Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 36
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
SWP No. 2445/2018
Date of pronouncement:- 08.11.2025
Date of uploading:- 13.11.2025
Asif Iqbal Malik, Age 29 years
S/o Mohammad Iqbal Malik,
R/o Village Bhatali, Tehsil
Thannamandi, District Rajouri.
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Syed Nadeem Hamdani, Advocate
vs
1. State of J&K th. Commissioner/Secy.
Home Department, Civil Secretariat,
Srinagar/Jammu.
2. Director General Police Jammu/Srinagar.
3. Dy. Inspector General of Police, RajouriPoonch Range, Rajouri.
4. Senior Superintendent of Police, Rajouri.
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Ms. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JAVED IQBAL WANI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
The petitioner, in the instant petition filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India , has challenged order No. 924 of 2018 dated
27.08.2018 [for short “the impugned order”], passed by Senior
Superintendent of Police, Rajouri-respondent No. 4 herein, in terms
whereof, the service of the petitioner as Special Police Officer (SPO)
have been terminated and a prayer has been made for reinstatement of
the petitioner from the date he has been disengaged, on the premise
that the petitioner herein came to be engaged as SPO by Inspector
General of Police (IGP), Jammu Zone, Jammu in the year 2013 and
came to be allotted Belt No. 1155/SPO-R, whereafter the petitioner
successfully completed his three months training and consequently,
came to be deployed at Police Station Thanamandi, wherefrom after
serving for almost three years, he came to be transferred to District
Police Line, Rajouri and thereafter came to be disengaged as SPO
despite the fact that the he have had performed his duties with full
dedication and discipline.
2.
The petitioner has challenged the impugned order on the multiple
grounds, including that the same has been issued in gross violation of
principle of natural justice, inasmuch as the rules and norms regulating
the terms and conditions of his service as SPO.
3.
Reply to the instant petition has been filed by the respondents, wherein
it is being stated that during the course of screening of SPOs’ of
District Rajouri, a verification of Character Antecedents thereof was
conducted through DySP CID, SB Rajouri, who, vide his letter No.
CID/SBR/2018/3269 dated 27.08.2018, reported that there is nothing
adverse against all the SPOs’ working in District Rajouri except the
petitioner-SPO Asif Iqbal Malik, who reportedly has been found
indulged in bovine smuggling, whereafter, respondent No. 3-Dy.
Inspector
General
of
Police,
Rajouri-Poonch
Range,
vide
communication dated 14.08.2018, directed the Senior Superintendent
of Police, Rajouri to disengage the petitioner from his services, as a
consequence whereof, in terms of the impugned order, the petitioner
came to be disengaged.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused material
available on record, as well as that produced by the counsel for
the respondents in compliance with the order passed by this
Court on the previous date of hearing.
SWP No. 2445/2018
4.
Before adverting to the respective submissions of the appearing
counsel for the parties, it would be significant to mention here that the
engagement of the SPOs’, inasmuch as, their powers, privileges,
protection and duties are provided under and in terms of the provisions
of Sections 18 and 19 of the Police Act Samvat., 1983 (1927 A.D.),
which, for the sake of convenience, are extracted and reproduced
hereunder:“….…..18.Special Police officers.When it shall appear that nay unlawful assembly, or riot or disturbance of the
peace has taken place, or may be reasonably apprehended, and that the Police
force ordinarily employed for preserving the peace is not sufficient for its
preservation and for the protection of the inhabitants and the security of
property in the place where such unlawful assembly or riot or disturbance of
the peace has occurred, or is apprehended, it shall be lawful for any Police
officer not below the rank of Inspector to apply to the nearest Magistrate to
appoint so many of the residents of the neighbourhood as such Police officer
may require to act as Special Police officers for such time and within such
limits as he shall deem necessary ; andthe Magistrate to whom such
application is made shall unless he see cause to the contrary comply with the
application.
19. Powers of Special Police Officers.––
Every special Police Officer so appointed shall have the same powers,
privileges and protection, and shall be liable to perform the same duties and
shall beamenable to the same penalties, and be subordinate to the same
authorities as the ordinary officers of Police…………..”
5.
Keeping in mind the aforesaid provisions of the Police Act of 1983 and
reverting back to the case in hand, it is not in dispute that the petitioner
came to be engaged by the respondents as SPO in the year 2013. It is also
an admitted fact that the petitioner continued to work as SPO with the
respondents up till the issuance of the impugned disengagement order
manifestly suggesting that the petitioner has worked with the respondents
for a considerable period of more than five years.
SWP No. 2445/2018
6.
