Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:4285
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Digitally
signed by
RAHUL
RAHUL JHA
Date:
JHA
2026.01.27
13:27:03
+0530
Order reserved on 22-01-2026
Order delivered on 27-01-2026
MCRC No. 10287 of 2025
Arti Wasnik W/o Dr. Vikash Bombeshwar Aged About 47 Years R/o E-1/39,
Sector-17, Atal Nagar, Naya Raipur, Raipur, Chhattisgarh 492002
Applicant
Versus
Central Bureau Of Investigation (CBI) Anti Corruption Branch, Raipur,
District- Raipur (C.G.)
Respondent(s)
(Cause-title is taken from Case Information System)
For Applicant(s)
: Mr. Ankit Pandey, Mr. L.N. Malviya, Dr. Sharad
Pandey, Mr. Navin Ahuja & Mr. Balraj Sahu,
Advocates
For Resp/CBI
: Mr. Himanshu Pandey, Adv. appears on behalf of
Mr. B. Gopa Kumar, Advocate.
C A V Order
Per Bibhu Datta Guru, J.
1.
The applicant has preferred this first bail application under Section 483
of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 20231 for grant of bail as she
henceforth ‘the BNSS’
has been arrested in connection with Crime No. RC1242024A0004
registered at Police Station CBI, Anti Corruption Branch/Economic
Offence Wing, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G) for the offence punishable
under Sections 120B read with Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code 2
and Sections 7, 12, 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(A) of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988.
2.
In respect of certain illegalities and irregularities committed by the
authorities of the Chhattisgarh Public Service Commission 3 in the
recruitment process, two separate FIRs bearing Crime No.05/2024 of
EOW/ACB, Chhattisgarh, Raipur and Crime No. 28/2024 of Arjunda PS,
Dist. Balod, Chhattisgarh were registered and subsequently, the matter
was transferred to the Central Bureau of Investigation 4. Initially, in the
said Crime Number, there were seven accused persons. A-1 Taman
Singh Sonwani, the then Chairman of the PSC; A-2 Shravan Kumar
Goyal, Director of Bajrang Power and Ispat Ltd.; A-3 Shashank Goyal
(son of A-2); A-4 Ms. Bhumika Katiyar (Daughter-in-law of A-2); A-5
Nitesh Sonwani (nephew of A-1) & A-6 Sahil Sonwani (nephew of A-1)
and A-7 Lalit Ganvir, Deputy Controller (Examination) of the PSC.
During the course of investigation, the applicant herein, who at the
relevant time was posted as Controller of Examination of the PSC, has
been inculpated.
3.
The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that during the period 2020–
2022, the PSC conducted the State Service Examination. At the relevant
henceforth ‘the IPC’
henceforth ‘the PSC’
henceforth ‘the CBI’
time, Accused No. 1 was the Chairman of the PSC and is alleged to have
extended undue advantage to his family members and favoured
candidates. Accused Nos. 5 and 6 are the nephews of Accused No. 1,
while Accused No. 7 was posted as Deputy Controller (Examination) of
the PSC. It is alleged that, under the instructions of Accused No. 1, the
question papers were leaked and shared with Accused Nos. 5 and 6, and
thereafter Accused No. 7 shared the said question papers with Accused
No. 2, who in turn provided the same to his son and daughter-in-law,
namely Accused Nos. 3 and 4.
The allegation against the applicant/accused Smt. Arti Wasnik is
that during the relevant period the applicant was posted as Controller of
Examination. It was the official duty of the applicant to maintain strict
confidentiality in respect of the examinations conducted by the PSC.
However, it is alleged that during the said period, for obtaining illegal
direct and indirect benefits, the applicant along with other co-accused
breached such confidentiality and provided question papers to certain
candidates. It is further alleged that the said candidates, who have
already been arrested in the present case, had received the question
papers prior to the examination, prepared answers in advance, appeared
in the examination, and were thereafter selected to the concerned posts.
4.
