Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:1133
Serial No.01
Supple List 1
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl. Petn. No.13 of 2024
Date of Decision: 26.11.2025
____________________________________________________________
1.Smti Anu Jain Bohra.
W/o- Shri Sumit Kumar Jain Bohra
R/o “Bohra Residency”
Near Durga Puja Mandap,
Fancy Valley, Tura
District: West Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
2. Shri Sumit Kumar Jain Bohra
S/o- Shri Suresh Kumar Jain Bohra
R/o “Bohra Residency”
Near Durga Puja Mandap,
Fancy Valley, Tura
District: West Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
……. Petitioners.
Vs.
1.State of Meghalaya
Represented by the Superintendent of Police,
West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
2. Sri Amit Kumar Jain Bohra
S/o- Shri Suresh Kumar Jain Bohra
R/o “Bohra Residency”
Near Durga Puja Mandap,
Fancy Valley, Tura
District: West Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
……Respondents.
2025:MLHC:1133
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. V. K. Jindal, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S. Goenka, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mrs. T. Yangi B, AAG with
Mr. K. P. Bhattacharjee, GA (R: 1)
Mr. P. R. Paske, Adv. (R: 2).
JUDGDMENT AND ORDER
Heard Mr. V. K. Jindal, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. S.
Goenka learned Counsel appearing for the petitioners, Mrs. T. Yangi B,
learned AAG assisted by Mr. K. P. Bhattacharjee, learned GA appearing
for the State-respondent No.1 and Mr. P. R. Paske, learned Counsel
appearing for the respondent No.2.
1.
This criminal petition has been filed praying for quashing of the FIR
dated 14-03-2023 registered as Tura PS Case No. 23 (3) of 2023 under
Section 420/468/471 IPC.
2.
The brief fact of the case is that the respondent No.2, acting as an
agent of one Smti Kusum Gupta, filed the FIR dated 14-03-2023 alleging
that the petitioner No.1 claiming herself to be the owner of the property
covered by P.P. No. 420, Dag No. 1450 measuring about 0B-1K-3L under
Mouza No. X-I, situated at fancy valley, Tura, issued eviction notices to the
tenants residing therein.
It was also alleged that the petitioner No.1
2025:MLHC:1133
claimed the property to be ‘Bohra House’. According to the FIR, Smti
Kusum Gupta is the owner of the said property which devolved on her from
her husband (late) Shiv Jatan Gupta by way of inheritance. On an enquiry
from the office of the Garo Hills Autonomous District Council (GHADC)
with regard to the status of the property, it was learnt that the property in
question had been mutated in the name of the petitioner No.2 in the revenue
records of GHADC. It was alleged that if such illegal mutation had
happened, the petitioner No.2, being a non-tribal, had no right to purchase
any property or to get the land mutated in his favour from late Shiv Jatan
Gupta, the original owner of the land, in terms of the provision of the Land
Transfer Act of Meghalaya and such illegal transfer would only be possible
through an act of criminal conspiracy, cheating, fraud, impersonation and
other provisions of the Indian Penal Code. Further, the petitioners have no
authority to issue eviction notice to the tenants. The FIR, as such, called
for inspection of revenue records of GHADC as the petitioner No.2 holds
influence in the town and his antecedents could well be seen from an earlier
FIR dated 22-03-2021. Four enclosures were attached to the FIR 14-032023.
3.
On the basis of the aforesaid FIR dated 14-03-2023, the Tura PS
Case No. 23 (3) of 2023 was registered under Section 420/468/471 IPC and
an investigation was launched in the matter by the police. The petitioner
No.1 was arrested and was subsequently released on bail by the Court of
the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Tura vide order dated 01-05-2023 and the
petitioner No.2 was granted anticipatory bail by the High Court vide order
dated 28-04-2023 passed in A.B. No. 10 of 2023.
2025:MLHC:1133
4.
