Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
* THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.V. SHRAVAN KUMAR
+ Application No.1 of 2025 in C.S. No.13 of 1958
% Dated 20-02-2026
Between:
# Ashrafunnissa Begum (died)
Defendant No.123 died Per LRs
Ibrahim Ali Khan S/o. Late Nawab Safdar Ali Khan,
and Nine others
…
Applicants/Petitioners
and
$ Syed Hassan S/o. Nawab Syed Abdullah
(Died per LRs respondents No.1 to 5 herein)
Lateefunnisa Begum W/o. Nawab Syed Hassan
and One Hundred and Sixty One others.
…
Respondents/Defendants
! Counsel for the Petitioner
:
Mr. Ali Farooq
^ Counsel for the respondents
:
Vedula Chitralekha
< GIST
:
---
>HEAD NOTE
? Cases referred:
1. AIR 2006 KERALA 255
2. (2012) 3 Supreme Court Cases 548
:
:
---
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.V. SHRAVAN KUMAR
Application No.1 of 2025 in C.S. No.13 of 1958
Between:
Date: 20.02.2026
Ashrafunnissa Begum (died)
Defendant No.123 died Per LRs
Ibrahim Ali Khan S/o. Late Nawab Safdar Ali Khan,
and Nine others
…
Applicants/Petitioners
And
Syed Hassan S/o. Nawab Syed Abdullah
(Died per LRs respondents No.1 to 5 herein)
Lateefunnisa Begum W/o. Nawab Syed Hassan
and One Hundred and Sixty One others.
…
Respondents/Defendants
JUDGMENT: (Per the Hon’ble Sri Justice N.V. Shravan Kumar)
Mr. Ali Farooq, learned counsel for the Applicants and Mr.
Vedula
Srinivas, learned Senior Counsel represents Ms.Vedula
Chitralekha, learned counsel for the respondent No.9.
2.
This Application is filed under Order XXII Rule 4 read with
Section 23 of CPC seeking to bring the Applicants as the legal
representatives of the deceased Smt. Ashrafunnisa Begum (Defendant
No.123) as defendants 163 to 171 in C.S. No.13 of 1958 pending on
the file of the High Court. The Applicant No.4 on his behalf and on
behalf of the other Applicants/petitioners, who are his real brothers,
sisters, nephews and niece with their consent has filed the present
Application.
3.
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
Learned counsel for the Applicants/petitioners would submit
that originally the defendant No.11 i.e. Nawab Sajid Yar Jung S/o. late
Nawab Dawar Ali Khan @ Behram-Ud-Dowla, in C.S. No.13 of 1958,
died intestate leaving behind his wife, two sons and five daughters
and they were brought on record as defendants No.117 to 124 as their
sole legal heirs as per the order in Application No.173 of 1960 order
dated
23.09.1960.
The
mother
of
the
petitioners
Smt. Ashraf Unnisa Begum W/o. late Nawab Safdar Ali Khan D/o. late
Nawab Sajid Yar Jung, (Defendant No.11) being one of the daughters
was also brought on record as defendant No.123 in the above case.
4.
It is submitted that the Applicants are the legal heirs of the
deceased late Smt. Ashraf Unnisa Begum, who died intestate on
01.04.2015, at Kamineni Hospital, Boggulkunta, Hyderabad, leaving
behind the Applicants No.1 to 6 being the sons, and Applicants No.7
being the daughter and the Applicants No.8 to 10 being Grand Sons
and Grand Daughter.
The sister of the Applicants No.1 to 7
Meherunnisa Begum died intestate on 08.03.2016, leaving behind two
sons and one daughter i.e. the Applicants No.8 to 10).
5.
It is further submitted that the Applicants/petitioners being the
legal heirs and successors of Smt. Ashraf Unnisa Begum (defendant
No.123 in C.S. No.13 of 1958) inherited her right, title and interest in
the preliminary decree, passed in Applicant No.134, 137, 138 and 139
of 1958 and Applications dated 17.11.1958 and 02.12.1958 vide order
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
dated 05.03.1959, in which the Maternal Grand Father of the
Applicants, Nawab Sajid Yar Jung being defendant No.11 was entitled
to 27-3/5th Paisa in a Rupee share in the properties and 36-31/96
Paisa in a Rupee in commutation amount. In the preliminary decree,
the mother of the Applicants inherited 1/9th share from out of 28
Paisa of her father’s share late Sajid Yar Jund (defendant No.11), from
out of total 192 Paisa, as per the said decree passed in the abose case.
