Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:2050
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ORDER RESERVED ON 01.12.2025
ORDER DELIVERED ON 13.01.2026
ORDER UPLOADED ON 13.01.2026
MCRC No. 8313 of 2025
1 - Anil Tuteja S/o Late H.L. Tuteja Aged About 62 Years R/o House
No.35/1396, Beside Farishta Nursing Home, Katora Talab, Civil Lines,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
... Applicant(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Station House Officer Police Station
Eow/acb, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
For Applicant (s)
:
Arshdeep Singh Khurana, Shri Harsh
Shrivastava and Shri Chetan Nagpal
Advocates through VC assisted by Shri
Saurabh Dangi, Advocate
For Respondent/EOW
:
Dr. Saurabh Pande, Dy. AG for the
respondent/State.
(HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE ARVIND KUMAR VERMA)
C A V Order
The applicant has preferred the instant application under Section
483 of the Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 seeking grant of
regular bail in FIR No. 01/2024 dated 17.01.2024 registered at police
station EOW/ACB, Raipur (hereinafter referred to as “subject FIR” or
“said FIR”) for offences under Sections 384,409,120-B of the IPC, 1860
read with Sections 11,13(1)(a) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988 pending before the learned Special Judge (PC Act) and First
Additional Sessions Judge, Raipur.
2.
The applicant had earlier preferred a bail application under
Section 483 of the BNSS dated 07.08.2025 before the learned Trial
Court which was erroneously rejected vide order dated 22.08.2025. The
applicant is therefore invoking the inherent jurisdiction of this Court
against the said order impugned.
BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE :
3.
The genesis of the instant case lies in the alleged “Custom Rice
Milling Scam” in Chhattisgarh which traces its origin to Income Tax
Department raids conducted on 21.08.2023 wherein
Complaint was filed
a Prosecution
against 8 specific persons - conspicuously, the
applicant was neither targeting eight persons notably, the applicant was
never named. Acting on ED’s letter dated 09.01.2024 under Section
66(2) of the PMLA, Respondent No.2 registered the subject FIR on
16.01.2024 and the applicant has still not arraigned as accused.
Subsequently vide letter dated 09.01.2024 under Section 66(2) of the
Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, the ED forwarded material
to the respondent pursuant to which the subject FIR No. 01/2024 dated
16.01.2024
came to be registered at PS EOW/ACB, Raipur initially
under Sections 120-B and 409 IPC read with Sections 11, 13(1)(a) and
13(2) of the PC Act, shockingly the applicant was not named as an
accused even in the FIR.
4.
Despite over 1.5 years of exhaustive investigation spanning from
from 16.01.2024 to 09.07.2025, the respondent EOW/ACB never once
summoned, questioned or interrogated the applicant in relation to the
subject FIR thereby underscoring the complete absence of any
perceived necessity or urgency for his arrest.
respondent filed its first charge sheet
On 01.02.2025, the
under Section 173 BNSS
exclusively against two principal co-accused namely Manoj Soni (MD,
MARKFED
and
Roshan
Chandrakar,
Association) wherein certain vague and
(Treasurer,
Rice
Millers
unsubstantiated allegations
were levelled against the applicant without formally arraigning him as an
accused, strategically keeping the doors open for a future arrest. It was
only on 6.10.2025 much after the applicant’s arrest that a supplementary
charge sheet was filed naming the applicant and mechanically adding
Section 384 IP?C to the array of offences thereby completing the
investigation qua him.
5.
The applicant’s protracted incarceration however, predates the
subject FIR and stems from a parallel and entirely distinct “liquor scam”
investigation. The applicant was first arrested on 21.04.2024 by the Ed
in relation to a separate ECIR pertaining to the alleged liquor scam, an
arrest which the Hon’ble Apex Court deprecated as “disturbing” and
“glaring”, reflecting gross abuse of process. Consequent thereto, the
applicant faced arrests in the Chhattisgarh Liquor FIR (by the
EOW/ACB) and UP Liquor FIR (by UP Police) with the latter being
declared illegal by the Allahabad High Court. The applicant secured
regular bail in two these three cases and his bail application in the third
and final case (Chhattisgarh Liquor FIR) was listed for hearing before
the Apex court on 18.07.2025. It is in this precarious context mere one
week prior to the scheduled hearing, apprehending imminent release
that the respondent effected a brazen “insurance arrest” of the applicant
on 09.07.2025 in the subject FIR without any prior interrogation or
questioning whatsoever over 1.5 years of probe, furnishing merely a
vague, half page non speaking grounds of arrest memo which is a
blatant violation of the sacrosanct safeguards under Article 22(1) of the
Constitution.
6.
The calculated modus operandi of the respondent agencies in
perpetuating the applicant’s custody through “ever-greening arrests”
stands exposed through the following irrefutable chronology of events
which this Court may graciously take notice of :
Date
Event Demonstrating Mala Fides
21.08.2023
IT Prosecution Complaint filed against 8 persons
(applicant unnamed)
14.10.2023
ED registers Rice ECIR/RPZO/04/2023 (applicant
unnamed.
16.01.2024
Subject FIR
unnamed)
21.04.2024
Applicant first arrested in ED Liquor scam case
(termed “disturbing” by Apex Court).
28.06.2024
ED files Prosecution Complaint in Rice ECIR
(applicant unnamed).
25.09.2024
Respondent files false affidavit before the Apex
registered
by
ACB
(applicant
Court falsely claiming applicant’s role in”scams”
(no material annexed).
04.11.2024
Co-accused Manoj Soni and Roshan Chandrakar
arrested in the subject ECIR
01.02.2025
First charge sheet filed (Applicant implicated
vaguely but unnamed).
09.05.2025
Manoj Soni granted regular bail by this Court
(MCRC No. 2078/2025)
20.05.2025
Supreme Court grants ACB final 2 months to
complete liquor FIR probe;matter listed on
18.07.2025
09.07.2025
Insurance arrest of applicant in subject FIR (no
prior questioning despite 1.5 years probe.
18.07.2025
Roshan Chandrakar granted regular bail by this
Court in M.Cr.C. No. 6581/2025
6.10.2025
Supplementary charge sheet filed against the
applicant (investigation qua him complete).
7.
The applicant has already undergone over 134 days of
incarceration in the subject FIR alone, with the charge sheet qua him
stands filed; more than 350 witnesses cited alongside hundreds of
documents and further investigation is still ongoing-rendering charge
framing and trial commencement a remote possibility in the foreseeable
future. Such indefinite pretrial detention without recovery of incriminating
material from the applicant constitutes cruel and unusual punishment
infringing the inviolable right to liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution
of India.
SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE APPLICANT
8.
Without prejudice to the above narration of the facts, learned
counsel for the Applicant submits as under:
Learned Senior Counsel submits that the present application
deserves to be allowed as the continued incarceration of the applicant is
manifestly illegal, unconstitutional, arbitrary and punitive, offending
Articles 14,21 and 22(1) of the Constitution of India, and contrary to the
settled principles governing arrest and grant of bail.
The applicant
seeks enlargement on regular bail in FIR No. 01/2024 registered at
police station EOW/ACB, Raipur for the alleged offences under Sections
3894,409,120-B IPC read with Sections 11,13(1)(a) and 13(2) of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
I.
