Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3514 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE FOURTH DAY OF AUGUST
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
SMT
THE HONOURABLE
COMMERCIAL COU RT APPEAL Nos: 44 and 45 OF 2026
COMMERCIAL CO URT APPEAL NO: 44 OF 2026
Appeal filed under Section 1 3 of the Commercial Courts Act, 20'1 5 read with
Order XLlll Rule 1(r) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 aggrieved by the Order
daled 21.07 .2026 passed in l.A. No 717 of 2026 in C O.S.NO. 52 of 2026 on the file
of the Court of the Special Court in the cadre of District, Judge for Trial and Disposal
of Commercial Disputes, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar.
Between:
1. Arionrx Al Private Limited, a company tncorporated under the Companies Act,
2013, having rts registered office at B-2-12011131314F , 3rd Floor' Sanali lnfo
Park, Block A, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad, Telangana - 500 034. also at 12th
Floor, Sohini Tech Park, Nanakramguda, Financial District, Gachihowli
Telangana, represented by its Authorised Signatory/Drrector. Sri Avinash
G upta
2. Arionix lnc., a corporation incorporated under the laws of the United States of
America, having its registered office at 1 100 Cornwall Road, Suite 136,
I\rlonmouth Junction, New Jersey 08852, USA, represented by its Authorised
S ig natory.
3. Sreedhar Narayanan, S/o. Krishnaswamy N, aged about 54 years, Occ.
Partnei, Precision Technologies Corp. / Precision Tech Global lT Solutions
LLP and Co-Founder and CEO, Arionix lnc., R/o. 12th Floor. Sohini Tech
Park. Nanakramguda. Hyderabad - 500 032, Telangana.
...Appellants/RespondenUDefendant Nos. 1,2 and 9
AND
'1 Wexa lnc., a company incorporated under the laws of the State of Delaware,
United States of America, having rts office at 2261 lltarket Street, Suite 86018,
San Francisco, California, USA, represented by its Co-Founder and CEO A/1r.
Naga Kiran Pasavedala (Plarntiff No. 1 / Petitioner No. 1 in the Court below)
V sronwexa SoJtware Prjvate Limited, a company rncorporated under the
Comoan e: A,.r 2013 having its registered office at H. No. 6-135/2/5RK/18,
SRK Green park Bowrampet, K.V Rangareddy, Telangana 500 043.
Naga Kiran Pasavedala. (Plaintiff No 2 /
reoresented by rts D rector
below)
Petitroner No 2 rn the Court
[/r
-
Respo nd enUPetitioners/Pla intiffs Nos. 1 and Z
Oentellr Sorutrons Prrvate Limited having its registered office at 4th Floor, Unit
2-B Salarpunu Sattva Knowledge City, OCTAVE Block, Opposite ln orbit
l\/ati t\/ladhapur Hyderabad, Telangana 500 081, represented by its
Director
B
eentelli LLC havrng its office at 14241 Dallas Parkvray, Suite 540, Dallas,
Texas _ 75254 USA, represented by its President.
precision Tech Global lT Solutions LLP, having its registered office at 8-2i2ot113t3l4F Sanali lnfo Park' Block A, 3rd Floor, Road No. 2, Banjara Hills,
Hyderabad Telangana - 500 034, represented by its Partner'
precisron Technologies Corp, having its office at 1100 Cornwall Road. Suite
134 lr,{onmouth Junctron, New Jersey 08852, USA, represented by its
Director
lVls Deepal Sontakke (also known as Deepali Sontakke Khadakban), Wo.
