The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
28. 04.2025, issued by District Magistrate, Baramulla-respondent No.2, whereby the detenue, namely, Arif Ahmad Malla, has been placed under preventive detention so as to prevent him from indulging in the activities which are prejudicial to the maintenance of security of the UT of J&K. 2) In the petition, it has been contended that that the impugned order of detention has been passed on hyper technical and self-contradictory grounds. It has been further contended that the allegations mentioned in the grounds of detention have no relevance and the same are not based on HCP No. /2025 Page1of7 any specific details. It has been contended that the impugned order of detention has been passed in violation of the constitutional safeguards and the relevant provisions of J&K Public Safety Act, 1987. It has also been contended that the representation submitted by the detenue through his wife has not been considered. 3) The respondents, in their counter affidavit, have contended that the impugned order of detention has been passed after proper application of mind. It has been further contended that the grounds urged by the petition are legally misconceived and factually untenable. It has been contended that the activities of the detenue have been found prejudicial to the security of the State. It has been contended that the impugned detention order has been passed by the detaining authority val…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT
SRINAGAR
Reserved on: 20.07.2026
Pronounced on:31.07.2026
Uploaded on:
31.07.2026
Whether the operative part
or
full
judgment
is
pronounced:
Full
HCP No.114/2025
ARIF AHMAD MALLA
...PETITIONERS/APPELLANT(S)
Through: -
Mr. Gulzar Ahmad Bhat, Advocate.
Vs.
UT OF J&K AND OTHERS
Through: -
…RESPONDENT(S)
Mr. Hakeem Aman Ali, Dy. AG.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1)
The petitioner has challenged detention order bearing
No.06/DMB/PSA/2025
dated
28.04.2025,
issued
by
District Magistrate, Baramulla-respondent No.2, whereby
the detenue, namely, Arif Ahmad Malla, has been placed
under preventive detention so as to prevent him from
indulging in the activities which are prejudicial to the
maintenance of security of the UT of J&K.
2)
In the petition, it has been contended that that the
impugned order of detention has been
passed on hyper
technical and self-contradictory grounds. It has been further
contended that the allegations mentioned in the grounds of
detention have no relevance and the same are not based on
HCP No.
/2025
Page1of7
any specific details. It has been contended that the
impugned order of detention has been passed in violation of
the constitutional safeguards and the relevant provisions of
J&K Public Safety Act, 1987. It has also been contended that
the representation submitted by the detenue through his
wife has not been considered.
3)
The respondents, in their counter affidavit, have
contended that the impugned order of detention has been
passed after proper application of mind. It has been further
contended that the grounds urged by the petition are legally
misconceived
and
factually
untenable.
It
has
been
contended that the activities of the detenue have been found
prejudicial to the security of the State. It has been contended
that the impugned detention order has been passed by the
detaining authority validly and legally after carefully
examining the record/material. It is pleaded that the
detention order and grounds of detention along with the
material relied upon by the detaining authority were handed
over to the detenue and the same were read over and
explained to him. It has been further contended that the
detenue was informed that he can make a representation to
the government as well as to the detaining authority against
his detention. It is also averred in the reply affidavit that all
statutory requirements and constitutional guarantees have
HCP No.
/2025
Page2 of7
been fulfilled and complied with by the detaining authority.
The respondents have produced the detention record to lend
support to the stand taken in the counter affidavit.
4)
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused record of the cases including the detention record.
5)
Learned counsel for the petitioner, while seeking
quashment of the impugned order, projected various
grounds but his main thrust during the course of arguments
was on the ground that the grounds of detention are vague
and cryptic, which prevented him from making an effective
representation against his detention.
6)
Upon perusal of the detention record produced by
learned counsel for the respondents, the ground projected
regarding vagueness of the averments made in the grounds
of detention, appears to be forceful. In the grounds of
detention, it is mentioned that the detenue provided all
logistic support and assistance to the terrorist of LeT outfit.
It is also mentioned in the grounds of detention that the
detenue has maintained constant contact with active OGWs
of the LeT outfit and that he has facilitated the movement of
LeT terrorists within the Sopore area.
7)
In the grounds of detention, there is no mention of the
particulars of the places and the identity of the alleged
HCP No.
/2025
Page3 of7
terrorists, to whom the petitioner was providing logistic
support and assistance. There is no mention of the OGWs
of the LeT terrorist outfit with whom the petitioner was in
constant contact. The identity of
the terrorists whose
movement was being facilitated by the petitioner is also not
mentioned. The particulars of the period when the detenue
is alleged to have provided logistic support and assistance to
these terrorists, when he managed to establish contact with
OGWs and when he facilitated movement of terrorists, are
also not mentioned in the grounds of detention. Thus, the
grounds, being vague lacking in material particulars, the
detenue could not have made an effective representation
against his detention. Article 22(5) mandates that each
ground for detention must be individually specified and not
vague, ensuring transparency and accountability in the
detention process. The grounds must not be vague,
indefinite or general. Vague allegations make it impossible
for the detenu to understand the reasons and effectively
challenge the detention.
