Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
HCP No. 271/2025
Pronounced on: 09.07.2026
Asif Ahmad Dar
…Petitioner(s)
Through:
Mr. M. Ayoub Bhat, Advocate with
Ms. Mahjabeena Bhat, Advocate
Vs.
Union Territory of J&K and Ors.
...Respondent(s)
Through:
None
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAHUL BHARTI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner as well
as learned counsel for the respondents.
2.
Perused the writ pleadings and documents
annexed therewith.
Also
examined the
detention
record produced from the end of the respondents
relating to the petitioner’s detention.
3.
The facts of the case attending the preventive
detention custody of the petitioner getting ordered by
HCP No. 271/2025
the respondent No.2-District Magistrate, Pulwama are
that the Senior Superintendent of Police, (SSP),
Pulwama came to monitor and document alleged
activities of the petitioner which counted to be
prejudicial to the security of the State so in order to
prevent him from further indulging in such state of
activities while being in state of personal liberty, a
dossier came to be submitted to the respondent No.2District Magistrate, Pulwama accompanying letter No.
CS/PSA/25/25-28 dated 28.04.2025.
4.
The dossier introduced the petitioner as a
person who has done his Moulvi Course in the year
2017 and then getting in religious services in Jamia
Masjid,
Marvel
in
the
year
2019.
As
per
the
Intelligence Agencies’ reports and also as per Beat Incharge, Marvel Kakapora, the petitioner is said to have
got in contact with Anti-National elements during the
course study of his moulviship and got involved in
commission of anti-national and subversive activities
in the area to sabotage the integrity, security and
sovereignty of Nation. The petitioner is said to have
HCP No. 271/2025
been giving objectionable sermons about Jihad during
Friday prayers, thereby luring young generation to get
involved terrorist ranks. The petitioner was reckoned
to be a potential OGW of killed terrorists Riyaz Ahmad
Dar alias Khalid alias Sheeraz and Rayees Ahmad Dar,
by providing all logistical support in terms of food,
clothes, shelter and other logistical infrastructure. The
petitioner is said to be a highly radicalized and
sympathizer to terrorists being operative in District
Pulwama (Marvel area). The petitioner is reportedly in
touch with the POK handlers through different means.
5.
By reference to the purported noted state of
indulgences of the petitioner, he is said to have been
bound
down
on
05.03.2025,
10.04.2025
and
25.04.2025 under section 126 of Bharatiya Nagrik
Suraksha Sanhita, (BNSS), 2023, which provides for
security for keeping peace in other cases. On this
dossier’s content quality, the petitioner’s preventive
detention under J&K Public Safety Act, 1978 was
solicited from the end of the respondent No.2-District
HCP No. 271/2025
Magistrate, Pulwama vested with the jurisdiction to
order preventive detention of a person.
6.
One and half page dossier came to be literally
borrowed word by word by the respondent No.2District Magistrate, Pulwama to be introduced as a
grounds of detention for generating and lending a
purported subjective satisfaction to the respondent
No.2-District Magistrate, Pulwama that the petitioner
by purported reference to his alleged state of activities
deserves to be deprived of his fundamental right to
personal liberty by his preventive custody. Accordingly,
by virtue of an Order No. 03/DMP/PSA/25 dated
30.04.2025, the petitioner was ordered to be detained
so as to prevent him from acting in any manner
prejudicial to the security of the State and to be kept
detained in the District Jail, Udhampur for a period to
be specified by the Government.
7.
By virtue of a communication No.DMP/PSA/
25/07-09 dated 30.04.2025, the respondent No.2District Magistrate, Pulwama came to address to the
petitioner’s
notice
HCP No. 271/2025
about
the
fact
of
passing
of
detention
order
No.
03/DMP/PSA/25
dated
30.04.2025, and also apprising him about his right to
make a representation either to the Government or to
the detention order making authority that being the
District Magistrate, Pulwama.
8.
The
aforesaid
detention
order
No.03/DMP/PSA/25 dated 30.04.2025 came to be
executed by SI Mohd Yousuf of District Police Line,
Pulwama, who took the petitioner into custody on
01.05.2025 but before handing over his person to the
Assistant Superintendent, District Jail Udhampur
provided to the petitioner, against a proper receipt, the
entire
material/relevant
documents
and
also
explaining to him in the language, i.e. Urdu/Kashmiri
to the satisfaction that the petitioner had understood
all said material fully.
9.
record
The executing officer-SI Mohd Yousuf is on
to
say
in
his
Execution
Report
dated
01.05.2025 that he informed the petitioner about his
right to make a representation to the Government
against the detention order meaning thereby what was
HCP No. 271/2025
edited out from being apprised to the petitioner is a
fact that he was also entitled to make a representation
against his preventive detention even to the detention
order
making
authority
that
being
the
District
Magistrate, Pulwama.
10.
The receipt of grounds of detention fetched
from the petitioner against his signature by SI Mohd
Yousuf is also confirming the said fact that what the
petitioner
came
to
be
apprised
and
which
he
acknowledged as a fact is that he could make a
representation against his preventive detention to the
Government.
11.
By virtue of Government Order No. Home/PB-
V/884 of 2025 dated 08.05.2025, approval came to be
granted to the detention order No.03/DMP/PSA/2025
dated 30.04.2025 awaiting the opinion of the Advisory
Board to whom the petitioner’s detention case was
forwarded for examination.
