Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 10 July 2026
Pronounced on: 17 July 2026
+
W.P.(C) 6102/2017
ANIL KUMAR & ORS
..... Petitioners
Through: Mr. Mahesh Srivastava and
Mr. Vaibhav Manu Srivastava, Advs.
Versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR
..... Respondents
Through: Ms. Archana Gaur, CGSC
with Ms. Ridhima Gaur and Mr. Deepu
Kumar, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD KUMAR
JUDGMENT
17.07.2026
%
VINOD KUMAR , J.
1.
The petitioners have filed the present petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India laying a challenge to the
order dated 15.12.2016 rendered by Central Administrative
Tribunal, Principal Bench in OA No. 2989 of 2015 and other
connected OAs whereby the said OAs filed by the petitioners
were dismissed.
Signed By:PRAMOD
W.P. (C) 6102/2017
KUMAR VATS
16:03:50
2.
The admitted facts are that the petitioners were appointed
as ‘Badli’ workers from 01.01.1999 to 31.12.1999 with Delhi
Milk Scheme (i.e. respondent no.2), which is a ‘factory’ as
defined in Section 2 (m) of the Factories Act 1948 and the terms
and conditions of their employment are governed by Certified
Standing Orders for the Employees of the Delhi Milk Scheme as
certified under the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act,
1946 (in short ‘the Standing Order’). Para 4 (iii) of the Standing
Order defines ‘Badli’ workers as under:
“4.(i) Classification:- The workers shall be classified as:(a) Casual
(b) Badli, and
(c) Apprentice
(ii). ……….
(iii). ‘Badli’ means a worker who is employed for the
purpose of working in place of regular employees who are
temporarily absent.
Provided that a badly worker who has actually
worked for not less than 240 days in any period of 12
months shall be transferred to regular establishment
governed by the Fundamental and Supplementary Rules.”
3.
The above portion of the Standing Order provides that if a
‘Badli’ worker has actually worked for not less than 240 days in
any period of 12 months, worker shall be transferred to regular
establishment governed by the Fundamental and Supplementary
Rules. The case of the petitioners is that they had completed
more than 240 days in a year by counting weekly holidays,
compensatory holidays in lieu of weekly holidays on which they
worked and benefit of national holidays. Under Section 52 and
53 of the Factories Act 1948, workers are allowed weekly off and
Signed By:PRAMOD
W.P. (C) 6102/2017
KUMAR VATS
16:03:50
such weekly off is counted as working day and they are duly
paid. However, if the workers have to work on weekly off days,
they shall be given a compensatory holiday. The stand of the
petitioners is that not only the weekly off days, on which they
had worked, should be counted but also the compensatory
holidays granted in lieu of the said days be also counted for the
purpose of calculation of 240 working days.
4.
Vide impugned order, the Central Administrative Tribunal
dismissed the OAs of the petitioners on the ground that when the
payment for working on holidays had been given to the
petitioners, the compensatory holiday in lieu of the same would
not be added in counting of 240 days. The Central Administrative
Tribunal held that if computed in this manner, the petitioners
have not completed 240 days and are therefore not eligible for
regularizing their service.
5.
Learned Counsel for the petitioners submits that Central
Administrative Tribunal did not take note of Rule 77 of Delhi
Factory Rules 1950, which provides as to how compensatory
holidays can be given to a particular worker. Further Form 9
prescribed under Rule 77 of the Delhi Factory Rules, 1950 has
been provided to calculate the compensatory holidays in case of
the workers whose weekly off has been lost.
6.
On the other hand, learned Counsel for the respondent no.2
has countered the aforesaid submissions and argued that a ‘Badli’
worker is nothing but a contractual employee and if he does not
complete 240 days in a year, he cannot get any benefit of the
Signed By:PRAMOD
W.P. (C) 6102/2017
KUMAR VATS
16:03:50
Standing Order. It is argued that the petitioners want the re
computation of working days by adding the off days like Sundays
on which they had worked as well as the compensatory holidays.
It is submitted that in the present case, the petitioners had been
paid for the work done on the off days/ Sundays. Therefore,
compensatory holiday in lieu of such off days/Sundays cannot be
counted in computation of 240 days. Learned Counsel for the
respondent has relied upon an order of the Division Bench of this
Court titled as UOI and Anr. v Shishpal and Ors., W.P.(C)
77/2007 decided on 23.05.2013, wherein it was held that since
the petitioners had already been paid wages for work done on off
days, no double benefit by treating the same as extra working day
can be granted. It was further held that while recomputing the
working days, only actual working days, weekly offs (Sundays)
and national holidays are to be taken into consideration. It is
submitted that as the petitioners are ‘Badli’ workers and have not
worked for 240 days in a year, consequently they are not entitled
for regularization.
7.
