Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(CRIMINAL JURISIDICTION)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH: BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017
Anil Oberoi
Properitor M/s Anil Oberoi
M.G Marg, Gangtok,
East Sikkim
.… Petitioner
Versus
Sajan Kumar Agarwal
Propreitor M/s Anmol Enterprise,
Convey Ground,
Daragaon, Tadong,
East Sikkim
.... Respondent.
AND
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017
Subash Chaturvedi,
Proprietor M.s S. Chaturvedi,
A-2, Eden Apartment, Paresh Nagar,
P.O. Sevok Road, Siliguri,
West Bengal
.… Petitioner.
Versus
Sajan Kumar Agarwal
Propreitor M/s Anmol Enterprise,
Convey Ground,
Daragaon, Tadong,
East Sikkim
.... Respondent.
PETITIONS UNDER SECTION 482 OF THE CODE OF
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE, 1973.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. K.T Bhutia, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Bandana Pradhan, Ms.
Sarita Bhusal and Mr. Saurav Singh, Advocates for the
Petitioner.
Mr. Rahul Rathi and Ms. Phurba Diki Sherpa, Advocates for the
Respondent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
ORDER
(25.10.2017)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
This common order shall dispose of two petitions under Section
482, Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.P.C) preferred by two petitioners
against two orders, both dated 20.02.2017, rejecting two applications
under Section 311, Cr.P.C seeking prayers to recall and re-examine
the common Complainant, one Sajan Kumar Agarwal who had initiated
Private Complaint Case No. 06/2015 and Private Complaint Case No.
10/2015 against Anil Oberoi and Subash Chaturvedi, the petitioners
herein, respectively, as both the petitions raises identical issues.
2.
Briefly the relevant facts are:(i)
The petitioners in both the petitions under Section 482
Cr.P.C are facing trial for alleged commission of offence under
Section 138/142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. The
records would reveal that in Crl. Misc Case No. 02/2017 the
application
under
Section
Cr.P.C
was
preferred
on
16.11.2016 after the examination of the petitioner as accused
had been completed under Section 313 Cr.P.C in Private
Complaint Case No. 06/2015. In Criminal Misc Case No. 03/2017
the application under Section 311 Cr.P.C was filed by the
petitioner when some of the witnesses of the Complainant were
yet to be examined in Private Complaint Case No. 10/2015.
(ii)
The common grounds taken by both the petitioners in their
applications under Section 311, Cr.P.C were that the case was
conducted
by
one
learned
Counsel,
Mr.
Dinesh
Agarwal,
Advocate who due to serious illness retired from the case and in
his place the present counsel was engaged by the petitioners. It
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
was further contended that while preparing for the case it was
noticed that in cross-examination certain vital questions touching
the root of the matter had not been put to the Complainant. It
was also contended that the Complainant had not been
confronted with a vital document in possession of the petitioner.
The petitioners averred that it was the specific case of the
petitioners that the cheques in question was handed over as
security and vital questions on this aspect had not been put to
the complainant nor had the complainant been confronted with
documentary evidence on record. It was also averred that the
two Private Complaints have been filed on the same set of facts
and it was necessary to put common questions on some of the
documents relied on by the complainant.
(iii)
The said applications under Section 311 Cr.P.C was
contested
by
the
complainant.
Replies
with
preliminary
objections as well as on merits were filed praying for dismissal of
the said applications. It was contended, inter alia, that sufficient
time have been taken by the petitioners for cross-examination of
the complainant who was examined at length by the said learned
counsel, Mr. Dinesh Agarwal in the presence of the petitioners. It
was also contended that relevant documents pertaining to the
case was supplied well in advance and that the petitioner were
trying to mis-lead the Court on the plea of being laymen and
further cross-examine the complainant to fill up the lacunae in
the case which is not permissible. In Private Complaint Case No.
06/2015 it was further contended that the application under
Section 311 Cr.P.C had been filed at a belated stage, after more
than thirteen months after the closing of the witnesses of the
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
complainant and the examination of the accused under Section
313 Cr.P.C.
(iv)
On
20.02.2017
both
the
applications
filed
by
the
petitioners under Section 311 Cr.P.C in both the criminal
complaints were taken up for hearing by the learned Trial Court.
During the hearing a list of questions which the petitioner
proposed to put to the complainant was also furnished to the
learned Trial Court for its examination with a request, however,
not to disclose the same to the complainant to protect the
defence of the petitioners.
