Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:6309
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ACQA No. 5 of 2026
Arman Ali S/o Late Rajjab Ali, Aged About 27 Years R/o Chantidih,
Pathan Mohalla, P.S. Sarkanda, Bilaspur (C.G.)
... Appellant(s)
versus
1 - Akbar Khan S/o Gulabjaan Khan, Aged About 55 Years R/o G-2/910,
Devnandan Nagar, Phase - 1, Sarkanda, P.S. Sarkanda, Distt. Bilaspur
(C.G.)
2 - Tayyab Hussain, S/o Akhtar Hussain, Aged About 40 Years R/o
Magarpara, P.S. Civil Line, Distt. Bilaspur (C.G.)
3 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through P.S. Sarkanda, Bilaspur Distt.
Bilaspur (C.G.)
... Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. Ruhul Ameen Memon, Advocate.
Mr. Anusha Naik, Dy. G.A.
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Judgment on Board
04/02/2026
1.
The present acquittal appeal is filed against the judgment of acquittal
dated 16.10.2025 passed by learned 9th Additional Sessions Judge,
Bilaspur in Sessions Trial No.92/2024, whereby learned trial Court
has acquitted the accused / respondent from the charge under
Section 306/34 of the IPC.
2.
Prosecution story, in brief, is that on 04.10.2022, Hamam Ali @
Arman Ali, son of deceased Ranjab Ali, submitted a written
complaint at Police Station Sarkanda alleging that the accused
persons had been repeatedly threatening the deceased and his
family with the intention of forcibly occupying their shop and
residential house. It was further alleged that the accused persons
used to bring along 25–30 persons and intimidate the family, causing
severe mental harassment. Owing to such continuous harassment,
Ranjab Ali committed suicide. Upon receipt of information regarding
the death of Ranjab Ali from the informant Sheikh Babba, a Merg
Intimation No. 123/2022 was registered at Police Station Sarkanda
vide (Exhibit P/08). Notices were issued to the witnesses for inquest
proceedings vide (Exhibit P/03), and Merg statements of the family
members of the deceased were recorded. The inquest (Panchnama)
of the dead body was conducted, and the Naksha Panchayatnama
was prepared vide (Exhibit P/06). Thereafter, the dead body was
sent to SIMS Hospital, Bilaspur for post-mortem examination along
with the requisition vide (Exhibit P/07), and the post-mortem report
was obtained vide (Exhibit P/07-A).
3.
After the post-mortem examination, the dead body of the deceased
was handed over to his relatives in accordance with Supurdnama
(Exhibit P/24), and a duty certificate was issued vide (Exhibit P/25).
A spot map (Nazri Naksha) was prepared vide (Exhibit P/04). During
the inquest proceedings, in the presence of witnesses, a handwritten
suicide note found in the pocket of the deceased’s lower, one Nokia
mobile phone, and cash amounting to Rs.1,520/- were seized under
seizure memo (Exhibit P/05). On 04.10.2022, Merg statements of
Sheikh Babba, Arman Ali, Riyaz Ali, Shabana Begum, Rehman Ali,
and Mohammad Wasim were recorded.
4.
During the course of investigation, a handwritten page written by the
deceased was seized from his son, Arman Ali vide seizure memo
(Exhibit P/13). Notices were issued to Arman Ali vide (Exhibits P/14
and P/15) for producing documents containing the natural
handwriting of the deceased in connection with verification of the
suicide note. Upon production, the documents containing the natural
handwriting of the deceased were seized vide (Exhibit P/12), and a
certificate submitted by Arman Ali in this regard was taken on record
vide (Exhibit P/16). During further investigation, on 14.04.2024,
notices under Section 160 of the Code of Criminal Procedure were
issued to Wasim Qureshi vide (Exhibit P/33) and to Mohammad
Saddam vide (Exhibit P/19) for assistance in investigation. On the
same date, the memorandum statement of accused Akbar Khan was
recorded vide (Exhibit P/20). Pursuant thereto, in the presence of
witnesses Wasim Qureshi and Mohammad Saddam, documents
relating to demarcation were produced by accused, Akbar Khan at
Devnandan Nagar, Phase-01, Sarkanda, Bilaspur, which were
seized vide seizure memo (Exhibit P/21).
5.
