Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:4104-DB
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 6105 of 2025
Arman Ogrey S/o Shri Sukhram Orgey Aged About 19 Years R/o Bolar
Parisar, Devrikhurd, District Bilaspur Chhattisgarh 495001
... Petitioner
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Principal Secretary, Department Of
Health, Mahanadi Bhavan, Mantralaya, Atal Nagar, Naya Raipur, District
Raipur Chhattisgarh
2 - Commissioner Department Of Medical Education Chhattisgarh
Mahanadi Bhavan, Mantralaya, Atal Nagar, Naya Raipur, District Raipur
Chhattisgarh
3 - Director Of Medical Education North Block, Sector-19, Swasthya
Bhawan, 2nd Floor, Nawa Raipur, Atal Nagar, Chhattisgarh 492002
4 - Chairman State Counselling Committee, Directorate Of Medical
Education, Through Director Of Medical Education, Raipur, North Block,
Sector 19, Swasthya Bhawan, 2nd Floor, Nawa Raipur, Atal Nagar,
Chhattisgarh 492002
5 - Liza Mahima D/o Premlal Mahima Aged About 20 Years Student 1st
Year Session 2025 M B B S Course Through The Principal, Bharatratna
Late Shri Atal Bihari Vajpayee Memorial Government Medical College (M G
M C), Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh 491441
... Respondents
(Cause title taken from Case Information System)
VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Digitally signed
by VED PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Date: 2026.01.30
18:54:27 +0530
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Bidya Nand Mishra, Advocate
For Respondents/State
:
Mr. Shashank Thakur, Additional A.G.
For Respondent No.5
:
Mr. Siddharth Pandey, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
23/01/2026
1.
Heard Mr. Bidya Nand Mishra, learned counsel for the petitioner as
well as Mr. Shashank Thakur, learned Additional A.G. on behalf of the
respondents/State and Mr. Siddharth Pandey, learned counsel for the
respondent No.5.
2.
The petitioner, who appeared in the NEET-2025 examination for
admission to the MBBS/BDS Course under the Government Quota in
the State of Chhattisgarh, has approached this Court being
aggrieved by the action of the respondent authorities in depriving him
of seat allotment in the MBBS Course for the academic session 2025
in Bharatratna Late Atal Bihari Vajpayee Government Medical
College, Rajnandgaon (C.G.), despite his higher merit position. It is
the case of the petitioner that though one clear vacancy under the
SC category (without any sub-category) was available in the said
institution during the Mop-Up Round, and though he was placed at
Serial No. 877 in the merit list (3rd Round) uploaded on 24.10.2025,
he was illegally superseded by a lower-ranked female candidate,
namely Liza Mahima (respondent No.5), who was placed at Serial
No. 882 in the same merit list and was allotted the seat vide
Provisional Allotment List of the Mop-Up Round published on
05.11.2025. The petitioner further asserts that his representation
dated 06.11.2025 highlighting the said anomaly was not considered
by the authorities, compelling him to invoke the jurisdiction of this
Court seeking redressal of his grievance.
3.
The present petition has been filed by the petitioner seeking the
following reliefs:-
“10.1 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to call the entire records relating to this
case.
10.2 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to allow the petition and set aside the
impugned Chhattisgarh Neet-UG (MBBS/BDS)
2025 Provisional Allotment List-Mop-Up Round
dated 05.11.2025 (P/5) with reference to serial
no.113 of the list allotted in the name of female
candidate Liza Mahima respondent no.5 by which
the petitioner is deprived of his legitimate right to
selection for admission.
10.3 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to quash the admission taken by
respondent no.5 in MBBS Course 2025 illegally in
the said institution MGMC Rajnandgaon on the
basis of undue favour by respondent no.1 to
respondent no.4 as stated above.
10.4 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to direct respondent's no.1 to 4 to grant
and allow petitioner's admission in MBBS 2025
Course in Govt. Quota in the said institution
"Bharatratna Late Shri Atal Bihari Vajpayee
MGMC" Rajnandgaon (C.G.) on the basis of facts
and grounds stated above.
10.5 That any other relief, which this Hon'ble
Court may deem fit and proper together with cost
of the petition.”
4.
