Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE UDAY KUMAR
CRR 5059 OF 2025
CRR 5066 OF 2025
ARKA MOLLICK
-VSBIPASA SAHA NEE MOLLICK
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Moyukh Mukherjee
Ms. Sagnika Banerjee
Ms. Sanghamitra Middya
For the Opposite Party
: Mr. Apalok Basu
Mr. Soumava Mukherjee
Mr. Rishav Deb Barman
Reserved on
: 06.10.2026
Pronounced on
: 08.10.2026
UDAY KUMAR, J.: –
1.
These two revisional applications, being C.R.R. No. 5059 of 2025 and
C.R.R. No. 5066 of 2025, are taken up together for analogous hearing
and disposal, as they stem from an interconnected chain of matrimonial
discord and statutory maintenance proceedings initiated between the
same parties. By invoking the inherent jurisdiction of this Court under
Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (corresponding to
Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023), the
petitioner-husband seeks to assail the foundational ex parte interim
order of maintenance dated February 17, 2023 passed by the learned
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
9th Judicial Magistrate at Alipore in A.C. Case No. 3115 of 2022 under
the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (in short,
the "PWDV Act"), and setting aside of the order dated October 09, 2025
passed in execution proceedings arising out of Misc. Execution Case No.
489 of 2023.
2.
The factual matrix, as revealed from the materials on record and
canvassed by the learned counsel representing the contesting parties,
are; that the marriage between the petitioner, Sri Arka Mollick, and the
opposite party, Smt. Bipasa Saha @ Mollick, as an outcome of a love
affair, was solemnised on January 23, 2013 according to Hindu rites
and customs and was duly registered under the Hindu Marriage Act,
1955. The wedlock was blessed with two minor daughters, Hrutvi
Mollick, born on September 10, 2015, and Kiara Mollick, born on June
20, 2019. Unfortunately, marital harmony was short-lived, leading to
deep-seated estrangement between the parties. Consequently, in April
2021,
the
petitioner-husband
instituted
a
matrimonial
suit
for
dissolution of marriage, registered as T.S. (Div) No. 266 of 2021, which
was later transferred and re-numbered as Mat Suit No. 1248 of 2023
and is presently pending before the learned 7th Court of the learned
Additional
District
Judge
at
Alipore.
In
the
said
matrimonial
proceedings, upon an application filed by the wife/O.P. for maintenance
pendente lite, registered as Civil Misc. Case No. 31 of 2022, the learned
Additional Judge, Family Court, West Tripura, Agartala, upon taking
note of an admitted monthly salary of approximately ₹80,000/- of the
husband while recording that the wife had no independent source of
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
income, by an order dated April 25, 2022, directed the husband to pay
a monthly sum of ₹18,000/- as alimony pendente lite under Section 24
of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 exclusively in favour of the wife.
3.
Records further disclose that on June 16, 2022, the opposite party-wife
was ousted from the matrimonial domicile along with the two minor
daughters, after which she was constrained to take shelter at a rented
accommodation in Kolkata. Subsequently, on November 4, 2022, she
instituted a substantive proceeding under Section 12 of the PWDV Act,
giving rise to A.C. Case No. 3115 of 2022, now pending before the 9th
Court of the learned Judicial Magistrate at Alipore, levelling allegations
of domestic violence, cruelty, and misappropriation of stridhan against
the petitioner and his family members, claiming various monetary
reliefs, compensation, and maintenance for herself and the two minor
children. On January 4, 2023, the opposite party filed an application
under Section 23(2) of the PWDV Act accompanied by her statutory
affidavit of assets and liabilities, wherein she candidly disclosed the
existence of the prior interim order of maintenance passed by Tripura
Family Court on April 25, 2022.
4.
The learned Magistrate, Alipore, taking note of the urgency and the
educational requirements of the minor children, passed an ad interim
ex parte order on February 17, 2023 granting total monetary relief of
₹24,000/- per month, comprising ₹12,000/- for the wife and ₹6,000/each for the two minor daughters, while expressly stipulating that this
relief was "in excess of and in addition to" the order of maintenance
passed
by the Family Court, Tripura dated April 25, 2022, thereby
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
creating an unadjusted cumulative monthly burden of ₹42,000/-(Rs.
18,000/- + Rs. 24,000/-) on the petitioner.
5.