Parity with Co-accused : It is submitted that the applicant's case
stands on a far better footing as the bedrock of the prosecution case
rests entirely on the principal co-accused, namely Manoj Soni (MD,
MARKFED)
and
Roshan
Chandrakar
(Treasurer,
Rice
Millers
Association) both of whom have been granted regular bail by this Court
after enduring substantial periods of incarceration. Every single
allegation against the applicant is derivative, stemming exclusively from
statements of these co-accused whose own conviction this Court has
categorically held to be “uncertain”. The entire prosecution narrative
admittedly rests upon these two individuals. The allegations against the
present applicant are purely derivative, flowing only from the
statements of co-accused, whose conviction this Court itself has held to
be “uncertain”. Parity is not a matter of discretion but a constitutional
imperative flowing from Article 14. Denial of parity in identical factual
circumstances amounts to hostile discrimination and shocks the judicial
conscience.
9.
If the fountainhead is impure, the steam cannot be pristine. Parity
is not discretionary but a mandate of Article 14 - denial thereof shocks
judicial conscience (State of Kerala Vs. Raneef, (2011) 1 SCC 78;
Vijay Kumar Vs. State of UP 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1125;
Chandrakeshwar Prasad Vs. State of Bihar, 2024 SCC OnLine SC
1567.
II. The arrest of the Applicant is patently illegal and vitiated,
malicious and in gross violation of Article 22(1) of the Constitution:
The so called grounds of arrest dated 09.07.2025 constitute a derisory
half page, vague, non-speaking and boiler-plate document that
discloses absolutely no specific necessity, urgency or material
particulars justifying the arrest. Despite 1.5 years of exhaustive
investigation, the applicant was :
never summoned;
never interrogated;
never questioned prior to arrest.
10.
The so called “grounds of arrest” is a vague, half page, non-
speaking document, disclosing no material particulars or necessity for
arrest rendering it constitutionally invalid. The Apex Court has
categorically held that communication of grounds must be real,
meaningful and complete,not ritualistic. Reliance is placed on
•
Prabir Prukayastha Vs.State (NCT of Delhi), (2024) 8 SCC 254
•
Vihan Kumar Vs. State of Haryana, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 269
•
Ashish Kakkar Vs. UT of Chandigarh, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1318
•
Mihir Rajesh Shah Vs. State of Maharashtra , Cr.A. No.
2195/2025.
The timing of arrest-one week prior to the applicant's bail hearing
before the Apex Court clearly exposes a brazen “insurance arrest”,
deprecated by constitutional courts.
III. No Necessity for Arrest-Investigation Already complete.
11.
There existed no statutory or investigative necessity to arrest
the applicant. The investigation qua the applicant stands completed;
Supplementary charge sheet filed on 06.10.2025; No recovery pending;
Entire evidence is documentary and secured. Arrest merely to justify
custody is impermissible. Reliance is placed on Gautam Navlakha Vs.
State (NCT of Delhi), 2021 SCC OnLine SC 99 and Satender Kumar
Antil Vs. CBI (2022) 10 SCC 51.
IV. Absence of Prosecution Sanction renders continued custody of
the applicant legally Untenable and illegal: Respondent/EOW has
categorically admitted that prosecution sanction stands sought but not
yet obtained qua the Applicant. No cognizance of offence whatsoever
can be taken by the learned Special Judge without a valid prosecution
sanction under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. Int he absence of
sanction :
•
Cognizance is legally barred;
•
Trial cannot commence;
•
Continued incarceration becomes per se illegal.
Reliance has been placed in the matters of (Arun Pati Tripathi
Vs. ED SLP (Crl) No. 16219/2024; Anil Tuteja Vs. ED, SLP (Crl.) No.
3148/202; Manoj Soni Vs. State of Chhattisgarh, MCRC 2078/2025
“Custody cannot continue in perpetuity when thelaw itself prohibits
cognizance”.
V. The applicant indisputably satisfies the Triple Test for grant of
bail- No Subjective Discretion can Override Settled Law
12.
The bail is rule, jail is exception under out constitutional scheme
(State of Rajasthan Vs. Balchand (1977) 4 SCC 308;
Sushila
Aggarwal Vs. State (NCT of Delhi), (2020) 5 SCC 1; P. Chidambaram
Vs. Directorate of Enforcement (2020) 13 SCC 791 and Arnesh
Kumar Vs. State of Bihar (2014) 8 SCC 273). The Triple Test stands
conclusively satisfied on impeachable facts and unimagined by
prosecution:
•
The applicant is not a flight risk- He is a Raipur resident of
longstanding with deep familial, social and business roots and is a
retired IAS Officer with 34 years of unblemished public service.
There is no flight risk, all evidence documentary and secured. The
Apex Court itself granted hims regular bail in the ED liquor ECIR
(ECIR/RPZO/04/2024) on 15.04.2025, observing no flight risk
despite prosecution’s objections (Sushila Aggarwal Vs. State
(NCT Delhi) (2020) 5 SCC 440) para 10 “Roots in society
determinative”.
•
Witness tampering is a physical impossibility- Entire evidence is
documentary-charge sheets filed; 350+ witness statements
recorded under Section 180/183 BNSS; hundreds of documents
exhibited. No pending witness examination requires applicant's
presence. No allegation of threats to any witness across cases
(P.Chidambaram Vs. Directorate of Enforcement, (2020) 13
SCC 516) : “Documentary evidence eliminates tampering risk”).
ensure trial delay; no recoveries; case rests on uncorroborated
co-accused statements.
•
Evidence
Tampering-Physical
impossibility
-
All
seized
material (devices, documents, digital records) lies in safe
custody of learned trial court since charge sheet filing on
6.10.2025. Applicant never accessed premises post-arrest.
Robust conditions (reporting, sureties,GPS) can safeguard
(Directorate of Enforcement Vs. Abhishek Singh, 2024
SCC OnLine SC156.
•
Prosecution cannot approbate and reprobate : Supreme Court
granted bail post considering identical “antecedents” and
material. Triple test pre-supposes satisfaction (Arnesh Kumar
Vs. State of Bihar (2014) 8 SCC 273).
VI.
Prolonged Pre -Trial Punishment violates Article 21
13.
The applicant languishes in 134 days incarceration specifically
qua subject FIR. Charge sheet stands filed hundreds of documents
requiring formal proof; further investigation ongoing per prosecution
reply dated 21.08.2025. No charge-framing possible till final report.
In the first charge sheet filed on 01.02.2025, no cognizance was
taken even after more than ten months. The sanction is pending against
the applicant and cognizance barred. This Court in the matter of coaccused has noted that “Trial is unlikely to commence/conclude in near
future” (Manoj Soni, M.Cr.C. 2078/2025 and Roshan Chandrakar
MCRC 6581/2025).
Legal Position Crystal Clear:
Binding precedents leave no
manner of doubt- “Pre-trial detention cannot continue indefinitely- it
transforms
into
punishment
without
trial,
violating
Article
21”
(Hussainara Khatoon Vs. State of Bihar (1979) 1 SCC 81 para 5.
“where trial is likely to take years, continued
custody amounts to legal butchery.” (Supreme
Court Legal Aid Committee Vs. State of MP,
1994 Supp. (5) SCC 560 para 12.”
“Where trial is likely to take years, continued custody amounts to
legal butchery” (supreme Court Legal Aid Committee Vs. State of MP,
1994 Supp. (5) SCC 560 para 12.
14.
