The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. Consequently, I.A. No. 1 of 2018 stands disposed of.
15. In view of the above circumstances, the stay granted by this Court vide order dated 22.11.2018 stands vacated.
16. Crl. M.C. No. 10 of 2018 disposed of accordingly. Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
Crl.M.C. No. 10 of 2018
ANKIT SARDA
PETITIONER
VERSUS
NUKUL BANSAL
RESPONDENT
Date: 13.06.2019
CORAM:
THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
For Petitioner
Mr. Jorgay Namka, Advocate.
Ms. Panila Theengh, Advocate.
For Respondent
Mr. Rahul Rathi, Advocate.
O R D E R (ORAL)
1.
Heard on I.A. No. 1 of 2018.
2.
The Petitioner is before this Court assailing the Order
dated 25.10.2018 of the Court of the Special Division-I, Sikkim
at Gangtok in Criminal Appeal No. 11 of 2017 (Ankit Sarda v.
Nakul Bansal). Vide the impugned Order, the learned Appellate
Court while considering the petition under Section 391 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short „Cr.P.C.‟) filed by the
Petitioner herein inter alia allowed the Petitioner to examine one
Rabindra Kumar Sarda but rejected his prayer to examine one
Ashish Somani. The learned Appellate Court also opined that the
evidence of two other witnesses viz. Naresh Kumar Agarwal and
Suresh Agarwal would be relevant for a just adjudication of the
matter and directed that the said two witnesses also be
examined by the Petitioner. The Petitioner contends before this
Court that firstly he does not seek to examine witnesses Naresh
Kumar Agarwal and Suresh Agarwal in view of the fact that
Exhibit 1 where the two persons are witnesses, is an admitted
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
document and secondly because these two witnesses were cited
as witnesses by the Respondent but were subsequently not
examined. That, in view of the fact that the Respondent also
admits Exhibit 1, no purpose emanates from their examination.
It is prayed that the Order of the learned Appellate Court with
regard to examining of these two witnesses be set aside and
Ashish Somani be permitted to be examined by the Petitioner.
3.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent concedes that he
has no objections to the submissions of the Petitioner with regard
to the examination of Naresh Kumar Agarwal and Suresh
Agarwal not being necessary in view of the fact that Exhibit 1 is
an admitted document. However, he submits that the prayer of
the Petitioner seeking to examine Rabindra Kumar Sarda and
Ashish Somani ought to be rejected as nowhere earlier had the
Petitioner
cited
the
requirement
of
examining
these
two
witnesses. That, allowing the prayer would prejudice the case of
the Respondent. Hence the petition be dismissed.
4.
I have carefully considered the rival submissions of
learned Counsel and perused all relevant documents.
5.
Section 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
(for short „Cr.P.C.‟) provides as follows;
“311.
Power
to
summon
material
witness, or examine person present.-Any
Court may, at any stage of any inquiry, trial or
other proceeding under this Code, summon any
person as a witness, or examine any person in
attendance, though not summoned as a
witness, or recall and re-examine any person
already examined; and the Court shall summon
and examine or recall and re-examine any such
person if his evidence appears to it to be
essential to the just decision of the case.”
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
6.
In Shailendra Kumar v. State of Bihar and Others, (2002)
1 SCC 655 while discussing this provision of the Cr.P.C., it was
held as follows;
“…11. Bare reading of the aforesaid section
reveals that it is of a very wide amplitude and if
there is any negligence, laches or mistakes by
not examining material witnesses, the court's
function to render just decision by examining
such witnesses at any stage is not, in any way,
impaired.
This
Court
in
Rajendra
Prasad v. Narcotic Cell [(1999) 6 SCC 110]
observed: (SCC p. 113, para 8)
“After all, function of the criminal court is
administration of criminal justice and not to
count errors committed by the parties or to find
out and declare who among the parties
performed better.”……”
The position of law on this count is no more res integra and also
requires no further elucidation.
7.
Along with the provision supra we may also profitably
refer to Section 391 of the Cr.P.C. which reads as hereunder;
“391. Appellate Court may take further
evidence or direct it to be taken.- (1) In
dealing with any appeal under this Chapter, the
Appellate Court, if it thinks additional evidence
to be necessary, shall record its reasons and
may either take such evidence itself, or direct it
to be taken by a Magistrate, or when the
Appellate Court is a High Court, by a Court of
Session or a Magistrate.
(2) When the additional evidence is taken by
the Court of Session or the Magistrate, it or he
shall certify such evidence to the Appellate
Court, and such Court shall thereupon proceed
to dispose of the appeal.
