Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:3811-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 6221 of 2025
1 - Ashok Kumar Mittal S/o P.L. Mittal Aged About 59 Years Occupation A Class Contrator R/o - Main Road Korba P.S. and Tehsil Korba, District
- Korba (C.G.)
... Petitioner
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Public Works
Department Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Raipur, District Raipur
(C.G.)
2 - Chief Engineer, Public Works Department, Naya Raipur, District
Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Executive Engineer, Public Works Department, Division Jagdalpur,
District Jagdalpur (C.G.)
4 - Executive Engineer, Public Works Department, Division Raipur,
District Raipur (C.G.)
5 - Superintendent Engineer, Public Works Department, Circle Civil
Lines District Raipur (C.G.)
6 - Engineer-In-Chief, Public Works Department, Naya Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
MOHAMMED
AADIL KHAN
Date: 2026.01.29
19:32:45 +0530
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
: Mr. Manoj Paranjpe, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Sanjay Agrawal, Advocate.
For Respondents-State : Mr.
Praveen
Das,
Additional
Advocate
General.
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
22-01-2026
1.
The present writ petition filed by the petitioner under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India challenging the order dated 11-11-2025
(Annexure-P/1) and 14-07-2025 (Annexure-P/2) and prayed the
following relief(s):“10.1 That, this Hon’ble Court may kindly be pleased to setaside the order dated 11/11/2025 (Annexure P-1)
passed by the Respondent No.6.
10.2 That, this Hon’ble Court may kindly be pleased to setaside the order dated 14/07/2025 (Annexure P-2)
passed by the Respondent No. 2 demoting the
petitioner’s contractor Licence from Class ‘A’ to Class
‘B’.
10.3 That any other relief which this Hon’ble Court may
deem fit and just in the facts and circumstances of the
case.”
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner is a Class
contractor with unique ID No.CGeR01707 . The respondent No.1 issued
a tender for construction of H.L. Bridge at Indrawati river in KM 1/8 on
NH-30 to Khadakghat road under the supervision of P.W.D. Bridge
Division Jagdalpur. The petitioner was also participated and declared
L1. The work order was issued on 21-10-2022 and the total period
under the work order for completion of work was 25 months. Due to
high
tension
electricity
lines,
huge
number
of
trees,
illegal
encroachment etc. the construction of project was obstructed time to
time and when the petitioner intimated the difficulties to the respondent
department, they made a communication on 07-01-2025 that the
encroachments from the proposed site have been removed, high
tension electricity wires have also been removed and and drawing has
been issued on 14-02-2025. As the respondents issued the work order
without clearing site having knowledge of dense forest and naxalite
affected area. Considering the difficulties, the respondent No.3
extended the period of completion of work uptill 31-10-2026 vide its
letter dated 12-03-2025. On 24-02-2025 the respondent No.3 submitted
the revised drawing before the respondent No.2 for increasing the
length of the bridge and then the petitioner was also directed to submit
revised decision. The respondent No.4 forwarded it to respondent No.3
on 27-02-2025. The petitioner’s work for construction of bridge was
running in its schedule with the object to complete it before 31-10-2025.
All of sudden a show cause notice was issued to the petitioner on 1405-2025 issued by respondent No.4 and he was directed to show cause
as to why the work has not been completed which was obtained by the
petitioner and why his category of licence should not be demoted. The
said show cause notice was replied by the petitioner on 28-05-2025
assigning the reason and difficulties which he felt in the area. It has also
been replied that the petitioner asked for police protection so that the
work can be carried out smoothly, but no heed was given to his request.
He duly explained the delay in construction work in the district Korba,
District Raipur, however vide order dated 14-07-2025 the respondent
No.2 demoted the contractor licence of the petitioner from Class ‘A’ to
Class ‘B’. the petitioner made his representation on 17-07-2025 and he
was heard on 06-08-2025, but the authorities have not decided his
representation and then a WPC No.5167/2025 was filed by the
petitioner before this Court. The said writ petition, WPC No.5167/2025
has been disposed of vide order dated 16-10-2025 reserving the liberty
to the petitioner to take recourse to law if aggrieved by the order passed
by the authorities.
3.