As such, the Applicants No.1 to 6 being the sons and Applicant No.7
being the daughter and the Applicants No.8 to 10 being grand sons
and grand daughter of Smt. Ashrafunnisa Begum are entitled to come
on record as defendants in the said C.S. No.13 of 1958 being the legal
heirs of defendant No.123 and that except the Applicants, their
mother has not left any other person/s as her legal heir.
6.
It is further submitted that the Applicants No.1 to 7 along with
their deceased sister Meherunnisa filed Application in SR No.5123 of
2015,
subsequently
numbered
as
Application
No.1
of
2023.
On the death of Applicant No.8 Smt. Meherunnisa, the Applicants and
the legal heirs of Smt. Meherunnisa i.e. Applicants No.8 to 10 filed
another Application in I.A. No.3 of 2023 in I.A. No.1 of 2023,
to bring them on record as defendants being the legal heirs and
representatives of the deceased Smt. Ashrafunnisa Begum (defendant
No.123) in C.S. No.13 of 1958.
This Court vide order dated
23.02.2024, disposed of the said Applicants with a leave to obtain and
file Succession Certificate, if any before the disposal of C.S. No.13 of
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
1958. The Applicants as per the orders have filed Succession O.P. by
name SOP. No.55 of 2024 on the file of the I Senior Civil Judge, City
Civil Court at Hyderabad and the trial Court by an order dated
04.11.2024 allowed the petitioner and issued Succession Certificate in
favour of the Applicants holding that the Applicants are the legal heirs
and Successors of Smt. Ashrafunnisa Begum (Defendant No.123).
It is further submitted that as per the said preliminary decree dated
05.03.1959, the mother of the Applicants Smt. Ashrafunnisa Begum
inherited from her father’s defendant No.11 allotted share i.e. 28-3/5th
share from out of 1 Rupee or 192 Paisa.
The Applicants mother
inherited the said share in the above said immovable properties along
with her four sisters and two brothers i.e. defendants No.117 to 122 in
the above C.S. No.13 of 1958. Accordingly, the Applicants being the
proper and necessary parties to the suit are to be brought on record
as the legal heirs of defendant No.123.
7.
On behalf of the respondents No.9 and 10, while denying the
averments made in the Application, counter affidavit has been filed,
inter alia, stating that late Smt. Ashrafunnisa Begum was one of the
daughters of late Nawab Sajid Yar Jung, who was the 11th defendant
in the C.S. No.13 of 1958.
After his demise, the mother of the
Applicants i.e. Smt Ashrafunnisa Begum was brought on record in the
C.S. No.13 of 1958 as defendant No.123. Ultimately, the C.S. No.13
ended in a compromise and a compromise decree was passed on
05.03.1959
wherein
the
defendant
No.11
i.e.
father
of
late
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
Smt. Ashrafunnisa Begum was allotted with 28-3/5th share in the
schedule of properties. The said 11th defendant in C.S. No.13 of 1958
late Nawab Sajid Yar Jung had four sons and three daughters and
hence the mother of the Applicants i.e. Smt. Ashrafunnissa Begum
was entitled to 1/9th share of 28-3/5th Paise in the schedule of
properties during her lifetime. It is further submitted that the father
of the respondents is late Syed Abdullah Khan, who was the brother of
late Zainab Begum who was the mother of late Salar Jung-III i.e., wife
of late Nawab Salar Jung-II.
Thus, late Nawab Salar Jung-III was
their first cousin and their father died on 20.02.1954 subsequent to
the death of late Nawab Salar Jung-III, on 02.03.1949. As their father
was alive at the time of death of late Nawab Salar Jung-III, their father
became sole surviving successor of late Nawab Salr Jung-III.
When the Nazim Atiyat cum Jagir Administrator directed all the
interested parties to obtain succession as the successors of Salar
Jung-III through a competent Civil Court, the mother of the
Applicants late Smt. Ashrafunnisa Begum along with some others had
filed O.S. No.156 of 1980 on the file of VII Senior Civil Judge, City
Civil Court Hyderabad, to declare them as successors of Salar Jung-III
and also eligible for the commutation amount. The respondents No.9
and 10 were the defendants No.31 and 32 in the said suit. The said
suit was decreed on 12.10.2004 whereby some of the plaintiffs therein
including the mother of the Applicants i.e. late Smt. Ashrafunnisa
Begum were allotted with 2/3rd share in the commutation amount and
the defendants including respondents No.9 and 10 were allotted with
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
1/3rd share lying with the Nazim Atiyat cum Jagir Administrator and
some parties to the suit were denied the successorship. Against the
judgment and decree dated 12.10.2004 Appeals in A.S. No.222 of
2005 and A.S. No.335 of 2005 were filed by the unsuccessful parties
in the Court of the III Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, which
were dismissed on 01.08.2007 by a common judgement. The Court,
while dismissing the appeals, observed as under:
“As per above rules the Paternal and Maternal
uncles and aunts of the descendants in class III
heirs, the descendants HLS, nearer in degree
excluding more remote.
