The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. Point Nos.2 and 3: (a) PW.1 testified that, as on the date of the accident, he was aged about 43 years, hale and healthy, and was working as a Cable Operator, earning Rs.20,000/- per month and on account of the injuries sustained in the accident, he suffered permanent disability, lost his source of income and suffered loss of amenities. To substantiate his version, PW.2, the doctor who treated the claimant, deposed that the claimant sustained four grievous injuries, underwent surgery, debridement and internal fixation using plates and screws, and was treated by a physician as he was diabetic. He was discharged on 09.12.2012 in a stable condition. (b). PW.2 further testified that the claimant was advised bed rest, physiotherapy, medication and follow-up treatment on 17.12.2012, the claimant was again admitted to the hospital with infection in the right proximal tibia fracture and on
18. 12.2012, another surgery was conducted, debridement was done, the implants were removed and an external fixator SUN, J MACMA_1687_2016 was fixed. Further, he was discharged on 29.12.2012 and again, on
12. 03.2013, the claimant was admitted to the hospital, underwent surgery, the external fixator was removed and he was discharged on the same day. PW.2 further stated that the claimant had an ankylosed right knee joint with 10 degrees flexion deformity and required a walking aid, he had difficulty in sitting, walking, climbing stairs and running. PW.1 admitted Ex.X1/original discharge summary; Ex.X2/ comprises the inpatient bill dated 29.12.2012 and
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010706222016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3604]
SATURDAY, THE 19th DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUNITHA GANDHAM
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1687/2016
Between:
1. APSRTC, REP BY ITS DIVL MGR, ANANTAPURAMU DIST,
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIVISIONAL MANAGER, ANANTAPURAMU,
ANANTAPURAMU DIST.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. PAMIDI VENKATESH ANANTAPURAM DIST
ANR, S/O. P.
NAGAMUNI, RUNING A DISH AND CABLE OPERATOR, HINDU,
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS, R/O. D. NO: 6/432, UDDIBAVICHENU,
NARPALA VILLAGE & MANDAL, ANANTAPURAMUAM DISTRICT.
2. M LAKSHMI REDDY, S/O. M. THATI REDDY, HINDU, MAJOR, R/O. D.
NO: 6-3-4/6, RAMNAGAR, ANANTAPURAMU TOWN, (DRIVER OF
CRIME BUS NO: AP-28-Z 2292) (R2 IS NOT NECESSARY IN THIS
CMA)
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Courtaggrieved by
the Judgment and Decree dated: 02.03.2016 in O.P. No: 53/2013 on the file of
the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal - Cum - IV Addl. District & Sessions
Judge (FTC), Anantapuramu
IA NO: 1 OF 2016(MACMAMP 2313 OF 2016
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
stay of all further proceedings including the execution proceedings in OP
NO.53 of 2013 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-IV Addl.
SUN, J
MACMA_1687_2016
District & Sessions Judge [FTC], Anantapuram, Anantapuramu district and
pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
release the attachment amount of Rs.12,19,006/- lying in S.B.H.Account
belongs to the APSRTC, Anantapur, by raising attachment order dated
28.04.2016 in EP.No. 82/2016 in M.V.O.P.No. 53/2013 on the file of Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-IV Additional District Judge, Anantapur and
pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. K VISWANATHAM (SC FOR APSRTC)
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. N ASWARTHA NARAYANA
The Court made the following:
SUN, J
MACMA_1687_2016
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUNITHA GANDHAM
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL No:1687 of 2016
JUDGMENT:
Assailing the judgment and decree dated 02.03.2016 passed in
O.P.No.53 of 2013 by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-IV Additional
District and Sessions Judge (FTC), Ananthapuramu, the unsuccessful first
respondent has preferred the present appeal. By the impugned judgment, the
learned Tribunal awarded compensation of Rs.9,93,995/- to the claimant,
together with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of petition
till the date of deposit or realization.
2.