8)
A Division Bench of this Court in the recent case titled
“Imran Rashid Rather vs. UT of J&K” 2024 LiveLaw (JKL)
351 has, while deliberating upon the effect of vagueness of
the grounds of detention on the subjective satisfaction of the
detaining authority, observed as under:HCP No.
/2025
Page4 of7
“Therefore, this Court holds that vague and nonspecific grounds of detention firstly, violates the
fundamental right to life and personal liberty of the
detenue under article 21 of the constitution as it
summarily curtails the liberty of the citizen based on the
subjective satisfaction of the executive which is an
exceptional power as against the general law relating to
arrest and detention. Secondly, it deprives the detenue
of giving a specific rebuttal to the grounds of detention
which may satisfy the detaining authority or the
Government that his detention is unlawful and compels
him to answer the grounds of detention as "it is
incorrect" or "it is false" etc. Thirdly, vague and
generalised grounds in the order of detention, smacks
of arbitrariness on the part of the detaining authority
rendering the subjective satisfaction arrived at as
violative of article 14 of the constitution and fourthly,
vague and non-specific grounds raise the impression
that the same has been done deliberately in order to
deprive the detenu of giving a precise rebuttal. Malafide
in fact may be difficult to establish as they must be
pleaded with specific facts, but the lack of
bonafides 1State of Bihar Vs. P.P. Sharma,1992
Supp(1) SCC 222, paragraph 49 - State of Punjab Vs.
Gurdial Singh, (1980) 2 SCC 471, paragraph 9 -Pooja
Batra Vs. Union of India and others, (2009) 5 SCC 296,
paragraphs 18,40 and 41 may be presumed where the
executive act results in the deprivation of personal
liberty from a detention order based on vague grounds.
In such cases, the lack of bonafides is to be presumed
due to a cavalier or casual exercise of the authority to
detain the citizen without any specific ill will or
personal animosity. The lack of bonafides is on account
of failure to take due care and act without introspection,
blindly on the report of the SP without insisting on
supporting material which justifies the deprivation of
liberty.”
9)
From the above analysis of the law, it is manifest that
vagueness of grounds of detention strikes at the root of the
subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority thereby
vitiating the order of detention. Thus, the impugned order of
detention, in the instant case, cannot be sustained in law.
10)
It has been further contended by learned counsel for
the petitioner that the impugned order of detention has been
HCP No.
/2025
Page5 of7
passed on the basis of stale incidents having no proximate
link with the activities alleged to be prejudicial to the security
of the State.
11)
A perusal of the grounds of detention reveals that the
incidents referred therein pertain to the year 2018, that is
more than six years prior to the passing of impugned order
of detention. There is no reference to any recent incident
involving the petitioner in the grounds of detention. Thus, it
is clear that the order of detention has been based on past
and stale incidents.
12)
The Supreme Court in the case of Sama Aruna v. State
of Telengana and & anr, (2018) 12 SCC 150, while holding
that the incidents which are said to have taken place long
back, cannot form basis for being satisfied that the detenue
is going to engage in similar activities, observed as under:
“17. We are, therefore, satisfied that the aforesaid
detention order was passed on grounds which are stale
and which could not have been considered as relevant
for arriving at the subjective satisfaction that the detenu
must be detained. The detention order must be based
on a reasonable prognosis of the future behavior of a
person based on his past conduct in light of the
surrounding circumstances. The live and proximate
link that must exist between the past conduct of a
person and the imperative need to detain him must be
taken to have been snapped in this case. A detention
order which is founded on stale incidents, must be
regarded as an order of punishment for a crime, passed
without a trial, though purporting to be an order of
preventive detention. The essential concept of
preventive detention is that the detention of a person is
HCP No.
/2025
Page6 of7
not to punish him for something he has done but to
prevent him from doing it.”
From the aforesaid enunciation of the law on the
subject, it is clear that there has to be a live and proximate
link between the past conduct of the detenue and the
activities alleged to be prejudicial to the maintenance of
public order. In the instant case, the said link is completely
missing as the time between the order of detention and the
incidents referred to in the grounds of detention is far too
large to presume such a link. The impugned order of
detention, therefore, cannot be sustained.
13)
For the afore-stated reasons, the petition is allowed and
the impugned detention order is quashed. The respondents
are directed to release the petitioner from the preventive
custody forthwith, provided he is not required in connection
with any other case.
14)
The detention record be returned to learned counsel for
the respondents.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
Srinagar:
31.07.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the judgment is reportable: Yes/No
HCP No.
/2025
Page7 of7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review