Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 03
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 89 of 2019
Date of Decision: 30.01.2023
Shri. Ashim Deb Roy & 6 Ors.
Vs.
Union of India & Anr.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. M. Chanda, Adv.
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. N. Syngkon, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This writ petition is directed against the impugned orders dated
08.02.2019, 08.03.2019 and 15.02.2019, issued by the respondent No. 2,
declaring the placement/re-designation of the writ petitioners as Warrant
Officer as promotion, which has been alleged to be in violation of
instructions contained in the Office Memorandum dated 22.01.1998,
issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs, as well as in total violation of the
orders of this Court dated 23.03.2017, passed in WP(C) No. 403 of 2014
and WP(C) No. 311 of 2016. It is alleged that, in the process of
implementation of the judgment and order dated 23.03.2017, the
declaration of the re-designation of the writ petitioners as Warrant
Officer, a promotion, the same has resulted in a substantial reduction of
the basic pay of every individual petitioner on account of 1 st ACP under
O.M. dated 09.08.1999, as well as, 2nd MACP under O.M. dated
19.05.2009, on completion of the prescribed qualified period.
2.
The grievance as portrayed centres around the action of the
respondents, which is stated to be deliberate and wrongful, in treating the
placement of the writ petitioners as Warrant Officer as a promotion, when
the order dated 23.03.2017, passed by this Court had directed them to
grant appropriate Rank, Structure and Pay Scale as per the 5th Central Pay
Commission in terms of O.M. dated 22.01.1998, including financial
upgradation under the ACP Scheme. This action it is contended, has
caused severe loss and prejudice to the writ petitioners.
3.
Mr. M. Chanda, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that
the petitioners never prayed for grant of promotion, to the cadre of
Warrant Officer (ASI), nor did this Court by order dated 23.03.2017,
passed in WP(C) No. 403 of 2014 and WP(C) No. 311 of 2016, direct for
the same. He submits that by the judgment dated 23.03.2017, this Court
had given two directions, firstly, to give appropriate Rank and Pay Scales
to the petitioners, as per the 5th Central Pay Commission and Office
Memorandum dated 22.01.1998, and for including financial upgradation
under the Modified Assured Career Progression Scheme of the
Government of India within a period of three months. Learned counsel
submits that these two directions carry two different meanings, inasmuch
as, the word Financial Upgradation refers to the MACP scheme only and
not to Rank and Pay Scale, and that the other direction is prefixed by the
word Give, which he submits is not a direction for upgradation of Rank
and Pay, but to give appropriate Rank and Pay.
4.
The learned counsel strongly contends that the respondents have
deliberately misconstrued and misinterpreted, the two distinctly different
directions, by combining them both to suit their convenience. He further
submits that the judgment dated 23.03.2017, issued directions, with
regard to the grant of MACP and not ACP, with an added condition that,
if any individual petitioner did not get the benefit of MACP, the same be
granted, if any. He submits that in terms of the O.M. dated 22.01.1998,
the respondents have wrongly interpreted the order dated 23.03.2017, and
by no stretch of the imagination can it be said that, this Court had directed
for grant of promotion of the petitioners, to the rank of Warrant Officer
and that, it is, but a mere re-designation. It has also been submitted by the
learned counsel that, in the implementation for grant of Rank, Status and
Pay, in terms of the 5th Central Pay Commission, with regard to other
trades, such as Draftsmen in WP(C) No. 268 of 2012 and WP(C) No. 19
of 2010, the word Promotion was never used, but the word Redesignation was used. Learned counsel submits that similar is the case of
Riflemen ORL to Havildar ORL, wherein the word Upgradation and Redesignation have been used, without using the word Promotion. Other
instances have also been illustrated, on this same vein, with regard to
other trades.
5.