On 18-11-2025 the respondent No.5 wrote a letter to the
department that no prior permission was obtained for clearing the work
site, land acquisition proceedings were also not completed and
therefore, for the fault of P.W.D. the petitioner cannot be held liable. The
respondent authorities has rejected the appeal filed by the petitioner on
the ground that he failed to complete the work within the stipulated
timeframe and also there is arbitration clause and the petitioner had to
approach the C.G. Madhyastham Adhikaran. Considering the lapses on
the part of the department, a date of completion of the work again
extended from 11-11-2025 to 31-10-2026, however, since the category
of the licence of the petitioner is demoted from ‘A’ to ‘B’ he cannot
participate in the tender other than Public Works Department, therefore,
he filed the present writ petition challenging the impugned order.
4.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner would submit that the
arbitrary exercise of powers by the authorities would amounts to civil
death to a contractor. There was no clause in the work contract that if
the petitioner fails to comply with the work contract the category of his
licence should be demoted. The petitioner is constrained to work in core
naxalite area which is dense forest and various clearance like forest
clearance, environmental clearance etc. are required despite the
difficulties he run his project in time to achieve the target of cut off date,
but it is the fault of the department that they asked for revised plan. He
would further submit that considering the difficulties time to complete the
work is extended upto 31-10-2026 and there is no reason for reduction
of the category of licence. The department itself has considered that
there are difficulties about the land proceeding, clearing the work site
and other clearance, yet the petitioner has been punished by reduction
of his category of licence. The demotion of the category of licence
amounts to punishment for no fault of the petitioner when the authorities
themselves extended the time which amounts that the petitioner was
not at fault, yet the category of licence has been demoted which is
arbitrary and against the principles of natural justice. Therefore, the
impugned orders may be quashed and the respondent authorities may
be directed to upgrade the petitioner’s contractor licence from Class ‘B’
to Class ‘A’.
5.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the State would submit
that due to oversight and bonafide mistake of the authorities concerned,
the work of the petitioner as considered as deficit and the explanation of
work with respect to Asna Khadakghat and completion certificate of
bridge of Lakhna Champaran is also oversight by the authorities and the
impugned orders have been issued. He would also submit that there are
certain difficulties with respect to construction of Asna Khadakghat
bridge as certain hindrance in shifting electric high voltage pole, land
acquisition and removal of encroachment and therefore, the time was
extended to complete the work to October, 2026. He would also submit
that with respect to bridge on Jhora Kodiya Ghat the said work has
been completed though it was completed after due date, but the delay
caused due to trees standing on site which could not be removed in
time and an extension was also granted uptil 31-12-2025. The mistake
has been committed due to oversight of relevant records which is
bonafide.
6.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material annexed with the writ petition.
7.
There are two parts of the punishment order dated 14-07-2025,
one is slow work in the construction of Asna Khadkghat project and
demotion of category of contractor licence from Class ‘A’ to Class ‘B’.
The relevant part of the order dated 14-07-20225 is reproduced herein
below:"वि चारोपरान्त Jh v'kksd dqekj वि ्ቈल, "अ" ्ቇ ठेकेदार] कोरबा ्ቛारा CGRIDCL
योजनान्त्ቇत जिजला&बस्तर के अन्त्ቇत NH-30, आसना से खडकघाट
ा्ቇ के विक- ी-
1/8 पर इं्ቖा ती नदी पर mPpLrjh; सेतु विन ाण काय (अनुबंध ्ቅ. 12/DL-202223) की ्ቚ्ቇतित अत्यन्त धी ी ए ं vlekuqikfrd gksus rFkk काय को पूण करने ें
fo'ks"k रुतिच नहीं fy;s tkus ds dkj.k छ.्ቇ. शासन, लोक विन ाण वि भा्ቇ
ं्ቔालय
रायपुर के आदेश ्ቅ- ,Q 5&8/19/ 2013/विनवि दा, विदनांक 29.10.2014
ें संyXu
विदशा-विनद7श की कंतिडका 7,2(II)(b) के
rgr~ muds पंजीयन (आई.डी. ्ቅ ांक
CGeRO1707 विदनांक 16.08.2024) को mDr अनुबंतिधत काय पूण होने तक "ब" ्ቦेणी
ें पदा नत (Demote) विकया जाता है।"
8.
