The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. Challcnging the said order, the present Appeal is l'Lled. ri I l. Leamed counsel fbr the appellants contended that the land originallrv in Sy.No.370 ol Visrvanadhapally village belongs to thc grancltather o1' appellant No.i. rrho is thc panedar and possessor of the propcrt-v right tionr Khasra I'ahani till date. and that all the Revenue ftrcoltls cleallv erhibits that the originaI owrrer by narnc Yapuri Ar-rantha Ranraiah rvas irr posscssic'rn of thc pr-operly as pattedar, and that the said aspect clearll, indicates in tlre revcnue records and the said aspect is also cit.ecl b1' th.r leamed I rial Courr and no iniunction can be granted against tht oligirral on ner o l' thc lancl ll. l-e'arned counse'l fbr the appellants furthe'r contended that thc learned l-rial Court failed to appreciate that the land is situated in the Aecncy Area and one person by name Veera Reddy, who alleged to have purchased the property lionr another person and out of the said property Ac.l.00 gts is donatecl to thc respondent for construction ol-bus shelter in thc 1,ear [99-i and thc said land is situated in Agency Area and that the said Vecra Redd1, is not the pattedar ol the property and did not producc an1 salc deecl u,herelionr he purchased the property.
13. l-eamed counsel for the appellants further contended that rhe learned lrial Courl did not mark any documents hefbre passing the impugneC () order, which is contrary to the settled proposition of larv, and therefore, on the ground uf non-nrarkirrg of docurnc'nts has no evidentiary value unless it i:; nrarl<cd as c.rhibits, and on tiris gl'ound also, the inrpugncd order is liablc to be set aside. l-1. Irr suprport ol his contentions, learned counsel tbr the appellants rclicd uporr 1hc decisions in T.Bhopul Redd)' ond anollter Vs. K.R. Lokshtni Bui anl unuthart. Antitro A)'esho Vs. Model Conslructions, rep. h.r its ll[anaging Diret'bi. R.Parijilhtm und unother Vs. M.Kameshwari ani! otherst an<1 Mahoveer [nJbx,a1' Ltrt., IlJderabad and tnother Vs. Te ch Mi nft, Li. lnfo Solutions LLP, Hyderabatl tntl othersa On the other hand, lcarned Standir.rg Counsel appearing on behall ol ihe respondent-Corporation contended that the order passed by the leamed -['rial Cor.rrt is rveil reasoned order and do not call tbr any indulgence by ihis Court. Llorvevcr, when the appellants have tried to interfere with its pcacclui possession ol'the land, the Corporation had instituted the suit, and I that the leanrcd Trial Court, consideling the various issues and f-actual I position, granted injunction, which is legal and valid ' toosr r; .,rr.o lto 1ou; ' :c t-rr I1 AL. f i.t:1DBy 'lol7(5) ALD j48 (Du) …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY,THE EIGHTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 434 OF 2023
Appeal Under Order 43 Rule 1 of C.P.C against the Order made in
l.A.No.20 of 2023 in O.S.No.'16 of 2O23 on the file of the Agent to Government,
Khammam.
Between:
'1. Apuri Kotaiah, S /o. Late Anantha Ramaiah, aged 65 years, Occ. Agriculture,
R/o. Vutukuru Village Kameapalli t\4andal, Khammam District
2. Apuri Bhaskar Rao, S/o. Late Anantha Ramaiah, aged 75 years Occ.
Agriculture, R/o. Vutukuru Village Kameapalli Mandal, Khammam District
3. Apuri Ramesh @ Ravi, S/o. Bhaskar Rao, aged 46 years, Occ. agriculture
R/o. H No. 7 -3 -34713, G -2, Sai Ganesh Towers Vijaynagar Colony,
Khammam
...APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS
AND
TSRTC (The Then APSRTC), Established under Sec 3 of Road Transport
Corporation Act 1950 Having its head office at Musheerabad, Hyderabad Rep by its
Depot Manager (Estate Officer) by name Badisha Srinivasa Rao, S/0. Chenchulu.
Khammam
...RESPONDENT/PETITIONER/PLAINTIFF
|.A.NO. 2 0F 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
SUSPEND the operation of the Order clated 2410512023 passed in l.A. No. 20 of
2023 in O.S. No. '.6 ol 2023 passed by the court of the Agent to Government,
Khammam, pending disposal of main CIvlA.
