Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No.297/2025
Reserved on:
04.08.2026 26.02.2026
Pronounced on: 20.08.2026
Uploaded on:
20.08.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced-Full
.....Appellant/petitioner(s)
Anil Kumar Jalali
Through :- Ms. Shivani Jalali, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Neeraj Verma, Advocate.
v/s
.....Respondent(s)
UT of J&K & Anr.
Through :- Mr. Divyanshu Malhotra, Advocate vice
Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA.
CORAM: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SINDHU SHARMA, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SEKHRI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
(Sekhri-J)
01.
Petitioner has invoked writ jurisdiction of this Court to assail order dated
05.11.2024 passed by Central Administrative Tribunal, Jammu Bench [“the
Tribunal”], whereby his application; T.A No. 208/2023, came to be dismissed.
02.
As factual matrix of the case would unfurl, the petitioner, in terms of
Government Order No. 264/Agri of 1986 dated 29.07.1986, came to be selected
and temporarily appointed as Village Extension Worker under the National
Agriculture Extension Project subject, however to the production of requisite
certificates and fulfillment of the conditions of eligibility for entering the
Government service. Appointees were directed to report the respective Directors
of Agriculture Department within 15 days from the date of the appointment
order.
03.
Contention of the petitioner is that he was selected in the Jammu Division
and within the time specified he submitted his joining report in the office of
Director, Agriculture, Jammu, which though was duly received, but adjustment
order was not issued in his favour, whereas other incumbents figuring in the
selection list were adjusted. He submitted various representations and reminders
to the respondents for his adjustment, but nothing was done or initiated, though
his selection and appointment remained intact. According to the petitioner, after
he submitted his jointing report, he was assured by the Director, Agriculture that
his case has been forwarded to the higher authorities for sanction of his
adjustment and he remained attached in his office, however despite repeated
representations neither he was adjusted nor his salary was paid.
04.
It is next contended by the petitioner that he was told that he would be
treated as a migrant and respondent No. 2 would release his salary in pursuance
of the order passed by the State Government in favor of all the migrant
employees. The Director, Agriculture, Jammu, respondent no. 2, issued a
circular dated 18.04.2006, in which name of the petitioner figured as a migrant.
05.
It is also contention of the petitioner that respondents issued seniority lists
by way of circulars dated 20.04.2006 and 26.06.2013, in which his name figured
at serial No. 582 and 823 respectively. According to the petitioner, these
seniority lists/circulars would clearly indicate that his service remained intact
and his salary remained unpaid, thus it was incumbent and obligatory upon the
respondents to pay his salary.
06.
It is also case of the petitioner that on 21.02.2014, a notice came to be
published in the local newspaper, Daily Excelsior, by the official respondents
WP(C) 297/2025
that his status for last seven years was not known and this was last opportunity
for him to join, failing which his candidature would be terminated. He
immediately submitted his joining report in the office of respondent no. 2 and
served a reminder that he may be adjusted, but in vain. Thereafter, in response
to his RTI application under Right to Information Act seeking information
regarding his appointment he came to know that Department has no information
regarding his appointment and salary.
07.
The petitioner through the medium of SWP No. 2542/2014 invoked writ
jurisdiction of this Court for the following reliefs:“i. By allowing this petition with a prayer to command the
official
respondents
to
adjust
the
petitioner
in
the
department in the light of selection list and joining letter
submitted by the petitioner within prescribed time by
treating at par with other candidates who have been
adjusted in the department and in whose favour salary
has been released.
ii. With a further prayer that in alternate by not adjusting the petitioner
in Jammu then arrears of salary be released in
his favour in pursuance of issued Gout. Order no 506-GR of
1990 issue on dated 19-04-1990 by treating him as
MIGRANT as per the admission made by the department in
issued seniority li.st of dated 18-04-2006.
iii. With a further prayer that the period of service be counted from the
date petitioner has joined with the department in pursuance of the
selection and all the arrears of consequential service benefits be
released.
iv. With a further prayer that the seniority of the petitioner be also
fixed for the post of village extension worker from the date of joining
under Rule 24 of Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal)
Rules 1956."
08.
The aforesaid writ petition, at the threshold, came to be disposed of by a
Single Bench of this Court vide order 19.09.2014, with a direction to respondent
no. 2 to pass orders regarding adjustment of the petitioner appropriate to his
status and release the arrears of his salary accrued from the date of his joining,
within 15 days from the date of the order was served upon respondent no. 2. It
WP(C) 297/2025
was also directed that status of the petitioner, in the meanwhile, may not be
disturbed.
09.
The aforesaid order passed by learned Single Judge came to be assailed
by the respondents in an intra-court appeal by way of LPASW No. 04/2015, and
the Division Bench, vide order dated 05.05.2015, set-aside the order passed by
learned Single Judge by holding that, having regard to the controversy involved,
the writ court ought to have issued notice to the appellants, respondents herein,
and given them an opportunity to controvert the factual aspect of the matter. The
Division Bench noticed that averments made in the writ petition itself would
reveal that there were triable issues raised in the petition, as to whether
respondent, (petitioner herein) had joined pursuant to his engagement order as
Village Extension Worker, as claimed in the writ petition, or he stayed away and
did not serve the appellant Department for two and half decades and these issues
were required to be examined by the writ court. It was also observed that it was
for the writ court to conclude as to how the respondent’s (petitioner herein)
inclusion in two seniority lists issued by the appellants and the order by virtue of
which he was shown as a Junior Agriculture Extension Officer would impact the
outcome of petition. The writ court was also directed to examine that in what
circumstances respondent (petitioner herein) figured in the final notice, wherein
he was shown to have submitted his joining report in 1986 and was asked to join
against the post of Village Extension Worker. With these observations, order
passed by the writ court was set-aside, matter was remanded, and writ court was
requested to consider the matter afresh.