So, the Paternal aunt
Sultan Bakt Begum and Maternal uncle Syed
Abdullah Khan of Salar Jung III are in Group-I; per
clause –II of Sec.102 the groups each in turn must
be exhausted before any member of the next group
can succeed.
It is evident that the paternal and
maternal uncles and aunts of Salarjung III come in
first preference to succeed the deceased Salarjung
III and they must be exhausted before the next
group can succeed.
(d) In that view of the matter, as rightly held by the
court below those parties in OS No.156/80, who
are the heirs of class III under Sec.102 will exclude
the remoters i.e., the appellants herein in both the
appeals.
No other provision of law other than
Sec.102, has been shown to this court by the
appellants to substantiate their contention that they
can also claim a share as nearest heirs in class III,
to inherit the estate of Salrajung-III.
find issue No.1 against the appellants.”
Therefore, I
8.
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
It is further contended that the respondents No.9 and 10 are in
Group-I and as per clause II of Section 102, are the first group that is
to be exhausted before any member of the next group. It is further
submitted that the mother of the Applicants Smt. Ashrafunnisa
Begum was never a successor of Salar Jung-III but only legal
representative of Salar Jung-I and per the above observation made in
A.S. No.222 of 2005 and 333 of 2007, she does not fall into the
criteria of near descendants at all and is not eligible for the
commutation amount.
The paternal aunts of Salarjung-III are all
predeceased hence are not entitled to claim any succession through
Salarjung-III and these are the descendents of the paternal aunts.
Though no appeal was filed by the respondents against the above
order dated 01.08.2007 in A.S. Nos.222 and 335 of 2005, the same is
decided in contravertion to Section 102 of the Mohamedan Law and
hence the same is bad as such, the Application is liable to be
dismissed.
9.
The Applicants/Petitioners, filed reply/rejoinder to the counter
affidavit and while denying would submit that the averments are
factually incorrect and would submit that Nawab Sajid yar Jung who
is their maternal grand father had only two sons and five daughters
and the respondent No.9 is not a member of the Salar Jung family at
all.
The issues of inheritance, relationships and fractional shares
entitled to each party in commutation amounts have absolutely no
relevance to this suit and the present Application is filed only to bring
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
the heirs and successors of their mother late Ashrafunnissa Begum
defendant No.123 on record in the suit in C.S. No.13 of 1958 and
having fulfilled all the requirements to satisfy the Court filed the
present Application with all the relevant documents and a decree of
the Civil Court to prove their succession and there are fair chances of
their application being allowed.
It is further submitted that the
respondent No.9 had no occasion to try to import proceedings of suits
and appeals concerning Jagir commutation amounts that were before
a Civil Court and the appellate Court and such acts are obviously
done to cause confusion and mislead the Court and also waste its
valuable time.
10.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material made available on the record.
11.
The Applicants claim to be the legal heirs and successors of
Smt. Ashraf Unnissa Begum, who is defendant No.123 in C.S. No.13
of 1958. This Court on 23.02.2024, disposed of the Applications No.3
of 2024 and I.A. No.1 of 2023 in C.S. No.13 of 1958, which were filed
by the Applicants therein to bring them as the legal representatives of
the deceased Smt. Ashrafunnisa Begum (Defendant No.123) as
defendants 159 to 166 in C.S. No.13 of 1958. The relevant portion of
the order is extracted for reference:
“3.
The applicants claim to be legal heirs of the
deceased Smt.Ashrafunnisa Begum.
But they
have not filed any succession certificate.
They
have also failed to disclose as to how the subject
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
property has devolved on them as being legal
heirs.
4.
In view of the material defects filed along
with this application, the application cannot be
entertained.
5.
However, petitioners are granted leave to
file appropriate application and obtain succession
certificate.
6.
We leave it open to the petitioners to file the
succession certificate, if any, before the disposal of
C.S. No.13 of 1958 finally.
7.
12.
Accordingly, application is disposed of.”
Thereafter, the Applicants have filed SOP. No.55 of 2024 under
Section 372 of Indian Succession Act for grant of Succession
Certificate in their favour in respect of debts of deceased Smt. Ashraf
Unnisa Begum, who died on 01.04.2015, on the file of the I Senior
Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad and obtained Succession
Certificate vide order dated 04.11.2024, which is filed along with the
present Application, wherein and whereby the schedule of property
was mentioned which is extracted for reference:
“All that the share amount of Rs.49,111/- of
Smt.Ashraf Unnisa Begum, D/o.Late nawab Sajid
Yar Jung, W/o. Late Nawab Safdar Ali Khan, who
died on 01.04.2015, lying with the respondent
No.1.