Counsel for the Appellants : SRl. MUMMANENI SRINIVASA RAO
Counsel for the Respondent: SRI U.SHANTHI BHUSHAN RAO
(sc FoR TGSRTC )
The Court made the following: ORDER
tl
IN THE HIGH COUR'I FOR'THE STA'TE OF'TELANGANA
A'I'HYDE,RABAD.
TH[- HON'BLI! SRl.lt jS'tlCE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
(1.\1.A. No.{l{ of 202-l
I)ate of Orde r : 08-01 -2026
Betrveen:
l. Apuri Kotaiah,S,/o Late Anantha [{arnaiah
and two others
Appc.llants
And
I SR f('. the thcn \l'}SRT(
..". Respondenl.
JT]DGM[,NT:
Ileard Sri Mummaneni Srinivasa Rao. leamed coullsel tbl thr'
appellants and Sri U.Shanthi Rhushan Rao, learned Standing Counsel
appearing lbr the respondent
l.
The above Appeal is filed assailing the order dated 24.05.2021
passed in I.A.No.20 of 2023 in O.S.No. l6 01'2()23 on thc file of the Arrnt
to Cor ernrncnt. Khanrmanr granting ad intarin injunction in fai,our ol thc
rcspondent-Corporation against thc appellants/defendanrs rvith the
I
l
irrrssessioir alr(l u1;()vrrent oi'the respondent/plaintifl over the scireduled
iri()pefi! in lerm';,ri'Ordel l() Rule I of the Cocle of Civil Procedure.
-1.
l'he apgrcllrnts helcin arc the def-endants in the suit O.S.No.16 ol'
1023 f ilcd tr1' the lespondcrrt /plaintill lbr the relief of pennanent injunction
restraining the appcllants/de t'endants from interfering with the peaceful
possession and enioyurent of the respondent-Corporation over the suit
schedule propcrl\
1,.
Pending tlre suit, the rt'spondent flled I.A.No.20 of 2023 seeking ad
lr.!ter n Irlr.lnclrLrir
5.
It is the case of the rcspondent-Corporation that it is the owner and
pi-rsiessor ol' the suit schcdule property under an unregistered Giti
Setticrrent Dced datcd 2ti.09.199(r, uhich was given by one Sangabathula
Veera Reddy. Slo. R arnachandra Reddy tbr construction of bus shelter, and
since the' date o1' the gili deed, the respondent-Corporation \\'as tlt
posscssion and crrjoyment ol'the same. The Corporation constructed a bus
shelter b1' spending an amount of around Rs.5.24 lakhs and the same was
also inaugurated on I 1.08. 1998 and is being operated at Karepally X Road
bus station till thc month of January, 2023.
)
(')
6. It is the turther case of the respondent-Corporation that originally
thc donor Sangabathula Venkata Reddy had purchased the schedtrlc
propcfl) to an e\tent ol- .Ac.l.l I ll'ont the pattedar Surapurcddv Venkat
Reddy and
'[
hirupathi Rccldl on 28. 10.199] utrcler unregistered Sada Sale
deed and donatecl thc subject propeny an extent of Ac.l.00 on 28.09.19116
in l'avour of the ('orporation urrder unregistered qift settlenrent clecd.
1.
lL is the funher case of the respondent-Corporation that its donor has
perfect title and possession o!'c'r the subject pr'()pen)' and donated thc sanre
in Iavour olthe Corporation and as such, the Corporation constructcd a bus
shelter and in possession of the sub.iect propefty ever since 1999. When
the appellants/det'endants tried to occupy the schedule propefty otl
ll.0 I .2023 and demolished the shelter, the Corporation llled a complaint
vide F.l.li.No. I 6 o1'2023.
8.
It is the tirrther case ol'the appe llants/de l-endants that appellant No.1
herein filed O.S.No.10l of 2018 belore the Sub-l)ivisional Magistratc.
Nzfobilc ('ourt, Bhadrachalam against third parties i.e.