It is further submitted by learned Counsel for the
respondent no.2 that ‘Badli’ workers are substitutes for regular
Mates and therefore cannot be regularized unless 240 days in a
year are strictly completed as per Section 52. It is submitted that
petitioners have not completed 240 days of attendance in any
period of 12 months in a year. She explained that ‘Badli’ workers
were engaged only in place of regular staff who remained absent
or were on leave. Further the said practice was discontinued
Signed By:PRAMOD
W.P. (C) 6102/2017
KUMAR VATS
16:03:50
w.e.f. 30.09.2000 as even the regular staff had became surplus. It
is further stated that presently there is no vacancy for the post of
Mate. Learned Counsel for the respondent no.2 relied upon a
judgment of the Constitution Bench of Supreme Court of India in
Secretary, State of Karnataka v Uma Devi 2006 (4) SCALE 197,
wherein it was held that temporary or casual workers are not
entitled to regularization merely because they continued in
service for some time. It is argued that since appointment of
petitioners as ‘Badli’ workers was not made through any regular
selection process, they are not entitled to regularization.
8.
After having considered the rival submissions, we would
like to specify that the only question before us is as to how the
computation of working days has to be done. The Division Bench
of this Court in Shishpal (supra) is directly on this point. It
observed as under:
“……. The only issue which is raised before us, is that
while recomputing the working days, whether the off
days/Sundays, when the respondents have worked, need to
be counted as extra days (over and above 30/31 days in a
calendar month). The answer is No, for the simple reason,
the respondents were paid for the work done on off
days/Sundays. Double benefit, of wages and treating as
extra day, can’t be given. We clarify that while
recomputing, the petitioner is only required to take into
consideration the actual working days, the Sundays,
Weekly Offs and National Holidays in a calendar month
and nothing more.”
9.
This being the opinion of the Division Bench we are of the
opinion that there is no substance in the submissions of the
petitioners because it has been emphatically held by the Division
Signed By:PRAMOD
W.P. (C) 6102/2017
KUMAR VATS
16:03:50
Bench that since the workers were paid for the work done on off
days/Sundays, the double benefit i.e. of wages and at the same
time treating it as extra day(s) cannot be given. The argument of
Counsel for the petitioners is that the said judgment of the
Division Bench does not apply to their case because it has not
taken into its consideration Sections 52 and 53 of the Factories
Act, Rule 77 and relevant Form 9 of Delhi Factory Rules, 1950.
The argument of the petitioners is that the respondent no.2 should
have extended the benefit of weekly holidays as well as of
compensatory holidays while calculating the number of working
days.
10.
The Central Administrative Tribunal has crystallized the
issue in para 16 of the impugned order as under:
“……whether the applicants are entitled to both the
benefits of weekly holidays under Section 52 and
compensatory holidays under Section 53 together or not,
in peculiar facts and circumstances of the case?”
11.
The Tribunal went through the relevant provisions and
held that primary object of Section 52 is to provide weekly
holiday i.e. Sunday for workers. If for any special reasons it
becomes necessary to make Sunday a working day, a
substitutional holiday is made compensatory under Section 53 of
the Factories Act 1948. Therefore, the workder cannot claim both
the benefits at the same time. The Tribunal was of the opinion
that a conjoint and meaningful reading of the relevant provisions
would lead to a conclusion that a worker cannot simultaneously
claim weekly holidays (under Section 52) and compensatory
Signed By:PRAMOD
W.P. (C) 6102/2017
KUMAR VATS
16:03:50
holiday (under Section 53) at the same time. The only legal
requirement to count the actual working days is to add National
and weekly holidays and nothing more. Therefore, it was held
that the respondent no.2 i.e. Delhi Milk Scheme had calculated
the working days correctly.
12.
We have perused Section 52 and Section 53 of the
Factories Act, 1948. The same are reproduced as under:
“52. Weekly holidays. —
(1) - No adult worker shall be required or allowed to work
in a factory on the first day of the week (hereinafter
referred to as the said day), unless—
(a) he has or will have a holiday for a whole day on one of
the three days immediately before or after the said day,
and
(b) the manager of the factory has, before the said day or
the substituted day under clause (a), whichever is
earlier,—
(i) delivered a notice at the office of the Inspector of his
intention to require the worker to work on the said day
and of the day which is to be substituted, and
(ii) displayed a notice to that effect in the factory:
Provided that no substitution shall be made which will
result in any worker working for more than ten days
consecutively without a holiday for a whole day.
(2) Notices given under sub-section (1) may be cancelled
by a notice delivered at the office of the Inspector and a
notice displayed in the factory not later than the day
before the said day or the holiday to be cancelled,
whichever is earlier.
(3) Where, in accordance with the provisions of subsection (1), any worker works on the said day and has had
a holiday on one of the three days immediately before it,
that said day shall, for the purpose of calculating his
weekly hours of work, be included in the preceding week.
Signed By:PRAMOD
W.P. (C) 6102/2017
KUMAR VATS
16:03:50
53. Compensatory holidays.—(1) Where, as a result of the
passing of an order or the making of a rule under the
provisions of this Act exempting a factory or the workers
therein from the provisions of section 52, a worker is
deprived of any of the weekly holidays for which provision
is made in sub-section (1) of that section, he shall be
allowed, within the month in which the holidays were due
to him or within the two months immediately following
that month, compensatory holidays of equal number to the
holidays so lost.
