Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
ORISSA HIGH COURT : CUTTACK
CMP No.1623 of 2023
An application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
***
Anil Kumar Das
…
Petitioner.
-VERSUSSt. Bidulata Das & Others
…
Opposite Parties.
Counsel appeared for the parties:
For the Petitioner
: Mr. G. C. Rout, Advocate.
.
For the Opposite Parties
: Mr. B. Bhuyan, Senior Advocate
Assisted by Ms. S. Sahoo, Advocate.
P R E S E N T:
HONOURABLE
MR. JUSTICE ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA
Date of Hearing : 24.04.2026 :: Date of Judgment :13.05.2026
CMP No.1623 of 2023
J UDGMENT
ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA, J.—
1.
This Civil Miscellaneous Petition under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 has been filed by the petitioner
(defendant No.1 in the suit vide C.S. No.779 of 2023) against
the Opp. Parties (plaintiffs in the suit vide C.S. No.779 of 2023
pending in the Court of learned Civil Judge, Jr. Division
Bhubaneswar)
praying
for
setting
aside
the
impugned
Judgment dated 18.11.2023 (Annexure-5) passed in F.A.O
No.82/2023
by
the
learned
Addl.
District
Judge,
Bhubaneswar.
2.
The factual backgrounds of this Civil Misc. Petition,
which prompted the petitioner for filing the same is that, the
Opp. Parties being the plaintiffs filed the suit vide C.S. No.779
of 2023 against the petitioner and others arraying them as
defendants praying for declaration that, the registered sale
deed No.3142 dated 29.04.2003 as well as the R.o.R vide
Khata No.299/579 in the name of the petitioner (defendant
No.1 in the suit vide C.S. No.779 of 2023) in respect of “B”
CMP No.1623 of 2023
schedule suit properties is illegal and the same is not binding
upon them (plaintiffs) and to restrain him(defendant No.1)
along with other defendants permanently from creating any
sort of disturbance in the possession of the plaintiffs over both
the suit schedule properties stating in the plaint that,
one
Iswar Chandra Das died leaving behind his only
son Golekha Bihari Das.
Golekha Bihari Das died leaving behind his 3 sons i.e.
Gagan Bihari Das, Atal Bihari Das and Narayan Das.
The plaintiffs (Opp. Parties in this CMP) are the
successors of Narayan Das.
The petitioner (defendant No.1) is one son of Gagan
Bihari Das.
Both the schedule of properties are situated in one
compact area. Their predecessor i.e. Golekha Bihari Das had
constructed a house over a portion of “B” schedule properties
i.e. in a portion of plot No.197. A government road is running
to the east of the said suit plot No.197. When on dated
28.12.2022, the defendant No.1 (petitioner in this CMP)
started demolishing the old house on schedule “B” properties,
CMP No.1623 of 2023
to which, the plaintiffs (Opp. Parties) protested, then, the
petitioner
showed
a
sale
deed
bearing
No.3142
dated
29.04.2003 executed by the co-sharers of the suit properties
in his favour and subsequently, they (plaintiffs) came to know
that, the petitioner has mutated the same to his name and he
has also converted the B schedule suit land from agricultural
to homestead in his favour as per the Order passed in OLR
Case No.267/2018 though, the same is not related to the B
schedule suit properties rather the same is an another
property. When again on dated 08.05.2023, the petitioner
(defendant No.1) came to the suit land with bulldozer along
with some labourers and started demolishing the old house
over suit plot No.197, to which, the plaintiffs (Opp. Parties in
this CMP) protested, for which, the defendant No.1 (petitioner)
threatened to occupy both the schedule suit properties, then,
the plaintiffs filed the suit vide C.S. No.779 of 2023 seeking
the aforesaid reliefs against the defendants including the
defendant No.1.
3.
In the said suit vide C.S .No.779/2023, the plaintiffs
filed I.A. No.1/2023 under Order 39, Rule 1 and 2 read with
CMP No.1623 of 2023
Section 151 of the CPC, 1908
defendant
praying for injuncting the
No.1 (petitioner in this CMP) temporarily from
changing the nature and character of both the suit schedule
properties and from making any illegal alienation and from
creating third party interest therein in any manner till the
final disposal of the suit.