.fhulluri
Venkatesrvarlu and Surapureddy Venkat Recldy for grant of permanent
injunction clairning that the defendants therein ale no way concerned u,ith
the sclicdule propefty i.e. land in S1,.No.370 to an exrenl ol'Ac.3.02 gts ol
+
,
\':srt,anaclhirp:rlli rillage ol Singareni Mandal, Khanrrnarn District, and
latel the p.!i1i.s have tilcd conrprornisc rnerno dated 03.01.2022, according
to rrhich, tlrt ilctr:ndanLs thc-rcin arc no \\ay conccrned to thc suit schcdule
property ancl accordingly. O.S.No. l0l ol 2018 was decreed in favour of
appellant No.1 o1' on 2 I .0 I .1022 holding that the appellant No.l herein is
absolute ou'ncr and possessor ol'thc sub.iect land. It is also contended that
there is rro irus sration and that the Colporation itlegally dismantled the
i'encing and therelbre pleaded to dismiss the l.A.
9.
Basing on thc pleadinus and on considcration, the learned Trial
Court held that the land g,as donated in lavour of the respondentCorporalion and tendcrs r,' cre called fbr in 1990s for construction ofbus
-station and iacts are supported by otficiat documents produced by the
respondent-Corporation, and due to advantage olthe delunct bus station,
lurther issues u,ere started tbr filing ol'suit against third parties, obtaining
decree in tenlrs of'compromise and e.pass books basing on the decree. The
learned I'rial Coiut, believing the contentions ol the respondent(lorporation as wcli as on perusal of rccord, granted ad interim injunction
in tavour o1'the respondent-Corporation.
10. Challcnging the said order, the present Appeal is l'Lled.
ri
I
l.
Leamed counsel fbr the appellants contended that the land originallrv
in Sy.No.370 ol Visrvanadhapally village belongs to thc grancltather o1'
appellant No.i. rrho is thc panedar and possessor of the propcrt-v right
tionr Khasra I'ahani till date. and that all the Revenue ftrcoltls cleallv
erhibits that the originaI owrrer by narnc Yapuri Ar-rantha Ranraiah rvas irr
posscssic'rn of thc pr-operly as pattedar, and that the said aspect clearll,
indicates in tlre revcnue records and the said aspect is also cit.ecl b1' th.r
leamed I rial Courr and no iniunction can be granted against tht oligirral
on ner o l' thc lancl
ll.
l-e'arned counse'l fbr the appellants furthe'r contended that thc learned
l-rial Court failed to appreciate that the land is situated in the Aecncy Area
and one person by name Veera Reddy, who alleged to have purchased the
property lionr another person and out of the said property Ac.l.00 gts is
donatecl to thc respondent for construction ol-bus shelter in thc 1,ear [99-i
and thc said land is situated in Agency Area and that the said Vecra Redd1,
is not the pattedar ol the property and did not producc an1 salc deecl
u,herelionr he purchased the property.
13. l-eamed counsel for the appellants further contended that rhe learned
lrial Courl did not mark any documents hefbre passing the impugneC
()
order, which is contrary to the settled proposition of larv, and therefore, on
the ground uf non-nrarkirrg of docurnc'nts has no evidentiary value unless it
i:; nrarl<cd as c.rhibits, and on tiris gl'ound also, the inrpugncd order is liablc
to be set aside.
l-1. Irr suprport ol his contentions, learned counsel tbr the appellants
rclicd uporr 1hc decisions in T.Bhopul Redd)' ond anollter Vs. K.R.
Lokshtni Bui anl unuthart. Antitro A)'esho Vs. Model Conslructions, rep.
h.r its ll[anaging Diret'bi. R.Parijilhtm und unother Vs. M.Kameshwari
ani! otherst an<1 Mahoveer [nJbx,a1' Ltrt., IlJderabad and tnother Vs.
Te ch Mi nft,
Li.
lnfo Solutions LLP, Hyderabatl tntl othersa
On the other hand, lcarned Standir.rg Counsel appearing on behall ol
ihe respondent-Corporation contended that the order passed by the leamed
-['rial
Cor.rrt is rveil reasoned order and do not call tbr any indulgence by
ihis Court. Llorvevcr, when the appellants have tried to interfere with its
pcacclui possession ol'the land, the Corporation had instituted the suit, and
I
that the leanrcd Trial Court, consideling the various issues and f-actual
I
position, granted injunction, which is legal and valid
' toosr r; .,rr.o lto 1ou;
' :c t-rr I1 AL. f i.t:1DBy
'lol7(5) ALD j48 (Du)
lotT(i) AI-t) .l5 t (DB)
r
16. I have given lny earnest consideration to the contentions advanceti
on either side
l1
.