(2) The State Government may prescribe the manner in
which the holidays for which provision is made in subsection (1) shall be allowed.”
13.
Section 52 simply provides that one weekly holiday would
be provided to the workers. Section 53 makes a provision for not
only granting a compensatory holiday in case a worker has to
work on off day/Sunday but also provides a mechanism for
ensuring it. In other words, if a factory allows a worker to work
on such off day, a compensatory leave would be provided to him.
However, it does not say that such compensatory leave would
also be counted as a working day. Now we would like to
reproduce Rule 77 of the Delhi Factory Rules, 1950 as under:
“77. COMPENSATORY HOLIDAYS –
(1)
Except in the case of workers engaged in any work which
for technical reasons must be carried on continuously
throughout the day, the compensatory holidays to be
allowed under sub-section (1) of Section 52 of the Act
shall be so spaced that not more than two holidays are
given in one week.
(2)
The Manager of the factory shall display, on or before the
end of the month in which holidays are lost, a notice in
respect of workers allowed compensatory holidays during
the following month and of the dates therefore, at the
place at which the notice of Periods of Works, prescribed
under Section 61 is displayed. Any subsequent change in
Signed By:PRAMOD
W.P. (C) 6102/2017
KUMAR VATS
16:03:50
the notice in respect of any compensatory holiday shall be
made not less than three days in advance of the date of
that holiday.
(3)
Any compensatory holiday or holidays to which a worker is
entitled shall be given to him before he is discharged or
dismissed and shall not be reckoned as part of any periodof notice required to be given before discharge or
dismissal.
(4)
(a) The manager shall maintain a Register in Form No.9:
Provided that if the Chief Inspector of Factories is of the
opinion that any muster roll or register maintained as part
of the routine of factory or return made by the manager,
gives in respect of any or all of the workers in the factory
the particulars required for the enforcement of Section 52;
he may, by order in writing, direct that such muster roll or
register or return shall, to the corresponding extent be
maintained in place of and be treated as the register or
return required under this Rule for that factory.
(b) The register maintained under Clause (a) shall be
preserved for a period of three years after the last entry in
it and shall be produced before the Inspector on
demand.”
14.
Rule 77 has been framed for setting the mandate of
providing compensatory leave as contained in Section 53 of the
Factories Act 1948, in action. Rule 77 (4) prescribes a Register in
Form No. 9 to be maintained by the Manager of the factory for
the purpose of enforcement of mandate of Section 52 and 53 of
the Factories Act 1948. Learned Counsel for the petitioners has
relied upon this Form in support of his contentions. We would
like to reproduce Form No. 9 as under:
Signed By:PRAMOD
W.P. (C) 6102/2017
KUMAR VATS
16:03:50
DELHI FACTORY RULES
FORM No.9
(Prescribed under Rule 77)
Register of Compensatory Holidays
exempting order
Year
January to March
April to June
October
December
July to September
January to March
April to June
July to September
October
December
Lost rest days carried to
the next
Remarks
and
to
Name
to
Group of Relay No.
15.
of
of workers
Name
date
Number in the register
Date of Compensatory
Holidays Given in
Serial No.
Week Rest Days Lost due
to the Exempting order in
Perusal of this Form No. 9 reflects that there are specific
columns for Week Rest Days lost and Dates of Compensatory
Holidays. The scheme of providing Compensatory Holidays as
specified in Sections 52 and 53 of the Factories Act 1948 and
Rule 77 read with Form No. 9 of the Delhi Factory Rules 1950
only provide a mechanism for ensuring Compensatory Holidays.
None of these provisions contain any direction as to how 240
days would be calculated. Therefore, reference to above
provisions of law and Form No. 9 by learned Counsel for the
petitioners is of no benefit to them.
16.
Now we come to the proviso to Rule 4 (iii) of the Standing
Order,
already
reproduced
above.
It
requires
that
for
regularization, the ‘Badli’ workers should ‘actually’ work for
240 days in a period of 12 months. By use of the word ‘actually’,
the Standing Order has clearly excluded the Compensatory
Holidays out of computation of the working days. As already
Signed By:PRAMOD
W.P. (C) 6102/2017
KUMAR VATS
16:03:50
opined that Central Administrative Tribunal has agreed with the
respondent no.2 that if Compensatory Holidays are removed
from consideration, none of the petitioners has completed 240
days in 12 months.
17.
Accordingly, we are of the opinion that the impugned
order is a reasoned and detailed exposition of law and it also
follows a Division Bench judgment of this Court i.e. Shishpal
(supra). Accordingly, we find no infirmity in the impugned
order.
18.
Accordingly, the petition is dismissed.
VINOD KUMAR, J
C. HARI SHANKAR, J
JULY 17, 2026
VB
Signed By:PRAMOD
W.P. (C) 6102/2017
KUMAR VATS
16:03:50
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review