Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
07.07.2026
Item No.1 & 2
Ct. No. 30
Piya
WPA 27424 of 2024
with
CAN 1 of 2025
Vodafone Idea Limited & Anr.
Vs.
Regional Provident Fund CommissionerII/Recovery Officer, Employees’ Provident Fund
Organization & Ors.
WITH
WPA 27799 of 2024
Aniruddha Banerjee
Vs.
Regional Provident Fund CommissionerII/Recovery Officer, Employees’ Provident Fund
Organization & Ors.
Mr. Soumya Majumdar, ld. Sr. Adv.
Mr. Deepan Kr. Sarkar
Ms. Ashika Daga
Ms. Sanchali Bhowmik
Ms. Urrvi Chowla
...for the petitioners
Mr. Biswaroop Bhattacahrya
Mr. Sohom Saha
… for the applicant
in CAN 1 of 2025
Ms. Aparna Banerjee
… for the respondent/
P.F. Authority
Mr. Srijib Chakraborty
Ms. Urmila Chakraborty
Mr. Pankaj Agarwal
Ms. Champa Pal
… for the respondent no. 4
in WPA 27424 of 2024
Mr. Srijib Chakraborty
Ms. Urmila Chakraborty
Mr. Pankaj Agarwal
Ms. Champa Pal
… for the petitioner
in WPA 27799 of 2024
Mr. Sujit Sankar Koley
Mr. Swagatam Deb
… for the WBSEDCL
1.
The petitioners case herein is that in the year
2014, Vodafone Idea Limited (hereinafter
referred to as "the petitioner no.1") entered
into a service agreement with M/s Shomuk
Engineering
&
Consultancy
(hereinafter
referred
to
as
"the
Services
private
respondent") as a service provider for the
purpose of rendering services to the petitioner
no.1 as and when required. The service
agreement was subsisting till the period of
August, 2018.
2.
On 6th April, 2023, an order was passed by
the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner- I
/ Recovery Officer, Employees' Provident
Fund Organization, Ministry of Labour and
Employment, Union of India, in a proceeding
being E-Court Diary No. 83/2017, wherein
the private respondent was directed to pay an
amount of Rs. 1,81,34,381/- (Rupees One
Crore Eight ne Lakhs Thirty Four Thousand
and Three Hundred and Eighty-One) to the
respondent no. 2 in lieu of the statutory
contributions for some of its employees under
Section 7A of the Employees' Provident Funds
and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952.
3.
Admittedly in the said proceeding the
petitioners were not put on notice and
thus were not heard.
4.
The proceeding under Section 7A of the EPF
Act was conducted in respect of the private
respondent no. 4’s establishment herein, the
contractor who was engaged by the petitioner
no.
1 herein and thus the petitioner no. 1
became the principal employer.
5.
In the proceeding under Section 7A of the
EPF Act, the authority observed/held in
respect
of
the
respondent
no.
4’s
establishment as follows:“The hearings were prolonged mainly due
to delayed submission of necessary records
by the establishment. It did not submit the
records required in the hearings easily and
repeated adjournments were sought for
tracing the documents leading to prolonging
the Instant hearing. The proceedings under
section 7A were continued from 30.10.2017
to 13.03.2019 due to non appearance of
establishment
and
non
submission
or
partial submission of necessary records. Srl
T. P. Niroula, E.O. submitted his report on
12.03.2019 which was placed in the 7A
hearing dated 13.03.2019. The report of E.
O. was found to be Incomplete. It was
found that the basic wages of EPF
members were kept very low and rest of
the remuneration was paid in form of
different allowances for which EPF was
not paid by the employer. Therefore,
the element of subterfuge in wage
splitting was apprehended.”
6.
Finally it has been recorded in the order as
follows:“9. Sri Sanjay Biswas, (EO), submitted
his final report on 18.01.2023 copy of
which
was
forwarded
to
the
establishment. In the 7A hearing dated
23.01.2023
the
proprietor
of
the
establishment, Sri Aniruddha Banerjee
accepted the receipt of the report dated
18.01.2023.
Sri
Banerjee
further
stated that the establishment has no
objection
on
the
Enforcement
quantum
finding
Officer
of
Accordingly
the
and
dues
the
of
the
payable.
hearings
were
closed.
