Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.33974 of 2025
….
Petitioner
Mr. M. K. Chand, Advocate
Ashok Muthamajhi
-Versus-
State of Odisha & others
….
Opposite Parties
Mr. P.K. Sahoo, ASC
CORAM:
JUSTICE R.K. PATTANAIK
DATE OF HEARING:17.12.2025
DATE OF JUDGMENT:08.04.2026
1. Instant writ petition is filed by the petitioner challenging the
impugned order dated 7th November, 2025 as at Annexure-4
disqualifying him as the Sarpanch of Marlang Gram Panchayat
as illegal and in violation of principles of natural justice,
hence, therefore to be quashed with a consequential direction
to opposite party Nos. 2 and 3 to restore his position on the
grounds inter alia that such exercise of jurisdiction in terms of
Section 26 of Odisha Grama Panchayats Act, 1964 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the Act’) is not in accordance with law.
2. As per the facts pleaded on record, consequent upon
notification for the Panchayat Election in 2022 in the State, the
petitioner filed nomination for the post of Sarpanch of the
concerned G.P. and for him having polled maximum votes was
declared elected with the result published and ever since
assumed office, he continued discharging the duties and
responsibilities attached to the post with sincerity and while
matter stood thus, opposite party No.3 along with other
unsuccessful candidates, who had contested the election with
him, ganged up and hatched a plan and registered a complaint
on 17th June, 2025 addressed to the BDO with a request to
initiate a proceeding under Section 26(2) of the Act for his
disqualification under Section 25(1)(v) of the Act for having
more than two children born to him after the cut-off date. It is
further pleaded that even though the said complaint was not
directly addressed to opposite party No.2 for action under
Section 26 of the Act but still it was admitted and without
inviting show cause, notice was issued vide Annexure-2,
which was not received by him and for that, it was followed by
notice dated 13th October 2025 as per Annexure-3 with a
direction to appear before opposite party No.2. It is claimed by
the petitioner that till 24th October, 2025, he was only served
with a copy of the complaint without any supportive
documents, for which, on his appearance, a request was made
to opposite party No.2 to supply the same but hearing on
disqualification was concluded without even confronting the
reports received from the CHC, Kotagarh and the CDPO,
ICDS, Kotagarh and also the Birth Register of AWC and
therefore, under such circumstances, the impugned decision
vide Annexure-4 cannot be sustained in law.
3. On the contrary, the opposite parties refuted the claim of the
petitioner, filed the counter affidavit and pleaded therein that
such a complaint was received by opposite party No.2 with a
copy to the BDO, Kotagarh alleging disqualification of the
petitioner for having more than two children and upon
receiving the same, inquiry was directed and a joint inquiry
report dated 25th July, 2025 was received and it revealed that
he has in total four children. It is further pleaded that after
receipt of the said report as at Annexure-B/2, opposite party
No.2 issued notice to the petitioner for hearing to be held on
12th September, 2025, but it was him who denied to receive the
same and did not appear on the date fixed. A copy of the said
notice is at Annexure-C/2 and due to the absence of the
petitioner, it is pleaded that the next date of hearing was fixed
to 17th October, 2025 with an intimation to the petitioner
through the Tahasildar, Kotagarh and its compliance was
reported to opposite party No.2 by letter No.2522 dated 14 th
October, 2025. But for abundant caution, notice was also sent
through Registered Post with postal receipt at Annexure-D/2.
