Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
APHC010724182022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
MONDAY, THE SIXTEENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2/2023
ALONG WITH
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 310/2022
1.
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2/2023
Between:
1. APSRTC, REP. BY ITS VICE CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR,
BUS BHAVAN, VIJAYAWADA
2. APSRTC,, REP. BY ITS REGIONAL MANAGER, RTC COMPLEX,
ONGOLE, PRAKASAM DISTRICT.
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1. GADDAM VEERANJANEYULU, S/O CHINNAIAH, AGED 28 YEARS,
CHENNAREDDIPALLI
VILLAGE,
NASARAHEBPALLI
POST,
TARLUPADU MANDAL, PRAKASAM DISTRICT.
2. JAYAMPU ANJANEYULU, S/O KOTESWARA RAO, AGED 52 YEARS,
OCC RTC DRIVER, PEDAKANCHERLA VILLAGE, VINUKONDA
MANDAL,
...RESPONDENT(S):
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
2.
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 310/2022
Between:
1. GADDAM VEERANJANEYULU, S/O. CHINNAIAH, AGED 28 YEARS,
CHENNAREDDIPALLI
VILLAGE,
NASARAHEBPALLI
POST,
TARLUPADU MANDAL, PRAKASAM DISTRICT.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. AP STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION, REPRESENTED BY
ITS VICE CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR, OWNER OF THE
BUS AP 27 Z 0962, RTC BUS STAND COMPLEX, BUS BHAVAN,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
2. AP STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION, REPRESENTED BY
ITS REGIONAL MANAGER , REGIONAL OFFICE, RTC BUS STAND
COMPLEX, ONGOLE, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
3. JAYAMPU ANJANEYULU, S/O KOTESWARA RAO, AGED 52 YEARS,
KAMMA, DRIVER OF APSRTC BUS AP 27Z 0962, PEDA KANCHERLA
VILLAGE, VINUKONDA MANDAL, GUNTUR DISTRICT, CARE OF
DEPOT MANAGER, MARKAPUR DEPOT, MARKAPUR POST AND
TOWN, PRAKASAM DISTRICT
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. ARAVALA RAMA RAO(SC FOR APSRTC KKAC)
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. NUTHALAPATI KRISHNA MURTHY
The Court made the following:
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2/2023
ALONG WITH
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 310/2022
COMMON JUDGMENT:
1.
The Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal (for short MACMA)
No.2 of 2023 has been preferred by the Respondents No.1 and 2 i.e., Andhra
Pradesh State Road Transport Corporation (for short APSRTC), represented by
its Chairman, Bus Bhavan, Vijayada, Krishna District; and the A.P.S.R.T.C,
represented by its Regional Manager, Regional Office at RTC Bus Stand
Complex, Ongole, Prakasam District, challenging the Order and Decree dated
28.10.2021 in M.V.O.P.No.251 of 2018 passed by the Chairman, Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal (for short MACT) –cum- Principal District Judge, Prakasam
District at Ongole, awarding compensation of Rs.14,09,582/- as against the claim
of Rs.20,,00,000/-.
The MACMA No.310 of 2022 has been preferred by the appellant/injured
seeking enhancement of compensation in all aspects in different heads in case of
personal injury cases and marriage prospects of the appellant, being aggrieved
by the same order
For the sake of convenience and to avoid confusion, the parties hereinafter
are referred to as they were arrayed before the Tribunal i.e., AppellantsMACMA
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
No.2 of 2023 and Respondents No.1 and 2 in MACMA No.310 of 2022 as
Respondents No.1 and 2, Respondent No.1 in MACMA No.2 of 2023 and
appellant in MACMA No.310 of 2022as Petitioner and Respondent No.2 in
MACMA No.2 of 2023 and Respondent No.3 in MACMA No.310 of 2022 as
Respondent No.3
2.
The petitioner being injured (hereinafter referred to as the „injured‟),
filed MVOP No.251 of 2018 under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988,
claiming compensation of Rs.20,00,000/- for the injuries sustained by him in a
motor vehicle accident that occurred on 29.01.2018.
3.
The brief averments of the petition in MVOP No.251 of 2018 are that
- the petitioner as working as a coolie in the fields of one Pardhasaradhi of
Guntur and his father – Bapaiah stayed in the fields and Petitioner used to
provide milk and tiffin to the said Bapaiah.
i.
While so, on 29.01.2018 at about 06.00 a.m., as usual, the petitioner went
to the said Bapaiah to provide milk, which was collected from his village and after
returning from there on a motorcycle of his owner, when he reached an electric
transformer near the field of Chinthalacheruvu Venkataiah, the APSRTC bus
bearing No.AP 27Z 0962 came in opposite direction with a high speed in a rash
and negligent manner, on observing the high speed of the bus, the petitioner
stopped his motorcycle on the side of the road but the driver of the bus drove it in
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
a rash and negligent manner and dashed against the motorcycle, resultantly the
petitioner sustained severe injuries on right leg and fell down on the ground.
ii.