The case of the claimant, in brief, is that on 30.11.2012 at about 11.00
a.m., while he was proceeding along with another person to Ananthapuramu
on his motorcycle bearing No.AP-02-AE-5186, and when they reached near
Narasamma Temple on Ananthapuramu-Narpala road, the A.P.S.R.T.C. bus
bearing No.AP-28-Z-2292 came from the opposite direction in a rash and
negligent manner and dashed against his motorcycle, as a result of which he
fell down and sustained multiple injuries. Immediately after the accident, he
was shifted to Government General Hospital, Ananthapuramu, and thereafter
to Y.S.R. Hospital, Ananthapuramu, and from there to Apollo Hospital,
Hyderabad, for treatment. The claimant was aged about 43 years, hale and
healthy, and was working as a Cable Operator, earning Rs.20,000/- per month
as on the date of the accident. Due to the accident, he suffered permanent
disability and loss of earning capacity. The accident occurred due to the rash
and negligent driving of respondent No.2. The police registered a case in
Crime No.201 of 2012 for the offences punishable under Sections 337 and
338 of the Indian Penal Code against respondent No.2.
SUN, J
MACMA_1687_2016
3.
Respondent No.1 filed a counter disputing the material allegations
made in the claim petition. It was, inter alia, contended that there was no
negligence on the part of respondent No.2 and that the claimant had to prove
his age, income, occupation and injuries. It was further contended that all the
injuries sustained by the claimant had healed and that he had taken treatment
under the Arogyasree scheme. On those grounds and other formal grounds,
respondent No.1 prayed for dismissal of the claim petition.
4.
During the trial, the claimant examined himself as PW.1 and examined
two doctors as PWs.2 and 3 and marked Exs.A1 to A4 and Exs.X1 to X3. On
behalf of the respondents, the driver of the A.P.S.R.T.C. bus was examined as
RW.1. At the conclusion of the trial, the learned Tribunal allowed the claim
petition and awarded compensation of Rs.9,93,995/- with interest at the rate of
7.5% per annum from the date of petition till the date of deposit or realization.
5.
Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree, respondent No.1 preferred
the present appeal contending, principally, that the judgment of the learned
Tribunal is contrary to law, arbitrary, illegal, unjust and unsustainable; that the
Tribunal failed to see that there was no negligence on the part of respondent
No.2; that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the
claimant; that there was contributory negligence on the part of the claimant;
that the non-joinder of the owner and insurer of the motorcycle was fatal to the
claim; that the evidence on record was not properly appreciated; and that the
Tribunal erroneously assessed the permanent disability at 60%. It was also
contended that the claimant had taken treatment under the Arogyasree
scheme. On those grounds, the appellant sought allowance of the appeal.
6.
Heard Sri K. Viswanatham, learned Standing Counsel for the appellant,
and learned counsel appearing for respondent No.1. Perused the material
available on record, including the impugned judgment dated 02.03.2016, the
SUN, J
MACMA_1687_2016
oral evidence of the witnesses and the documents marked before the
Tribunal.
7.
The following points arise for consideration in this appeal:
(i) Whether the driver of A.P.S.R.T.C. bus bearing No.AP-28Z-2292 drove the vehicle in a rash and negligent manner and
caused the accident?
(ii) Whether the claimant is entitled to compensation? If so, to
what amount?
(iii) Whether the appellant is liable to pay the compensation?
(iv) To what relief?
8. Point No.1:
(a)
Being the first appellate Court and the final fact-finding Court, this Court
is required to re-examine and re-appreciate the entire oral and documentary
evidence available on record. PW.1, the injured claimant, deposed that on
30.11.2012 at about 11.00 a.m., while he was proceeding to Ananthapuramu
on his motorcycle bearing No.AP-02-AE-5186, the A.P.S.R.T.C. bus bearing
No.AP-28-Z-2292 came from the opposite direction near Narasamma Temple
on Ananthapuramu-Narpala road in a rash and negligent manner and dashed
against his motorcycle, resulting in his falling down and sustaining multiple
injuries. He further deposed about the treatment received by him immediately
after the accident at Government General Hospital, Ananthapuramu, Y.S.R.
Hospital, Ananthapuramu, and thereafter at Apollo Hospital, Hyderabad.
