Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MACMA NO. 500 of 2022
VS,J.
APHC010628002022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
TUESDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 500/2022
Between:
1. APSRTC, BY ITS V.C AND MANAGING DIRECTOR, APSRTC, RTC
HOUSE, PANDIT NEHRU BUS STATION, VIJAYAWADA.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. GADIPINGI MURALI, S/O KRISHNA RAO @ KRISHNA, AGED ABOUT 47
YEARS, MASON, R/AT DOOR NO.1-120, SC STREET, LIVIRI VILLAGE,
BHAMINI MANDAL, SRIKAKULAM DISTRICT
2. BABULA NATH, S/O LATE PITAMBARANATH, AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS,
DRIVER OF APSRTC BUS BEARING NO. AP30-Z-0062, PALASA,
DEPOT, SRIKAKULAM DISTRICT,
R/AT PUTTURU VILLAGE,
MANDASA MANDAL, SIKAKULAM DISTRICT
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. K SRINIVASA PRASAD SC For APSRTC
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GORIPARTHI GOPINADH YADAV
The Court made the following:
MACMA NO. 500 of 2022
VS,J.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 500/2022
JUDGMENT:
1.
The Andhra Pradesh State Road Transport Corporation (for short
APSRTC) preferred the present Motor Accident Claims Miscellaneous Appeal
(for short MACMA) challenging the Order/Award and Decree passed by the
Chairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (for short MACT) –cum- I Additional
District Judge, Srikakulam in M.V.O.P.No.55 of 2020 dated 17.08.2022, wherein
the Tribunal has awarded an amount of Rs.13,80,190/- as against the claim of
Rs.20,00,000/-.
For the sake of convenience and to avoid confusion, the parties hereinafter
are referred to as they were arrayed before the Tribunal i.e., Appellant herein as
2nd respondent, 1st respondent herein as petitioner and 2nd respondent herein as
2nd respondent.
2.
The Petitioner being injured filed claim petition in M.V.O.P.No.55 of
2020 under section 153A & 166 of M.V Act, 1988 and Rule 455 of A.P Motor
Vehicles Rules, 1989 claiming compensation of Rs.20,00,000/- together with
interest and costs for the injuries sustained by him in an accident.
3.
Brief averments of the claim petition in MVOP No.55 of 2020 are
that: the petitioner was hale and healthy, aged 45 years, doing mason work and
used to earn not less than Rs.15,000/- per month.
MACMA NO. 500 of 2022
VS,J.
i.
While so, on 25.05.2019, the petitioner was taking his daughter - Gowri to
Narasannapeta Residential School for admission into Intermediate 1st year and
they reached RTC Complex at Tekkali at 10.00 a.m.,. Respondent No.1 who was
driver of the RTC Bus bearing No.AP 30 Z 0062, while taking the bus on to the
platform, drove the bus in a rash and negligent manner and dashed against the
petitioner. Petitioner sustained grievous injuries to his left foot and left knee and
other parts of the body, admitted in Area Hospital, Tekkali. The Station House
Officer, Tekkali Police Station, registered a case in crime No.123/2019 for the
offence punishable under section 338 of IPC against respondent No.1, after
investigation, charge sheet was filed against respondent No.1.
ii.
In view of fracture of both bones of left leg, petitioner was shifted to KIMS
Sai Seshadri Hospital, Srikakulam. He underwent surgery on 25.05.2019 and
then referred him to Apollo Hospital, Visakhapatnam on 26.05.2019, there also
he underwent operation on 26.05.2019 and 28.05.2019 and after a prolonged
treatment he was discharged on 10.06.2019. He spent Rs.1,00,000/- for the
surgeries. In the surgery steel rods were inserted in his left leg and for removal of
the said steel rods, he has to incur Rs.1,00,000/- again. He was advised to take
rest for six (06) months. He spent Rs.8,00,000/- for his treatment. He availed
male assistance by paying Rs.1,00,000/-. 1st respondent caused this accident in
the course of his employment under 2nd respondent and hence respondents No.1
and 2 are jointly and severally liable to pay compensation.
MACMA NO. 500 of 2022
VS,J.
4.
Respondent No.1 remained ex-parte.
5.
Respondent No.2 filed written statement, stating that the 1st
respondent is an expert driver with valid driving license and when respondent
No.1 stopped the bus in the platform, the petitioner tried to board the running bus
and fell down on the platform, as such the accident occurred due to the
petitioner's negligence only and hence he is not entitled to any compensation.