Immediately after the accident, the petitioner was shifted to Government
Hospital, Markapur, after first-aid, he was again shifted to Sai Bhaskar Hospital,
Guntur and again from there to Manipal Hospital, Vijayawada. As per advice of
their known persons, the petitioner returned from Vijayawada and joined at Sri
Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Hospital, Guntur, on 29.01.2018 night at
about 08.30 p.m. On 30.01.2018 operation was conducted and the right leg of
the petitioner was amputated above knee. The petitioner took treatment as inpatient from 29.01.2018 to 13.02.2018. The petitioner incurred expenditure to a
tune of Rs 2.00,000/- towards treatment, travelling and other expenses.
Thepetitioner got permanent disability due to the injuries sustained by him in the
accident.
iii.
The petitioner was hale and healthy prior to the accident and used to earn
more than Rs.300/- per day. After the accident, the petitioner is depending upon
others. Due to amputation of right leg, marriage prospectus of petitioner deprived
and he is in depression.
iv.
The accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the
bus who is 3rd respondent, the 1st respondent being the owner of the said bus;
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
and as the said bus plying in that region under the control of the 2ndrespondent;
all are jointly and severally liable to pay compensation to the petitioner.
4.
The 1st respondent filed written statement, denying the material
averments made in the petition, contending that the alleged accident did not
occur due to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the APSRTC bus bearing
No.AP 27Z 0962. The accident occurred solely due to negligent act of the
petitioner. In fact, the APSRTC bus was proceeding from Markapur to
Tadivariapili and during the course of journey after crossing Chennareddypalli
village at S-turning, the driver of the bus observed a motorcycle coming in
opposite direction with high speed in a rash and negligent manner, he slowed
down the bus, even then the petitioner hit the right side bumper of the bus in a
rash and negligent manner, fell down on the road and received injuries to his
right leg. The petition is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties i.e., owner and
insurer of the motorcycle which the petitioner was riding at the time of accident.
The claim of compensation is highly excessive and exorbitant. Hence, prayed for
dismissal of the petition.
5.
Respondents No.2 and 3 remained ex-parte.
6.
Basing on the above pleadings, the following issues have been
settledfor trial:-
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
1) Whether the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the
driver of the APSRTC bus bearing No.AP 272 09629
2) Whether the petitioner is entitled for compensation? If so, to what amount
and against whom?
3) To what relief?
7.
On behalf of the petitioner, P.W.1 to P.W.3 examined and Exs.A.1
to A.10 documents marked. On behalf of the respondents, 3rd respondent got
examined as R.W.1.
8.
Upon hearing both side counsel, upon perusing the oral and
documentary evidence placed on record by both parties, the Tribunal awarded
Rs.14,09,582/- towards compensation together with proportionate costs and
interest at 7.5% p.a, from the date of petition till the date of realization, directing
respondents No.1 to 3 jointly and severally to pay compensation amount within
three (03) months from the date of Order/Award.
9.
Being aggrieved by the said Order and decree, the 1st Respondent
being the Managing Director, APSRTC, Vijayawada, Krishna District, and 2nd
Respondent being Regional Manager, RTC Complex, Ongole, Prakasam District,
have preferred MACMA No. 2 of 2023, on the grounds that without any evidence,
the Tribunal considered the income of the injured as Rs.7,000/- per month which
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
is high, that the tribunal failed to consider that the injured himself contributed for
accident and there is contributory negligence on the part of petitioner as he lost
balance of motor cycle and fell down and sustained injuries, that the owner and
insurer of motor cycle are proper and necessary parties, that P.W.2 evidence
states that petitioner sustained 80% disability, but the tribunal failed to consider
the functional disability of the petitioner. Hence, prayed to set aside the Order
and Decree dated 28.10.2021 passed in M.V.O.P.No.251 of 2018 by the
Chairman, MACT –cum- Principal District Judge, Prakasam District at Ongole.
Aggrieved by the same award, the claimant has preferred MACMA No.310
of 2022 for enhancement of compensation amount under special damages and
general damages for the injuries sustained by him.
10.
Heard both sides, perused the material in record.
11.
Now the point for determination is – Whether the Order/Award
passed by the Tribunal needs any interference?
12.