The
Chief
Commissioner
Land
Administration (Jagir Administration) under Khata
No.5 towards the Jagir Commutation amount or
any other heading relating to the last holder of the
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
Jagir Nawab Yousuf Ali Khan, Salar Jung III, from
the
declared
2/3rd
commutation
amount
of
Rs.12,15,650-88 paisa to the descendants of
Sultan Baqth Begum, D/o. Salar Jung I, Paternal
Aunt of Salar Jung III in O.S.156 of 1980 from out
of Total amount of Rs.18,23,476-32 paisa.”
13.
On a perusal of the said order, the trial Court issued Succession
Certificate in favour of the Applicants with a direction to the
respondent
No.1
therein,
The
Chief
Commissioner,
Land
Administration (Jagir Administration), O/o. CCLA, Nampally Station
Road, Hyderabad, to transfer the petition schedule amount of
Rs.49,111/- in favour of the Applicants with accrued interest lying
with the respondent No.1 on proper identification and under proper
acknowledgment.
Further, it is observed that in the Succession
Certificate in SOP. No.55 of 2024, the Applicants have not made the
respondents in the present Application as party respondents therein,
however, made the Chief Commissioner, Land Administration (Jagir
Administration), as the respondent No.1 and the respondent No.2 as
“All Concerned”. The respondents No.9 and 10 have denied/disputed
the legal heirship of the Applicants and when the respondents have
specifically
denied,
the
Applicants
ought
to
have
sought
for
declaratory relief for their legal heirship status to the extent of
claiming
immovable
properties
and
ought
to
have
filed
a
comprehensive suit separately to declare their legal heirship status.
It is further to be noted that the Succession Certificate issued under
Indian Succession Act does not establish legal heirship or title to
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
immovable property and by itself is not sufficient to get impleaded or
recognised legal heirship when the heirship itself is disputed. Section
370 to 381 of Indian Succession Act apply to debts, securities,
movables, assets and immovable properties are expressly excluded.
As
such,
the
Succession
Certificate
cannot
decide
heirship
conclusively to the extent of immovable properties.
14.
The Kerala High Court in the case of P.K. Vishalakshi Vs. The
Bank of India1 held that under Section 372, Succession Certificate
can be granted only in respect of debts and securities therefore,
refusal to grant certificate in respect of the immovable property is not
improper. Relevant paras 4 and 7 are extracted for reference:
“4.
A reading of Secs. 70 and 72 of the Act,
particularly, clause (f) of sub section (1) of Sec.
372 of the Act, will show that a succession
certificate can be applied for only in respect of
debts and securities. The expression “Debt” has
not been defined under the Act.
expression has not been
The said
defined under the
General Clauses Act as well. If so, one has to go
by the ordinary meaning of the said expression. A
debt
means
any
pecuniary
liability
whether
payable in praesenti or in future to another in
return for money, services, goods or any other
obligation. A debt is also property in the form of
a chose in action and is heritable and assignable
as understood in law.
In the case of securities
sub-section 2 of Sec. 70 of the Act enumerates the
various securities envisaged by the section. They
are as under:
AIR 2006 KERALA 255
“(a)
any
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
promissory
note,
debenture,
stock or other security of the Central Government
or of a State Government;
(b)
any bond, debenture, or annuity
charged by Act of Parliament (of the United
Kingdom) on the revenues of India;
(c)
any stock or debenture of, or share
in, a company or other incorporated institution :
(d)
any debenture or other security for
money issued by, or on behalf of, a local authority;
(e)
any other security which the (State
Government) may, by notification in the Official
Gazette, declare to be a security for the purposes
of this part”.
The fact that a succession certificate can be
issued only in respect of a debt or security is
further reinforced from the wording sub section (3)
of Sec. 372 which clarifies that an application for
a succession certificate can be made in respect of
any debt or debts due to a deceased creditor or in
respect of portions thereof.
Sec. 376 of the Act
makes provision for the grant of extension of
succession certificate to any additional debt or
security.
Sec. 377 of the Act says that the
certificate as well as extension of certificate shall
be in the forms set forth in Schedule VII of the
Act.
7.
justified
Thus the Court below was perfectly
in
declining
to
grant
a
succession
certificate in respect of the immovable property
described in the II Schedule of the O.P. We see no
reason to interfere with the order passed by the
Subordinate Judge.
The result of the forgoing discussion is that
this appeal which is bereft of any merit is liable to
be dismissed and we do so. However, in the facts
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
and circumstances of the case, there shall be no
order as to costs.
Appeal dismissed.”
