Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
APHC010804712016
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL
NOs: 2446 of 2016 & 1180 of 2017
APSRTC
...Appellant
Vs.
Mavilla Sujeevana and others
...Respondent(s)
**********
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 11th August 2026
Present:
Advocate for claimants:
MADHAVA RAO NALLURI
Advocate for Respondent:
PENUMAKA VENKAT RAO
COMMON JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
Both these appeals are preferred under Section 173 of the
M.V.Act, assailing the very same judgment and decree dated
21.04.2016 in M.V.O.P. No.60 of 2014 on the file of learned
VI Additional District Judge, SPSR Nellore District.
2.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2446 of 2011 is preferred by APSRTC
(herein after, called as ‘Corporation’) and whereas M.A.C.M.A.
No.1180 of 2017 is preferred by claimants.
The Corporation
challenged the award both on liability as well as quantum of
Bench Sr.No:-29
[3584]
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.2446 of 2016 &
1180 of 2017
compensation. The claimants, on the other hand, are seeking
enhancement of compensation.
3.
For convenience sake, the parties will hereinafter be referred
to as they were arrayed before the Tribunal.
4.
(a)
in
MPPPS
Deceased was working as Secondary Grade Teacher
School,
East
Harijanawada,
Rebala
Village,
Buchireddypalem Mandal, SPSR Nellore District. On 15.01.2014,
the deceased, along with his friend, was proceeding on motorcycle
to attend the obsequies of his Junior Paternal Uncle, which was
performed at Badvelu, en route, on Nellore - Mumbai Highway,
near Sangam Village, at about 15.45 hours bus belonging to
respondent corporation driven by its driver dashed against
motorcycle, on account of which the deceased who was riding the
bike fell down and sustained severe injuries and died on the spot.
Friend of deceased also suffered injuries and he was shifted to
hospital for treatment.
(b)
The deceased stated to have been earning ₹40,000/- per
month, therefore, wife, two children and mother of deceased
preferred claim before the Tribunal claiming compensation of
₹40,00,000/-.
(c)
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.2446 of 2016 &
1180 of 2017
The respondent Corporation filed written statement denying
the liability, that the accident had occurred on account of rash and
negligent driving of the driver of offending bus. It was also pleaded
that the deceased was riding bike in rash and negligent manner at
high speed, though the driver of the bus tried to slow down the bus
and took extreme left side of the road, nevertheless, the bike
dashed into the bus, therefore, the rider of motorcycle alone was
responsible for causing the accident. Besides the avocation, age
and earnings of deceased were denied and disputed.
(d)
The tribunal framed following issues:
(1) Whether the accident occurred due to rash and negligent
driving of the driver of APSRTC bus bearing No.AP 29Z
0741?
(2) Whether the accident occurred due to the negligence of
driver of motor cycle bearing No.AP 26 AN 0648?
(3) Whether the rider of the motor cycle bearing No.AP 26AN
0648 is not possessing valid and effective driving licence
to drive the motorcycle?
(4) Whether the owner and insurer of the MotorCycle bearing
No.AP 26AN 0648 are proper and necessary parties to
the proceedings?
(5) Whether the claimants are entitled for compensation? If
so to what amount?
(6) To what relief?
(e)
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.2446 of 2016 &
1180 of 2017
Claimants examined P.W.1 to P.W.3 and marked Ex.A1 to
Ex.A6 and Ex.X1. For respondent Corporation, RW.1 was
examined and no documents were marked.
(f)
The Tribunal, on overall appreciation of evidence on record,
held that the driver of offending vehicle was responsible for
accident due to his negligence. Further, though corporation has set
up plea of contributory negligence attributable to the deceased
rider, due to lack of sufficient evidence, the same has been
repelled.
(g)
Based on Ex.A6 - salary certificate and Ex.X1, the Tribunal
has assessed income of deceased as ₹46,060/- per month. The
age of deceased was considered as 51 years, accordingly, applied
multiplier of 11. 1/4th of the income has been deducted towards
personal expenses. The Tribunal also awarded ₹1,00,000/towards consortium, ₹2,00,000/- towards loss of care and
guidance and ₹25,000/- towards funeral expenses. After deducting
10% of the earnings towards income tax, in total, Tribunal awarded
₹43,28,946/- as just and fair compensation, along with interest at
the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of petition till realisation.