It has also been urged before this Court, that the Rank, Status
and Pay of Warrant Officer (ASI) has been granted at the entry grade to
other similar situated employees of the Assam Rifles, whereas, the similar
order of placement in the case of the writ petitioners has been declared
promotion instead of re-designation. It is also submitted that the
placement in the cadre of Warrant Officer, must be by way of redesignation, with a commensurate prescribed replacement pay scale, and
as such, it cannot be termed a promotion, as per O.M. dated 22.01.1998.
Learned counsel has referred to various orders rendered by this High
Court, to impress upon the point that the grant of Rank, Status and Pay
Scale of Warrant Officer which were granted, were in terms with the
recommendation of the 5th Central Pay Commission and in terms of the
O.M. dated 22.01.1998, whereas, instead of affording equal treatment, the
petitioners have been declared as promoted, which has caused them
irreparable financial loss.
6.
The learned counsel has also referred to the order of this Court
dated 09.04.2013, passed in WP(C) No. 268(SH) of 2012, wherein, it was
directed that, the petitioners (Havildar, Draftsman) be re-designated as
Warrant Officer/Assistant Sub-Inspector, with a replacement pay scale of
Rs.4000/- to Rs.6000/- w.e.f., date of respective initial appointment. As
such, he prays, as the instant case is similarly situated, the impugned
implementation order dated 08.02.2019, the consequential impugned
order dated 15.02.2019 and implementation order dated 08.03.2019, be
set aside and quashed.
7.
Mr. N. Syngkon, learned counsel for the respondents has at the
outset traced the multitude of cases, which he submits has a bearing on
the instant case. He submits that in compliance to order dated 13.05.2013,
passed in WP(C) No. 412 of 2010, filed by the same petitioner herein, the
grant of 1st ACP from the date of remusteration of Cipher personnel had
been finalized, pursuant to which orders for grant of ACP/MACP were
issued by the respondents granting pay scale from Rs. (3200-4900)/- to
Rs. (5500-9000)/-. He submits that thereafter, two writ petitions being
WP(C) No. 403 of 2014 and WP(C) No. 311 of 2016, were disposed of
by a common judgment and order dated 23.03.2017, for upgradation of
rank and structure and the same on being referred to the Ministry of Home
Affairs was approved by letter dated 30.11.2018. It is further submitted
that, in consonance with the said letter, the respondents issued letter dated
21.12.2018, whereby the impugned orders for upgradation as Warrant
Officer (Cipher), w.e.f. 10.10.1997, or from the date of passing Cipher
Class-II and ACP/MACP orders were issued. He also submits that, prior
to the implementation of the upgradation, the case for granting
ACP/MACP to the Cipher persons stood changed as the introduction of
Warrant Officer (Cipher) was taken as one set of financial upgradation in
the revision of their pay fixation, which has resulted in the decrease of
their existing basic pay. Learned counsel submits that in this situation,
some of the Cipher personnel submitted their unwillingness to accept the
rank of Warrant Officer (Cipher) granted to them as promotion, as the pay
re-fixation on the subsequent grant of MACP, was not financially
beneficial to them.
8.
Learned counsel submits that in compliance with the judgment
dated 23.03.2017, passed in WP(C) No. 403 of 2014 and WP(C) No. 311
of 2016, the rank of Warrant Officer had been introduced in the Cipher
category w.e.f. 10.10.1997, in between Havildar and Naib Subedar, and
that with introduction of this new rank, all affected Cipher personnel were
promoted/upgraded as Warrant Officer (Cipher) w.e.f. 10.10.1997. He
further submits that, the upgradation from Havildar (Cipher) to Warrant
Officer (Cipher) rank involves higher rank and pay scale, and hence, the
same has been termed as 1st financial upgradation for the purpose of
ACP/MACP schemes. All the eligible Cipher personnel, he submits, have
been further granted 2nd and 3rd financial upgradations under the
ACP/MACP schemes as applicable from the date of remusteration in the
Cipher category, instead of date of enrollment. Learned counsel to
illustrate this point, has cited the example of the petitioner No. 3, and
submits that after treating the promotion from Havildar (Cipher) to
Warrant Officer (Cipher) as 1st financial upgradation, the petitioner No. 3
was granted 2nd financial upgradation w.e.f. 01.09.2008, and was
promoted to the rank of Subedar (Cipher) on 01.01.2014, which was
counted as a 3rd financial upgradation under the MACP scheme.