As a natural consequence of non-compliance, the opposite party-wife
initiated execution proceedings being Misc. Execution Case No. 489 of
2023 on July 19, 2023. The execution Court witnessed intense contest,
culminating in the order dated March 06, 2024 computing maintenance
arrears amounting to ₹2,56,000/- as on March, 2024 and the eventual
issuance of a warrant of arrest against the petitioner on October 04,
2024. The petitioner although challenged the warrant of arrest by filing
Criminal Appeal No. 265 of 2024 before the Sessions Court; and
ultimately secured a stay order (which is operating till date) and the
said appeal was disposed of on November 19, 2025, he did not prefer
any statutory appeal under Section 29 of the PWDV Act against the core
interim order of February 17, 2023 within the prescribed period of
limitation. Instead, on November 14, 2025, the petitioner filed an
application under Section 25(2) of the PWDV Act seeking modification
or revocation of the maintenance order on the ground of changed
circumstances, specifically pleading that he had been rendered
unemployed since April 2025 due to acute mental health issues,
depression, and severe loan liabilities running up to ₹1,80,00,000/-,
alongside residing in rented premises. It is imperative to note that in
the execution proceedings (Misc. Ex. Case No. 489 of 2023), the
executing Court, by the order dated October 09, 2025 had directed the
petitioner to pay a lumpsum amount of Rs. 50,000/- to the O.P.
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
6.
This was followed by the institution of the present criminal revisions on
November 20, 2025, after a lapse of nearly two years and nine months
from the foundational ex parte interim order of maintenance dated
February 17, 2023. It is also pertinent to note that subsequent to these
filings, the trial court passed an order on November 24, 2025 (in stark
contrast to the executing Court’s order dated October 09, 2025)
recording that no dues or outstanding amounts remained payable by
the petitioner for the specific period under review.
7.
Mr. Moyukh Mukherjee, learned Counsel appearing for the petitionerhusband has vehemently argued that the foundational interim order
dated February 17, 2023 passed in the DV proceedings is a nullity in
the eye of law and suffers from a grave jurisdictional error because the
learned Magistrate stacked obligation to pay an additional excess
amount of maintenance to the tune of ₹24,000/- on top of the preexisting order of maintenance to the tune of ₹18,000/- passed by the
Family Court, Tripura order without framing any working mechanism
for set-off or adjustment, thereby visiting the petitioner with an
oppressive double-recovery regime. Placing reliance on the landmark
pronouncements of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rajnesh v. Neha &
Anr., [(2021) 2 SCC 324] and Kiran Jyot Maini v. Anish Pramod Patel,
[[2024] 13 SCC 66], the petitioner contends that simultaneous execution
of overlapping maintenance awards without reconciliation is completely
impermissible. Learned Counsel further invokes the classical doctrine of
‘sublato fundamento cadit opus’, drawing support from State of Punjab
v. Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar & Ors. [(2011) 14 SCC 770] and Naresh
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
Kavarchand Khatri v. State of Gujarat & Anr. [(2008) 8 SCC 300] to urge
that once the foundational order is tainted by non-application of mind,
all consequential execution proceedings, warrants, and subsequent
orders must collapse automatically. Additionally, citing Mamta Jaiswal
v. Rajesh Jaiswal [2000 (3) MPLJ 100], it is argued that the opposite
party is a well-qualified person who cannot be permitted to sit idle as
an "army of idlers" when the husband himself is burdened with
financial collapse and unemployment. To overcome the bar of
alternative remedy, learned counsel relies upon Shaurabh Kumar
Tripathi v. Vidhi Rawal [2025 SCC OnLine SC 1158] and V. Krishnamma
& Ors. v. Garima Bais [2025 SCC OnLine SC 2935], to submit that where
a gross abuse of process or perversity is writ large, the petition under
Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. challenging the proceedings emanating from
Section 12(1) of the PWDV Act, instead of resorting to the appeal under
Section 29 of the PWDV Act, is maintainable.
8.
Per contra, Mr. Apalok Basu, learned counsel appearing for the opposite
party-wife has stoutly resisted the maintainability of these revisional
applications. It is submitted that the petitions are nothing but a thinly
veiled attempt to circumvent the statutory appellate forum provided
under Section 29 of the PWDV Act, suffering from an inordinate,
unexplained delay of nearly three years. The learned counsel points out
that
the
petitioner
has
actively
participated
in
the
execution
proceedings, made part-payments, and more importantly, consciously
invoked a parallel statutory remedy by filing an application under
Section 25(2) of the PWDV Act on November 14, 2025 seeking
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
modification of the said foundational ex parte order of maintenance
dated February 17, 2023. Learned counsel contended that a litigant
cannot be permitted to approbate and reprobate simultaneously by
prosecuting a modification application under Section 25(2) PWDV Act
while simultaneously maintaining a petition under Section 482 to
quash the very same order, invoking the bar illustrated in R.N. Gosain
v. Yashpal Dhir [(1992) 4 SCC 683]. On merits, it is argued that the
order of maintenance passed by the Tripura Family Court was granted
solely to the wife in a separate matrimonial proceeding initiated under
the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 whereas the foundational interim order
under the PWDV Act independently addresses the welfare, schooling,
and educational expenses of two growing minor children studying at a
premier institution like South Point School in Kolkata. Relying upon the
authoritative pronouncements of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Juveria
Abdul Majid Patni v. Atif Iqbal Mansoori & Anr. [(2014) 10 SCC 736] and
Prabha Tyagi v. Kamlesh Devi [(2022) 8 SCC 90], the opposite party
contends that a Magistrate is fully empowered under Section 23(2) of
the PWDV Act to grant ex parte interim monetary relief based on
affidavits to prevent destitution, and such welfare orders cannot be
lightly interfered with under the revisional jurisdiction of the High
Court.