(v)
The learned Trial Court while examining the issues raised,
has found that the record of proceedings in both the Private
Complaints
reveals
that
an
adjournment
was
sought
on
09.11.2015 on the ground that learned Counsel, Mr. Dinesh
Agarwal, had suffered brain stroke. In Private Complaint case
No. 06/2015 it was contended that on 16.03.2016, 18.04.2016
and 04.07.2016 learned Counsel, Mr. Dinesh Agarwal, was
himself
present
in
the
Court
and
continued
the
further
proceedings and it was only on 01.09.2016 the new Counsels put
their appearances. The learned Trial Court also found that on
24.02.2016,
29.03.2016,
21.04.2016,
09.05.2016
and
04.07.2016 learned Counsel, Mr. Dinesh Agarwal, was himself
present and continued further proceedings and it was only on
02.09.2016 the new counsels had entered appearance in Private
Complaint Case No. 10/2015 .
It was thus concluded by the
Trial Court that on the day of cross-examination of the
complainant, the learned Counsel, Mr. Dinesh Agarwal, was not
suffering from illness and the plea of the petitioners about the
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
illness of the learned Counsel, Mr. Dinesh Agarwal, representing
the petitioners was discounted.
It was held that mere change of
Counsel cannot be a ground to allow the application under 311
Cr.P.C.
(vi)
The learned Trial Court examined the set of questions
placed by the petitioner’s counsels and came to the conclusion
that 16 questions out of the total 32 questions was such that the
answer would be a ‘yes’ to all of them. Out of the remaining
questions it was held by the Trial Court that answer to 8
questions were “undoubtedly already on record when one
carefully considers the cross-examination of the complainant
when he admits that there are no documents to show that he in
fact supplied the material, any further discussion of evidence
here more than this would lead to premature discussion of
evidence.” The rest of the questions were rejected on the ground
that they were not required for just decision of the case.
(vii)
The learned Trial Court thus held that the case was at the
stage of examination of defence witness in Private Complaint
case No. 06/2015
and at the stage of examination of
complainant witnesses in Private Complaint case No. 10/2015,
fair opportunity had been granted to the petitioners for crossexamination, cross-examination does not reveal that it was lame
and grant of further cross-examination would in fact be allowing
second extra opportunity to the petitioners which would be
unfair. Thus holding, the applications under Section 311 Cr.P.C
filed by the petitioners were rejected.
3.
At the hearing Mr. K.T Bhutia, learned Senior Advocate,
appearing for the petitioner would draw the attention of this Court to
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
Exhibit 3 (Agreement), Exhibit 4 (letter dated 01.08.2014), and Exhibit
5 (cheque no. 134104) in Private Complaint Case No. 06/2015 and
Exhibit 3 (Agreement), Exhibit 4 (letter dated 20.08.2014), and Exhibit
5 (cheque no. 238856) in Private Complaint Case No. 10/2015. Mr. K.T
Bhutia, would submit that in Exhibit 4 of both the Private Complaints
which are letters dated 01.04.2014 and 20.08.2014 alleged to have
been signed by the two petitioners he represents in the present
proceedings, the type set and the handwriting on the blank space for
dates are identical which would clearly reflects that the said letters
were in fact letters which were typed from one and the same
computer/printer and the handwriting was also of one and the same
person. Similarly, the cheques marked Exhibit 5 in both the cases for
different amounts payable to the same entity by the petitioners are
not only of the same date but in the same handwriting of one and the
same person. It is submitted by Mr. K.T Bhutia that certain vital
question pertaining to this was not put in cross-examination of the
Complainant which would go to the root of the matter during the
cross-examination of the Complainant by the learned Counsel Mr.
Dinesh Agarwal and as such, it would highly prejudice the defence if
the application under Section 311 Cr.P.C are not allowed. Mr. K.T
Bhutia would also argue that certain relevant questions pertaining to
Exhibit 3 in both Criminal Complaints i.e. Agreement dated 30.05.2014
between Anmol Enterpirses and Anil Oberoi (accused in Private
Complaint Case No 06/2015) and Agreement dated 30.05.2014
between Anmol Enterprises and M/s S. Chaturvedi & Co.
(S.
Chaturvedi being accused in Private Complaint Case No. 10/2015) to
show the falsity of the Private Complaints based on the terms of the
said Agreements were not put to the complaint by the said learned
counsel, Mr. Dinesh Agarwal, while cross-examining the Complainant.