The facts of the case are that, the petitioner is a citizen of India and
is entitled to all legal and fundamental rights guaranteed under the
Constitution of India. The petitioner appeared in the NEET-UG 2025
examination conducted for admission to MBBS/BDS courses in the
State of Chhattisgarh in accordance with the prescribed rules. As per
the “NEET-UG (MBBS/BDS) 2025 Mop-Up Round Seat Matrix”
uploaded on 13.10.2025 on the CGDME website, one clear vacancy
under the SC category (without any sub-category) was available
under the Government Quota for the MBBS course in Bharatratna
Late
Atal
Bihari
Vajpayee
Government
Medical
College,
Rajnandgaon. The reservation policy governing the allotment of such
seats is contained in the Gazette Notification dated 16.07.2025
issued by the Medical Education Department, Government of
Chhattisgarh.
5.
The CG-NEET-UG 2025 Merit List for the Mop-Up Round (Round-3),
uploaded on 24.10.2025, showed the petitioner placed at Serial No.
877 with Category Rank SC-1, whereas a female candidate, namely
Liza Mahima, respondent No.5, was placed at Serial No. 882 with
Category Rank SC-4. Despite the petitioner being higher in merit and
the seat being earmarked exclusively for SC category without any
sub-category, the Provisional Allotment List of the Mop-Up Round
dated 05.11.2025 revealed that the petitioner was not allotted the
said seat. Instead, respondent No.5 was allotted the MBBS seat at
the said institution, as reflected at Serial No. 113 of the provisional
allotment list.
6.
It is the petitioner’s specific case that the seat matrix clearly excluded
any preference based on sub-categories such as women or other
classes within the SC category, and therefore the petitioner, being
the sole eligible and highest-ranked SC-1 candidate, was entitled to
the said seat. The petitioner was thus illegally superseded by a
lower-ranked candidate in clear violation of the merit list and
reservation rules. Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner submitted a
representation dated 06.11.2025 to the Commissioner, Medical
Education Department, Raipur, highlighting the illegality and
discrimination in the allotment process; however, no action was taken
on the said representation, compelling the petitioner to file the
present petition seeking enforcement of his lawful and legitimate right
to admission in the MBBS course.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that, the petitioner
duly appeared in and qualified the NEET-UG 2025 examination for
admission to the MBBS course in the State of Chhattisgarh and, as
per the Mop-Up Round Seat Matrix dated 13.10.2025 read with the
Gazette Notification dated 16.07.2025, only one seat under the
Government Quota in Bharatratna Late Shri Atal Bihari Vajpayee
Government
Medical
College,
Rajnandgaon
was
earmarked
exclusively for the SC-1 (N) category without any sub-category
preference. It is further submitted that the petitioner was placed at
Serial No. 877 with Category Rank SC-1 in the Round-3 merit list
dated 24.10.2025, whereas respondent No.5, a female candidate,
was ranked lower at Serial No. 882 with Category Rank SC-4, and
therefore the petitioner was the first and sole eligible candidate
entitled to the said seat. However, in utter disregard of merit and the
applicable reservation rules, the petitioner was illegally excluded from
the Provisional Allotment List of the Mop-Up Round dated 05.11.2025
and was wrongly superseded by respondent No.5, who was allotted
the seat at Serial No. 113 of the allotment list, despite there being no
provision for allotment to any sub-category such as women. Such
arbitrary and biased action on the part of respondent Nos.1 to 4 has
resulted in grave discrimination against the petitioner, violating
Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution of India, causing irreparable
loss to his academic career, and therefore the impugned provisional
allotment dated 05.11.2025 deserves to be quashed to the extent of
the seat allotted to respondent No.5, with a consequential direction to
allot the said MBBS seat to the petitioner strictly in accordance with
merit.
8.
Per contra, learned Additional Advocate General appearing for the
respondents/State would submit that, the present petition is wholly
misconceived, devoid of merit, and liable to be dismissed at the
threshold, as the admission process has been conducted strictly in
accordance with the Chhattisgarh Medical, Dental and Physiotherapy
Under Graduate Admission Rules, 2025. It is submitted that Rule 5(2)
of the said Rules mandates 30% horizontal reservation for women
candidates across all categories, including the Scheduled Caste
category. In the instant case, during the second round of counselling,
the lone SC category seat in Bharatratna Late Shri Atal Bihari
Vajpayee Government Medical College, Rajnandgaon was rightly
allotted to an SC female candidate, Ms. Tabbu, in compliance with
the horizontal reservation policy; however, upon her failure to join,
the seat remained vacant and was necessarily carried forward to the
Mop-Up Round under the same category and class, as a reserved
seat
once
operated
cannot
be
converted
or
de-reserved.