9.
I have given my anxious and thoughtful consideration to the
submissions advanced across the bar, perused the pleadings, notes of
arguments, and carefully examined the judicial precedents cited and
relied on by both parties. The primary question that falls for
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
determination is whether the ex parte interim order dated February 17,
2023 and the subsequent execution proceedings warrant interference or
quashing under the inherent jurisdiction of this Court, or whether the
equities of the case are better subserved by harmonizing the parallel
proceedings through the established parameters of judicial set-off and
statutory modification.
10. However, before embarking on the said discussion, the objection of the
O.P. as to the maintainability of the present petitions under Section 482
CrPC / Section 528 BNSS in the face of an alternative statutory remedy
under Section 29 of the PWDV Act must be examined. I am mindful of
the principles enunciated by the Supreme Court in Shaurabh Kumar
Tripathi (supra). While the Apex Court has reiterated that the availability
of a statutory provision of appeal does not completely oust the
jurisdiction of the High Court under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C., the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has concurrently emphasized that High Courts
must exercise extreme circumspection and adopt a hands-off approach
unless a patent jurisdictional error, absolute nullity, or manifest abuse
of the process of court is clearly made out.
11. In the instant case, the foundational order dated February 17, 2023
was passed by the learned Magistrate in PWDV proceedings upon a
proper consideration of the Affidavit of Assets disclosing the order of
maintenance pendente lite passed in Tripura Family Court proceedings
initiated under Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. It (PWDV proceeding) was
not a proceeding initiated without jurisdiction or in defiance of
mandatory procedural prerequisites. Furthermore, the petitioner slept
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
over his appellate rights for nearly three years, actively participating in
execution, suffering warrants, and subsequently filing an application
under Section 25(2) of the PWDV Act. To now permit him to invoke
Section 482 Cr.P.C. simultaneously to wholesale quash a proceeding
instituted for the sustenance of minor children, after having elected to
seek modification under Section 25(2) PWDV Act, would run counter to
the orderly administration of justice. The reliance placed by the
petitioner on the doctrine of ‘sublato fundamento cadit opus’ is
misplaced, as the foundational order cannot be categorized as a nullity
ab initio so as to invalidate the entire structural superstructure of
execution.
12. However, the grievance of the petitioner regarding the stacking of
maintenance amounts without a mechanism for reconciliation touches
upon a vital principle of substantive fairness. Both parties have rightly
invoked the seminal guidelines laid down by the Supreme Court in
Rajnesh v. Neha (supra) and reiterated in Kiran Jyot Maini (supra). In
Rajnesh v. Neha (supra), the Hon’ble Apex Court categorically mandated
that where successive claims for maintenance are made under different
statutes, the applicant must make a full disclosure of prior proceedings,
and the court passing the subsequent order must consider an
adjustment or set-off of the amounts awarded in the previous
proceedings to avoid oppressive double recovery. The relevant excerpts
from Rajnesh v. Neha, at paragraph 128 of the report, worth bearing in
mind, are reproduced below:
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
“128. To overcome the issue of overlapping jurisdiction, and avoid
conflicting orders being passed in different proceedings, it has
become necessary to issue directions in this regard, so that there is
uniformity in the practice followed by the Family Courts/District
Courts/Magistrate Courts throughout the country. We direct that:
(i) Where successive claims for maintenance are made by a party
under different statutes, the court would consider an adjustment or
set-off, of the amount awarded in the previous proceeding(s), while
determining whether any further amount is to be awarded in the
subsequent proceeding.
(ii) It is made mandatory for the applicant to disclose the previous
proceeding and the orders passed therein, in the subsequent
proceeding.
(iii) If the order passed in the previous proceeding(s) requires any
modification or variation, it would be required to be done in the same
proceeding.”