In yet another judgment Bikramjit Singh Vs. State of Punjahb
(2020) 19 SCC 273 para 15; and Ajay Kumar Ghose Vs. State of
Jharkhand (2022) 12 SCC 472.
15.
There is no recovery from the applicant despite raids and that the
co-accused have been enlarged on identical grounds. The impugned
order is perverse and ignores binding precedents; mechanically recites
prosecution reply sans analysis. Liberty paramount-Article 21 mandates
immediate release (Maneka Gandhi Vs. Union of India (1978) 1 SCC
248.
VII. Prosecution Case Collapses on Merits- No Prima Facie case
disclosed :
16.
The prosecution's case against the applicant is bereft of any
credible evidence, hinging entirely on the uncorroborated testimony of
the co-accused, which renders it wholly unsustainable for purposes of
denying bail. In the absence of any recovery of unaccounted cash
assets or other incriminating material, the allegations fail to establish
even a prima facie case. The purported evidence, comprising affidavits
exposed as "cut-copy-paste" fabrications and unreliable statements from
Roshan Chand, lacks the requisite corroboration mandated under
Sections 133 and 114(b) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, rendering it
inadmissible and unworthy of judicial reliance.
Absence of Corroboration
17.
The testimony of an accomplice, such as the co-accused herein,
is admissible under Section 133 of the Evidence Act but stands
presumptively unworthy of credit unless corroborated in material
particulars by independent evidence connecting the accused to the
crime, as per Illustration (b) to Section 114. The Supreme Court has
consistently held it unsafe to convict solely on such uncorroborated
evidence, emphasizing the need for cautious scrutiny given the
accomplice's potential motive to falsely implicate others for personal
gain or leniency. In the instant matter, the affidavits tendered by 47 rice
millers, dismissed as inadmissible "cut-copy-paste text" fabrications, and
the uncorroborated complaint of Roshan Chandrakar—a "no miller"—fail
to meet this threshold, leaving the prosecution's edifice crumbling
without substantive support.
No Recovery of Assets
18.
No recovery of unaccounted cash assets has been effected from
the applicant despite exhaustive searches, nor has any tangible
evidence of misappropriation surfaced to substantiate the charges. The
prosecution rests solely on the bald assertions of the co-accused,
which, absent physical recovery or independent corroboration, cannot
sustain restraint on the applicant's liberty. Such zero recovery scenarios
underscore the infirmity of the case, aligning with judicial precedents
where absence of material evidence militates against pre-trial
incarceration.
No Attributable Role
19.
The applicant neither posted in the Food Department nor held any
association with MARKFED rice millers, disentitling the invocation of
enhanced charges premised on a Cabinet decision embodying a
collective policy that precludes individual culpability. Absent direct or
attributable role in the alleged irregularities, the charges enhanced via
governmental policy cannot be fastened upon the applicant, who stands
exculpated from operational involvement. This lack of nexus fortifies the
case for bail, as collective policy decisions do not impute vicarious
liability without proof of personal complicity.
Pick-and-Choose Investigation :
20.
The prosecution's case against the applicant is bereft of any
credible evidence, hinging entirely on the uncorroborated testimony of
the co-accused, which renders it wholly unsustainable for purposes of
denying bail. In the absence of any recovery of unaccounted cash
assets or other incriminating material, the allegations fail to establish
even a prima facie case. The purported evidence, comprising affidavits
exposed as "cut-copy-paste" fabrications and unreliable statements from
Roshan Chand, lacks the requisite corroboration mandated under
Sections 133 and 114(b) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, rendering it
inadmissible and unworthy of judicial reliance.
21.
Absence of Corroboration: The testimony of an accomplice,
such as the co-accused herein, is admissible under Section 133 of the
Evidence Act but stands presumptively unworthy of credit unless
corroborated in material particulars by independent evidence connecting
the accused to the crime, as per Illustration (b) to Section 114. The
Supreme Court has consistently held it unsafe to convict solely on such
uncorroborated evidence, emphasizing the need for cautious scrutiny
given the accomplice's potential motive to falsely implicate others for
personal gain or leniency. In the instant matter, the affidavits tendered
by 47 rice millers, dismissed as inadmissible. "cut-copy-paste text"
fabrications, and the uncorroborated complaint of Roshan Chand—a "no
miller"—fail to meet this threshold, leaving the prosecution's edifice
crumbling without substantive support.
22.
No Recovery of Assets: No recovery of unaccounted cash
assets has been effected from the applicant despite exhaustive
searches, nor has any tangible evidence of misappropriation surfaced to
substantiate the charges. The prosecution rests solely on the bald
assertions of the co-accused, which, absent physical recovery or
independent corroboration, cannot sustain restraint on the applicant's
liberty. Such zero recovery scenarios underscore the infirmity of the
case, aligning with judicial precedents where absence of material
evidence militates against pre-trial incarceration.
23.
No Attributable Role: The applicant neither posted in the Food
Department nor held any association with MARKFED rice millers,
disentitling the invocation of enhanced charges premised on a Cabinet
decision embodying a collective policy that precludes individual
culpability. Absent direct or attributable role in the alleged irregularities,
the charges enhanced via governmental policy cannot be fastened upon
the applicant, who stands exculpated from operational involvement. This
lack of nexus fortifies the case for bail, as collective policy decisions do
not impute vicarious liability without proof of personal complicity.
Reliance has been placed on
•
Haricharan Kurmi Vs.State of Bihar, AIR 1964 SC 1184
•
Kashmira Singh Vs. State of MP, AIR 1952 SC 159
•
Balveer Vs. State of Rajasthan, 2024 SCC OnLine SC1367
VIII. Post-Reply Introduction of material-impermissible
in Bail
Proceedings
24.
The respondent’s attempt to introduce new material through
additional written submissions is illegally impermissible. False affidavit
dated 25.09.2024 before the Apex Court fabricating Applicant’s role-no
material annexed. Pattern of harassment: Liquor arrests deprecated by
SC; UP arrest quashed by Allahabad High Court.
IX. Response to Anticipated Prosecution Objections:
25.
Chats/Interrogation : Pre-scam (2020); irrelevant (co-accused
statement inadmissible) as has been held in Tarun Kumar Vs. ED,
2023 INSC 1006-PMLA, Section 45 rigor absent; petitioner was later
granted bail by the Delhi High Court. Antecedents; the Supreme Court
has granted bail post consideration as the applicant has been unnamed
throughout in the ED/IT cases. Bail adjudication must confine itself to
material placed at the relevant stage. Reliance is placed in the matter of
Hansabhai Vakilbhai Qureshi Vs. State of Gujarat (2004) 5 SCC 347
and State of Maharashtra Vs.Suresh (1997) 11 SCC 378.
26.
The impugned order dated 22.08.2025 is perverse, suffering from
non-application of mind-ignores binding precedents on parity, illegal
arrest, sanction and triple test. No purpose served by continued
incarceration of a retired public servant.
Through these additional submissions, respondent/EOW/ACB has
desperately attempted to introduce statements recorded under Section
161 BNSS of certain rice millers and Section 164 BNSS statements of
Ankur Paliwal and Suraj Pawar dated 29.11.2024. These material are
inadmissible, fabricated and legally infirm, warranting their outright
exclusion from bail adjudication.