Assailing the impugned FIR, Mr. V. K. Jindal, learned Senior
Counsel submits that the petitioner No.2 and the respondent No.2 are
related as brothers and the dispute between the petitioners and the
respondent No. 2 is purely civil in nature. He submits that the property in
question measuring about 1K-3L, covered by Dag No.1450 and PP No.420,
was originally owned by one (late) Ram Dhani Gupta who sold a part of the
property measuring about 12L to the grandfather of the petitioner No.2,
namely, (late) Deo Chand Jain Bohra and separate patta was created
numbered as PP No. 420 and Dag No. 1450. In the year 1969, the property
was mutated in favour of the father of the petitioner No.2 (late) Suresh
Kumar Jain Bohra and on 14-03-1997 mutation was allowed in favour of
both the petitioners by right of inheritance. The names of both the children
of petitioners were also added in the land record and a new patta number
2258, Dag No. 5630 was issued on 11-05-2022.
The learned Senior
Counsel further submits that on 30-07-2009 (late) Shiv Jatan Gupta
executed a General Power of Attorney in favour of the petitioner No.2 by
inadvertently mentioning the entire original land measuring 1K-3L; Smti
Kusum Gupta wife of (late) Shiv Jatan Gupta was a witness to the said
Power of Attorney.
5.
In the above factual background, the learned Senior Counsel submits
that the initiation of criminal investigation against the petitioner on the
basis of the impugned FIR is nothing but a clear abuse of process of law.
He further submits that there is no whisper of commission of any criminal
offence by the petitioners in the FIR and no case is made out even if the
allegations made in the FIR are accepted. He submits that the respondent
No.2 did not have proper authority or power to file the impugned FIR and
2025:MLHC:1133
he is acting at the behest of Smti Kusum Gupta in order to cause
unnecessary harassment to the petitioners. He contends that the ingredients
of offence under Section 420/468/471 IPC are totally missing in the FIR
and the FIR is vague as there is no specific disclosure of any offence by the
petitioners. The learned Senior Counsel submits that on an earlier occasion
in the year 2022 a similar FIR was filed against the petitioners on false
grounds but the police did not take any action as the preliminary
investigation revealed that it was a false case and was civil in nature. He
submits that the allegation of violation of the Meghalaya Transfer of Land
(Regulation) Act, 1971 and the issuance of eviction notice by the petitioner
No.1 cannot be construed as a criminal act as the notice has not been issued
in the name of Smti Kusum Gupta by forging her signature. He submits that
this High Court while allowing the anticipatory bail application of the
petitioner No.2 by order dated 28-04-2023 has held that the matter appears
to be a civil dispute. He submits that owing to the continuous harassment
by the respondent No.2 at the behest of Smti Kusum Gupta, the petitioners
have instituted Title Suit No. 10 of 2023 along with Misc. Case No. 12 of
2023 in the Court of the Assistant to the Deputy Commissioner (J), Tura
with regard to the property in dispute. He, therefore, prays that the
impugned FIR dated 14-03-2023 and the related Tura PS Case No. 23 (3)
of 2023 under Section 420/468/471 IPC be quashed.
To buttress his
argument, the learned Senior Counsel places reliance on the decisions of
the Apex Court in Municipal Corporation of Delhi V. Ram Kishan Rohtagi
& Ors, AIR 1983 SC 67, Mahendra K.C. Vrs. State of Karnataka & Anr.,
(2022) 2 SCC 129 and Dara Lakshmi Narayana & Ors. Vs. State of
Telangana & Anr, (2025) 3 SCC 735.
2025:MLHC:1133
6.