The police filed charge sheet without proper investigation, the claim is highly
excessive and the petitioner sustained simple injuries.
6.
Basing on the above pleadings, the Tribunal framed the following
issues for trial:1) Whether the petitioner sustained injuries in the motor vehicle accident
which occurred on 25.05.2019 at about 10.00 a.m., at RTC Complex,
Tekkali, Srikakulam District, due to the rash and negligent driving of the 1st
respondent being the driver of APSRTC Bus bearing No.AP 30 Z 0062?
2) Whether the petitioner is entitled for the compensation for the injuries
sustained by him in the accident, if so, to what amount and from whom??
3) To what relief?
7.
During trial, petitioner himself got examined as P.W.1, Dr.A.Siva
Pasada examined as P.W.2, Dr. A. Thaj Kumar examined as P.W.3. Dr.
Suneetha, G.Yelavarthi examined as PW4. (PWs 2 to 4 were examined through
Advocate Commissioner) and got marked Ex.A.1 – certified copy of F.I.R in
MACMA NO. 500 of 2022
VS,J.
Crime No.123/2019 of Tekkali police station, Ex.A.2 – certified copy of charge
sheet, Ex.A.3 – certified copy of wound certificate, Ex.A.4 – certified copy of
motor Vehicle Inspector report, Ex.A.5 – Discharge summary issued by KIMS
Hospital, Srikakulam, Ex.A.6 – Outpatient record issued by KIMS Hospital,
Srikakulam, Ex.A.7 – Lab reports issued by KIMS Hospital, Srikakulam, Ex.A.8 –
C.T Scan issued by Apollo Hospital, Visakhapatnam, Ex.A.9 – X-Ray report,
Ex.A.10 – Report issued by Anthology Department, Ex.A.11 – Discharge
Summary issued by Apollo Hospital, Visakhapatnam, Ex.A.12 – Disability
certificate issued by Area Hospital, Palakonda, Ex.A.13 – medical prescriptions
(6), Ex.A.14 – Bunch of medical bills (44) for Rs.6,28,730/-. Ex.A.15 – X-Rays
(27), Ex.X.1 – case sheet and Ex.X.2 – case sheet.
On behalf of the Respondents, 1st respondent himself got examined as
R.W.1 and no documents were marked for the respondents.
8.
Upon hearing learned Counsel for Petitioner as well as Respondents
and upon perusing the oral and documentary evidence placed on record, the
Tribunal awarded Rs.13,80,190/- as compensation to the Petitioner directing
respondent No.2 to deposit the compensation amount within two (02) months
from the date of order with costs and interest at 9% p.a on award amount.
9.
Being aggrieved by the said order and decree, the 2 nd Respondent –
APSRTC has preferred the present appeal on the ground that except P.W.1 –
MACMA NO. 500 of 2022
VS,J.
injured person, there is no independent eyewitness examined on behalf of P.W.1
to prove that there is negligence on the part of driver and in such case, the
Tribunal ought not to have believed the version of the claimant/injured. The
further contention of the appellant is that the injured tried to board moving bus
without waiting till the bus is brought to platform and fell down, as such he is also
equally responsible for the injuries sustained in the said accident. Hence, prayed
to allow the appeal by setting aside the Order/award and decree dated
17.08.2022 in MVOP No.55 of 2020 passed by the Chairman, MACT –cum- I
Additional District Judge, Srikakulam.
10.
Heard the learned counsel for appellant as well as the respondent
and perused the material available in record.
11.
Now the point for determination is:
Whether the Order/award passed by the Tribunal needs any interference?
12.
POINT: On perusal of the order/award passed by the Tribunal it can
be observed that P.W.1/injured got examined himself as P.W.1 who deposed that
he along with his daughter were going on extreme left side of the road at Tekkali
RTC bus stand, 1st respondent being driver of APSRTC bus bearing No.AP30 Z
0062 drove in a rash and negligent manner, with high speed, without blowing
horn and dashed the petitioner, while taking the bus on to the platform. Though
MACMA NO. 500 of 2022
VS,J.
there is no other independent eyewitness examined to prove that the claimant
sustained injuries because of the rash and negligent driving of the driver of
APSRTC bus, by relying upon Ex.A.1 – F.I.R, Ex.A.2 – charge sheet, filed
against Respondent No.1, the Tribunal held that Ex.A.1 and Ex.A.2 are sufficient
to prove that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of
Respondent No.1.
13.