Consequently, during the Mop-Up Round, the said seat was validly
allotted to respondent No.5, Liza Mahima, who belongs to the SC
female category, strictly in conformity with the statutory reservation
framework. The petitioner’s contention based solely on vertical merit
is misconceived, as merit operates subject to reservation rules, and
no vested right accrues merely on the basis of a higher rank when
horizontal reservation applies. There is thus no arbitrariness,
illegality, or violation of Articles 14 or 15 of the Constitution, and the
provisional allotment dated 05.11.2025 is lawful, valid, and
unassailable, warranting dismissal of the writ petition.
9.
Mr. Siddharth Pandey, learned counsel appearing for Respondent
No. 5 would submit that, the present writ petition is misconceived and
liable to be dismissed at the threshold, as the petitioner seeks to
assail a lawful allotment made strictly in accordance with the Medical,
Dental and Physiotherapy Under Graduate Admission Rules, 2025. It
is submitted that Rule 5(2) of the said Rules expressly provides for
30% horizontal reservation for women across all categories, including
the Scheduled Caste category. In the instant case, during the second
round of counselling, the lone SC category seat in Bharat Ratna Late
Atal Bihari Vajpayee Government Medical College, Rajnandgaon was
rightly operated under the horizontal reservation for SC women and
allotted to an SC female candidate, Ms. Tabbu, who, however, did not
join the course. Consequently, the seat was validly carried forward to
the Mop-Up Round under the same category and class, as a
reserved seat once operated cannot be converted. In the Mop-Up
Round, Respondent No. 5, being an eligible SC female candidate,
was duly allotted the seat in accordance with the statutory
reservation framework. The petitioner’s claim based solely on higher
vertical merit is legally untenable, as merit operates subject to
reservation rules, and no arbitrariness or discrimination can be
attributed to a selection made in strict conformity with law. The
allotment in favour of Respondent No. 5 is thus lawful and
unassailable, and the petition, being devoid of merit and substance,
deserves outright dismissal.
10.
To rebut the contention made by learned counsel appearing for the
respective respondents, learned counsel for the petitioner would
submit that, the defence taken by the State and Respondent No.5 is
wholly misconceived, factually incorrect, and contrary to the scheme
of reservation contained in Rules 5(2) and 5(4) of the Chhattisgarh
Medical, Dental and Physiotherapy Under Graduate Admission
Rules, 2025. While Rule 5(2) provides for horizontal reservation of
30% for women, the manner of operating such reservation is
expressly governed by Rule 5(4), which mandates that once the
prescribed quota of a horizontal class is exhausted, the remaining
seats in the parent category must be filled strictly on merit without
reference to sub-category. In the present case, out of 12 SC seats
available in the State Quota of Bharatratna Late Atal Bihari Vajpayee
Government Medical College, Rajnandgaon, the 30% women quota
(i.e., 3 seats) stood fully exhausted in the first round of counselling,
wherein five female candidates were in fact allotted seats, as
reflected from the seat matrix and allotment lists on record.
Thereafter, in the second round, one seat was expressly notified as
SC ‘No Class’, meaning without any sub-category, and was rightly
allotted to Ms. Tabbu on pure merit; however, upon her non-joining,
the said seat was carried forward to the Mop-Up Round retaining its
character as SC No-Class, as clearly shown in the Mop-Up Round
Seat Matrix dated 13.10.2025 (Annexure-P/2). Once the seat stood
earmarked as SC No-Class, there was no legal scope for re-applying
horizontal reservation for women, and the seat could only be filled by
the highest-ranked candidate in the SC category as per merit. Since
the petitioner was ranked higher at Serial No. 877 (SC-1) than
Respondent No.5 at Serial No. 882 (SC-4), the petitioner alone was
entitled to allotment of the said seat. The respondents’ plea that a
reserved seat, once allotted to a woman candidate, must perpetually
remain a women’s seat is contrary to Rule 5(4) and settled principles
governing horizontal reservation, and acceptance of such an
argument would lead to distortion of the reservation roster and
obliteration of merit within the parent category. The impugned
allotment in favour of Respondent No.5 is thus patently illegal,
arbitrary, and violative of Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution of
India, and the petitioner, having been illegally superseded despite
higher merit, is entitled to the reliefs as prayed for in the writ petition.
11.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and considered their
rival submissions made herein above and also gone through the
entire records of the case with utmost circumspection.
12.
