Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 282 of 2020
Date of Decision: 28.07.2023
Shri. Arun Kumar Tiwari
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. M. Chanda, Adv.
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. R. Debnath, CGC (For R 1-6)
None for R 7 & 8.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The issue in the present writ petition concerns the inter se
seniority of the petitioner vis-à-vis the respondents No. 7 and 8, in the
cadre of Warrant Officer (Personal Assistant) following their re-
mustering in the said cadre w.e.f. 19.02.2008. While the two private
respondents were re-mustered from the cadre of Havildar/Clerk, the
petitioner was re-mustered from the cadre of Rifleman/Operator Radio
and Line (ORL), which was a cadre lower in hierarchy than that of the
Havildar cadre. As such, at that point of time, the two private
respondents were assigned higher seniority than the petitioner in the
cadre of Warrant Officer (PA), which was as per Paragraph – 5 of the
Assam Rifles Record Office Instruction (ROI) No. 04/2002.
2.
The basis of the claim of the writ petitioner to seniority over
the private respondents was on his being retrospectively upgraded to the
cadre of Havildar (ORL) w.e.f. 09.11.2002, vide order dated 29.05.2017,
which was passed in compliance to the common judgment and order of
this Court dated 10.03.2017, in a batch of writ petitions being WP(C)
No. 322 of 2015, WP(C) No. 49 of 2016, WP(C) No. 295 of 2015 and
WP(C) No. 321 of 2015. It is the case of the petitioner therefore, that
while the petitioner has been treated to be a Havildar on and from
09.11.2002, the two private respondents were appointed to the said cadre
only on 28.11.2005 and 09.01.2006 respectively, and as such, he should
be placed at a higher position than the private respondents.
3.
Mr. M. Chanda, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the petitioner to assert his vested right had filed representations dated
05.10.2017, 08.10.2018 and 21.10.2019, seeking to be placed above the
private respondents in the gradation list of Warrant Officer (PA), but the
prayer was rejected by the authorities, by the impugned letters dated
28.02.2019, 18.06.2019, 10.10.2019 and 21.11.2019, which he contends
is in violation of ROI 4/2002, Para – 5. It is further submitted that, the
claim for due seniority had been rejected by the respondents, even
though his superior/controlling authorities had recommended the same.
In this regard, the learned counsel has referred to DO letters dated
08.10.2018, 18.10.2018, 25.10.2018 and 08.05.2019 (Annexures – 8,
8A, 8B and 14 respectively), to support this contention. As such he
submits, from the clear facts that have been placed, the petitioner has
been deprived of his rightful seniority, inasmuch as, the situation cannot
be that the private respondents who were not yet borne in service in that
grade, be considered senior. In support of his arguments, the learned
counsel has placed reliance on the judgment dated 19.11.2019, of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court passed in Civil Appeal No. 8833-8835 of 2019
(K. Meghachandra Singh & Ors. vs. Ningam Siro & Ors.) and other
two connected matters.
4.
Mr. R. Debnath, learned CGC for the respondents has
submitted that the case of the petitioner was examined on the
representations so made, and that the respondents had already granted
financial benefits of such upgradation of Havildar (ORL) w.e.f.
09.11.2002 to 07.03.2008, to him, but however, the representation was
rejected as the claim for retrospective seniority was devoid of merit. In
this context, the learned counsel has referred to the SOP, with regard to
Re-musteration of Personnel from one category to another, which
outlines the procedure regarding Re-mustering of Personnel from one
category to another, and has placed reliance on ROI No. 1/92 on the
point of seniority. Para – 6 of the said ROI No. 1/92, he submits
stipulates that, seniority for all purposes in the re-mustered trade will be
reckoned from the date of re-musteration only, and not from the date of
enrollment. The petitioner, he contends does not have any vested right
for his seniority to be reckoned from the date of re-musteration as
Havildar (ORL), and further he had also been granted all the financial
benefits as entitled on re-musteration. In support of his arguments,
learned counsel has placed reliance on the case of Shiba Shankar
Mohapatra & Ors. vs. State of Orissa & Ors. reported in (2010) 12 SCC
471, which speaks about delay and laches in challenging inter se
seniority and also the determination thereof, in the absence of statutory
rules.
5.
None has appeared for the private respondents No. 7 and 8,
inspite of service of notice, which has been evidenced by receipts dated
04.05.2023, and 10.05.2023. As they have been served, this matter was
heard and is being disposed of in their absence.
6.
The only point for consideration is the claim of the petitioner
to retrospective seniority over the respondents No. 7 and 8, in view of
the fact that, as noted above pursuant to Court orders, he received the
benefit of such upgradation of Havildar (ORL) w.e.f. 09.11.2002 to
07.03.2008. This claim however, has to be looked at from the facts and
circumstances surrounding the case, and cannot be said to be as straight
forward or simple, as to the determination of seniority between a person
who is on paper senior to other persons, who were not yet borne in the
cadre, as sought to be made out by the petitioner. In this regard, the order
dated 05.03.2008, whereby the petitioner including the respondents No.
7 and 8, were re-mustered, needs to be examined. An extract whereof is
reproduced hereinbelow.
MAHANIDESHALAYA ASSAM RIFLES
DIRECTORATE GENERAL ASSAM RIFLES : SHILLONG
ORDER
I.12016/9/2008/Adm-II/
Dated: 05 Mar 2008
1. The following pers of Fmns/units as shown against each are
hereby approved for remustering into WO (PA) w.e.f. 19 Feb 2008 to
the scale of pay Rs. 4000-100-6000/- pm :-
Ser
No.
