Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/12
GAHC010154202023
2026:GAU-AS:7885DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/324/2023
O.N.G.C. CONTRACTUAL LABOUR UNION
SIVASAGAR, REP. BY PRESIDENT, B.G. ROAD, SIBASAGAR, PIN- 785640,
ASSAM.
VERSUS
OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED AND ANR.
REP. BY THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR AND ASSET MANAGER, ASSAM
ASSET, ONGC LTD., EASTERN REGION, P.O.- NAZIRA, DIST.- SIBASAGAR785645.
2:THE UNION OF INDIA
REP. BY THE SECRETARY GOVT. OF INDIA
MINISTRY OF PETROLEUM AND NATURAL GAS
SHASTRI BHAVAN
NEW DELHI
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. A D GUPTA, MS B DAS
Advocate for the Respondent : DY.S.G.I., MR N ANIX SINGH,MS N K DEVI,MR G N
SAHEWALLA
Linked Case : WA/275/2024
ANJAL CHUTIA AND 13 ORS.
S/O ANJAL CHUTIA
VILLAGE- BOGIDOLE BHAKOT GAON
P.O- BOGIDOLE
P.S- SIVSAGAR
PIN-785697
Page No.# 2/12
DISTRICT- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
2: TULARAM CHARUKIA
S/O GHANAKANTA CHARUKIA
R/O VILL-THOWRA JAPISOJIA
P.S.-DEMOW
DIST-SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN- 785670
3: PRANAB JYOTI CHUTIA
S/O HEMADHOR CHUTIA
R/O VILL- NABA JUWAR
P.O. UDAYANPUR
P.S. DEMOW
DISTRICT- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN- 785662
4: KHAGESWAR CHETIA
S/O LATE SUKHESWAR CHETIA
R/O VILL-THOWRA MAJGAON
PO RAJMAI
P.S.- DEMOW
DIST-SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN- 785672
5: PURUKHUTTAM CHUTIA
S/O NOKUL CHUTIA
R/O VILL- HAHCHARA SOLOGURIA GAON P.O. HAHCHARA
P.S.CHEREKAPAR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN- 785701
6: ARUN CHUTIA
S/O LATE KONBAPU CHUTIA
R/O VILL- HAHCHARA SOLOGURIA GAON P.O. HAHCHARA
P.S.CHEREKAPAR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN- 785701
7: TRILUCHAN GOGOI
S/O ARUN GOGOI
Page No.# 3/12
R/O VILL- HAHCHARA SOLOGURIA GAON P.O. HAHCHARA
P.S.CHEREKAPAR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN- 785701
8: MONUJ RANJAN CHUTIA
S/O LATE BUDHESWAR CHUTIA
R/O VILL- HAHCHARA SOLOGURIA GAON P.O. HAHCHARA
P.S.CHEREKAPAR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN- 785701
9: RANA BORGOHAIN
S/O LATE SUMESWAR BORGOHAIN
R/O VILL-MACHAGARH AMKOTIA DEMOWKINAR
GAON
P.O.-AMKOTIA
P.S.-DEMOW
DIST-SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN- 785697
10: DIPEN DIHINGIA
S/O RAJEN DIHINGIA
RESIDENT OF BETBARI NO
2 KONWAR GAON
PO BETBARI ALIMUR
DIST SIVASAGAR
ASSAM 785640
11: DEBANANDA BORAH
S/O NANDESWAR BORAH
RESIDENT OF HATIMURIA GAON
PO MORABAZAR
PS AMGURI
DIST SIVASAGAR
ASSAM 785680
12: SUNIL BORUAH
S/O LATE LOKNATH BORUAH
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE THOWRA JAPIHAJIA GAON
PO RAJMAI
PS DEMOW DIST SIVASAGAR
Page No.# 4/12
ASSAM785672
13: DIMBESWAR GOGOI
S/O LATE GOPAL GOGOI
RESIDENT OF DEMOW SUKAFA NAGAR (DIHAJAN HABI) PO DEMOW
DIST SIVASAGAR
ASSAM 785662
14: RUPAM KONWAR
S/O BHUBAN KONWAR
RESIDENT OF SANTIPUR RUDAKHY BAM
PO UDOIPUR
PS AND DIST DEMOW
DIST SIVASAGAR
ASSAM 785662
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND ANR.
