Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:202
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Civil Revision No. 100 of 2025
06 January, 2026
Anupama Prakash
--Revisionist
Versus
Anirudh Singh and others
--Respondents
-------------------------------------------------------------Presence:Mr. Vishesh Srivastava, learned counsel for the revisionist.
Mr. Aditya Singh, learned counsel for the respondents.
------------------------------------------------------------Hon'ble Rakesh Thapliyal, J.
1.
The instant revision has been preferred by the
defendant against the order dated 15.09.2025 passed by
the learned Civil Judge (S.D.) Dehradun in Original Suit
No. 279 of 2025, titled as Anirudh Singh vs. Anupama
Prakash and others, whereby the application preferred by
the defendant under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC , i.e., paper
no. 26A1 has been rejected.
2.
Instant matter was heard earlier on different stages
and on 25.09.2025, further proceeding of O.S. No. 279 of
2025 was stayed. Relevant paragraphs of the order dated
25.09.2025 are reproduced herein as under:3. Learned counsel for the revisionist submits that plaintiff is
nephew of the defendant no. 1 and he has given general power
of attorney to the defendant / revisionist on 24.04.2015 and
being power of attorney holder of the plaintiff, defendant no. 1 /
revisionist executed five sale deeds.
4. Apart from this, he submits that as per averment made in
the plaint power of attorney dated 24.04.2015 was revoked on
29.03.2025, the date after execution of the sale deeds,
therefore, there was no cause of action for the plaintiff to
2026:UHC:202
institute the suit. He further submits that suit property was
undervalued and by taking all these pleas the defendant moved
an application under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC for rejection of the
plaint, however, the same has been rejected and being
aggrieved with the same, instant revision has been preferred.
5. It is contended by the learned counsel for the revisionist that
undisputedly, as per the plaintiff itself registered power of
attorney was revoked after execution of the five sale deeds,
therefore, for plaintiff there was no cause of action to file suit
for cancellation of sale deeds, which were executed prior to the
revocation of power of attorney. He further argued that total
valuation of the property is approx. Rs. Nine Crore but it was
undervalued and the plaintiff valued it only Rs. 24 lakh. He
further argued that while rejecting the application under Order
7 Rule 11 CPC, these two important aspects have not been
considered by the trial court. In support of his contention, he
has placed reliance upon the judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in
Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 9472 of 2023 (V. Ravikumar
Vs. S. Kumar) 2025 INSC 343, particularly, by place reliance to
paragraph 8 and submits that if power of attorney is revoked,
after execution of sale deed, then no cause of action will arise
for institution of suit for cancellation of sale deed.
3.
The main contention of the revisionist is that as per
the plaint, the power of attorney dated 24.04.2015 was
revoked on 25.03.2025, after execution of five sale deeds
which are the subject matter of the suit, and, therefore,
there is no cause of action to file the suit, and,
furthermore the suit was also undervalued and on these
two grounds, an application under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC
has been filed, however, the trial court by the order
impugned reject the suit and being aggrieved instant civil
revision has been filed.
4.
On the previous date after hearing at length this
Court passed the following order on 19.12.2025.
3. Brief facts of the case are that a suit was filed by respondent /
plaintiff seeking declaration of five sale deeds as null and void as the
same are forged and also praying for permanent injunction restraining
2026:UHC:202
the defendant from interfering in the peaceful possession of the
plaintiffs.
4. Mr. Siddharath Sah, learned counsel for the revisionist argued that
suit is not maintainable at all, as the same is filed on fictitious grounds
without any substance and in respect of the five sale deeds there is no
cause of action except one sale deed. There are five sale deeds, two
sale deeds were executed on 21.01.2025 and three sale deeds were
executed on 11.02.2025, 13.02.2025 and 17.03.2025 by defendant
no. 1, real aunt of plaintiff to whom power of attorney was given on
24.04.2015 and being power of attorney holder defendant no. 1
executed three sale deeds whereby entire share of plaintiff was sold
out and by virtue of two sale deeds, half of the share of plaintiff was
sold out.
5. Mr. Sah argued that in fact, the suit filed by plaintiff – respondent
has to be rejected primarily on the two grounds. Firstly, there is no
cause of action and secondly, the suit is barred by Section 34 of the
Specific Relief Act since there is no consequential relief with regard to
restoration of possession. In support of his contention, he has placed
reliance on the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Vasantha (dead) through legal representative Vs. Rajalakshmi alias
Rajam (dead) through legal representative (2024) 5 SCC 282,
particularly, paragraph 55.