27.
Statements under Section 161 BNSS of Rice Millers-tutored,
inadmissible and Post-Hoc Fabrication: The statements under the said
Section are wholly inadmissible in evidence and cannot constitute the
basis for denying bail. Such statements are meant exclusively for
contradistinction at trial and carry no evidentiary value at the
interlocutory stage.
28.
These statements of 47 rice millers are evidently tutored and
coerced, as demonstrated by the identical “cut-copy-paste” final
paragraphs across all statements-a glaring hallmark of fabrication.
These statements were suddenly recorded post facto only after this
Court’s categorical observation in MCRC No. 6581 of 2025 (Roshan
Chandrakar Vs. State) decided on 18.07.2025 wherein it was noted:
“No rice miller or any related person has filed any complaint before
EOW that
the applicant has extorted money”. The agencies
manufacturing
evidence
post
judicial
reprimand
merits
severe
deprecation (Roshan Chandrakar Vs. State of CG, MCRC NO. 6581
of 2025).
29.
Statements of co-accused/accomplices Ankur Paliwal and Suraj
Pawar under Section 164 BNSS cannot form the sole basis for
prosecution as it is legally incompetent and Quit Pro Quo fabrication.
They are only admissible for corroborative purposes after independent
corroboration as has been held in Haricharan Kurmi Vs.State of
Bihar, 1964 SCC OnLine SC 28; Somasundaram Vs, State (2020) 7
SCC 722; Kashmira Singh Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1952
SC 159).
30.
He submits that neither Ankur Paliwal nor Suraj Pawar names the
applicant anywhere in their statements dated 29.11.2024 nor do they
claim the alleged money was intended for the applicant. These
statements are pure hearsay, lacking any direct linkage to the applicant
and thus devoid of probative value at bail stage (Balveer Vs. State of
Rajasthan, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1367). Next submission of the
learned Senior counsel for the applicant is that the pick and choose
policy has been exposed- Despite admitting involvement in the alleged
offences, neither Ankur Paliwal nor Suraj Pawar has been arrested or
subjected to any coercive actin. This selective non-prosecution screams
quid pro quo for falsely implicating the applicant-modus operandi
already judicially noted by this Court in Manoj soni Vs. State and
Roshan Chandrakar Vs. State.
31.
The aforesaid allegations are wholly misconceived, factually
incorrect, and bereft of any legal or evidentiary foundation. At the outset,
it is categorically denied that the Applicant ever convened, participated
in, or influenced any meeting at Udyog Bhavan, Raipur, or elsewhere,
for the purpose alleged by the prosecution. The assertion that the
Applicant instructed the Food Secretary to seek enhancement of the
Central Rice Quota is entirely imaginary and unsupported by record.
It is significant to note that no document, correspondence, file noting,
cabinet memorandum, or approval order has been placed on record by
the prosecution to substantiate:
•
the existence of any such instruction by the Applicant,
•
the date or manner in which the alleged proposal was initiated,
•
the authority under which such proposal was approved, or
•
the identity of any officer who allegedly acted at the behest of the
Applicant.
32.
On the contrary, as per the complaints and charge-sheets filed by
the Income Tax Department, the Enforcement Directorate, and the
Respondent Agency itself, the increase in milling charges and incentives
was publicly announced by the then Chief Minister, and that too in the
context of an Abhinandan Samaroh organized by the Rice Millers.
Nowhere in any of these statutory proceedings is the Applicant
attributed with any role, direct or indirect, in either the decision-making
process or its implementation.
33.
Notably, the prosecution’s own records are conspicuously silent
regarding:
•
any participation of the Applicant in cabinet deliberations,
•
any influence over policy formulation,
•
any benefit derived by the Applicant from the alleged increase in
milling charges, or
•
any linkage between the Applicant and the administrative process
governing Central quota allocation.
The decision relating to Central rice allocation is taken at the level
of the Government of India, involving multiple layers of scrutiny by
senior officers of the Central Government. The allegation, if accepted
even hypothetically, would lead to the absurd and untenable inference
that senior IAS officers of the Central Government acted under the
influence of the Applicant—an inference which is not only unsupported
by material but is patently untenable in law.
34.
It is further relevant to emphasize that no allegation whatsoever
has been levelled against the Food Secretary or any Central
Government official, nor has the prosecution explained why, if such a
proposal was allegedly illegal, no action has been initiated against the
approving authorities. This selective attribution clearly exposes the
targeted and baseless nature of the accusation.
35.
In sum, the allegation is a post-facto narrative, constructed
without corroboration, contradicted by the prosecution’s own documents,
and founded on conjecture rather than evidence. The Applicant has
been falsely sought to be implicated in a policy decision taken at the
highest executive level, without any material to demonstrate mens rea,
participation, or benefit. The allegation, therefore, does not withstand
judicial scrutiny and deserves to be rejected at the threshold.
36.
Learned counsel for the applicant therefore submits that the
respondent/EOW cannot impose case post filing reply as they are
tutored statements and non prosecution of alleged accomplices and
illegal recording collectively demolish prosecution narrative. The
impugned order dated 22.08.2025 suffers from non-application of mind,
ignores binding precedents and perpetuates illegal custody. Lastly, it is
submitted that the investigation is complete qua applicant, the coaccused are granted bail, the applicant has satisfied the triple test and
the delay in trial is inevitable. Continued custody is punitive and violation
of Article 21 of the Constitution as it serves no investigational or societal
purpose and therefore, the instant application may be allowed and
enlarge the applicant on regular bail in FIR No. 01/2024 (Trial No.
01/2025) on terms as this Court deems fit.
SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE STATE
37.
Learned counsel for the State submits that following arguments
opposing the bail application:
The applicant has preferred the present bail application under
Section 483 of the BNSS, 2023 seeking enlargement on bail in
connection with Crime No. 01/2024 registered at police station
ACB/EOW,Raipur
for commission of offences punishable under
Sections 384, 409.120-B of the IPC and Sections 11 , 13(1)(a) and 13(2)
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
38.
Learned State counsel opposes bail for the reasons stated below:
(a) the allegations disclose grave and organized criminality involving
public servants and systematically-collected extortion/diversion of funds;
(b) there is voluminous incriminating material-documentary, digital and
cash-seized during lawful searches;(c) the offences charges are
scheduled predicate offences for the PMLA and therefore engage
money-laundering investigation and seizure regimes; and (d) recent
jurisprudence and the statutory regime require close scrutiny of bail
where the nature of the offence and the stage of investigation indicate a
real risk to the integrity of the investigation and to public interest.
39. STATUTORY FRAMEWORK- BNSS, PMLA, PREVENTION OF
CORRUPTION ACT : Section 483 BNSS preserves the Court’s special
power to order bail in appropriate cases and frames the high court’s
jurisdiction to pass protective and conditional orders in furtherance of
liberty. The applicant proceeds under that provision.
The present crime is not a standalone or isolated incident. The
investigation has its origin in information and material shared by the
Enforcement Directorate and the Income Tax Department (Investigation)
which had unearthed large scale irregularities during investigation into
the Custom Rice Milling Operations in the State of Chhattisgarh.
40.
A prosecution complaint dated 21.08.2023 was filed by the
Income Tax Department before the Court of the learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Raipur. During investigation under the Prevention of Money
Laundering Act, 2002, the Enforcement Directorate discovered multiple
predicate offences falling within the jurisdiction of the ACB/EOW
Chhattisgarh.