The return has been filed by the respondent/State stating therein
that due to oversight of the relevant documents certain orders have
been issued by the authorities concerned which is bonafide mistake. It
is necessary to reproduce the relevant part of the return filed by the
respondents/State which reads as under:“8.
It is respectfully submitted that the work of Raipur
Lakhna Champaran was complete and a completion
certificate was issued by the department on 02/07/2025,
however, on account of oversight and bonafide mistake,
this was erroneously included as a deficit work
attributed to the petitioner. That the oversight of the
extension of work with respect to the Asna Khadakghat
and
completion
certificate
of
bridge
of
Lakhna
Champaran is purely unintentional and bonafide.
9.
It is further submitted that with respect to Asna
Khadakghat Bridge, it is respectfully submitted that as
there were certain hindrances such as electric high
voltage pole shifting, land acquisition, removal of
encroachment, therefore, extension was given to the
petitioner to complete the said work up till October,
2026. Departmental order 18/11/2025 issued by the
Superintendent Engineer [Annexure P/14], whereby,
completion of work has been extended till 31/10/2026. It
is most respectfully submitted that since the order of
extension dated 18/11/2025 has been passed after
order dated 14/07/2025 [Annex. P/2] as well as order
dated 11/11/2025 [Annex. P/1] it could not be
considered by the concerned authorities before passing
the orders of annexure P/1 and P/2.
10.
With respect to the bridge on Jhora Kodiya Ghat it is
submitted that the bridge has been completed and there
was some delay because of some trees on one side,
i.e., towards Jhora and those trees could not be
removed. It is further submitted that upon examination
of records it emerged that with respect to the Jhor
Kodiyaghat
bridge
that
has
been
granted
an
unpenalized extension till 31/12/2025 for completion of
work vide order dated 25/06/2025. It respectfully
submitted that on account of unintentional and bonafide
mistake this fact was overlooked by the respondent
authorities.”
9.
It is also relevant to quote the relevant contents of the memo
dated 18-11-2025 (Annexure P/14) which reads as under:“fo"k;kafdr
dk;Z dk dk;kZns’k fnukad 21-10-2022 dks tkjh fd;k x;kA
vuqca/kkuqlkj fuekZ.k dk;Z dks iw.kZ djus gsrq 25 ekg o"kkZ _rq lfgr 1 ekg
fjd.M vFkkZr fnukad 20-12-2024 rd fu/kkZfjr FkhA orZeku esa fuekZ.k dk;Z
izxfrjr gSA
bl dk;kZy; }kjk iwoZ esa fofHkUu dkj.kksa tSls Hkw&vtZu dh dk;Zokgh esa
foyac] vcVesaV ,1 dh vksj vfrdze.k gksus ds dkj.k] pyns;dksa ds Hkqxrku esa
foyac] MªkbZax fMtkbZu ds vuqeksnu esa foyac ds dkj.k ftlls lger gksrs gq;s
bl dk;kZy; ds }kjk izFke le;o`f) i= dz- 646@lk-@jk;iqj fnukad 27-02-
2025 }kjk fnukad 21-12-2024 ls fnukad 31-10-2025 rd vuqca/k dh dafMdk
1-13-1 ds rgr fcuk fdlh naM ds le;o`f+) iznku dh xbZ FkhA
fdUrq foHkkx }kjk fn;s x;s le; esa dk;Z iw.kZ ugh fd;k x;k gSA
dk;Zikyu
vfHk;ark
yks-fu-fo-
lsrq
laHkkx
txnyiqj
ds
i=
dz-
2199@vads@txnyiqj fn- 28-10-2025 ds ek/;e ls fnukad 01-11-2025 ls
fnukad 31-10-2026 rd vuqca/k dh dafMdk 1-13-1 ds rgr fcuk fdlh naM ds
le;o`f) iznku djus dh vuq’kalk dh xbZ gSA le;o`f) izdj.k gsrq lquokbZ
fnukad 14-11-2025 dks fu;r dh x;h ftlesa dk;Zikyu vfHk;ark ,oa
Bsdsnkj }kjk viuk dFku izLrqr fd;k x;kA
izdj.k ds ijh{k.k esa ik;k x;k gS fd gkbZVs’ku fo|qr rkj dk vkt
fnukad rd foLFkkiu ugh gqvk gS rFkk txnyiqj dh vksj dk;ZLFky esa Hkw&vtZu
dh dk;Zokgh fnukad 13-08-2025 dks iw.kZ dh x;h gS ftl dkj.k dk;Z dh xfr
izHkkfor jghA pfyr ns;dks dk Hkqxrku le; ij u gksus ds dkj.k ,oa bl o"kZ
cLrj {ks= esa vR;kf/kd o"kkZ gksus ds dkj.k Hkh dk;Z dh xfr izHkkfor jgh gSA