,A p.'rusal ol'thc record discloses that the learned frial ('ourt. thougir
basing on the evidcnce. alicr hearing both parties and on perusal ol the
documerrts. helcl that it is a lact that there was a bus station thrt existecl
u ith an old building. but it was defunct for the last several r,eals ancl iis
such, thc civil suit has been liled against the thircl parties h1 the lppcllarrt
No. i bclbrc thc' Sub-l)ivisional Magistrate, Mobile Court, tJhaih'achallnr
alleging that hc uas in pcaceful possession 01-the land accrucd fi-onr his
lather and that thc delendants therein are interlering with his possession of
land. and that onlr basing on the entries recorded, the said suit u,as liled
and the leatnccl Sutr-Divisional Magistrate, Ivlobile Court, Bhadrachalarn
has not qone into depth of the physical possessiorr olappcllant No. I as 1<r
r.r'hethcr il'therc \ras any crops raised and whether the alleged dcli'ndants
therein are disturhing the possession, but simply based on the conrprontisc.
decreed the su it
18. ln T.Bhopol Reddy (supra), the erstwhile High Coum of'Andhra
Pradesh rvhilc dealing with Order l3 CPC regarding marking of docurnent_s
in lnterlocutory Applications held that it is necessary that the docunrents
l,
adnrittcd in eviriencr- have to be rnarked in proper series and there is no
spccilic r--,rovisiou prohibiting thc satle. [t rvas further held that even
tirougir l{ulc i i-i ol'the Civil IluLcs ol l)ractice. I990 enr isages rnarking ol'
cxhibits adciuccd in evidence as 'A', 'B'. 'C'and'X'scries during trial.
thc sarne cannot bc construed so as to exclude the marking of any
tlocurncnt in an Intcrlocutory matter. [t was lurther hcld that the Court
lvhilc dcciding the Interlocutolv Applications r,,'ould decide thc prirna.fltcie
ease basingl on the allidavit but also on thc strcngth ol the documents
rl:rlketl th ercirr.
i9.
Adnrittedly, in the present case, no docurnents ha'ne been marked nor
ai.il il ilnc-ss i-ias been examined.
10. ln vier.., of thc settled position ol law, this Court deems it proper to
sei asidc tlrc order oated 24.05.2023 passcd in I.A.No.20 of 2023 ln
O.S.r.r-o. l6 o12023 on the flle olthe Agent to Govcmment. Khammam and
ic;rit tllr nri,ttcl back to the lcarned I'rial Court tbr lir'sh considcration
liici alfix'riirrg opporlunity to both sides. and that thc learrred Trial Court
shall endearour to expeditc hearing of'the suit and dispose olthe suit as
c:rpr'clitiorslv as possible, preferabll,' u'ithin a period of cight (08) u'eeks
Irorn the d;rtc ,,rl'ieccipt of a copy ol'this .iudgrnellt.
r
21. lt is needlc'ss to observe that til[ disposal olthe Inain sttit. the itrle-rii-'r
nrolcction sranted i'rv r irtu.' o1'tlte ordt-r 24.05.1023 passcd in I.A.No.lti
of l0ll in O.S.No. l6 rrf l0li shalI continue to operate.
tl
Subjcct to ahur c obse'rr ations and direction, C.M.A.No.4l4 ol20l-r
is dispose'd. Misce Ilarteous applications pending, if any shall stand closcd,
Therc shall be no ordcr as to costs.
SD/. T, KRISHNA KUMAR
JOINT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
ECTION OFFICER
To
The Agent to Government, Khammam
) One CC to Sri Mummaneni Srinivasa Rao, Advocate (OPUC)
J One CC to Sri U.Shanthi Bushan Rao, Advocate (OPUC)
Two CD Copies
Ks/PSL
!
HIGH COURT
DATED:0810112026
ORDER
CMA.No.434 of 2023
o
ilftB{m
O
*
Disposing of the C.M.A
Without costs.
()-
ilt
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review