Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MLHC:24
Serial No. 02
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 433 of 2024
Date of Decision :30.01.2026
1. Smti Arjuma Begum,
W/o Shri Rajiul Islam,
R/o Village Haripur,
P.O Haripur, P.S. Rajabala,
District- West Garo Hills, Meghalaya
2. Smti Hashan Zarin Afrin,
D/o Shri Golam Hashan,
R/o Village Haripur,
P.O Haripur, P.S. Rajabala,
District- West Garo Hills, Meghalaya
… Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. State of Meghalaya represented by
The Commissioner & Secretary to the
Government of Meghalaya,
Community & Rural Development Department,
Shillong, Meghalaya
2. The Mission Director,
State Rural Employment Society (SRES)
Shillong, Meghalaya.
3. The Deputy Commissioner & District Programme Coordinator,
(MGNREGS), West Gato Hills, Tura
4. The Project Director,
District Rural Development Agency, (DRDA), Tura
West Garo Hills, Meghalaya
5. The Block Development Officer, (BDO) & Programme Officer,
(MGNREGS), Selsella C&RD Block,
West Garo Hills, Meghalaya
2026:MLHC:24
6. Smti Muslima Begum,
W/o Shri Saminul Islam, elected president
candidate of Haripur VEC,
R/o Village Haripur,
P.O Haripur, P.S. Rajabala,
District- West Garo Hills, Meghalaya
7. Smti Rajina Sultana,
W/o Shri Lalbahadur Islam, elected president
candidate of Haripur VEC,
R/o Village Haripur,
P.O Haripur, P.S. Rajabala,
District- West Garo Hills, Meghalaya
… Respondent(s)
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S.K. Hassan, Adv.
Mr. S. Chanda, Adv.
Ms. M. Rahman, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, Addl. Sr. GA
Ms. S. Laloo, GA (For R 1-5)
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv. with
Mr. R. Pahsyntiew, Adv. (For R 6&7)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
2026:MLHC:24
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The writ petitioners are before this Court with a prayer to set aside
the election and the results dated 15.11.2024 of the Haripur VEC, with a further
prayer that the respondent No. 5, conduct a detailed enquiry and verification of
Job card holders to ensure free and fair elections. The grievance of the writ
petitioners, is that in spite of a detailed complaint dated 25.10.2024, wherein
details of anomalies in the Job cards of Haripur VEC were provided, the
respondent No. 5, without conducting Job card verification, had issued an order
dated 28.10.2024, declaring for the elections to be held to the Haripur VEC on
15.11.2024.
2.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. S.K. Hassan,
learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that the office of the respondent
No. 5, without preparation of any electoral roll, had issued the order dated
28.10.2024, scheduling the elections on 15.11.2024, which prompted the
petitioners to file RTI queries on 04.11.2024 for furnishing documents
pertaining to the list of Job card holders of Haripur VEC. It is further submitted
that in spite of the complaints, the elections were conducted on 15.11.2024, and
the petitioners who had contested for the post of President and Secretary
respectively, were unsuccessful due to the unfair malpractice and anomalies.
The learned Senior counsel submits that the election therefore, not being
2026:MLHC:24
transparent and fair, has caused serious prejudice to the petitioners and other Job
card holders.
3.
To buttress his submissions, the learned Senior counsel has
submitted that 9(nine) numbers of shifted Job card holders were allowed to cast
their votes illegally, despite serious objections being raised. Similarly, he
submits 17(seventeen) numbers of Dual Job card holders were also allowed to
cast their votes, and further 3(three) numbers of proxy votes were also cast.
Added to these irregularities he submits, as the polling was not completed on
time, the officer-in-charge of the elections had issued 12(twelve) number of
tokens to the Job card holders or voters to cast their votes, but however when
these token holders sought to cast their votes, they were not allowed to cast the
same. In view of these illegalities he submits, the petitioners had filed a
complaint on 19.11.2024, which however, was never addressed. He submits that
the entire elections being vitiated by these instances, directions may be issued to
set aside the election and the results of Haripur VEC, conducted on 15.11.2024.
4.