41.
Pursuant thereto, information was forwarded to the State
authorities, leading to registration of the present FIR. The registration of
the FIR is strictly in accordance with law and the mandate laid down by
the Apex Court in Lalita Kumari Vs. State of UP (2014) 2 SCC 1, which
makes registration of FIR mandatory where cognizable offences are
disclosed.
42.
The Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 as amended criminalizes”
criminal
misconduct”
by
public
servants
and
provides
penal
consequences for misuse of office (Section 13). The offences
originally invoked against the applicant and co-accused fall
squarely within the scope of that Act and of the scheduled
offences concept for PMLA consequences.
43.
The investigation conducted os far has revealed a well
orchestrated conspiracy involving office bearers of the Chhattisgarh
State Rice Millers Association, officials of MARKFED and district level
officers. The modus operandi
as disclosed from seized documents,
digital devices and recorded statements, was that rice millers were
compelled to apply illegal gratification at fixed rates per quintal of paddy
milled for clearance of their legitimate bills. Searches conduced by the
Income Tax Department and Enforcement Directorate resulted in :
•
Seizure of incriminating documents and loose sheets containing
coded entries;
•
Recovery of digital evidence from mobile phones and other
devices.
•
Seizure of unaccounted cash amounting to approximately 1.06
crores;
•
Recording of statements under statutory provisions which
corroborate the prosecution case.
Statements of key persons, including public servants, clearly
indicate that the payment of illegal gratification was a precondition for
bill clearance and that the conspiracy operated in a systematic and
organized manner.
44.
The material collected during investigation prima facie discloses
the involvement of the applicant in the larger conspiracy. The role
attributed to the applicant is not peripheral or incident, but forms part of
the decision making and facilitation
mechanism through which
illegal collections were made.
45.
It is submitted that the at this stage, the Court is not required to
conduct a mini trial. It is sufficient that the prosecution has placed
credible material showing the applicant’s nexus with the alleged
offences.
46.
The Economic offences involving corruption by public servants
stand on a distinct footing. Such offences are committed with
deliberation, affect public institutions and have serious ramifications on
governance and public confidence. The Apex court has consistently held
that economic offences and corruption cases require a cautious
approach while considering bail, particularly when the investigation is
ongoing and involves complex financial trails and multiple accused. The
present case concerns:
Abuse of public office;
Criminal breach of trust in respect of public funds;
Systematic
extortion
affecting
statutory
procurement
and
distribution systems.
The magnitude and nature of the allegations clearly militate
against grant of bail at this stage.
47.
Next submission is that the investigation is at a crucial stage.
Analysis of seized digital data, examination of money trails and further
recording of statements are still in progress. There exists a reals and
reasonable apprehension that if released on bail at this stage, the
applicant may influence or intimate witnesses many of whom are public
servants or associated with statutory bodies; interfere with or tamper
with
documentary
and
digital
evidence;
hamper
the
ongoing
investigation which involves multiple agencies and accused.
48.
The apprehension of the prosecution is not speculative but is
based on the nature of the offence; the position held by the accused and
the manner in which the conspiracy was allegedly executed.
While personal liberty is undoubtedly a valuable constitutional
right, it is
equally well settled that liberty of an individual must be
balanced against the interest of society and the need for a fair and
effective investigation. In cases involving corruption and economic
offences of this nature, premature grant of bail is likely to undermine
public confidence in the administration of justice.
49.
At the outset, it is respectfully submitted that the present bail
application is wholly misconceived devoid of merits and deserves
outright rejection in view of the gravity of allegations, the depth of
conspiracy involved, the magnitude of public money siphoned and the
dominant role played by the applicant/accused Anil Tuteja in
orchestrating a systematic extortion and corruption racket under the
garb of policy decisions.
50.
Investigations conducted by the Directorate of Enforcement under
the Prevention of Money Laundering Act 2002 has revealed that an
amount of approximately 140 Crores was illegally collected from rice
millers across State of Chhattisgarh under the guise of “special
incentive” for custom milling.
51.
It has surfaced during investigation that the special incentive
payable to ricemillers for custom milling of paddy was artificially
enhanced to Rs. 120 per quintal, pursuant to a concerted criminal
conspiracy between the then political dispensation, senior bureaucrats
and office bearers of the Chhattisgarh State Rice Millers Association
with the ulterior motive of recovering kickbacks of Rs. 40 per quintal
from the ricemillers.
52.
Investigation further discloses that Roshan Chandrakar, Treasurer
of the State Rice Millers Association was entrusted with the
responsibility of collecting these illegal kickbacks from rice millers
throughout the State and channelizing the same for the benefit of
political and bureaucratic patrons. The said illegal collection was carried
out with active connivance of co-accused Manoj Soni the then Managing
Director, MARKFED, Who was the competent authority for clearance of
milling bills. He issued instructions to District Marketing Officers to
forward only those bills which were “cleared” by the District Rice Millers
Associations, thereby institutionalizing extortion. District Marketing
Officers also played an active role by facilitating the clearance of bills
only of those millers who paid the demanded kickbacks, thus becoming
complicit in the offence. These acts, prima facie, constitute offences
punishable under Sections 120-B, 384,417,418 and 420 IPC, 1860
besides offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act. On the basis of
disclosures made by the Directorate of Enforcement, an FIR was duly
registered by EOW/ACB and investigation commenced in accordance
with law.
53.
It is next submitted that from the material collected during
investigation, it has clearly emerged that the present applicant, a highly
influential bureaucrat during the then regime of the government, was not
a peripheral actor, but the principal architect and controller of the custom
milling illegal collection mechanism.
54.
Digital evidence, including Whatsapp chats and documents seized
by the Income Tax Department conclusively demonstrates that no
significant administrative or policy decision across departments was
implemented without the applicant’s approval. His influence extended to
allocation of contracts, implementation of schemes, posting of officials
and protection of illegal operations.
55.
It has been further revealed that the applicant in criminal
conspiracy with Roshan Chandrakar, engineered the enhancement of
special incentive from Rs. 40 per quintal to Rs. 120 per quintal with the
malicious intent of illegality recovering Rs. 20 per quintal per installment
from ricemillers. The applicant, acting through Anwar Dhebar and
Roshan Chandrakar received approximately Rs. 20-22 crores as illegal
gratification from rice millers. Anwar Dhebar functioned as a conduct
and shield for the applicant, providing political and administrative cover
for the illegal collections. Without the patronage and backing of the
applicant, Roshan Chandrakar would have been incapable of exerting
pressure on rice millers or influencing officials of MARKFED and the
Food Department.
56.
It is further revealed that Roshan Chandrakar did not originally
hold any key position in the State Ricemillers Association. The Applicant,
by exerting pressure, ensured the removal of the then Treasurer
Naresh Somani and facilitated the appointment of Roshan
Chandrakar as Treasurer, solely to deploy him as an instrument of
extortion across the State. The applicant deliberately chose Roshan
Chandrakar due to his in depth knowledge of the custom milling
business
and
vulnerabilities
of
ricemillers,
enabling
systematic
exploitation through threats of departmental action and financial
coercion. Thus, the increase in special incentive was not a bona fide
policy decision but a calculated device to create a parallel illegal fund.