Upon completion of Merg inquiry, a prima facie cognizable offence
was found to have been committed, as reported by the Additional
Superintendent of Police (City), District Bilaspur. Consequently, on
05.01.2024, FIR No. 28/2024 was registered at Police Station
Sarkanda, District Bilaspur, under Sections 306 and 34 of the Indian
Penal Code against accused Tayyab Hussain and Akbar Khan vide
(Exhibit P/27). On 14.04.2024, accused Akbar Khan was arrested in
the presence of witnesses Wasim Qureshi and Mohammad Saddam
vide arrest memo (Exhibit P/22), and information regarding his arrest
was furnished to his relative Mohammad Rasool vide (Exhibit P/34A). Thereafter, applications were forwarded for recording statements
of witnesses under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
and the statements so recorded were placed on record. The seized
suicide note and admitted handwriting of the deceased were sent to
the State Questioned Documents Examiner, Naya Raipur, for
examination, and acknowledgement thereof was received. A
requisition was also sent to the Tahsildar, Bilaspur, vide (Exhibit
P/32), for production of revenue records relating to ownership of
land bearing Khasra Nos. 368/1 and 369. Upon receipt, the said
documents were taken on record. Thereafter, the expert report along
with documents from the State Questioned Documents Examiner,
Naya Raipur, was received and filed in the case.
6.
Upon completion of investigation, and as accused, Tayyab Hussain
was absconding, a Fugitive Panchnama was prepared against him.
Thereafter, the charge-sheet was filed against the accused persons
before the Court of Judicial Magistrate First Class, Bilaspur (C.G.).
The case was committed to the Court of Sessions, Bilaspur, on
29.06.2024. Subsequently, pursuant to orders of the learned
Sessions Judge, the case was transferred and received by the
Additional Sessions Court on 04.07.2024, and thereafter, upon
further transfer, was received by the Court on 03.04.2025.
7.
During the course of trial, the prosecution examined as many as 17
prosecution witnesses and exhibited the documents (Exs.P-1 to P-
35) and (article-01 to article 19A). After completion of the
prosecution evidence, the statements of the accused persons
were recorded under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, wherein the accused persons pleaded innocence and
did not adduce any evidence in their defence.
8.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the learned trial Court
has committed manifest error in law as well as on facts while
recording the judgment of acquittal, which is perverse and
unsustainable. The learned trial Court proceeded on an erroneous
understanding of the law of abetment by holding that harassment
does not amount to abetment unless there is an immediate
instigating act preceding the suicide. The settled legal position is that
sustained harassment, continuous threats, and mental torture, if of
such intensity as to drive a person to commit suicide, constitute
“instigation” within the meaning of Section 107 of the Indian Penal
Code, and are sufficient to attract Section 306 IPC. The insistence of
the trial Court on a last-minute provocation is contrary to the scheme
and spirit of the law relating to abetment of suicide and has resulted
in a grave miscarriage of justice.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellant further submits that the learned
trial Court has erred in discarding material and reliable prosecution
evidence on wholly untenable grounds. The rejection of the suicide
note merely on the ground that it did not bear a date or signature,
and that comparison documents were not earlier marked as articles,
is legally perverse. The suicide note was recovered from the person
of the deceased during inquest, was identified by witnesses as being
in the handwriting of the deceased, and its authorship was
supported by the opinion of the handwriting expert. Such
deficiencies do not render a suicide note inadmissible, particularly
when corroborated by oral and expert evidence. Further, the learned
trial Court erroneously rejected the consistent testimonies of the
deceased’s sons (PW-4 and PW-16) and independent neighbours
(PW-6 and PW-8), who uniformly deposed that the accused persons
repeatedly threatened the deceased, arrived with groups of men to
intimidate him, and pressurized him to vacate the disputed land,
causing extreme mental distress. Discarding their evidence merely
on the ground of relationship or perceived interest is contrary to
settled law that credible testimony cannot be rejected solely on that
basis.
10.
Learned counsel for the appellant also submits that the learned trial
Court has misdirected itself by relying upon irrelevant considerations
and by ignoring material circumstances proved on record. The
absence of a prior written complaint by the deceased was treated as
fatal, overlooking the reality that victims of intimidation often refrain
from lodging complaints due to fear, and that the deceased had
consistently disclosed the harassment to his family members. The
trial Court further erred in treating the delay in registration of FIR No.