(a)
Particulars
Present Unit
C/362842M Hav/Clk
L Sanaton Singh
ARASU
Date of
Remusteration
19 Feb 2008
(b)
C/362964W Hav/Clk
Pankaj Kumar Singh
ARTC & S
19 Feb 2008
(c)
C/363027L Hav/Clk
Satheesh S
HQ DGAR
19 Feb 2008
(d)
C/5010513X Hav/Clk
J Justine
15 AR
19 Feb 2008
(e)
C/5010659L Hav/Clk
Binti Singh
44 AR
19 Feb 2008
(h) G/193740N Rfn/GD
Anil Kumar KL
19 AR
19 Feb 2008
(g)
G/213832K Rfn/GD
Saji PV
2 AR
19 Feb 2008
(f)
G/359021M Rfn/ORL
Arun Kumar Tiwari
HQ 23 Sect
AR
19 Feb 2008
7.
The seniority it can be seen was fixed in order of the cadre,
from which the persons had been originally borne in, before being remustered as Warrant Officer. Accordingly, the petitioner as well as, two
other Riflemen were ranked lower in seniority, than those who were
originally belonging to the higher cadre of Havildar/Clerk, such as, the
respondents No. 7 and 8.
8.
As observed earlier, the basis of the claim of the writ
petitioner to seniority over the private respondents was on his being
retrospectively upgraded to the cadre of Havildar (ORL) w.e.f.
09.11.2002, vide order dated 29.05.2017, which was passed in
compliance to the common judgment and order of this Court dated
10.03.2017, in a batch of writ petitions. In this context therefore, this
Court is to examine as to whether, the writ petitioner has acquired any
vested right for retrospective reckoning of seniority, even though,
financial and other benefits have been accorded to the writ petitioner
from the date he was upgraded retrospectively to the post of
Havildar/Clerk. It is to be noted that, the date of re-musteration for all
the eight persons was given as 19.02.2008. In this regard ROI No. 1/92,
which is relevant on the point of seniority at Para – 6, stipulates as
follows.
“Seniority
6. Seniority for all purposes in the remustered trade will
reckon from the date of remusteration only and not from the
date of enrollment.”
9.
ROI No. 1/92, therefore having provided the basis for
determination of seniority and the respondents No. 7 and 8, being placed
higher in the list, it cannot be the case that, this ROI will not apply to a
situation where all the employees are re-mustered on the same date, and
that it only applies to cases, where the date of re-musteration to the said
rank were made on different dates, as sought to be made out by the
petitioner to assert that the date of enrollment, in this case retrospective,
should be the defining factor.
10.
Further, it is observed that the judgment and order dated
10.03.2017, relied upon by the writ petitioner, which was passed in
WP(C) No. 322 of 2015, WP(C) No. 49 of 2016, WP(C) No. 295 of
2015 and WP(C) No. 321 of 2015, does not allude to grant of respective
seniority, but only to fixation of pay and pension including calculation of
arrears and revision of pension, as per the 5th, 6th and 7th CPC as
applicable. This appears in the pleadings of the writ petitioner itself at
Para – 6, wherein this portion has been quoted. The petitioner, as per the
said order has in the considered view of this Court been given all
benefits as admissible, that is, monetary benefits of such upgradation of
Havildar (ORL) w.e.f. 09.11.2002 to 07.03.2008, and as such, can no
longer derive any other benefit from the said judgment and order dated
10.03.2017.
11.
The seniority of the petitioner as discussed, was fixed at the
time of his re-musteration as Warrant Officer (PA) on 05.03.2008, the
same therefore cannot be altered now after a lapse of over a decade, as it
will unsettle a settled position. It has to be kept in mind that, the grant of
any relief as prayed by the petitioner for review of seniority on grounds
of upgradation of his previous rank/post retrospectively, will surely
result in upsetting the seniority position, inasmuch as, the petitioner after
his re-musteration as Warrant Officer (PA) had remained junior to the
private respondents No. 7 and 8, for more than 12 years, for which
review is sought for now. The Supreme Court in the case of Shiba
Shankar Mohapatra & Ors. vs. State of Orissa & Ors. reported in
(2010) 12 SCC 471 at Para – 30, had held as follows.
“30. Thus, in view of the above, the settled legal
proposition that emerges is that once the
seniority had been fixed and it remains in
existence for a reasonable period, any challenge
to the same should not be entertained. In K.R.
Mudgal, this Court has laid down, in crystal
clear words that a seniority list which remains in
existence for 3 to 4 years unchallenged, should
not be disturbed. Thus, 3-4 years is a reasonable
period for challenging the seniority and in case
someone agitates the issue of seniority beyond
this period, he has to explain the delay and
laches in approaching the adjudicatory forum,
by furnishing satisfactory explanation.”
12.
The judgment placed by the learned counsel for the petitioner
K. Meghachandra Singh & Ors. vs. Ningam Siro & Ors. (supra), is of
no assistance to the case of the petitioner, as the same is on a different
footing altogether. The other grounds set up by the petitioner such as,
recommendations for re-fixation of his seniority and the airing of his
grievances before the higher authorities has also been suitably replied
and in the opinion of this Court, had been rightly rejected by the
department, inasmuch as, any tinkering with the seniority list after a
lapse of so many years, would surely result in turmoil and upheaval in
the organizational structure of the concerned ranks, wherein similar
upgradation exercises have been undertaken.
13.
For the aforementioned reasons, the writ petition fails and is
accordingly dismissed, however, with no order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
28.07.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review