12 a) The establishment M/S Shomuk
Engineering & Consultancy Services is a
Sole Proprietorship concern having five
units. These five units have separate
EPF Code numbers issued by different
Regional Offices in different Political
States. A single Balance Sheet is
maintained for all these five units
and therefore scrutiny of Balance Sheet
for the whole establishment is of little
use for assessing EPF liabilities of its
Kolkata Unit having EPF Code Number
WB/PRB/40096.
b) The business activities of Kolkata Unit
of the establishment are supply of
Manpower
establishment
to
certain
and
other
execution
engineering and construction work.
of
c) The EPF liabilities of the Kolkata Unit
of the establishment having Code No.
WB/PRB/40096 for the notice period
have been assessed on the basis of
report
of
Enforcement
Officer
dated
07.09.2017 (based on which the instant
7A proceedings have been initiated), EO
report dated
financial
03.05.2019, records of
transactions
of
the
establishment like Ledger Head Site
Expenses, Vouchers and Bills, Salary
Sheet of labour charges involved, copies
of work orders/agreements made by the
establishment
with
different
parties,
clarifications about different types of
expenses incurred by the establishment
and the comprehensive report of Sri
Sanjay Biswas, E. O. dated 18.01.2023
and his clarification dated 10.03.2023.
d) Salary Sheet of on roll employees
deployed in various establishments
reveal that conveyance allowances paid
to the employees are abnormally high,
varying from 18% to 65% of Basic Pay.
This is obvious case of subterfuge on
part of the establishment to reduce
its PF liability. Hence EPF liability is
being
assessed
on
conveyance
allowances paid to the employees over
and above 10% limit of Basic Pay subject
to statutory ceiling of Rs 15000 per
month. Month wise dues assessed for
EPF chargeable conveyance allowance
(greater than 10% of basic salary) from
September 2014 to August 2017 has
been summarised in Annex-A, copies of
which has already been provided to
employer. The employer has accepted
the dues payable on hearing dated
23.01.2023.
e) Ledger head of the establishment for
the period 07/2015 to 03/2016 and for
the period 04/2016 to 12/2016 shows
that labour
Rajarhat
payment
Site
by
was
made
ongoing
at
sub
contractors. Since details of labour
charges are available in office records,
assessment
of
establishment
liability
has
of
been
the
made.
Contractor wise and Month wise EPF
dues for evaded employees (by their
name) has been summarised in AnnexB. Copy of the said list has been provide
to the employer and the dues payable
by the employer has been accepted
on hearing dated 23.01.2023.
f) Similarly other dues like month wise
cite expense dues and dues to several
sub-contractors have been summarised
in Annex - C, D, E and F. These figures
have
been
provided
establishment
and
the
to
the
same
has
been accepted by it on hearing dated
23.01.2023.
14.
Accordingly,
I,
Tushar
Kant
Mukherjee, Regional Provident Fund
Commissioner-I
in
exercise
of
the
powers conferred on me under Section
7A of the Act, having gone through the
facts of the case and submissions made
hereby
determine
an
amount
of
Rs.1,81,34,381/- (Rupees One Crore
Eighty
One
Lakh
Thirty
Four
Thousand Three Hundred and Eighty
One
Only)
to
establishment
be
paid
M/S
by
the
Shomuk
Engineering
L
and
Consultancy
Services under section 7A of the EPF
and MP Acts, 1952.”
7.
On 3rd September, 2024, the petitioner no.1
received a letter from the private respondent,
which stated that the petitioner no.1 was
liable
to
make
certain
payment
to
the
employees of the private respondent. No
reason was given in the letter as to the basis
for raising such claim on the erstwhile
Vodafone entities/petitioner no.1 especially
when all due and payable amounts were
paid by the petitioner no. 1 to the private
respondent.
8.
The impugned notice carried an attachment
being a purported assessment order bearing
Reference E-Court Diary No. 83/2017 dated
6th April, 2023 passed by the respondent no.
whereby
directed
to
the
pay
private
an
respondent
was
amount
Rs.
of
1,81,34,381/- to the respondent no. 2 in lieu
of non-payment of statutory contributions for
some of its employees.
9.
The impugned notice referred to in the
impugned order, had been passed solely
against the private respondent. Despite this,
vide the impugned notice dated 6th Nov, 2024,
the petitioner no.1 was called upon to clear
the dues of the employees of the private
respondent in the capacity of a principal
employer. The petitioner no.1, was further
directed to remit its alleged share of the said
purported dues of Rs. 1,49,89,347/- through
DD/BC in favour of Regional Provident Fund
Commissioner (“RPFC").