9.
It is in this context, he submits that, the introduction of Warrant
Officer rank in between Havildar and Naib Subedar has caused financial
loss to some of the Cipher personnel, who were earlier granted the
benefits of the 1st financial upgradation under the ACP scheme in the pay
of Naib Subedar (Cipher) and therefore, as the upgradation to the rank of
Warrant Officer (Cipher) has been termed as 1st financial upgradation for
ACP scheme purpose, a substantial amount of recovery on pay and
allowances has to be realised from such persons, due to the grant of
Warrant Officer (Cipher) rank, in terms of the orders of this Court dated
23.03.2017, which however, have been kept in abeyance as per the orders
of this Court, in the present writ petition and other connected matters.
10.
Learned counsel submits that, the petitioners are not entitled to
the benefits as prayed, which if granted, will cause a financial drain of tax
payers money, and remarks that some personnel who had received ACP
earlier in the pay of Naib Subedar, had refused promotion to the post of
Warrant Officer, as it was not beneficial to them. He submits that the
petitioners herein, also had the same choice, but as they chose not to
exercise the same, and having accepted promotion, will be entitled only
to benefits attached to the said post, and cannot claim the benefit of
promotion to the post of Warrant Officer, and at the same time, enjoy the
benefits of ACP provided for the pay of Naib Subedar. This he asserts, is
based on the logic that, the very purpose of ACP/MACP schemes was
meant for a stagnant post, but once, the petitioners were promoted to a
higher rank and pay scale, they are not entitled for such benefits under the
ACP scheme.
11.
The learned counsel in his submissions as observed earlier, has
also made references to the various orders and Office Memorandum
issued by the respondents with regard to the promotion and upgradation
of the petitioners, as also the judgment passed by the Gauhati High Court,
in WP(C) No. 3580/2018 (Bhagwan Ram Chauhan), whereby vide order
dated 12.09.2018, it has been directed that, finalisation of pensionary
dues, shall be on the basis of correct pay payable to the petitioner and not
based upon an incorrect higher pay that was paid to him, during his
service tenure. This the learned counsel submits, is to emphasize the point
that, final settlement of Cipher personnel who are proceeding on
retirement, is being carried out as per the revised pay, and the recovery of
overpaid amount, is being effected from the gratuity and leave
encashment dues. He however submits that, if the writ petitions are ruled
in favour of the petitioners, the pay and pension of the Cipher personnel
will be revised accordingly, and remaining pensionary benefits and arrear
pay and allowances as admissible will be paid to them.
12.
In conclusion, the learned counsel submits that, the writ
petitioners who were initially enrolled as Rifleman(Operator Radio Line)
had already been given the benefits of higher rank and pay scale of
Havildar (Cipher) on their remusteration, which was not counted as 1st
financial upgradation by the respondent authority, and more benefits were
granted in rank and pay scale, in the higher rank of Warrant Officer, Naib
Subedar (Cipher) and Subedar (Cipher) which were counted as 1st, 2nd
and 3rd financial upgradations, in terms of ACP/MACP schemes, and as
such, the actions of the respondents in reckoning Warrant Officer as 1 st
financial benefit, in terms of ACP/MACP schemes, is therefore correct.
As such, it is contended, the case of the writ petitioners that, the benefits
granted should be counted from Naib Subedar (Cipher) is misplaced and
is an attempt to obtain double benefits, which is against public policy. He
therefore submits that, the prayer of the writ petitioners to grant benefit
of 1st ACP scheme, in the pre revised pay scale of Rs.5500-9000, in the
rank of Naib Subedar (Cipher) on completion of 12 years of service, from
the date of remusteration, in the cadre of Cipher trade is not tenable, and
as such, all the instant writ petitions and other connected petitions being
devoid of merit are liable to be dismissed.
