Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 13th OCTOBER, 2017
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.02 of 2017
Petitioner
:
Ashok Kumar Subba,
S/o Late Budh Bir Subba,
R/o 31A National Highway,
Sisa Golai, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba,
W/o Shri Ashok Kumar Subba,
S/o Late Bhud Bir Subba,
R/o 31A National Highway,
Sisa Golai, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
2.
Shri Bharat Basnett,
S/o Late Indra Bahadur Basnett,
R/o Ranipool Bazaar,
East Sikkim – 737 135.
3.
The District Collector (East),
District Administrative Centre Building,
Sichey, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
Petition under Articles 226/227
of the Constitution of India
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. R. P. Sharma, Mr. Sajal Sharma and Ms. Janu Tamang,
Advocates for the Petitioner.
Md. Mazhar Ali, Advocate for the Respondent No.1.
Mr. C. K. Kumai and Mr. Vivek Anand, Advocates for the Respondent
No.2.
Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Government Advocate for the StateRespondent No.3.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No. 02 of 2017
Ashok Kumar Subba
vs.
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba and Others
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioner, (Plaintiff before the Learned Trial Court)
is before this Court assailing the Order dated 12-12-2016, of the
Learned Civil Judge, East Sikkim, at Gangtok, in T.S. Case No.33 of
2014, Shri Ashok Kumar Subba vs. Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba and
Others.
2.
By
the
impugned
Order,
the
Learned
Trial
Court
considered an Application filed by the Defendant No.2 (Respondent
No.2 herein) under Order VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short “CPC”) seeking to amend
his Written Statement and duly allowed the amendment.
3.
While seeking to amend the Written Statement, the
Defendant No.2 submitted that the proposed amendment was not
incorporated in the Written Statement due to inadvertent mistake
and oversight and sought to incorporate the following statements;
“4.
That Smt. Mim Rani Limboo is legally married
wife of Sri Ashok Kumar Subba, the Plaintiff.
They were married in the year 1966, according
to their custom, rites, rituals and ceremonies in
the parent’s house of Mim Rani Limboo in the
village Tambong, P.O. & P.S. Sombaray, District
West Sikkim. Late Dhoj Bir Begha Limboo and
Gaurani Limboo were /are father and mother
respectfully of Mim Rani Limboo.
After the
marriage the above spouse lived together as
lawfully married husband and wife in the house
of Plaintiff at Thurpu, West Sikkim and other
places in Sikkim. Out of the said wedlock, three
daughters and one son were born to them
namely:
I.
II.
Amrita Limboo…………………...Daughter
Anita Limboo……………………….Daughter
WP(C) No. 02 of 2017
Ashok Kumar Subba
vs.
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba and Others
III.
IV.
Sangita Limboo…………………..Daughter
Amar Kumar Subba……………….Son
The above marriage between the Plaintiff and
Mim Rani Limboo has not so far been dissolved
by a decree of divorce and same is still
subsisting one.
5.
That Kamal Kumari Subba the Defendant No. 1
in above suit is a Mistress/Concubine of the
Plaintiff. She is not his legally married wife,
since during the subsistence of valid and lawful
marriage with Mim Rani Limboo, the Plaintiff had
contracted a second marriage with Defendant
No. 1 in the year 1973 in the parents’ house of
the Defendant No.1 in village Assam Linge,
Surani East Sikkim.
Dhoj Bir Subba and
Gaumaya Subba are the father and mother of
Defendant No.1.”
It was also canvassed that the proposed amendment is
germane for the full and final adjudication of the matter in dispute
between the parties and will not change the nature and character of
the suit.
4.
Aggrieved by the Order allowing the amendment, the
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner contends that, in the first
instance, the matter was already fixed for filing of evidence by the
Plaintiff and witnesses, issues having been settled for determination
by the Court. The provisions of the amended Order VI Rule 17 of
the CPC does not envisage amendment of pleadings after the
commencement of the trial. Hence, the Learned Trial Court ought
not to have allowed the amendment.
5.
In the next limb of his argument, it was advanced that
the Suit in question is a Declaratory Suit. Thus, the question as to
whether the Plaintiff was previously married or not is not essential
for the determining the real question in controversy between the
WP(C) No. 02 of 2017
Ashok Kumar Subba
parties.
vs.