vksiu Qkm.Ms’ku gsrq CykfLVax dh vuqefr fnukad 09-04-2024 dks izkIr gqbZ
ijarq ekg ebZ esa unh ij ikuh dk Lrj vR;kf/kd gksus ds dkj.k Qkm.Ms’ku dk
dk;Z ugh fd;k tk ldk ftl dkj.k Hkh dk;Z dh izxfr izHkkfor jgh] tks fd
ekU; ;ksX; gSA
vr% fn;s x;s dkj.kksa rFkk dk;Zikyu vfHk;ark yks-fu-fo- lsrq laHkkx
txnyiqj }kjk dh xbZ Li"V vuq’kalk ls lger gksrs gq;s 'ks"k cps gq;s fuekZ.k
dk;Z dks Ikw.kZ djus esa gks jgs gsrq Bsdsnkj dks nks"kh u ekurs gq;s fnukad 01-112025 ls fnukad 31-10-2026 rd vuqca/k dh dafMdk 1-13-1 ds rgr fcuk fdlh
naM ds le;o`f) iznku djus dh Lohd`fr nh tkrh gSA Lohd`r le;o`f) dk
vkns’k vius Lrj ij tkjh djsaA””
10.
When the respondents/State have admitted that due to oversight
of the documents the orders have been issued and ultimately the time
to complete the work of Asna Kadakghat bridge was extended upto
October, 2026 and they have considered the difficulties in providing the
proposed site as certain hindrance in shifting of high voltage electricity
poles, land acquisition and removal of encroachment, the petitioner
cannot be held liable for causing the delay in completing the work.
Considering the difficulties, the respondents/State have extended the
time of completion of he work repeatedly and it cannot be said that the
petitioner is at fault that he is not completing the work in time. From the
return filed by the State it is clear that due to oversight of the document
by the authorities the said orders have been passed which has been
ultimately corrected by issuing the extension order of time to complete
the work.
11.
Once the substantive part of the order has been considered by the
authorities that due to oversight of the document the show cause notice
was issued to the petitioner and for that reason his category of licence
was demoted. Once, it has been observed that the petitioner is not at
any fault and it is the mistake on the part of the respondent authorities,
the category of licence cannot be demoted from category ‘A’ to ‘B’ which
amounts to punishment for his fault. Certainly he shall be debarred from
participating in further tender process under the licence of category ‘A’
which amounts to its civil death. The appellate authority while deciding
the appeal of the petitioner also has not considered and dismissed the
appeal on the ground that the petitioner could not completed the various
work allotted to him at different places and he could avail remedy of
arbitration clause and therefore, his category of licence was demoted is
also appears to be erroneous. When the authorities have considered
that the petitioner is not at any fault and there are reasons for delay in
completion of the work, however, the petitioner has completed the work
allotted to him and there is no substantial delay in completing the work.
Further, the period for completion of work was extended upto October,
2026 which itself amounts that there is no fault of the petitioner. The
said order of extension of time was passed on 18-11-2025, i.e., after
passing of the order dated 11-11-2025 (Annexure-P/1) despite the
dismissal of the appeal filed by the petitioner, the respondent authorities
have extended the time to complete the work without any fault, the
impugned order cannot be sustained.
Having considered the entire facts and circumstances of the case,
we are of the opinion that the petitioner has made out a case for
interference to quash the impugned orders, Annexure-P/1 and P/2.
Consequently, the order dated 11-11-2025 (Annexure-P/1) and order
dated 14-7-2025 (Annexure-P/2) are hereby quashed. The writ petition
is allowed. No order as to cost.
Aadil
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review