(h)
Assailing the same, both the corporation as well as claimants
preferred respective appeals.
5.
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.2446 of 2016 &
1180 of 2017
Heard Sri Madhava Rao Nalluri, learned counsel for
claimants and Sri Penumaka Venkat Rao, learned counsel for
respondent Corporation.
6.
Learned counsel for Corporation contended that the findings
of Tribunal suffer from perversity on account of non-appreciation of
the evidence on record. Further, it is also contended that the
Tribunal has assessed income of deceased as ₹46,060/- per
month, which is also not supported by proper evidence. Therefore,
the compensation determined is on higher side.
7.
(a)
Per contra, learned counsel for claimants, while
supporting the impugned award to the extent of the findings with
regard to the dismissal of plea regarding the contributory
negligence, insofar as the findings and conclusions arrived at with
regard to the determination of compensation, it is contended that
the Tribunal erroneously considered the age of deceased as 51
and applied multiplier of 11. The Tribunal having referred to the age
of deceased as 50 years 6 months 14 days, ought to have
considered the age for the purpose of applying multiplier as 50,
following the ratio laid down in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport
Corporation1 and thereafter applied multiplier of 13.
(2009) 6 SCC 121
(b)
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.2446 of 2016 &
1180 of 2017
Further, the Tribunal also failed to award future prospects
and that in view of the judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in case of
National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi and
others2, the future prospects at the rate of 30% to be awarded,
having regard to the age and avocation of the deceased. Even with
regard to various components under the conventional heads, the
amounts awarded by Tribunal are also required to be revised in
tune with judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in Pranay Sethi’s case2.
(c)
Learned counsel for claimants further contended that the
Tribunal ought to have taken into consideration the income of
deceased as ₹55,690/-, as per the latest PRC, but not ₹46,060/-.
8.
We have considered submissions made by respective
counsels and also gone through the material on record.
9.
Now, the question that falls for consideration of this Court is:
1. Whether the order passed by the Tribunal suffers from patent
illegality or perversity in awarding compensation to the
claimants and, if so, what is the just and fair compensation to
be awarded?
2. To what relief?
(2017) 16 SCC 680
10.
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.2446 of 2016 &
1180 of 2017
The accident occurred on account of collision between the
motorcycle and bus belonging to the Corporation. The deceased
was riding the motorcycle, accompanied by his friend as pillion
rider, who was examined as P.W.2. As per the claim of claimants
and evidence of P.W.2, the bus coming in opposite direction
dashed against motorcycle. No doubt the accident occurred while
both the vehicles were crossing the curve. The evidence marked
on behalf of claimants by way of Ex.A1 – FIR and Ex.A5 - charge
sheet indicates that the accident had occurred on account of rash
and negligent driving by the driver of the bus, who was arrayed as
accused in the crime.
11.
Conversely, the Corporation pleaded that the driver of bus
slowed down the bus, nevertheless, the biker dashed into the bus,
therefore, negligence, if any, would be attributable only to the
deceased rider. To support the said version, the driver of bus was
examined as R.W.1. Except for his statement, no other evidence,
such as that of any of the passengers in the bus, was adduced to
support and corroborate the version of the driver of bus. Further,
as rightly found by the Tribunal, the respondent Corporation also
did not file any rough sketch to show that the bus had slowed down
and the driver had taken extreme left of the road. Since the plea of
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.2446 of 2016 &
1180 of 2017
contributory negligence was raised by the Corporation, it is for it to
prove the same. The Tribunal, on overall appreciation of the
evidence, ultimately found that the driver of bus was alone
negligent and responsible in causing the accident. We do not see
any infirmity with such finding, nor there is any cogent evidence for
us to come to any other conclusion.
12.