As per the evidence of P.W.1, he was working as Mason and he was
earning Rs.15,000/- per month. In the absence of any evidence to prove the
occupation and earnings of the claimant, the Tribunal assessed the income of the
claimant as Rs.7,500/- per month, in view of the circular issued by the State
Legal Services Authority in connection with settlement of cases before the Lok
Adalath.
14.
To prove the injuries, he got marked Ex.A.3 - wound certificate,
Ex.A.5 - discharge summary issued by KIMS Hospital, Srikakulam, Ex.A.6 Outpatient record issued by KIMS Hospital, Srikakulam, Ex.A.7 - Lab reports
issued by KIMS Hospital, Srikakulam, Ex.A.8 - C.T Scan issued by Apollo
Hospital, Visakhapatnam, Ex.A.9 - X-ray report, Ex.A.10 - report issued by
Amathology department, Ex.A.11 - discharge summary issued by Apollo
Hospital, Visakhapatnam, Ex.A.12 - Disability certificate issued by Area Hospital,
Palakonda, Ex.A.13 - Medical prescription, Ex.A.14 - Bunch of medical bills for
MACMA NO. 500 of 2022
VS,J.
Rs.6,28,730/-, Ex.A.15 - X-Rays. To prove said documents, the claimant got
examined P.W.2, who deposed that on 25.05.2019 at 02.00 p.m., the petitioner
was admitted into KIMS Sai Seshadri Hospital, Srikakulam for fracture fibula left,
fracture calcanium left, crush injury, left leg and left ankle and left foot. Ex.X.1 is
the case sheet maintained by the KIMS Hospital, Srikakulam. P.W.2 stated that
the KIMS Hospital, Srikakulam issued final bill for Rs.38,971/- vide bill No.457
dated 25.05.2019.
15.
P.W.3 – Dr. A.Tajah Kumar, Orthopedic surgeon in Area Hospital,
Palakonda, deposed that their hospital issued Ex.A.12 - disability certificate and
assessed the disability as 45%.
16.
P.W.4 – Dr. Suneetha G.Velavarthi, deposed that the petitioner was
admitted in their hospital on 20.05.2019 and underwent two surgeries. She
advised the petitioner to take rest for six months. According to her, Ex.X.2 is the
case sheet maintained by the hospital. Ex.A.8 to Ex.A.11 and Ex.A.15 are the
bills issued by their hospital for a sum of Rs.3,87,469/-.
17.
Considering the age of the petitioner as 45 years as on the date of
the accident, the Tribunal has taken the monthly income of the petitioner as
Rs.7,500/-. Therefore, annual income would come to Rs.90,000/- (Rs.7,500 X
12). As the age of the claimant is 45 years as on the date of the accident, he is
entitled for an additional amount of 25% of his income towards his future
MACMA NO. 500 of 2022
VS,J.
prospects as held by the Apex Court in “National Insurance Company Vs.
Pranay Sethi 1 ”, as such the annual income of the claimant would come to
Rs.1,12,500/-. (Rs.90,000+22,500(90000X25/100)). Considering the age of the
claimant as 45 years as on the date of the accident, the appropriate multiplier
applicable is „14‟ as per the decision of the Hon‟ble Apex Court in “Sarla Verma
Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation2”. Considering the disability of 45% and after
applying the multiplier 14, the loss of future income would come to Rs.7,08,750/(Rs.1,12,500 X 14 x 45/100).
18.
In addition to the above, the Tribunal also awarded a sum of
Rs.1,50,000/- towards pain and suffering, Rs.25,000/- towards expenditure on
attendant and extra nourishment, Rs.25,000/- towards loss of amenities and
enjoyment, Rs.45,000/- (Rs.7,500 X 6) towards loss of income for 6 months and
Rs.4,26,440/- towards medical expenditure. In total, the Tribunal below awarded
Rs.13,80,190/- to the claimant.
19.
Considering the material available on record, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the amount of Rs.13,80,190/- awarded by the Tribunal to
the claimant, for the injuries sustained by the claimant, was on reasonable basis
and is sustainable under law, which needs no interference.
2018 ACJ 2782
2009 ACJ 1298
MACMA NO. 500 of 2022
VS,J.
20.
Accordingly,
Motor
Accident
Civil
Miscellaneous
Appeal
is
dismissed. No costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
__________________
JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
KS
Dated 10.03.2026.
MACMA NO. 500 of 2022
VS,J.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENTS CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO:500 /2022
DATED 10.03.2026
KS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review