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
Mr. K.T Bhutia would also produced a photocopy of a receipt
purportedly under the signature of the proprietor of Anmol Enterprises,
the Complainant in the present proceedings and submit that it was just
and necessary to confront the complainant with the said document and
if not permitted best evidence in this regard would be withheld from
the Court.
4.
Per Contra, Mr. Rahul Rathi, learned Counsel appearing for
the Complainant would argue that there are no compelling reasons for
setting aside the impugned orders dated 20.02.2017 as it does not
suffer from any infirmity. The learned Counsel would also submit that
the said applications under Section 311 Cr.P.C were filed after
considerable delay and that the said applications were for the sole
purpose of covering of the lapses, lacunae or negligence in the crossexamination which has already been completed. The learned Counsel
would also submit that the said applications would, if allowed,
encourage litigants to change counsels and filed applications under
Section 311 Cr.P.C to cover up the lacunae, which certainly is not the
object of the Section.
5.
The Complainant was cross-examined on 03.10.2015 in both
the cases. On 09.11.2015, on an application moved, the learned Trial
Court granted an adjournment on the ground that the conducting
Counsel, Mr. Dinesh Agarwal, is unable to appear and proceed with the
case due to brain stroke. This unfortunate event was just a month
after the cross-examination. It is also evident from record that after
the new Counsels put in their appearances, Mr. Dinesh Agarwal has
not conducted the case. In such circumstances, it was incumbent upon
the Trial Court to examine whether the prayer for recall of the
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
Complainant and further cross-examination of the Complainant was
essential for the just decision of the case.
6.
In re: Hoffman Andreas v. Inspector of Customs, Amritsar1,
was a case in which during trial three witnesses were examined by the
prosecution and cross-examined by the Counsel for the accused. After
the stage of cross-examination of the three witnesses the said counsel
passed away and the accused engaged another who filed a petition
under Section 311 Cr.P.C for recalling the three witnesses for the
purpose of further cross-examination. It was urged that the previous
counsel had died during the pendency of the trial and that it had now
transpired that the said counsel had not been keeping well and was
under some mental pressure and could not concentrate during the
proceeding and fail to cross-examine the prosecution witnesses on
material points. The Trial Court dismissed the said application holding
that there was nothing on record to show that the previous counsel
was under mental pressure or that he was not keeping well or he could
not concentrate during the proceedings of the case or that he failed to
cross-examine the prosecution witnesses effectively. Setting aside the
conviction of the accused by the Trial Court and confirmed by the High
Court, the Apex Court would hold:“ 6. Normally, at this late stage, we would be disinclined to open up a
closed trial once again. But we are persuaded to consider it in this case
on account of the unfortunate development that took place during trial
i.e. the passing away of the defence counsel midway of the trial. The
counsel who was engaged for defending the appellant had crossexamined the witnesses but he could not complete the trial because of
his death. When the new counsel took up the matter he would
certainly be under the disadvantage that he could not ascertain from
the erstwhile counsel as to the scheme of the defence strategy which
the predeceased advocate had in mind or as to why he had not put
further questions on certain aspects. In such circumstances, if the new
(2000) 10 SCC 430
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
counsel thought to have the material witnesses further examined the
Court could adopt latitude and a liberal view in the interest of justice,
particularly when the Court has unbridled powers in the matter as
enshrined in Section 311 of the Code. After all the trial is basically for
the prisoners and courts should afford the opportunity to them in the
fairest manner possible.”
In re: Zahira Habibullah Sheikh (5) v. State of Gujarat2,
7.
the Apex Court would hold:-
“26. In this context, reference may be made to Section 311 of the Criminal
Procedure Code which reads as follows:
“311. Power to summon material witness, or examine person
present.—Any court may, at any stage of any inquiry, trial or other
proceeding under this Code, summon any person as a witness, or
examine any person in attendance, though not summoned as a
witness, or recall and re-examine any person already examined; and
the court shall summon and examine or recall and re-examine any
such person if his evidence appears to it to be essential to the just
decision of the case.”