(3) The accused or his pleader shall have the
right to be present when the additional evidence
is taken.
(4) The taking of evidence under this section
shall be subject to the provisions of Chapter
XXIII, as if it were an inquiry.”
8.
In Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh and another v. State of
Gujarat and others, AIR 2004 SC 3114
while discussing the said
provision, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court would hold as follows;
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
“23. Section 391 of the Code is intended to
subserve the ends of justice by arriving at the
truth and there is no question of filling of any
lacuna in the case on hand. …
……………………………………………………………………………
41. A criminal trial is a judicial examination of
the issues in the case and its purpose is to
arrive at a judgment on an issue as a fact or
relevant facts which may lead to the discovery
of the fact issue and obtain proof of such facts
at which the prosecution and the accused have
arrived by their pleadings; the controlling
question being the guilt or innocence of the
accused. Since the object is to mete out justice
and to convict the guilty and protect the
innocent, the trial should be a search for the
truth and not a bout over technicalities, and
must be conducted under such rules as will
protect the innocent, and punish the guilty. The
proof of charge which has to be beyond
reasonable doubt must depend upon judicial
evaluation of the totality of the evidence, oral
and circumstantial and not by an isolated
scrutiny.”
9.
Much earlier in time, in Rajeswar Prasad Misra v. State
of West Bengal and Another, AIR 1965 SC 1887 the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court while considering the same provision would observe as
extracted hereinbelow;
“………………………………………………………………………..
8. Since a wide discretion is conferred on
appellate courts, the limits of that courts'
jurisdiction must obviously be dictated by the
exigency of the situation and fair play and good
sense appear to be the only safe guides. ……
9. Additional evidence may be necessary for a
variety of reasons which it is hardly proper to
construe one section with the aid of
observations made to do what the legislature
has refrained from doing, namely, to control
discretion of the appellate court to certain
stated circumstances. It may, however, be said
that additional evidence must be necessary not
because it would be impossible to pronounce
judgment but because there would be failure of
justice without it. The power must be exercised
sparingly and only in suitable cases. Once such
action is justified, there is no restriction on the
kind of evidence which may be received. It may
be formal or substantial. It must, of course, not
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
be received in such a way as to cause prejudice
to the accused as for example it should not be
received as a disguise for a retrial or to change
the nature of the case against him. The order
must not ordinarily be made if the prosecution
has had a fair opportunity and has not availed
of it unless the requirements of justice dictate
otherwise. ...”
10.
Further, in Brig. Sukhjeet Singh (Retd.) MVC v. The State
of Uttar Pradesh & Ors., Criminal Appeal No. 148 of 2019 (arising out
of SLP (Crl.) No. 1120/2017) it was inter alia held as follows;
“As noted above, this Court has laid down that
when it becomes necessary to take additional
evidence, cannot be enlisted or enumerated in
any fixed formula. It depends on facts of each
and every case to come to a conclusion as to
whether it is necessary to take additional
evidence or not.”
11.
The above propositions categorically expound the
parameters of the provisions and the discretion that the Court is
clothed with. That having been said, it would be useful to
consider that Section 165 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (for
short „Evidence Act‟) also vests the Court with powers to put
questions or order production of witness or document.
12.
Considering the aforestated positions of law and the
wide discretion afforded to the Courts, I am of the considered
opinion that the prayers of the Petitioner ought to be allowed in
order to subserve the ends of justice and to give a closure to the
issues between the parties. Consequently, the impugned Order of
the learned trial Court is modified to the following extent;
(i)
Ashish Somani is also allowed to be examined as
the Petitioner‟s witness along with Rabindra
Kumar Sarda.
(ii)
Bearing in mind that Section 58 of the Evidence
Act provides that facts admitted need not be
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
proved, in view of Exhibit 1 being a document
the contents of which are not disputed by both
sides, there is no requirement to examine
witnesses Naresh Kumar Agarwal and Suresh
Agarwal.
13.
Let the Petitioner furnish witnesses Rabindra Sarda
and Ashish Somani before the learned trial Court on 15.07.2019
and all proceedings before the learned trial Court be completed
by 15.08.2019. Thereafter the matter be forwarded to the Court
of the Special Division-I, Sikkim at Gangtok.
14.
Consequently, I.A. No. 1 of 2018 stands disposed of.
15.
In view of the above circumstances, the stay granted
by this Court vide order dated 22.11.2018 stands vacated.
16.
Crl. M.C. No. 10 of 2018 disposed of accordingly.
Judge
13.06.2019
ml
Index
Internet
: Yes / No
: Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review