POINT:
On a perusal of the award, it can be observed that in
support of his case, the claimant got examined himself as P.W.1 and also got
marked Exs.A1 to A10. P.W.1 categorically stated that on 29.01.2018, at about
06.00 a.m., in usual course, he went to Bapaiah to deliver milk collected from his
village and while returning from that place on his own motorcycle, when he
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
reached the electric transformer situated at the fields of Chinthalacehuruvu
Venkatesh, the APSRTC bus bearing No.AP27 Z 0962 being driven by the 3rd
respondent was coming in the opposite direction in rash and negligent manner,
upon observing which, the claimant stopped his motorcycle to a side of the road,
but, the driver of the bus dashed against the motorcycle, as a result of which, the
claimant fell down and sustained severe injuries to his right leg.
13.
Though the 3rd respondent – driver of the bus was examined as
R.W.1 who denied that the accident occurred because of his negligence,
however, in the absence of any convincing evidence to that effect, the Tribunal,
relying upon the evidence of P.W.1 coupled with Ex.A2 – copy of FIR and Ex.A3
– copy of charge sheet filed against 3rd respondent, which confirm that the
accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the 3rd respondent,
answered issue No.1 in favour of the claimant by holding that the 3 rd respondent
is responsible for the said accident.
14.
Now coming to issue No.2, the claimant claimed compensation of
Rs.20,000/- for the injuries sustained by him contending that his right leg was
amputated above knee and suffered 80% disability. In support of the said
contention, he got marked Ex.A4 – copy of the disability certificate and Ex.A6 –
wound certificate. He also got examined P.W.2 – Assistant Surgeon, Area
Hospital, Markaput, who is a member of the Medical Board, who issued Ex.A.4 –
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
Disability Certificate, categorically deposed that the petitioner cannot walk, bend,
squat and sit on the floor, even with the help of artificial leg he can walk and
attend his personal pursuits, but he cannot attend agricultural works in the fields
and cannot drive the motor cycle.
He also got examined P.W.3 who is
Consultant Orthopedic Surgeon in Sri Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences,
Guntur, who treated the claimant immediately after the accident categorically
deposed that on 29.01.2018 the claimant attended to his hospital with crush
injuries of right leg with fracture dislocation of right knee with Neuro vascular
deficit with fracture proximal tibia right side. He was operated on 30.01.2018,
right side above knee amputation was done, he was discharged on 13.02.2018.
He further deposed that the claimant sustained partial and permanent disability of
80%.
15.
The claimant was aged 28 years as on the date of accident and as
per the claim petition he was earning Rs.300/- per day as coolie. In the absence
of any documentary evidence to prove that he was earning Rs.300/- per day, the
Tribunal fixed the income of the claimant as Rs.7,000/- per month. As rightly
contended by learned counsel for the claimant, in the absence of any
documentary evidence, the Tribunal ought to have fixed wages of the claimant as
per the minimum wages act applicable as on the date of accident. If the same is
considered, the minimum wages payable to a coolie payable as on the date of
accident i.e. in the year 2018 is Rs.318/-, however, as the claimant has claimed
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
only Rs.300/- per day, the same is considered and the monthly income of the
claimant would compute to Rs.9,000/- [Rs.300/- X 30] and the annual income
would become Rs.1,08,000/- [Rs.9,000/- X 12]. After applying the appropriate
multiplier „17‟ considering the age of the claimant as 28, as per Sarla Verma Vs.
Delhi
Transport
Corporation,
the
loss
of
earnings
would
come
to
Rs.18,36,000/-.
16.
Though the disability as per Ex.A.4 is 80%, however, the evidence of
P.W.2 and P.W.3 is clear that the right leg of the claimant was amputated above
the knee and because of which he cannot walk, bend, squat and sit on the floor.
Even with an artificial leg, he can walk and attend his personal pursuits, but
cannot attend his work in agricultural fields and drive motor cycle. Under the
similar circumstances, the Hon‟ble Apex Court in “Sarnam Singh Versus
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors1” wherein at para No.9, 10 and 11
of the Judgment the Hon‟ble Apex Court held that “9. As to how compensation, in case where permanent disability of an injured
affects his functional disability, is to be assessed has been considered by this
Court, repeatedly. Reference can be made to the judgment of this Court in
Mohan Soni vs. Ram Avtar Tomar And Others, (2012) 2 SCC 267 . In the
aforesaid case the injured was working as a cart puller. As a result of the
accident, his left leg was amputated. His permanent disability was assessed at
60%. The Tribunal assessed the compensation taking the loss of earning at 50%
on the theory that he can still do some other work while sitting. The High Court
2023 Supreme(SC) 606
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
did not disturb the finding regarding loss of income on account of disability. This
Court found that the Tribunal was in error in taking the loss of earning at 50% as
the injured was 55 years of age and it may be difficult for him to find a job at that
stage. In fact, any physical disability resulting from an accident has to be judged
with reference to the nature of the work being performed by the person who
suffered disability. The same injury suffered by two different persons may affect
them in different ways. Loss of leg by a farmer or a rickshaw puller may be end of
the road as far as his earning capacity is concerned. Whereas, in case of the
persons engaged in some kind of desk work in office, loss of leg may have lesser
effect. This Court enhanced the loss of earning capacity from 50% to 90%.