The section is manifestly in two parts. Whereas the word used in the first part
is “may”, the second part uses “shall”. In consequence, the first part gives
purely discretionary authority to a criminal court and enables it at any stage
of an enquiry, trial or proceeding under the Code (a) to summon anyone as a
witness, or (b) to examine any person present in the court, or (c) to recall
and re-examine any person whose evidence has already been recorded. On
the other hand, the second part is mandatory and compels the court to take
any of the aforementioned steps if the new evidence appears to it essential to
the just decision of the case. This is a supplementary provision enabling, and
in certain circumstances imposing on the court the duty of examining a
material witness who would not be otherwise brought before it. It is couched
in the widest possible terms and calls for no limitation, either with regard to
the stage at which the powers of the court should be exercised, or with regard
to the manner in which it should be exercised. It is not only the prerogative
but also the plain duty of a court to examine such of those witnesses as it
considers absolutely necessary for doing justice between the State and the
subject. There is a duty cast upon the court to arrive at the truth by all lawful
means and one of such means is the examination of witnesses of its own
accord when for certain obvious reasons either party is not prepared to call
witnesses who are known to be in a position to speak important relevant
facts.
27. The object underlying Section 311 of the Code is that there may not be
failure of justice on account of mistake of either party in bringing the valuable
evidence on record or leaving ambiguity in the statements of the witnesses
examined from either side. The determinative factor is whether it is essential
to the just decision of the case. The section is not limited only for the benefit
of the accused, and it will not be an improper exercise of the powers of the
court to summon a witness under the section merely because the evidence
(2006) 3 SCC 374
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
supports the case of the prosecution and not that of the accused. The section
is a general section which applies to all proceedings, enquiries and trials
under the Code and empowers the Magistrate to issue summons to any
witness at any stage of such proceedings, trial or enquiry. In Section 311 the
significant expression that occurs is “at any stage of any inquiry or trial or
other proceeding under this Code”. It is, however, to be borne in mind that
whereas the section confers a very wide power on the court on summoning
witnesses, the discretion conferred is to be exercised judiciously, as the wider
the power the greater is the necessity for application of judicial mind.
28. As indicated above, the section is wholly discretionary. The second part of
it imposes upon the Magistrate an obligation: it is, that the court shall
summon and examine all persons whose evidence appears to be essential to
the just decision of the case. It is a cardinal rule in the law of evidence that
the best available evidence should be brought before the court. Sections 60,
64 and 91 of the Evidence Act, 1872 (in short “the Evidence Act”) are based
on this rule. The court is not empowered under the provisions of the Code to
compel either the prosecution or the defence to examine any particular
witness or witnesses on their side. This must be left to the parties. But in
weighing the evidence, the court can take note of the fact that the best
available evidence has not been given, and can draw an adverse inference.
The court will often have to depend on intercepted allegations made by the
parties, or on inconclusive inference from facts elicited in the evidence. In
such cases, the court has to act under the second part of the section.
Sometimes the examination of witnesses as directed by the court may result
in what is thought to be “filling of loopholes”. That is purely a subsidiary
factor and cannot be taken into account. Whether the new evidence is
essential or not must of course depend on the facts of each case, and has to
be determined by the Presiding Judge.
29. The object of Section 311 is to bring on record evidence not only from the
point of view of the accused and the prosecution but also from the point of
view of the orderly society. If a witness called by the court gives evidence
against the complainant, he should be allowed an opportunity to crossexamine. The right to cross-examine a witness who is called by a court arises
not under the provisions of Section 311, but under the Evidence Act which
gives a party the right to cross-examine a witness who is not his own witness.
Since a witness summoned by the court could not be termed a witness of any
particular party, the court should give the right of cross-examination to the
complainant. These aspects were highlighted in Jamatraj Kewalji Govani v.
State of Maharashtra [(1967) 3 SCR 415 : AIR 1968 SC 178 : 1968 Cri LJ
231] .
30. Right from the inception of the judicial system it has been accepted that
discovery, vindication and establishment of truth are the main purposes
underlying the existence of the courts of justice. The operative principles for a
fair trial permeate the common law in both civil and criminal contexts.
Application of these principles involves a delicate judicial balancing of
competing interests in a criminal trial: the interests of the accused and the
public and to a great extent that of the victim have to be weighed not losing
sight of the public interest involved in the prosecution of persons who commit
offences.”
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
8.