It is significant to mention here that the doctrine of Audi Alteram Partem
and its application to judicial/quasi judicial and administrative institutions is
not new and that though the principles of Audi Alteram Partem have been
held to be a procedural requirement, yet it has been consistent view of the
Courts that the same ensures strong safeguard against any judicial or
administrative order or action adversely affecting the substantive rights of
an individual.
It is also pertinent to note here that the first principle of Audi
Alteram Partem is that there should be no bias and the rule against
the bias is expressed in the maxim that "no one must be judge in
his own cause", whereas the second broad principle of Audi
Alteram Partem is that "no person should be condemned
unheard", in that, the right to be heard would mean that a person
must know the case he or she has to meet and must have reasonable
opportunity to present his or her case, and the requirement of
issuance of a show cause notice as also an opportunity of hearing
has been held to be flowing directly from the said second principle
of doctrine of Audi Alteram Partem.
Here a reference to the judgment of the Apex Court passed
in case titled as "Dharampal Satyampal Limited vs. Deputy
Commissioner of Central" reported in 2015 (8) SCC 519 would be
appropriate wherein at Paras 21, 24 and 28, following has been
held:".………21. In common Law, the concept and doctrine of natural justice,
particularly which is made applicable in the decision- making by judicial and
quasi-judicial bodies, has assumed a different connotation. It is developed
with this fundamental in mind that those whose duty is to decide, must act
judicially. They must deal with the question referred both without bias and
they must give (sic an opportunity) to each of the parties to adequately present
the case made. It is perceived that the practice of aforesaid attributes in mind
SWP No. 2445/2018
only would lead to doing justice. Since these attributes are treated as natural
or fundamental, it is known as "natural justice". The principles of natural
justice developed over a period of time and which is still in vogue and valid
even today are: (i) rule against bias i.e. nemo debet esse judex in propria sua
causa; and (ii) opportunity of being heard to the party concerned i.e. audi
alteram partem. These are known as principles of natural justice. To these
principles a third principle is added, which is of recent origin. It is the duty to
give reasons in support of decision, namely, passing of a "reasoned order".
"24. The principles have a sound jurisprudential basis. Since the function of
the judicial and quasi-judicial authorities is to secure justice with fairness,
these principles provide a great humanizing factor intended to invest law with
fairness to secure justice and to prevent miscarriage of justice. The principles
are extended even to those who have to take an administrative decision and
who are not necessarily discharging judicial or quasi-judicial functions. They
are a kind of code of fair administrative procedure. In this context, procedure
is not a matter of secondary importance as it is only by procedural fairness
shown in the decision-making that a decision becomes acceptable. In its
proper sense, thus, natural justice would mean the natural sense of what is
right and wrong."
"28. It is on the aforesaid jurisprudential premise that the fundamental
principles of natural justice, including audi alteram partem, have developed.
It is for this reason that the courts have consistently insisted that such
procedural fairness has to be adhered to before a decision is made and
infraction thereof has led to the quashing of decisions taken. In many
statutes, provisions are made ensuring that a notice is given to a person
against whom an order is likely to be passed before a decision is made, but
there may be instances where though an authority is vested with the powers to
pass such orders, which affect the liberty or property of an individual but the
statute may not contain a provision for prior hearing. But what is important
to be noted is that the applicability of principles of natural justice is not
dependent upon any statutory provision. The principle has to be mandatorily
applied irrespective of the fact as to whether there is any such statutory
provision or not. ………….."
7.
Since the fundamental plea urged by the petitioner in the instant
petition against the impugned order is that the same has been issued
without following principles of natural justice, which plea of the
petitioner has not been specifically denied or controverted by the
respondents in the reply filed to the instant petition. Having regard to
SWP No. 2445/2018
the aforesaid position of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court
qua the doctrine of Audi Alteram Partem, as also the record available
on the file and the one produced by the counsel for the respondents, it
cannot be said that the respondents have observed the said principles
of Audi Alteram Partem, in breach, having failed to either issue a
show-cause notice to the petitioner or else providing him an
opportunity of hearing before issuing of the impugned order.
8.
Thus in view of the aforesaid position obtaining in the matter, the
impugned order, therefore, is not legally sustainable.
9.
For what has been observed, considered and analzed hereinabove, the
instant petition succeeds, as a consequence whereof, instant petition is
allowed and impugned order No. 924 of 2018 dated 27.08.2018 is
quashed and the respondents consequently are directed to re-instate the
petitioner back in service without back wages.
10.
Disposed of.
(Javed Iqbal Wani)
Judge
Jammu
08.11.2025
Vishal Sharma
Whether the order is reportable:
Yes
Whether the order is speaking:
Yes
SWP No. 2445/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review