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY GOVT. OF INDIA
MINISTRY OF PETROLEUM AND NATURAL GAS
SHASTRI BHAWAN
NEW DELHI-1.
2:THE OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED
REPRESENTED BY THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR AND ASSET MANAGER
ASSAM ASSET ONGC LTD. EASTERN REGION PO NAZIRA
DIST SIVSAGAR
ASSAM 785645
-----------Advocate for : MR M H AHMED
Advocate for : MR S CHAKRABORTY(SC
ONGC) appearing for THE UNION OF INDIA AND ANR.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE ASHUTOSH KUMAR
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE ARUN DEV CHOUDHURY
For the Appellants
: Mr. A. Dasgupta, Sr. Advocate assisted by Ms. B.
Das, Advocate in WA No. 324/2023.
Page No.# 5/12
Mr. M. H. Ahmed, Advocate in WA No. 275/2024
For the Respondents
:Mr. G. N. Sahewalla, Senior Advocate.
Mr. N. Anix Singh, Advocate for respondent No. 1
in WA No. 324/2023.
Mr. S. Chakraborty Advocate for respondent No. 2
in WA No. 275/2024.
Date on which Judgment is
Reserved
:
NA
:
04.06.2026
Date of pronouncement of
Judgment
Whether the pronouncement
is of the operative part of the
Judgment
:
NA.
Whether the full Judgment has
been pronounced
:
Yes.
Page No.# 6/12
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
(A.D.Choudhury, J)
1.
The present intra-court appeals arise from the judgment and order of
the learned single Judge, dismissing the common judgment dated
08.06.2023 passed in WP(C) 6045/2016 and WP(C) 1794/2022
dismissing the writ petitions instituted by the appellants Union and
similarly situated contractual workers respectively, seeking a direction
upon Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited, (here in after referred
to as ONGC) to accord the benefit of an industrial award dated
25.09.2014, in the event of their future engagement, who had been
disengaged prior to 01.04.2012.
2.
The dispute has its genesis in an industrial reference, raised before the
Central Government Industrial Tribunal, concerning the wages and
service conditions of contractual labourers engaged in the operations
of ONGC.
3.
During the pendency of the reference, a settlement was arrived at
between the management and the representative Union in the course
of conciliation proceedings. The settlement culminated in an award
dated 25.09.2014, passed by the Tribunal.
4.
The settlement/award specifically provided that the benefit of job
Page No.# 7/12
security would be available to contract workers, who had been
engaged on 24.06.2008 and continued in engagement till the relevant
date, as well as those engaged on 01.01.2011, who had continued till
the date of settlement.
The settlement further contemplated that whenever a contractor was
replaced, the list of eligible workers would be made available to the
incoming contractor for their engagement.
5.
The grievance of the appellants is that a class of workers who were
initially engaged before 24.06.2008 but ceased to be engaged before
01.04.2012 have been excluded from the benefit of future
engagement.
6.
According to the appellants, notwithstanding the terms of settlement,
such workers are entitled to preferential consideration whenever fresh
contractual engagements are made.
7.
The learned single Judge declined the relief sought. The court held that
a settlement, having been reached during conciliation proceedings and
subsequently forming part of the award, was binding upon all
concerned.
8.
Assailing the judgment, Mr. A Dasgupta, learned Senior counsel
appearing on behalf of the appellants, has submitted that the
settlement ought to be interpreted in a manner that advances the
Page No.# 8/12
objective of job security.
9.
It has been urged that the concept of ‘principal employer’ under the
Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1970, the ONGC
herein, must protect the rights of contractual labourers and that the
principal underlying section 25H of the Industrial Dispute Act should be
extended to workers who had earlier rendered service in ONGC
establishment through contractors.
Reliance has also been placed on the circumstance that the number of
workers presently covered by the settlement has substantially
diminished, thereby justifying an equitable direction in favour of the
appellants.
On the other hand, Mr. GN Sahewalla, learned Senior counsel and Mr.
S. Chakraborty, learned counsel, appearing for the ONGC, have
supported the judgment under appeal WA No 324/2023 and WA
275/2024 respectively.
10.
It has been submitted that settlement represents a negotiated
resolution of an industrial dispute; that the settlement was reached
through a conciliation; that the award merely incorporated the agreed
terms; and that no relief inconsistent with those terms can be granted
unless the settlement or award itself is successfully challenged.