The applicant stood at the apex of the conspiracy, while Anwar
Dhebar
and
Roshan
Chandrakar
operated
as
trusted
intermediaries.
57.
Digital evidence further established sustained and contiguous
communication between the applicant and Roshan Chandrakar since at
least 2020 times, on matters relating to paddy procurement, custom
milling and government schemes clearly rebutting any claim of a casual
or incidental association. Though these chats may not directly pertain to
the precise transaction in the present FIR, they are highly relevant to
demonstrate the nature of relationship, control and trust thereby
strengthening the prosecution case of conspiracy. To substantiate the
facts, the statements of the witnesses recorded under Section 161
Cr.P.C have been filed and the applicant has been arrested strictly in
accordance with law and is presently in judicial custody. Upon
completion of investigation charge sheet has already been filed and
investigation against the remaining accused is ongoing. From the FIR
and material available in the case diary, a strong prima facie case under
the Prevention of Corruption Act is clearly made out. The offence is an
economic offence of grave nature, involving deep rooted conspiracy and
large scale loss to public exchequer. The Apex Court in the matter of P.
Chidambaram Vs. Directorate of Enforcement (2019) 9 SCC 24, has
held that economic offences committed with deliberate design require a
strict approach in bail matters.
58.
Reliance is further placed on State of Gujarat Vs. Mohanlal
Jtamalji Powal (1987) 2 SCC 364, Y.S.Jagan Mohan Reddy Vs. CBI
(2013) 7 SCC 439; Tamesh Bhavan Rathod Vs. Vishanbhai Hirabhai
Makwana (2021) 6 SCC 230 and Tarun Kumar Vs. Assistant
Director, Directorate of Enforcement, wherein it has been consistently
held that economic offences constitute a class apart and prose a serious
threat to the financial health of the State. In the matter of Tarun Kumar
(supra), it has been held as under:
18. The submission of learned Counsel Mr. Luthra
to grant bail to the appellant on the ground that the
other co-accused who were similarly situated as the
appellant, have been granted bail, also cannot be
accepted. It may be noted that parity is not the law.
While applying the principle of parity, the Court is
required to focus upon the role attached to the
accused whose application is under consideration.
XXXXX
XXXXX
XXXXX
22. Lastly, it may be noted that as held in catena of
decisions, the economic offences constitute a class
apart and need to be visited with a different
approach in the matter of bail. The economic
offences having deep-rooted conspiracies and
involving huge loss of public funds need to be
viewed seriously and considered as grave offences
affecting the economy of the country as a whole and
thereby posing serious threat to the financial health
of the country. Undoubtedly, economic offences
have serious repercussions on the development of
the country as a whole. To cite a few judgments in
this regard are Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy vs. Central
Bureau of Investigation (2013) 7 SCC 439,
Nimmagadda
Prasad
vs.
Central
Bureau
of
Investigation (2013) 7 SCC 466, Gautam Kundu vs.
Directorate of Enforcement (supra), State of Bihar
and Another vs. Amit Kumar alias Bachcha Rai
(2017) 13 SCC 751. This court taking a serious note
with regard to the economic offences had observed
as back as in 1987 in case of State of Gujarat vs.
Mohanlal Jitamalji Porwal and Another (1987) 2
SCC 364 as under:“5… The entire community is aggrieved if the
economic offenders who ruin the economy of the
State are not brought to books. A murder may be
committed in the heat of moment upon passions
being aroused. An economic offence is committed
with cool calculation and deliberate design with an
eye
on
personal
profit
regardless
of
the
consequence to the community. A disregard for the
interest of the community can be manifested only at
the cost of forfeiting the trust and faith of the
community in the system to administer justice in an
even-handed manner without fear of criticism from
the quarters which view white collar crimes with a
permissive eye unmindful of the damage done to
the National Economy and National Interest…”
59.
The plea of parity raised by the applicant is wholly untenable as
parity is not a rule of law and the Court is required to examine the
specific role of the accused seeking bail. The applicant herein stands on
a distinctly higher footing as the mastermind and controller of the
conspiracy.
60.
He therefore submits that in view of the aforesaid facts, evidence,
seriousness of allegations, the influential postilion of the applicant,
likelihood of tampering with evidence and ongoing investigation, it is
respectfully submitted that the applicant has failed to make out any a
ground for grant of bail under Section 483 of the BNSS. The present
application is false, frivolous and an abuse of the process of law. Grant
of bail at this stage would seriously prejudice the investigation and
undermine public confidence in the administration of justice.
FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION:
61.
The Court has bestowed its anxious consideration to the rival
submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the parties at
considerable length. I have also carefully perused the FIR, the charge
sheet filed till date, the case diary, the statements of witnesses recorded
under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the digital
material collected during investigation and the documents placed on
record. I have also considered the rival submissions advanced and the
precedents cited by both the sides.
62.
According to the prosecution case, the so called Custom Milling
Scam had its genesis in a meeting purportedly held between the
applicant and one Roshan Chandrakar at Udyog Bhavan, Raipur
wherein the applicant acting in concert and criminal conspiracy with the
aforesaid individual is stated to have instructed the Food Secretary to
forward a proposal to the government of India seeking enhancement of
the Central Rice Quota for the Kharif Marketing Year 2012-22. The
allegation further proceeds on the premise that such proposal was
allegedly made in anticipation of an unusually high procurement of
approximately 10.4 million metric tonnes of paddy and that
enhancement of the Central quota was engineered to facilitate the illegal
gains under the guise of custom milling operations. The prosecution
seeks to attribute a central and controlling role to the applicant in the
alleged conspiracy without delineating the precise manner, authority or
process through which such influence was allegedly exercised.
63.
The prosecution has sought to rely upon statements recorded
under Section 161 CrPC of certain rice millers, as well as statements
under Section 164 CrPC of Ankur Paliwal and Suraj Pawar, to oppose
the prayer for bail.
64.
In the present case, the material placed before this Court prima
facie indicates that the statements of the rice millers are stereotyped
and mechanically recorded. The Applicant has placed on record a
comparative chart demonstrating that the concluding portions of as
many as 47 statements of witness numbers 46, 40, 44, 45, 131, 130,
132, 118, 114, 113, 112, 111,110,109,108,106,105,115,126,128,129,160,
165,163,159,162, 54, 63, 96, 154,122,121,120,119,123, 201 and 203
namely, Sohan Lal Sahu, Shyam Sundar Agarwal, Saurabh Chandrakar,
Vinay Kumar Agrawal, Amit Kumar Goyal, Aakash Panjwani, Arun
Agarwal, Abhishek Agarwal, Deepak Kumar Jain, Dinesh Agarwal,
Hotaram Chaudhary, Indar mittal, Kishan Agarwal, ManishAgarwal,
Naresh Kumar Jain, Sanjay Agarwal, Sumit Agarwal, Aayush Agarwal,
Deepak Kumar Agarwal, Shiv Kumar Agarwal, Yogesh Kumar Agarwal,
Manish Kumar Agarwal, Vikas Kumar Agarwal, Prakhar Agarwal,
Hemant Kumar Patel, Pawan Goyal, Dongermal Jain, Ganesh Rangatta,
Lavlesh Chandravanshi, Vivek Singh Tomar, Dilip Agarwal, Danesh
Memon, Chandrashekhar Agarwal, Chandan Agarwal, Manoj Agarwal,
Mandeep Singh Arora and Vijay Goyal respectively are verbatim
reproductions of each other. It has been reproduced as under:
“jks’ku panzkdj dks iz’kklfud ,oa jktuhfrd laj{k.k
Fkk] ftl otg ls og voS/k olwyh dj ik jgk FkkA
bu izHkko dh otg ls og ekdZQsM] [kk| foHkkx ,oa
I;kZoj.k foHkkx ds vf/kdkfj;ksa dks izHkkfor dj jgk
FkkA tks vf/kdkjh deZpkjkh mldk fojks/k djrs Fks
mldk og VªkaLQj djk nsrk FkkA ;g leLr dk;Zokgh
og ljdkj ds laj{k.k esa dj jgk FkkA mls ljdkj ds
izHkko’kkyh O;fDr;ksa vfuy VqVstk ,oa jkexksiky
vxzoky dk izR;{k laj{k.k izkIr FkkA”
This, coupled with the fact that these statements are verbatim
reproductions of each other. This, coupled with the fact that these
statements were recorded only after the observations made by this
Court in its order dated 18.07.2025 granting bail to co-accused Roshan
Chandrakar in MCRC No. 2836 of 2025—wherein it was noted that no
rice miller had lodged any complaint of extortion.