10. The
impugned
letter
herein
dated
06.11.2024, issued by the respondent P.F.
authorities
is
scanned
and
reproduced
herein:-
11. The authority has referred to Section 8(A)(1)
of the EPF & MP Act, which refers to how a
principal
employer
has
to
recover
the
statutory dues from the contractor, who is
liable to pay the same, after the principal
employer pays the outstanding dues (liability)
of the contractor.
12. The respondent no. 4 herein, being the
petitioner
in
WPA
27799
of
has
challenged the order under Section 7A of the
EPF & MP Act dated 06.04.2023, on the
ground that the establishment/contractor
herein has not received the wages including
total
statutory
dues
from
the
principal
employer and as such is not in a position to
pay any amount.
13. The
respondent
no.
relies
upon
the
provision of Para 30(3) of the EPF scheme, to
state that it is the responsibility of the
principal
employer
to
pay
both
the
contribution.
14. It appears that as per Para 30(2) of the
scheme, the duty of the contractor herein is
to recover the contribution payable by such
employees and pay the same to the principal
employer.
15. The
authority
06.04.2023
proceeded
then
in
the
order
dated
under Section 7A of the Act,
to
manipulation
probe
into
the
of
wages
issue
by
of
the
establishment (contractor respondent no.
herein)
to
eliminate
possibility
of
subterfuge.
16. While doing so, it appears that the authority
considered copies of agreements made by the
establishment (contractor respondent no. 4
herein) with the petitioner Vodafone and with
WBSEDCL.
17. On
16.10.2019,
establishment/respondent
no. 4 submitted copies of invoices of sub
contractors and cash vouchers for the period
under reference, before the P.F. authorities.
18. The findings in Para 12(d) of the said order
under Section 7A of the Act shows that salary
sheets were placed in respect of on roll
employees
deployed
in
various
establishment, which also showed there was
subterfuge on part of the establishment to
reduce it’s PF liability. This proves that the
establishment was duly paid by the principal
employer, the petitioner no. 1 herein and the
salary
sheets
submitted
by
the
establishment, shows the disbursement of
salary
along
with
establishment
allowances
herein
in
by
the
various
establishments.
19. It further appears that a single balance sheet
is maintained for the five units of the
respondent no. 5 in different states.
20. In
Para
12(d),
the
employer/contractor/respondent no. 4 has
accepted the dues payable on the hearing
dated 23.01.2023 and the same has been
also recorded in Para 12(f) as follows:f) Similarly other dues like month wise
cite expense dues and dues to several
sub-contractors have been summarised
in Annex - C, D, E and F. These figures
have been provided to the establishment
and the same has been accepted by it
on hearing dated 23.01.2023.
21. Para 12(e) in the said order shows there
were sub contractors engaged.
e) Ledger head of the establishment for
the period 07/2015 to 03/2016 and for
the period 04/2016 to 12/2016 shows
that labour
Rajarhat
payment
Site
by
was
made
ongoing
at
sub
contractors. Since details of labour
charges are available in office records,
assessment
establishment
of
liability
has
been
of
the
made.
Contractor wise and Month wise EPF
dues for evaded employees (by their
name) has been summarised in Annex-B.
Copy of the said list has been provide to
the employer and the dues payable by
the employer has been accepted on
hearing dated 23.01.2023.
22. On hearing, the parties and considering the
materials on record, the issue in WPA 27424
of 2024 is taken up for consideration.
23. The service agreement between the parties
being part of the writ petition contains the
clauses relevant herein, which are:“3.1 The service provider shall be
responsible for paying salary to the
associates for the services rendered
by the associates to Vodafone under
this Agreement and Vodafone shall
not
be
responsible
for
paying
salary or any other outgoings to
the associates.
3.2 The Service Provider shall raise
an invoice every month on respective
Vodafone Entities for the respective
Telecom Service Areas detailing the
Service Fee & other reimbursement
which, shall be inclusive of all taxes,
levies
and
statutory
payments
except the service tax which shall be
extra.”
24. These clauses clearly show that the petitioner
no. 1 herein did not have the responsibility to
pay salary or any other outgoings to the
associates (employees) including statutory
payments.
25. The responsibility was of the respondent no.
4 (service provider) in the agreement and as
per clause 3.2, the service provider would
raise invoice for reimbursement on the
respective
principal
employers
which
would include statutory payments.
26. The fact that salary was paid by the
establishment/respondent no. 4 has been
corroborated by the findings of the authority
under Section 7A EPF & MP Act as discussed
earlier herein.