Mrs. T. Yangi B, learned AAG appearing for the State-respondent
No.1, on the other hand, submits that the FIR dated 14-03-2023 speaks of
suspicious transfer of the property and the same could not have been done
without the co-operation of the officials of the concerned land record
department. By referring to the averments made in the instant criminal
petition and the materials on record, she submits that the claim of the
petitioners with regard to the property in question is contradictory in many
aspects and the facts and situation of the case demands thorough
investigation of the matter by police to unearth the truth. The learned AAG
further submits that though the allegations made in the FIR speaks of a civil
dispute, it also involves criminal offence constituting on the same set of
facts. She submits that when the FIR clearly discloses commission of
criminal offence, the investigation initiated in the matter should not be
interfered with merely because a civil wrong has also been committed. She
submits that the FIR is only a piece of information basing on which
investigation is initiated and it would be improper for this Court, at this
juncture, to scuttle the investigation by evaluating the truthfulness of the
allegations made in the FIR.
The reliability or genuineness of the
allegations made in the FIR can only be ascertained after conducting a
proper investigation. She submits that the institution of the title suit by the
petitioners with regard to the property in dispute is after thought just to
escape from the criminal liability of the matter. The learned AAG,
therefore, submits that the investigation may be allowed to come to a
logical conclusion and prays that the criminal petition be dismissed being
devoid of merits. She supports her argument by relying on the decisions of
the Apex Court in Kaptan Singh Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors., (2021)
9 SCC 35, Iqbal Alias Bala & Ors. Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors.,
2025:MLHC:1133
(2023) 8 SCC 734, State of UP. Vs. O.P. Sharma, (1996) 7 SCC 705, Rajiv
Thapar & Ors. Vs. Madan Lal Kapoor, (2013) 3 SCC 330 and Amit Kapoor
Vs. Ramesh Chander & Anr., (2012) 9 SCC 460.
7.
Mr. P. R. Paske, learned Counsel appearing for the respondent No.2
endorses the submission made by the learned AAG and further submits that
the property in dispute never belonged to one (Late) Ram Dhani Gupta as
the property was originally a waste land and was settled in favour of one
(Late) Ram Jatan Ram by way of a Suitability Certificate issued by the then
Deputy Commissioner, Garo Hills District in the year 1958-1959 and by
the Executive Member, I/C Revenue, District Council, Tura vide order
dated 27-08-1959. He submits that the grandfather or the father of the
petitioners had never purchased or owned the said property at any point of
time and the statements made by the petitioners in the present case are
totally incorrect. He further submits that the property in dispute in the
present case stands in the name of Smti. Shella Devi Prasad and (Late) Shiv
Jatan Gupta (Ram) as per the records of Land Rights maintained by
GHADC and the mutation carried out by the petitioners is based on forged
and fabricated documents.
He submits that the petitioners carried out
mutation of the property and obtained two joint land pattas on 26-10-2021
on the basis of a General Power of Attorney dated 30-07-2009 in gross
violation of the bar posed by the Meghalaya Transfer of Land (Regulation)
Act, 1971. The learned Counsel submits that the fact that the name of Shiv
Jatan Gupta (Ram), the husband of Smti Kusum Gupta, had been shown as
a recorded owner of the property in the Periodic (Miadi) Patta having
validity till 31-03-2016 (Enclosure-II to the FIR dated 14-03-2023) clearly
projects the falsity of the claim of the petitioners. He, therefore, submits
2025:MLHC:1133
that the illegal act and unlawful transaction of the petitioners with regard to
the property in dispute can only be ascertained by a proper investigation
and prays that the criminal petition be dismissed.
8.
Having heard the learned Counsels for the rival parties and having
gone through the materials on record, it is clear that there exists a dispute
between the petitioners and one Smti. Kusum Gupta represented by the
respondent No.2 concerning the property situated at fancy valley, Tura
covered by PP No. 420, Dag No. 1450 measuring 0B-1K-3L under Mouza
No. X-I and the dispute referred in the FIR dated 14-03-2023 is with regard
to the said property.
9.
Before coming to the allegations made in the FIR, it would be
appropriate to refer to the various authorities relied on by the parties in
support of their respective pleas.
10.