The Opp. Party/defendant No.1 (petitioner in this CMP)
objected to the same stating that, he has purchased the “B”
schedule suit plot No.197 through RSD No.3142 dated
29.04.2003 from the owners thereof i.e. from the other
defendants and he has also mutated the said properties to his
name and after mutation, separate mutation R.o.R has
already been prepared in his name vide Khata No.299/579
and
the
said
land
has
already
been
converted
from
agricultural to homestead in his favour. After conversion of
the said suit plot No.197 from agricultural to homestead, he
demolished a portion of the old house therein and he is
making a new construction therein and the said construction
is going on and that constructions have already been reached
up to linten level and he is residing in the other undemolished
CMP No.1623 of 2023
portion of the said plot No.197. For which, on the basis of the
documents relating to his ownership and possession coupled
with the constructions thereon substantially up to lintel level,
no order of temporary injunction should be passed against
him and the I.A. filed by the plaintiffs for temporary injunction
is liable to be dismissed.
4.
After hearing from both the sides, the learned Trial Court
as per Order dated 21.06.2023 dismissed to the said I.A.
No.1/2023 of the petitioners (plaintiffs) on contest assigning
the reasons that,
“the sale deed as well as R.o.R and the order passed in OLR Case
No.267/2018 are going to show that, the petitioner is in possession over
the suit land described in Schedule “B” and he had built a pucca house
thereon in a portion thereof up to roof level and if at this stage, the order of
temporary injunction will be passed against the Opp. Party, the same will
certainly create greater inconvenience to him. For which, balance of
convenience does not tilt in favour of the petitioners. Accordingly, the
aspect of irreparable injury need not be looked into. The I.A. liable to be
dismissed.”
5.
On being dissatisfied with the aforesaid dismissal order
of I.A. No.1/2023 passed on dated 21.06.2023 by the learned
Civil Judge, Jr. Division, Bhubaneswar, the petitioners
(plaintiffs) challenged the same by preferring an Appeal vide
F.A.O. No.82/2023 under Order 43, Rule 1(r) of the CPC,
CMP No.1623 of 2023
1908 being the appellants against the defendant
No.1
arraying him (defendant No.1) as respondent praying for
setting aside the impugned order dated 21.06.2023 passed in
I.A. No.01/2023.
After hearing from both the sides, the learned Appellate
Court allowed that F.A.O. No.82/2023 as per Judgment dated
18.11.2023 and directed both the parties to maintain status
quo over the suit properties till the disposal of the suit vide
C.S. No.779 of 2023 and also directed the learned Trial Court
to take all necessary steps for early disposal of the suit vide
C.S. No.779/2023 preferably within a period of 6 months from
the date of communication of that Judgment with a further
direction to the parties not to take any unnecessary
adjournments and to cooperate the learned Trial Court for
early disposal of that suit assigning the reasons that,
“the suit properties are the Sikim properties of the appellants and
respondent. The appellants and respondent are the successors of Sikim
tenant Iswar Chandra Das having their right, title and interest over the
suit schedule properties. The respondent (petitioner in this CMP) has
purchased the suit land through R.S.D. No.3142 dated 29.04.2003 from
his vendors and thereafter, he has mutated the same to his name and
CMP No.1623 of 2023
subsequently, he has converted the same from agriculture to homstead as
per the order passed in OLR Case No.267/2018 and after conversion of
the land, the respondent (petitioner in this CMP) demolished a portion of
the old house situated over the suit land and he is constructing a new
structure, which has been reached up to linten level and when the
appellants (plaintiffs) have challenged the legality of registered sale deed
bearing No.3142 dated 29.04.2003 executed in favour of the respondent
(petitioner in this CMP), for which, prima facie case is existing in favour of
the appellants and it also appears from the record that, the respondent is
trying to change the nature and character of the suit properties by making
construction on the same and if the respondent is allowed to proceed with
the construction on the suit land, then, he will take an undue advantage.
The law is well settled that, when a dispute arose in respect of the title of
the suit land and parties were found to be in possession over the disputed
land, an order of injunction restraining the respondent from putting up
construction on the suit land would be justified.
When in the case at hand, the respondent is constructing a new
structure on the suit land as discussed above and both the parties have
claimed their right, title and interest over the suit properties and when the
suit is at its initial stage and the rights of the parties are yet to be
determined by the learned Trial Court with reference to the evidence to be
led by both the parties, then, if injunction or status quo would not be
granted during the pendency of the suit, the nature and character of the
suit properties can be changed at the instance of the respondent
CMP No.1623 of 2023
(defendant No.1). For which, it would be just and proper to direct both the
parties to maintain status quo over the suit properties till the final disposal
of the suit.”