Khadakban Occ Chief Executive Officer Precision
lvlr Charudatta
(,orp
l2lh Floor, Sohini Tech Park, Nanakramguda,
Technoloqres
Hyoerabal lelargana- 500 032 '
Mr Santav Jut,udr Occ President, Qentelli LLC and Director, Qentelli
SolLrtrons Prrvatc Lrmtted. 14241 Dallas Parkway, Suite 540, Dallas, Texas 75254. IJSA. also at 4th Floor. Unrt 2-8, Salarpuria Sattva Knowledge City,
OCTAVE Block, Opposite lnorbit I\,4all, Madhapur. Raidurgam, Hyderabad -
500 081. Telangana
... Respondents/Respondents/Defendants
Nos. 3 to g
Nos
to
are
formal
and
rrot necessary parties)
(Respondent
l.A. NO: 1 O F 2026
Petition under Order XLlll Rule 2 R/w order XLI Rule 3 and Section 151 CPC
'1
908 praying that in the ciTcumstances stated in the affidavrt filed in support of the
cetition, the-High Court may be pleased to suspend the operation of the ex-parte adnterim injunciron order daled 21 07 -2026 passed tn l.A.No 717 oI 2026 n
l.O.S.No-52 of 2A26 on the file of the Special Court in the cadre of Drstricl Judge for
frial and Disposal of Cornmercial Disputes, Ranga Reddy Districl at L B Nagar
(lounsel for the Appellants : Sri Purnima Singh
Oounsel for the Respondents : -
COMMERCIAL COURT APPEAL NO: 45 OF 2026
Appeal filed under Section 13 of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 read with
Order XLlll Rule 1(r) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 aggrieved by the Order
daled 21 .07.2026 passed in l.A. No. 718 ol 2026 in C O.S NO 52 of 2026 on the file
of the Court of the Special Court in the cadre of District, Judge for Trial and Disposal
of Commercial Disputes, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar.
Between:
1. Arionix Al Private Limited, a company incorporated under the Companies Act,
2013, having its registered office at 8-2-12011131314F , 3rd Floor, Sanali lnfo
Park, Block A, Banlara Hills, Hyderabad, Telangana - 500 034 also at 12th
Floor, Sohini Tech Park, Nanakramguda, Financial Drstrrct, Gachihowli.
Telangana, represented by its Authorised Signatory/Director. Sri Avinash
Gupta
2. Arionix lnc , a corporation incorporated under the laws of the United States of
America, having rts registered office at 1100 Cornwall Road, Suite 136,
l\r]onmouth Junction, New Jersey 08852, USA, represented by its Authorised
Signatory.
3. Sreedhar Narayanan, S/o. Krishnaswamy N, aged about 54 years, Occ.
Partner, Precision Technologies Corp. / Precision Tech Global lT Solutions
LLP and Co-Founder and CEO, Arionix lnc., R/o. 12th Floor. Sohini Tech
Park. Nanakramguda. Hyderabad - 500 032, Telangana.
...Appellants/RespondenUDefendant Nos. 1,2 and 9
AND
1. Wexa lnc., a company incorporated under the laws of the State of Delaware,
United States of America, having its office at 2261 Markel Street, Suite 86018,
San Francisco, California, USA, represented by its Co-Founder and CEO Mr.
.1
Naga Kiran Pasavedala. (Plaintiff No 1 / Petitioner No. in the Court below)
2. Visionwexa Software Private Llmited, a company incorporated under the
Companies Act, 2013, having its registered office at H. No. 6 135/2/SRK/18,
SRK Green Park, Bowrampet, K.V. Rangareddy, Telangana - 500 043,
represented by its Director [t4r. Naga Kiran Pasavedala. (Plaintiff No.2 /
Petitioner No.2 in the Court below)
RespondenUPetitioners/Plaintiffs Nos. 1 and 2
3 Qentelli Solutrons Private Limited, having its registered office at 4th Floor, Unit
2-8, Salarpuria Sattva Knowledge City, OCTAVE Block, Opposite ln orbit
tr/all, Nladhapur, Hyderabad, Telangana - 500 081, represented by its
Director.
4. Qentellr LLC having ts offrce at 14241 Dallas parkway, Suite 540, Dallas.
fexas 75254 USA represented by its President
5. Precisron Tech Global lr Solutions LLp, having its regrstered office at g 2-
12011131314F Sanali lnfo Park, Block A, 3rd Floor, Road No. 2, Banlara Hills,
Hyderabad Telangana 500 034, represented by its partner
6. Precisron 1-echnologies corp, having its office at 1'100 cornwal Road, suite
134. A,4onmouth Junctron New Jersey 0gg52, USA, represented by its
Director
7. lVIs. Deepalr Sontakke. (atso known as Deepalr Sontakke Khadakban), Wo.
