.2 admittedly took deceased-1 to the hospital
at the first instance. P.W.15 the medical officer attached to the Coimbatore
medical college hospital has issued the accident register Ex.P.17 relating to
deceased-1. He has stated that only P.W.2 brought deceased-1 to the hospital
and he was informed that 3 to 4 persons attacked deceased-1 at around 09.40
p.m. P.W.15 has noted 10 x 4 cm stab injury on the right side chest and
laceration measuring 3 x 2 cm on the left leg second toe. The evidence of
P.W.15 clearly shows that deceased-1 was first brought to the hospital by P.W.2
and P.W.2 asserted that the Sub Inspector of police came to the hospital and he
has given the narration of the incident to the sub inspector in the hospital.
Whereas P.W.18, Sub Inspector who registered the FIR at 01.30 a.m., in his
evidence has stated that when he went to the hospital, no relatives were present.
Later, P.W.1 appeared before him in the police station and gave Ex.P.1
complaint. These facts clearly suggests that the earlier information given to the
18/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
police about the occurrence was totally suppressed by the prosecution. Whereas
Ex.P.1 complaint came to be registered at a later point of time at 01.30 a.m.
Ex.P.17, the copy of the accident register indicates as if P.W.2 has informed that
deceased-1 was attacked by 3 to 4 persons. The same would show that the
participation of six accused has not been mentioned by P.W.2. Therefore, the
very genesis of the first information has been suppressed in this case.
17.Ex.P.1 came to be filed at 01.30 a.m. According to P.Ws.1 and 2, they
are the eyewitnesses to the occurrence. They have seen all the six accused
persons in the place of occurrence. According to P.W.1, A-3 and A-5 caught
hold of Deceased-1 and A-1 stabbed him. A-1 also instigated A-4 and A-6 to
catch deceased-2. Accordingly, A-4 and A-6 caught hold of deceased-2 and
thereafter, A-2 caused stab injury on deceased-2. Whereas, according to P.W.2,
who also claimed to be the eyewitness to the occurrence, only A-5 and A-6
caught hold of Deceased-1 and A-4 and A-6 caught hold of deceased-2 which is
totally inconsistent to the evidence of P.W.1. According to the evidence of
P.W.1, A-1 instigated A-4 and A-6 to catch hold deceased-2, whereas P.W.2, in
his evidence, says that only A-2 instigated A-4 and A-6 to catch hold
deceased-2. These contradictory statements of the witnesses, particularly, the
so-called eyewitnesses, in the light of the earlier version, one given before the
doctor about the number of persons and the narration of incident to the Sub
Inspector of Police which is burked by the prosecution, creates serious doubt
19/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
about the presence of P.Ws1 and 2 at the place of occurrence.
18.According to P.W.1, as usual, he went to his mother-in-law's house at
7.00 p.m. Where deceased nos.1 and 2, P.W.2, one Sheriff and one Abbas
Mandri were present. Deceased-1 has informed about the earlier incident which
was said to have taken place with regard to taking away of beef by A-1 from
the shop of deceased-1 in the morning. While they were discussing, A-3 called
deceased-1 over cell phone. Therefore, they had discussion about 1 hour 15
minutes and later, they went to the place of occurrence to sort out the issue. The
other persons said to have accompanied P.Ws.1 and 2, namely one Abbas
Mandri and Sheriff have not been examined by the prosecution for the reasons
best known to them and no explanation whatsoever was given in this regard. It
is relevant to note that P.Ws.1 and 2 are close relatives of deceased-1. The very
conduct of P.Ws.1 and 2 and other persons who accompanied them to the place
of occurrence assumes significance to assess whether P.Ws.1 and 2 were
actually present in the place of occurrence. According to the evidence of P.W.1,
immediately after the stab injury of deceased-1, he fell down and P.W.1 has not
even made any attempt to find out the nature of the injury of deceased-1. His
evidence indicates that immediately, he returned to his house and thereafter,
went to the hospital and after the death of deceased-1, he went to the police
station at 01.30 a.m. According to him, P.W.10, the brother of deceased-2, came
to the spot at the relevant point of time and has taken deceased-2 to KG
20/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
hospital. In this regard, the evidence of P.W.20, medical officer attached to KG
hospital, when carefully perused, would show that he was in the casualty duty
on 31.10.2015 and deceased-2 was brought to the hospital by his friends and he
has noted 5 x 3 cms stab injury on the right side stomach. P.W.20 had also
issued Ex.P.30, accident register and sent an intimation to the police station
under Ex.P.31.