The Apex Court in re: Rajaram Prasad Yadav v. State of Bihar3, would hold:“14. A conspicuous reading of Section 311 CrPC would show that widest of
the powers have been invested with the courts when it comes to the question
of summoning a witness or to recall or re-examine any witness already
examined. A reading of the provision shows that the expression “any” has
been used as a prefix to “court”, “inquiry”, “trial”, “other proceeding”, “person
as a witness”, “person in attendance though not summoned as a witness”,
and “person already examined”. By using the said expression “any” as a
prefix to the various expressions mentioned above, it is ultimately stated that
all that was required to be satisfied by the court was only in relation to such
evidence that appears to the court to be essential for the just decision of the
case. Section 138 of the Evidence Act, prescribed the order of examination of
a witness in the court. The order of re-examination is also prescribed calling
for such a witness so desired for such re-examination. Therefore, a reading of
Section 311 CrPC and Section 138 Evidence Act, insofar as it comes to the
question of a criminal trial, the order of re-examination at the desire of any
person under Section 138, will have to necessarily be in consonance with the
prescription contained in Section 311 CrPC. It is, therefore, imperative that
the invocation of Section 311 CrPC and its application in a particular case can
be ordered by the court, only by bearing in mind the object and purport of the
said provision, namely, for achieving a just decision of the case as noted by
us earlier. The power vested under the said provision is made available to any
court at any stage in any inquiry or trial or other proceeding initiated under
the Code for the purpose of summoning any person as a witness or for
examining any person in attendance, even though not summoned as witness
or to recall or re-examine any person already examined. Insofar as recalling
and re-examination of any person already examined is concerned, the court
must necessarily consider and ensure that such recall and re-examination of
any person, appears in the view of the court to be essential for the just
decision of the case. Therefore, the paramount requirement is just decision
and for that purpose the essentiality of a person to be recalled and reexamined has to be ascertained. To put it differently, while such a widest
power is invested with the court, it is needless to state that exercise of such
power should be made judicially and also with extreme care and caution.”
Then again:
“17. From a conspectus consideration of the above decisions, while dealing
with an application under Section 311 CrPC read along with Section 138 of the
Evidence Act, we feel the following principles will have to be borne in mind by
the courts:
17.1. Whether the court is right in thinking that the new evidence is needed
by it? Whether the evidence sought to be led in under Section 311 is noted by
the court for a just decision of a case?
17.2. The exercise of the widest discretionary power under Section 311 CrPC
should ensure that the judgment should not be rendered on inchoate,
inconclusive and speculative presentation of facts, as thereby the ends of
justice would be defeated.
17.3. If evidence of any witness appears to the court to be essential to the
just decision of the case, it is the power of the court to summon and examine
or recall and re-examine any such person.
(2013) 14 SCC 461
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
17.4. The exercise of power under Section 311 CrPC should be resorted to
only with the object of finding out the truth or obtaining proper proof for such
facts, which will lead to a just and correct decision of the case.
17.5. The exercise of the said power cannot be dubbed as filling in a lacuna in
a prosecution case, unless the facts and circumstances of the case make it
apparent that the exercise of power by the court would result in causing
serious prejudice to the accused, resulting in miscarriage of justice.
17.6. The wide discretionary power should be exercised judiciously and not
arbitrarily.
17.7. The court must satisfy itself that it was in every respect essential to
examine such a witness or to recall him for further examination in order to
arrive at a just decision of the case.
17.8. The object of Section 311 CrPC simultaneously imposes a duty on the
court to determine the truth and to render a just decision.
17.9. The court arrives at the conclusion that additional evidence is
necessary, not because it would be impossible to pronounce the judgment
without it, but because there would be a failure of justice without such
evidence being considered.
17.10. Exigency of the situation, fair play and good sense should be the
safeguard, while exercising the discretion. The court should bear in mind that
no party in a trial can be foreclosed from correcting errors and that if proper
evidence was not adduced or a relevant material was not brought on record
due to any inadvertence, the court should be magnanimous in permitting such
mistakes to be rectified.
17.11. The court should be conscious of the position that after all the trial is
basically for the prisoners and the court should afford an opportunity to them
in the fairest manner possible. In that parity of reasoning, it would be safe to
err in favour of the accused getting an opportunity rather than protecting the
prosecution against possible prejudice at the cost of the accused. The court
should bear in mind that improper or capricious exercise of such a
discretionary power, may lead to undesirable results.
17.12. The additional evidence must not be received as a disguise or to
change the nature of the case against any of the party.