(b)
As against the above evidence, respondent No.2, who was the driver of
the offending vehicle, was examined as RW.1. Except alleging contributory
negligence on the part of the claimant, he did not place any sufficient material
before the Tribunal to establish that the accident occurred due to such
contributory negligence. Nothing useful was elicited in the cross-examination
of PW.1 so as to discredit his version regarding the manner of the accident.
Further, based on the report of the de facto complainant, Crime No.201 of
SUN, J
MACMA_1687_2016
2012 was registered for the offences under Sections 337 and 338 of the
Indian Penal Code against respondent No.2, which fact was admitted by
RW.1. After completion of investigation, the police filed a charge-sheet
alleging that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of
respondent No.2.
(c).
Ex.A1, the attested copy of the First Information Report, and Ex.A3, the
attested copy of the charge-sheet, lend support to the evidence of the
claimant. No rebuttal evidence has been adduced by the respondents to
displace the said evidence. The testimony of PW.1, being that of an injured
witness, receives corroboration from Exs.A1 to A3. In the absence of any
convincing rebuttal, the evidence of PW.1 establishes that the accident
occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of respondent No.2.
Accordingly, Point No.1 is answered in favour of the claimant.
9. Point Nos.2 and 3:
(a)
PW.1 testified that, as on the date of the accident, he was aged about
43 years, hale and healthy, and was working as a Cable Operator, earning
Rs.20,000/- per month and on account of the injuries sustained in the
accident, he suffered permanent disability, lost his source of income and
suffered loss of amenities. To substantiate his version, PW.2, the doctor who
treated the claimant, deposed that the claimant sustained four grievous
injuries, underwent surgery, debridement and internal fixation using plates and
screws, and was treated by a physician as he was diabetic. He was
discharged on 09.12.2012 in a stable condition.
(b).
PW.2 further testified that the claimant was advised bed rest,
physiotherapy, medication and follow-up treatment on 17.12.2012, the
claimant was again admitted to the hospital with infection in the right proximal
tibia fracture
and
on
18.12.2012,
another
surgery
was conducted,
debridement was done, the implants were removed and an external fixator
SUN, J
MACMA_1687_2016
was fixed. Further, he was discharged on 29.12.2012 and again, on
12.03.2013, the claimant was admitted to the hospital, underwent surgery, the
external fixator was removed and he was discharged on the same day. PW.2
further stated that the claimant had an ankylosed right knee joint with 10
degrees flexion deformity and required a walking aid, he had difficulty in
sitting, walking, climbing stairs and running. PW.1 admitted Ex.X1/original
discharge summary; Ex.X2/ comprises the inpatient bill dated 29.12.2012 and
12.03.2013 and two discharge summaries; and Ex.X3/ Bunch of medical bills.
(c)
The evidence of PW.1, coupled with the evidence of PW.2, clearly
establishes that the claimant sustained multiple fracture injuries, underwent
three surgeries, had implants inserted, suffered infection, had an external
fixator fixed and subsequently removed, was advised bed rest and underwent
treatment on different occasions. The evidence also establishes that he
sustained permanent disability.
(d)
With regard to the disability, the claimant relied upon the evidence of
PW.3, who issued Ex.A4 disability certificate. According to PW.3, the claimant
sustained post-traumatic sequelae due to the road accident dated 30.11.2012,
consisting of posterior dislocation of the right hip joint with a comminuted
fracture of the posterior wall of the acetabulum, comminuted fracture of the
right patella, and Grade-II compound bicondylar fracture of the right tibia
involving the right knee joint. PW.3 further stated that the claimant underwent
surgeries and, on examination, though all the wounds had healed, he had
sustained permanent disability assessed at 60%.
(e)
As regards assessment of loss of earning capacity, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar 1 , has explained that the
percentage of permanent physical disability cannot automatically be treated as
the percentage of loss of earning capacity. The effect of disability has to be
(2011) 1 SCC 343
SUN, J
MACMA_1687_2016
assessed with reference to the claimant's occupation, the nature of work
performed before the accident, the activities that can still be performed and
the extent to which the disability restricts the claimant from carrying out his
earlier work.
(f).