19.Ex.P.30 when carefully perused, it is seen that deceased-2 was in fact
admitted in the hospital by one Subaib Mohammad which has been clearly
noted by P.W.20 in Ex.P.30. Therefore, the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 2 that P.W.10
Sugail Mohamed took deceased-2 to the hospital is highly doubtful. P.W.10 is
Sugail Mohamed, whereas the person who admitted deceased-2 in the KG
hospital at the first instance is Subaib Mohammad. The evidence of P.W.20
clearly shows that deceased-2 was brought to the hospital only by his friends
and not by his brother. Therefore, the evidence of P.W.1 that P.W.10 took
deceased-2 in a two wheeler to the KG hospital is also highly doubtful in this
case.
20.It is further to be noted that P.W.1 in his evidence has stated as if after
the phone call from A-3 to deceased-1 at 07.00 p.m, they all had discussion
about 1 hour and 15 minutes as to whether to go to the place or not and
thereafter, they went to the place of occurrence. Whereas P.W.2 who was said to
have accompanied P.W.1, had never stated in his evidence that after the phone
21/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
call from A-3 calling deceased-1 to come to the place of occurrence, they had
discussion for about 1 hour and 15 minutes in the house and thereafter they
went to the place of occurrence. In this regard, the complaint Ex.P.1 filed by
P.W.1 when carefully seen, it is stated therein that at 07.30 p.m., A-3 called
deceased-1 over cell phone to come to the place of occurrence to sort out the
issue and immediately, after such a call, P.W.1 and one Sheriff [who was not
examined] and deceased-2 [Abib Mohamed] and P.W.2 [Akthar], one Abbas
Mandri [who was not examined], Askar Ali-A-3, and deceased-1 went to the
place of occurrence. At that time, A-1, A-2, A-4, A-5, A-6 were standing in the
place of occurrence. A-3 and A-5 caught hold of deceased-1 and A-1 caused
stab injury on deceased-1. A-4 and A-6 caught hold of deceased-2 and A-2
stabbed deceased-2. Immediately, P.W.2 took deceased-1 to CMC hospital and
deceased-2 was taken to KG hospital by P.W.10, who is the brother of
deceased-2. Thereafter, P.W.1 went to the hospital and later gave complaint
Ex.P.1. In the entire complaint Ex.P.1, according to P.W.1, when he visited the
house at 07.00 p.m., at that time, one Sheriff [not examined], Habeeb
Mohamed-deceased-2, P.W.2, one Abbas Mandri [not examined] alone were
present in the in-law's place, whereas in the evidence, for the first time, he has
introduced six persons who have accompanied him. Further, in the complaint, is
the specific case of P.W,1 that immediately after the phone call from A-3 at
07.30 p.m, they proceeded to the place of occurrence. In the entire complaint,
22/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
there is no whisper whatsoever with regard to the cloudy condition or rainy
condition. Whereas, for the first time, in the evidence, P.W.1 has introduced as if
there was cloudy condition and rain is expected. That apart, they had discussion
for 1 hour and 15 minutes to go to the place of occurrence. This fact creates
serious doubt about the very time of occurrence. Admittedly, the occurrence
took place in a busy area in Coimbatore in Oppanakara street. Though P.Ws.1
and 2 said in their evidence that the occurrence took place near Aroma bakery,
but the rough sketch shows that the scene of occurrence was in the middle of the
road in Oppanakara street which is a busy road. It is admitted by the prosecution
that the police station is situate in 500 meters from the place of occurrence, but
none of the witnesses who accompanied deceased-1 have not gone to the police
station immediately after the occurrence. This fact creates some serious doubt
about their presence, particularly with regard to the time of occurrence.
21.Further, a detailed complaint has been given by P.W.1 with meticulous
details, though the FIR need not contain minute details and the FIR need not be
an encyclopedia to the incident. Whereas Ex.P.1 contains minute details right
from the motive and phone call from A-3 at the relevant point of time to
deceased-1 calling him to come to the place of occurrence and thereafter, they
went to the place of occurrence and there, the alleged occurrence took place.
The presence of six persons said to have accompanied P.W.1 is found missing in
Ex.P.1. That apart, in the complaint, it is specifically alleged that immediately
23/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
after the phone call from A-3 at 07.30 p.m, they went to the place of occurrence
and at that stage, the occurrence took place. Whereas in the evidence, it is the
case of prosecution witness that the occurrence took place at around 09.30 p.m.