In the matter of “Pramati Educational & Cultural Trust v. Union of
India” (2014) 8 SCC 1, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, discussing the
issue with respect to the scope and object of Article 15(5), has held
that:-
“Clause (5) of Article 15 of the Constitution reads
as follows:“Nothing in this article or in sub-clause (g)
of clause (1) of article 19 shall prevent the
State from making any special provision, by
law, for the advancement of any socially
and educationally backward classes of
citizens or for the Scheduled Castes or the
Scheduled Tribes in so far as such special
provisions relate to their admission to
educational institutions including private
educational institutions.”
13.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of “State of Kerala v. N.M.
Thomas” (1976) 2 SCC 310 has held that:-
“……….. There is thus nothing in Art. 16(1) of the
Constitution to prevent the State from making
reasonable classification in order to boost up the
members of the scheduled castes and tribes by
giving
concessions
without
imperilling
the
efficiency of the services. .....”
14.
For admission of all the Under Graduate courses under the State
quota in the Government Medical, Dental and Physiotherapy
Colleges within the State of Chhattisgarh, as well as in the seats
under the Government Quota, Management Quota and Non-resident
Indian Quota of Private Medical, Dental and Physiotherapy Colleges
are governed by the “Medical, Dental and Physiotherapy Under
Graduate Admission Rules, 2025”. Rule 5 of Rules 2025 deals with
reservation of the seats and Rule 5(2) provides that, there would be
horizontal reservation of 30% for women in all categories, which
reads as under:-
“5. Reservation of seats:(1) In every Government College and
Government quota of Private College, 32
percent of the seats in each institution shall
be reserved for the Scheduled Tribes, 12
percent for the Scheduled Castes and 14
percent for the Other Backward Classes
(except
Creamy
Layer).
In
every
government college 10 percent seats will
be reserved for EWS. To avail the benefit of
this reservation, it will be mandatory for the
candidate to produce the permanent caste
certificate
or
EWS
certificate
of
Chhattisgarh State.
(2) There will be horizontal reservation of 3
percent for Defense Class, 3 percent for
freedom fighter class, 5 percent for Person
with disability class and 30 percent for
women class in all categories.
(3) Seats reserved for person with disability
shall be the eligibility criteria filled up as per
prescribed by NMC.
Disability Certificate: Only the certificate
issued
by
Chhattisgarh
the
State
Medical
Board
be
accepted.
This
will
certificate will be issued by the State
Medical Board after receiving application
from the candidate applies and after
conducting all examinations and tests.
Certificates
issued
one
day
before
admission will be valid.
(4)
In
all
categories,
3%
horizontal
reservation is available for Defense Class,
3% for freedom fighter class and 5% for
PWD class. Candidates applying in these
class, if eligible in the said. class, will be
able to get allotment of seats of the
respective class and if the seats of the
class
get
exhausted,
then
eligible
candidates of the class will be eligible for
allotment as per merit in their category. But
if after applying in the class, they are found
ineligible in the scrutiny, then they are
excluded from the merit list, that is, they
become ineligible for counselling.”
15.
The petitioner could not secure position in the first round of
counseling and during the second round of counseling, following the
30% horizontal reservation for women candidates, the said seat was
allotted to SC Female category student and one Ms. Tabbu who was
placed at serial No. 596 with State Rank of 1107 was allotted the said
seat. Ms. Tabbu did not join the said seat and it was remained
vacant, which was carry forward and included in the Mop-Up Round
under the same heading, because once the seat has been reserved
for a particular class, the same cannot be converted. The respondent
No.5 is also belongs to SC Female category and in the condition that
Ms. Tabbu had not joined, the said seat was allotted to the
respondent No.5, which cannot be said to be an arbitrary exercise of
powers or the seat was wrongly allotted to her, and therefore, there is
no illegality in the same.
16.
In light of the foregoing submissions and in accordance with settled
principles of law, as upheld by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in cases
of “Pramati Educational and Cultural Trust (supra) and “N.M.
Thomas” (supra), it is clear that the petitioner’s claims are without
merit. The petitioner’s attempt to override established horizontal
reservation norms, which have been consistently endorsed by the
Supreme Court, cannot stand. The seat allotment process followed
the statutory reservation framework, and the petitioner’s higher merit,
though significant, cannot negate the horizontal reservation once it
has been properly applied. Consequently, the petitioner’s writ petition
lacks substance and is not sustainable in law.
17.
We do not fine any good ground to entertain the matter agitated by
the petitioner, accordingly, the present writ petition deserves to be
and is hereby dismissed.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
ved
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
HEAD NOTE
********The seat allotment process should follow the statutory
reservation framework and the petitioner’s higher merit cannot
negate the horizontal reservation, once it has been properly
applied.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review