15.
In the Application filed in SOP. No.55 of 2024, it was submitted
that the deceased was the daughter of late Nawab Sajid Yar Jung, who
was the defendant No.11 in a partition suit in respect of properties left
by Nawab Yousuf Ali Khan (Salar Jung-III) who is the last holder of
Jagirs died on 02.03.1949.
After the death of Salarjung-III a
Committee was formed by the Government of Hyderabad to manage
the estate of the Salarjung-III. While so, several parties had filed suit
for partition of the Matruka properties vide O.S. Nos.39/1/1955,
40/1/1955 in view of the importance of the cases, clubbing all the
suits and numbered the same as C.S. No.13 of 1958. On 05.03.1959
Preliminary Compromise Decree was passed in C.S. No.13 of 1959
hence, Nawab Sajid Yar Jung being defendant No.11 (who is maternal
grand father of petitioners) allotted 28-3/5 paise share in the
immovable properties and Rs.36-31/96 paise in the commutation
amount in Khata No.5 and others.
On death of Nawab Sajid Yar
Jung, the deceased being one of the daughter brought on record in the
said suit as defendant No.123 entitled to 3½ share out of 36-31/96
share of Nawab Sajid Yar Jung.
It was further submitted that the
mother of the petitioners and other legal heirs approached respondent
No.1 to release the commutation amount. However, they refused to
release the said amount and directed the parties to approach the
Court for declaration. Hence, petitioners’ mother and other legal heirs
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
of Salarjung-III filed suit for declaration vide O.S. No.156 of 1980 and
O.S. No.1451 of 1983.
On 12.10.2004, VII SCJ, City Civil Court,
Hyderabad passed common judgment and decree in favour of the
plaintiffs along with other defendants declared to entitle to receive
2/3rd share out of commutation amount of Rs.12,15,650-88 paise
from Rs.18,23,476.32 paise according to their share and personal law
to the branch of Sultan Baqth Begum, who is none other than
paternal aunt of late Nawab Yusuf Ali Khan, Salarjung-III.
It was
further submitted that as per preliminary decree in C.S. No.13 of
1958, the VII SCJ, City Civil Court, Hyderabad confirmed the share of
the petitioners mother Smt. Ashraf Junnisa Begum, who is entitled to
an amount of Rs.49,111/-from out of Rs.12,15,650/-. After the death
of late Smt. Ashraf Unnisa Begu, petitioners filed petition before
respondent No.1 for release of said amount, but no action has been
taken by the respondent No.1 but informed the petitioner to get
Succession Certificate for release of the said amount.
Thereafter,
summons were dispatched to the respondents No.1 and inspite of
paper publication, no objections were received against the respondent
No.2/All concerned as such, the proceedings against the respondents
went on ex parte. The trial Court observed that the petitioners filed a
petition by invoking Section 372 of Indian Succession Act, seeking the
relief of Succession Certificate in favour of the petitioners and
consequentially to direct the respondent No.1 to transfer the petition
schedule amount which is lying in the name of deceased in favour of
the petitioners. It was the contention of the petitioners that during
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
the life time of deceased, she acquired her commutation amount share
lying with respondent No.1 and the deceased did not make a
testamentary disposition and they alone are entitled to claim the
same. The trial Court further noted that Ex.P37 is the certified copy
of common judgment and decree, which showing that the said
judgment and decree passed by VII SCJ, City Civil Court, Hyderabad
in O.S. No.156 of 1980 and 1451 of 1983 in favour of the plaintiffs to
receive 2/3rd commutation amount.
Ex.P38 is the certified copy of
common judgment in A.S. No.222 of 2005 and As.No.335 of 2005 and
Ex.P 39 is the Fatwa. The trial Court has further observed that prima
facie the petitioners had a case as there is no contra evidence was
available on record and allowed the petition and issued Succession
Certificate in favour of the petitioners 1 to 10 therein and directed the
respondent No.1 to transfer the petition schedule amount.
16.
As could be seen from the relief sought for by the Applicants is
that their mother inherited from her father defendant No.11 allotted
share i.e. 28-3/5th share from out of 1 Rupee or 192 Paisa.
The Applicants mother inherited the said share in the above said
immovable properties along with her four sisters and two brothers
i.e. defendants No.117 to 122 in the C.S. No.13 of 1958. The mother
of the Applicants inherited 2-281/360 share in the immovable
properties from out of her father’s defendant No.11 allotted share
i.e. 28-3/5th share from out of 1 Rupee or 192 Paisa.
17.
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
At this juncture, it is to be noted that the Applicants have not
mentioned the details of the immovable properties for which they lay a
claim as legal heirs of defendant No.123. It is also to be noted that
the Applicants have also not mentioned the extent of immovable
properties, to which compromise was recorded in the preliminary
decree dated 05.03.1959.