This fact creates serious doubt about the time of occurrence and the place of
occurrence also. The cloudy condition and rainy condition has been spoken for
the first time in the evidence by P.W.1. The other witnesses have not spoken
about any such condition at the relevant point of time. It is further to be stated
that it is the evidence of P.W.1 that only A-3 and A-5 caught hold of deceased-1,
whereas P.W.2 stated that A-5 and A-6 caught hold of deceased-1 and A-4 and
A-6 caught hold of deceased-2. This also creates serious doubt about the
prosecution case.
22.Further, the very conduct of P.W.1 has to be looked into. P.W.1 has not
even taken any steps to even lift deceased-1 after the occurrence, but casually he
returned to home and thereafter, went to the hospital and later has gone to the
police station. This conduct of P.W.1 is against the normal human behaviour. If
really all the six persons accompanied deceased nos.1 and 2 and in fact, they all
anticipated some problem and went to the place of occurrence to sort out the
issue, they all would have made some attempts to overpower the accused, but
they were all mute spectators and had not even made any attempt to prevent
such attack at the relevant point of time. It is further to be noted that the police
station is situate 500 meters from the place of occurrence, as per the evidence of
24/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
investigating officer. They have not even rushed to the police station
immediately. It was not the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 2 that at the time of
occurrence, it was raining. The investigating officer who claimed to have rushed
to the spot after the FIR, prepared observation mahazar and he has recorded that
since there was rain, no bloodstains were found in the place of occurrence. The
so-called observation mahazar though said to have been prepared on the same
day, sent to the court on 16.11.2015 with delay. The reasons for the delay in
dispatching the important document has not even been explained by the
investigating officer. It is further to be noted that P.W.2 in his evidence would
say that after the phone call from A-3, he along with one Sheriff, deceased-2
and 1, Akthar, Jahir and Abbas Mandri all went to the place of occurrence. It is
relevant to note that his evidence is parrot like repetition of statement and
creates serious doubt and his evidence is attached with artificiality. He has
spoken as if one Akthar accompanied him, but the said Akthar is none other
than P.W.2 himself. Further, he has admitted deceased-1 in the hospital where he
has given statement that only 3 to 4 persons have attacked deceased-1. Further,
he has clearly narrated the entire incident to the police when the sub inspector
came to the hospital. Whereas the Sub Inspector P.W.18 would state that since
relatives were not available in the hospital, he could not record their statements.
All these facts creates serious doubt about the first information report.
23.Further, P.Ws.1 and 2 have not even rushed to the police station which
25/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
is situate in 500 meters away from the place of occurrence and is in busy area,
the above conduct creates doubt about their presence at the place of occurrence.
According to the witnesses, the occurrence took place at 09.40 p.m, whereas it
is evident from the complaint lodged by P.W.1n that immediately after the
phone call from A-3, they all went to the place of occurrence at 07.30 p.m. and
at that time, the occurrence took place. It is relevant to note that the residence of
P.W.1 and deceased-1 is near the place of occurrence. Therefore, the witnesses
changing the time of occurrence at a later point of time in their evidence creates
serious doubt about the presence of P.Ws.1 and 2. Further, according to P.W.2,
his dresses also got bloodstains. His evidence is to the effect that he took bath
and washed the bloodstained clothes. This conduct is unusual and is against the
normal human conduct. If really P.W.2 claimed to be the eyewitness and his
dresses are stained with blood, the normal conduct would be to hand over the
dresses to the police. But, he has stated in his evidence that since he took bath,
he washed the bloodstains in the dresses. It is highly improbable and creates
serious doubt about his presence.
24.It is further to be noted that according to P.W.1, only one stab injury
was caused on deceased-1, whereas the P.W.15 medical officer's evidence when
carefully seen, it indicates that laceration measuring 3 x 2 cm on left leg second
toe also noted. But, P.Ws.1 and 2 claimed to be the eyewitnesses and they have
asserted as if there was only one stab injury. In fact, P.W.1 has admitted in his
26/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
evidence that he did not know whether deceased-1 suffered injury on the leg.