Mr. A. Kumar, learned AG assisted by Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang,
learned Addl. Sr. GA for the respondents Nos. 1 to 5, in reply has submitted that
the elections on 15.11.2024, was held after all due measures and steps had been
taken to ensure that only eligible and qualified persons were enrolled as voters
for the Haripur VEC election, and that the writ petitioners, are the unsuccessful
candidates who had contested for the post of President and Secretary of the VEC
2026:MLHC:24
and lost by margins of over 100 votes. It is submitted by the learned AG that the
office of the respondent No. 5, had on 16.10.2024 issued orders for Aadhar
seeding along with directions to the concerned Gram Sevaks/Sevikas and Data
Entry Operators, to hold the Aadhar campaign, conduct spot verification and
entry into the Management Information System, of Job card holders who did not
respond for Aadhar seeding, or deletion in cases of Dual Job cards/Death/Shifted
Job card holders. Further he submits, by order dated 17.10.2024, the deputed
officials were directed to conduct the Job card verification of Haripur VEC and
to submit a report at the earliest, which was accordingly submitted on
28.10.2024, confirming that in accordance with the orders, the Job card
verification had been conducted on 23.10.2024 and 24.10.2024. It is submitted
that during the process, it was found that 28(twenty-eight) Job cards holders had
expired and 5(five) Job cards holders were Dual/Shifted Job cards holders, and
accordingly as per the guidelines, a total of 33(thirty-three) cards holders were
to be deleted from the Management Information System. Thus, he submits, the
list of eligible voters was prepared using the updated Job cards database. The
complaint filed by the Goanbura he submits, was looked into and given due
consideration, which upon examination however, did not warrant postponement
of the scheduled elections.
5.
It is also submitted that the writ petitioner No. 1, had contested the
election for the post of President of Haripur VEC against the respondent No. 6,
2026:MLHC:24
and lost by a margin of 105 votes. Similarly, the writ petitioner No. 2, who
contested for the post of Secretary against the respondent No. 7, lost by a wider
margin of 111 votes, out of a total of the 697 votes, which were cast. The
allegations made by the writ petitioners of proxy voting have also been denied,
and the elections he submits, were held strictly in terms of the conditions, laid
down wherein a Job card holder was to produce their original Job card at the
time of voting. It is also submitted that complaints as to the token system, which
was implemented as a practical measure to accommodate voters who could not
cast their votes during regular polling hours were also examined, but the said
complaint lack substantive materials, or evidence to suggest any procedural
lapse. The attendance sheet itself he submits, of the Haripur VEC elections
clearly and definitely reflect the names of the Job card holders, Job card numbers
and signature, or thumb impression of all the total 697 eligible voters, who were
present and had voted in the election. With regard to the complaint dated
19.11.2024, it is submitted by the learned AG that there is no record of such
complaint in the office of the respondent No. 5, but however, a letter signed by
77(seventy-seven) Job card holders rebutting the said complaint was received
on 20.11.2024, in the office. The learned AG then concludes by submitting that
there was no discrepancy or illegality in the conduct of the elections and that the
writ petition being devoid of merit, was liable to be dismissed.
2026:MLHC:24
6.
On behalf of the respondents Nos. 6 & 7, it has been submitted by
Mr. Philemon Nongbri learned counsel that, as there has been no elected VEC
since 2022, the Job card holders of the Village were deprived of their wages and
on their request the respondent No. 5, initiated the process for elections, which
was thereafter, followed by Job card verification which was conducted on the
date as scheduled i.e. 23.10.2024. The complaint dated 25.10.2024, allegedly
filed by the Goanbura it is submitted, is doubtful in nature as the same does not
bear the acknowledgment seal of the office of the respondent No. 5, and appears
to be a contrived document which has been created by the petitioners in
connivance with the Goanbura, after their loss in the elections. With regard to
the other allegations of an incorrect voters list, it has been submitted by the
learned counsel that after due verification of the Job cards, an updated database
of Job cards holders was prepared and used as a final electoral roll of voters for
the elections, which is reflected in the order dated 28.10.2024 at Para-9 (i)
thereof. Learned counsel submits that the allegations that no electoral roll was
prepared for the elections of Haripur VEC held on 15.11.2024, is factually
incorrect. It has been further submitted that the petitioners have not pleaded as
to how and in what manner, the alleged malpractice and anomalies had occurred
during the elections, nor have the petitioners produced, or provided any list
containing the full details of the alleged illegal voters who were allowed to cast
their votes. It has been further submitted that even assuming, if the casting of
2026:MLHC:24
votes by 9(nine) alleged Shifted Job card holders and 17(seventeen) numbers of
Dual Job cards holders is correct, the same cannot render the election of returned
candidates invalid, coupled with the fact that there is no knowledge in whose
favour the votes had been cast. He therefore, submits that the allegations of the
petitioners having no material effect on the results, whereby the respondents
Nos. 6 & 7, had won by wide margins, the writ petition is liable to be dismissed
with heavy cost.