28/2024 as fatal, without appreciating that the case initially
commenced as a Merg under Section 174 CrPC, that prompt
inquest, post-mortem and recording of statements were undertaken,
and that the FIR was registered pursuant to supervisory findings.
Minor omissions and trivial contradictions were unduly magnified,
while the complete failure of the accused to offer any plausible
explanation in their statements under Section 313 CrPC regarding
their repeated acts of intimidation, presence with large groups, and
role in the land dispute was ignored. The prosecution having proved
its case beyond reasonable doubt, the impugned judgment of
acquittal deserves to be set aside.
11.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the State has supported
the impugned judgment of acquittal and submitted that the learned
trial Court, upon a proper appreciation of the evidence on record,
has rightly acquitted the accused–respondent, and the said wellreasoned judgment does not call for any interference by this Court.
12.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the records
of the trial Court.
13.
While considering the scope of interference in an appeal against
acquittal, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of "State of
Rajasthan Vs. Kistoora Ram" reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC
984, has held as follows:"8. The scope of interference in an appeal against
acquittal is very limited. Unless it is found that the
view taken by the Court is impossible or perverse, it is
not permissible to interfere with the finding of
acquittal. Equally if two views are possible, it is not
permissible to set aside an order of acquittal, merely
because the Appellate Court finds the way of
conviction to be more probable. The interference
would be warranted only if the view taken is not
possible at all."
14.
In the present case, the first and foundational aspect requiring
determination is the nature of the death of the deceased Ranjab Ali.
Upon a cumulative consideration of the Merg intimation, inquest
proceedings, post-mortem report and the consistent testimony of the
medical officer, it stands conclusively established that the death of
the deceased was suicidal in nature, caused due to asphyxia as a
result of hanging. The said finding recorded by the learned Trial
Court is fully supported by medical and ocular evidence and does
not suffer from any infirmity warranting interference by this Court.
15.
The pivotal question is whether the prosecution has been able to
prove, beyond reasonable doubt, that the accused persons had
abetted the commission of suicide within the meaning of Sections
107 and 306 of the Indian Penal Code. On a careful re-appreciation
of the entire evidence, this Court finds that the suicide note
recovered from the person of the deceased, though proved to be in
his handwriting, does not attribute any role, act of instigation or
harassment to the accused persons. The second document,
allegedly produced by the son of the deceased, has been rightly
disbelieved by the learned trial Court in view of the categorical
opinion of the handwriting expert, coupled with serious infirmities
regarding its seizure, absence of date and signature, and
contradictions in the testimony of the witnesses associated with its
production. The oral evidence of the sons of the deceased alleging
repeated threats and intimidation by the accused suffers from
material contradictions, embellishments and improvements when
compared with their earlier Merg statements and police statements.
The allegation that the accused used to arrive with large groups of
persons to threaten the deceased does not find mention in the
earliest versions, thereby affecting the credibility of such testimony.
Independent witnesses have either not supported the prosecution
version or have confined themselves to formal aspects of
investigation, without attributing any specific overt act of instigation
to the accused. It has also been established from the revenue
records and demarcation documents that the shop of the deceased
was not situated on land recorded in his name and that the
demarcation proceedings were undertaken by revenue authorities
pursuant to an application filed by a third party. A civil or revenue
dispute, or lawful demarcation proceedings carried out by competent
authorities, cannot by itself constitute abetment of suicide. The
absence of any contemporaneous complaint by the deceased,
coupled with the delay in registration of the FIR after completion of
Merg proceedings, further weakens the prosecution case.
16.
The learned trial Court has meticulously analyzed both oral and
documentary evidence and has taken a view which is not only
possible but also reasonable and plausible on the basis of the
record. It is a settled principle of law that in an appeal against
acquittal, interference is warranted only when the findings of the trial
Court are perverse, manifestly illegal or based on a complete
misappreciation of evidence. Mere possibility of a different view is
not a ground to overturn an order of acquittal.
17.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds no perversity,
illegality or misreading of evidence in the impugned judgment of
acquittal dated 16.10.2025. The prosecution having failed to
establish the essential ingredients of abetment as required under
Sections 107 and 306 of IPC, the acquittal of the accused does not
call for interference.
18.
Accordingly, the acquittal appeal being devoid of merit is liable to be
and is hereby dismissed.
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
Akhil
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review