6.
On being aggrieved with the aforesaid Order dated
18.11.2023 passed in F.A.O No.82/2023 directing both the
parties to maintain status quo over the suit properties till the
disposal of the suit, the defendant No.1 challenged the same
by filing this CMP under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India, 1950 praying for setting aside the impugned order
dated 18.11.2023 passed in F.A.O. No.82/2023.
7.
I have already heard from the learned counsel for the
petitioner (defendant
No.1) and the learned Senior Counsel
for the Opp. Parties (plaintiffs).
8.
During the course of hearing, learned Senior Counsel for
the Opp. Parties (plaintiffs) relied upon the decision between
Daitari Swain Vs. Kartika Swain & Others : 2019 (I) ILR
Cuttack 659 (Full Bench) in support of the impugned order
passed in FAO No.82/2023.
9.
It is the concurrent findings and observations of the
learned Trial Court and the learned Appellate Court in the
CMP No.1623 of 2023
Order and Judgment passed in I.A. No.01/2023 and F.A.O
No.82/2023 respectively that,
both the parties are the successors of Sikim tenant i.e.
Iswar Chandra Das and they have their right, title and interest
over the suit properties and the petitioner is the purchaser of
the properties described in Schedule B of the plaint through
R.S.D. No.3142 dated 29.04.2003 and after purchase, the said
purchased properties of the petitioner have already been
mutated to his name and a separate R.o.R vide Khata
No.299/579 has already been prepared in his name and he
(petitioner) has also converted his purchased land described
in schedule-B of the plaint into homestead land and he has
also demolished a portion of the old house situated on the
said schedule-B land and after demolition, he is making a new
construction on the demolished portion, which has already
been raised up to linten level and the learned appellate court
passed the impugned order of status quo against the
petitioner restraining/prohibiting him (petitioner) indirectly
from completing the constructions of the house assigning the
CMP No.1623 of 2023
reasons that,
if he will be allowed to proceed with the
construction, the same will provide him an undue advantage.
10. The documents i.e. revenue records in favour of the
petitioner i.e. R.S.D. No.3142 dated 29.04.2003 and the R.o.R
vide Khata No.299/579 as well as the order of conversion of
the schedule-B suit properties from agriculture to homestead
land and the construction made by the petitioner up to linten
level over the demolished portion of the schedule-B suit
properties are going to show that, the petitioner is in
possession over the B-schedule suit properties.
11. It
is
the
settled
propositions
of
law
that,
when
constructions will have been made by any party on the suit
properties substantially up to lintel level, then, there will be
no justification under law to stop such constructions.
Because, balance of convenience leans in favour of the
completion of such construction, but not to stop that
construction, as the same cannot be in the interest of justice.
It is the settled propositions of law that, a half
constructed house is beneficial to no party. Therefore, the
CMP No.1623 of 2023
balance of convenience leans in favour of completion of the
construction, rather than obstruction of construction.
On this aspect, the propositions of law has already been
clarified in the ratio of the following decisions:(i)
In a case between Khiroda Prasad Routray vrs.
Smt.
Satyabhama
Routray
and
others
:
reported in 1986(II) OLR NOC22 that, Order of ad
interim injunction prohibiting the defendant from
completing a half constructed house passed in
Order-39, Rules-1 and 2 of the C.P.C. was vacated,
because, a half constructed house is beneficial to
no party.
(ii)
In a case between Bholeswar Sahu and another
vrs. Rama Chandra Behera and another :
reported in 90(2000) CLT294(Para-6) that, When
a
building
has
been
constructed
upto
a
considerable extent, then, it may not be in the
interest of justice to stop further construction. It
cannot be said that, balance of convenience lies in
favour of the party opposing such construction.
(iii)
In a case between Assa Manayami vrs. Pawan
Kumar Dugat : reported in 2025(2) Civil Court
Cases-535(Rajasthan) that, When, construction of
CMP No.1623 of 2023
wall is already over and only finishing work is
remain, then, petition under Order-39, Rules-1 and
2 read with Section 151 of the C.P.C. was rightly
rejected.(Para-6)
(iv)
In a case between Trilochan Mangaraj Vs.