7.
On hearing the learned counsel for the parties, from the submissions
and materials placed, the only issue in question it appears is with regard to
whether the verification of Job card holders was conducted at all and if so,
whether the same was irregular and not as per set procedure, which in turn could
have vitiated the elections to Haripur VEC. Shorn of other details, it can be seen
that the VEC of Haripur has not been constituted since 2022, in view of the tussle
in the Village by aspirants to office. It is noted from the materials placed on
record that in March, 2022, when elections had been ordered, the father of the
petitioner No. 2, had challenged the notice by way of WP (C) No. 75 of 2022,
and the election process was put on hold. Similarly, the petitioner No. 1, had
preferred WP (C) No. 151 of 2022, praying for conduct of elections. The said
two writ petitions along with another similar writ petition being WP(C) No. 84
of 2022, were disposed by this Court vide order dated 27.04.2022, whereby it
was directed that, after the matters concerning the Haripur VEC on the question
2026:MLHC:24
of bifurcation and others, on a decision being arrived at and orders passed, the
elections were to be announced and conducted. It is therefore, in this backdrop
that though as per the respondents, the entire process has been completed and
elections held, the same has been put to challenge by the petitioners who
admittedly, were unsuccessful in the said elections.
8.
From the materials it can be seen that the process had been initiated
for Job cards verification for Haripur VEC vide order dated 17.10.2024, and the
verification was conducted on 24.10.2024, with the verification report being
submitted on 28.10.2024. Before proceeding further, it may be noted herein that
with regard to the report dated 28.10.2024, which is annexed at Annexure-R-3
to the affidavit of the respondent No. 5, certain doubts had been raised by the
petitioners alleging that the same report dated 28.10.2024, a copy which had
been obtained by them showed the date as 21.10.2024. This Court therefore, to
ascertain the correct picture by order dated 04.12.2025, had called for the records
and examined the same. On the records being produced, the said letter dated
28.10.2024, has been compared with the letter dated 21.10.2024, annexed by the
petitioners, and it is seen that the letter dated 21.10.2024 refers to a Job card
verification conducted on 16th & 17th October, 2024, whereas the letter dated
28.10.2024, is a report of Job cards verification conducted on 23 rd & 24th
October, 2024. Though the verification finds the same number of 33(thirtythree) Job card holders which need to be deleted, in the considered view of this
2026:MLHC:24
Court, the veracity of letter dated 21.10.2024, needs to be re-examined as the
same does not find place in the records produced, except for the original
verification report dated 28.10.2024. This has been explained by the State
respondents as a version not intended for submission and contains a clerical error
as the verification itself had not yet commenced on 21.10.2024. This aspect
however, will not have any impact on the results of the elections, wherein 697
Job card holders had voted in view of the fact, that the margin of victory obtained
by the respondents Nos. 6 & 7, exceeds the number of Job cards holders alleged
by the petitioners to be doubtful. However, on the discrepancy of dates, it is left
to the authorities to examine and take appropriate action on the same, if
necessary.
9.
From the original records itself, what can be discerned is that the
elections were held after a verification process had been initiated and further,
from the other materials present and also evidenced by the rejoinder affidavit of
the writ petitioners, the complaint dated 19.11.2024, was never submitted
personally, but alleged to have been filed through Speed Post, however, without
any material to show that the complaint had been lodged at all before the
respondent No. 5.
10.
In the totality and circumstances therefore, without dwelling into
the other details, and also in consideration of the settled legal position that
election of returned candidate should not normally be set aside unless there are
2026:MLHC:24
compelling and ironclad reasons to do so, moreover, with the doubtful votes not
having any material effect on the outcome of the results i.e. the election of
respondents Nos. 6 & 7 as President and Secretary respectively of Haripur VEC,
this writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
11.
Records to be returned back immediately.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
30.01.2026
“V. Lyndem- PS”
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2026.01.30 17:25:50 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review