In the present case, the claimant was working as a Cable Operator. His
disability is confined to the right lower limb. PW.3 specifically stated that he
had weakness of the right thigh and leg muscles with limping due to
shortening of the right lower limb by one inch, he could not sit in a squatting or
cross-legged position and had difficulty in walking long distances, standing for
prolonged periods, climbing and getting down stairs and running. Therefore,
while the medical percentage of disability cannot mechanically be equated
with loss of earning capacity, the evidence regarding the claimant's
occupation, the nature of his disability and the functional restrictions resulting
there from were relevant considerations for determining the functional
disability. The Tribunal, therefore, cannot be said to have acted without
evidence in assessing the functional disability at 60%.
(g).
The principles governing compensation in cases of personal injury
require the Court to consider, as appropriate to the facts and evidence,
medical and treatment expenses, loss of earnings during the period of
treatment, loss of future earning capacity arising from permanent disability,
future medical expenses, pain and suffering and loss of amenities. Particularly
in a case involving serious injuries and permanent disability, the assessment
has to be reasonable and based on the medical and other evidence available
on record, with the object of awarding just compensation rather than
mechanically applying the percentage of physical disability.
SUN, J
MACMA_1687_2016
(h).
The decision in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation 2 ,
recognizes the legal soundness of the multiplier method where the facts
warrant its application. The assessment, however, has to be made with
reference to the evidence relating to age, income, disability and its impact on
earning capacity. The principle does not permit arbitrary capitalization of future
income without applying the appropriate method.
(i).
On a careful re-appreciation of the entire evidence, this Court finds that
the learned Tribunal considered the claimant's age, occupation, income,
injuries,
treatment
and
permanent
disability
while
determining
the
compensation. The appellant has not placed any evidence before this Court
demonstrating that the findings of the Tribunal on these aspects are perverse
or unsupported by the record. The mere fact that the amount awarded
exceeds the amount originally claimed does not, by itself, render the award
illegal, since the Tribunal is required to determine the just compensation
payable on the basis of the evidence and the provisions of the Motor Vehicles
Act.
(j).
Having regard to the nature of the claimant's occupation and the
location and functional effect of the disability sustained by him, the learned
Tribunal was justified in assessing the functional disability at 60% and
awarding compensation accordingly. The contention of the learned counsel for
the appellant that the claimant had taken treatment under the Arogyasree
scheme does not, by itself, justify denial or reduction of the compensation
otherwise payable for the injuries and their consequences. The principles
referred to in Raj Kumar's case (Supra) have to be considered in their
entirety and not merely with reference to the amount allegedly incurred
towards medical treatment.
(k).
So far as the income of the claimant is concerned, he stated that he
was working as a Cable Operator and earning Rs.20,000/- per month. Nothing
(2009) 6 SCC 121
SUN, J
MACMA_1687_2016
material was elicited in his cross-examination to discredit his evidence on this
aspect. The learned counsel for the appellant also failed to place material
before this Court to establish a different income. Having regard to the nature
of the claimant's work and the year of the accident, the learned Tribunal took
the notional monthly income at Rs.5,000/- and awarded a total compensation
of Rs.9,93,995/-. The assessment made by the Tribunal, on the evidence
available on record, does not call for interference.
(l).
For the foregoing reasons, this Court finds no merit in the
contentions raised by the appellant. The appellant has failed to establish any
error, perversity or illegality in the findings recorded by the learned Tribunal
warranting interference by this Court. This appeal is devoid of merits and
accordingly, the judgment and decree dated 02.03.2016 in O.P.No.53 of 2013
passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-IV Additional District and
Sessions Judge (FTC), Ananthapuramu, are sustainable on the facts and in
law and do not warrant interference. Accordingly, Point Nos.2 and 3 are
answered in favour of the claimant and against the appellant/respondent No.1.
10. Point No.4:
In the result, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is
dismissed, confirming the judgment and decree dated 02.03.2016 in
O.P.No.53 of 2013 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-IV
Additional District and Sessions Judge (FTC), Ananthapuramu. There shall be
no order as to costs.
As a sequel thereto, the pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall
stand closed.
SUNITHA GANDHAM,J
Date: 19.09.2026
SSA/knl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review