65.
As regards the statements recorded under Section 164 CrPC of
Ankur Paliwal and Suraj Pawar, the legal position is no longer res
integra that the statement of a co-accused or accomplice cannot be the
sole basis for implicating another accused and can be relied upon only
for corroboration. This principle has been authoritatively laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Haricharan Kurmi v. State of Bihar, 1964
SCC OnLine SC 28 and reiterated in Somasundaram v. State, (2020) 7
SCC 722. A perusal of the said statements reveals that neither Ankur
Paliwal nor SurajPawar, the legal position is no longer res integra that
the statement of a co-accused or accomplice cannot be the sole basis
for implicating another accused and can be relied upon only for
corroboration. This principle has been authoritatively laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Haricharan Kurmi v. State of Bihar, 1964 SCC
OnLine SC 28 and reiterated in Somasundaram v. State, (2020) 7 SCC
722. A perusal of the said statements reveals that neither Ankur Paliwal
nor Suraj Pawar has named the present Applicant nor has any
allegation been made that the alleged money was intended for or
received by him.
66.
On the contrary, as per their own statements, both the said
persons appear to be directly involved in the alleged transactions. Yet,
neither has been arrested nor subjected to any coercive action, which
lends weight to the Applicant’s contention that the investigation has
proceeded in a selective manner. Such a pick-and-choose approach has
already been taken note of by this Court in MCRC No. 2078 of 2025
and MCRC No. 2836 of 2025.
67.
Further, in law, the statement of an accused person cannot be
recorded under Section 164 CrPC unless such person has been
tendered pardon and made an approver, which admittedly has not been
done in the present case.
68.
It is also not in dispute that after filing of the main charge-sheet,
the prosecution proceeded to collect further material and to file a
supplementary charge-sheet without obtaining prior leave of the
competent Court as mandated under Section 173(8) CrPC. The material
so collected cannot, at this stage, be permitted to prejudice the liberty of
the Applicant.
69.
Additionally, though a supplementary charge-sheet has been filed
against the present Applicant, no valid prosecution sanction has been
obtained till date. In the absence of such sanction, the learned Special
Court is legally barred from taking cognizance, with the inevitable
consequence that the commencement of trial stands indefinitely
deferred.
70.
The Applicant also stands on parity with co-accused Manoj Soni
and RoshanChandrakar, who have already been enlarged on bail. The
role attributed to the Applicant is not distinguishable in any material
respect, and denial of bail in such circumstances would offend the
principle of parity and equal treatment. Having regard to the nature of
the evidence, the settled legal position governing Sections 161 and 164
CrPC, the lack of sanction, the likelihood of a protracted trial, and the
principle of parity, this Court is of the considered view that further
incarceration of the Applicant is not warranted.
71.
The settled position of law is that while considering bail, the Court
must assess whether there exists a prima facie case, the nature and
gravity of accusation, the role attributed to the accused, the
possibility of the accused absconding, tampering with evidence or
influencing witnesses and the larger interests of justice. The
presumption of innocence continues to operate until
guilt is proved
beyond reasonable doubt in a full fledged trial. In the present case,upon
careful scrutiny of the material placed on record, it emerges that the
prosecution case against the applicant rests largely on documentary
material, digital evidence and statements of witnesses, all of which
are already in custody of the investigating agency. The applicant is
no longer in a position to influence the collection of such evidence. The
apprehension expressed by the State regarding tampering with
evidence or influencing witnesses remains general in nature and is not
supported by any specific material showing an attempt on the part of the
applicant after his arrest.
72.
It is also relevant to note that the applicant has been in judicial
custody for a considerable period. Investigation, in so far as the
applicant is concerned, the charge sheet has already been filed.
Continued incarceration of the applicant at this stage would therefore
partake the character of pre-trial punishment which is impermissible in
law,.
73.
The argument advanced by learned State counsel that economic
offences constitute a class apart and require a strict approach is well
founded as a principle of law,. However, the Apex court has consistently
held that seriousness of the offence alone cannot be the sole
ground for denial of bail, particularly where investigation is
substantially complete and the presence of the accused at trial can be
secured by imposing appropriate conditions.
74.
The reliance placed by the State on judgments such as P.
Chidambaram Vs. Directorate of Enforcement, Y.S.Jaganmohan
Reddy Vs. CBI and other precedents does not lay down an absolute
bar on grant of bail in economic offences. On the contrary, the said
judgments reiterate that each case must be decided on its own facts,
balancing the gravity of offence with the fundamental right to personal
liberty guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
75.
At the outset, it is well settled that policy decisions taken by the
Government, particularly those involving economic or administrative
matters, do not ipso facto attract criminal liability unless a clear, specific
and overt act demonstrating mens rea and criminal conspiracy is
established by cogent material. The Apex Court has consistently held
that courts must exercise great circumspection before criminalizing
policy decisions, lest the criminal process itself becomes an instrument
of harassment. In State of Maharashtra v. Som Nath Thapa, (1996 (4)
SCC 659) the Apex Court has authoritatively held that for an offence of
criminal conspiracy, there must exist prima facie material showing a
meeting of minds to commit an illegal act, and that mere suspicion,
conjecture, or inference cannot substitute proof even at the threshold
stage. It has been observed as follows:
“Let us note the meaning of the word
‘presume’. In Black’s Law Dictionary it has
been defined to mean “to believe or accept
upon probable evidence”. (emphasis ours). In
Shorter Oxford English Dictionary it has been
mentioned that in law ‘presume’ means “to take
as proved until evidence to the contrary is
forthcoming”. Stroud’s Legal dictionary has
quoted in this context a certain judgment
according to which “A presumption is a
probable consequence drawn from facts (either
certain, or proved by direct testimony) as to the
truth of a fact alleged”. (Emphasis supplied). In
Law Lexicon by P.Ramanath Aiyar the same
quotation finds place at p.1007 of 1987 Edn.