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba and Others
That, the intention of the Defendant No.2 in seeking the
amendment is to deny justice by making an effort to get the Suit
dismissed by bringing it within the ambit of the provisions of the
Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988 (for short
“Benami Act”). That, the Defendant No.2 has also invoked the
provisions of a Notification, being, Notification No.1520/H dated 0301-1963 of the Government of Sikkim Home Department, pertaining
to “Rules to provide for Registration and Solemnisation of a Form of
Marriage in Sikkim” (for short “Notification of 1963”). However, the
marriage between the parties was not solemnised under this
Notification and, therefore, is not relevant for the present purposes.
Besides, a plethora of Judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
have laid down that, if a man and woman live together for several
years as husband and wife, they shall be deemed by the Law to be
husband
and
wife.
The
Plaintiff
and
the
Defendant
No.1
(Respondent No.1 herein) were married in 1973 and from the
wedlock, have seven children.
Thus, there can be no doubt that
they were legally married. The validity of by the marriage between
the Plaintiff and the Defendant No.1 cannot be challenged by the
Defendant No.2, who has no locus standi in the matter. Strength on
this count was drawn from the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Satyendra Kumar and Others vs. Raj Nath Dubey and Others1.
6.
It was next contended that the pleadings and the
documents relied on by the Defendant No.2 would indicate that
AIR 2016 SC 2231
WP(C) No. 02 of 2017
Ashok Kumar Subba
vs.
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba and Others
there is an admission that the Plaintiff and the Defendant No.1 are
husband and wife as evident from the admissions made by the
Defendant No.2 before the DRT, DRAT, this High Court, Gauhati
High Court and Calcutta High Court, he cannot now retract this
admission. It was also contended that declaratory reliefs cannot be
granted by the Benami Adjudicating Authority and neither is the suit
property a benami property in view of the provisions of Section
2(9)(A)(iii) of the Benami Act which clearly states that property
purchased in the name of the spouse will not be considered to be a
benami transaction, hence, the impugned Order be set aside.
7.
The contra arguments put forth by Learned Counsel for
the Defendant No.2 were that, under Section 45 of the Benami Act
the jurisdiction of the Civil Courts is specifically barred, therefore,
the Learned Trial Court has no jurisdiction in the matter.
While
supporting the Order of the Learned Trial Court, it was contended
that the amendment was allowed as the Learned Trial Court
considered the amendment essential for determining the real
position of the Defendant No.1 as wife of the Plaintiff, which would
strike at the real question in controversy in the Suit, therefore, the
Order requires no interference.
8.
Learned Counsel for the Defendant No.1 submitted that
he was in agreement with the aforestated submissions advanced by
Learned Counsel for the Defendant No.2.
9.
The opposing arguments of Learned Counsel were heard
in extenso and carefully considered. I have also carefully perused
WP(C) No. 02 of 2017
Ashok Kumar Subba
vs.
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba and Others
the records of the Learned Trial Court as well as the impugned Order
and given it my anxious consideration.
10.
In the first instance, the argument of Learned Counsel
for the Petitioner that the Defendant No.2 has garnered strength
from the Notification of 1963 while seeking to establish the nonmarital status of the Plaintiff and Defendant No.1, has no bearing in
the instant matter as it is not the subject-matter of the amendment
and is not being addressed.
11.
Now, to consider the relevant legal provision; Order VI
Rule 17 of the CPC deals with amendment of pleadings. For clarity
in the matter, the provision of law is reproduced below;
“17. Amendment of pleadings.―The Court may
at any stage of the proceedings allow either party to
alter or amend his pleadings in such manner and on
such terms as may be just, and all such amendments
shall be made as may be necessary for the purpose of
determining the real questions in controversy between
the parties:
Provided that no application for amendment shall
be allowed after the trial has commenced, unless the
Court comes to the conclusion that in spite of due
diligence, the party could not have raised the matter
before the commencement of trial.”
12.
The Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1999
(Act 46 of 1999), omitted Rule 17 in order to expedite litigation, but
due to the controversy generated by this deletion, the Code of Civil
Procedure (Amendment) Act, 2002 (Act 22 of 2002), restored the
Rule with certain limitations.
has been inserted in the Rule.