Rasabihari Pradhan & Others decided on dated
10.04.2026 in CMP No.373 of 2024 that, when
the construction of a building has been has been
made up to a considerable extent, then, the same
cannot be in the interest of justice to stop its
further construction, because, a half constructed
house is beneficial to no party.
12. When it is the concurrent findings of the learned Trial
Court and the learned Appellate Court in the Order and
Judgment passed in I.A. No.01/2023 and F.A.O. No.82/2023
respectively that, the petitioner is the purchaser of the B
schedule suit properties through R.S.D. No.3142 dated
29.04.2003 and he is in possession over the same on the
basis of the R.o.R vide Khata No.299/579 as well as the order
of conversion passed in OLR Case No.267/2018 and when the
aforesaid sale deed dated 29.04.2003 as well as the R.o.R vide
Khata No.299/579 and the order passed in OLR Case
CMP No.1623 of 2023
No.267/2018 in favour of the petitioner in respect of the B
schedule suit properties have not been set aside or cancelled
as yet and when the petitioner is constructing a pucca house
over the demolished portion of B schedule suit properties and
when the said construction has already been reached up to
linten level and when it is the settled propositions of law that,
a half constructed house is beneficial to no party and the
balance of
convenience leans in favour of the completion of the
construction, rather than obstruction of construction, then, at
this juncture, in view of the principles of law enunciated in
the ratio of the aforesaid decisions, the learned Appellate
Court should not have reversed the dismissal order of I.A.
No.1/2023 passed by the learned Trial Court and also should
not have passed the impugned order of status quo directing
both the parties including the petitioner to maintain status
quo over the suit properties indirectly restraining
the
petitioner from completion of his half constructed building
which has already been raised up to a considerable extent.
For which, there is justification under law for making
CMP No.1623 of 2023
interference with the said part of the impugned order passed
by the learned Appellate Court in F.A.O. No.82/2023 through
this CMP filed by the petitioner.
Therefore, this CMP filed by the petitioner is to be
allowed in part.
For which, the decision relied on behalf of the Opp.
Parties indicated in Para No.8 of this Judgment is not
applicable to this matter at hand for the reasons assigned
above.
13. The impugned order of status quo passed in F.A.O.
No.82/2023
by
the
learned
Addl.
District
Judge,
Bhubaneswar is liable to be set aside.
As such, there is some merit in the CMP filed by the
petitioner. The same is allowed in part.
14. The impugned order i.e. the order of status quo in
respect of the “B” schedule suit properties passed on dated
18.11.2023 in F.A.O No.82/2023 by the learned Appellate
Court is set aside and the petitioner is allowed to complete the
constructions of the half constructed house over B schedule
suit
properties
CMP No.1623 of 2023
subject
to
the
condition
that,
he
(petitioner/defendant No.1) shall submit an undertaking
before
the
learned
Trial Court
in
the
suit
vide C.S.
No.799/2023 stating clearly that, he shall not claim any
equity in respect of the completed construction and such
construction shall be subject to the Judgment and direction
made/passed by the learned Trial Court in the suit vide C.S.
No.799/2023, but the other part of the Judgment passed in
F.A.O No.82/2023 by the learned Appellate Court directing
the learned Trial Court to dispose of the suit preferrably
within a period of 6 months from the date of communication
of the Judgment is confirmed.
15. As such, with the aforesaid modification of the Judgment
passed in F.A.O. No.82/2023 by the learned Appellate Court,
this CMP is disposed of finally.
16. Accordingly, the learned Trial Court is directed to
dispose of the suit vide C.S. No.799/2023 pending in his
Court within a period of 6 months either from the date of
communication of this Judgement or from the date of
production of the certified copy of this Judgment by any of the
parties.
CMP No.1623 of 2023
17. Registry is directed to communicate the copy of this
Judgment
to
the
learned
Civil
Judge,
Jr.
Division,
Bhubaneswar in reference to the suit vide C.S. No.799/2023.
18. Hence, this CMP filed by the petitioners (plaintiffs) is
disposed of finally.
(ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA)
JUDGE
High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
The 13th May, 2026// Rati Ranjan Nayak
Sr. Stenographer
Digitally Signed
Signed by: RATI RANJAN NAYAK
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC
Date: 15-May-2026 21:39:22
CMP No.1623 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review