(a)
Learned counsel appearing for the applicant would submit that the
applicant is innocent and has been falsely implicated. However, on
account of some complaints, which have been made with regard to
alleged irregularities committed in the said process of State Service
Examination conducted by the PSC, two FIRs were lodged at different
police stations which was subsequently transferred to the CBI. Learned
counsel would submit that the applicant has discharged her duties as per
the directions of the Chairman of the PSC who is the competent
authority in this regard. He would submit that A-7, the Deputy Controller
of Examinations, was entrusted with and looked after the affairs of the
examination pursuant to the order dated 29.06.2021. The only allegation
against the applicant is that the Publisher made a statement that she has
received the question papers. According to the learned counsel, there is
no communication, no seizure of any document and even there is not
trail of money. He would submit that the applicant herein is not the
beneficiary and even she has not made any phone call or messages in
this context. Learned counsel would submit that A-7 collected the
question papers and the same has been proved in the investigation. From
para 16.7.2 of the Final Report dated 16.01.2025, it can be seen that the
nature of duties and responsibilities of the Chairman of PSC have been
mentioned, and in terms of the same the Chairman of the PSC assigns
the duties from time to time. According to para 16.7.4, A-7 was assigned
the work namely to maintain the account of expenditure made by the
Selection/Recruitment Section, Examination Section, Advertisement
Section, Confidential Section, to prepare result of State Civil Service,
Main Examination and Civil Judge Examination manually. In addition
to this, he also attends the work assigned by Chairman, Secretary and
controller of examination from time to time. Learned counsel would
submit that the allegations leveled against the applicant are contrary to
the notification dated 29.06.2021.
(b)
Learned counsel would submit that the applicant has no criminal
antecedents and prima facie, there is no evidence that the applicant is
guilty of the offence as alleged in the subject crime. He would submit
that no incriminating material has been recovered from her; the applicant
is a lady having two minor children; and she is in detention since
18.09.2025. Thus, the applicant may be granted bail.
5.
(i)
Learned counsel appearing for the CBI, per contra, would oppose
the bail application. He would submit that the applicant herein leaked
the question papers without maintaining the secrecy. He would submit
that in respect of the applicant, the charge-sheet has been filed. By
referring para 16.7.13 of the Final Report, he would submit that in the
month of January, 2022 under the instructions of Arun Dwivedi of AKD
Printers Pvt. Ltd., one Mahesh Das visited Raipur and handed over the
sealed packet containing draft question papers of preliminary
examination of CGPSC 2021 to the applicant. Thereafter, he stayed at
Raipur two-three days and collected the same sealed packet from the
residence of the applicant. At that time, he found one more person who
subsequently identified as A-1. Subsequently, on due approval of the
applicant and A-1, final print out of both the question papers along with
OMR-Sheet was delivered to CGPSC by AKD Printers through Mahesh
Das. Thus, it is evident that the applicant and A-1 had knowledge of
questions which were supposed to be asked in both the papers. Learned
counsel would submit that this Court on an earlier occasions considered
and rejected the bail applications of A-1, A-7 and other co-accused
persons. Thus, the applicant is also not entitled for bail and he would
pray the bail application may be rejected.
6.
I have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties at length and also
gone through the charge sheet, which has been placed before this Court.
7.
It is reiterated again, as observed while considering the bail applications
of other accused persons in the crime in question that a person who
indulges in facilitating leakage of question paper relating to competitive
examinations, plays with the career and future of lacs of young aspirants,
who are ‘burning the midnight oil’ to prepare for competitive exams.
Such an act is more heinous than an offence of murder because by
killing a person, only one family gets affected but by ruining the career
of lacs of aspirants whole society is adversely impacted. Therefore, the
alleged charges levelled against the accused persons including the
present applicants can by no stretch of imagination be termed as ordinary
charges. The action of the accused persons is clear example of ‘fence
eating the crop’.
8.
Having considered the entire fact situation of the case; particularly
considering the role attributed to the applicant by the Investigating
Agency that the question papers were delivered to the applicant and
subsequently the same were collected by Mahesh Das of AKD Printers
from the residence of the applicant, where A-1, who is the main accused
in the case, was very much present there; and also considering the fact
that in the entire examination process they have not maintained the
confidentiality and the sanctity, this Court is of the considered opinion
that present is not a fit case to grant bail to the applicant.
9.
In the result, the bail application is rejected.
Sd/(Bibhu Datta Guru)
Judge
Gowri/Rahul
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review