6. He further submits that as per plaintiff, un-partitioned property was
sold out, therefore, then in such an eventuality, plaintiff has to file a
suit for partition and if he has not received consideration towards the
sale deed, then he has to pray for recovery of money. He submits that
neither the plaintiffs is praying for possession nor for partition and
even he is not praying for recovery of money, therefore, in absence
thereof the suit filed by the plaintiff is thoroughly misconceived, and as
such, is liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC.
7. He further argued that in respect of sale deeds, some amount has
been credited in the account of the plaintiff as part consideration and
as such, since he has received the money, he can pray for recovery of
the remain part consideration, if any, which he has not prayed. In
reference to this argument, he further placed reliance on the judgment
of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Dahiben Vs. Arvindbhai
Kalyanji Bhanusali (2020) 7 SCC 366 paragraph 29.1 to 29. He further
submits that the suit was filed for cancellation of sale deeds on the
ground of forgery but there is no specific pleading in this regard. In
reference to this, he has placed reliance on the judgment of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 78 of 2 1950 (Bishundeo Narain Vs.
Seogeni Rai) decided on 04.05.1951 particularly paragraph 25 and in
the case of Electrosteel Castings Ltd. Vs. U.V. Asset Reconstruction
Company Ltd. (2022) 2 SCC 573.
8. Mr. Sah, further submits that plaint was drafted cleverly, which is
2026:UHC:202
evident from the relief (f) of the plaint. Since the suit was filed for
cancellation of registration of sale deed, therefore, plaintiff cannot
pleaded that he is in possession and when sale deed was executed
possession was handed over to the purchased and in support of his
arguments, he has placed reliance on in the judgment of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of K. Akbar Ali Vs. K. Umar Khan and
others (2021) 14 SCC 51, particularly, paragraph 7. He finally
concluded his argument by submitting that the trial court while
dismissing the application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC has not applied
his judicial mind and as such order impugned is wholly illegal and liable
to be set aside.
9. On the other side, Mr. Aditya Singh, learned counsel for the
respondent / plaintiff, argued that plea as taken in the application
under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC are completely misconceived and the
power of attorney given by the plaintiff to defendant is only for limited
purposes and not for the purpose of execution of sale deed, therefore,
sale deeds are forged. He pointed out that the power of attorney
conferred defendant no.1 to execute an agreement to sell and not sale
deed and as such, in terms of Section 53-A of even at the time of
agreement
to
sell
possession
can
be
given
order
and
past
performance. He further submits that in fact, defendant no. 1 misused
the power of attorney and specific averment has been made in this
regard in paragraph 6, 7 and 8 of the plaint. He further pointed out
with regard to forgery by misusing power 3 of attorney specific
averment has been made in paragraph 30 and 31 of the plaint. So far
as relief (f) is concerned, he submits that since admittedly property
which was sold out was unpartitioned property and therefore, unless
the property is partitioned by metes and bounds, every corner of the
land, presumed to be in joint possession. He pointed out that
application under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC is misconceived since the
same is based on vague assertion without any substance and even
with regard to the cause of action there is no such assertion, as such
the trial court rightly rejected the application moved under Order 7
Rule 11 of CPC. In reference to the judgments, as relied upon by Mr.
Siddharath Sah, he submits that all the judgments are distinguishable
and are not applicable to the facts of present case. In support of his
contention, he has placed reliance on the judgment of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 5622 of 2025 arising out of Special
Leave Petition (Civil) No. 2549 of 2021 (P. Kumarakurubaran Vs. P.
Narayanan and others) 2025 INSC 598 particularly, paragraph 14.
After passing the aforesaid order, both the parties
were directed to appear through V.C. This Court heard
their respective contention against each other. The
2026:UHC:202
respondents/plaintiffs contended that he has not received
entire money and no power of attorney was given to
execute the sale deed. On the other hand, the defendant
contended that entire money towards consideration has
been paid, therefore, their rival contentions reveals that
all these contentions are admittedly disputed question of
facts and cannot be examined within the parameter of
Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC.
5.
Learned counsel for the revisionist, at this juncture,
submits that the plea as raised in the application under
Order 7 Rule 11 may be permitted to raise before the trial
court for the purposes of framing preliminary issues
which has not been rejected by the other side.
6.
In such view of the matter, the instant civil revision
is disposed of finally with the direction to the trial court to
proceed with the trial and plaintiff/revisionist is permitted
to take all plea with regard to the cause of action and the
valuation of suit, and on such plea trial court is directed
to frame preliminary issues. In addition to this, if the
defendant wants to take any other plea with regard to
preliminary issue he can take it and after framing the
preliminary issues, in addition to the other issues, the
trial court first dealt with the preliminary issues only then
proceed further. Apart from this, the trial court also
makes all possible efforts to expedite the trial positively
within six months.
(Rakesh Thapliyal, J.)
Parul
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review