13. In the present case, while the opposite party-wife discharged her initial
obligation of disclosing the prior existence of an order of maintenance
pendente lite passed by the Tripura Family Court, the learned
Magistrate, while granting the interim relief of ₹24,000/-, loosely
designated it as "in excess of and in addition to" the Tripura award
without spelling out an operational formula for credit and set-off. This
lacuna naturally generated friction at the execution stage in Misc.
Execution Case No. 489 of 2023. But as clarified by the Hon’ble
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
Supreme Court, the remedy against such overlapping execution is not
the wholesale quashing of the welfare proceeding under Section 482
Cr.P.C., but rather the strict judicial enforcement of adjustment and
set-off for any overlapping periods. The executing court cannot be
permitted to execute duplicate or double claims for identical months
where
payments
have
already
been
tendered
under
the
prior
matrimonial proceeding.
14. As regards the petitioner's reliance on Rajesh Jaiswal (supra) to contend
that the wife is sitting idle, the said principle is clearly distinguishable
on facts. In Rajesh Jaiswal (supra), the wife was independently qualified
and deliberately chose not to work solely to burden the husband. Here,
the opposite party is an estranged mother who has the actual physical
custody and day-to-day responsibility of nurturing two minor daughters
who are growing up and attending school in Kolkata. The educational
and sustenance needs of minor children stand on a completely different
pedestal from mere spousal maintenance, and the welfare of the
children must remain the paramount consideration of the court,
overriding technical objections.
15. Furthermore,
the
petitioner
has
himself
invoked
the
statutory
mechanism under Section 25(2) of the PWDV Act on November 14,
2025, seeking a modification of the maintenance order on the ground of
subsequent changes in circumstances, citing his alleged recent
unemployment and financial distress since April 2025. It is a wellsettled principle that when a statute provides a specific and efficacious
remedy for modification of an interim or final order in light of altered
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
circumstances, the party must pursue that remedy before the original
forum rather than bypassing it through belated quashing petitions. The
trial court's subsequent recording on November 24, 2025 that no
arrears
remained
outstanding
for
the
relevant
tranche
further
demonstrates that the executing court is fully equipped to handle
calculations of set-off and payment compliance.
16. In light of the aforesaid detailed discussion, balancing the paramount
welfare of the minor children against the imperative need to prevent
double recovery and ensure financial fairness, I am of the considered
view that the prayers for quashing the main PWDV proceeding, setting
aside of the foundational interim order dated February 17, 2023 as well
as the order of the Execution Court dated October 09, 2025 cannot be
sustained. However, the mechanics of execution and the operation of
the interim order must be structured in strict compliance with the
mandate of Rajnesh v. Neha (supra).
17. Accordingly, C.R.R. No. 5059 of 2025 and C.R.R. No. 5066 of 2025
are disposed of with the following specific directions:
I.
The ex parte ad interim maintenance order dated February
17, 2023 passed in A.C. Case No. 3115 of 2022 shall remain
operative, but its implementation shall be strictly subject to
the principle of adjustment and set-off as laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rajnesh v. Neha (supra).
II.
Any amount paid, deposited, or remitted by the petitionerhusband pursuant to the maintenance orders passed by the
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
Family Court or competent court in Tripura (under Section
24 of the Hindu Marriage Act) for the corresponding
overlapping period shall be given full credit and set off
against the total monthly maintenance awarded under the
PWDV Act. The opposite party-wife shall not be permitted to
execute duplicate or double recovery for identical months.
III.
The learned Executing Court shall re-verify and re-calculate
the computation of arrears in Misc. Execution Case No. 489
of 2023 in light of the aforesaid adjustments and recent trial
court records (including the order dated November 24, 2025),
and any genuine, reconciled arrears shall be cleared by the
petitioner in structured, manageable instalments as may be
fixed by the Executing Court.
IV.
The petitioner's pending application filed under Section 25(2)
of the PWDV Act on November 14, 2025, seeking modification
or revocation of the maintenance order on the ground of
subsequent unemployment and financial hardship, shall be
taken up, considered, and adjudicated upon by the learned
Magistrate independently on its own merits, uninfluenced by
any observations made herein, within a period of eight weeks
from the date of communication of this order.
V.
The 9th Court of learned Judicial Magistrate, at Alipore, is
requested to expedite the final hearing and disposal of A.C.
Case No. 3115 of 2022 as expeditiously as possible, without
granting unnecessary adjournments to either parties.
CRR 5059 OF 2025
& CRR 5066 OF 2025
18. Connected pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of
accordingly.
19. There shall be no order as to costs.
20. Let a copy of this judgment along with the Trial Court Records (T.C.R.)
be transmitted down to the learned Trial Court forthwith for necessary
compliance and execution.
21. Case diary, be returned to the Learned Counsel for the State.
22. Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance with all requisite formalities.
(Uday Kumar, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review