This fact also creates serious doubt about their presence in the place of
occurrence. According to P.W.3, he came to the place of occurrence by chance
and at that time, A-1 to A-3 came in a black colour Honda Car, A-4 and A-5
came in Pulzar two wheeler and A-6 came in another bike and they were
discussing that they want to finish off deceased-1. One Hakkeem was also
present along with P.W.3 and when they were standing there, P.Ws.1 and 2,
Sheriff came to the place of occurrence along with two deceased persons. His
evidence does not show about one Sheriff and Abbas Mandri who have
accompanied P.Ws.1 and 2, to the place of occurrence. It is further to be noted
that according to him, A-1 stabbed deceased-1, while A-3 and A-5 caught hold
of deceased-1 and at the instance of A-2, A-4 and A-6 caught hold of deceased-2
and A-2 caused stab injury to him. Thereafter, P.W.3 went to the hospital at
12.00 midnight on the same day. His evidence clearly indicates that bloodstains
were very much available in the place of occurrence. Further, his evidence also
shows that there were CCTV cameras in and around the place. P.W.3 claimed to
be the eyewitness and also visited the hospital and he has admitted that several
CCTV cameras are available in nearby shops.
25.It is further to be noted that P.W.3 claimed to be very close to
deceased-1. According to him, with regard to earlier incident of taking away
some beef from the shop of deceased-1 by A-1, deceased-1 called P.W.3 through
27/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
some one. Accordingly, deceased-1 and P.W.3 went to A-1's shop at 04.00 p.m.
and there, some quarrel ensued and at that time, A-1 threatened deceased-1 that
he will come to his place and will finish him off. When P.W.3 was close to
deceased-1, even after the alleged occurrence and having witnesses the crime
and gone to the hospital, he never whispered anything to the police, whereas he
was examined by the police for the first time only on 06.11.2015 by the
subsequent investigating officer. He has not even reported the occurrence to the
police station which is situate about 500 meters from the place of occurrence.
But his statement was recorded for the first time only on 06.11.2015 and the
said statement was sent to the court only on 04.03.2016. This fact creates
serious doubt about the entire prosecution. If really P.W.3 is very close to
deceased-1, his normal conduct would be that on seeing such double murder, at
least to give statement to the police immediately. Absolutely, there is no
explanation whatsoever from him to give belated statement to the police on
06.11.2015. It is further to be noted that according to him, prior incident was
informed by deceased-1 through some one else, whereas P.W.4 who is said to
have been examined to prove the alleged motive has spoken that deceased-1
only called P.W.3 over phone and informed about A-1 taking away some beef
from his shop. Thereafter, P.W.4 and P.W.3 and Mohideen Basha (deceased-1)
also went to A-1's shop in Ukkadam and questioned him. Therefore, the
evidence of P.Ws.3 and 4 with regard to earlier incident is also doubtful.
28/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
26.It is further to be noted that P.W.4 who claimed to be working under
deceased-1 and he is also very close relative of deceased-1. According to him,
on 31.10.2015, A-1 came to the shop of deceased-1 and took away 4 kgs of beef
liver and it was the motive and the same was questioned by deceased-1 later
along with P.W.3 and others. Whereas P.W.3 states that deceased-1 sent a word
to him through somebody and therefore, he went along with deceased-1 and
questioned A-1. But P.W.4 states that P.W.3 was informed through phone and
thereafter, all of them went to question A-1. At that time, there arose quarrel and
A-1 proclaimed that they will finish deceased-1 off in his place. It is relevant to
note that the evidence of P.W.4 also shows that he had also went to the hospital
but he had not given any complaint. He was examined for the first time by the
police on 08.11.2015 and his statement was sent to court on 04.03.2016. There
was no reason as to why such a close friend and relative has not come forward
to give any complaint. It is the evidence of P.W.4 that even on the next day, they
had also attended the funeral. Such being the case, giving statement to the
police after a week creates doubt about the alleged motive and P.W.3 witnessing
the crime. It is further to be noted that the very complaint indicates as if A-3
also accompanied P.Ws.1 and 2 and deceased-1 to question the other accused
persons and that Ex.P.1 does not implicate A-3. In the evidence, totally a
different version has been spoken by the witnesses.