27. Thus the contention of the respondent no. 4
that as the petitioner did not make payment,
they could not do so, is not correct. Not only
was salary paid by the respondent no. 4,
manipulation of wages and subterfuge was
also found on the part of the establishment
by
the
authority
on
hearing
the
establishment.
28. Admittedly the petitioner no. 1 herein was not
made a party to the proceeding under Section
7A of the EPF & MP Act and as such the
claim of the respondent no. 4 (establishment)
and that of the P.F. Authorities herein vide
their letter dated 06.11.2024 is
a clear
abuse of the process of law.
29. The said letter dated 06.11.2024 refers to the
assessment order under Section 7A of the Act
against the establishment/respondent no. 4
herein, in which the petitioner admittedly was
not a party.
30. The assessment order further mentions that
“these dues belong to employees, who have
worked under various principal employers
one of which is M/s Vodafone Idea Pvt. Ltd.”
and this shows that the petitioner herein is
not the only/sole principal employer for
the dues as assessed.
31. This again is a vague observation, which puts
the liability upon the petitioner no. 1 herein,
in spite of holding that:i.
The assessment order under Section 7A
of the EPF & MP Act was against the
establishment/respondent no. 4.
ii.
The dues in the said assessment order
belong to employees, who have worked
under various principal employers,
one of which is the petitioner herein
as admitted by the respondent no. 4 as
petitioner in WPA 27799 of 2024.
32. In WPA 27799 of 2024, the Petitioner is a
proprietorship concern and a supplier of
Management Services, Manpower Service and
Works Contract Service to Government, Local
Authority, Non-Government entities, etc. The
details of the parties are as per following:(a) The West Bengal Power Development
Corporation
Limited
(GSTIN
19AABCT3027C1DZ);
(b) WBSEDCL, Midnapore Zonal Office
(GSTIN 19CALM05977G1D0);
(c)
West
Distribution
19CALW029
Bengal
Company
State
Limited
Electricity
(GSTIN
(d) Ministry of External Affairs;
(e) RITES Ltd;
(f) Tractor India (now Gainwell India);
(g) Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd;
(h) Vodafone Spacetel Ltd; and
(i) Vodafone Idea Limited, Kolkata.
It is stated that many of these companies are
managed
and
owned
either
by
the
Government of India or any of the State
Governments or big MNCs.
33. The reference to Section 8(A)(1) of the EPF &
MP Act, in the letter/order dated 06.11.2024,
remains
a
question,
considering
the
reference/findings in the order under Section
7A of Act, as to sub-contractors being
engaged by the establishment (contractor),
in which case the contractor becomes the
principal
employer
to
the
said
sub
contractors.
34. In spite of such finding, the authority has
referred to the provisions under Section
8(A)(1)
of
the
EPF
&
MP
Act
in
the
letter/order dated 06.11.2024, while putting
the liability on the petitioner no. 1 herein for
the dues of the respondent no. 4, which is
also against the terms and conditions in the
service agreement between the parties and
also the fact that the assessment was made
in respect of various principal employers.
35. As
such
the
impugned
order
dated
06.11.2024, which suffers from erroneous
findings as noted above being bad in law is
hereby quashed and set aside.
36. WPA 27424 of 2024 is thus allowed.
37. In respect of the WPA 27799 of 2024, the
establishment/contractor has not made the
principal employer a party to the writ
application but has prayed for leave to add
Vodafone Idea limited, prayer (d), Tractor India
(now Gainwell India Ltd.) prayer (e) and Zee
Entertainment Enterprises Ltd., prayer (f) as
parties.
38. Respondent no. 5 Rail India Technical and
Economic Services (RITES) and Respondent no.
6 West Bengal State Electricity Board are
already on record as added respondents.
39. In
the
present
writ
application,
the
establishment as petitioner, has admitted that
he
works
contractor/
as
immediate
several
employer
with
companies/governmental
agencies (principal employers) even though in
WPA 27799 of 2024, the argument by the
learned counsel for the respondent no. 4
therein being the petitioner herein, is that, only
the petitioner Vodafone Idea Ltd. therein, is
liable for the dues, even though the assessment
was admittedly done in respect of various
principal employers by the authority and as
admitted by the establishment petitioner
herein.
40. The
relief
prayed
respondents/P.F.
for
is
authorities
that
the
should
not
proceed against the establishment beyond the
amount/sum of Rs. 38,09,646 and for setting
aside of the assessment order dated April 06,
2023, under Section 7A of the EPF & MP Act.