According to the opposite parties, despite the above exercise to
ensure service of notice on the petitioner, he deliberately
avoided receiving it himself and remained absent on 12th
September, 2025, hence, a fresh notice was issued for his
appearance on 24th October, 2025, the date on which, he
appeared through a counsel but instead of participating in the
hearing, moved an application for time on health ground which
was allowed and the next date of hearing was fixed to 31 st
October, 2025, which was deferred to 7th November, 2025 and
during that time, no any request was ever received by opposite
party No.2 to supply copies of documents by a separate
application moved. As per the opposite parties, on the date of
first hearing on 7th November, 2025, the petitioner appeared
through his Advocate, who was provided all the reports and
there was a hearing and also cross-examination of two official
witnesses, namely, GPDO, Kotagarh, who produced the joint
inquiry report and Lady Supervisor, ICDS, Kotagarh and the
latter proved the Anganwadi Survey Register and in the
proceeding, the counsel was allowed to orally examine the
complainants, however, after such participation, another
application for time was moved with medical reports, which
was not accepted by opposite party No.2 and thereafter, in
open court the impugned order i.e. Annexure-4 was dictated
and pronounced and therefore the allegation regarding nonsupply of copies of the documents and not granting
opportunity of hearing by the petitioner is totally false. It is
also pleaded that such complaint was registered as Case
No.1/GP-2025 and the petitioner was accordingly proceeded
with for having invited disqualification under Section 25(1)(v)
of the Act and while claiming the petitioner’s participation in
proceeding, a copy of the Attendance Sheet dated 7th
November, 2025 as at Annexure-G/2 is referred to. At last, it is
pleaded that even though there has been no such application
received from the petitioner for supply of documents/inquiry
report which was called for by opposite party No.2, ample
opportunity was provided to the petitioner to cross-examine
the official witnesses on the inquiry report confronted at the
time of hearing and on a subjective satisfaction reached at to
the effect that the complaint regarding him having more than
two children after the cut-off date, it was followed by
disqualification and hence, no illegality has been committed. It
is pleaded that such disqualification of the petitioner was duly
notified vide Annexure-H/2. The stand of the opposite parties
is that the petitioner having been provided reasonable time and
opportunity to reply and respond to the complainant and also
the report, opposite party No.2, in absence of anything to
contrary, directed disqualification of the petitioner in view of
Section 25(1)(v) of the Act and hence, therefore, in absence of
any illegality committed, the writ petition is liable to be
dismissed affirming the impugned order i.e. Annexure-4.
4. Heard Mr. Chand, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr.
Sahoo, learned ASC for the State.
5. Mr. Chand, learned counsel for the petitioner would submit
that opposite party No.2 was duty-bound to confront all the
adverse materials to the petitioner before accepting the same
and reaching at a conclusion on disqualification vide
Annexure-4. It is contended that the documents have not been
supplied nor have the official witnesses who prepared the
report been cross-examined with any such exercise being
undertaken by opposite party No.2, who, however, finally
concluded, the petitioner having invited disqualification under
Section 25(1)(v) of the Act, which is in gross violation of the
principles of natural justice. Mr. Chand, learned counsel
further submits that the petitioner is an elected representative,
hence, before any such disqualification directed against him, it
was for opposite party No.2 to conduct the proceeding in such
a manner that he received a proper audience but no such
procedure was followed and it has ultimately led to the
disqualification under Annexure-4. According to Mr. Chand,
learned counsel, all the adverse materials referred to and relied
on during the proceedings should have been brought to the
notice of the petitioner for a proper hearing and response and
the same having not taken place, the entire exercise stood
vitiated, hence, the impugned decision on disqualification vide
Annexure-4 is liable to be interfered with.
6. On the contrary, Mr. Sahoo, learned ASC for the State
would submit that there has been no wrong or any such
illegality committed by opposite party No.2 since a proper
hearing was held and no response by way of a show cause was
filed disputing the claim of having more than two children
born to him after the cut-off date and in that case, to demand
any such plea for non-observance of principles of natural
justice cannot be entertained and in support of the above
contention, a decision of this Court in Jitendra Muduli Vrs.
State of Orissa and others 2016 SCC OnLine Ori 153 has
been placed reliance on.
7. To the counter affidavit of the opposite parties, no rejoinder
is filed by the petitioner, which means, the claim of a hearing
held in the manner described therein has not been disputed and
for the above, the Court has to proceed on the premise that the
adverse report of inquiry had been confronted to the petitioner
at the time of hearing with no response received from him. The
attendance of the petitioner and his appearance through an
advocate is not in dispute and therefore, it has to be assumed
that the fact-finding report having been received from the
CDPO, Kotagarh and BPHO, Kotagarh through the BDO,
Kotagarh was brought to the notice of the petitioner during and
in course of hearing. Under the above circumstances, the
question is whether the order on disqualification vide
Annexure-4 can be interfered with and set at naught?
8. A disqualification under Section 25(1)(v) of the Act is
invited when a member of the G.P. has more than two children
born after the cut-off date and as per sub-section (2) thereof,
the Sarpanch or any other member of the G.P. shall be
disqualified to continue and cease to be a member, if he invites
disqualification on any of the grounds specified therein. On a
reading of the above provisions, it is made to understand that a
person with more than two children is not qualified for being
elected as Sarpanch of the G.P. but someone having more than
two children on 18th April, 1994, the date on which Odisha
Grama Panchayats (Amendment) Act, 1994 was introduced,
no such disqualification is invited and similarly, a 3rd child if
born within one year from 18th April, 1994, the disqualification
is not attached.