29/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
27.As already pointed out, the very Ex.P.1 is not the first information and
this came after much deliberations and discussions. Therefore, the very presence
of P.Ws.1 and 2 in the place of occurrence is highly doubtful. The motive
spoken to by P.W.4 also creates some doubt to the prosecution case. The entire
prosecution theory indicates as if only after A-3 called deceased-1 over mobile
phone, the witnesses accompanied deceased to the place of occurrence. The
prosecution has not even made any attempt to seize or recover the mobile phone
of either A-3 or deceased-1 to find out whether there was actually any call at the
relevant point of time from A-3 to deceased-1. The seizure of the mobile phone
is the best evidence the prosecution could have been collected, as according to
P.W.1, only through the cell phone, A-3 called deceased-1. Therefore, the
prosecution could have easily produced such evidence. Further, the three
investigating officers, namely P.Ws.22, 23 and 24, Inspectors of Police who
conducted investigation, have not made any attempt to collect this piece of
evidence. This also creates a serious doubt about the entire genesis of the
prosecution case.
28.Admittedly, the alleged occurrence took place in a busy road in
Oppanakara Street, Coimbatore and it is surrounded by various shops, etc., The
evidence of the witnesses clearly show that CCTV cameras are very much
available in nearby shops. The investigating officers have not made any attempt
30/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
even to find out any footages from nearby shops. As per Ex.P.1 complaint, the
occurrence took place immediately after 07.30 p.m,, whereas the time has been
totally changed during their examination. This fact clearly suggest that only
after knowing that deceased-1 has received some stab injury and later he was
admitted in the hospital, only to suit the convenience of time of his admission in
the hospital, the time of occurrence was conveniently spoken by the witnesses.
The prosecution has not even made any attempt to show that bloodstains in the
place of occurrence was washed away in the rain and actually there was rain and
that it was a rainy day was not established. The prosecution could have at least
taken ordinary photographs to show the nature of the area and locality where
the alleged occurrence took place. The investigating officers have not made any
attempt even to take photographs of the place of occurrence. This also creates
serious doubt about the entire genesis of the prosecution theory.
29.The other eyewitness the prosecution relied on is P.W.7. P.W.7 is also a
neighbour of deceased-1 who resides in the same place. According to P.W.7,
deceased-1 is the neighbour and he and one Imran as usual were standing in
front of the Bakery on 31.10.2015 at about 09.15 p.m. Deceased 1 and 2, one
Jaheer, P.Ws.1 and 2, one Abbas Mandri came to the spot. At that time, the
accused also came there. A-3 and A-5 caught hold of deceased-1 and A-1
stabbed him. A-4 and A-6 caught hold of deceased-2 at the instruction of A-2
and A-2 stabbed him and by threatening the witnesses, the accused left the
31/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
place. P.W.7 and Imran went to the house and on the next day, on hearing the
news about the death of deceased-1, he gave statement to the police on
02.11.2015. His conduct assumes significance. According to him, immediately
after the occurrence, he went to the house, but he never informed the occurrence
to the family members or the neighbours. He has also admitted that there was
bloodstains in the place of occurrence. According to him, he himself gave
statement to the police on 02.11.2015. If really he was a witness and according
to him, he is the neighbour and in the very next house, deceased-1 was owning
beef stall and they know each other. Such being the position, P.W.7 casually
returning home even after witnessing such a gory incident of two serious
injuries on two persons and keeping silent even without informing his family
members or neighbours, also creates serious doubt about his presence in the
place of occurrence. Further, one Imran who also claimed to have seen the
occurrence has not been examined by the prosecution. Even the evidence of
P.W.7 does not indicate that the accused came in the car and motor cycle. His
161 Cr.P.C statement was recorded only on 02.11.2015 and it was sent to the
court for the first time on 04.03.2016. These facts create serious doubt about his
presence in the place of occurrence.
30.It is relevant to note that there were more than six persons apart from
P.Ws.3 and 7 along with deceased persons at the time of occurrence but they all
remained mute spectators and not even made any attempt even to prevent such
32/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
attack made by the accused persons. This conduct of witnesses creates serious
doubt about the occurrence. If really, P.W.2 who was the eyewitness could have
given the exact number of accused persons in the place, he has stated before the
doctor at the time of admission of deceased-1, that only 3 to 4 persons came to
the place and attacked deceased-1. According to P.W.10 who claimed to be the
brother of deceased-2, he came to the place of occurrence at 09.45 p.m and at
that time, P.W.2 was taking deceased-1 in an auto to the hospital and finding his
brother also lying down, P.W.10 took him to KG hospital and admitted him
there. Though he claimed that he had gone to the hospital, the evidence of
P.W.20, medical officer, clearly shows that only the friends of deceased-2
brought him to the hospital and it was one Subaid Mohamed who had brought
him to the hospital and not P.W.10. Therefore, his evidence does not prove the
prosecution case in any manner.