13.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties. The saga
concerning the claim of service benefits and entitlements of the
petitioners and other similarly situated personnel, appears to be unending,
and a perusal of the materials bear testimony to this fact.
14.
In the present writ petition, the basic question involved is to
whether, the re-designation of the writ petitioners as Warrant Officer with
a replacement pay scale, could be termed as a promotion in the process of
the implementation of the orders of this Court dated 23.03.2017, and
whether this action has resulted in the violation of the Government of
India Office Memorandum dated 22.01.1998. In this backdrop therefore,
it would be necessary to first examine the purport and the substance of
the order dated 23.03.2017, passed in WP(C) No. 403 of 2014 and WP(C)
No. 311 of 2016. The petitioners, by way of WP(C) No. 403 of 2014 and
WP(C) No. 311 of 2016, had earlier approached this Court, praying for
grant of appropriate rank, status and pay of Warrant Officer (ASI) in the
light of the instructions contained in the Office Memorandum of the
Ministry of Home Affairs dated 22.01.1998. The prayer as made out in
the said writ petitions, was for directions to grant appropriate rank and
pay scale as per the recommendations of the 5th Central Pay Commission
and Office Memorandum dated 22.01.1998, and also to include financial
upgradation under the ACP, and modified ACP scheme.
15.
This Court by order dated 23.03.2017, had then allowed the writ
petitions and directed the respondents to give appropriate rank and pay
scale to the petitioners, as per the 5th Central Pay Commission, and Office
Memorandum dated 22.01.1998, including financial upgradation under
ACP and MACP schemes of the Government of India, within a period of
three months. This Court, by the judgment dated 23.03.2017, while
allowing the writ petitions, and issuing the aforesaid directions had
digested the earlier cases concerning the grant of rank and pay structure,
as per recommendations of the 5th Central Pay Commission, apart from
other rulings, with regard to parity of pay on the doctrine of ‘Equal Work,
Equal Pay’.
The relevant extract of the order dated 23.03.2017, is quoted
herein below;
“30. The respondents have extended the benefit of
the Fifth Pay Commission to the same category of
person who had moved the Court, however, the
petitioners being similarly situated are treated
differently. In a decision of Division Bench of
Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of
‘Satbir Singh vs State of Haryana’ 2002 (2) SCT
354 taken a view that when a judgment attains
finality, the State is bound to grant relief to its
employees who are similarly situated even though
they are not party to the litigation. A final decision
of the Court must not only be respected but should
also be enforced and implemented evenly and without
discrimination in respect of all the employees who are
entitled to the benefit which has been allowed to the
employees who have obtained orders from the Court.
The matter is one of principle and should not depend
upon who comes to the Court and who does not. In
‘Dr. (Mrs.) Santosh Kumari vs. Union of India and
Ors.’ (1995) 1 SCC 269, Hon’ble Supreme Court
lamented that a more deserving candidate may not
have the means to approach the Court, should he be
denied the benefit which has been granted to those
persons who dared the department with Court orders.
31. The position which emerges from the present
case is that to deny the benefit of the earlier judgment
which has attained finality, to the similarly situated
employee, is nothing but a blatant discrimination.
