The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. In the event of her appointment, she shall be granted all consequential notional benefits, including seniority, from the date on [2026:RJ-JP:30489-DB] (7 of 7) [SAW-1121/2022] which similarly situated candidates were appointed. However, she shall not be entitled to any arrears of salary or other monetary benefits for the period she remained out of service, on the principle of "no work, no pay."
16. The appeal stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms. Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of. No order as to costs. (ASHUTOSH KUMAR),J 94/ASHWANI-TANISHA (ARUN MONGA),J
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:30489-DB]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN BENCH AT
JAIPUR
D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 1121/2022
CNR: RJHC020761172022 | URN: SAW / 2000U / 2022
Antima Jain D/o Shri Hukum Chand Jain, Aged About 23 Years,
R/o Rang Bhariyo Ki Gali, Saraf Bazar, Alwar (Raj.)
----Appellant
Versus
1.
The State Of Rajasthan, Through Principal Secretary,
Department
Of
Public
Health
And
Engineering,
Government Secretariat, Jaipur (Raj.)
2.
Chief Engineer (Administration), Department Of Public
Health And Engineering, 2-Jal Bhawan, Jacob Road, Civil
Lines, Jaipur.
3.
Miss Akansha Asthana D/o Late Shri R.P. Asthana, Aged
About 23 Years, Resident Of 15, Avas Vikas Colony,
Chhota Choraha, Hardaui, U.P.
----Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Akshit Gupta, Adv. with
Mr. Pallav Pancholi, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Ms. Mahi Yadav, AAG with
Ms. Chelshi Agarwal, AAAG
Mr. Kuldeep Singh Rathore, Adv.
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN MONGA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHUTOSH KUMAR
Order(Oral)
Reportable
05/08/2026
Per: Arun Monga, J.
1.
Instant intra court appeal is directed against the judgment and
order dated 19.07.2022 passed by the learned Single Judge in S.B. Civil
Writ Petition No. 11635/2015, whereby the writ petition assailing an
order dated 20.10.2015 rejecting the appellant's candidature for the
(2 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:30489-DB]
[SAW-1121/2022]
post of Junior Engineer (Civil), on the ground that she failed to produce
the requisite OBC (Non-Creamy Layer) certificate at the stage of
document verification, despite having applied under the OBC (NonCreamy Layer) category, was dismissed.
2.
Briefly stated, the facts of the case are that the appellant applied
for the post of Junior Engineer (Civil) (Diploma) pursuant to the
recruitment advertisement dated 30.09.2014. In the absence of any
valid proof, although she belonged to the General (Female) category,
but her online application form reflected her category as OBC (NonCreamy Layer) (Female). She participated in the selection process and
secured 35.77 marks, which was above the cut-off prescribed for the
General (Female) category, i.e., 35.40 marks. At the stage of document
verification, the respondents required her to produce an OBC (NonCreamy Layer) certificate. The appellant informed the respondents that
the category had been incorrectly entered in the online application and
requested that her candidature be considered under the General
(Female)
category.
However,
by
order
dated
20.10.2015,
the
respondents rejected her candidature for failure to produce the requisite
OBC (Non-Creamy Layer) certificate.
2.2
Aggrieved thereby, the appellant filed S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.
11635/2015, challenging the rejection of her candidature and seeking
consideration for appointment under the General (Female) category.
During the pendency of the writ petition, by interim order dated
20.08.2015, the respondents were directed to keep one post in the
General
category
vacant
for
the
appellant.
By
judgment
dated
19.07.2022, the learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition,
holding that the appellant had applied under the OBC (Non-Creamy
Layer) category, had failed to avail the opportunity provided under the
[2026:RJ-JP:30489-DB]
(3 of 7)
[SAW-1121/2022]
recruitment advertisement to correct the particulars in her application
form, and was therefore not entitled to seek a change of category after
conclusion of the selection process.
2.3
Hence, the instant appeal.
3.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the mention of
OBC (Non-Creamy Layer) in the online application was a bona fide
clerical error. That the appellant had, at the first available opportunity
during document verification, disclosed her correct status. And that,
having secured marks above the General (Female) cut-off, she was
entitled to be considered on her own merit in the General category. In
support of the proposition that a candidate cannot be confined to a
reserved category and denied consideration in the open category on
merit, reliance was placed upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Ramnaresh @ Rinku Kushwah & Ors. v. State of Madhya
Pradesh & Ors.
4.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents vehemently
opposes the appeal. He urges that a candidate is bound by the
declarations made in her application form, and the appellant, having
consciously applied under the OBC (Non-Creamy Layer) category,
participated in the selection process on that footing throughout. It is
further submitted that the recruitment advertisement itself afforded a
specific window to all candidates to correct the particulars furnished in
their application forms, which the appellant admittedly failed to avail.
That a change of category cannot be countenanced after the selection
process has concluded, as it would unsettle the select list and prejudice
other candidates. And that, the rejection of her candidature for nonproduction of the requisite certificate was, therefore, strictly in
accordance with the terms of the advertisement. It was accordingly
[2026:RJ-JP:30489-DB]
(4 of 7)
[SAW-1121/2022]
urged that the learned Single Judge rightly dismissed the writ petition
and the judgment warrants no interference.
5.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
6.
Two questions arise for our consideration, i.e., :(i).
Whether the appellant was entitled to claim the benefit of
the OBC (Non-Creamy Layer) category ?
(ii).