31.P.W.14 is the auto driver in the nearby auto stand. According to him, at
around 08.30 p.m., it was slightly drizzling and around 09.00 p.m, all the six
accused came there and A-3 and A-5 caught hold of deceased-1 and A-1 stabbed
him and A-4 and A6 caught hold of deceased-2 and A-2 stabbed him. The next
day, he came to know from the newspaper that two people died and thereafter
the police enquired him. Further, according to P.W.14, he has witnessed the
occurrence along with Paulraj, Ganeshkumar, Sirajudeen, Asif, Liyakath Ali,
Riyasudeen. However, none of them were examined by the prosecution. It is
33/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
relevant to note that in his evidence he has admitted that in the next day
newspaper, it has been appeared as if only two people came and stabbed the
deceased. Though the newspaper has not been filed, the fact remains is that if
P.W.14 has seen the occurrence along with friends, the prosecution has not
examined none of them and further the police station is situate very near. P.W.14
and others have also not reported the same to the police immediately. His
statement was also recorded, according to the prosecution, for the first time only
on 06.11.2015 and the same has been sent to court only on 04.03.2016. There
was inordinate delay and this creates serious doubt about the prosecution case.
32.The evidence of medical officers clearly proved this as homicidal
violence. Unfortunately, two persons have lost their lives in the homicidal
violence. The evidence of postmortem doctors clearly proved the fact that both
the deceased died by serious stab injuries, but the fact remains is that who
caused the stab injury has to be established. When the very genesis of the FIR is
the result of deliberation and there is serious embellishment in filing the FIR
and parrot like repetition by the relatives and friends, it is highly unsafe to
convict the accused. The motive though is trivial, P.W.4 was examined to prove
the motive aspect. The evidence of P.W.4 shows that he is close relative of
deceased-1. In this regard, his conduct assumes significance. Having present in
the hospital, he never disclosed the same to the police at the earliest point of
time. His section 161 statement was recorded only on 06.11.2015 and the
34/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
statement was sent to court on 04.03.2016. Further, the prosecution also claimed
to have seized the material objects M.Os.1 and 2 and the vehicles alleged used
in the crime, but no material whatsoever was placed by the investigating officer
as to who is the owner of the vehicles. The RC book and other documents
relating to the vehicle were not seized and placed. The CCTV camera footages
have also not been collected from the place. Further, the very best evidence with
regard to the alleged phone call from A-3 to deceased-1 at 07.30 p.m. on the
date of occurrence, has not been established. There was no reason as to why the
best evidence has not been recovered by the investigating officer. The material
objects were alledgedly seized by the investigating officer on 04.11.2015, but
the mahazar and Form 91 were sent to court for the first time on 16.11.2015.
This fact also creates serious doubt about the entire prosecution theory.
33.The very casual and slipshod investigation was conducted in this case.
Though three investigating officers have conducted investigation, they have not
even made any attempt even to seize the cell phone and CCTV footages from
the place of occurrence. Though all the witnesses have made parrot like
repetition about the occurrence that the same took place in front of the bakery, a
perusal of the rough sketch shows that the occurrence has taken place in the
middle of the busy road. Further, all the material objects and mahazar were sent
to the court only on 16.11.2015 with delay and there is no proper explanation
for the delay caused. Further, the forensic report does not show any
35/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
incriminating material against the accused. According to the evidence of P.W.8,
who was examined with regard to the seizure of material objects, he had
voluntarily gone to the police station and informed that on 04.11.2015, A-1,
A-2, A-3 and A-4 were travelling via Palladam and the police intercepted their
car bearing registration No.TN 37 AS 2526 and arrested them and recorded their
confession in his presence and pursuant to the same, the material objects were
seized. It is the prosecution case that all the bloodstained dresses were seized
from the accused at the time of arrest. It is highly improbable that the accused
were wearing the same dresses which they were wearing at the time of
occurrence for more than three days, till their arrest. The trial court rightly
disbelieved the arrest, seizure. Further the forensic reports Exs.P.20 and P.21 do
not point out any incriminating evidence like bloodstains in the material objects.
Only from the dresses recovered from the dead body of the deceased, the blood
group was found and no other items seized from the accused persons contain
any blood group. Therefore, the seizure also creates serious doubt and will not
prove the prosecution case.