Such an action smacks of arbitrariness and highhandedness on the part of the employer. To drive
each one of the similarly placed person to obtain
orders of the Court, would amount to exploitation of
the employees having limited resources, time and
energy. The Courts would also be burdened with unnecessary litigation. As a matter of fact, it is also the
duty of the State to take remedial measures to curtail
the litigation and to wipe off or minimize the already
over-crowded dockets of the Courts. How to eliminate
the arrear and curtail the delays are the questions
which are vexing every mind. The State instead of
extending its cooperation to bring down the litigation
should not encourage its employees to take recourse
to multiple legal proceedings on the same point which
stands already decided finally. There is also an
element of wastage of public money as the State has
to defend the cases by employing its legal agency
resulting in payment of the substantial amount in the
shape of fees. The State should avoid the fruitless
exercise and wasteful expenditure. Unnecessary
litigation further breeds strained relations between the
members of the staff and the State as a employer
which has to be avoided at all costs. The State has
pervasive obligation to discharge in relation to
maintaining its accepted standards of employeremployee relationship. One of the obligations of the
State is to be reasonable and fair in granting service
benefits to its employees in accordance with the Service
Rules and the principles enunciated in the decisions of
the Courts. When the decisions to which the State is
party become final, a duty is cast upon the State to
grant relief to its employees who are similarly situated
and on identical facts. In my view, it is not necessary
for the State to require each one of its employees to
approach the Court of law for grant of reliefs which
State ought to grant to the employees in the normal
course of its administration.
32. In the light of aforesaid discussion, the writ
petitions are allowed. The respondents are directed
to give appropriate rank and pay scales to the
petitioners as per the Fifth Central Pay Commission
nd
and Office Memorandum dated 22 January, 1998
including financial up-gradation under modified
Assured Career Progression Scheme of the
Government of India, if any, within a period of three
months.”
16.
The Office Memorandum dated 22.01.1998, issued by the
Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, on which great emphasis
has been laid upon, for the sake of convenience is also reproduced
hereinbelow:
“No.27011/103/97-PF.I/56
Government of India/Bharat Sarkar
Ministry of Home Affairs/Grith Mantralaya
North Block,
Delhi, the 22nd Jan 98
Office Memorandum
Subject :
FIXATION OF PAY ON RATIONALISATION OF PAY SCALES
WITH EFFECT FROM 10.10.97 IN THE CADRE PARA
MILITARY FORCES.
In the context of certain doubts expressed by the Central Para Military
Forces in fixation of pay of certain non-gazetted personnel of the Central Para
Military Forces with effect from 10.10.97, vide order No.27011/1/97PCCell/PF.I dated 10.10.97, it is hereby clarified that the orders are equally
applicable to all combatised categories. For example, the HC (RF) will be given
the replacement pay scale of Rs.3200-4900, as approved by the Government, in
the said orders for HCs and will continue to the known as HC (RF).
2.
In the case of HC (RM) Gr. I and Gr. II and HC (Draughtsman), since
the pay commission has given the replacement pay scale of Rs.4000-6000/- in
respect of these three categories of posts in Central Para Military Forces, these
three categories may be re-designated as ASI in the scale of pay of Rs.4000-5000.
As regards other categories of HC, in any of Central Para Military Forces, such
as HC (RO, Cry) etc., these posts will continue to be known as HC in the relevant
scale of pay approved by the Government.
3.
This issues with the concurrence of Integrated Finance Division of this
Ministry vide their Dy.No.305/97-Fin.II dated 22nd January, 1997.
Sd/-XXX
(A.Gopinathan)
Desk Officer
To
1. DG BSF/CRPF/ITBP/CISF/NSG/Assam Rifles.
2. Fin.II/III/PF.II/III/IV/V Desk.
3. Guard File.”
17.
A careful perusal of the O.M dated 22.01.1998, reflects that the
Ministry of Home Affairs, on certain doubts being expressed by Central
Para Military Forces in fixation of pay w.e.f. 10.10.1997, had clarified
that a Notification dated 10.10.1997, which provided for re-designation
and fixation of pay scale in all para-military forces, would be equally
applicable to all combatised categories. As such, therefore, this redesignation and grant of replacement pay scale in this case of Rs.40006000/- was applicable to all the combatised categories. Para-2 of the O.M.
also made it clear that the post of Head Constable be re-designated as
ASI, in the scale of pay of Rs.4000-6000/- as replacement pay scale.
18.