If the answer to above question is in the negative, whether
her candidature ought nonetheless to have been considered
in the General (Female) category on the strength of her own
merit ?
7.
On the first question, what emerges from the record is that the
appellant had indeed opted for the OBC (Non-Creamy Layer) category
in her application but failed to produce the supporting certificate to
claim the benefit thereof. She further failed to avail the opportunity of
correction provided under the advertisement. To that extent, we are in
complete agreement with the reasoning of the learned Single Judge,
and the finding that the appellant could not claim the benefit of the OBC
(Non-Creamy Layer) category calls for no interference.
8.
However, what appears to have escaped the notice of the learned
Single Judge is the necessary corollary of that very finding viz. once the
appellant was held not entitled to the benefit of the OBC (Non-Creamy
Layer) category, she did not stand ousted from the selection process
altogether. Rather, she ought to have been treated as a General
category candidate and her candidature ought to have been tested
against the General (Female) cut-off.
9.
It is not in dispute that the appellant secured 35.77 marks, which
is above the cut-off of 35.40 marks prescribed for the General (Female)
[2026:RJ-JP:30489-DB]
(5 of 7)
[SAW-1121/2022]
category. The rejection of her candidature thus proceeded on an
erroneous compartmentalization of categories, treating reservation as a
rigid slot foreclosing consideration on merit in the open category.
10.
The legal position in this regard is no longer res integra.
Reference may be had to the cited judgement by learned counsel for the
appellant rendered by hon’ble Supreme Court in Ramnaresh@ Rinku
Khushwah and others v/s State of Madhya Pardesh and others 1.
Relevant extract of the same is reproduced herein below:-
“10. By now, it is a well-settled principle of law that a candi-date
belonging to any of the vertical reservation categories who on the basis
of his own merit is entitled to be selected in the open or general category,
will be selected against the gen-eral category and his selection would not
be counted against the quota reserved for such vertical reservation
categories. Reliance in this respect could be placed on the 9-Judge
Bench judgment of this Court in the case of Indra Sawhney and Others v.
Union of India and Others, and in the cases of R.K. Sabharwal and
Others v. State of Punjab and Others and Ritesh R. Sah v. Dr. Y.L. Yamul
and Oth-ers.
x-x-x-x-x-x
13. It will also be apposite to refer to the following observations made by
S. Ravindra Bhat, J. in his concurring judgment:
"66. I would conclude by saying that reservations, both
vertical and horizontal, are method of ensuring
representation in public services. These are not to be seen as
rigid "slots", where a candidate's merit, which otherwise
entitles her to be shown in the open general category, is
foreclosed, as the consequence would be, if the State's
argument is accepted. Doing so, would result in a communal
reservation, where each social category is confined within
the extent of their reservation, thus negating merit. The open
category is open to all, and the only condition for a
candidate to be shown in it is merit, regardless of whether
reservation benefit of either type is available to her or him."
14. It could thus be seen that the learned Judge clearly observed that the
horizontal as well as the vertical reservation would not be seen as rigid
"slots", where a candidate's merit, which otherwise entitles her or him to
be shown in the open general category, is foreclosed. It was observed
that by doing so, it would result in communal reservation, where each
social category is confined within the extent of their reservation, thus
negating merit. It was observed that the open category is open to all, and
the only condition for a candidate to be shown in it is merit. regardless of
whether reservation benefit of either type is available to her or him.”
11.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts at hand, the
open/General category was open to the appellant on her own merit,
2024 SCC OnLine SC 2058
(6 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:30489-DB]
[SAW-1121/2022]
irrespective of the category mentioned in her application form or her
failure to substantiate the claim to OBC (Non-Creamy Layer) status.
12.
The submission of the respondents that the appellant stands
bound by her application, while attractive at first blush, cannot be
stretched to defeat her consideration in the open category on merit, for
merit alone is the criterion for the open category. The failure to produce
a reserved-category certificate, at the most, disentitles a candidate to
the benefit of reservation. It does not disentitle her to compete in the
open category.
13.
In view of the aforesaid legal position, the impugned judgment
dated 19.07.2022 is modified to the following extent:13.1 While the dismissal of the writ petition insofar as it sought the
benefit of the OBC (Non-Creamy Layer) category is upheld;
13.2 The appellant's claim for consideration as a General category
candidate shall be examined in accordance with law;
13.3 If, on the basis of the marks secured by her in the selection
process, the appellant is found entitled to appointment in the General
(Female)
category,
the
Competent
Authority
shall
consider
her
candidature and pass appropriate orders expeditiously, preferably within
a period of three months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of
this judgment.
14.
Since, by the interim order dated 01.11.2024 passed by the
Coordinate Bench of this Court, then seized of the matter, one post was
directed to be kept reserved, the appellant shall be entitled to the
benefit of the said post if she falls within the merit of the General
(Female) category.
15.
In the event of her appointment, she shall be granted all
consequential notional benefits, including seniority, from the date on
[2026:RJ-JP:30489-DB]
(7 of 7)
[SAW-1121/2022]
which similarly situated candidates were appointed. However, she shall
not be entitled to any arrears of salary or other monetary benefits for
the period she remained out of service, on the principle of "no work, no
pay."
16.
The appeal stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms. Pending
application(s), if any, also stand disposed of. No order as to costs.
(ASHUTOSH KUMAR),J
94/ASHWANI-TANISHA
(ARUN MONGA),J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review