34.Considering the evidence of witnesses and considering their parrot like
version of implicating all the accused and further, the evidence of P.W.14, an
auto driver, has no connection with the accused persons, but no test
identification parade was conducted, all these makes it unsafe to rely on their
evidence to convict the accused. Further, the documents were sent to the court
36/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
with a delay which remained unexplained. That apart, the non recovery of the
best piece of evidence, namely the mobile phone allegedly used by A-3 to call
deceased-1 to the place of occurrence and non collection of CCTV footages
from in and around the locality where the occurrence took place, all creates
serious doubt about the prosecution theory. Further, Ex.P.1, complaint registered
at the earliest point of time, never implicated A-3 and Ex.P.1 proceeded as if
A-3 also accompanied the witnesses. Whereas in the evidence only, A-3 was
implicated. Therefore, this is nothing but a clear case of improvement. Further,
the time of occurrence differs from Ex.P.1 and the evidence of witnesses. No
bloodstains whatsoever was recovered from the place of occurrence and not
even photographs were taken to show that the bloodstains were washed away in
the rain water. Further, no material was produced to show about the rainy or
cloudy condition. It is to be further noted that the trial court relied on the
evidence of eyewitness, namely P.Ws.1 to 3 and 7 and 14, but in the section
313 Cr.P.C questioning, the evidence of P.W.2 was not even put to the accused
which has also caused serious prejudice to the accused.
35.In the light of the above discussions and reasonings, this court is of the
considered view that the prosecution has not proved the guilt of any of the
accused beyond all reasonable doubt. Hence, the accused are entitled to the
benefit of doubt.
37/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
36.At this stage, it is also necessary to consider the case of A5/Jahir @
Jahir Hussain S/o.Abdul Razak, who has not preferred any separate appeal
against the judgment of conviction and sentence passed by the trial Court. In
this regard, to extend parity, it is necessary to refer to a decision of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Sahadevan and another v. State of Tamil Nadu reported in
(2012) 6 SCC 403, wherein, in paragraphs 40 to 44, it has been held as follows :
“40.In view of our above discussion, the last question for
consideration of the Court is as to what order, if any, is required to be
made against the non-appealing accused, i.e., accused No.1,
Chandran. From the prosecution evidence, it is clear that some role
had been specifically assigned to the accused Chandran. He is the
brother-in-law of the deceased and is stated to have been last seen
taking the deceased on the moped whereafter the deceased never
returned. In normal circumstances, the obvious result would be to
leave the nonappealing accused to undergo the punishment awarded
to him in accordance with law. But, where the Court finds that the
entire case of the prosecution suffers from material contradictions,
the most crucial evidence is not reliable, there are definite and
material flaws in the case of the prosecution and the Police has
failed to discharge its duties at different steps, in that event, it will be
difficult for this Court to leave the non-appealing accused to his fate.
41.Under the Indian criminal jurisprudence, an accused is presumed
to be innocent until proven guilty and his liberty can be curtailed by
putting him under imprisonment by due process of law only. If the
entire case of the prosecution has been found to be unreliable and
the prosecution, as a whole, has not been able to prove its case
beyond reasonable doubt, then the benefit should accrue to all the
38/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
accused persons and not merely to the accused who have preferred
an appeal against the judgment of conviction.
42.In Raja Ram v. State of Madhya Pradesh [(1994) 2 SCC 568 : 1994
SCC (Cri) 573], this Court extended the benefit of conversion of
sentence to all the accused, from that under Section 302 IPC to one
under Section 304 IPC, including the non-appealing accused. The
Court held that in its opinion, the case of the non-appealing accused
was not really distinguisbable from other accused persons and it was
appropriate that benefit of the judgment should also be extended to the
non-appealing accused, Ram Sahai, in that case.
43.Again, in Bijoy Singh v. State of Bihar [(2002) 9 SCC 147 : 2003
SCC (Cri) 1093] this Court clearly stated the principle that: (SCC p.
157, para 12)
“12. … [it] has set up a judicial precedent that where on
evaluation of the case if the court reaches the conclusion that
no conviction of any accused is possible, the benefit of that
decision must be extended to the co-accused, similarly
situated, though he has not challenged the order by way of an
appeal.”