17.13. The power must be exercised keeping in mind that the evidence that
is likely to be tendered, would be germane to the issue involved and also
ensure that an opportunity of rebuttal is given to the other party.
17.14. The power under Section 311 CrPC must therefore, be invoked by the
court only in order to meet the ends of justice for strong and valid reasons
and the same must be exercised with care, caution and circumspection. The
court should bear in mind that fair trial entails the interest of the accused, the
victim and the society and, therefore, the grant of fair and proper
opportunities to the persons concerned, must be ensured being a
constitutional goal, as well as a human right.”
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
In re: State (NCT of Delhi) v. Shiv Kumar Yadav4 while
9.
answering the question whether recall of witnesses, at the stage when
statement of accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C has been recorded,
could be allowed on the plea that the defence Counsel was not
competent and had not effectively cross-examined the witnesses, the
Apex Court would, after examining various judgments, hold:“27. It is difficult to approve the view taken by the High Court. Undoubtedly,
fair trial is the objective and it is the duty of the court to ensure such fairness.
Width of power under Section 311 CrPC is beyond any doubt. Not a single
specific reason has been assigned by the High Court as to how in the present
case recall of as many as 13 witnesses was necessary as directed in the
impugned order. No fault has been found with the reasoning of the order of
the trial court. The High Court rejected on merits the only two reasons
pressed before it that the trial was hurried and the counsel was not
competent. In the face of rejecting these grounds, without considering the
hardship to the witnesses, undue delay in the trial, and without any other
cogent reason, allowing recall merely on the observation that it is only the
accused who will suffer by the delay as he was in custody could, in the
circumstances, be hardly accepted as valid or serving the ends of justice. It is
not only matter of delay but also of harassment for the witnesses to be
recalled which could not be justified on the ground that the accused was in
custody and that he would only suffer by prolonging of the proceedings.
Certainly recall could be permitted if essential for the just decision but not on
such consideration as has been adopted in the present case. Mere observation
that recall was necessary “for ensuring fair trial” is not enough unless there
are tangible reasons to show how the fair trial suffered without recall. Recall
is not a matter of course and the discretion given to the court has to be
exercised judiciously to prevent failure of justice and not arbitrarily. While the
party is even permitted to correct its bona fide error and may be entitled to
further opportunity even when such opportunity may be sought without any
fault on the part of the opposite party, plea for recall for advancing justice has
to be bona fide and has to be balanced carefully with the other relevant
considerations including uncalled for hardship to the witnesses and uncalled
for delay in the trial. Having regard to these considerations, we do not find
any ground to justify the recall of witnesses already examined.”
10.
The search for truth is the solitary goal of any judicial trial.
The scope and ambit of Section 311 Cr.P.C is well defined by the law
itself and coherently articulated by judicial pronouncements of the Apex
(2016) 2 SCC 402
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
Court. The extracted paragraphs of the judgments of the Apex Court
need no reiteration. The underlying object of Section 311 Cr.P.C is to
ensure that the truth is out and there is no failure of justice on account
of any reason be it a mistake, error of judgment, inadvertence, failure
on the part of the client or lawyer, knowingly or unknowingly to ensure
that best evidence is made available to the Court. If the evidence
proposed to be adduced appears to the Court to be essential for the just
decision of the case, the Court must exercise its power under Section
311 Cr.P.C with the object of finding out the truth while giving latitude
and taking a liberal view in the interest of justice. The application under
Section 311 Cr.P.C cannot be allowed without adequate or sufficient
reason. Recall is not matter of course and the discretion given must be
exercised judiciously to prevent failure of justice. The plea in such cases
must necessarily be bonafide. It is only when the Court comes to the
conclusion that the intention for invoking the provisions of Section 311
Cr.P.C is to fill up the lacunae in the case, would the Court be
circumspect in exercising its discretionary power.
11.
The Trial Court while examining the applications under
Section 311 Cr.P.C filed by the petitioner has erred in failing to examine
whether the evidence sought to be adduced was essential for the just
decision of the case save some questions which were rejected by stating
so. The Trial Court has come to the conclusion that the answer to 16
out of 32 questions proposed by the petitioners would be ‘yes’ and out
of the remaining the answer to 8 questions were already on record.
However, the Trial Court has not rendered any finding as to whether
those questions were essential for the just decision of the case. Further,
if the answer to those 16 questions were likely to be ‘yes’ and if the
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
questions had a vital bearing to the issues involved, the answers would
definitely be crucial for the just decision of the case.