12.
The Advisory Board, by virtue of its report
dated 21.05.2025, came to examine the detention of
HCP No. 271/2025
the petitioner and found it to be based on sufficient
grounds and, accordingly, recommended so.
13.
The Advisory Board in its Opinion Report
comes forth with a recital in para 2 that the petitioner
was informed of his right of making representation
against his detention to the detaining authority as also
to the Government. Wherefrom this fact came to be
read by the Advisory Board from the record produced
is, least to say, is left to be better known to the
Advisory Board because the Execution Report and the
Receipt on record is contrary to said observation and it
is here where the very constitutional right of the
petitioner got punctured vitiating the very basis of
procedural safety and safeguards for a detenu being
subjected to a preventive detention custody.
14.
On the basis of the Advisory Board’s purported
Opinion, the confirmation of the petitioner’s preventive
detention
came
to
be
effected
by
virtue
of
a
Government Order No. Home/PB-V/1052 of 2025
dated
30.05.2025
and
also
prescribing
first
installment of period of detention from 01.05.2025 till
HCP No. 271/2025
31.10.2025 and continued to be detained in District
Jail, Udhampur.
15.
The petitioner’s preventive detention has been
further extended from 01.11.2025 till 30.04.2026 by
virtue of subsequent Government Order No. Home/PBV/1964 of 2025 dated 29.10.2025.
16.
The Advisory Board, in its opinion report, has
categorically referred to fact that there was a no
representation
made
by
petitioner
as
no
such
representation was found lying on the file so placed by
the Government before the Advisory Board for seeking
its
opinion
with
respect
to
justifiability
of
the
petitioner’s preventive detention.
17.
As against the aforesaid fact, the District
Magistrate, Pulwama in terms of his communication
No. DMP/PA/25/184-87 dated 13.05.2025 addressed
to none else than the petitioner is on record to say that
on 13.05.2025 representation was presented on his
behalf by his wife-Ruhi Jan, very much in the hands of
the District Magistrate, Pulwama and still the Advisory
Board in its opinion report dated 21.05.2025 was
HCP No. 271/2025
finding no such representation accompanying the file
so forwarded by the Government for examining it for
its opinion.
18.
The
respondent
No.2-District
Magistrate,
Pulwama, by virtue of his aforesaid communication
dated 13.05.2025, purportedly apprised the petitioner
about the fact that his representation upon being
considered by him has been found devoid of any merit.
19.
by
The Superintendent, District Jail, Udhampur,
communication
No.
DJU/MS/25/4702
dated
14.05.2025 addressed to the Additional Secretary
Home
Department,
Government
of
Jammu
and
Kashmir was apprising him about the fact of disposal
of the petitioner’s representation so made to the
District Magistrate, Pulwama meaning thereby even
the Government was well posted with the notice of fact
that the petitioner had made a representation against
the preventive detention to the District Magistrate,
Pulwama, notwithstanding the fact that he was not
apprised about his said right by the detention warrant
executing officer Mohd Yousuf, and still when the file
HCP No. 271/2025
came to be forwarded to the Advisory Board there was
no such representation accompanying the file for
consideration of the Advisory Board and its fate found
by Advisory Board to be missing on record.
20.
The petitioner has assailed his preventive
detention and the Government through the counter
affidavit filed by District Magistrate, Pulwama of the
time is defending the preventive detention of the
petitioner.
21.
The
respondent
No.2-District
Magistrate,
Pulwama in his counter affidavit is nowhere adverting
to
the
fact
that
how
come
the
petitioner’s
representation made to him and its disposal by him
was not further forwarded to the Government for
notice and consideration of the Advisory Board.
22.
The petitioner cannot be expected to have an
access to the file/record which is in the making related
to preventive detention of the petitioner and, therefore,
a challenge to this type of omission on the part of the
District Magistrate concerned as well as the Home
Department,
Government
HCP No. 271/2025
of
UT
of
Jammu
and
Kashmir cannot fall to the notice of the detenu to be
cited as a ground of challenge to the preventive
detention but upon examination of the record sent for
by constitutional court such serious flaws come
rushing out which cannot escape from being taken
into serious consideration for examining the legality of
preventive detention so imposed and inflicted upon a
detenu.
23.
In the light of the aforesaid serious flaws, this
Court finds that the preventive detention of the
petitioner is afflicted with an illegality which renders
the very exercise a nullity.
24.
Accordingly,
the
detention
order
No.
03/DMP/PSA/25 dated 30.04.2025 passed by the
respondent No.2-District Magistrate, Pulwama read
with approval/confirmation/extension order(s) passed
by the respondent No.1 related to the petitioner are
hereby quashed.
25.
The petitioner is directed to be restored to his
personal liberty by his release from the concerned Jail
wherever he is kept confined and to said effect, the
HCP No. 271/2025
Superintendent concerned Jail to act in compliance by
release of the petitioner from the Jail custody.
26.
The detention record being in Photostat form
needs not be returned and is to be retained on the file.
27.
Disposed of.
(RAHUL BHARTI)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR:
09.07.2026
“Manzoor”
Whether the judgment is speaking
:
Yes / No
Whether the judgment is reportable
:
Yes / No
HCP No. 271/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review