A proviso, as extracted hereinabove,
WP(C) No. 02 of 2017
Ashok Kumar Subba
13.
vs.
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba and Others
In terms of the proviso, once the trial has commenced
ordinarily no application for amendment of the pleadings shall be
allowed unless the Court concludes that, in spite of due diligence the
party could not have raised the matter before the commencement of
trial.
Needless to add that whether the party has acted with due
diligence or not would depend upon the facts and circumstances of
each case. It would be in the correctness of things to mention here
that all amendments ought to be made for the purpose of
determining the real question in controversy between the parties to
any proceedings or for correcting any defect thereof. At the same
time, the Court has to be alive to the fact that the proposed
amendment ought not to cause prejudice to the other side nor
should it change the nature and character of the lis in question.
14.
In Vidyabati and Ors. vs. Padmalatha and Anr.2 the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, while considering the question as to whether the
pleadings can be directed to be amended after the hearing of the
case begins, discussed the Civil Procedure Code (Amendment) Act,
2002 (Act 22 of 2002) and the proviso thereof.
The Hon’ble
Supreme Court opined that the proviso is in a mandatory form and
the Court’s jurisdiction to allow an application for amendment is
taken away by the proviso, unless the conditions precedent therefor
are satisfied, i.e., it must come to a conclusion that in spite of due
diligence the parties could not have raised the matter before the
commencement of the trial.
AIR 2009 SC 1433
WP(C) No. 02 of 2017
Ashok Kumar Subba
15.
vs.
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba and Others
We may now proceed to the next pertinent question viz;
what stage would be commencement of trial.
In a Civil Suit, trial
commences when issues are framed and the Suit is ready for
recording of evidence. It would be appropriate to refer to Order XIV
Rule 1(5) of the CPC which provides that;
“1. Framing of issues.―(1)………………………
………………………………………………………………………..
(5)
At the first hearing of the suit the Court
shall, after reading the plaint and the written
statements, if any, and after examination under rule 2
of Order X and after hearing the parties or their
pleaders, ascertain upon what material propositions of
fact or of law the parties are at variance, and shall
thereupon proceed to frame and record the issues on
which the right decision of the case appears to depend.
………………………………………………………………………..”
Thus, it is evident that the first hearing of the Suit is on the
date on which the issues are settled for determination.
16.
In Kailash vs. Nanhku and Others3 the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held as follows;
“13. At this point the question arises: when
does the trial of an election petition commence or what
is the meaning to be assigned to the word “trial” in the
context of an election petition? In a civil suit, the trial
begins when issues are framed and the case is set
down for recording of evidence. All the proceedings
before that stage are treated as proceedings
preliminary to trial or for making the case ready for
trial. ………………………………..”
17.
In Baldev Singh and Others vs. Manohar Singh and Another4
the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as follows;
(2005) 4 SCC 480
(2006) 6 SCC 498
WP(C) No. 02 of 2017
Ashok Kumar Subba
vs.
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba and Others
“17. Before we part with this order, we may
also notice that proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 CPC
provides that amendment of pleadings shall not be
allowed when the trial of the suit has already
commenced. For this reason, we have examined the
records and find that, in fact, the trial has not yet
commenced. It appears from the records that the
parties have yet to file their documentary evidence in
the suit. From the record, it also appears that the suit
was not on the verge of conclusion as found by the
High Court and the trial court. That apart,
commencement of trial as used in proviso to Order 6
Rule 17 in the Code of Civil Procedure must be
understood in the limited sense as meaning the final
hearing of the suit, examination of witnesses, filing of
documents and addressing of arguments. As noted
hereinbefore, parties are yet to file their documents,
we do not find any reason to reject the application for
amendment of the written statement in view of proviso
to Order 6 Rule 17 CPC which confers wide power and
unfettered discretion on the court to allow an
amendment of the written statement at any stage of
the proceedings.”
In the said matter, amendment was allowed as documentary
evidence was yet to be filed and, therefore, it was held that the trial
had not commenced.
18.