18.
Succession Certificate does not suffice for claiming immovable
properties and cannot establish the legal heirship when disputed.
Since the partition proceedings are property specific, the Applicants
must specify definite immovable properties in respect of which they
claim rights. Without specifying the same, impleadment of legal heir
is not maintainable.
It is to be noted that the trial Court did not
determine the rights of the Applicants for the immovable properties in
compromise/preliminary
decree
dated 05.03.1959 as
such
the
Succession Certificate cannot be the basis to determine their rights to
the extent of immovable properties. It is also pertinent to note that
the preliminary decree was passed on 05.03.1959 and Smt. Ashraf
Unnisa Begum W/o. late Nawab Safdar Ali Khan D/o.Nawab Sajid Yar
Jung, died intestate on 01.04.2015. Thereafter, the first application
in I.A. No.1 of 2023 and Application No.3 of 2024 in C.S. No. 13 of
1958 and the present Application was filed without explaining reasons
for the delay.
19.
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
Further, the Applicants in Application No.3 of 2024 and
I.A. No.1 of 2023 in C.S. No.13 of 1958 prayed this Court to bring
them as legal heirs as defendants No.159 to 166 however, in the
present Application are seeking to bring them as legal heirs of the
deceased Ashraf Unnisa Begumas as defendants No.163 to 171 in
C.S. No.13 of 1958.
20.
Further, upon a perusal of the latest cause title amended from
time to time by the Registry, wherefrom it is culled out that as per
order dated 12.06.2002 in Application No.635 to 637 of 2002
defendants were brought on record as defendants No.159 to 168 and
similarly vide Court order dated 01.09.2004 in Application No.854 of
2004 in C.S. No.13 of 1958, defendants No.169 to 180 were brought
on record as legal heirs of defendant No.2.
Since the defendants
No.159 to 168 and 169 to 180 were already brought on record vide
Court orders dated 12.06.2002 and 01.09.2004, now, at this point of
time, the Applicants in the present Application cannot be brought on
record and arrayed as defendants No.163 to 171 in C.S. No.13 of
1958.
21.
Further, since the Applicants are seeking to come on record as
proper and necessary party being the legal heirs of defendant No.123
claiming shares in immovable properties as per preliminary decree
dated 05.03.1959, the details of such immovable properties are also
not mentioned in the Applications and that since their status of legal
heirship is also disputed, the Applicants ought to have obtained
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
declaratory decree in terms of Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act,
1963 as to declaration of their status or rights.
COURT PROCEEDINGS:
22.
This Court by a common order dated 24.01.2023 in Application
Nos.299 and 1235 of 2012 appointed Commissioners to look into the
extent of property involved in the suit and apportionment thereof
amongst the parties to the suit in terms of the preliminary decree
drawn up on the basis of compromise and file report.
Accordingly,
the Commissioners have submitted a detailed report on 13.10.2025
and the report was taken on record. Thereafter, by an order dated
16.10.2025 granted permission to the contesting parties to obtain
report dated 13.10.2025 from the Registry for filing objections, if any,
on or before 27.11.2025. Upon request, the Registry was directed to
furnish a copy of the Commissioners report dated 13.10.2025 to the
contesting parties and the matter was directed to be listed on
27.11.2025 under the caption ‘Final Hearing’.
23.
On a perusal of the record, the present Application is filed on
17.12.2024.
COMMISSIONER’S REPORT
24.
For better appreciation, it is necessary to extract the relevant
portion of the report dated 13.10.2025, which is extracted as under:
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
“N.
FINDINGS
14.
Now that the movable and immovable
properties belonging to Nawab Salar Jung III
appears to have been dealt with under the so
called Compromise Preliminary Decree dated
05-03-1959
under
the
directions
and
permissions of this Hon’ble Court from the date
of the Conditional Compromise Preliminary
Decree dated 05-03-1959 till the order in
I.A. No.417 of 1961 dated 09-02-1962, AND
this Hon'be Court by order dated 09-02-1962
ordered passing of a final decree as prayed for
under
certain
terms
mentioned
therein.
The office has to be directed to draw a final
decree in terms of the order in I.A. No.417
of 1961 dated O9-02-1962, if it remains
unchallenged.
14.1
The
record
made
available
to
us
indicates that Application No.2 of 2023 is
filed praying the Court to declare the
preliminary decree is passed under the garb
of fake and false theory that Salar Jung
Died issueless and he was unmarried and
that the alleged compromise preliminary
decree is not executable.