32. The aforesaid shows that if on the basis of
materials on record, a court could come to the
conclusion that commission of the offence is a
probable consequence; a case for framing of
charge exists. To put it differently, if the court
were to think that the accused might have
committed the offence it can frame the charge,
though for conviction the conclusion is required
to be that the accused has committed the
offence. It is apparent that at the stage of
framing of a charge, probative value of the
materials on record cannot be gone into; the
materials brought on record by the prosecution
has to be accepted as true at that stage.”
76.
Similarly, in CBI Vs. K. Narayana Rao (2012) 9 SCC512, the
Apex Court has cautioned that officers or persons cannot be prosecuted
merely because a decision taken by them, or in which they are alleged
to have been involved, later turns out to be questionable, unless there is
material to show abuse of position for personal gain. It was held as
under:“24. The ingredients of the offence of criminal
conspiracy are that there should be an
agreement between the persons who are
alleged to conspire and the said agreement
should be for doing of an illegal act or for
doing, by illegal means, an act which by itself
may not be illegal. In other words, the essence
of criminal conspiracy is an agreement to do
an illegal act and such an agreement can be
proved either by direct evidence or by
circumstantial evidence or by both and in a
matter of common experience that direct
evidence to prove conspiracy is rarely
available. Accordingly, the circumstances
proved before and after the occurrence have
to be considered to decide about the
complicity of the accused. Even if some acts
are proved to have been committed, it must be
clear that they were so committed in
pursuance of an agreement made between the
accused persons who were parties to the
alleged conspiracy. Inferences from such
proved circumstances regarding the guilt may
be drawn only when such circumstances are
incapable of any other reasonable explanation.
In other words, an offence of conspiracy
cannot be deemed to have been established
on mere suspicion and surmises or inference
which are not supported by cogent and
acceptable evidence.”
77.
Tested on the anvil of the aforesaid principles, this Court finds that
the core allegation against the Applicant—that he orchestrated or
influenced the enhancement of the Central Rice Quota or milling
charges—is entirely unsupported by contemporaneous documentary
material. No file noting, cabinet record, correspondence, approval order,
or statutory document has been produced to demonstrate that the
Applicant had any role, direct or indirect, in the policy-making process.
78.
Although a supplementary charge-sheet has been filed against
the present Applicant, no prosecution sanction, as required in law, has
been obtained till date. In the absence of a valid sanction, the learned
Special Court is legally precluded from taking cognizance of the alleged
offences. Consequently, the trial has not even commenced and is bound
to be protracted. Continued incarceration of the Applicant in such
circumstances would amount to punitive detention without trial, which is
impermissible in law and violative of the Applicant’s fundamental right to
personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution.
79.
This Court also finds substance in the submission that the
allocation of Central Rice Quota is a decision taken by the Government.
80.
The Apex Court in P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of
Enforcement (supra) has categorically held that bail cannot be denied
as a matter of punishment, and that in economic offences as well,
custody must be justified by compelling reasons such as flight risk,
tampering with evidence, or influencing witnesses. None of these
circumstances have been demonstrated in the present case.
81.
Further, in Sanjay Chandra v. CBI (supra), the Apex Court has
observed that pre-trial incarceration should not be resorted to merely
because allegations are grave, and that the object of bail is to secure
the presence of the accused at trial, not to inflict punishment before
conviction.
82.
It is also relevant to note that no recovery of unaccounted money,
movable or immovable assets has been effected from the Applicant,
despite searches conducted by multiple agencies.
83.
The Court must now assess whether continued incarceration of
the Applicant is necessary having regard to:
the nature of allegations,
the stage of investigation,
the nature of evidence,
the likelihood of the Applicant fleeing justice, and
the possibility of tampering with evidence or influencing witnesses.
The prosecution has not demonstrated that:
•
the Applicant is a flight risk;
•
the Applicant has attempted to interfere with the investigation;
any recovery remains to be effected from the Applicant; or
•
84.
custodial interrogation is presently required.
It is also significant that the trial in the present matter is likely to
take considerable time, having regard to the number of accused
persons, volume of documents and nature of evidence. Prolonged
incarceration, pending trial in such circumstances, would offend the
principles of fairness and reasonableness embedded in criminal
jurisprudence.
85.
The Apex Court has consistently held that gravity of offence alone
cannot be the basis for denial of bail. Courts are required to strike a
balance between the interest of the State in investigation and the
fundamental right of the accused to personal liberty. Prolonged pre-trial
incarceration, particularly in cases involving voluminous records and
multiple accused, offends the guarantee under Article 21 of the
Constitution, when the trial is unlikely to conclude within a reasonable
time. This Court is conscious that bail proceedings are not to be
converted into a mini trial. At the same time, mere allegations, however
serious, cannot justify indefinite custody in the absence of compelling
reasons.
86.
Having regard to the nature of the allegations, the stage of
investigation, the period of custody already undergone, the volume of
evidence involved, this Court is also conscious that the trial is likely to
take considerable time. The object of bail being to secure the presence
of the accused at trial and not to impose punishment prior to conviction
and in the absence of any specific material indicating a likelihood of
misuse of liberty, this Court is of the considered view that the ends of
justice can be adequately safeguarded by imposing stringent conditions
ensuring the applicant’s presence during trial and preventing any misuse
of liberty. The object of bail is to secure attendance of the accused at
trial and not to inflict punishment before conviction. Thus, balancing the
gravity of the allegations with the fundamental right to personal liberty,
the stage of investigation, the nature of evidence, the period of
custody already undergone and the absence of specific material
indicating likelihood of misuse of liberty, this Court is satisfied that the
applicant has made out a case for grant of bail.
87.
Accordingly, the bail application filed by the applicant under
Section 483 of the BNSS is allowed. The applicant shall be released
on bail upon his furnishing a personal bond in the sum of ₹1,00,000/(Rupees One Lakh only) along with two local sureties of the like amount,
to the satisfaction of the learned Trial Court, subject to the following
stringent conditions, so as to ensure the fair, smooth and expeditious
conduct of the trial:
1) The Applicant shall surrender his passport, if
any, before the learned Trial Court forthwith. In
case he does not possess a passport, an
affidavit to that effect shall be filed.
2) The Applicant shall cooperate fully with the
investigation and the trial proceedings, and shall
make himself available before the Court or the
Investigating Agency as and when required, in
accordance with law.
3. The Applicant shall not directly or indirectly
make any inducement, threat or promise to any
person acquainted with the facts of the case,
nor shall he attempt to influence any witness or
tamper with the evidence in any manner
whatsoever.
4) The Applicant shall not commit any offence of
a similar nature or otherwise during the period
he remains on bail.
5) In the event of any change in residential
address and/or mobile number, the Applicant
shall intimate the same to the learned Trial
Court by way of a sworn affidavit within a
reasonable time.
6) The Applicant shall comply with any other
condition that may be imposed by the learned
Trial Court in accordance with law.
88.
It is made abundantly clear that the observations made
hereinabove are confined strictly to the adjudication of the present bail
application. Nothing stated in this order shall be construed as an
expression of opinion on the merits of the case. The learned Trial Court
shall proceed with the matter independently and uninfluenced by any of
the observations contained in this order.
89.
Violation of any of the aforesaid conditions shall entail cancellation
of bail in accordance with law.
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
Judge
SUGUNA
DUBEY
Digitally signed
by SUGUNA
DUBEY
Date:
2026.01.13
19:14:19 +0530
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review