From a perusal of the records herein, the Petition under
Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC was filed after the trial commenced,
i.e., after settlement of issues for determination. That, having been
said, the hands of the Court are not tied and it can permit an
amendment or amendments, subject to the fact that the party could
not have raised the matter in spite of due diligence, before the
commencement of trial. As pointed out by Learned Counsel for the
Plaintiff and as the pleadings would reveal, the portion sought to be
inserted by way of amendment was not due to the inability of the
party to raise the matter before the trial had commenced and in
WP(C) No. 02 of 2017
Ashok Kumar Subba
vs.
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba and Others
spite of due diligence, but was admittedly an “inadvertent error” as
revealed in the pleading of the Defendant No.2.
Besides, the pleadings of the Defendant No.2 indicates
19.
that he has addressed the Defendant No.1 as the wife of the
Plaintiff.
Paragraph 2 of the “PARAWISE REPLY” in his Written
Statement is as follows;
“2.
20.
That, the contents of para 2 of the plaint are
partly denied. The answering Defendant is an
acquaintance of the Plaintiff and well known to
the Defendant No. 1 sharing relation as “miteri”
brother and co-villager prior to her marriage
with the Plaintiff herein.”
Thus, the Defendant No.2 is now attempting, by the
amendment sought, to approbate and reprobate as now he seeks to
put forth that the Defendant No.1 is the mistress of the Plaintiff
which is not permissible.
21.
It thus emerges that not only has the amendment been
sought after trial commenced, but was admittedly on account of an
“inadvertent error” and not due to inability to raise the matter
despite due diligence, besides the Defendant No.2 is approbating
and reprobating on the marital status of the Defendant No.1.
22.
The Learned Trial Court in its impugned Order has
erroneously placed reliance on the decision of A. K. Gupta and Sons
Ltd. vs. Damodar Valley Corporation , at which period there was no
amendment to Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC as already explained
AIR 1967 SC 96
WP(C) No. 02 of 2017
Ashok Kumar Subba
vs.
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba and Others
hereinabove and, therefore, would not be relevant for the present
purposes.
23.
I have also perused the provisions of the Benami Act
relied on by the Learned Counsel for the Defendant No.2, but
restrain myself from making any observations on this count having
limited my Judgment to the provisions of Order VI Rule 17. In any
event, it would be pre-mature to reach a finding on Section
2(9)(A)(iii) and Section 45 of the Benami Act as it would tantamount
to delving into the merits of the case.
24.
Thus, in conclusion, having considered the facts and
circumstances of the matter and in view of the discussions
hereinabove, the impugned Order of the Learned Trial Court is set
aside.
25.
However,
it
may
be
noticed
that
the
Plaintiff
in
Paragraph 1 of the Plaint has pleaded as follows;
“1.
That the Plaintiff is a businessman by profession
and had purchased immoveable properties in the
Town of Gangtok, more fully detailed in Schedule
hereunder and at the relevant time of the
purchase of the said suit premises the Plaintiff
was carrying on the business of Lottery. The
Plaintiff herein is also the absolute owner of the
building standing in Plot No. 1104/1676 and
1104/1805 [ANNEXURE 1] and the said land on
which the building is super constructed was
purchased by the Plaintiff in the benami of his
wife above named, viz., Smt. Kamal Kumari
Subba, herein the Defendant No.1, which was
the prevalent practice at that time.”
The Defendant No.2 has repudiated this in his Written
Statement “PARAWISE REPLY” as follows;
WP(C) No. 02 of 2017
Ashok Kumar Subba
“1.
26.
vs.
Smt. Kamal Kumari Subba and Others
That, the contents of para 1 of the plaint are
denied.”
Consequently, in such a situation, for a just decision in
the matter, the Learned Trial Court is to frame an appropriate Issue
in view of the claim of benami transaction by the Plaintiff and denial
thereof by the Defendant No.2. The Learned Trial Court shall take
steps accordingly and thereafter, proceed with the trial in terms of
the legal provisions.
27.
It is clarified that the observations made herein are not
to be construed as opinions on the merits of the case, by this Court.
28.
The Writ Petition stands disposed of accordingly.
29.
No orders as to costs.
30.
Copy of this Judgment be forwarded to the Learned Trial
Court for information and compliance.
31.
Records of the Learned Trial Court be remitted forthwith.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
13-10-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review