10. Applying the same principle to the case in hand, we find that the appellant
herein was working as a gunman with Bharat Hotel Limited. On account of
amputation of his right leg above the knee, he was terminated from service w.e.f.
31.05.2015. It is not a matter of dispute that a person with his right leg amputated
cannot perform the duty of a gunman. This is his functional disability. He was 50
years & 5 months old at the time of accident. Considering the aforesaid facts, in
our view, the Tribunal was right in assessing the loss of earning capacity of the
appellant at 100% and assessing the compensation accordingly. The High Court
was in error in reducing the loss of earning capacity to 80%, relying upon the
judgment of High Court, despite there being a judgment of this Court available on
the issue.
11. To put the records straight, we may add that there is another error in order
passed by the High Court in calculating the compensation. The compensation
awarded by the Tribunal was taken on Rs.33,34,800/-. Reducing a sum of
Rs.4,92,205/- therefrom, the compensation was assessed at Rs.28,43,000/(rounded off). However, total compensation awarded by the Tribunal was
Rs.34,29,800/- and not Rs.33,34,800/-.”
Hence, the disability of the claimant should be treated as a functional disability of
100% and considering the said fact, this Court feels it appropriate to fix the loss
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
of earnings of the claimant as 100% which comes to (9000 x 12 = 1,08,000 x 17
=) Rs.18,36,000/-.
17.
The Tribunal also awarded a sum of Rs.1,72,182/- towards medical
expenses (Rs.1,25,341/- under Ex.A.8 – inpatient final bill statement, Rs.42,611/towards pharmacy bills under Ex.A.9, Rs.4,230/- towards laboratory bills under
Ex.A.10 in total Rs.1,72,182/- towards medical expenses), Rs.20,000/- towards
transport and extra nourishment, Rs.50,000/- towards pain and suffering,
Rs.25,000/- towards support of the bystander.
18.
The compensation awarded by the Tribunal under different heads
and the amounts enhanced by this Court, are as follows:
Sl.
No.
Head of the claim
1.
Loss of income due to permanent
disability
Medical expenditure
Transport and extra nourishment
Pain and suffering
Support of the bystander
Total
2.
3.
4.
19.
Compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
in Rs. Ps.
11,42,400-00
Amounts now
awarded by this
Court
Rs. Ps.
18,36,000-00
1,72,182-00
20,000-00
50,000-00
25,000-00
14,09,582-00
1,72,182-00
20,000-00
50,000-00
25,000-00
21,03,182-00
In the present case, the claimant claimed an amount of
Rs.20,00,000/- only, but on considering facts and circumstances of the case, this
Court came to the conclusion that the claimant is entitled for an amount of
Rs.21,03,182/-.
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
20.
With regard to awarding compensation more than the claim amount
claimed in the petition, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in “Nagappa Vs. Gurudayal
Singh and Others2 , held as follows:
“…there is no restriction that the Tribunal/Court cannot award
compensation amount exceeding the claimed amount. The
function of the Tribunal/Court is to award “just” compensation,
which is reasonable on the basis of evidence produced on record.”
21.
In “Kajal V. Jagadish Chand and Ors.3 the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
held as follows:
“33. We are aware that he amount awarded by us is more than the
amount claimed. However, it is well settled law that in the motor
accident claim petitions, the Court must award the just
compensation and, in case, the just compensation is more than
the amount claimed, that must be awarded…..”
22.
In view of the law laid down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, this
Court need not restrict the compensation to the amount claimed in the petition
and can award more compensation than the amount claimed in the claim petition,
depending upon the facts and circumstances of the case.
23.
In the result, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal vide
MACMA No.2 of 2023 is dismissed and Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous
Appeal vide MACMA No.310 of 2022 is allowed enhancing the compensation
from Rs.14,09,582/- to Rs.21,03,182/- with interest at 7.5% P.A., from the date
(2003) 2 SCC 274
2020 (04) SCC 413
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
of filing of the petition till the date of realization, subject to payment of deficit
court fee on the amount of Rs.1,03,182/-. There shall be no order as to costs.
Consequently, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand
closed.
____________________
JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
Dated: 16.03.2026
KS
MACMA NO’S. 2 / 2023 and 310 / 2022
VS,J.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2 / 2023
ALONG WITH
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 310 / 2022
DATED 16.03.2026
KS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review