8.1. In so far as the case of the petitioner is concerned, he
appears to have four children and all of them were born long
after 18th April, 1994. As per the joint inquiry report submitted
by
the CDPO, Kotagarh and the BPHO, Kotagarh as at
Annexure-B/2 to the counter affidavit, the eldest child was
born to the petitioner on 12th September, 2005 and 2nd, 3rd
(female) arrived on 7th August, 2006, 30th July, 2010 and 28th
July, 2010 respectively, which means all have been born much
after the cut-off date and the same was revealed from the
Family Register and Aasha Survey Register maintained at the
Salki Sitaguda AWC. The report reveals that the Anganwadi
Worker, who submitted the Family Register, was examined
during the field visit and also the Aasha Worker in respect of
the Survey Register and conclusion of the joint inquiry was to
the effect that based on the field verification, examination of
the Family Register and Aasha Survey Register, it is
confirmed that the petitioner has four children and hence, the
complaint against him is found to be true and substantiated.
When such a joint report dated 21st July, 2025 was received
and it was shared with the petitioner or at least him having the
knowledge about the same on being confronted in course of
hearing in presence of his counsel, a response to the same was
expected. But neither a reply nor any such response was
received from the petitioner on the allegations levelled and the
report of inquiry. Therefore, it has to be held that either the
allegations remained undisputed or admitted by the petitioner
for no response received from him even after all the
incriminating materials had been confronted. It is reiterated
that in absence of any such reply to the show cause notice, the
allegation for having more than two children born to the
petitioner after the cut-off date shall have to be admitted as
true.
8.2. In absence of a reply by way of rejoinder to the counter of
the State, it has to be concluded that all such materials
including the report received after a joint inquiry held at the
ground level and the reason behind disqualification was well
within the knowledge of the petitioner but still no response
was received. The Court is not inclined to accept the plea of
the petitioner that there was no proper hearing held by
opposite party No.2. No occasion lies either to consider the
correctness of the joint inquiry report at Annexure-B/2
referring to which opposite party No.2 reached at a conclusion
that the petitioner is having four children, all of whom were
born after the cut-off date, hence, there is disqualification
invited under Section 25(1)(v) of the Act. In Jitendra Muduli
(supra), a Division Bench of this Court held that a Court is not
to insist on observance of principles of natural justice when the
allegations are not disputed or are admitted and concluded that
non-service of report of a Medical Officer therein would not
amount to denial of opportunity of hearing.
9. A proceeding under Section 26 of the Act is summary in
nature but at the same time, fairness is to observed allowing
the Sarpanch or any such member of the G.P. a reasonable
opportunity of hearing before any such decision on
disqualification is arrived at. If any application is received or
even an oral request for cross-examination of official
witnesses responsible for the reports prepared and to be relied
on is adverse to the interest of the Sarpanch, it shall have to be
entertained since ultimately the truth is to be unearthed. An
allegation of having more than two children born after the cutoff date is normally based on records. It is of course not
possible for anyone to prove a fact in the negative. Any such
claim alleging disqualification under Section 25(1)(v) of the
Act is to depend on the evidence received during inquiry,
hence, it is for the State to substantiate the same.
10. In the case at hand, the joint inquiry report dated 21st July,
2025 revealed the family status of the petitioner on the basis of
a field visit and verification of the relevant Registers of the
AWC. In fact, the Family Register with the relevant extracts
with all details recorded therein have been referred to and
similarly with respect to the Aasha Survey Register and the
same bared it all that the petitioner is having children born to
him long after the cut-off date dated 18th April, 1994. The
impugned order at Annexure-4 reveals that the petitioner filed
no documents to refute the allegation and therefore the
conclusion is about his disqualification under Section 25(1)(v)
of the Act. Considering the nature of inquiry normally
conducted in a proceeding under Section 26 of the Act, the
need is to ensure a proper opportunity of hearing and as such,
in the case of the petitioner, all the adverse reports were
brought to his notice at the time of hearing, a fact which has
not been disputed by a rejoinder filed, hence, it has to be
concluded that he invited disqualification under Section 25
(1)(v) of the Act. For the discussions as aforesaid and
recording submissions of the learned counsel for the respective
parties, this Court finds no any reason to interfere with the
decision of opposite party No.2 vide Annexure-4.
11. Accordingly, it is ordered.
12. In the result, the writ petition stands dismissed.
(R.K. Pattanaik)
Judge
Balaram
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BALARAM BEHERA
Designation: PERSONAL ASSISTANT
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, CUTTACK
Date: 09-Apr-2026 13:35:52
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review