Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Revisional Jurisdiction)
DATED : 11th April, 2023
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl.Rev.P. No.02 of 2022
Petitioners
:
Ashal Kumar Thapa and Another
versus
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
through the Director,
Vigilance Department
Revision Petition under Sections 397 and 401
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Mr. A. J. Sharma, Mr. Rahul Rathi
and Ms. Tara Devi Chettri, Advocates for the Petitioners.
Mr. Yadev Sharma, Additional Public Prosecutor with Mr. Sujan
Sharma, Assistant Public Prosecutor for the State-Respondent.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
O R D E R (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
This petition filed under Sections 397 and 401 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, (hereinafter, the “Cr.P.C.”),
assails the Order, dated 07-02-2022 of the Learned Special Judge
(PC Act, 1988), Gangtok, Sikkim, in Sessions Trial (Vigilance) Case
No.01 of 2019 [State of Sikkim (Through Vigilance Department)
vs. Ashal Kumar Thapa and Others].
2.
Briefly, the submissions put forth by Learned Senior
Counsel for the Petitioners is that the Petitioners herein filed an
application under Section 319 read with Sections 227/228 of the
Cr.P.C. (for short, “Section 319 Cr.P.C. petition”) before the
Learned Trial Court, praying that in view of the evidence appearing
against the persons named in the said petition, they also be
arrayed as accused persons along with the three Petitioners, who
were facing trial in the aforementioned case. That, the persons to
Crl.Rev.P. No.02 of 2022
Ashal Kumar Thapa and Another vs. State of Sikkim through the Director, Vigilance Department
be arrayed as accused, along with the Petitioners herein, are the
witnesses presently arraigned in the Charge-Sheet in the following
order; P.W.1 Smt. Rinzing Doma Bhutia; P.W.2 Smt. Lily Bhutia;
P.W.27 Shri B. B. Subba; P.W.28 Shri Bikram Tamang; P.W.32 Ms.
Laxmi Rai; P.W.33 Smt. Bina Gurung; P.W.47 Smt. Passangkit
Lepcha and P.W.48 Smt. Tshering Ongmu.
(i)
That, the Prosecution while making a categorical
admission in Paragraphs 4, 5 and 6 of their response to the Section
319 Cr.P.C. petition, to the effect that P.Ws 1, 2 and 47 were
complicit in the said offences, failed to advert to the role of the
other persons (P.Ws) named supra, in the offence.
Instead, the
Prosecution by a tangential prayer sought to make the said three
persons (P.Ws 1, 2 and 47) “Approvers” in the instant case,
without filing a petition under Section 306 of the Cr.P.C., thereby
depriving the Petitioners of an opportunity of contesting the
petition. That, the Learned Trial Court while rejecting the prayer of
the Petitioners under Section 319 Cr.P.C. instead of giving a
reasoned Order, proceeded first to deal with the prayer of the
Prosecution pertaining to the question of Approvers, sans a petition
under Section 306 Cr.P.C.
That, it is apparent that the Learned
Trial Court has failed to appreciate the legal issues involved in its
correct perspective, hence the impugned Order be set aside and
the Section 319 Cr.P.C. petition be ordered to be heard afresh.
3.
Learned Additional Public Prosecutor conceded fairly
that no petition was filed by the Prosecution under Section 306 of
the Cr.P.C., however the Order of the Learned Trial Court cannot
be said to be suffering from any infirmity, hence the Revision
Petition be dismissed.
Crl.Rev.P. No.02 of 2022
Ashal Kumar Thapa and Another vs. State of Sikkim through the Director, Vigilance Department
4.
Having heard learned Counsel for the parties, I have
also perused the impugned Order of the Learned Trial Court and
the Section 319 Cr.P.C. petition as well as the response filed by the
Prosecution.
5.
Indeed, the records of the Learned Trial Court do not
reveal any application filed by P.Ws 1, 2 and 47 themselves under
Section 306 of the Cr.P.C. or for that matter by the Prosecution. It
may also relevantly be noted that the Section 319 Cr.P.C. petition
was filed by the Petitioners on 03-09-2021, to which response was
submitted by the Special Public Prosecutor, Vigilance, on 22-092021.