41. Mr. Majumder, learned senior counsel has
placed several copies of order sheets and a list
of dates in WPA 27424 of 2024 and submits
that WPA 27799 of 2024 has been filed
challenging the same impugned order dated
06.04.2023 and a prayer claiming limited
liability by suppressing that the issue were
raised in an earlier writ application being
WPA 21772 of 2023 wherein also Vodafone
was not a party.
42. The establishment in the said writ application
(WPA 21772 of 2023) prayed for installment
facility
considering
that
it
had
accepted/admitted the dues assessed under
Section 7A of the Act before the authority
and the authority had recorded the same in
the said order.
43. In the order dated 20.09.2023 in WPA 21772
of 2023, it was recorded by the Court as
follows:“Mr.
Bhattacharyya,
learned
advocate
representing the petitioner submits that the
petitioner is not interested to question
the order dated 6th April, 2023, passed
under Section 7A of the said Act and the
petitioner
accepts
the
determination
made.”
44. The
Court
directed
that
the
establishment/petitioner therein to place a
cheque for a sum of Rs. 50,00,000/- in the
name of RPF.
45. On the next date fixed for hearing an
undated cheque was placed. The Court on
noting that the petitioner there in could not
establish his bonafide, dismissed the writ
application.
46. In appeal, being MAT 41/42 of 2025, the
Hon’ble
Division
Bench
vide
order
dated
14.01.2025 recorded as follows:“6. The September 20, 2023 order
recorded
that
the
petitioner,
as
represented by his counsel, was not
interested to question the impugned
order dated April 6, 2023 passed under
Section 7A of the Employees’ Provident
Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions
Act, 1952.
8.
Under
such
circumstances,
on
November 26, 2024, the proprietor of
the appellant-firm, who was present in
court, instructed his learned senior
counsel to pray for time for two weeks
within which he shall unconditionally
(emphasis in original order) pay the
assessed
amount
under
the
impugned assessment order dated
April 6, 2023 to the Provident Fund
Authority after adjustment of the
amount
already
paid
by
the
contractor to the Provident Fund
Authority.
18. The appellant, unequivocally
gave undertaking several times over
before the learned Single Judge
that
he
was
not
interested
in
assailing the impugned order of
assessment
but
unconditionally
pay
would
the
amount
within a limited period, which was
further extended from time to time
at
the
behest
of
the
appellant
having
specifically
himself.
19.
Thus,
after
submitted before the learned Single
Judge that he does not intend to
challenge the assessment order, the
appellant cannot be permitted to
resile
from
such
specific
undertaking given before the court
on the flimsy pretext that there
cannot be any estoppel against the
law. The assessment order cannot
be reopened at this stage at the
behest of the appellant himself.
21. The undertaking which was given
unequivocally before a court of law to
obtain the advantage of buying time for
the purpose of making payment in
terms of the assessment order is not
restricted
to
estoppel
but
has
crystallized into an order of court
based
on
concession.
the
The
appellant’s
present
appeals
are, thus a clear attempt to resile
from the same, which tantamounts
to nothing less than contempt of
court.
23. A larger underlying factor involved
here is that the delay in making such
payments directly and adversely
affects the concerned employees,
who are being deprived of their
provident fund dues, which is also
one of the considerations which
ought to be borne in mind while
deciding the present appeals.
25. The learned Single Judge was
perfectly
within
his
rights
and
jurisdiction to accept the undertaking of
the appellant in good faith and merely
grant further time to make payments to
the appellant on the latter’s plea to
make such payments of the assessed
amount.”
47. The appeals were then dismissed by the Hon’ble
Division Bench.
48. In spite of such findings by the Hon’ble Division
Bench, the petitioner (establishment) has once
again approached this Court, assailing the self
same order dated 06.04.2023 under Section 7A
of the EPF & MP Act by suppressing the orders
passed in the earlier writ application and
appeals, which is still in force and holds good
till date.
49. The
said
establishment
conduct/suppression
/petitioner
is
by
the
not
only
contemptuous, but is also abuse of the process
of law, in /before a Court of law.
50. Considering the said facts, the writ application
being WPA 27799 of 2024 having no merit is
dismissed on contest.
51. Connected application, if any, stands disposed
of.
52. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
53. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this Order, if
applied
for,
be
supplied
to
the
parties
expeditiously after due compliance.
(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review