The decision of Ram Kishan Rohtagi (supra), relied on behalf of the
petitioners, laid down that the proceeding against an accused in the initial
stages can be quashed if on the face of the complaint or the papers
accompanying the same, no offence is constituted. The test is that taking
the allegation and the complaint as they are, without adding or subtracting
anything, if no offence is made out than the High Court will be justified in
quashing the proceeding in exercise of powers under 482 Cr.PC.
In
Mahendra K.C (supra) case, the above proposition was reaffirmed by the
Apex Court and further held that while exercising the power of quashing,
the Court cannot function as a Court of appeal or revision. At this stage,
the High Court cannot test the veracity of the allegations nor can proceed in
the manner like a Judge conducting a Trial. Further, in Dara Lakshmi
2025:MLHC:1133
Narayan & Others (supra) it was provided that if an FIR is lodged making
vague and omnibus allegation without mentioning any specific details
including date, time, place or manner of commission of alleged occurrence,
entire criminal proceeding arising out of that FIR can be quashed.
11.
In the decisions of Kaptan Singh (supra) and Iqbal alias Bala &
Others (supra), relied on behalf of the State-respondent, it was broadly held
that if the petition under Section 482 Cr.PC was at the stage of FIR, in that
case the allegations in the FIR/complaint only are required to be considered
and whether a cognizable offence is disclosed or not is required to
considered.
However, when the statements are recorded, evidence is
collected and the charge-sheet is filed after conclusion of the
investigation/inquiry, the matter stands on different footing and the Court is
required
to
consider
the
material/evidence
collected
during
the
investigation. It was also provided that proper remedy of accused in such
case is to prefer discharge application before the Trial Court for
consideration in accordance with law. In the cases of O.P. Sharma (supra)
and Rajiv Thapar and Others (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court while
dealing with the issue of quashing of criminal proceeding at initial stage,
held that High Court should be reluctant to interfere at the threshold to
thwart the prosecution exercising its inherent power when FIR contains all
the ingredients of the offence and that is not the stage for evaluating the
truthfulness or otherwise of the allegation levelled by the prosecution
against the accused.
Likewise, it is not a stage for determining how
weighty the defence is raised on behalf of the accused. In the case of Amit
Kapoor (supra) it was held that mere existence of civil dispute would not
by itself alter status of allegations constituting criminal offence. If the
2025:MLHC:1133
records disclose commission of a criminal offence and ingredients of the
offence are satisfied, then criminal proceeding cannot be quashed merely
because a civil wrong has also been committed.
12.
The record of the present matter does not reflect the current status of
the case or the progress made in the investigation by police. It is stated by
the learned AAG that because of a stay order passed in a connected matter,
the investigation of this case could not proceed. However, it appears that no
stay order has been passed in the instant matter. Thus, read in the light of
the above authorities relied on by the parties, what falls for consideration of
this Court is whether the allegations made in the impugned FIR dated 1403-2023 makes disclosure of any cognizable offence justifying initiation of
investigation in the matter by police.
13.
Perusal of the impugned FIR dated 14-03-2023 shows that the filing
of the FIR was triggered by the fact of alleged issuance of the eviction
notice dated 21-10-2022 by the petitioner No.1 to the tenants living under
occupancy in the property in dispute by claiming the property to be ‘Bohra
House’. The FIR further stated that it was ascertained from the office of
the GHADC, Tura that the property in question had been mutated in the
name of the petitioner No.2 in the revenue records of the GHADC. It was
alleged that if such mutation had taken place, it would be against the
provisions of the Meghalaya Transfer of Land (Regulation) Act, 1971.
Further, any act, deed or thing done towards such illegal transfer would
only be possible through an act of criminal conspiracy, cheating, fraud,
impersonation and other provision of the Indian Penal Code.
2025:MLHC:1133
14.