14.2
The
record
made
available
to
us
indicates that Applications No.1 of 2023, 1 and
2 of 2024 and 1 of 2025 are filed claiming
share in the property of Nawab Salar Jung III
independently and hence they wanted their
impleadment in CS 13 of 1958.
14.3
The applicants in Application No.1 of
2024 claim share in the property left behind by
Nawab Salar Jung IlI, contending that the
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
Salar Jung Estate has got mixed properties of
the grand mother of the applicants therein
("Saheb Begum" D/o Mir Alam Bahadur and
grand father Ali Zaman Khan, Munir-ul-Mulk)
and also the properties of one Habeebunnisa
Begum D/o Mir Alam Bahadur and properties
of Mir-i-Duran S/o Mir Alam Bahadur.
14.4
In view of para 11 of conditional
compromise preliminary decree and in view of
peculiar circumstances under which the said
conditional
compromise
preliminary
decree
came to be passed and in view of the fact that
order in I.A. No.417 of 1961 dated 09-02-1962
is passed directing the registry to draw final
decree,
the
point
that
arises
for
the
consideration of this Hon'ble Court is, whether
the applicants in Applications No.1 and 2 of
2023, 1 and 2 of 2024 and 1 of 2025 can
maintain such application in CS No. 13 of
1958.
14.5
In
our
humble
opinion
enquiry
in
Applications No.1 and 2 of 2023, 1 and 2 of
2024 and 1 of 2025 amounts to reopening the
main suit in CS No.13 of 1958 which may
amount
to
discarding
the
Compromise
Preliminary Decree dated 05-3-1959. (Virtually
undoing all the labor of the then Receiver-cum
Commissioner)”.
EFFECT OF PRELIMINARY DECREE:
25.
In
the
Commissioners
Commissioner’s
report
questioned
maintainability
the
dated
13.10.2025,
of
the
the
present
Application i.e. Application No.1 of 2025 in C.S. No.13 of 1958 and
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
further opined that the said Application amount to discarding the
Compromise Preliminary Decree dated 05.03.1959.
Though this
Court granted permission to the contesting parties to file objections,
if any, to the said report, the Applicants have not filed any objections
to the said report.
26.
It is to be noted that compromise has already been recorded and
preliminary decree was passed to that extent on 05.03.1959.
The Applicants, at this point of time by filing the present Application
and if considered would virtually amounts to reopening of the
compromised preliminary decree dated 05.03.1959 in O.S. No.13 of
1958 and the Commissioners have rightly observed in the report that,
it amounts to discarding the compromise preliminary decree dated
05.03.1959.
27.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Bimal Kumar and another Vs.
Shakuntala Debi and others2 while observing the difference between
preliminary and final decree in partition suit held that the term
“compromise” essentially means settlement of differences by mutual
consent and in such process, the adversarial claims come to rest.
The relevant paras No.24 to 28 are extracted for reference:
“24. In Renu Devi v. Mahendra Singh [(2003) 10
SCC 200 : AIR 2003 SC 1608] the effect of a
compromise decree and allotment of shares in
pursuance of the said decree was dealt with. The
two-Judge
(2012) 3 Supreme Court Cases 548
Bench
referred
to Raghubir
Sahu v. Ajodhya
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
Sahu [AIR
Pat
482]
and Muzaffar Husain [AIR 1933 Oudh 562] and
opined that the law had been correctly stated in
the said authorities.
25. In
the
said
case,
after
referring
to Civil
Procedure Code by Mulla, this Court in Renu Devi
case [(2003) 10 SCC 200 : AIR 2003 SC 1608] ,
while
drawing
a
distinction
between
the
preliminary and the final decree, has stated that a
preliminary decree declares the rights or shares of
the parties to the partition. Once the shares have
been declared and a further inquiry still remains
to be done for actually partitioning the property
and placing the parties in separate possession of
the divided property, then such inquiry shall be
held and pursuant to the result of further inquiry,
a final decree shall be passed. A preliminary
decree is one which declares the rights and
liabilities of the parties leaving the actual result to
be worked out in further proceedings. Then, as a
result of the further inquiries conducted pursuant
to the preliminary decree, the rights of the parties
are finally determined and a decree is passed in
accordance with such determination, which is the
final decree. Thus, fundamentally, the distinction
between preliminary and final decree is that: a
preliminary decree merely declares the rights and
shares of the parties and leaves room for some
further inquiry to be held and conducted pursuant
to the directions made in the preliminary decree
which inquiry having been conducted and the
rights of the parties finally determined a decree
incorporating such determination needs to be
drawn up which is the final decree.