44. In Pawan Kumar v. State of Haryana [(2003) 11 SCC 241 : 2004
SCC (Cri) 109] , while referring to the myth of the salutary powers
exercisable by the Court under Article 142 of the Constitution for
doing complete justice to the parties, the Court opined that powers
under Article 136 of the Constitution can be exercised by it even suo
motu and that the right to personal liberty guaranteed to the citizens, as
enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution, would be a factor
which can be considered by the Court in granting such reliefs .”
(emphasis supplied)
39/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
37.Similarly, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Md. Sajjad @ Raju @ Salim
Vs. State of West Bengal reported in (2017) 11 SCC 150 granting the benefit of
acquittal to the advantage of non-appealing accused also, has held in paragraphs
20 and 21 as follows:
‘20. Mr Mrinal Kanti Mandal, learned Advocate is right in submitting
that in certain cases this Court had granted benefit even to a nonappealing accused. In Bijoy Singh v. State of Bihar [Bijoy Singh v.
State of Bihar, (2002) 9 SCC 147 : 2003 SCC (Cri) 1093] , this Court
observed that if on evaluation of the case, a conclusion is reached that
no conviction of any accused was possible the benefit of that decision
must be extended to the similarly situated co-accused even though he
had not challenged the order by way of the appeal. To similar effect
was the dictum of this Court in Suresh Chaudhary v. State of Bihar
[Suresh Chaudhary v. State of Bihar, (2003) 4 SCC 128 : 2003 SCC
(Cri) 801] and in Pawan Kumar v. State of Haryana [Pawan Kumar v.
State of Haryana, (2003) 11 SCC 241 : 2004 SCC (Cri) 109] and in
Mohinder Singh v. State of Punjab [Mohinder Singh v. State of Punjab,
(2004) 12 SCC 311 : 2004 SCC (Cri) Supp 252] .
21. In the circumstances we allow the present appeal, set aside the
judgments of conviction recorded by the courts below against the
appellant and acquit him of all the charges levelled against him. We
further direct that the benefit of this acquittal and our decision will
also enure to the advantage of the non-appealing accused, namely, Sk.
Sahid alias Bablu. ‘
38.Therefore, the Supreme Court has consistently held that, where the
appellate Court, upon re-appreciation of the entire evidence, comes to the
40/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
conclusion that the prosecution has failed to establish the entire prosecution
case and no conviction of any of the accused can be sustained, the benefit of
such finding can also be extended to a non-appealing accused who is similarly
situated.
39.In the case on hand, as already stated supra, the prosecution has failed
to prove its case beyond all reasonable doubt and therefore, it is really unsafe to
convict the accused based on the evidence and the documents available and the
entire prosecution case is shrouded with serious doubt. Therefore, all the
accused are certainly entitled to the benefit of doubt.
40.In the light of the above, these three criminal appeals are allowed and
the judgment of the trial Court dated 27.10.2025 made in S.C.No.195 of 2016 is
set aside and all the appellants herein are acquitted of the charges levelled
against them. Though A-5 in this case, namely Jahir @ Jahir Hussain S/o.Abdul
Razak has not filed any separate appeal before this court as against the
conviction and sentence imposed on him by the trial court, since this court has
disbelieved the entire prosecution case, the benefit of acquittal should
automatically be extended to all the accused in this case, including A-5.
Accordingly, A-5 is also acquitted of all the charges levelled against him. It is
submitted by learned Additional Public Prosecutor that A-5 is also undergoing
incarceration in the Central Prison, Coimbatore.
41/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
41. Therefore, the appellants herein, namely A-1, A-3, A-4 and A-6 and
also A-5 (who has not filed any appeal before this court, details given supra),
are therefore directed to be set at liberty forthwith unless their custody is
required in connection with any other case. Fine amount, if any, paid by the
accused, shall be refunded to them. Consequently, connected miscellaneous
petitions are closed.
(N.SATHISH KUMAR J.)(K.RAJASEKAR J.)
24-09-2026
Index:Yes
Speaking order
Internet:Yes
vvk
To
1.V Additional District and Sessions Court,
Coimbatore.
2.The Inspector of Police,
Variety Hall Road Police Station,
Coimbatore.
3.The Public Prosecutor,
High Court, Madras.
4.The Superintendent,
Central Prison, Coimbatore.
42/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3925
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
N.SATHISH KUMAR J.
AND
K.RAJASEKAR J.
vvk
CRL A No. 1753 of 2025
and CRL A No. 233 of
2026,CRL MP No. 7519
of 2026,CRL MP No.
11184 of 2026,CRL A No.
1798 of 2025
24-09-2026
43/43
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review