From the materials placed on record, it is evident that the allegations
levelled in the FIR are vague, speculative and unsupported by any definite
or ascertainable facts. The FIR does not disclose any concrete incident or
factual foundation that would constitute the basic ingredients of the alleged
offences. In particular, no specific document has been identified as having
been forged by the petitioners. There is also no assertion in the FIR that the
eviction notice dated 21-10-2022 was issued by petitioner No. 1 in the
name of Smt. Kusum Gupta by forging her signature. In the absence of
such specific averments, the allegations under Sections 468 and 471 of the
Indian Penal Code are wholly unsustainable and lack foundational basis.
Furthermore, a mere allegation of contravention of the provisions of the
Meghalaya Transfer of Land (Regulation) Act, 1971 does not, by itself,
give rise to any offence under the Indian Penal Code. Section 9 of the said
Act exclusively provides for the penalties in case of violation of Section 7
and sub-section (1) of Section 8 thereof, and no other penal consequences
are contemplated under the said Act. The allegations made in the FIR are,
therefore, not relatable to, nor covered by, the offences or penalties
prescribed under the Meghalaya Transfer of Land (Regulation) Act, 1971.
15.
The condition necessary for an act to constitute an offence under
Section 420 IPC is that there was dishonest inducement by the accused. No
act on part of the petitioners has been alleged in the FIR that discloses an
intention on the part of the petitioners to induce the delivery of any
property to the petitioners or to any other person. There is, thus, nothing on
the face of the FIR to indicate that the petitioners dishonestly induced any
person to deliver any property to them.
The ingredients necessary to
2025:MLHC:1133
constitute the offence of cheating is not made out from the face of the FIR
and, consequently, no offence under Section 420 IPC is made out.
16.
Further, to maintain an FIR or complaint on the allegation of forgery
for purpose of cheating and using as genuine a forged document under
Section 468/471 IPC, it is mandatory to alleged that the accused has made
false document or false electronic record or part of a document or
electronic record. It is not the case of the respondent in the present case
that the petitioners made false document with intention to use it for the
purpose of cheating the respondent No.2 or any other person. Further, there
is no allegation that the petitioners have dishonestly and fraudulently made,
signed, sealed or executed any particular document or part of a document.
There is also no assertion in the FIR that the petitioners have used any
particular forged document as genuine.
17.
Insofar as the allegation of lodging of earlier FIR dated 22-03-2021
(Enclosure-IV) against the petitioners is concerned, there is nothing on
record to show that the said FIR was registered as a regular case and
investigated into by the police. No details are stated in the FIR dated 1403-2023 under challenge in this petition. The rest of the enclosures i.e.
Enclosure-I, Enclosure-II and Enclosure-III to the FIR dated 14-03-2023
also contain no material to support the offence alleged in the FIR. It is,
therefore, clear that even if the allegation made in the FIR is taken in their
face value, none of the ingredients constituting the alleged offence are
culled out. Thus, the allegation the FIR appears to be totally frivolous and
vexatious.
2025:MLHC:1133
18. The Apex Court in the case of Prof. R.K. Vijayasarathy and Another
Vs. Sudha Seetharam and Another (2019) 16 SCC 739 observed that where
the ingredients required to constitute a criminal offence are not made out
from the bare reading of the complaint, the continuation of the criminal
proceeding will constitute an abuse of process of the Court. In the present
case, as has been observed in the foregoing paragraphs, the allegations
made in the FIR do not constitute the ingredients necessary for the offences
under Section 420/468/471 IPC.
In absence of ingredients necessary to
constitute a criminal offence, continuation of investigation on the basis of
the impugned FIR dated 14-03-2023 will result in abuse of process of law.
19.
In view of the discussions made above, this criminal petition
succeeds. The FIR dated 14-03-2023 in Tura PS Case No. 23 (3) of 2023
under Section 420/468/471 IPC stands quashed.
20. The Criminal petition stands allowed.
Judge
Meghalaya
26.11.2025
“Biswarup PS”
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2025.11.26 17:43:19 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review