Mr. Charudatta Khadakban, Occ. Chief Execut ve Officer, precision
Technologres Corp., 12lh Fioor. Sohini Tech park, Nanakramguda,
Hyderabad Telangana - 500 032
8. I\/lr. Sanlay Jupudi. Occ. President, eentelli LLC and Director, eentelli
Solutions Prrvate Limited. 14241 Dallas parkway, Suite 540, Dallas, Texas _
75254, USA also at 4th Floor, Unit 2-B, Salarpurra Sattva Knowledge City,
OCTAVE Block, Opposite tnorbit Mall, IVadhapur, Raidurgam, Hydeiabad-_
500 081 Telangana
...Respondents/Respondents/Defendants Nos. 3 to g
(Respondent Nos. 3 to 8 are formal and not necessary parttes)
l-A. NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under order XLlll Rule 2 RAfu order xii Rule 5 Rly'V section i51 cpc
praying that in the crrcumstances stated in the affidavrt filed in support of the petition,
the High court may be pleased to suspend the operation of the ex-parte ad-interim
injunction order dated 21-A7 -2026 passed in lA No 718 of 2026 in C O S No 52 of
2026 on the file of the Special court in the cadre of District Judge for Trial and
Disposal of Commercial Disputes. Ranga Reddy District at L.B Nagar
Counsel for the Appellants : Sri. purnima Singh
Counsel for the Respondents : The Court made the following:
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
COMCA Nos.44 and 45 OF 2O 26
DATE: O4.08.2O26
Between:
Arionix AI l)rivatc Limrted and tu'o othcrs
Appellan ts
And
Wexa Inc. and seven others
Responden ls
Ms- Purnima Srngh, lcarned counscl appcar rng 1br Lhe appellants
COMMON JUDGMENT: (l'cr ilon'ble..lLLSticc N4oushumi ithattacharya)
L.
The prcsent Commcrcial Court Appcals havc bcen liled
challenging two orders datccl 2 I 07 .2026, passcd by the
Commercial Court at L.13. liagar in two Interlocutory
Applications (l.A.Nos.7t7 of 2026 and T.A.No.718 of 2026 in
C.O.S.No.52 of 2026), filcd by the rcspondent Nos.1 and
2/plaintiffs, which culmrnared rn thc impugned orders.
2.
The :rppellants :Lre Lhc delendant Nos. 1, 1l and 9 in the
SLrit (C.O.S.No.52 ol 2O2(>) filcd b,r, thc rcspondent Nos.1 and
2/plarntifls
3.
In tirc setirl Sr rit. thc plarntilfs have soug,ht for a r.vide
ranqc ol rclicis. t;rLnr:trrh Irt'rman.-rt irr-junctton restraining lhc
dr:lcndarrts fr-onr using, rcproducing, adapting, disclosing,
commercialisir'rg! rc\rerse cngrnecring, decompiling, circulating,
cxplorting or ('laiming an-r' right in the plaintifl's' proprietary
platlorm. ('on cxl ()raph 'l'cchnolog'r.,, SWARM/'SOAC technrcal
archiLeclurc. rlocLrmttn l ation, source code related materiai,
P:'ocltLcl ll('qui.emert I)ocumc.nLs (l,RDs), roadmaps, connector
framc'uork. r('sorrr('(' plans, pricing modcls erncl confidential
inlormation 'l'Irc plarnrrlfs hare also sought frrr pcrmancnt
in.junr:tion r-estrainin;3 Lhc clcfcnclants frorn inducing, soliciting,
en'rploling, engaging or al tcmpring ro engage , ;r in anr other
manner caLLSlnq, anr clnplovce , consultant or contractor of the
pl:rinLrffs' Lo lc:rr e Lhi' r'mplor mcnt or engagerncnt of the
plain trffs Lo lorn thc clcfcnd:rnts or anv of their affiliates or
asso( ra1( corrp,:lics. Lrr r iolat ron ol Lhc Ivlr.rtual Ncn l)isclosure
and (lon lidcn1 ia ltt\ Aqr('cmcn I cl:ttcd 30.07.2025.
4.
The plaintiffs further claim damages of Rs.1.00 Crore on
account of the defcndants' unlawful inducemcnt and
procurement of brcach of the employmcnt, conlidentiality,
intellectual property and other allicd contractual obligations
binding on the plaintiffs' employees and for the consequential
loss, injury, disruption ol busincss, crosion of goodwill, and
u'rongful commercial exploitation o[ the plaintiffs' proprietary
technolory, trade secrets and confidential information caused
I
herebv.