Evidently,
the
Section
Cr.P.C.
petition
sought
arraignment of the persons named therein as accused persons, in
light of the documentary evidence submitted by the Prosecution
allegedly indicating their involvement and collusion in the offences
under which Charge-Sheet was filed.
(i)
Pausing here momentarily, the Charge-Sheet filed by
the Prosecution reflects that only the three Petitioners are arrayed
as accused persons. The Special Public Prosecutor in his response
to the Section 319 Cr.P.C. averred that the Prosecution had already
prayed for making P.Ws 1, 2 and 47 Approvers, when the Chargesheet was submitted.
(ii)
At this juncture, it is essential to reiterate that although
no application under Section 306 Cr.P.C. was filed either by P.Ws 1,
2 and 47 or by the Vigilance Department, the Learned Trial Court
by
taking
into
consideration
the
response
of
the
Vigilance
Department proceeded to treat it as a petition under Section 306
Cr.P.C. and recorded inter alia as follows;
“
…………………………………………………………..
Crl.Rev.P. No.02 of 2022
Ashal Kumar Thapa and Another vs. State of Sikkim through the Director, Vigilance Department
(iii)
17.
Insofar as the joint petition filed by the
accused Nos.1 & 3 under Section 319 read with
Sections 227/228 of the Cr.P.C, 1973 for
arraigning the concerned individuals and
officials including the above two individuals as
additional accused in the matter, it is only seen
to be an attempt to scuttle the prosecution
case. In fact, the prayer with regard to Ms.
Passingkit Lepcha and Ms. Lily Bhutia is seen to
be made only as an offshoot to the above
prayer of the prosecution. It is only seen to be
ruse to frustrate the prayer of the prosecution
in that regard. Although it was also contended
on behalf of the accused persons that the
prosecution having earlier failed to take timely
recourse to Section 306 Cr.P.C vis-à-vis the
above two individuals the only course open to
this Court is to summon them under Section
319 Cr.P.C the said contentions are also
without merit. The decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Girish Sharma’s case(supra)
is itself clear in this regard.
18.
It needs no reiteration that the power to
summon additional accused is an extraordinary power and should be exercised
sparingly. Such powers cannot be exercised in
a casual and cavalier manner. Merely making
bald claims that the concerned individuals are
somehow involved in the preparation of the
concerned false bills and having it approved
officially and so on would certainly not suffice
and justify summoning them as additional
accused, moreso, where no other culpable
overt acts have been attributed to them. This
Court is required to look into the entirety of the
case set up by the prosecution. Further, it is
now well-settled that the power under Section
319 Cr.P.C can be exercised only on the basis
of the ‘evidence’ brought before the Court
during the trial and not on the basis of
materials collected during investigation. We
may refer to the cases of S.Mohammed
Ispahani v. Yogendra Chandak & Ors. AIR 2017
SC 4994; and Hardeep Singh v. State of Punjab
& Ors. AIR 2014 SC 1400 in this regard.
Needless to say, the above joint petition cannot
as such be allowed.
19.
Resultantly,
the
prayer
of
the
prosecution is allowed. Ms. Passingkit Lepcha
and Ms. Lily Bhutia shall be present before this
Court on the next date. The joint petition of
the accused Nos.1 & 3, on the other hand,
stands rejected.
…………………………………………..” [emphasis supplied]
In the first instance, while referring to Paragraph 17 of
the impugned Order, extracted supra for convenience, it becomes
Crl.Rev.P. No.02 of 2022
Ashal Kumar Thapa and Another vs. State of Sikkim through the Director, Vigilance Department
evident that the Learned Trial Court failed to appreciate that the
prayer with regard to arraying the persons as accused was not an
offshoot to the prayer of the Prosecution, in view of the fact that
the Section 319 Cr.P.C. petition was obviously prior in time to the
response filed. Secondly, it is evident thus that the Learned Trial
Court
in fact allowed a tangential prayer
of the Vigilance
Department seeking to make P.Ws 1, 2 and 47 Approvers sans an
application under Section 306 Cr.P.C. filed by the Prosecution or by
the concerned persons, while at the same time failing to give a
reasoned order for rejecting the Section 319 Cr.P.C. petition of the
Petitioners/Revisionists.