10.
The writ petition came to be opposed by the respondents primarily on the
ground that petitioner had not approached the Court with clean hands and was
guilty of suppressing material facts.
WP(C) 297/2025
11.
Pertinently, the respondents though admitted before the writ court that
petitioner was selected and appointed as Village Extension Worker in terms of
Government Order dated 29.07.1986 but contended that as per the record
maintained by the Director, Agriculture, Jammu, the petitioner never reported
the concerned office for his joining. It was submitted that respondent no. 2,
Director, Agriculture, Jammu, did not entertain the representations preferred by
the petitioner after more than 28 years.
12.
The respondents denied before the writ court that petitioner had submitted
his joining report in the year 1986 after issuance of the select list. They also
denied the seniority lists/circulars as false and fabricated and submitted that
since petitioner neither approached the respondents for joining nor filed any
representation till 2014, there was no question of his adjustment. According to
the respondents, the petitioner approached for his joining in the year 2014 i.e.,
after 28 years of issuance of the select list. Respondents prayed for dismissal of
the petition.
13.
Subsequently, the aforesaid writ petition came to be transferred to the
Tribunal after its creation and learned Tribunal, vide impugned order, dismissed
the T.A by holding that petitioner had failed to produce any evidence to show
that he had submitted his joining report and worked in the Department.
According to the Tribunal, the petitioner slept over the matter for approximately
28 years and approached the Department in the year 2014 only for his joining on
the basis of a seniority list published in the newspaper, wherein his name was
reflected.
14.
Having heard learned counsels for the parties, we have perused the
record.
WP(C) 297/2025
15.
Petitioner is aggrieved of the impugned order of the Tribunal primarily on
the ground that Tribunal was obliged to examine all the issues those were
directed to be examined by the Division Bench of this Court while disposing of
LPA No. 04/2024, that whether he joined pursuant to his engagement order as
Village Extension Worker as claimed in the writ petition, or he stayed away and
did not serve the respondent Department for two and a half decades, as to how
his inclusion in the two seniority lists issued by the respondents and the order by
virtue of which he was shown as Junior Agriculture Extension Officer would
impact the outcome of the petition and in what circumstances he figured in the
final notice, wherein he was shown to have not submitted his jointing report in
1986 and was asked to join against the Village Extension Worker position.
16.
It is an admitted fact that petitioner came to be selected and appointed as
Village Extension Worker in terms of Government Order dated 29.07.1986 and
appointment was subject to the production of requisite certificates and
fulfillment of the conditions of eligibility for entering the Government service,
and appointees were directed to report the respective Directors of Agriculture
within 15 days from the date of issuance of the order.
17.
Contention of the petitioner is that within the time specified he submitted
his joining report in the office of Director, Agriculture, Jammu, which though
was duly received by him but he was not adjusted anywhere.
18.
It is trite in law that mere selection or inclusion in a merit list by itself
would not confer any indefeasible right to appointment. [See Shankarsan Dash
vs. Union of India; (1991) 3 SCC 47].
19.
In service jurisprudence, a contract of employment would enure only
when the selected candidate, acting upon the appointment order, satisfies the
pre-joining formalities and submits a formal proof of joining. Without the
WP(C) 297/2025
joining report or an attendance roster, it cannot be said that relationship of
employer-employee was ever established.
20.
Reverting to the case on hand, it is pertinent to underline that though
petitioner in the writ petition/OA had asserted that his joining report and its
receipt by respondent. 2 were on the record, however, a perusal of the writ
record would show that neither he had placed on record any evidence with
respect to his joining report nor its receipt by respondent no. 2. It appears that
after issuance of notice dated 21.02.2014 by the respondents in the local
newspaper, Daily Excelsior, i.e., that his status for the last seven years was not
known and it was his last opportunity to join, the petitioner approached the
respondents for the first time to submit his joining report. Learned Tribunal
while examining the issues, those were directed by the Division Bench to be
examined by the writ court, has rightly observed that there was no merit and
substance in the contention of the petitioner because petitioner slept over the
matter for 28 years and approached the respondent Department in the year 2014
only for his joining on the basis of a seniority list published in the newspaper.
21.
The entire claim of the petitioner is based upon two seniority
lists/circulars dated 20.04.2006 and 26.06.2013, purported to have been issued
by the respondents, wherein, according to him, he figured at serial Nos. 582 and
823 respectively and was shown to have been placed as Junior Agriculture
Extension Officer. Pertinently, the respondents before the writ court denied both
these seniority lists/circulars as false and fabricated, however the petitioner
failed to dispute the stand of the respondents by filing any rejoinder affidavit
that said seniority lists/circulars were genuine.
22.
For the foregoing reasons, the present petition, filed after inordinate delay
of nearly three decades for claiming service benefits solely on the basis of initial
WP(C) 297/2025
selection and appointment, in the absence of any proof of joining or physical
service, is barred by the doctrine of laches. We do not find any illegality or
impropriety in the impugned order propounded by the Tribunal. Hence, present
petition is dismissed.
(Rajesh Sekhri)
Judge
JAMMU
20.08.2026.
Abinash
Whether the judgment is speaking? Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable? Yes
WP(C) 297/2025
(Sindhu Sharma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review