11.
It is further contended that section 25H has no application to
Page No.# 9/12
contractual labourers, who do not come within the definition of a
retrenched workman within the meaning of the statute.
12.
The rival submissions now fall for consideration.
13.
Industrial jurisprudence in India places significant emphasis on
collective bargaining and negotiated settlements. The statutory
framework recognises that industrial peace is often best achieved not
through adjudication but through consensus. It is for this reason that
settlements arrived at in the closure of conciliation proceedings are
accorded a special status under section 18(3) of the Industrial Dispute
Act.
14.
Such settlements are not confined to signatories alone; they bind all
persons falling within the ambit of the industrial dispute.
15.
The Honourable Apex Court has consistently recognised that a
settlement reached in conciliation proceedings acquires an extended
and binding operation.
16.
Thus, the rationale is self-evident. Once the parties to an industrial
dispute negotiate and reach a mutually acceptable resolution, the law
attributes finality to the outcome to preserve industrial harmony and
certainty in labour relations.
17.
The binding nature of such settlements cannot be diluted merely
because, over time, a section of workers perceives the negotiated
Page No.# 10/12
terms as inadequate.
18.
In the present case, the settlement expressly confined the benefit of
job security to those workers identified in numbers who satisfied the
stipulated conditions of engagement and continuity. The cut-off dates
were neither accidental nor incidental. They constituted an essential
component of the bargaining reached between the parties.
19.
A writ Court, in exercise of its power of judicial review under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, cannot ignore those stipulations and
create an additional category of beneficiaries which the settlement
itself does not contemplate.
To do so would be to rewrite the settlement rather than interpret it.
Significantly, neither the validity of the settlement nor the legality of
the award has been challenged.
20.
The appellants seek to derive rights under the settlement while
simultaneously inviting the Court to enlarge its scope. Such a course is
impermissible. If the grievance lies in the settlement, the remedy must
be directed against the settlement itself. So long as it stands, the Court
must give it effect as negotiated.
21. Equally unpersuasive is the reliance placed upon Section 25 H of the
Industrial Dispute Act by the learned Senior Counsel for the Appellants.
22. The provision embodies a statutory preference in favour of retrenched
Page No.# 11/12
workmen when an employer proposes to fill vacancies. The provision
operates within a distinct legal context and is predicated upon
retrenchment.
23. The present proceeding does not arise from a case of retrenchment.
More importantly, the invocation of section 25 H cannot be used as a
vehicle to override the express terms of a settlement that has attained
statutory finality.
24.
The learned Senior counsel for the appellants has laid particular
emphasis on the clause in the award providing that, in future
contracts, the Award shall be applicable. It has been urged that once
the settlement was required to be incorporated in future contracts, the
appellants acquired an enforceable right to be considered for
engagement wherever fresh engagements were undertaken.
25. We are unable to accept such a submission. The clause requiring the
incorporation of the settlement into future contracts cannot be read in
isolation but must be construed as a whole. The obligation to
incorporate the settlement in future contracts was intended to ensure
implementation of the rights and benefits created under the
settlement.
26. It was not intended to enlarge the class of beneficiaries beyond those
specifically identified therein. Thus, incorporation of settlement into
future contractual engagements cannot be interpreted as creating an
Page No.# 12/12
independent source of entitlement in favour of a person who
admittedly falls outside the eligibility criteria.
27. At the same time, such a clause cannot be rendered negatively. Once
such conditions are incorporated into future notices inviting tenders
and into contractual arrangements, every workman engaged pursuant
thereto would be governed by the contractual and statutory regime
arising from the settlement. Therefore, while the appellants cannot
claim a right to be treated as continuing beneficiaries of the settlement
for the period during which they admittedly remain disengaged and
outside its protective ambit, it is clarified that in the event any of the
appellants are engaged afresh under any future contract in which
settlement conditions have been incorporated, they shall be entitled to
all benefits available thereunder from the date of such engagement
but shall not confer any claim to continuity of service, notional
benefits, back wages, seniority or any other retrospective advantage
for the period preceding such fresh engagement.
28. For the reasons aforesaid, we find no infirmity in the judgment of the
learned Single Judge warranting interference in the appeals.
29. The appeals are accordingly dismissed. Parties to bear their own cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review