6.
Now, reverting back to the Section 306 Cr.P.C., it deals
with tender of pardon to accomplice. It is relevant to notice that
only P.W.2 and P.W.47 were granted pardon by the Learned Trial
Court with no reason for exclusion of P.W.1 from such pardon,
although the response of the Special Public Prosecutor, Vigilance
makes mention of P.W.1 as well.
(i)
It needs no reiteration that the object of Section 306
Cr.P.C. is to allow pardon in cases where a heinous offence is
alleged to have been committed by several persons, so that, with
the aid of the evidence of the person granted pardon, the offence
may be brought home to rest. [See Suresh Chandra Bahri vs. State of
Bihar ].
The Learned Special Judge was to previously have
ascertained what evidence the accused will give, to enable him to
decide whether pardon should be granted [See Emperor vs. Pir
Imamshah ].
The concerned Special Judge may tender a full
pardon to such person on condition of his making a full and true
AIR 1994 SC 2420
AIR 1944 Sind 184
Crl.Rev.P. No.02 of 2022
Ashal Kumar Thapa and Another vs. State of Sikkim through the Director, Vigilance Department
disclosure of the whole of the circumstance within his knowledge
relative to the offence and to every other person concerned. The
Order of 07-02-2022 was pronounced allowing the prayer of the
Prosecution, but questions were put to P.W.2 and P.W.47 only on
14-02-2022 enquiring whether they sought to make full disclosure.
On this facet in Central Bureau of Investigation vs. Ashok Kumar
Aggarwal and Another
the Supreme Court while considering the
scope of Section 306 Cr.P.C. referred to the decision of Lt.
Commander Pascal Fernandes
vs. State of Maharashtra and Others4
wherein it was inter alia observed that before the Learned Special
Judge acts to tender pardon, he must, know the nature of the
evidence the person seeking conditional pardon is likely to give, the
nature of his complicity and the degree of his culpability in relation
to the offence and in relation to the co-accused. Pardon cannot be
prior in time to the persons agreeing to make a disclosure, the
pardon is in anticipation of the truth being told.
(ii)
That apart, Section 306(4)(b) requires that every
person accepting a tender of pardon made under sub-Section (1)
shall unless he is already on bail, be detained in custody until the
termination of the trial. No orders of the Learned Trial Court in this
context is seen.
The impugned Order of the Learned Trial Court
thus is revelatory of non-application of judicial mind.
7.
In light of all that has emerged in the discussions
hereinabove,
while
examining
the
correctness,
legality
and
propriety of the impugned Order dated 07-02-2022, it emerges
with clarity that the Learned Trial Court proceeded to grant a relief
to the Prosecution sans petition under the relevant provision of law
(2013) 15 SCC 222
AIR 1968 SC 594
Crl.Rev.P. No.02 of 2022
Ashal Kumar Thapa and Another vs. State of Sikkim through the Director, Vigilance Department
and even while doing so failed to adhere to the legal requirements
prescribed therein. Consequently, I am of the considered view that
the Order dated 07-02-2022 deserves to be and is accordingly
quashed and set aside.
8.
The matter is remanded back to the Learned Trial Court
for fresh consideration of the Section 319 Cr.P.C. petition.
9.
shall
The Learned Trial Court while considering the matter
give
a
reasoned
order,
uninfluenced
by
any
of
the
observations of this Court made hereinabove and shall decide the
application purely on merits.
10.
The stay order passed by this Court on 12-05-2022
stands vacated.
11.
Crl.Rev.P. No.02 of 2022 is disposed of accordingly as
also pending applications, if any.
12.
Copy of this Order be remitted to the Learned Special
Judge (PC Act, 1988), Gangtok.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
11-04-2023
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds/sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review