12.
It is seen that both the Private Complaint Cases are still
pending trial. In Private Complaint Case No. 06/2015 the petitioner had
been examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C and defence witnesses was
yet to be examined when the application under Section 311, Cr.P.C was
filed. In Private Complaint Case No. 10/2015 some of the Complainant
witnesses were yet to be examined when the application under Section
311 Cr.P.C was filed.
13.
On examination of the letter dated 01.08.2014 (Exhibit 4)
in Private Complaint Case No. 06/2015 and letter dated 20.08.2014
(Exhibit 4) in Private Complaint Case No. 10/2015, it is quite evident
that in the previous cross-examination no questions have been put to
the Complainant regarding the similarity in the handwriting of the dates
scribed therein or of the similarity in the type set of the two documents
exhibited by the Complainant. Similarly, on examination of the cheque
number 134104 (Exhibit 5) in Private Complaint Case No. 06/2015 and
cheque no. 238856 (Exhibit 5) in Private Complaint Case No. 10/2015 it
is also evident that in the previous cross-examination no questions have
been put
to
the
Complainant
regarding
the
similarity
in
the
handwriting. The answer to the similarity and commonality of the said
two letters, both exhibit 4, as well as the two cheques, both exhibit 5, in
the two Private Complaint cases and who was the scribe of the
handwriting in all the aforesaid documents exhibited by the Complainant
in the two cases filed against two different persons, the petitioners
herein would definitely assist the Court in search of the truth. The said
documents being exhibited by the Complainant in the Private Complaint
Cases, it is quite evident that the ambiguity regarding the same if left
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
unanswered, the only casualty would be the truth. The answers thereof
would therefore be essential for the just decision of the case.
This
Court has also perused the photocopy of the receipt dated 12.07.2014
produced by the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners during the
hearing of the present cases which were adverted to in the applications
under Section 311 Cr.P.C filed in Private Complaint Case No. 10/2015
and on the face of it, it is quite evident that the said document relates
to the transaction in issue and therefore, relevant for the just decision
of the case. No question had been put to the complainant during his
cross examination. Resultantly the answers regarding the said receipt
would necessarily elucidate the truth which would have a direct bearing
to the case. This would definitely help in clearing the ambiguity which
would not amount to filling up the lacunae.
14.
In view of the aforesaid the impugned orders both dated
20.02.2017 in Private Complaint Case Nos. 06/2015 and 10/2015 are
set aside. The evidence already brought on record shall necessarily
continue as part of the evidence in the respective Private Complaint
Cases. The learned Trial Court is directed to recall the Complainant in
both the cases on common dates as per the calendar of the Trial Court
and permit the cross-examination of the said Complainant on the
aforesaid documents restricted, however, to elucidating the truth
regarding the commonality and similarity of the two letters, both
numbered exhibit 4 and the two cheques, both numbered exhibit 5, in
the said Private Complaint Cases and questions directly connected
therewith. The Trial Court shall also permit the petitioner to confront the
Complainant with the receipt dated 12.07.2014. While doing so, the
learned Trial Court shall keep in mind the contours of Section 311
Cr.P.C and the guidelines laid down by the Apex Court and quoted
Crl. M.C No. 02 of 2017 (Anil Oberoi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
&
Crl. M.C No. 03 of 2017 (Subash Chaturvedi v. Sajan Kumar Agarwal)
hereinabove. The learned Trial Court shall be free to examine and
determine the relevancy of the questions proposed to be put by the
petitioners to the Complainant and conduct and regulate the trial as per
law keeping in mind that the sole purpose of allowing the present
petitions preferred by the petitioners is to ensure that the truth is out.
While doing so, the learned Trial Court shall ensure no attempt is made
to fill up any lacunae in the two Private Complaint Cases. After the
defence Counsel further cross-examines the Complainant, if the
Complainant desires to adduce further evidence, it is open to the Trial
Court to grant such permission. Needless to say, the Trial Court shall
not be trammelled by any finding or observation made in this Order
while finally deciding on the merits of the case.
15.
In view of the aforesaid, Crl. M.C No. 02/2017 and Crl. M.C
No. 03/2017 are both allowed accordingly.
16.
The Trial Court records in Private Complaint Case Nos. 06/2015
and 10/2015 shall be remitted to the Trial Court forthwith.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
24-10-2017
Avi/
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review