5.
The respondcnt Nos. 1 and 2/plainl.iffs lilcd I.A.Nos.717 of
2026 and I.A.No.718 ot 2026 in C.O.S.No.S2 of 2026 seeking
substantially lhe same relicls zrs those clarmcd in thc Suit, savc
and cxccpt that thc rclicfs sought wcre in the nature of
temporary injunctions.
(:;. By thc impugned ordcrs datcd 21,.O7 .2026, the
Commercial Court grantcd ex parle od inLenm in.junctions
1n
favour of the responder)L Nos.I and 2/plaintilts. 'l'he impugned
orders are operalive till 05.08.2026 i.e., tomorrow
7.
Learned counsel appearrng ior thc appcllants has placed
the factual outline of the appellants' case before us
8.
We nori: rh:rt [;orh thc impugned ordcrs de led 21.07.2026
srLlfer |rom thr. r ir:t' of be ing unreasonecl. The Commercial
Court ltas ntcrr:h reprodur:ed thc pra).crs ;nacle in the I.As
u'ithout indi,'atinq anr grounds or reasons es to $.hy the
Ccrrnmcrci;r1 (loL.Lrl considt'rccl ir neccssar.\.to grant ad inteim ex
parte in junctiorrs in thc plaintiffs' favour. FIowever, since the
rmltugncci rtrcer s rcnrain opcr:ttivc onlv tili tomor:o\:, wr_. clo not
r:onsidc'r ir nc,cr_'ssilrr 1o cx;tminc the two impu6lncd orclers or
c x[) r(]
ss itl\ o]lillrolt lhcrcof.
L
'l'he onl-r rczrson ,.r'h-r. rvc considcr it nccessary to engage
witir Lht' mi111ers is that ttrr'plaintiffs have filecl a subseqtrent l.A
unrlcr Orclcr XXXIX IluLc 2A of 'l'hc Codo OI Ci.,,il proceclure,
1908 ('CP(ll. sct'k jnq an ordr:r lrom the Comrnercral Court
holcling cci-iair: rcspon<lcnLs gr-l1tr of u.illul clisobccLencc of the
rrrdcrs claLcil ),1.O /.21)),o p:rsscrl b-r Lhc Commercial Court and
for dctention r,1'thc saLd rcsponclcnts in civrl prison on that
grouLnd.
10. Wc acc'orrlinsir rlccm it fit to disposc of thc present
Appeals bv drr,'ctrnq the Commcrcial Court to consider and
clrsposr: ol' I A \os. / I ,. :rnrl 718 of' ?-026 <.tn merits. as
cxpecliriousl-r :rs possilrlc ltrllcrabl-v u,ithin an outcr limtt
of 3
months, after affording an opportunity oi hearing to all the
parties. The Commercial Court shall not proceed with the
subsequent l.A filed by the ptaintiffs under Order XXXIX
Rule
2A of the CPC alleging clisobedience of the impugned orders
dated 21.07.2O26 until the Commercial Court hears
and
disposes of lA Nos.717 ot 2026 and 718 of 2026
The
CommercialCourtshallnotgrantadjournmentstoanyofthc
partles
11. COMCA Nos.44 and 45 <tl 2026, along with all connecled
applications, are accordingly disposed of in terms of the
above'
There shall be no order as to costs
It. is made clear Lhat wc have noL expresscd any
oplnlon
on the mcrits of the Appcals, savc and cxccpt' for noting
ttrat the
\2.
impugned orders do not disclose any reasons for
parle ad inteim rnjunctttlns
granting the ex
Sd/- K. S RINIVASA RAO
JOINT REGI
,TRUE COPY//
ECTION OFFICER
To,
a
J
DL
J u.dO-efor
The Special Court in the cadre of District'
C"r"r!i"rf Disputes' Ranga Reddy District at L
B Nagar'
One CC to SRl. Purnima Singh' Advocate [OPUC]
Two CD CoPies
.&
Trial and Disposal of
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0410812026
COMMON JUDGMENT
COMCA.Nos.44 & 45 of 2026
DISPOSING OF THE APPEALS
,.]\
/5
l-/ )rJ .I
s'l e lN
o
\.
e STATS o
0t, AUG 20-t
)_,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review