Now, coming to the aspect of income of deceased, the
Tribunal has considered the same as ₹46,060/- as per Ex.A6 and
Ex.X1. Ex.X1 is the service register of the deceased and Ex.A6 is
salary certificate. Though P.W.3, in her evidence, stated that the
salary of deceased after revised pay scales at relevant point of time
would be ₹55,690/-, the service register of the deceased marked
as Ex.X1 merely indicated that the deceased was earning
₹44,870/- as on 01.07.2013 and after effecting increment, the
same was revised to ₹46,060/-. The Tribunal, after analysing the
evidence on record, assessed aforesaid income. We have also
gone through the contents of Ex.A6 and Ex.X1 and as well as the
evidence of P.W.3. Except for the self-serving statement of P.W.3
that deceased would get salary of ₹55,690/-, there is nothing on
record to suggest the same, on contra, Ex.X1 and Ex.A6 clearly
demonstrate that deceased was drawing a salary of ₹46,060/-.
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.2446 of 2016 &
1180 of 2017
Thus, we sustain the income of the deceased as determined by the
Tribunal.
13.
Basing on the pay slip supported by Ex.X1 service register,
we arrived at the income of the deceased as ₹46,060/-. We haven’t
provided any deduction of income tax as per the pay slip, however,
are inclined to apply the deduction based on the relevant period
slab rate. Since deceased died on 15.01.2014, we consider it apt
to apply the tax rate as applicable for assessment year 2014-15
(Financial Year – 2013-14).
Income Tax Computation – Assessment Year 2014-2015
Financial Year 2013-2014
Monthly income
₹46,060.00
Annual income (₹29,752 × 12)
₹5,52,720.00
Tax Slab
Up to ₹2,00,000
₹2,00,000 to ₹5,00,000
Income above
₹5,00,000
14.
Rate
0%
10%
20%
Taxable
Amount
₹2,00,000.00
₹3,00,000.00
Tax
₹0.00
₹30,000.00
₹52,720.00
Total tax
₹10,544.00
₹40,544.00
The Tribunal, however, has not granted future prospects,
which we thus allow at the rate of 30%. The age of deceased was
considered as 51 years, which is improper, rather the age of
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.2446 of 2016 &
1180 of 2017
deceased would be 50 years, therefore, the proper multiplier would
be 13 for assessing the loss of income.
15.
Therefore, the compensation stands revised as under:
Compensation
Heads
Amount Awarded
Monthly Income
₹46,060/-
Yearly Income
₹5,52,720/-
Less – Income Tax
Future Prospects
(Age being 50 years)
Deduction (1/4)
Multiplier (13)
Loss of Income of
the deceased
Loss of Estate
Loss of Funeral
Expenses
Loss of Consortium
₹5,52,720/- - ₹40,544/- =
₹5,12,176/30% of ₹5,52,720/- =
₹1,65,816/₹6,77,992/- - ₹1,69,498/- =
₹5,08,494/₹5,08,494/- x 13 =
₹66,10,422/-
In accordance with
National Insurance Co.
Ltd v. Pranay Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC 680
Paras 37, 39, 41, 42 and
59.4
₹66,10,422/₹18,150/(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
₹18,150/(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
National Insurance Co.
Ltd v. Pranay Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC 680
Paras 37, 39, 41, 42 and
59.4
₹48,400/- x 4 = ₹1,93,600/(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
United Insurance
Co.Ltd. v. Satinder
Kaur
(2021) 11 SCC 780
Para 37.12
Rajwati alias Rajjo and
Ors v. United India
Insurance Company
Ltd. And Ors.
2022 SCC OnLine SC
Para 34
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.2446 of 2016 &
1180 of 2017
Sadhana Tomar & Ors.
Ashok Khushwaha &
Ors.
2025 SCC OnLine SC
Para 17
Total
16.
₹68,40,322/-
In the result, M.A.C.M.A. No.2446 of 2016 preferred by
respondent Corporation is dismissed and M.A.C.M.A. No.1180 of
2017 preferred by claimants is allowed in part in the following
terms:
i) The claimants are granted revised compensation of ₹68,40,322/as just and fair, with interest @ 7.5% per annum thereon from the
date of claim petition till realization;
ii) The entire revised compensation amount shall be distributed
equally among all the claimants.
iii) The Corporation is directed to deposit the amount as aforesaid
with
interest
and
costs,
adjusting
the
amount
already
deposited/paid, if any, before the Tribunal within one month.
iv) On such deposit being made, the claimants are entitled to
withdraw their respective shares as per the apportionment made
above. There shall be no order as to costs.
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.2446 of 2016 &
1180 of 2017
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending in this case, if
any, shall stand closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
SS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review