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
26. Applying the principles laid down in the
aforesaid authorities, it is graphically clear that in
the case at hand, the parties entered into a
compromise and clearly admitted that they were in
separate
and
exclusive
possession
of
the
properties and the same had already been allotted
to them. It was also admitted that they were in
possession
of
therefore,
no
their
final
respective
decree
or
shares
and,
execution
was
required to be filed. It is demonstrable that the
compromise application does not contain any
clause regarding the future course of action. The
parties were absolutely conscious and rightly so,
that their rights had been fructified and their
possession had been exclusively determined. They
were well aware that the decree was final in
nature as their shares were allotted and nothing
remained to be done by metes and bounds. Their
rights had attained finality and no further enquiry
from any spectrum was required to be carried out.
The whole thing had been embodied in the decree
passed on the foundation of compromise.
27. It is to be borne in mind that the term
“compromise” essentially means settlement of
differences by mutual consent. In such process,
the adversarial claims come to rest. The cavil
between the parties is given a decent burial. A
compromise which is arrived at by the parties puts
an end to the litigative battle. Sometimes the
parties feel that it is an unfortunate bitter struggle
and allow good sense to prevail to resolve the
dispute. In certain cases, by intervention of wellwishers, the conciliatory process commences and
eventually, by consensus and concurrence, rights
get concretised. A reciprocal settlement with a
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
clear mind is regarded as noble. It signifies
magnificent and majestic facets of the human
mind. The exalted state of affairs brings in
quintessence of sublime solemnity and social
stability.
28. In the present case, as the factual matrix
would reveal, a decree came to be passed on the
bedrock of a compromise in entirety from all
angles leaving nothing to be done in the future.
The curtains were really drawn and the court gave
the stamp of approval to the same. Thus, the
inescapable conclusion is that the compromise
decree dated 3-4-1964 was a final decree.”
28.
Since the trial Court granted a Succession Certificate holding
that the petitioners therein are entitled to their respective share in
accordance to Muslim Personal Law for the petition schedule amount
described in Succession O.P. No.55 of 2024 dated 04.11.2024,
the Applicants and the respondents may pursue their remedies to that
extent before the respondent No.1 only to the extent of the
commutation amount.
ON AUTHORISATION:
29.
That apart, the Applicant No.4 has filed the present Application
and in support of this Application filed affidavit stating that “I am filing
this affidavit on my behalf and also on behalf of the other
petitioners/Applicants, who are my real brothers, sisters, nephews and
niece with their consent.” However, he has not filed any authorisation
to that extent seeking permission of this Court to act on behalf of
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
other Applicants. Therefore, this Application is not in accordance with
the Rule 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules of Practice and Circular Orders
in A.P. / Telangana. For reference, Rules are extracted hereunder:
“32. Party appearing by Agent:(1) When a party appears by any agent, other
than an advocate, the agent shall, before
making
of
or
doing
any
appearance,
application, or act, in or to the court, file in
court
the
power
of
attorney,
or
written
authority, thereunto authorizing him or a
properly authenticated copy there of together
with an affidavit that the said authority shall
subsisting, or, in the case of an agent carrying
on a trade or business on behalf of a party,
without a written authority, an affidavit stating
the residence of his principal, the trade or
business carried on by the agent on his behalf
and the connection of the same with the
subject-matter of the suit, and that no other
agent is expressly authorised to make or do
such appearance, application, or act.
(2) The Judge may thereupon record in writing
that the agent is permitted to appear and act
on behalf of the party; and unless and until the
said permission is granted, no appearance,
application, or act, of the agent shall be
recognized by the Court.
33. Signing or verification by Agent:If any proceeding, which under any provision of
law or these rules, is required to be signed or
verified by a party, is signed or verified by any
person on his behalf, a written authority in this
behalf signed by the party shall be filed in
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.1 of 2025
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
court, together with an affidavit verifying the
signature of the party, and stating the reason
of his inability to sign or verify the proceeding,
and stating the means of knowledge or the
facts set out in the proceeding of the person
signing or verifying the same and that such
person is a recognized agent of the party as
defined by order III Rule 2 of the Code and is
duly authorized and competent so to do.”
30.
In view of the foregoing observations and after due consideration
of the report of the Commissioner dated 13.10.2025, this Court is of
the considered view that the present Application suffers with several
material
defects
and
discrepancies
and
is
devoid
of
merits.
Accordingly, the prayer sought for by the Applicants in the present
Application seeking to bring them on record being as the legal heirs of
defendant No.123 cannot be entertained at this belated stage.
Accordingly, Application No.1 of 2025 in C.S. Nof.13 of 1958 is
dismissed.
_____________________________
APARESH KUMAR SINGH, CJ
_____________________________
Date: 20-02-2026
Note: L.R. copy be marked.
B/o.
LSK
N.V. SHRAVAN KUMAR, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review