This Court, by the order dated 23.03.2017, on the basis of the
O.M. then, had accordingly directed the respondents to give appropriate
rank and pay scale to the petitioners, as per recommendations of the 5th
Central Pay Commission, and Office Memorandum dated 22.01.1998. It
is pertinent to note herein, that the post of Assistant Sub-Inspector (ASI)
in the scale pay of Rs.4000-6000/- is equivalent to the post of Warrant
Officer, at the entry grade, as is evident, from order dated 21.06.2016
(Annexure – 4 to the writ petition), issued by the Ministry of Home
Affairs, wherein the respondent Assam Rifles, was requested to
implement judgment and order dated 23.08.2012, passed in WP(C) No.
277(SH) of 2010, which had directed for introduction of the rank of ASI
(Warrant Officer), at the entry grade.
19.
The respondents implemented the order passed by this Court on
23.08.2012, in WP(C) No. 277(SH) of 2010, in the case of other similarly
situated personnel, by introducing the rank of ASI (Warrant Officer), at
the entry grade, and the same was never treated as promotion. However,
what emerges in the case of the petitioners herein, is that, the respondents
while implementing the judgment and order dated 23.03.2017, passed in
WP(C) No. 403 of 2014 and WP(C) No. 311 of 2016, while introducing
the rank of Warrant Officer, which is a re-designation, declared the same
to be a promotion by way of upgradation. This in the considered view of
this Court, is not in consonance with the directions contained in the order
dated 23.03.2017, which had specifically directed for grant of appropriate
rank and pay scale to the petitioners, and the same tantamount to unequal
treatment being meted out to the petitioners from other similarly situated
personnel, which is also not in line with the Office Memorandum dated
22.01.1998.
20.
It is also noticed that, in the order dated 23.03.2017, as submitted
by the petitioners, two distinct directions have been issued that is, firstly,
to give appropriate rank and pay scales to the petitioners as per the 5 th
Central Pay Commission, and Office Memorandum dated 22.01.1998,
and secondly, for financial upgradation under the Modified Assured
Career Progression Scheme of the Government of India, if any, within a
period of three months. The directions clearly imply that, the respondents
were to give appropriate rank and pay and it does not imply that, the same
be upgradation of rank and pay. Similarly, the judgment dated
23.03.2017, had only limited the direction to financial upgradation under
the MACP scheme, and not with regard to ACP. What follows therefore,
is that, the respondents were to give appropriate rank and pay scale, which
would necessarily be to grant the benefits of being re-designated as ASI
(Warrant Officer). As observed in the preceding paragraph, there is no
direction for grant of promotion to the petitioners to the rank of Warrant
Officer, rather it is but, re-designation of the post, as such, the terming of
the same as a promotion is contrary to the directions of this Court,
contained in order dated 23.03.2017, and also the Office Memorandum
dated 22.01.1998.
21.
In this view of the matter, the impugned orders dated 08.02.2019
(Annexure – 8), 15.02.2019 (Annexure – 9) and 08.03.2019 (Annexure –
15) are liable to be interfered with, inasmuch as, in order dated
08.02.2019, and consequential order dated 15.02.2019, the order for
financial upgradation under ACPs issued were superseded and in the case
of the writ petitioner No. 1, it was shown that he was promoted to the post
of Warrant Officer (Cipher), w.e.f. 23.01.1999, and therefore not entitled
to 2nd ACP. Consequential effects of the incorrect implementation of the
order dated 23.03.2017, also resulted in reduction of the basic pay of the
writ petitioners, which also needs correction. In the totality of the
circumstances therefore, the impugned orders are hereby set aside and
quashed, and the respondents are directed to re-visit the matter of
implementation of the judgment and order dated 23.03.2017, for grant of
appropriate rank and pay structure to the writ petitioners, and to issue
fresh orders thereon, taking into account, the observations made in this
order.
22.
For the foregoing reasons, this writ petition is allowed and is
accordingly disposed of.
23.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
30.01.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review